Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

TEA

TEA

Moorakh · 25 Oct 2003

Waheguru Je ka Khalsa Waheguru Je Ke Fateh Please could any answer such as Kulbir Singh, Balpreet Singh etc. Whats wrong with having tea??? Are Gursikhs allowed to have tea??? Waheguru Je ka Khalsa Waheguru Je Ke Fateh

Re: TEA

confused · 25 Oct 2003

y is this faith so much about not consuming stuff like silly things, tea, coke, ect?

Re: TEA

jinder · 25 Oct 2003

There's nothing wrong with it bro, I remember reading an article on Sant Jarnal Singh Ji, he said it was a nasha. Not too sure what people think.

Re: TEA

unknown · 25 Oct 2003

We are not allowed to have tea because there is something to do with tobacco in there and it has caffeine. If you were to take tea, you would be a Bajjar Kureihtia and would lose your amrit. If you want to try something, set the Tea Bag on fire and you will smell cigarettes.

Re: TEA

.... · 25 Oct 2003

Bhai Sahib Randhir singh ji has also said that drinking tea is doin nasha, and therefore one would be considered a Bajjar Kureihtiee. [%sig%]

Re: TEA

123 · 25 Oct 2003

Vaaheguroo jee ka khalsa Vaaheguroo jee ki fateh Unknown I think your going over the top saying it is a bujjar kurehit to drink tea, and I dont think it has tobacco in there, if it did, im sure the whole panth would know about it. (im sure at least 70% of people drink tea) are you saying they have all committed a bujjar kurehit?? should they go pesh?? what do you think the panj piyarrea would say, when they asked you what is your sin? and people say i drank tea!! Reason for tea, should not be consumed is because it has caffine in there, and that can make one addicted to tea, and subconcsciencly you would not even know it! that is why gursikhs should not drink tea. If you want to give up, the best thing to do, is cut down your tea, try to consume maybe one cup or two a day (because if you just give up straight away, you will feel head aches, reason for this because your body is used to the caffine, and also drink plenty of water) for a few weeks and then just stop drinking it and drink hot milk (with long in it hmm nice!) instead and you will be fine, there is also green tea, which is tea with out caffine, but for the best, just go for the milk. hope this has helped. Vaaheguroo jee ka khalsa Vaaheguroo jee ki fateh

Re: TEA

dizzy · 25 Oct 2003

VJKK VJKF! "If you were to take tea, you would be a Bajjar Kureihtia and would lose your amrit." Quote taken from the post made by unknown. I'm just wondering about all the Gurdwara Sahibs that serve tea in Langar. What about that? I drink tea, not because it gives me a high or makes me feel good, I drink it because it a nice hot drink, does this mean I have 'broken/lost' my Amrit? Guru Ji Bless! VJKK VJKF!

Re: TEA

Mkhalsa · 25 Oct 2003

WHAT?!?! TEA doesnt have tobacco LOL thats the silliest thing ive ever heard! The reason tea (made up of natural herbs) cannot be consumed is because it has caffiene, same as coke pepsi and coffee. Caffeine creates nasha and is highly addictive (scientific fact) i myself was addicted to it at one time and went back to pesh and asked panj specifically if it was ok (previous panj had said it was to my knowledge) this time they said no and I was releived. I stopped caffeine right there, its not good for you at all and even stunts your growth.

Re: TEA

Tea Lover · 26 Oct 2003

so wat about gurdwaras which serve tea... are they also "breaking and making" amrit for people???... in one room they have amrit sanchar, in the other they serve langar with tea (which is apparently laced with tobaco) excuse me, my tea is on the table - tata

Re: TEA

dizzy · 26 Oct 2003

VJKK VJKF! "If you were to take tea, you would be a Bajjar Kureihtia and would lose your amrit." Quote taken from the post by unknown. Just a quick query... What about Gurdwara Sahibs that serve tea in Langar?? I remember when I 'took' Amrit some time back, straight after we went for Langar and had tea afterwards... Guru Ji Bless, VJKK VJKF!

Re: TEA

G · 26 Oct 2003

theres no tabacco in tea

Re: TEA

Surrey Singh · 26 Oct 2003

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH I think we should not get dependant on anything. From what i have seen from some family members is that they really need tea in the morning or else they "just don't feel right". I think it is a nasha. Some people, if they don't get their cha in the morning, feel irritated and get cranky. I think its best to just avoid it all together. WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH [%sig%]

Re: TEA

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 26 Oct 2003

tea being abujjer khurati? lolll tea is ntn but a drink tha's warm and damn swaaaaaaaaaaaad i get cranky if i dont' have chocolate milk, does that mean i'm gettin a nasha of it? or juss milk......... no! my body has become accustomed 2 it........

