Forum
BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 26 Oct 2003
WAHEGURU JEE KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JEE KE FATEH
Is it just me, or does ne one else feel the same way?
When i see a punjabi song, and see sardars with dariya and pugs i feel good, dunno why...........i juss love it when they doing pindoo bhangra...
better then having those (admin cut) with a aadi nangi kurdi and a poora nanga munda..........
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Mkhalsa · 27 Oct 2003
I personally find it disgusting to see someone whos wearing guru sahibs roop (somewhat) doing antigurmat activities.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Sikh · 27 Oct 2003
Gabroo - nice to see someone with a SOH!
ROFL!!
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
khalsa · 27 Oct 2003
Wahegurrooo Ji Ka Khalsa Wahegurroooo Ji Ki Fateh
man that is nasty,, i find it too be soo disturbing,, when people who wear a dastaar and have dharia(n) and do all of this gandh... i def call of this gandh,, there is no better word to describe all of this,,, guru ji isnt happy when he c's this kind of anti gurmat stuff happening,,,, lets get with it people,, we are here to do simran,, paath,, and keep rehat,,, to make our guru happy,, not to do this stuff
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
... · 27 Oct 2003
what's a SOH?
anyways... it would be kind of weird to see singhneea in dastaars dancing around like these guys do...
it's weird that guys with pugs go everywhere and do everything, in england lots of them go clubbing too, but a girl wearing a dastaar going clubbing, now that seems weird... if that seems weird then why doesnt it seem weird for guys to be doing that?
bhangra is one thing if u're just with a few friends or sangat fooling around but it's different when you're in front of all these people, who could misjudge your character, and get the wrong idea...
i dunno ..
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
RoopKaur khalsa · 27 Oct 2003
i totally agree that its disgusting. Just think, would Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji do any of that gandh? Of course not, then anyone with the gurmukhi appearance, who is representing guru ji should not even dare to think of that stuff.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 27 Oct 2003
nach nach hasse chale se roe
:(
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Mkhalsa · 27 Oct 2003
naach naach ttapae bohut dukh pavae
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 27 Oct 2003
so u guys think ne thing that has ntn 2 do with sikhi, but is clean fun, ie. bhangra wihtout the alchhol is disgusting?
hmmmmmmmm?
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 27 Oct 2003
i want 2 know what is sooo baddd about bhangra? seriously guys, this is nto islam, itsa leberal religion, no nashaye involveded or ne thing.........
its like saying all a singh/singhni can do is simiran ntn else or go get peshed.
and how many of u would refuse 2 dance at a wedding party (be honestly no horse manure) like i would'nt but go do it ne ways
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
akj · 28 Oct 2003
I guess it depends on the type of dance the person is doing. I also find it very amusing watching them and some of their fresh moves.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Kulbir Singh · 28 Oct 2003
The feet of Singhs do move with the dhol and they too jump at the beat of dhol but not in Bhangra but in Gatka. Bhangra is the work of kanjars. Kanjar nachde hunday aa. Mard nahi nachday.
A Singh who has taken amrit of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee can never indulge in such worldly things as nachna and tapnaa. A Singh has much more serious aim in life and he is eager to attain his goal. That goal is to be one with Vaheguru. Can a Singh honestly continue doing naam while he is doing bhangra?
When you do bhangra, you dance at the beat of dhol and at the same time some ishaqiya song (love song) is played in the back. If it is not an ishqiya song then it is almost always an egoistic song praising the Jats. And what praise is it? I think it is more nindiya than praise. They talk about how Jats wear white chador and keep daang. Then they talk about how Jats drink one bottle of sharaab in one shot. This is praise or nindiya? Seems like nindiya to me. Stupid Jats without realizing that their nindiya is being done, dance at their own nindiya.
Can we imagine a Singh living in the fear and love of Guru Gobind Singh, dancing on the beat of dhol along with a dirty song describing roop of paraayee istree (woman) or sharaab drinking skills of a Jat?
