Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

Balpreet Singh · 25 Jul 2005

A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa by Mahinder Singh Taken from Sant Sipahi, March 1994 Introduction Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh jee Khalsa (Babbar) was among those Sant Sipahi Khalsa warriors who lived their lives for the Guru and then died for their Guru. These Singhs, like Bhai Anokh Singh Babbar, Bhai Gurpal Singh Babbbar, Bhai Sulakhan Singh Babbar, Bhai Ravinder Singh Babbar etc. were abhiyaasi Gursikhs who joined the Sikh Movement, not for any personal gain, but to stand up for their brothers and sisters and to defend the name of their Guru. These Singhs were not just Shahids when their souls left their bodies, they lived as Zinda Shaheeds. They had given their heads to the Guru the day they received the gift of Amrit and for every moment after that, they did not live for themselves anymore. They accepted every Guru-Hukam completely. They had killed their “self” in Shabad. They didn’t fear death, because they belonged to the Guru who could take them as he wished. Bhai Anokh Singh Babbar After being freed from police custody, Bhai Anokh Singh Babbar appeared at an amrit sinchaar Smagam. Bhai Sahib’s closest friend, Bhai Sulakhan Singh had recently become a Shahid. A Vaak was taken and the shabad came, [gurbani]sUhI ] jo idn Awvih so idn jwhI ] krnw kUcu rhnu iQru nwhI ] sMgu clq hY hm BI clnw ] dUir gvnu isr aUpir mrnw ]1][/gurbani] the Singhs doing seva and Bhai Anokh Singh knew what this meant. Shahidi was not far off now. One of the Singhs in the Punj Pyaaray became emotional and a tear escaped his eye and rolled down his cheek. Bhai Anokh Singh smiled and said, “Jeeo, when we came on this path, was there any doubt where we would finish? Was death ever a question? So why be sad over this?” Shortly after, Bhai Sahib was arrested and tortured to death in the most brutal manner. These are the Singhs whose sacrifice will bear fruit and bring Khalsa Raj. These Singhs of the Guru who have dedicated their everything for the Khalsa. These are the true Babbars. Early Life Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa was born in village Hans Kala, Jagraon. Heis parents were Sd. Gulzar Singh and Mata Gurdail Kaur. Bhai Amarjit Singh had one brother and a sister. Bhai Sahib went to primary school in Hans Kalan and then went to High School there. Bhai Amarjit Singh was a very athletic youth. He was an avid field hockey player and was his school team’s captain. Bhai Sahib was also very smart in school and always came at the top of his class. When he graduated in 1988, Bhai Amarjit Singh secured 72% marks on his finals (a very high mark in India). During his time in High School, Bhai Sahib was known to be very outspoken. He wasn’t afraid of speaking the truth to anyone. Bhai Amarjit Singh had even physically challenged the local gangsters. He was always ready to stand up for those being bullied. Becoming a Gursikh and Khalsa Jeevan After High School, Bhai Amarjit Singh was accepted into Guru Nanak Engineering College, Ludhiana. It was here he came into contact with Gursikhs and became amritdhari. Bhai Sahib began to live a very strict Gursikh lifestyle at this point. He spoke very sweetly to all and loved to listen to keertan. He would wake at amrit vela and do keshi ishnaan. After naam abhyaas, Bhai Sahib would do his nitnem along with Sukhmani Sahib. After finishing his daily nitnem, Bhai Sahib would go to the Gurdwara and only then would he do anything else. Bhai Sahib stopped attending non-Gurmat events like wedding parties, etc. Bhai Amarjit Singh jee was also a Sarbloh Bibeki Singh. He made a point of always speaking sweetly and with love for all. He was opposed to swearing or speaking harshly. Bhai Sahib began to distribute Gurmat literature around the area for free and speak out against Manmat practices. At all times, his lips would have Gurbani on them and he would encourage others to become amritdhari. Bhai Amarjit Singh attended Ran Sabaees by the Akhand Kirtani Jatha very eagerly and at the same time, he was close friends with many Singhs associated with the Damdami Taksal and attended programs organized by the Taksal