Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

amrit - kakar

amrit - kakar

xzibit · 11 Apr 2003

if i took amrit from an akj panj can i still choose kesh as a kakar after its done, cause akal takhat says we can choose which ever one....?

Re: amrit - kakar

Khalsa Soulja · 12 Apr 2003

..........why take akj amrit if u think kes is a kakkar? myself i am still not sure, but i think dastaar needs to be worn all the time and by all, that is obvious, and the trivial matter of which is which shouldnt reallly make a difference- either way ur head should be covered all the time - nearly EVER rehitnama says that.

Re: amrit - kakar

sawa lakh · 12 Apr 2003

I think the main reason people amrit shuck from akj is for naam drir. All the details fall into place afterwards.

Re: amrit - kakar

xzibit · 13 Apr 2003

so can we take amrit cause of the naam drir, then have kesh instead of keski??

Re: amrit - kakar

Singh · 13 Apr 2003

Vahegurrooo Ji Ka Khalsa Vahegurrooo Ji Ki Fateh What is the big deal in wearing a keski. Keski is a kakkaar,, it should be worn by everyone,,, no exceptions,,, gur fateh

Re: amrit - kakar

Singhnee · 14 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> if i took amrit from an akj panj can i still choose kesh as a kakar after its done, cause akal takhat says we can choose which ever one....? <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Dear xzibit jeeo, you have to follow the hukams of punj. If they say keski is kakaar you can't accept kes as kakaar. You have to obey all the hukams given by punj during Amrit Sinchaar for whole life. I never heard that Akaal Takhat says you can choose any of keski or kakaar. Akaal Takhat never says anything. It's SGPC who says something and you first should think if they are rehatvaan people who are in power as SGPC members or any other jathebandi in panth who is talking about rehat. There is an example of this kind of incidents. Before approximately 1930 At Akaal Takhat Sahib there was no Amrit Sinchaar without keski. Then there was a new jathedaar appointed named bhai Gurmakh Singh and his Singhni was not wearing dastaar. It's understood that how he could tell all panth to wear keski as kakaar if his own singhni was not keeping that rehat. So, he started two Amrit Sinchaars. One with keski and another without keski. I don't blame innocent sangat if they argue over kes and keski, it's dhill of our leaders who confused sangat for their own benifits. Guru Sahib won't forgive them for all that confusen in panth. Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: amrit - kakar

xzibit · 14 Apr 2003

if keski is a kakar, how come we are given a choice between taht and kesh? akal takhat is the supreme court, we abide by it. if they say we have a choice, dotn we have a choice?

Re: amrit - kakar

Singhnee · 14 Apr 2003

No, we don't have choices. Akaal Takhat Sahib never gave us choices of kakaar. Guru Sahib gave us five kakaars not six to choose from. Who told you that we have choices of kakaars? Did you read it somewhere?

Re: amrit - kakar

Sarbloh Badman · 14 Apr 2003

i believe keski is a kakkar...... but why do some rehitnamas say kesh? were they just messed up? from my knowledge only bhai chaupa singhs says keski and he has some messed up views on brahminism and women........

Re: amrit - kakar

Harjinder Singh · 14 Apr 2003

singh jee take amrit from dixie Gurdwara sahib, this coming up weekend. You dont need to worry about keski being a kakar, all the sangat there believes in kesh. Hope to see you there! WJKK WJKF

Re: amrit - kakar

Singhnee · 14 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> singh jee take amrit from dixie Gurdwara sahib, this coming up weekend. You dont need to worry about keski being a kakar, all the sangat there believes in kesh. Hope to see you there! WJKK WJKF <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Bhai Sahib Harjinder Singh jeeo, kirpa karke don't try to mislead sangat. Did you ever try to research about the real fifth kakaar that was given by Guru Gobind Singh jee on April 13, 1699??? If not please do some more reading than just suggesting someone to accept wrong things going around in the panth. I know few Singhs used to do Amrit Sinchaar at Dixie and they know about the importance of keski but can't enforce it because sangat is too used to for kes kakaar now. Their jathedaar accepted that infront of me that they can't change it right now( even they know the truth) because there won't be more people coming to amrit chhuk with keski. Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: amrit - kakar

bhagwan · 14 Apr 2003

singhnee, why you think your view is right? the WHOLE panth other then akj and other small sects believe in kesh. how is it that akj comes up and puts their views on everyone. shastarvidya had valid points saying taht akj thinks their maryada is truth but they only just pretend to be full gursikhs like nihangs are. is the whole taksal misled too? boht damdami and mani singh taksal have been around since guru ji. are they totally wrong but a sect like akj whose been around a few decades all of a sudden right?

