Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Anand-Karaj-Important

Anand-Karaj-Important

JagKaur · 09 Oct 2003

Waheguru ji ka khlasa waheguru jiki fateh. I have a question. I was wondering Anand karaj can be done with the same person twice? for exemple in different coutries because parents could not attend? is there anything wrong with it? with the same person of course! i really need to know, please.

Re: Anand-Karaj-Important

s!nghn! · 09 Oct 2003

If you think about it, the most important thing is that Guru Sahib was present at your anand karaj. To re-do it just so that more people can view it would almost turn it into a ritual in my opinion. We don't do anand karaj to show people, but to make a commitment with Guru Sahib as the focal-point. Since your commitment was already made, re-doing your laavan would basically be an empty practice with no deeper meaning. If we start re-doing such substantial ceremonies just because so and so didn't get to attend, we'll lose the true significance altogether.

Re: Anand-Karaj-Important

Singh · 09 Oct 2003

I also feel that doing a second anand-kaaraj is a bit pointless; it would not be really a dharmic ceremony done for Sikhi purposes, but for others. Doesn't make much sense to me.

Re: Anand-Karaj-Important

Ranjit Singh · 09 Oct 2003

I agree. Doing it again is pointless. It also seems sort of disrespectful to Guru Saahib, in that it implies that Guru Jee's blessings weren't enough. Anand Karaj isn't to show people, it's to create a union in the presence of Guru Saahib. It's always nice to have family and friends present at important events, but if they weren't able to make it, then it's just too bad.

Re: Anand-Karaj-Important

JagKaur · 09 Oct 2003

If i understand it correct, you mean that it is pointless to, physically at least, make guru ji the center of our live by the recitation of The Great Lavan, to renew that link to Him and to the person he choose for me to be with??? Forget the familly member not being able to attend, thats a minor thing. another issue, If i was married to this person before in the presence of guru ji, but we were BOTH NOT amritdharee then, and now that we are, is it still pointless to do the Lavan Again? (dont bring me the issue that non-amritdharee people should not even be married in guru ji's hazooree, thats not what im pointing out) Stick to what the main point is. you said: "re-doing your laavan would basically be an empty practice with no deeper meaning. If we start re-doing such substantial ceremonies just because so and so didn't get to attend, we'll lose the true significance altogether." If taking the Lavan-Anand Karaj, by surrounding Guru ji so direspectfull, THEN why do Parkarman??? Or is it that Parkarman have no true Significant value-meaning and are just some rituals? Bhai Ranjit singh ji said"I agree. Doing it again is pointless. It also seems sort of disrespectful to Guru Saahib, in that it implies that Guru Jee's blessings weren't enough." Every day Gursikhs do ardas at least 3 Times (Nitnem, Rehras, And Sohial time). Does people never ask for blessings, because they have asked once? Is there an "ENOUGH" blessing from guru ji? Is there a limit to Blessings from Guru ji? Say this, you asked guru ji to do the blessing for amrit vela everyday. You got it. You happy. You never ever do the ardas again for amritvela? EVER? If lavan are something for ones entire life, and so is every ardas you do. According to me, if ardas and blessing are for life, then people should and MUST stop doing ardas over and over again, for Naam and amritvela and TRUE GURSIKHI, etc.! Its not respectfull either! Its like you dont trust Guru ji, you asked once, then keep on bugging him and asking over and over again? You think thats respectfull? It is is respectfull, and not wrong, then why shouldnt a second anand karaj to the same person? Actually when i think about it, i get confused somewhat. Not that im questioning Guru ji di Pavittar Gurbanee. If you read the meanings of the Four Lavan, I tend to think that it was meant for a pranee's relationship to GURU MAHARAJ and not to the spouse littereally? Am I wrong? When you read Gurbanee, in many many stences, you will find that Guru ji speaks of the humans in the a "female" tense. All the shabads for the "Pallah" and the "viah hoa"shabad are actually for the marriage between A human more likely, A TRUE GURSIKH to his Lord Guru. (Lavan 1 2 3 4, as the differents stages of the relationship with Gursikh and Guru ji). Is it not? Then why use these pavittar gurshabads as a union creator between a man and a woman? Shouldnt we read the lavan everyday? to make Guru ji the center of our life, by reciting these prayers and of course meaning them!!!! And walking around Guru Granth Sahib ji once, doesnt, according to me, make any sense if you dont recite and mean everything that is said in the 4 Lavans. Or when doing parkarmas, do them four times while reciting the Lavans? Kay nahee? What do you say? Im confused. Bhai Kulbir SIngh ji, your input on this? can someone ask bhai jarnail singh and ragbir singh ji about this, i need to clear this up please. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: Anand-Karaj-Important