as well. Meeting the Babbars Bhai Amarjit Singh became known as a very dedicated Gursikh and won the respect of those around him. In his days at Guru Nanak Engineering College, the Indian Government was terrorizing the people of Punjab. Thousands of innocent Sikhs had been killed and Gurdwaras desecrated. Bhai Sahib began to think seriously about Khalsa Raj. Bhai Sahib was attending a local Ran Sabaee keertan when Bhai Harbahan Singh Mand of Babbar Khalsa approached him. Babbar Khalsa was an organization of dedicated Gursikhs who fought a principled battle against the Indian State, based on Gurmat. Bhai Amarjit Singh eagerly offered any assistance he could provide. Bhai Amarjit Singh moved to Kila Raipur while studying at the College and made friends with Bhai Amarpreet Singh. Bhai Amarpreet Singh was also involved in the Sikh Liberation Movement and introduced Bhai Amarjit Singh to a number of Sikh fighters (Bhai Amarpreet Singh became Shaheed in June 1992). While still studying in College, Bhai Amarjit Singh became to work with Bhai Harbhajan Singh Babbar (Delianvali). He became an expert at secret operations and no one outside a very small group of Singhs knew about his involvement. He would go secretly on missions and then return in time to be an engineering student. No one could guess he was an active Sikh guerrilla. Manmat in the Movement While doing seva in Babbar Khalsa, Bhai Amarjit Singh began to take notice of weaknesses in the Sikh Movement. He noticed that some fighters in other organizations had taken to using narcotics and had made links with smugglers. Bhai Sahib summoned a meeting of all Organizations to discuss this issue. Local Singhs like Bhai Hardeep Singh Pona, Dr. Darshpreet Singh Rumi, Bhai Mohan Singh Shiekupra attended and agreed to fight this practice. Bhai Hardeep Singh Pona Dr. Darshpreet Singh Rumi In the final days of the Sikh Movement in 1992, some Sikh fighters also began to cut their hair to avoid capture. Bhai Sahib was very fiercely opposed to this. Bhai Amarjit Singh would say, [i]“According to Sikh history, Singhs like Bhai Taru Singh and many others lived and died with their kes intact. Today, some people who call themselves Singhs are having their kes cut. How can they call themselves Singhs of the Guru? Our Guru had said he would not even give his darshan to those without kes and called such people Bheds (cowardly sheep). These people cannot be Singhs of Guru Gobind Singh.”[/i] Bhai Sahib believed that a true Shahid was one who died with his Sikhi and rehit intact. If Guru Sahib would not give his darshan to a Sikh with cut hair, how could he accept such a person's death as a “shahidi”? Shahidi The Sikh Liberation Movement was beginning to suffer major setbacks, but Bhai Amarjit Singh remained in Chardi Kala. He had begun to work with Bhai Kuldeep Singh Sheikupura (KLF) and continued unafraid. Bhai Kuldeep Singh Sheikupura While still at Guru Nanak Engineering College, Bhai Amarjit Singh was betrayed by an informant. Bhai Sahib was doing his daily Amrit Vela at home when the police party swooped in. Bhai Sahib was arrested and tortured mercilessly. Bhai Sahib quietly bore everything but spoke nothing. The police then removed Bhai Sahib’s kakaars. Bhai Amarjit Singh declared that until his kakaars were returned, he would not so much as drink a drop of water. The torture continued and Bhai Sahib remained absorbed in naam simran. The police became frustrated and could not get Bhai Sahib to speak even a word. The police expected him to beg for water as the torture continued, but Bhai Amarjit Singh continued his jaap and asked for nothing. On March 11th, 1992, as Bhai Sahib’s body became weaker and still not one piece of information could be taken, the police took him to village Kaneeaa(n) and martyred him in a fake encounter. Bhai Sahib’s life is a glowing example of what a true Sikh fighter is like. His life was dedicated to Khalsa principals. It is the involvement of Singhs like this that will make Sikh liberation possible. It is the sacrifice of Gursikhs like this that will one day bring Khalsa Raj. Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa was a real Babbar.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