Re: TEA

Singh · 26 Oct 2003

If you look in the pictures section of this site, you'll see a notice put out by Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee which is called "Chaa dee Lahanat" or the Shame of Tea. In it, he cites a newspaper article which tell that many tea bags have tobacco in them as well. Drinking tea is not a bujjer kurehit but it's not a good thing to do and very few Gursikhs drink it. It's addictive and itself is composed of god knows what and because of this, is not bibek either. Overall, tea is not a good thing. A very nice substitute is "desi" tea or Khalsa Tea which is healthy too. Some Jatha Singhs in Gurdaspur I believe make a very famous desi tea mixture.

Re: TEA

G · 26 Oct 2003

tea doesnt have tabaco in it, some of it has caffine wich alot of panj say not to take caffine... but as far as tabacco there is not any in tea, maybe in india... things seem to be diffrent there... but they fda wouldnt allow tabacco to be in tea

Re: TEA

Mkhalsa · 26 Oct 2003

hey i peshed for drinking caffiene :( i dont think its silly.. technically.. getting nasha is a bujjar kurait right? so since caffiene give you nasha, wouldnt that imply that drinking caffiene is a bujjar kurait?

Re: TEA

Sikh · 27 Oct 2003

You guys seem to use Bujjer Kurehat very loosely. I was under the impression that there were only four Kurehats? If tea is addictive and detrimental to our health, should we then also go to the panj piyare and ask if we should cut our butter and salt intake..? Why go pesh for every little thing? When you go pesh are all the pang piyare there or just 1-2? Let commonsense prevail. Paracelsus once stated 'All substances are poisons; there is none which is not a poison. The right dose differentiates a poison and a remedy'.

Re: TEA

PREMI · 27 Oct 2003

WJKK WJKF In bhai sahibs time there was tabbaco in tea that was proven, but now it is proven that there is no such thing. So i think even bhai sahib would agree that it is okay now! wjkk wjkf

Re: TEA

Kulbir Singh · 27 Oct 2003

Regarding tea, it should be avoided by singhs but at the same time, consuming it is not a bajjar kurahit. It is wrong and singhs don't drink it but I just want to clarify that it is not a bajjar kurahit. Someone wrote that tea contains tobacco. Some forms of tea sold in India do contain tobacco. It is recycled tea that is sold as new. Tobacco flavour was added to this kind of tea. This was in news many years ago. I am not sure if this practice is still on. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: TEA

Guru-ka · 27 Oct 2003

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh. It was in news that the trader was arrested who used to mix tobacco in tea in order to make it strong , tasty and rich.His tea was very popular.When this news was in papers many singhs who used to take tea get peshed,and were orderded to avoid tea and don't take risk again.so we should avoid it.Mostly Jatha and Taksaali Singhs avoid it.We should also follow them. say NO TO TEA YES TO NAAM SIMRAN. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh. [%sig%]

Re: TEA

DhidPhookanee · 27 Oct 2003

I can't believe this thread !!!!!! Can all of you who write on this website compare your NaamKamai with GurSikhs such as Baba Harnam Singh Ji, Rampur Kheraywale. He used to drink tea, I saw it with my own eyes. Did that make him a Tankhayeea or a Patit ????????????? Bhai Sahib's article is based on what was labled as Tea at that time and mixed with Tobacco. The same thing occured in the 1970s when an Indian Toothpaste company also mixed tobacco in their toothpaste. Are all Singhs who now use Toothpaste, Tankhayaas or Patits ????? Give the Panth a break Singho. There are plenty of Charrdi-Kala Singhs in the Panth who drink Tea. There is no bigger nasha than Haumai, let's try to control that first before putting others down. BTW: I'm not a DhidPhookanee drinker, but feel this thread is a bit too much. Or do we just have toooooo toooo much time on our hands ???? -

Re: TEA

Mkhalsa · 27 Oct 2003

I will be first to admit i have incredible amounts of haumai, and i have haumai over htat too.. and i dont mean any disrespect towards any gursikh, i have no right to judge them.. but logic and science tell me that caffeine is an addictive substance which alters your mental state.. last time i checked this meant nasha... nasha is a bujjar kurait.. so logically even if caffeine is not a bujjar kurait it still has to be wrong in some way.. and i cant see any argument anyone can make that can change that, whether i have haumai or not or whether a gursikh drank it or not..