s!nghn! · 10 Oct 2003

One thing I'd like to mention before responding to the point at hand: Lately, I've noticed that people seem to be totally on edge and always looking for a fight, whether picking the fight themselves or jumping on the defensive while thinking their views are under attack. We all need to relax and quit twisting things. Let's try to see and read things in a positive light and respond to one another with patience and respect. >If i understand it correct, you mean that it is pointless to, physically >at least, make guru ji the center of our live by the recitation of The >Great Lavan, to renew that link to Him and to the person he >choose for me to be with??? Forget the familly member not being >able to attend, thats a minor thing. No Bhain Jee, I never said it is pointless to make Guru Sahib the center of one's life. You ASKED your question specifically in terms of family members not being able to attend, and you received answers specifically in terms of family members not being able to attend. If attendance of family members is now a minor thing, that's fine, but don't get upset with those who simply tried to answer your question. No one was trying to pick a fight with you. After reading your question, I simply tried to point out that you had the real important feature of an anand karaj present at your wedding -- Guru Sahib's presence, and that is worth more than all the guests in the world. >If taking the Lavan-Anand Karaj, by surrounding Guru ji so >direspectfull, THEN why do Parkarman??? Or is it that Parkarman >have no true Significant value-meaning and are just some rituals? I clearly stated that re-doing laavan JUST TO SHOW PEOPLE would be like an empty ritual. No one said that doing lavaan was disrespectful. Doing them just so more people can attend would be disrespectful. I believe that's what everyone else was saying as well. >another issue, If i was married to this person before in the presence >of guru ji, but we were BOTH NOT amritdharee then, and now that >we are, is it still pointless to do the Lavan Again? In this situation, I think you should indeed re-do your laavan. After being given Amrit, you have both become completely new people, so the new you should make a new commitment to begin a new relationship with your Guru. Other than the above "non-amritdharees-becoming-amritdharee-and-thus-redoing-their-laavan" situation, and in the case that one's first anand karaj wasn't done in the presence of Lareevaar saroop of Guru Sahib, I can't think of any other reason to re-do an anand karaj. The commitment made between husband and wife before Guru Sahib shouldn't be something which needs constant renewal, in my opinion. It should be ever-lasting, a commitment for life. If you feel your commitment needs renewal, instead of re-doing laavan, I think you could do ardaas and ask Guru Sahib to give you true love for your spouse, to receive true love FROM your spouse, and for you both to fall truly in love with Guru Sahib, together. You've already DONE your laavan...the next step should be to begin acting on them and implementing them into your life.

Re: Anand-Karaj-Important

JagKaur · 10 Oct 2003

Hey i aint picking up a fight or anything. I just replied to your ideas with mine. :-D nothing to worry. ;) Marriage doest need sonstant renewal. But what i needed to know is per GUSUKHI, is it OK to do the lavan twice or is it a sin? but i guess its all fine then. It is something that can be done. Should i take this conclusion? I was waiting hear a response from Bhai Kulbir Singh ji, but i guess he is too busy to reply. Thankx Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. i actually have a nother question. Is the presence of parents necessary for a anand karaj. Cause if you look at it, during anand karaj, the parents are asked to stand up and do the initial ardas. Why only the parents and not the whole sangat? Cause these children are Guru ji's above all. And the whole sangat should stand up for ardas, key nahee? well i think *Bhai Kulbir Singh ji, your input please, veerji.*

Re: Anand-Karaj-Important

my thoughts... · 10 Oct 2003

Behen ji JagKaur, you raise some interesting questions...which I'm not really qualified to answer..but as a reply to your original post.... I agree with veer Bhai Ranjit Singh's post on this one. And, also nowadays we do live in a high-tech world...you could have the wedding recorded and then when you meet your parents or who ever wasn't present at the wedding, you guys can all sit together and watch it...well even better is that, now, you can actually have the wedding brodcasted live from one part of the world to another..probably little expensive though....as per your point of making "guru ji the center of our live," only one way to do that behenji, follow gurmat...naam and bani, and following guru sahib's rehit...and only worry about pleasing guru shaib...and also behenji...we are nothing without ardas...making the effort and doing ardas is all we have, rest is in guru sahib's hand. This is what I think, if I'm wrong, plesase correct me.

Re: Anand-Karaj-Important

{¿?}™ · 10 Oct 2003

Just wondering whats the piont of asking if all your going to do is rebut the the piont given?

Re: Anand-Karaj-Important

singh2 · 10 Oct 2003

certain christian groups do follow the practice of allowing couples to re-do their vows in church to show/reconfirm to people the couples commitment and love etc. it is for the benefit of the people present. but sikhs do the anand kharaj ceremony in front of guru granth sahib to get guru's blessing. the other people/ sangat present are incidental to the ceremony. so a repeat ceremony for other's benefit doesn't seem relevant here. as to couples reaffirming their commitment to each other and guru sahib (ie. not for a show for others), some old sikh couples use to read the bani of laavan everyday together with their nitnem - i'm sure some still do today. most sundaar gutkhay still contain this bani alongside other banis that used to form part of the extended nitnem in older times. [%sig%]

Re: Anand-Karaj-Important

Gurpreet Kaur · 11 Oct 2003

>>>Just wondering whats the piont of asking if all your going to do is rebut the the piont given?<<< Penji didn't exactly know what the replies would be. It was obviously after she read them that she realised she didn't agree with them, what's wrong with that?