HARJ · 25 Jul 2005

DHAN SHAHEED BHAI AMARJEET SINGH BABBAR !!!!!! PLEASE KEEP DOING ARDASSAN AND PATH FOR BHAI JAGTAR SINGH HAWARA ! [%sig%]

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

... · 25 Jul 2005

this is an important story. Only Singhs can be fighters for Khalsa Raj. When you used Vikases, Jaspals and Samirs, the whole organization falls apart like a house of cards. If you want to do seva of the Panth, first give your head and become a Singh. Guru Sahib's not going to do kirpa on his fauj if those inside are monas.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

? · 25 Jul 2005

So a mona cant be a shaheed?

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

bsb · 26 Jul 2005

I dont' think that a mona can be called a shahid in the truest sense of that word. I don't think his death would be a waste, but it wouldn't be of the level of shahidi. Shahids go to sach khand and I don't think that a mona could have that even if he did die for the Sikh cause. At the same time, I dont think it would be a waste and I think Guru Sahib would do kirpa by giving him the opportuinty to be a gursikh.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

ASengh · 26 Jul 2005

WJKK WJKF I've always been inspired by these stories of Shahid Singhs, can someone please tell me, when the Singhs who fight for a good cause and become shaheeds what happens to their souls? I've heard quite a few stories about shaheed Singhs meeting Gursikhs whilst they do paath. I've also heard a story of a shaheed Singh beating a Singh up for doing a mistake (I know this Singh quite closely). Does anyone have any other stories like that?

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

Sucha Singh Machhiwara · 26 Jul 2005

So mona can't be Shaheeds eh??? This hatred for mona has to stop, this is not the attitude of a real Singh. In Sikhi there is no guarantee as to what awaits a Shaheed in the after-life, there are no promises of Sach-Kand or anything else, you are judged for every action you take in your life not your last. If a mona decides to stand up and not give in to oppression and is without ego, what difference is there between him and a Shaheed who is a Singh, I am talking purely on the point that both attained Shaheedi for the same cause and reasons, not any other aspects of their lives. So what happens to Shaheed Udham Singh, Shaheed Bhagat Singh and more recently Shaheed Bhai Harjinder Singh Parha Canadawala (Khalistan Liberation Force) who was really close with Mahaan Shaheed Bhai Avtar Singh Brahma. Bhai Brahma accepted Bhai Harjinder Singh, so who the hell is anybody to put down a mona Shaheed. Anyway mona is such a derogatory term, especially for a Sikh Shaheed. Shame on you so called Singhs. But back to what this thread should be all about, Dhan Dhan Shaheed Bhai Amarjit Singh Babbar.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

Singh · 26 Jul 2005

A chardi kala abhyasi Gursikh told me that a Singh who lives according to rehit and has given his/her all to Guru Sahib can become a Shahid. In the final moments s/he Guru Sahib takes care of everything if that Singh has put himself in Guru Sahib's hands and thinks that Guru Sahib is doing everything and he himself has no power. In that Singh's final moments, Guru Sahib gives jyot vigaas and that Singh goes to Sach Khand. The title of "Shahid" is very high and a very high rank given by Guru Sahib. I think these Gursikhs join the countless other Gursikhs in Sachkhand and in the army of Shahid Singhs that give protection to Gurdwara Sahibs and Gursikhs. These Shahid Singhs still stand guard where Guru Sahib is installed. When the army attacked Sri Darbar Sahib in 1984, the first tank stalled by the Shahid Ganj of Baba Deep Singh jee and wouldn't move forward. They say the reason the Indian Army suffered such massive losses was because these Shahid Singhs were fighting along side the other jujharus. In 1947, mobs attacking Gurdwaras sometimes reported being scared off by a puratan Nihang Singh or army of Singhs. Or I think maybe a Shahid Singh might even chose to be re-born to do seva of the Panth.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

Singh · 26 Jul 2005

not to demean the sacrifice of mona veers that died for Khalistan, but the title of "shahid" is only for rehitvan Gursikhs. When a Sikh is fighting, he isn't using his own power or intelligence. He is not trying to be clever and win that way. He knows his win is certain because Vaheguru is with him and his victory is Vahiguru's victory. He fights with the power of Guru Sahib, not his own. The only way to have this power is if the ones fighting are the Guru's own and are following Guru Sahib's hukams. The reason I think we are not successful now is because we think we can be smart and win Khalsa Raj. If we try to be smart, there are millions others who are smarter. The greatest smartness is to submit fully to Guru Sahib and then Guru Sahib will put victory in our lap.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

ekta · 26 Jul 2005

thissss is pure bsss!!! monah shaheed, and a gur-sikh shaheed the same thing, cept the gur-sikh gets shaheedi easier cause they fear it none, as a monah!!!!! i heard from students of baba thakur singh ji that simran can be done for a life time, but won't amount 2 a single shaheedi.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

