Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Kirpans In Prison

Kirpans In Prison

BC Singh · 10 Oct 2003

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH With Guru Ji's Kirpa, my brother is going to be taking Amrit this year. The only problem is that he is a corrections officer at a prison, and under strict rules, he cannot wear a Kirpan while at work. This is because one of the inmates could get a hold of it, and use it for attack. He's not too sure about what the Panj Piarays are going to say to him when he brings this issue up. Should he talk to the Panj Piarays before the Amrit Sanchar? Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Thank You. WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH [%sig%]

Re: Kirpans In Prison

hum · 10 Oct 2003

Hmm. they could also get hold of the guns and the rool-stick and other gadgets the officer has him also. Tell you what, a guns is far more dangerous then a Kirpan! ;-)

Re: Kirpans In Prison

Singhnee · 10 Oct 2003

"hum" Correctional officers don't carry guns or any other offensive weapons, All Guns and even batons are locked away in a secure place incase of a riot. Anyways, I think your Punj Pyarai would understand, I suggest taking Amrit at the December Samagam at Khalsa School, I took Amrit there last year, and the Punj pyarai were very understanding and wise when I went inside. [%sig%]

Re: Kirpans In Prison

BC Singh · 10 Oct 2003

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH I'm sorry, i should have been more clear. This is a minimum security institution, and guards do not carry guns,or any other weapons. WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH [%sig%]

Re: Kirpans In Prison

Kulbir Singh · 10 Oct 2003

I think instead of asking the Punj to give your brother exemption on kirpan, your brother should fight this case all the way if required. Obtaining exemption on wearing of kirpan for seekers or for punj pyaare to grant such exemptions could set very complex and detrimental consequences for us in the future. The reality is that the Punj Pyaare don't have the authority to change the rehit of Guru Gobind Singh jee. They have to stay within the parameters of Gurmat and Rehit. As far as I have heard from Gurmukhs, the Punj Pyaare cannot change the rehit but in some cases can be a little bit flexible but cannot grant exemption from rehit. This is why, after the operation most singhs (including Jathedar Tohra) get pesh and most don't get stiff tankhah for be-adbee of kesh but no punj pyaare give chhutee on this violation. Recently there was a case where a singh was given exemption by some punj pyaare to sell tobacco. Tomorrow if someone says that he is employed as a pimp, would Punj give him that exemption. I hope not. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Kirpans In Prison

s!nghn! · 10 Oct 2003

I agree with the above post. When faced with these types of dilemmas, we should fight for our rights, not just bow down and give up rehit in order to fit into social standards and work-related restrictions. Only by fighting for our rights will we ever be able to incite any change. If your brother succeeds in changing the rules, it'll be a great victory and will make things so much easier for future sikhs who enter this field or similar ones. Ultimately, we should always fight for our rights before agreeing to give up any rehits; we should hold Guru Sahib's standards and rules above any employers'.

Re: Kirpans In Prison

nirgun · 10 Oct 2003

but veerji kulbir singh, what other option could there be? isn't it dangerous for a corrections officer at a prison to carry a weapon just in case one of the inmates gets a hold of it? i mean... there's a reason why the authorities made sure that the corrections officers don't carry guns or batons.. ? ? ?

Re: Kirpans In Prison

my thoughts... · 10 Oct 2003

Following Guru Shaib's hukam is more important than following some guidelines set up by prison authority...'BC singh', if your brother takes the step to fight, so that he can wear a Kirpan, then Guru sahib will take care of rest...Otherwise..If he has already decided that it is going to be a tough fight and that he is going to lose...well he has lost the battle before it has even begun. Because, the path of sikhi is not very esay, as a Gursikh you are tested all the time. The point is to make the effort and do ardas, be strong when it comes to your Sikhi and Guru sahib will take care of the rest, becase in the end you are going be graded by Guru Sahib, not by anyone else. This is what i think, please correct me if I am wrong.

Re: Kirpans In Prison

Khalsa Soulja · 11 Oct 2003

quit your job or ensure u can take your kirpan with you to work. dont be torn away from ur kakkar afta amrit.

Re: Kirpans In Prison

Mkhalsa · 11 Oct 2003

You could look at it this way... You realize that in order for you to work at a refinery or chemical plant you need to have a clean shaven face to put the mask on. So you go to the doctor to ask how you can remove your dhari and kesha and put them back on after work. This is not possible as they are attached to you and are like your ang, once you remove them, they are gone. Kirpan is to be your ang too, you not to remove it, and just like removing dhari, or an arm, it causes a gursikh a lot of pain.

Re: Kirpans In Prison

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 11 Oct 2003

question: what if every1 became amritdhari ( that day will come) but we still ahve our average criminals andp risons, then what do we do about the kirpan issue, cause it is danegrious to take a kirpan 2 a prison cause if a prisoner gets a hold of it its jsuss dangerous. but now we have other ppl 2 take care of it, but what in the future?

Re: Kirpans In Prison

NO one · 12 Oct 2003

FATEH, A while back i was in a similar situation. Some of you may remember my post a few months back. I was sent to malaysia with my army unit, and whilst i was there, some concerns about my kirpan were raised by the local civilians that work on the base. As such the army had to research the issue, and it was determined that under malaysian civil and military law it was considered illegal to carry a concealed weapon. As it stands in malaysia today there are currently no official exemptions for sikhs to wear them. It came pretty quickly to a situation where i was restricted to base whilst i wore the kirpan, they even tried to get me to remove on the base and i basically said i can't do that and they managaed to speak to some malaysians and just allow it for a short time. I spoke to the sikh society in malaysia and they also got in contact with the Officer in Command of the Base, and they managed to get it as high as the Attorney General Of Malaysia but all he could do was to advice on the laws, and it was determined that their was no official exemption although the police generally dont mind and were aware of the situation. In the end i ended up being returned home as quickly as they could. I almost lost my employment due to this situation but the army were intelligent enough not to otherwise i would have considered legal action. Even thought i lost alot of extra money that i would have earnt being oin deployment, i gave it up, and decided to follow my rehat. The best bet for you friend is to take amrit, and to try to hide it, if that means not to wear it in his gatra then so be it. if he has to wear it on his thigh, or as a hip belt. Although i doint agree with the idea that we should have to hide aspects of our religion if his job is that important to him, then thats wat he should do, or he should quit his job and try to fight, although it is unlikely he would win, maybe they might be able to offer him a transfer to another position where he doesn't deal directly with the prisoners. Either way, he shouldn't be trying to seek an exemption. We are giving our head to the guru 100%, and when we do that, we dont ask if we can only give 95% or 80%. Bul chaak maaf and Good luck!