Debating to Cut Hair or Not
interesting · 16 Oct 2003
An Interesting article that appeared in the Toronto Star a few years ago. From what I can guess, I'd say the guy eventually probably did cut his hair. *********** Torn between two worlds Young Sikhs wrestle with a culture gap their elders often fail to understand By San Grewal Toronto Star Staff Reporter Looking up at a portrait of the founder of his faith, Paramjit Singh Saran stands and takes leave of his 18-year-old son, allowing the youth to address delicate questions that only he can answer. Sikhs around the world, including 140,000 in the Greater Toronto Area, are today celebrating the birthday of that founder, Guru Nanak Devji. It's the most important day of the Sikh religious calendar, and as they celebrate it for the last time this century, many Sikhs wonder anxiously whether their children will help their unique traditions survive into the next millennium. Sitting in his living room amid images of majestic-looking Sikh heroes with flowing beards, Lovdeep Saran talks about the struggles of Sikh youth growing up here. `Western culture is different from Sikh culture,'' he says. "The past generation is more traditional, but we're being exposed to things that are totally radical to the traditions that we've been taught. . . . Sometimes it seems that they're totally out of touch with reality.'' Saran personifies the hopes and fears of his community. A Day-Glo orange Nike sweatshirt hangs loosely on his lithe, 6-foot frame. Adolescent facial hair dusts his cheeks, and a jet-black patka covers uncut hair that would fall to his waist if not tied up. Unshorn hair, which signifies a bond with the community and with God, is one of five principal tenets followed by baptized Sikhs, but Saran recently told his parents he wanted to cut his hair. "When I was a child, I wanted to cut my hair because I found there was a lot more racism between children. Now I'm comfortable with my hair. That's not why I want to cut it.'' Though he talks of friends who have succumbed to it, Lovdeep says it is not the pervasive influence of media and pop culture that has led to his decision. ``I don't see myself as particularly religious. Wearing a turban is a misrepresentation of who I am. But I don't want to do it and regret it later on, so I'm taking my time with the decision.'' Traditionally, Sikhs don't make those kinds of distinctions between their faith and their way of life. Sikhism proclaims values that often get short shrift in permissive Canadian culture, such as chastity, marital fidelity and physical and spiritual cleanliness, including strict avoidance of alcohol, tobacco and swearing. The religion also values unity and equality, regardless of economic status or gender. But Harjinder Mann, 24, has often contemplated a disconnect between religion and culture in the Sikh community. Growing up on a farm just outside London, Ont., Mann had traditional values instilled in him by his parents. ``Like most Sikhs, education was the foundation for our upbringing, both religious and academic education,'' says Mann, who is articling with a Toronto law firm. ``When I was younger I took an active interest in my religion, until I was 16 or 17. . . . I was extremely well-read about the religion.'' At university, Mann began to question aspects of Sikh culture in Canada, especially a departure from spiritual values such as unity. He warns that many will do the same if the community strays from its founder's spiritual message. ``It started to occur to me that religion and culture were two different things. What occurred in the community, in the gurdwara, was driven more by cultural issues, as opposed to religious principles. The religion is all about equality, especially between men and women, but women are sometimes treated as subservient.'' The gurdwara, or temple, is a place to gather socially as well as worship. ``It was very political. What I saw was very incongruous (with) what I had been taught,'' Mann says. As elders get wrapped up in the political disputes that have come to define the struggles of Sikhs, critics say equally important struggles are taking place under their own roofs, with children adrift between two worlds. Canadian media have chronicled the community's inner strife, as rival temples argue about how to interpret religious practices, and outer strife over the issue of an independent Sikh homeland in India. Meanwhile, young Sikhs wrestle with a culture gap their parents may not comprehend. ``A lot of youth, because there's no support for them, are turning to gangs, Punjabi gangs, to drugs, to alcohol, even suicide,'' says Daljeet Dhillon, 29, a counsellor and founding member of the Punjabi-Canadian organization Sahara - ``support'' in Punjabi. Dhillon says the cultural gap is particularly hard on girls. ``Issues of gender inequality - girls not having the same rights of a male sibling, not being able to date, arranged marriages, that's still a huge issue - these are common. In our community there is a lot of pressure to get the daughters married. Parents feel it is a burden, their responsibility.'' Some Sikh girls, she said, have committed suicide because their parents tried to arrange marriages for them. ``What has to change is this notion that `If this is my house, my home ends at the laneway,' '' Mann says. ``Too many people think that, regardless of what happens out there, my home will always be Punjab, or with the gurdwara.'' Sewa Singh Sandhu serves on the board of the Malton Khalsa Community School in Mississauga, where 211 students up to Grade 7 learn about Sikh traditions. He says education should be the focus, and is perplexed that $17 million is being spent to build a new gurdwara on Dixie Rd. instead of funding youth programs. ``If we want our kids to be Sikhs, we have to show that first we are Sikhs, and then teach them what we know.'' The older generation hasn't done this well, Dhillon says. ``Some of the youth who are expected to follow traditional practices haven't even been taught the language. They're just somehow expected to understand things on their own.'' Parents struggling to give their children a better life wrap up their sacrifices in a symbolic shell. When kids move away from traditions, many fear their efforts will be for naught. ``We cannot pressure the kids,'' says Lovdeep's father. ``There has to be a collective effort of the society.'' ``My parents feel that I should keep my hair,'' Lovdeep says. ``If my parents had said, `No, you can't (cut it)' or `You have to do this or that,' I would have done it. But because they've been understanding and have said it's my decision, I feel more comfortable about thinking about it. ``Whatever I do, I do say that I practise the Sikh religion. I have the basic beliefs and values of a Sikh that are very important to me, so I feel that I can make the statement that I am a Sikh.''