ASengh · 27 Jul 2005

Shaheedi is only accepted by Guru ji if the the person who puts the shaheedi is a rehitvaan, naam japda vala Gursikh. The Gurvaak below gives some understanding that who is the shaheed; [gurbani]mrxu muxsW sUirAw hku hY jo hoie mrih prvwxo ]3][/gurbani] The death of brave heroes is blessed, if it is approved by God. ||3|| As you can see the death of the brave hero is only blessed if it is approved by Waheguru himself, but who is the true brave heros? The True heros are described in the gurvaak below; [gurbani]jw kau hir rMgu lwgo iesu jug mih so khIAq hY sUrw ][/gurbani] He alone is called a warrior, who is attached to the Lord's Love in this age. Those are the true warriors who are imbued with the Lord's love, and when they die for a good cause for the panth, Waheguru himself approves their deaths and they become shaheeds. So only rehitvaan, naam japde vale Gursikhs can attain shaheedi and not moneh.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

ekta · 27 Jul 2005

what ever, u can hate all u want, shaheedi is shaheedi, regardless of the way one lives life, because shaheedi is giving up of life for the furtherment of ones community and cause, say for instance the couple of hindu (very few) shaheeds. You guys, talk alott, but no action, these shaheed "monaye" have given their soul, their lives, their families, u think gods gonna be like o -well to bad u were'nt amritdhari..... he gave his head without amrit, which is basically just skipping a step, gods not gonna send him into the nararkds for that or even back here, they are shaheeds just like ne other. They fought they died honourably I highly doubt any of our fellow "amrithdari" posters on this board are prepared 2 do such. PLEASE.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

098 · 27 Jul 2005

Saheed's are Saheed's.....at least show some respect for those who laid their lives so you can be proud today. Anybody who stands up for the rights of others and give their life for that cause is a Saheed..eith Sikh, Muslim, or belong to no religion. I don't know when we are going to lear be mature

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

HARJ · 27 Jul 2005

MONAH SHAHEED OR GURSIKH SHAHEED THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE !!!! PEER BHUDU SHAH'S SON FOUGHT ALONGSIDE THE KHALSA AND GOT KILLED , YOU CAN'T SAY THAT HE IS NOT A SHAHEED JUST BECAUSE HE IS NOT A GURSIKH!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

another learner · 27 Jul 2005

What's so difficult about this concept? A sikh shaheed has to be a SIKH. If a mona gives his or her life for a cause, that's great. All the respect to them. However, Sikhi isn't just about how you die. It's how you live and die. Saying that giving your life honourably negates the way in which you lived life is BS. That's just your emotions talking, not sikhi. And nobody said a monah who gives their life will go to narak. Who said that? You guys need to read some history and banee before singlehandedly deciding who a shaheed is and accusing others of hate. Remember the muslim who asked guru jee for a place in his charan (sachkand)? He was willing to sacrifice everything, including his life, but Guru Jee told him he needed to shuk amrit. Remember Bhai Maha Singh and the 40 muktay? They gave their lives in battle. But it's said that until the Bhai Maha Singh jee asked for forgiveness and the badavaa was ripped up, these singhs weren't accepted into sachkhand. You can't turn your back on your guru and still be called a Sikh Shaheed. You can still be a brave warrior who died honourably and you'll be rewarded for your great deeds. But no great deeds, including an honourable death, are as great as naam. Without amrit naam, you're not a gursikh and not a shaheed. Cutting your hair is no less a badavaa than Bhai Maha Singh's badavaa. Remember, no shortcuts to sachkhand. Naam will get you there, and only naam raseeyai gursikhs will get true shahidi. Many people will die great deaths, but only someone who's already killed their mann and given themselves to their guru and live in His hukam, will be shaheed.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

singh · 27 Jul 2005

I think someone can die for the Panth and be a mona. I think it's possible and probably has happened. But I don't think that they qualify for "Shahid". Maybe they are a type of "Shahid" but not the highest kind that achieve liberation through their sacrifice. Guru Sahib accepts the head of a Sikh at the amrit sinchaar. Every day after that the Sikh is living-dead and should be a jinda shaheed.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

