"Crowd Pleasing"
Miss Stupid Kaur · 11 Apr 2003
Call me Stupid for what I am going to say...
Call me an Idiot...
Call me a Moorakh...
Call me Egotistical...
Call it Ninda...
Call me the worst person in the world for saying this...
But what I say might come off as ninda and mean, but it must be addressed. The WarriorSaint.com individuals shouldn't present the material on thier site. It doesn't give the right message about the true arts of martial for Sikhs.
They opened this site teach Gatkaa, I commend them. Good Job. I respect the site for great efforts, but accuracy of truth is much needed. If one sees the Multimedia section, we can all clearly see that this is mainly for show. Not in the sense that it is paakhand, but that it is for presentational purposes. Basically pleasing crowds.
This is where my main point comes in... The site is all good and dandy, but useless. There is no martial art in this, nor self defense. They do not have the knowledge of Shastar Vidhiya. Honestly, from seeing all the videos, they are all lacking the arts of Battle Combat. There are no skills presented here other than the fact that they can show us what the arts are to public by mass. But this is not what a "Gatkaa Akhara" is. We should learn what our true martial heritage is. It lyes in Shastar Vidhiya, or the science of weapons. Lets not get into the controversy of the things that the Nihang Singhs said on www.sarbloh.com or www.shastarvidiya.org said, but look at the shastar vidhiya. SHASTAR VIDHIYA IS GOLD. We have to respect these Singhs for the Battle Techniques and true Warrior spirit that they are upholding with them. What We have to understand is that they are 100% correct about what the common gatkaabaaj practitioners are doing compared to what the real martial heritage is. I have been aware of this for a long time but they have had the guts to get the point accross, give videos, pictures, literature, and other sources of multimedia to expose the truth about Shastar Vidhiya to the Sangat...
Lets not take what I am saying as an insult to warrior saints or anything but we dont need another site like thier's preaching the wrong thing that we can dress up as the well trained fauj of Guru Gobind Singh jee but we cannot uphold the values of Shastar Vidhiya or combat. I am not picking on WarriorSaints mainly, I am also referring to other sites and "akharas" that also present this.
After understanding, learning, and practicing what our true martial history is, seeing the videos on WarriorSaints is sad. The Nihang Singhs, or Shastar Vidhiya Gurdevs, have really put this concept into perspective. There is no constructive Vidhiya here. What do we learn from the sites from the martial arts perspective, seriously? Watch the sparring video... It is clearly set up. They are simply hitting the bamboo sticks together while jumping up and down and circling eachother. Also, they come accross as very fierce warriors with the face cloth on as bana, but they lack the true science of Shastar. What is the point then? They aren't even attempting to hit the opponent's leg or arm or vital body parts.
From a perspective of Martial Arts... Sorry to say... what is presented here is no match for any martial art -- Karate, Judo, Kung Fu, Ninjitsu, Boxing, Kickboxing, etc... A true Shastar Vidhiya Gurdev like the Nihangs (Which includes puratan singhs like Banda Bahadur, Baba Deep Singh, Akali Phoola Singh, etc. etc.), can destroy these Karate and other practitioners in a match. (or i would believe so. Guru Gobind Singh Jee's Shastar vidhiya is very effective).
Pyareo, you may think i am being mean, being arrogant, ignorant, foolish, slandering, etc... But these things must be said. This image of faslehood must be destroyed. Though I do not wish to attack WarriorSaints at all, I am simply using thier example as the prime one since they site is fairly new and is teaching the same old thing. It comes accross as the real thing but its not. Holding a sword and twirling it in a video, or for a crowd, or posing with it in a picture, is not Combat technique. Knowing Shastar Vidhiya and the Fighting techniques for Self Defence is what is needed. I doubt that if any of these gatkaabaaj were in a real life situation with simply what they are presenting on this site about "Sikh Martial Arts" i.e. Gatka, they wouldn't be able to fight the enemy. Lets get as close as we can to Shastar Vidhiya, and stay away from this mockery of the true battle arts. The maryland Gatka camp video is better. It shows a little closer and more practical amount of vidhiya of dhaal and kirpan, and other forms of sparring. By showing shananigans, we are simply letting on more taunts by experienced Shastar experts. This is a joke in comparison to the real deal.