Those out there who like bhangra can do what they want to do but what they should not do is try to justify Bhangra according to Gurmat. Gurmat and Bhangra or songs are not compatible.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
pk · 28 Oct 2003
to this issue i always say, turn off the volume of a video in which people are dancing and the dancing people look like idiots swinging their arms and legs, as if they've gone mad.
i once had an argument with a person about this issue. they argued that dancing can't be against gurmat because its possible to remember Akal purakh while doing it - I dont know about that..maybe they are at some next form of bairaag or something which is why they look mad... and maybe the gandha music they are listening while doing this is helping them remember Akal purakh too??
[%sig%]
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 28 Oct 2003
i seriously can't under-stand, if theres no alcohol or drugs involved a singh still can't have fun unless its sommin sikhi related?
like woah.............sounds a lil harsh dont' u think?
maybe they can't joke either........
no tv that sure aint sikhi related.........school becomes bad ............... playign video games is definatly wrong.........
ppl this is a liberal religion........... if we dont' get attatched 2 the activity i dont' c a problem(but then again i am prob wrong)
this is the reason i brougth this topic up.........2 c what u guys think...how strict u can get....its pretty sad........
not comparing....but is'nt that what the taliban did...bann all non-islam related activities?
remember i'm neithe rone of those ppl who say that sehaj dharis are sikh, i firmly believe to be a sikh u have to be amritdhari and shaster dhari...so im not one of those moderate mofoz
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 28 Oct 2003
then we also read that tea is bad?
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
... · 28 Oct 2003
what if it's normal music and you're with SANGAT and no weird people, or just a few of your close, gursikh friends?? no weirdos or perverts looking at you?? and you're just doing it to fool around, not to do any baysharmi or whatever?? some songs don't talk about jatts, lust, or alcohol.. (althuogh there arent very many songs that avoid all of that)
personally if im at a party its usually because my parents make me go, and i feel odd enough dancing with all these people looking at me ad stuff, it just doesn't seem right..
but sometimes if i'm at home with a few of my bhanjees we just do stupid stuff but we know we wouldn't ever do that in front of actual ppl
??
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Singh · 28 Oct 2003
Gabroo, it might sound harsh, but that's the reality of it. And it's not like anybody forces anyone to not do bhangra. You can compare rehitvaan singhs to the taliban, but if they were really like the taliban, then I don't think you'd even be having this discussion. You would never see amritdharees dancing because they'd be hunted out and punished. Singhs don't do that but they do have a duty to speak the truth about rehit and point out things that go against a khalsa way of life. Dancing definitely isn't part of the khalsa lifestyle. From the time of our guru's to today, name me any mahaan guru kaa sikh who did bhangra. Or even accepted bhangra as something that sikhs can do. Bhangra was around and a part of the punjabee lifestyle but wasn't part of the KHalsa way of life. There are activities that have a bad effect on your rehit and spirituality, and naching is one of them. What really is the point of nacching? ANd it's not saying that everything unrelated to sikhee is wrong. For example, things like basketball have nothing to do with sikhee, but most would agree that playing basketball is harmless (unless you become obsessed with it or something). Dancing and the psychology associated with dancing are completely different than other activities.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
gabbar singh · 28 Oct 2003
how would you feel if your sisters are dancing at a wedding with men dancing around them in bhangra? what kind of izzat is that for ur house?
oh its all fun and laffs. but hey there are other things one can do besides dancing or not?
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 28 Oct 2003
k then mr singh paji, name one of those rehit vaan sikhs of gurus time who watched tv? played nintendo
o i ogt the best one, used a computer?
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Kulbir Singh · 28 Oct 2003
Gabhroo jeeo, if you think there is nothing wrong in doing bhangra, do you think it should be allowed at Gurdwara Sahibs? If not, then there is certainly something wrong with it.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 28 Oct 2003
oh ok, then should tvs be allowed at gurdwara? should game systems, and other everyday things be allowed at gurdwara, ur car? ur bike?
somethings dont' belong in gurdwaras because they change the atmosphere such as bhangra......... veer u c what i'm gettin at?