SS Singh · 27 Jul 2005

This threads seems to have gotten out of hand. Anyway, I think that the story is amazing. Thank you for posting this story.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 27 Jul 2005

Shaheedee in SIKHI/GURMATT is NOT about DEATH/DYING. IT is About LIVING. A ZINDA SHAHEED like Baba DEEP SINGH JI, BABA GURBAKSH SINGH JI has even more credibility...because SHAHEDEE means doing something about which People will Give Wittness...make SAKHI..HISTORY out of as an EXAMPLE...of the WAY TO LIVE. Just imagine for a moment.. EXTREME HEAT KILLS within a few minutes... GURU ARJUN JI SAHIB was seated on a SIZZLING HOT TAVEE for ONE DAY..Next day Guru Ji Walked over to the BOILING POT in which He was BOILED like a POTATO...BUT GURU JI "LIVED" to show us an EXAMPLE..That THIS is the WAY TO LIVE... Many of the Singhs who underwent horrendous tortures at the hands of DUSHTS like Gobind Raam etc LIVED for DAYS...to let the BUTCHER have All the SATISFACTION he wanted...and SHOW him How a Singh of Guru Arjun Ji LIVES.... Every body DIES...some in air crashes, some in car crashes, some by drowning, some climbing mountains, some by murder/hanging/suicide/self destruction/..some even die sleeping at home/in icu wards if hospitals... BUT those WHO LIVE like Bab ji Deep Singh Ji, BBa Ji Zorawar Singh Ji bab JI Fateh Singh Ji...Baba Ji jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa..and all those mentioned in thsi post and other posts..THEY are ALL worthy of giving EXAMPLE/Wittness/Sakhi and part of our Glorious History. Singhs in Full khalsa banna BaNNI... LIVED a "FULL LIFE"..and "monah" sikhs Lived a "SHORT" life..BUT if BOTH lived for the KHALSA PANTH..then they are both examples. I am sure sombody can show me a few Fully Amritdharee "looking" singhs who turned traitors/police informers/and died cowardly deaths..and then somebody else can show me a few monah sikhs who did the exact opposite..??? SO ??. Some are naturally ahead of others but that should not be used against the "slower" ones. Let Guru Ji judge them. Bhul Chuk maaf Jarnail Singh.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

ekta · 28 Jul 2005

hate hate hate, shaheedi is daleri, sikh or not, sikhs are'nt the only ones capable of shaheedi and service of humanity a monah does mahaan seva by giving shaheedi.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

i.singh · 28 Jul 2005

i think we need to stop taking the creditability of those that have given their lives in the past recent years.....there is no doubt that many mona sikhs have given their lives, along with singhs, i have even read somewhere that there were probably more mone shaeeds then singhs....but thats beside the point, the point that we are forgetting is that alot of those that did die, were fighting for justice..i even know of a few hindus that were fighting against the govt...simple fact is that the people of punjab were getting killed and opressed! Moneh were getting killed and tortured along with singhs, maybe not in the same quantity, but never the less they were still be mistreated! singhs gave the life fighting for the panth, as the panth was under attack, along with the rest of punjab! not everyone that gave their life was fighting for the panth, but for the freedom of punjab....but i still think that those moneh that gave their life, including those singhs that wernt amrithdari had imense courage,more then any of us here...but whether they get to sachkand is a question we cannot answer, we read about many exceptions that have been made in the past, but one thing that is neccassary is taking amrit, whether or not these shaids have got to sachkand is a question that only dharamraja or maharaj can give n answer, lets not take the shine of these shaeeds, as they have made a huge sacrifice, n maharjad must have blessed them to give them the power to do so in the 1st place!