Enough said. Let us discuss. If you think I am being a wise guy, you are probably right, and I apologize to you in advance. Keep in mind, I am a lowly jaachak that is begging for the charan dhooR of true Warrior Saints. Even I am looking for making our community stronger and more prosperous. Please forgive this moorakh for what he has said is wrong.
Miss Stupid Kaur.
Re: "Crowd Pleasing"
Kulbir Singh · 12 Apr 2003
>>>>>>>>
We have to respect these Singhs for the Battle Techniques and true Warrior spirit that they are upholding with them. What We have to understand is that they are 100% correct about what the common gatkaabaaj practitioners are doing compared to what the real martial heritage is.
>>>>>>>
I have heard this from the UK nihungs so many times that all gatka except theirs is fake. This is pure ahankaar. At some places they call it a circus but it is not true. Uptej Singh and his team does some awesome Gatka and as I have heard from other singhs, they are fully skilled in the battlefield attacking techniques (Jangi Vaar).
What good is the UK Nihung gatka, when they don't uphold the golden principles of Gurmat? If we are to get impressed just by their fighting skills, then there are many in the world who are not in Sikhi but have great fighting skills. There are Tae-Kwon-Do Grandmasters. There are Shaolin Ninjas and what not. Rajputs have great fighting skills and so do the Mohammadens. Does that mean that we should consider these people our heroes just for their fighting skills?
It is utter stupidity to agree with the stupid notion of UK Nihungs that all other singhs who do gatka are doing circus and what they do is the real thing? It may be possible that when the singhs demonstrate Gatka, they show certain steps and also we should remember that they are only sparring and not doing actual fight. What are they supposed to do in front of all the people? Cut off each other?
The hand to hand combat displayed in the videos of shastervidiya site, are merely copy of Karate or Tae Kwon Do. I did not see any unique blocking or attacking technique. What they display in the videos, can be seen at any martial arts schools. Don't get overly impressed by what they say.
That Narsingh technique that they use is utterly barbarian like. To actually eat up someone's neck and drink blood from there is evil. This is what vampires do. I can't believe that many Sikhs are impressed at such evil. I cannot believe that the singhs in olden days went to this length as to drink blood from someone's neck. What a disgusting thing to do.
Bhain jee Kaur jeeo, you seem to be overly impressed by the nihungs. Please understand that the hand to hand combat is nothing new. It is same as other marital arts.
>>>>>>>>.
From a perspective of Martial Arts... Sorry to say... what is presented here is no match for any martial art -- Karate, Judo, Kung Fu, Ninjitsu, Boxing, Kickboxing, etc...
>>>>>>>
What are you talking about bhain jeeo? The hand to hand combat is no different from what they teach at Karate or Judo. In fact, to me it seems like it was hundred percent karate and judo - mixed. His blocking techniques are like Karate and grappling techniques are like Judo. I refuse to believe that what he is presenting is anything unique.
>>>>>>>>>>
Pyareo, you may think i am being mean, being arrogant, ignorant, foolish, slandering, etc... But these things must be said. This image of faslehood must be destroyed. Though I do not wish to attack WarriorSaints at all, I am simply using thier example as the prime one since they site is fairly new and is teaching the same old thing. It comes accross as the real thing but its not. Holding a sword and twirling it in a video, or for a crowd, or posing with it in a picture, is not Combat technique
>>>>>>>>>>>
This was such a mean attack at the video presented by warriorsaints. Can't you see that the Gatka Demo video, also has many beginners in that video, and as such you cannot expect them to cut off each other. The other videos i.e. free sword videos are pretty good and it is a must to learn that step work, in order to become an accomplished sword fighter. It is foolish to criticize such videos without understanding the reason and purpose of this step work.
If you are saying that this video is a circus, then what would you call Nidar Singh video with a child? Was that not a circus by your definition?