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Sikh · 28 Oct 2003
(((((Dancing definitely isn't part of the khalsa lifestyle. - Says who? Singh do you follow in the footsteps of any of the mahaan Gursikhs you mention?))))))
There is nothing wrong with celebrating a wedding or any other happy occasion with Bhangra; so long as you can control your lustful thoughts and dirty geets are avoided. Bhangra was originated in Punjab and is part of Punjabi Culture. Why should Punjabis (not just Jats) lose this? Anyway, I'm staying away from caste as this is a whole new topic that can be discussed independently from this thread.
-----------
(((((Gabhroo jeeo, if you think there is nothing wrong in doing bhangra, do you think it should be allowed at Gurdwara Sahibs? If not, then there is certainly something wrong with it.))))))
Is this your litmus test of what is acceptable for Sikhs? Rules out watching TV I take it...as you would not sit in a Gurdwara to watch TV unless it has educational value. Please come outta your box and realise that not everyone is strict as you chaps and not everyone has the same amount of kirpa to do so. Kulbir Singh, do your everyday actions result in you progressing spiritually?
Who are we to judge others? In the UK I've seen many Singhs do Bhangra -they are still in Sikhi, and not running wildly after girls on the dance floor like people with vivid imaginations assume.
We are NOT Talibanistic - I just hope you guys do not end up like those Kharkoos who shot bibian in their legs for not wearing Salwar Khameez in the mid-late 80's.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Balpreet Singh · 28 Oct 2003
Simple test: Can you see Dashmesh Pitaa Satguru Gobind Singh jee himself dancing? How about Baba Deep Singh jee? Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee? Maybe Baba Gurbachan Singh jee Bhindranvale or Baba Jarnail Singh jee then?
Yeah. I think not.
Sikhi is not easy. It is "khanio(n) tikhee vaalo(n) nikee". If it seems very hard and "talibanistic" to say that a lot of seemingly "fun" things are not according to Sikhi, then so be it.
A Sikh has a goal: finding Vahiguru. A Sikh also realises that in a short lifespan of about 75 years, he has almost no time to do this HUGE task. Every second lost is not coming back. If doing something will waste a Gursikh's time and is not necessary and brings him no nearer (and often farther) from Vahiguru, then s/he will rule out those things, and not do them.
Of course not all of us can meet this standard. I personally cannot. But, that doesn't mean we bring the standard down, that means we try to live up to the standard and in the mean-time, not try to justify our own weaknesses.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 28 Oct 2003
balpreet singh can u c dasmesh pita ji maharah watching tv? or driving a car? playing intendo, typing on a computer! ON A COMPUTER....OR CAN U SEE NE SANT JI DOING THAT?
yes a sikh has a goal no doubt, but does that rule out fun other then sikhi realated fun?
I THINK NOT
nore am i saying tha we all start pumpin bhangra no, i'm saying on occasion i c ntn wrong wit it!
plz stop ignoring things....dont' be so ignorant, u use a computer, i'm pertty damn sure u use it for things toher then juss sikh forums
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Mkhalsa · 28 Oct 2003
>>>>>somethings dont' belong in gurdwaras because they change the atmosphere such as bhangra......... <<<<<<
just as bhangra would change the atmosphere of a gurduwara.. it also changes the atmosphere of the internal gurudwara of the gursikh.
the gursikh always has gurudwara in his mind and soul and bhangra around him would ruin that atmosphere this is why a gursikh doesnt even want to do it, its not about rules.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Balpreet Singh · 28 Oct 2003
Gabroo,
Why would Guru Sahib or any Gursikh drive a car? They rode horses, so why wouldn't they drive a car?
As for computers: it's a way of writing and editing. I can't say that's somethign Guru Sahib would not do. Why wouldn't he if it was a way of doing parchaar and teaching?
TV/Nintendo: no, I think Guru Sahib had better things to do.
