Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

Kulbir Singh · 15 Apr 2003

NANAKSHAHI CALENDAR Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row Chander Parkash Tribune News service Bathinda, April 15 The mention of June 6 as the day for observing death anniversary of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale in Nanakshahi calendar issued by the SGPC on the occasion of Baisakhi yesterday may generate another controversy as the Damdami Taksal repeatedly has been claiming that Sant Bhindranwale was alive and in “high spirits”. Though Bhai Mohkam Singh, a spokesman of the Damdami Taksal while talking to The Tribune said that the Damdami Taksal did not want to make any comment on the issue pertaining to the observance of death anniversary of Sant Bhindranwale on June 6 as Akal Takht was involved in the preparation of Nanakshahi calendar, a member of the Taksal alleged that the calendar had been prepared by the SGPC on the directives of the BJP which had passed to it through SAD (B) President Parkash Singh Badal. The member of the Taksal, who refused to disclose his name and position in the Taksal, said that if the SGPC could claim that Sant Bhindranwale had attained martrydom then why it did not declare it in the past 19 years after the Operation Bluestar in the Golden Temple. Sources close to the Damdami Taksal revealed that though the SGPC consulted the Taksal while preparing Nanakshahi calendar and the Taksal had asked the SGPC to hold thorough discussion on the issue of Nanakshahi calendar before implementing it but this opportunity was denied to the Taksal. After the Operation Bluestar in the Golden Temple complex, different Sikh organisations had been holding different opinions in the connection with the death of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale. A section of Sikh organisations had been claiming that he is alive. The other section is of the opinion that he had attained martyrdom. A section of radical Sikh organisations had held Bhog ceremonies in connection with death of Sant Bhindranwale. Even the SGPC has not clarified whether Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale was alive or had attained martyrdom before releasing Nanakshahi calendar yesterday after 19 years of Operation Bluestar despite the fact that Jathedar of Akal Takht had given it directions to clear this issue to bring the Sikh Quam out of this dilemma. However, a few SGPC members had said that the wife of Sant Bhindranwale had been honoured for the sacrifices made during Operation Bluestar but they never came out with a statement that Sant Bhindranwale had attained martyrdom.

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

Curious · 16 Apr 2003

So what are they going to do about this? And, what does the sangat really think. Do you guys think Baba Jarnail Singh is alive or shaheed?

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

Khalsa Soulja · 16 Apr 2003

i would usually say shaheed but since the taksali website is even saying baba takhur singh is "filling in" for bhindrenwale while hes "away", i doubt they would lie on that just to fuel a bit of hope........ im 60percent sure shaheed 40percent sure in hiding and planning but if sant ji was alive......why wud he not be doing anything about situation in punjab

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

Jedi Singh · 16 Apr 2003

Baba Jarnail Singh Jee khalsa is SHAHEED. His shaheedi photos exist. The day of the attack he was seen by individuals who claimed that he stood with singhs and asked guru jee to give him another life to come back and finish the movement... He also told other close ones of his that it is a privelage to give shaheedi in such a place where Baba deep singh jee gave his shaheedi for the panth. Its been 20 years folks!! please, who are you kidding. He is not alive any longer, accept it and move on... Guru Jee will bless us with more Khalsa Fauj in the future. Baba Jarnail Singh Jee died with honor and went the best way a true Singh can go, as a Shaheed. Anyway, No gursikh would hide like if they were alive... He is khalsa. period. Jedi Singh