Re: TEA

pk · 28 Oct 2003

caffeine is a brain stimulant, it synthetically dilates the blood vessels in the cortex to increase blood flow to it, which is why students prefer drinking caffeine while studying...things seem to stick when they are on a caffeine high. prolonged use causes this vasodilation of the brain to become a normal thing, and the natural factors that may increase vasodilation seem to go low key seeing that the host is filling the body with another source of vasodilatant (caffeine) on a daily basis...thus when the person tries to wean themselves off this drug, they feel withdrawal effects such as headaches. its a drug people get over it. try the herbal version of chaa from india, its amazing tastes even better than chaa and no drugs in it. [%sig%]

Re: TEA

khalsa tea · 28 Oct 2003

banaksha zindabad!!

Re: TEA

Amarjit Singh · 29 Oct 2003

No tea HMMMMMMMMM. Has anyone read Amrit Kai Hai by Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh. If so how can any one from the Jatha or who follows Bhai Randhir Singh say tea isn't allowed, where in this book it claearly states how when the Singh (forgotten his name, the one who converses with Bhai Randhir Singh) was deeply unwell Nihang Singh poured him cup after cup of warm tea, following what Bhai Randhir Singh told him to do. So was Bhai Randhir Singh wrong. He oredered Nihang Singh to pour TEA for the unwell Singh , yet people say tea is not allowed., weird.

Re: TEA

Kulbir Singh · 29 Oct 2003

Veer Amarjit Singh, If you read the original text it does not mention tea but "chaahta" or "garam-jal". I think that Nihung Singh whom Veer Amarjit Singh is referring to was serving hot milk with saunf, jawain and other herbs and not tea. Tea was not common in Punjab back then. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: TEA

Whatever · 29 Oct 2003

Tea, coffee, coke, pepsi, and you name it, obviously its bad for you duh! First of all, it contains a drug called CAFFIENE and since CAFFEINE is a drug, whose symptons you can probably find on the internet, it still is wrong to consume too much tea

Re: TEA

Amarjit Singh · 30 Oct 2003

Thank you for the recipe above Kulbir Singh Veero. I guess Professor Trilochan Singh who translated the book and was a close freind of Bhai Sahib must be wrong. Interesting how Tea which is mentioned clearly on pge 27 was also being served to the other inmates, I guess they all also didn't beleive in drinking tea and Prof Trilochan Singh with all his knowledge must be wrong again. As for tea not being common in those days, the account isn't hundreds of years old when man didn't know what tea was. Funny how India one of the Worlds biggest exporters of tea at the time India apparently didn't have any tea. hmmmmm. Well we are all free to accept what we like.

Re: TEA

Balpreet Singh · 30 Oct 2003

Amarjit Singh, So essentially, Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee didn't mind tea, but then decided to put out a flyer called "chaah dee lahnat" on a whim? The "tea" gursikhs drank is herbal tea or bankshaa. Ask older people from Punjab and they'll tell you that the custom of drinking tea began later on and was copied from the British. My grandfather used to tell me how not many people at first drank tea, just hot milk etc. Later they all developed this habit.

Re: TEA

Amarjit Singh · 30 Oct 2003

Ah Balpreet Singh "Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee didn't mind tea, but then decided to put out a flyer called "chaah dee lahnat" on a whim? ", well there your words not mine. I'm only pointing out what the book says. So drinking tea was copied from the British, fair enoulght Balpreet Singh although I always thought the British were in India when Bhai Sahib was in jail, well I must be wrong.

Re: TEA

singh · 30 Oct 2003

A little caffeine is healthy for you... it keeps you alert, awake, and keeps your senses sharp temporarily. It also quickens reflexes. It not fair to say that its an abusive drug.

Re: TEA

S!kh · 30 Oct 2003

"singh" The same could be said many other things such as "speed" and other "stimulant" drugs which are universally accepted as Bujjer kurahits or atleast basic Kurahits.

Re: TEA

so wahtt huh · 30 Oct 2003

so singh your saying by drinking or consuming caffeine we are benefiting? well look at it this way: You could sharpen your senses by #1.......doing exercise (which most of the tecnologically advanced youth don't do) #2.............................eat nutritional foods (duh) and of course we could all sharpen our senses by doing paath and more paath (which most of us no lifers don't do)

Re: TEA

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 30 Oct 2003

use ur common sense, its not a big issue, its TEA

Re: TEA

jogeeeeeeeee · 31 Oct 2003

who knows the rss mite be doing summit to da tea bags in punjab cos they were caught distributing leaflets privately last year saying how they intend to slowly poison the food chain system where minority children study, so they grow up with defects and brain probs according to a dalit website. now suppose some of the chairmen directors in the top orgs are rss, what u think can happen? anything cud be in the tea in punjab even today and we wont know cos it wont be labelled. recently they found out mineral water contained high levels of a dangerous chemical which was harmful to people.