Please read my post over again. Like I said, the standard of Gurmat is high and we are low. Let's not lower the standard to where we are, lets rise to meet it.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 28 Oct 2003
ok bhangra is bad:)
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Sikh · 29 Oct 2003
((((Simple test: Can you see Dashmesh Pitaa Satguru Gobind Singh jee himself dancing? How about Baba Deep Singh jee? Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee? Maybe Baba Gurbachan Singh jee Bhindranvale or Baba Jarnail Singh jee then?))))
You guys need to take a chill pill. OK, we need to take Sikhi seriously. BUT not to the extent where you cannot have fun along the path.
Do you honestly think that Sikhs in Guru Ji's time did naam jap 24*7 and never enjoyed themselves? Like I said everyone has different levels of kirpa. If you or anyone else out there has reached the avastha of the Chardi Kala Singhs you mention, than you will not need to indulge in any activities other than Simran, Gurbani Vichaar and Seva. Personally, I do not feel that we can compare ourselves to mahapurkhs.
Bhangra is not an Un-Sikh like activity that you have portrayed it to be. If it is then so many luxuries we enjoy in this short lifespan must be as well. In fact almost everything other than Naam Jap is a waste of time as all is a perishable dream, an illusion eg visiting themeparks, going on holiday, eating your favourite food (why not stick to dry roti and water).....WE all know this, but seldom put it into practice.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
nihung · 29 Oct 2003
An object or thing cannot be bad, only its misuse can be called bad.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Munmukhi Moorakh · 29 Oct 2003
VahguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKeFateh
Some muslim person told my dad at work 'did your Guru Sahib give bhagra or Gatka to your sikh community'??
My dad replied 'Gatka and not bhangra' and the muslim said 'then why are your people doing bangra on television, marriage parties and on Visakhi days'
My dad was shocked when he heard the teaching of our Gurus from him.
This is a total shame for our sikh community. The people from other religions are telling us what our sikhs are doing wrong activites these days.
VahguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKeFateh
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Amarjit Singh · 29 Oct 2003
How funny can things get. People seem to think they are the guru's of today saying what a sikh can and can not do. Using half sentence quotes also doesn't mean much when the essence of the shabad is grossly ignored so that a line can be thrown in someones face.
So what if someon dances to bhanga, I have seen people more or less dancesing at Rainbebais to the beat of Bhangra tunes added to the Kirtan.
So called true and rehatvarn Sikhs have no problem with people at Rainsebai's putting blatent Bhangra tunes to Guru Ji's bani, and with people danceing where they sit in the sanget, but suddenly get all fanatical when they hear the word Bhangra.
Funny and hypocritical indeed.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Kulbir Singh · 29 Oct 2003
It is surprising to hear some Gursikhs are trying to justify the use of Bhangra. Our Guru Sahib says:
MERE MOHAN, SARVANEE EH NA SUNAAYE||
SAKAT NAAD, GEET DHUN JETE, BOLAT BOL AJAAYE||
(O Vaheguru, let my ears not hear the songs, music and tunes that manmukhs/sakats sing)
Guru Sahib instructs us to not even let your ears hear songs of sakats and manmukhs and here we have some Gursikhs and Guru Nanak-Naam-Leva sangat who is arguing about dancing on the sakat naad (sakat Music). This has got to be Kalyug.
It is one thing if we have a weakness and cannot overcome it but to justify our weakness by calling it Gurmat is not right. Khalsa can never indulge in activities like songs, movies, TV and Bhangra etc.
Some suggested that it is not possible to do naam 24hrs and that we need entertainment too. I agree that we need entertainment but to do bhangra or listen to sakat-naad is not the kind of entertainment that gursikhs do. The purpose of doing paath is to stablize our mind but when we listen to sakat-naad (songs of manmukhs) or do bhangra our mind wanders again. It becomes chanchal. Such people who do these kind of activities cannot get up at amritvela.
Let us do a simple test. Let us answer these questions:
Do people who listen to sakat-naad and do bhangra get up at 2am in the morning?
Do they do 2-3 hours of naam abhyaas?
Do they keep bibek and sarbloh dee rehit?
Do they stay away from 4 kurahits and wear 5 kakaars including Keski?