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

Tarnveer Singh · 16 Apr 2003

Vaaheguru Jee Ka Khalsa! Vaaheguru Jee Kee Fateh! Baba Jee is SHAHEED, without a doubt. I have great respect for Damdami Taksal and their many soormey shaheeds. Baba Thakur Singh himself told me to take amrit from their jatha when they were visiting the US back in the mid-90s, and I did so while in college at Gurdwara Sahib El Sobrante in California, so I am grateful to him for pushing me. But this is ridiculous. Baba Jarnail Singh is the reason I kept in touch with Sikhi as a youth. I did not know much about GurBaanee or Saakhees of the Guru Sahibaan, but I knew who Bhindranwale was, and I knew who Bhai Amrik Singh and General Shubeg Singh were, and I knew what Khalistan stood for and what they gave their lives for. That fueled me for years, and continues to do so daily. Denying Baba jee's sacrifice is pure disrespect to his life and the lessons he taught. This is one of the main reasons the Jujhaaroo sangharsh did not come to a successful end: Everyone sat around waiting for Baba jee to come back and lead us to victory. We must wake up! We must become the next Bhindranwales ourselves! We all must become Jarnail Singhs, and Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singhs, Sukhdev Singh Babbars, Baba Deep Singhs, Bhai Mani Singhs, and most of all, we must become like our Guru Sahibs. This is what all our greats had in common, that they all had thirst to meet Vaaheguru and had unquestionable dedication to Guru Granth Sahib and the Guru Khalsa Panth. I have spoken to many Taksaalee Singhs about this topic, and they all just say that Baba Thakur Singh says Sant Jee is in Chardee Kala. But a couple years ago I spoke to Baba Mukhtiar Singh, mukh sevadaar at Bradshaw Gurdwara Sahib in Sacramento. He was tabla-jee in the Asa-di-Vaar jatha who played at Akaal Takhat Sahib when the Singhs moved there from Guru Nanak Nivaas. Baba Mukhtiar Singh was in Akaal Takhat during the ghalooghaaraa and (very long story short), he and two other Singhs made it out (almost by accident, in a very strange way...truly by Guru's kirpaa) on late June 5/early June 6, only to be arrested right away immediately outside the Darbar Sahib Complex (he spent many years in a Rajasthan prison afterwards). I asked him if he thought Baba Jarnail Singh was alive or Shaheed. He smiled and said the standard "Sant jee chardee kala'ch ne." He said that Taksaalee Singhs abide by what Baba Thakur Singh says, and he didn't want to contradict him. Then we asked what he personally thought. Then Baba Mukhtiar Singh himself said that he believed Baba Jee attained shaheedee then and there. He told us how he was present when Baba Jarnail Singh did the final ardaas and asked to be born again and again to carry out Panthic sevaa. He said all the Singhs were in true chardee kala until early morning of June 6th, when they moved into the basement of Akaal Takhat Sahib. It was during that move that Baba Mukhtiar Singh became separated from the rest. If you have heard Baba jee's speeches and his vichaaraan, then you know what code he lived by. He would not remain gupt for 19 years when the Panth was suffering so much. This is is direct contradition to the maryada he lived by. Never did he condone the notion of hiding or waiting it out. When he used to be asked what the Sikhs wanted, Baba jee often replied that it was "do inch dee gal hai" - "a matter of two inches." By this he meant that the Indian government wants Sikhs to walk with their heads down, looking at the ground, while the Khalsa will only walk with their heads held high, looking forward. A man who lived by this sort of thinking would not hide while he was needed. He died the same way Baba Deep Singh jee did, defending Darbar Sahib and all of Sikhi. That should never be taken away from him. "Bhindranwale sant sipaahee, jineh sutee kaum jagaaee!" Bhindranwale, the saint soldier, who awakened the sleeping Sikh kaum! GurFateh! Tarnveer Singh Chicago, USA Khalistan Zindabad!

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

Vicky Singh · 16 Apr 2003

Please sadh sangat jeoo.. How can Singh, khalsa like Sant Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwale live in hiding/away by knowing the sick conditions of punjab rite now?? Im 100% sure that Sant ji is Shaheed cauz Khalsa never hide.. Let's respect sant ji's soul.. Gurfateh

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

Damdami Taksal · 17 Apr 2003

Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Chardi Kala vich hay!!! the times coming soon....... wjkk wjkf

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

Mkhalsa · 17 Apr 2003

Yes veer jee, he is in chardeekalaa, in sachkhand, along with all the other great gursikhs.

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

sangh · 17 Apr 2003

so i guess that would make Sant Baba Takhur singh's a liar. "Sant Jarnail SINGH IS STILL ALIVE, that would mean that one of the greatest Sant Siphai's of all time never died... !!!! that is off course if you beleive the words of a naami gursikh who spent the 90+ years of their life dedicated to serving Singhs, and even now at an age when many others would be left demobalized they continue to make sure they serve the singhs parshada before they actually sit down themselves.....I guess also spending what seems almost 24 hours a day (its not often you see them lie down and sleep) reciting bani and making sure that those around them recite bani at all times. who even though have fallen ill at many times seem to fully recover by the grace of Akaal Purkh. Yea then again such people themselves are always making up stories to deter us from the path of sikhi, right?

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

Tarnveer Singh · 17 Apr 2003

GurFateh! No one is calling Baba Thakur Singh anything but a GurMukh, Sangh. Don't jump to such conclusions and speak in such a condescending manner. Baba Thakur Singh may believe Shaheed Sant Jarnail Singh is alive, but it has been told to me by many Singhs that he says this believing that Sant Jee took birth again right after attaining Shaheedee in 1984. Many Taksaalees and other premi GurSikhs believe that Sant Jee was of such a high spiritual level that there is no doubt that Vaaheguru would answer his ardaas to be born again to continue fighting for the panth. That means he should be 18 years old in this new roop. So I think Baba Thakur Singh honestly believes Sant jee is in Chardee Kala.....the problem is, this is not the same Sant Jarnail Singh. That human sant-sipaahee is a Shaheed of the Panth, but only Guru Sahib knows what became of his soul. Just because we disagree with the official stance of the Damdami Taksal, that does not mean we are calling anybody a liar. Only Guru Sahib knows the truth.....and Baba Thakur Singh is not our Guru. Is there any proof at all of Sant jee's existence? All eye-witnesses, including members of his own family and jatha, said he was Shaheed following the ghalooghaaraa. There is a picture of Sant jee's body in shaheedee roop. His living in gupt for so many years goes strictly against the code he lived by and what he taught us. The Taksaal has been infiltrated by all kinds of anti-Panthic elements since 1984. Even their own old-timer Singhs admit to this. I have spoken to two GurMukhs who lived at Chowk Mehta with Sant jee when they were all students together under Sant Kartar Singh jee's leadership. Both believe he is shaheed and both admit that the Taksaal has many shady figures in it today who are not what they appear. WE MUST STOP WAITING FOR A LEADER TO COME LEAD US, AND BECOME LEADERS OURSELVES! GurFateh! Tarnveer Singh Akaal Takhat tou aaee avaaj, Khalistan! Khalistan!

