Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

Kulbir Singh · 07 Oct 2003

What a joke! When will this issue get resolved in panth? Gurbani is clear on this. No meat is allowed to Sikhs. Daas, Kulbir Singh Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue Manpreet Randhawa Jalandhar, October 7 If the Shiromani Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee (SGPC) has its way, all hotels, restaurants and fast-food chains will soon have to carry displays specifying the kind of meat they serve: halal or jhatka. SGPC honorary secretary Manjit Singh Calcutta has said he would write to the Union government to issue a notification in this regard because the consumption of halal meat is strictly prohibited for Sikhs. "It is, in fact, one of the cardinal sins for a Sikh to consume halal meat," said Calcutta. "In case a Sikh does so, he has to be re-baptised. Hence, it's important for eating joints to display what meat is served”. Akal Takht Jathedar Joginder Singh Vedanti has also taken note of the matter and called upon all Sikhs to avoid consuming halal meat. Arun, an official representing McDonald's here, said the fast-food chain had been using halal meat all over India. "We never knew its consumption was prohibited for Sikhs," he said. "Since the matter has come to our notice now, we have decided to inform our headquarters in the US. Once we receive a direction from them on displaying the kind of meat we serve, it will be done." J.S. Grover of Nirula's, Delhi, said that most of the non-vegetarian items at their outlets were cut and processed with the help of machines. "Hence, it's difficult to ascertain whether it's halal or jhatka meat," he said. Grover added if the Federation of Hotel and Restaurant Association of India (FHRAI) issued guidelines in this regard, he would abide by it. FHRAI secretary general Sham Suri said since the SGPC had decided to knock on the Centre's door, the association would await an official notification on the issue. So far, hotels, restaurants and fast-food joints are governed by the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, said Suri. Meanwhile, the SGPC's stand has already found sympathisers. "In Europe and other countries one gets certified halal and jhatka meat so that nobody's religious sentiments are hurt," says G.S. Lamba, editor, Sant Sipahi magazine. "It is shocking how the industry can be indifferent to the sentiments of Sikhs." Interestingly, the issue is not a new one. It is learnt that on October 9, 1938, then MLA Sampooran Singh, who was also a member of the SGPC, had moved a resolution in the Punjab assembly that all SGPC members must support the Jhatka Bill. Ninety-six SGPC members in the House had unanimously supported the resolution.

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

nirgun · 08 Oct 2003

Singh, I need all of the quotes and proper translations you can send me for this subject. G'S'Lamba requested it thanks

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

seeker · 08 Oct 2003

if u guys canot follow the rehat maryada, obviously it would seem a joke...imagine any number of groups popping up in Sikhism, claiming they know better because of .........rehitname and ........reference.. do u guys honestly believe that the rules were changed last minute? where is your proof that the maryada is not how it was initially drafted!

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

Mr Rice Pudding · 08 Oct 2003

I think the Panth has sorted it out, you know when the entire Panth inclusing Bhai Randhir Singh over 10 years taking into account Gurbani and Puratan Hukamnamah agreed on the Sikh Rehat Maryada. Where I am sure you are awaire Kutha (hahal) meat is banned, and thats all.

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

Kulbir Singh · 08 Oct 2003

Following books on maas are very convincing: 1) Jhakta Maas Parthaai - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee 2) Tau kyoon Murgi maarai - Why kill a chicken - by Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara 3) A book on Maas by Dr. Santokh Singh Bagga (Dharam). 4) A book on maas by GP Singh or GP Sangat. Out of these books, numbers 1 and 4 are in Punjabi and should be translated. The Western world is finding out today that eating meat is not healthy for our body but Gurbani is full of references to maas being prohibited in Gurbani. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

jagjit singh · 08 Oct 2003

waheguru ji ke khalsa,waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, The only real difference between halal and haram, is on one the throat is cut vertically, and on the other it is cut horizontally. That is it. So essentially removing all baseless arguments, is not meat just meat. The whole halal / haram debate between hindus and muslims is really silly. As far as sikhs, one is supposedly a bujjar kurehhat and the other fine. It is just such a hipocritcal stance. The only way to really know if meat is haram is by killing it yourself, which none of the meat eaters actually do. They all buy it from shops and supermarkets, basically meaning the whole thing is a farce. How do they know if it is bujjar kurehit or not. Anyone with daya will not eat it anyway. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

nirgun · 08 Oct 2003

bhai kulbir singh jee can you please give me as many quotes as possible on this subject please it's important

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

Mkhalsa · 09 Oct 2003

The word kuttha and its derivatives are used in bani multiple times on HUMANS.. you cannot do halal of a person lol.. its just ridiculous.. it means death or killing i beleive. Kuttha does NOT mean halal. this farce was added as a footnote to the maryada by sgpc at a later time.