It is unfortunate that the UK nihungs are causing a division in the gatkayee singhs of UK. Instead of forming a union and doing everything together, these so called "Real Khalsa" is pitting singhs against each other and are making open challenges from their website. They are doing no service to panth by acting in this way.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Crowd Pleasing"
Sarbloh Badman · 15 Apr 2003
a few views
i have learnt from uptej singh. hes a really great guy. no, really. although im not 100percent keen on his style of gatka he puts soooo much effort into making the kids enjoy it, it was really fun when i did it.
gatka is a useful art but shaster vidiya as taught by nihungs is the original art of the gurus. we should all try and learn a martial art, yes its better to learn shaster vidiya but if our intentions are pure then its ok. niddar singh is an extremely good martial artist but hes got more pride than anyone else ive ever seen, i doubt he reaches particularly high spiritual levels.
lol as for modern warfare, did u know afgans are teaching our sikh kids in pakistan that very thing right now (1st hand knowledge i got too)
although the pakis might be using us a bit, they are definately bein nice to us lol (we get treated better in pakistan than india, trust me, even if the gurdwaras arent quite ship shape) and they are training us up.
my advice is try to learn shaster vidiya, if u cant, then learn a really street applicable are like thai boxing or wing chun. failing that learn gatka, and u also, when u move to india (which u shud all be doing to help out our brothers n sisters lol) go learn other types of warfare.
the nihungs of gurujis time had a leathal combination - naam simran, shaster vidiya, and guerilla tactics. if we combine all these 3 then theres nothng stopping us......these days people only have 1, maybe 2, if u can learn all 3 then thas what u need.......
Re: "Crowd Pleasing"
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 15 Apr 2003
in 1984, the sings new gathka who defneded harminder sahib saach khaand sahib......... these singhs were dissaplined with bani bana and shaster videa they could control the bullet of a gun, only then they defended saach khaand harminder sahib from the hindoo raj, for one week against cannons helicopters and tanks with only small arms!
wahe gurooooo
Re: "Crowd Pleasing"
Sarbloh Badman · 16 Apr 2003
lol....to the person who says we dont need to know guerilla warfare....
tell me bhai what u will do if india decides to launch another bluestar when u are in the golden temple (it might happen u know)..........would u run away because u wud b useless like many people did (even blew a hole in the side of harimandir sahib to get out) or would u with your knowledge stay and fight with the sikh panth???
even now there are singhs dying in punjab, trying to uproot the tyranny that is the punjab police, guerilla tactics are more appropriate than ever nowadays
wjkk wjkf
Re: "Crowd Pleasing"
Khalsa Soulja · 16 Apr 2003
urmmmmmmmmmm nimrata
im only 16 but trust me i havent got the average life planned
lol if u look back thru oooold posts on sikhhistory ull see what i got planned - and i aint sittin on my butt at the moment either....and this isnt a joke either
u would be REALLY suprised how many young singhs and singhnees there are out there, who arent all talk, and are willing to put their life towards sikhi in panjab, they just need a direction, which is being provided.