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

sawa lakh · 17 Apr 2003

I think that only guru sahib is perfect. Secondly, any person can make a mistake. Thirdly, there are people who actually saw him getting shot etc and attain shaheedi. Fourth, Baba Jarnail Singh himself did ardaas for shaheedi..this is a well known fact. Lastly, Baba Jarnail Singh couldn't stay away from his brothers (fellow singhs) for this long... no way and why would he hide from khalsa panth, we consider the panth as guru do we not. Please respect his memory but do not get stuck in this foolishness. Why make people around you gumrah (lead them on wrong paths).

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

Mehta Chowk Singh · 17 Apr 2003

Who are we to say hes hiding or that hes scared? WHo are we to give our own opinions on what we 'think' he would do?........ Khalsa are not scared, true.....but they are also not stupid. Did Guru Gobind Singh Ji or any any other Sikh leaders just tell his soldiers to jump into the battle or get killed for no reason, without proper preperation? There was strategy invloved, you dont just let yourself get killed when you can get better results by staying alive, even if its temporarily. Why not just go into battle armless and defenseless? People have a misconception that sikhs just think dying alone is the ultimate goal. In the END we DO want to go out fighting, but we ALSO wnat victory for Sikhi as a whole. Sant Bhindranwale could be dead, he could be alive. But how shameless are these people who are calling him a coward when the have no clue why he would be alive and in hiding?

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

sangh · 18 Apr 2003

"Baba Thakur Singh may believe Shaheed Sant Jarnail Singh is alive, but it has been told to me by many Singhs that he says this believing that Sant Jee took birth again right after attaining Shaheedee in 1984." naw Baba Ji for a fact says he's a aliev in the same body. We have it all videotaped and everything.

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 18 Apr 2003

why'd my post get deleted sant baba jarnial singh ji is in chardi khalaaa in saachkhaand, or alive in naam simiran for yrs...or he could have b'n reborn and is yet 2 realise it..but he is happy and did his seva 2 the kaum either way 2004 we await the world will turn colors

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

sawa lakh · 18 Apr 2003

nobody called him a coward. anybody who does is an idiot. What are you talking about "mehta chowk singh". By the way you should understand one thing about what you just said. "victory for sikhi as a whole" ------> Well right now sikhs are losing big time in punjab. if he was alive you think he would sit back and let the government spread the drugs etc into punjabi communities. if he was alive you think he would sit by and watch the downfall of sikh youth in punjab without doing anything about it... the govenment actually opened up hair cutting places and sponsored these and made them available to destroy sikhi. i don't think he would sit back and let all this happen. my conclusion : he is a shaheed and let's respect him for it. yes this is my opinion just as what "mehta chowk singh" said above was his opinion.

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

Daughter of Guru Gobind Singh · 19 Apr 2003

I don't get it...what's the whole deal with 2004....what's going to happen (or what are people saying is going to happen)?

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

Khalsa Soulja · 20 Apr 2003

either way when im older im going punjab after 5yrs work w/ bout 10 people to do missionary stuff and try and sort out the youth............and i aint kidding either peeps shud stop worrying about bhindrenwale and where he is and get on with sortin the current situation.......its not like its even THAT hard to solve....all u need is a bit of dedication

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

A True Tiger · 20 Apr 2003

if jarnail singh jee khalsa came to earth again in new body today... would you all see that he is an imposter? or that he is the real deal? I think none of you would actually believe that he is sant jee... just an inkling...

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 20 Apr 2003

true tiger, tha's why baba thakur singh ji khalsa is there...to make that judgement

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 20 Apr 2003

ps: true tiger could u adress sant/baba ji with respect:D

Re: Bhindranwale’s death anniversary may kick up row

kaur00 · 20 Apr 2003

wjkk wjkf... what "A True Tiger" said is true... if he were to come back in 2004 as many of u claim then how many of us would actually believe it was him? I think instead of sitting here waiting for miracles to happen people should do something themselves. Sant Jarnail singh may have been a great hero, but he drank the same amrit we did, followed the same rehit and believed in the same guru sooo whats stopping any other gursikh piyaray from being just as influential and respected as he is? People need to stop waiting for his return and do something themselves... wjkk wjkf (gooo canucks!!!!)