Re: TEA

domalla premee · 31 Oct 2003

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh May I offer a little clarification and sense of perspective on this subject I think reason, common sense and sanity need to prevail here. Then it is up to the individual to decide. Please go to the following link for knowledge on effects on caffeine on the body and the dosage in tea vs coffee and other sources. I suggest the admin people keep this file as a ressource. Dependence is simply dose dependent. Like Kulbir Singh said, and I concur, Tea is to be used lightly or not at all but it is not a Kurrahit to do so. Babu Mal Singh, a very spiritually-endowed soul among so many who did drink tea. Tea has 1/2 to 1/3 of the dose of a regular cup of coffee. it takes quite a bit to cause harm and quite a bit on a regular basis to cause dependence. Given there is a lot of adulteration in India in many common products one needs to purchase whatever from a reputable company with a long track record. I found that to be even true of bottled water. Caffeine is not on the same footing as highly addictive narcotics such as heroin, opiates, amphetamines, cocaine, nicotine which cause varying degrees of severity of rapid physical and psychological dependence. These destroy the body and the cycle of addiction is often impossible to break. Cocaine is powerfully addictive in the very first dose. Heroine and nicotine take a bit longer but both are hard to quit and equally addictive. That is why it is so hard for so many smokers to quit smoking. Opiates, opiate synthetics and non-narcotic prescription pain drugs (excluding NSAID's (Advil, Aleve and the like), ASA or Acetaminophen) used in pain management if taken for a limited time for pain management are not as ealily addictive and destructive but become so if taken chronically over a longer time period. Alcohol is addictive physically and psychologically if taken daily over time and is also notoriously difficult to quit like nicotine is. ON the other hand tea has other compounds that are non-addictve that do benifit the body. It has powerful anti-oxidants that block damage by free radicals which cause cancer, anti-inflammatories that relieve the pain of arthritis, and contain something that blunts hunger and increases the metabolism of fat and of course the low dose of caffeine both affect the reticular formation of the brain that is responsible for alertness. Caffeine is a Xanthines and has similar properties to Theophilline, a weak bronchodilator that has fallen out of favor due to the arrival of nwer more specific drugs.Those who have tightness in their lungs find their lungs open up after a cup of tea or coffee. Though not as powerful as many inhalers it does provide relief for many along with their inhalers. I have seen this myself with patients who have chronic bronchitis and COPD. It is often that cup of tea or coffee that provides just that punch to open their lungs up. Please do visit the link below for more information. http://faculty.washington.edu/chudler/caff.html I think we need to be far more tolerant and understanding. We are definitely sanctioned not to indulge in the abuse of true narcotics, smoking and alcohol. It is common sense. These do destroy the body when one get hooked. The Guru had every reason to bar their intake because of the harm they do and how they not only alter the mind but actually destroy and atrophy the brain. These do create true addicts and dependents in the truest sense. Small doses of caffeine though usually have the same potential for addiction and harm. So please all, do not treat other Gursikhs who do take tea with disdain or bias or push them away. You may miss a very spiritually profound soul. They are not being bad Sikhs by indulging in their cup of tea. Bhul chuk maff karniji, dass

Re: TEA

Admin · 31 Oct 2003

And with this funny story, we bring the Tea discussion to an end. Everyone is free to form their own opinions based on the discussion. ********** Bhai Sahib on Coffee & Tea By Bhai Jodh Singh in Soan ChiRee ChaRee GaiN Translated by Admin www.tapoban.org One day Bhai Sahib was sitting during a stay at Kumarhatti when Rattan Singh of Shimla (now Chandigarh), whom Bhai Sahib lovingly used to call Mastaana came and said, "Bapoo jee, you've stopped us from drinking tea, but can we drink coffee? Coffee is made from seeds and there's no trace of tobacco in it." Bhai Sahib, in a very humorous way said very sweetly, "Bhai! There's no difference! Tea is horse urine (ghoRay daa pishaab) and coffee is a donkey's urine (gadhay daa pishaab)!" Everyone doubled over in laughter. Bhai Rattan Singh was laughing to most after hearing this.