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

Gurpreet · 09 Oct 2003

Well said Jagjit and Kulbir Singh VeerJi. This is not even an issue, eating meat is not allowed. Any person who is advanced spiritually will have so much compassion for all that he/she will not eat meat anyway, what a useless waste of time by the SGPC, looks like they have too much time on their hands! Gurfateh

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

mmmhhh? · 09 Oct 2003

The only way to really know if meat is haram is by killing it yourself, which none of the meat eaters actually do. They all buy it from shops and supermarkets, basically meaning the whole thing is a farce. How do they know if it is bujjar kurehit or not. Anyone with daya will not eat it anyway. so does this mean it is OK to eat maas if killed by your own hands using the Chatka method? also, if we are to talk of Daya (compassion) - how many Sikhs do you know that are members of the RSPCA/Anti Vivisectionist societies...? we are not Jains.... do you extend your dya to all of the creation ie ants/rats as well....imagine your house was infested and you had to bring in an exterminator? the same problem can be extended to an overpopulation of a particular species, like Deers in Scotland... or can you kill animals as long as they are not consumed..? these are the questions that Anti meat sikhs avoid answering....

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

jagjit singh · 10 Oct 2003

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru jike fateh Pyare jio, my point veer ji, is that only by killing it yourself, if you accept haram meat is not a bujer kurehit, is the only way you know that you are not doing a bujjer kurehit. Surely for any true Gursikh, this is important, knowing whether you are doing a kurehit or not. Are they going to leave your status of amritdharee or kurehiteean in the hands of a supermarket or fast food restaurant. This is there own (pro-meat) arguments making a mockery of them. For most gursikhs meat is just not an issue, it is blatantly obvious it is not as per Gurmat thinking, that is why most Gursikhs see every type of meat as a kurehit. As far as your arguments you say we avoid. We do not avoid them, it is just no-one has put this argument forward before. If you think about it logically you will understand why? I did not realise that meat eaters were eating meat to stop population growth of species. I guess that explains chicken farms, and pig farms, and fish farms. This totally flew over my head. Pyare jio, I just thought they ate it because of taste, or wanting to show how hard they are by killing a goat. Nature naturally balances itself out, it is one if its Guuns(virtues). The only time nature has problems is when humans have introduced species, which do not fit the natural equilibrium of that specific environment. For example, Americans introduced African killer bees to california, because they produce more honey. But the environment has meant that these bees are growing out of control, and their nature of self-protection means they are attacking and killing humans. Once again man interfering with nature because of greed, causing problems for himself. Gurmat teaches us to love and respect Akal, and his creation. We do not harm it, but live in an equilibrium with it. Meat has nothing to do with this, unless you are going to start eating deers and bees, etc. Man can live perfectly healthly without meat, in fact some scientist say far more healthily. The British dental Association clearly state our teeth are not designed for meat. So really enough of this. Basically, veer ji, I think it is shame, when the whole world is turning towards and discovering the benefits of vegetarianism, why for some reason, a handful of youth in sikhi, are suddenly trying to go back to meat eating. It was good when sikhi was setting the example. When we read articles like the one above about SGPC, it just feels embarrassing for us as sikhs, that this is our leadership. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

Mr Rice Pudding · 10 Oct 2003

We kill tens of small animals like mice and rodents if pertersides and chemical, not to mention digging up the ground when we grow our vegatables, yet we complain killing an animal to eat is wrong. Whats the difference both ways innocent animals are killed as they have to for us to survive, which is what Guru Nanak has revealed in his Sakhi when he accepted and cooked the dear (which by the way a certain Khalsa may argue was changed into guess what RICE PUDDING)

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

Balpreet Singh · 10 Oct 2003

The difference between all the lives we take when breathing walking vs. when we slaughter an animal is clear: one lacks mercy while the other is inadvertant. If I'm walking and I unknowingly squish an ant, I didn't do it on purpose. But if I cut the throat of a screaming and wailing calf because I like my veal, I have shown a massive lack of mercy. Mercy is the father of faith and if I can kill something that is begging me for mercy just because I think it'll taste good, no dharam can take hold in my life. Like all other arguments: facts are before you. Arguing any further is a waste of time. Let's move on.

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

huh · 10 Oct 2003

what about mouse and rodents?? wheres the mercy factor in taking their lives then?

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

Mr Rice Pudding · 10 Oct 2003

It makes no difference to the animal. Eighter way by consuming food man is guilty of killing animals even if they are vegetarians. This is the law of nature. So why not eat the animal rather then just killing tens of them and leaving them in the field.

Re: Jhatka vs halal: Sikh body raises meaty issue

Balpreet Singh · 10 Oct 2003

Mice & Rodents: if these are causing a health risk to the residents of a house, then I see no reason why they should be allowed to run around contaminating things. It's not a question of mercy now, it's a health/sanitation issue. Rice Pudding, If someone is "guilty of killing animals" no matter what, then I guess when we're walking and smell the smok someone is blowing while having a cigarette, we're also "guilty" of committing the bujjer kurehit of smoking? Right? As for leaving the animals we kill on the field....umm...if you can eat ants we stomp and the bacteria we inhale, I'd be very surprised. Please be rational. Slitting a screaming calf's throat is MUCH different than inhaling a bacteria. Anyone can see that.