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

Kulbir Singh · 28 Jul 2005

As “Singh” wrote in this thread, only a rehitvaan Singh who gives martyrdom totally selflessly and for the chardi kala of Panth can be classified as a “Shaheed” in Gurmat sense. Very few individuals who lost their lives in the period from 1978 to 1992 can be classified as pure shaheed in Gurmat sense. These shaheeds in pure Gurmat Sense go to Sach Khand and have an everlasting life that Brahmgiyanis have. Having said that, the individuals who gave their lives for the chardi kala of Panth but were not fully rehitvaan Gursikhs still greatly benefit from this sacrifice and no doubt get love of Guru Sahib. They are greatly elevated spiritually and get janam in the house of gursikhs and in the next life do more sewa of Guru Sahib and eventually go to Sach Khand. Whether a Rehitvaan Gursikh gives life or a monna or less rehitvaan gives life, either way sacrifice of one’s life greatly augments the kamaayee of the individual. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

ekta · 28 Jul 2005

I don't understand, the ultimate thing in life is to die selflessly ntn is above that...veer kulbir singh, i thought u'd be able to reason with that thought.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

Kulbir Singh · 28 Jul 2005

------- I don't understand, the ultimate thing in life is to die selflessly ntn is above that...veer kulbir singh, i thought u'd be able to reason with that thought. ------- Ekta jeeo, The ultimate aim in life is not to die selflessly (it is good to do so but it is not the ultimate aim) but to attain union with Vaheguru. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

ekta · 29 Jul 2005

which thus gives union with vaheguru. god is not selfish that he's gonna just see if u did abyaas on him

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

RoopKaur · 29 Jul 2005

>god is not selfish that he's gonna just see if u did abyaas on him< This world and our life is a game. The only way of winning is through naam abhyaas.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

ekta · 29 Jul 2005

thats putting a limit on the limitless.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

Sucha Singh · 29 Jul 2005

"As “Singh” wrote in this thread, only a rehitvaan Singh who gives martyrdom totally selflessly and for the chardi kala of Panth can be classified as a “Shaheed” in Gurmat sense. Very few individuals who lost their lives in the period from 1978 to 1992 can be classified as pure shaheed in Gurmat sense. These shaheeds in pure Gurmat Sense go to Sach Khand and have an everlasting life that Brahmgiyanis have." How do do you know that most of the Gursikhs who lost their lives from 1978 to 1992 were not rehitvaan Singhs? So while the 'non rehitvaan Singhs' were giving their lives for the Khalsa Panth, so what are the 'rehitvaan Singhs' up to during this time? Doing simran and ignoring the atrocities committed on the people of Punjab? These statements are so sick. The original post was about a Singh who gave his life for the Panth and now look what it has become.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

Niranjan Singh · 30 Jul 2005

Veer Kulbir Singh said : [i]Very few individuals who lost their lives in the period from 1978 to 1992 can be classified as pure shaheed in Gurmat sense. [/i] Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji, I usually agree with a lot of your posts, but like Sucha Singh, I am troubled by the above statement. How do you conclude there were "very few" ? I think most of the people who sacrificed their life for the Panth during that time deserve the Shaheed reference, regardless of what we think about them. How can we nit-pick someone's sacrifice ? Would Satwant Singh, Bhai Sukha, Bhai Jinda, and Dilawar Singh be classified as Shaheeds ? If not, it does not matter, the Panth still accepts them as such. Amyways, it seems this thread is truly digressed from it's original topic : Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa, so it really should be closed.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

Waheguru · 01 Aug 2005

in my stupid eyes, its easy to attain shaheedi ......compared to living a life of amritvelas, keeping the strict khalsa rehit and loving everyone equally. anyone can give their head physically, but to actually GIVE their life/soul/breath to guru ji is only attained by very few. http://mistakesingh.blogspot.com/

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

pointless · 01 Aug 2005

Nobody here is guru sahib, you dont know who goes were after they die, wether a mona shaheed gets ultimate union with akal purakh or not how do you know? Its not your decision to make on either side of the argument.

Re: A REAL Babbar: Shahid Bhai Amarjit Singh Khalsa

007 Singh · 01 Aug 2005

Was this 'Bhai Amarjit Singh Babbar' the same one as 'Bhai Amarjit Singh Daheroo'??? Its jus that 'Daheroo' wasnt mentioned in the article so I thought it maybe someone else. Answer to question will greatly be appeciated. Thanks W J K K, W J K F