Re: amrit - kakar

R2D2 · 14 Apr 2003

I agree with "Bhagwan". Research can be done by anyone as to the validity of kesh as a kakaar OR keski as a kakaar. Just because Singhnee Jee believes it, doesn't make it right. AKJ's belief in keski as a kakaar does not make it an absolute truth.

Re: amrit - kakar

Mkhalsa · 15 Apr 2003

I don't think another word needs to be said on this topic. Bhagwan jeeo, please read the gurmat section of this site for more information.

Re: amrit - kakar

Singhnee · 15 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> singhnee, why you think your view is right? <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Bhagwan jeeo I could be wrong but Guru Sahib's rehat is always right. I am just talking about rehat. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the WHOLE panth other then akj and other small sects believe in kesh. how is it that akj comes up and puts their views on everyone. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< What you mean by whole panth? you go after quantity but Gurmat is quality not quantity. Read these pankties from gurbaani: "ko virlaa gurmat challay jeeo" Now it is up to you whatever you call those virlaa gurmakhs. If you wanna see quantity there is example of sheep. All sheep follow one without using their brains. You think they are right??? Do you want gursikhs to be like sheep?. Waheguru gave us budh to think about right and wrong and there is Gurbaani to show us right path. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> shastarvidya had valid points saying taht akj thinks their maryada is truth but they only just pretend to be full gursikhs like nihangs are. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> So you have so much hate for akj that you justify those manukh UK Nihangs. A taksaali can't accept someone who's killing animals for their jeebh russ(for food). A taksaali can't justify having sukhaa(bhang) in sikhi. How you support taksaal then. I don't understand why you hate gurmat and love manmatt. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> is the whole taksal misled too? boht damdami and mani singh taksal have been around since guru ji. are they totally wrong but a sect like akj whose been around a few decades all of a sudden right? <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Who said these taksaals were started by Guru Sahib jee? Any reference from history??? If they were started from Guru Sahib jee they were suppose to keep bibek, sarloh rehat and keski as a kakaar. I have one question to all these pro kesh singhs and singhnees. Are Singhs and Singhnies have equal rights according to sikhi or they could be different????????? If the answer is yes then can a singh go to get Amrit by having jooRa at back part of his head or with breaded hair(gutt) as women go there. If he can't go without dastaar as a woman can, then why your big panth supports this discrimination????? Think about that with cool mind and please tell sangat in light of gurmat how you justify this discrimination. If this discriminations seems wrong then solution is KESKI NOT KESH. Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: amrit - kakar

Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 15 Apr 2003

Vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaheguru ji ki fateh Personally I think this thread is proving to be discouraging to those who are working towards taking Khanda baate ki Pahul. From a simple question alone we have moved onto bashing the Damdami Taksal and the rest of the Panth. Just because they do not follow the same Rehit, they are indirectly being called sheep. Come on people. Is this Sikhi? Even at the time of the Misls different Rehits existed. No one group liked the other. Let the person decide where he wants to take Amrit. We cannot force anyone by saying the ‘Jatha’ amrit is better the rest of the Panth. The Punj are the roop of Guru Sahib, regardless of where they are doing seva. Whatever they say, the person taking amirt has to abide by that. I think one is fine as long as he/SHE wears a Dastar. Does anyone really think it would matter at the end if we wear a Dastar at all times but just don’t take it as a kakaar? Those who take Kesh as a Kakaar are following the Hukam of their Punj and so are those who take Keski as a Kakaar. No one here can be proven wrong. I’m not writing this post to prove which the right kakaar is because individually I’m not the whole of Khalsa Panth and nor am I doing the seva of Punj Pyare.  “What you mean by whole panth? you go after quantity but Gurmat is quality not quantity. Read these pankties from gurbaani: "ko virlaa gurmat challay jeeo"” If Gurmat is all about quality and not even a tad about quantity then there was no need for Guru Sahib to create the Khalsa Panth. The Punj alone must have been enough. No? “Who said these taksaals were started by Guru Sahib jee? Any reference from history??? If they were started from Guru Sahib jee they were suppose to keep bibek, sarloh rehat and keski as a kakaar.” Even though I have nothing to do with the Taksal, it still hurts me to see such uncivilized and ignorant hate being put upon other Panthik Jathebandis. Singhnee ji, refrences do exist but sadly majority of us have not bothered to open a single panaa of historical books. My suggestion is that you go read ‘Sodhi Chamatkaar’ by Kavi Santokh Singh Ji. You will find your reference in one of the last 30 chapters. Don’t worry, there are less then a 100 pages to read. Bhai Sahib writes that it was Sahib Sri Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji who blessed the land of Damdama Sahib, which later became the starting point of Damdami Taksal. He even mentions Bhai Mani Singh Ji di Takaal. Many taksalis do keep bebeaik and sarbloh rehit. Our brother, mkhalsa even wrote on the American Sikh yahoo egroup that there are more bebeakis in Taksal than in the AKJ. Please ask him to prove his point. The argument here is only about Keski so you cannot use that point to prove Taksal did not start at the time of Guru Gobind Singh Ji Sahib. Lets first work onto proving it a kakaar and then only we can use this point against them. My suggestion is that we keep such posts off of this board. A week or so ago, this board was full of inspirational posts by veer Kulbir Singh Ji and now it has become an akhara to beat others using our keyboards. The admin should deal with similar posts using email and they shouldn’t be made public as they only give birth to hatred and nothing else. “if i took amrit from an akj panj can i still choose kesh as a kakar after its done, cause akal takhat says we can choose which ever one....?” xzibit ji, no one among us can give you the right answer. My suggestion is that you go talk to the Punj at the amrit sanchar. Raise all your questions there and let us know what they told you afterwards. vaaheguru ji ka khalsa vaaheguru ji ki fateh