Does their mind concentrate on Naam/Gurbani even for one minute?
The answer to these questions will most probably be NO. There could be some exceptions and some may answer some question in Yes but that would be their kamaayee from previous life. They are wasting that kamaayee now and are not sowing anything for the future.
Those who want to do bhangra can go ahead and do what they want but please don't incur karza (debt) of huge bad karma by preaching others to do the same. If someone reads your post and starts doing bhangra and listen to saakat-naad, you too will be responsible for the bad karma incurred by that person.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Sikh · 29 Oct 2003
(((It is surprising to hear some Gursikhs are trying to justify the use of Bhangra. Our Guru Sahib says:
MERE MOHAN, SARVANEE EH NA SUNAAYE||
SAKAT NAAD, GEET DHUN JETE, BOLAT BOL AJAAYE||
(O Vaheguru, let my ears not hear the songs, music and tunes that manmukhs/sakats sing)))))
This is all very well BUT not in anyway related to the topic at hand. The thread is focusing on the very act of dancing on a joyous occasion and not the music. We can all agree the gandhay songs - whether Bhangra or not should not be heard. NOT all songs are Saakat. Unless of course you view everything sung, other than naam, Saakat?
You are on one end of the spectrum and freely use terms such as manmukh. Jeez, I hope you don't run into any monay veers and scare them with your notions.
((Khalsa can never indulge in activities like songs, movies, TV and Bhangra etc.)) - all depends on the content.
(((It is one thing if we have a weakness and cannot overcome it but to justify our weakness by calling it Gurmat is not right))) - from what I recall no one is calling Bhangra Gurmat?
((( agree that we need entertainment))) - and what type would this be?
Like I said everyone has different levels of kirpa.
If you have set yourself this test, good on you - I hope you succeed. Many Amritdharis would one day hope to get to this stage (on this difficult path) and progress even further. Nevertheless many have not reached here yet.
If you want to judge yourself by all means do so. Do not be so quick to judge others. Even people who may in your eyes be manmukhs can cross the terrifying ocean with Maharaaj's kirpa - some before so called Amritdharis!!
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
khalsa · 29 Oct 2003
Wahegurrooo Ji Ka Khalsa Wahegurrooo Ji Ki Fateh
very well put bhai sahib bhai kulbir singh veerji,,, bhangra is a disease,,, i mean if u look at it,, anything that is bad,, a person picks up really fast,, such as bhangra,, watching all this gandh on tv and other stuff as well,, but the things that are right,, and that we should be doing,, people dont pick up,, our goal in life is too meet WAHEGURROOO.... we can only do that by doing simran 24/7.. guru ji di baani says,,, nit japyai sas grias,, nau parbad gar da.. how are we suppose to do sas grias when we are at a party listening to these gandey songs,, and just like all my other gursikh veers and bhainjis said,,, they have such a affect on us,, that those songs just keep on repeating in our heads and we cannot get up at amritvela and do abiyaas,, and keep rehat,,,
guru sahib says,, gursikh meet chalo gur chali,, jo gur kehey soi pal mano,, har har katha nirali,,, that line should hopefully seal this question about bhangra,, our guru sahib,, said,,, do what the guru has told u,, go on his path,,, and i sure as heck know that guru sahib never told us that we can do bhangra,,, so why should we do,,, we are not punjabis,,, we are guru key singhs and singhnia,,, the punjabi culture is soo messed up as of right now,,, it basically does everything against sikhi,,, we are sons and daughters of our dasmesh pita,,, he gave his family up for the khalsa,,, and why cant we make him happy by taking amrit,, keeping rehat,, doing naam abiyaas and reading as much bani as possible,,, well if i have said anything wrong please forgive this moorakh,, wahegurrooo ji ka khalsa wahegurrooo ji ki fateh
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Kulbir Singh · 29 Oct 2003
>>>>>>
This is all very well BUT not in anyway related to the topic at hand. The thread is focusing on the very act of dancing on a joyous occasion and not the music. We can all agree the gandhay songs - whether Bhangra or not should not be heard. NOT all songs are Saakat. Unless of course you view everything sung, other than naam, Saakat?
