Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Muslim Friend

Muslim Friend

.... · 25 Oct 2003

I'm really close to a Muslim girl, she's like a bhainjee to me (Dont worry, Im a girl too), and we always have discussions about the importance of religion and God in life.. She's not that much into her religion (it doesn't seem like it, because she still dresses somewhat revealingly, doesn't wear a hijab, drinks sometimes, parties, etc...) and she knows I think it's wrong when she does that stuff. Ive seen many Muslims like that though, and I think she thinks its ok.. They're kind of "moderate" Muslims, although she still respects her religion a lot. Either way, I see her doing fasts and stuff, and their ramadaan is coming up soon...I care for her a lot inside, but I can't break it to her that these fasts are all ritualistic and don't do anything... I know I would NEVER hold fasts myself, no karva chaut or no anything, because they are against Sikhi and they would lead me no where. But with her, I don't know if I should say something, or just respect her and let her do what she wants. It's not really my business right? I just feel bad -- for HER -- because it all seems ritualistic. But it seems ok - she says that they do it in order to remember how the poor feel every day, and to get a better perception of the suffering in the world, thus making you more thankful in the end... So it seems like her intentions are good but I just feel bad because I care about her a lot as my friend, I guess there's nothing you can do when your friends of other religions take part in things you disagree with? Are we just supposed to let it happen? I don't want to offend her by saying "you're being wrong".. Has anyone else been in the situation where they feel one of their friends of another religion is doing something wrong?

Re: Muslim Friend

Singh · 26 Oct 2003

I think people of most religions and just people in general do a lot of things I dont' agree with. Hindus worship rocks, Muslims all bow daily to a big one in Saudi Arabia. But that's there path and I have my own. If the friend is receptive, then perhaps you can discuss it or maybe say what Sikhi believes, but if the friend is likely to get upset, then leave it.

Re: Muslim Friend

my opinion · 26 Oct 2003

if it as the other way around and you were the one who was a bit slack, then they would do anything to convert you. I do not agree with converting, but it may be interesting to point out to her what Bhagat Kabir Ji and Farid ji say in their banis about muslim beliefs. Coming from individuals who also were once following the path, it is more powerful. Do not be afraid to talk to her about religion. They talk to us about it all the time. That is why so many non-practicing sikhs have acepted islam.

Re: Muslim Friend

hmm · 27 Oct 2003

guru nanak dev jee saw the brahmins throwing water to the sun and he did not think "i don't want to hurt their feelings" because he knew they were wise enough to realize their mistake the difference comes in if you can confirm that your friend is READY to hear you tell her the truth

Re: Muslim Friend

eh ki dunya · 27 Oct 2003

well one of my friends got me a job in a garage recently with a muslim and a sikh colleague. the muslim who i thought was a top guy inherited jagir from his father which he never checked. his fathers fathers father had passed it down from generation to generation. when he went there after his fathers death the place was actually a whole village and had it valued in english terms came up to £1.2 mill. as the caretaker of the village was asking him wat he wud like to do? the muslim sed "each man living under their roof will remain and now own their property as their own, just tell them not to bvackbite steal from each other". he transferred the whole village over to the people so they own it. he sacrificed the life of a luxery landowner millionaire for a garage worker who earns from a local garage for the last 30 years. now i kept this deed in mind this guy must be great. i had problems at home with my own family, me being gullible confided in this man, he gave gud advice which makes sense. However when i first started the job he told me he will talk down to me when he needs to because that is the only way i will lern and pick things up. the singh who got me the job also sed he has this way of teaching like a motiring guru of 30 years, just ignore his bad parts and take in his good, give him 100% dedication and he will teach. all i wanted to do was lern the job. anyways this guy starts shouting at me, belittling me that i know nothing. im like ok i know nuttin so teach me. then he wudnt and told me to go ask the boss what he wants me to do? then this other sikh guy there was a gud guy and he made a comment that made me switch a bit, the muslim analysed it. from there on the sikh started to talk down to me and he had a stroke and came bak to work within days, if i sed anything bak i was told anything can happen to him so jus bear it. and the muslim outright told the boss he doesnt want to teach me and feels agitated around me. then the boss takes me away to work in the shop front. now the muslim and the sikh both start making sly comments. now i left the job because of poor pay, long hours, and back pain, but i will be lieing if i denied part of it was not to do with the way i was treated. i asked the boss to sort it out, so we can all talk as a team with him present and ask what the prob is, his answer was he will have a word privately. that didnt work for me. i packed it in. then i meet these guiys up recently, the muslim asked the singh who got me the job to come round the back and meet his son in law hes the new worker within 2 days of me leaving. a new worker already comes in whos his son in law. then he acts all innocent and talks about how his son in law has taken a whole engine apart. this muslim takes off friday to go mosque, used to tell me about how god is great, and be truthful, and he does a dirty like dat. which affects someones bread and butter. the catch was if no one caught on already was i was on low pay, when i needed money the most, to the point where i was nearly kicked out of home, and this muslim knew when i confided in him for advice. the only way up within the workplace was to get taught by this muslim so my pay cud be doubled when i know what im doing. the muslim didnt want me getting taught so i wont earn much, so i cudnt have a hold in the place like him, so i get agitated and leave. i leave bingo his son in law appears. in my heart i first condemned the man, i thought how can one man do that to another? but i have lernt that sometimes no matta how bad a person is, doesnt mean every side to them is bad, the thing he did for the villagers was witnessed by oither people who went with him. i even thought bad of my boss who is an amritdhari singh. i thought how cud he place loyalty , politics above truth and fair play?? the thing was his hands were tied because its the muslim who brings him the bussiness and gives him the livelihood. this world is a crazy place. what to say? be on ur gaurd never open ur mind up to people out der, and if u need advice go to guru not a man. people can use that against u. even humbleness can be used against u as a weak point. a guy goes mosque,prays, talks about god, givs charity and can play dirty politics to get me out and plant his son in law in.

Re: Muslim Friend

Gurpreet Kaur · 27 Oct 2003

>>>this world is a crazy place. what to say? be on ur gaurd never open ur mind up to people out der, and if u need advice go to guru not a man. people can use that against u. even humbleness can be used against u as a weak point. a guy goes mosque,prays, talks about god, givs charity and can play dirty politics to get me out and plant his son in law in.<<< Great words Bhaji. I agree with you there. Trust the Guru, it's a crazy world out there! Gurfateh

Re: Muslim Friend

. · 27 Oct 2003

feel free to talk about yur religion freely and discuss yur views, dont blatently go up to her and go yur wrong, but instead say, this is wat sikhi believes and this is y we believe it and give her some quotes from gurbani to help her understand..... chances are it woint make any difference but at least she might start thinknig about it.... and if she honestly thinks that after dong the fast she comes as a better person by remember the less fortunate then isn't that a goood thing???? she isn't saying that by fasting she will reach god.... shes saying it helps her remember the poor.... and if that makes her a better person then i say let her do it. gurbani says that by doing ritual u wont reach god, and that all things of this nature are useless, and only naam will get u to god... but if she doing it to better herself as a person thats her motivations, then isn't htat a good thing???