Re: amrit - kakar

Kulbir Singh · 15 Apr 2003

I agree with “Son of Guru Gobind Singh jee” that we should never say anything unsavoury about our panthik organizations. Taksal is a respectable organization of panth and we should not allow any Taksal-bashing on this site or any other site. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: amrit - kakar

R2D2 · 15 Apr 2003

*** Bhagwan jeeo I could be wrong but Guru Sahib's rehat is always right. I am just talking about rehat. *** Actually Bhenji, I believe that is what we're talking about right now too. When you say you're just talking about Rehat you're implying that what YOU think Guru Sahib's Rehat to be is correct. The issue is that other people believe that your view is wrong. Don't make it seem like if someone disagrees with keski as a kakaar that they are going against Guru Sahib's rehat. This issue is not a resolved as of yet, and the simple fact is just because it is resolved for you, does not mean it is resolved for everyone else. ***What you mean by whole panth? you go after quantity but Gurmat is quality not quantity *** By the same token bhenji, one cannot say that AKJ has a patent on the 'quality' gursikhs in the panth. "Bhagwan"was illustrating the fact that the vast majority of Sikhs believe kesh to be a kakaar and not keski. This could possibly mean that because MOST people believe kesh to be the true kakaar that maybe it is. Moreover, Singhnee Jee your comment implying the rest of the panth as being blind sheep is not only deragatory to the rest of the Sikhs in the world but also reeks of ego. ***Who said these taksaals were started by Guru Sahib jee? Any reference from history??? If they were started from Guru Sahib jee they were suppose to keep bibek, sarloh rehat and keski as a kakaar. *** Wrong Bhenji, keski as a kakaar is what you interpret Rehat to be. Like stated above, other people disagree with you and they DO have their reasons and evidence for justifying their position. (as do you! :) ) *** I have one question to all these pro kesh singhs and singhnees. Are Singhs and Singhnies have equal rights according to sikhi or they could be different????????? If the answer is yes then can a singh go to get Amrit by having jooRa at back part of his head or with breaded hair(gutt) as women go there. If he can't go without dastaar as a woman can, then why your big panth supports this discrimination????? *** Last time I checked my "big panth" was also your big panth, unless you're saying otherwise. To answer your question, no he couldn't go in with a guth. Just like he couldn't go in wearing a chunee and a suit and sulvar because he'd look like an idiot. It's not discrimination bhenji, it's common sense. Would I go take amrit wearing a kachera on my head...afterall, it IS on my body, no? I guess this goes back to the very essence of the argument. You say that the man's keski IS his kakaar. Others say that it is a means of keeping his kesh safe, clean, etc. That is why women are allowed to take amrit without a keski because it is their kesh that is regarded as their kakaar. In reality, I agree with MKhalsa Veera on this one. This argument could go on forever and in some ways it feels like it has! In all honesty, I see no end to this issue and I cannot see it being resolved. People on both sides of the issue can justify their positions on this argument and therefore have a right to believe whatever they choose. But let me take this oppurtunity to ask Singhnee and Mkhalsa Jee and others how they plan on dealing with this disagreement. I personally can tolerate the view that you both have about keski being a kakaar. Can you say the same about my view? or Bhagwans? Or is it as easy as "i'm right, you're wrong...either you accept the way I think about this or I won't accept you"..???

Re: amrit - kakar

Admin · 15 Apr 2003

This topic of Keski Vs Kesh Kakaar is closed on this forum. Unless someone brings out something really unique or some new proof, this site will not entertain debate on this issue. Our stand is that Keski is Kakaar and we have made our case in the literature section of this site. Please read that and if you have anything new to say, we will be happy to debate.