Re: "Crowd Pleasing"
Khalsa Soulja · 17 Apr 2003
indeedy.......if u r really itching to know then mail me
Re: "Crowd Pleasing"
Pushpinder singh · 11 May 2006
THE MARTIAL ART BEING DEPICTED TODAY BY SIKHS IS NO MATCH TO WHAT IT ACTIULLY IS. THIS GATKA BEIN SHOWN IN VIDEOS OR NAGAR KIRTANS IS JUST A natak ITS NOT REAL
THE REAL GATKA NEEDS TO BE SO FAST .. SO ACTIVE .. SO STRIKING
IF ANYBODY TAKES THE TASK HE CAN STILL FIND SOME NIHANGS IN india WHO ARE NEAR DEATH AND KNOW REAL MARTIAL ART LIKE USING CHAKARS, STICKS, BOW AND ARROW, KIRPAN ETC
I AM ALL IN SUPPORT OF AUTHOR OF THIS POST THAT WHAT IS BEING SHOWN IS NOP WAY NEAR CHINESE AND JAPANEES EMARTIAL ART
THE HIGH LEVELS OR MARTIAL ART WORK OF DHYAN ... SPIRTUALITY .. NAAM SIMRAN .. ENLIGHTENMENT AND THESE SHOWMANS WHO DEPICT GATKA ARE NO WAY NEAR TO IT
IT WAS PRACTISED BY BHAI BACHITAR SINGH JI WHO PUT BARCHA IN HEAD OF ELEPHANT THROUGH IRON SHIELDS
GURU FATEH
Re: "Crowd Pleasing"
Qust_4_the_timeless_one · 12 May 2006
I 100% agree with the topic starter. Gatka is no where near close to a real fighting system. Sorry to disagree with you kulbir singh. I respect you and what you have to say a lot. But here I think your wrong. I've done gatka i've even talked indian nihungs who teach "gatka". They don't know what they talking about. I asked one nihung what should one do if he is attacked and only has his small kirpan. The nihung said I don't know grab on to the attacker with dear life. I Swear this is true. It made me sad. I've learned hapkido, muy tai kicboxing, karate and i even learned some shastar vidiya from a u.k nihung or nung. I learned very little but was very impressed at the depth he went into while teaching me. But then they started on there nung parchaar so i stopped learning. He was only in my town for a short time. But that short time was too long. I have no respect for these nungs I really don't. But honestly guys i have little respect for those who potray gatka as a real martial art when its nothing but a show. I've been to a few akharas and they teach u how to twirl and spin and jump. Never any real foot work. Mool panthra is taught for a few days nothing much. No proper stance, no hand to hand combat.
They don't even teach you how to strike with a real sword. Should we use our hips and have a snapping motion when decapitating someone, where are the kill spots. How do u kill with bare hands, how do u kill with small kirpan, heck they don't even show u how to kill with a real kirpan. Have u seen the types of kirpans they use in shows. Even in practice. Heck someone told me to join in on a show where a bunch of us are supposed to fight one person. And when i started attackign they told me to take it easy and only pretend to come in and when i'm close just stick my stick out so the main person can hit it. Really turned me off gatka. Not to mention the blind folded parler tricks. Where u can see from the bottom of the blind fold. Yes really clever, lets decieve the sangat so they think we are greater then we really are. Listen much respect to all those holding akharas and tournaments. Helping kids get out of bad things through gatka. But pls don't try to pass it off as a real art. Because anyone who has truly learned gatka knows its not.
Also if uptej singh has any battle tactics or fighting ability i'm sure it come from his vast background of different martial arts not gatka. Trust me on this, I learned the hard way. I thought i was learning the sacred art of the gurus, what i got was egotistical teachers who don't knwo a kill spot from a regular spot. (not talking about uptej singh, never learned from him) Honestly guys if u think gatka is the real deal. WAKE UP. test a "gatka ustaad" of ten years against a real martial artist of ten years. You will see whats up. I wish someone could teach shaster vidiya i would be the first one to learn. I refuse to learn from the nungs. My two cents.
Re: "Crowd Pleasing"
BirRass Singh · 13 May 2006
Quest, it is your opinion of what a "nung" is, according to Nihang maryada they believe what they believe because to them it is what is true, if you have conflicting views then you should sit down and do bachan with such persons and understand the concepts rather then walk away and forget about learning the art. The sad news is that the decades of neglect and not doing any "kadar", shastarvidiya/jang vidiya amongst the Sikhs has more or less become extinct, at this present time there is less then half a dozen real dedicated students and in years to come they will fully learn it with the Gurus Kirpa.
The last person who had knowledge of shastarvidiya was Baba Raam Singh from Patiala, but he passed away 2 years ago, some old babas within the Dal have small knowledge, no where enough that is needed to call what they know a system. Luckily/Unfortunately (depending on your belief) Niddar Singh is probably the last person who knows the art fully. Its your choice whether you wish to look past the ideology and maryada and learn a dying art.
I have respect for the people who teach Gatka because they instill Sikhi within their students, where the art is not the main goal but a Gursikhijeevan, however the portayl of Gatka being the true art of the Gurus is misleading, and if anything in the future the children learning will be dissapointed to see that the techniques that are shown are not effective against a proper martial artist.