Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

narag sach khand huh?

narag sach khand huh?

no one · 23 Oct 2003

Sikhs don't believe in heaven and hell, right? If so, what's narag and what's sach khand? thanx

Re: narag sach khand huh?

jkjk · 24 Oct 2003

yes, can someoen also explain swarag, and who goes there any why we go there? from waht i have heard, swarag is a place where people who have not do naam simran, but lived honest good lives go. can someone explain each of the places and who goes tehre..? thanks

Re: narag sach khand huh?

kookar raam ko · 24 Oct 2003

If you're a good sikh (you do naam-abhiaas, paath,etc.) then you will go to sach khand and your 8.4 million lives will be finished. If you go to swarag, it means that you will come back to earth. You will only go to narak if you don't do anything a Gursikh is supposed to do.

Re: narag sach khand huh?

no one · 24 Oct 2003

but isn't narag basically hell and sach khand basically heaven then?? :s

Re: narag sach khand huh?

jaggi · 25 Oct 2003

so there are actually heavens and hells in sikhi as opposed to what some western pseudo intelectual sikhs claim.

Re: narag sach khand huh?

mk · 25 Oct 2003

narak and swarag are states of being - heaven and hell - which you experience on and off this earth .. your spirit experiences them or your spirit IN THE clothing of your body on this earth... bhai nand lal jee says that heaven falls at the feet of gur gobind singh that means, through guru gobind singh jee's feet you can reach heaven but heaven it self is also a state of being - it's a state of "good times" in your life beyond swarag is a state of ultimate realization .. i dunno but there are also states of CONSCIOUSNESS or REALIZATION - these are called khands... they are not physically experienced like heaven and hell, they are mentally realized like saram karam dharam giaan and SACH khand.. sach khand is the ultimate realization of the infinite truth - and in this mental state of supreme spiritual consciousness you are ONE with God that is why in jap ji sahib it says 'SACH KHAND VASAI NIRANKAAR' so that's the difference between narak swarag sach khand hope that helps bhul chuk dee khima jee

Re: narag sach khand huh?

no one · 25 Oct 2003

so it's basically a state of mind -- not a phyiscal place? because sometimes people say that sach khand is a beautiful place, where there is keertan constantly playing, and where the shaheeds and true singhs dwell. so if they're conscious realizations then isn't that saying you can be in narag and sach khand while you're still on earth? (if they're both different states of mind) but then i've heard people describe narag as a physical place too where some lost souls go after death ??

Re: narag sach khand huh?

Mkhalsa · 25 Oct 2003

The concept of heaven is a very material idea filled with attachment.. to things, people etc.. Sachkhand is definitely above that.

Re: narag sach khand huh?

......... · 26 Oct 2003

ALL STATE OF MIND

Re: narag sach khand huh?

mk · 26 Oct 2003

I THINK seriously speaking it would be VERY UNLIKELY that somebody was in narag and sach khand at the same time but i THINK it's possible because of your PAST KARMS you are in narag but your PRESENT LIFE'S KARMA and GURU'S KIRPA your mind is elevated HOWEVER i think it's extremely rare.. because GURU JEE OPERATES IN SEHAJ and sehjai sehjai (with pace) people clean off their karma by their good actions and so nobody will be able to COMPILE so much bad karma and be in narag and then do so much good bhagtee and reach sach khand they both go hand in hand most people who reach sach khand have already cleaned their karma except a few rare cases like AJAAMAL, etc. bhul chuk maaf karneeeeeeee

Re: narag sach khand huh?

Cali_Singh · 28 Oct 2003

Please read Kulbir Singhs reply on different Khands as they are mentioned in JapJi Sahib .... no they are not just a State of Mind. http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=3708&t=3439#reply_3708 [%sig%]