>>>>>>>>>
Could you please give examples of “changay songs” and how often these so called “Changay Songs” are sung?
Saakat naad is anything other than Kirtan and Dhadee Vaars.
>>>>>
((Khalsa can never indulge in activities like songs, movies, TV and Bhangra etc.)) - all depends on the content.
>>>>
Please write what content is it that you can view Baba Deep Singh jee listening to? Can you view him listening and doing bhangra on any song? If not then why do you want other Gursikhs to do bhangra.
>>>>>
(((It is one thing if we have a weakness and cannot overcome it but to justify our weakness by calling it Gurmat is not right))) - from what I recall no one is calling Bhangra Gurmat?
>>>>>
If it is not in agreement with Gurmat, then why do it? Please justify it.
>>>>>>>>>
((( agree that we need entertainment))) - and what type would this be?
>>>>>>
Examples of Khalsa entertainment include:
1) Playing Gatka
2) Reading Gurmat books.
3) Doing Santhiya
4) Socializing with Gursikhs
Etc etc.
>>>>
Many Amritdharis would one day hope to get to this stage (on this difficult path) and progress even further. Nevertheless many have not reached here yet.
>>>>
What would you gain from having amritdharis do bhangra? What will you achieve from it? If anything, it should be avoided but you are propagating it and arguing that Bhangra is okay for amritdharis to do.
>>>>>>>
If you want to judge yourself by all means do so. Do not be so quick to judge others. Even people who may in your eyes be manmukhs can cross the terrifying ocean with Maharaaj's kirpa - some before so called Amritdharis!!
>>>>>
Whom did I judge? I just wrote my understanding of Gurmat. I believe that ones who indulge in activities like movies, songs, and bhangra and doing manmatt. Can you provide any pankiti justifying this manmatt?
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Dkaur · 29 Oct 2003
------If you have set yourself this test, good on you - I hope you succeed. Many Amritdharis would one day hope to get to this stage (on this difficult path) and progress even further. Nevertheless many have not reached here yet.-----
And why is it that these gursikh's have not reached to that level?? is it because they are to lazy to do paath for atleast 4-5 hours a day??? or even wake up early in the morning for amritvela??? these people choose the way they want their lifes to be. if a gursikh wants to wake up for amritvela, wants to keep bebik, wants to do paath for 5 hours a day, it shouldnt' be hard if they put there mind to it because guru ji will be helping them. using excuses such as its difficult and soon in the future they will become better are just sad. only reason people haven't reached that level of sikhi is because they aren't willing to try to keep rehit to the fullest...i think everyone should respect those that follow there sikhi to the fullest and everyone should try to become like them.
As for the Bhangra topic. this is a dumb discussion. gursikhs are not suppose to be doing bhangra, they are suppose to be doing gatka. and for those who say bhangra is okay for gursikhs to do...would waheguru ji do bhangra? would guru gobind singh ji do bhangra?? i think not so if they would never do it why is it that the gursikhs of today society should do it? if it was okay to do bhangra i'm sure our guru ji's would have done bhangra instead of gatka....its silly to think that bhangra is allowed in sikhi!!!!
[%sig%]
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Mkhalsa · 29 Oct 2003
>>>>>>Do you honestly think that Sikhs in Guru Ji's time did naam jap 24*7 and never enjoyed themselves? <<<<<<<<,
I hear BS like this all the time. But I am very VERY confused. So now naam jap, the ultimate pleasure is not enjoyment?!
WHAT PLANET ARE YOU LIVING ON?!
for me MY LIFE IS MISERABLE except for those few moments that i spend with gursikhs doing naam jap. The rest of my life is a sad shell of existance where i just sit in my room crying waiting for the next weekend to come so that i can spend it in bliss with gursikhs doing naam simran. There is no other enjoyment, movies, tv, yes i watch them, but its a total distraction, I just do it because my manmukh mind has nothing better to do, i mean its like sleeping to me.
The point is naam simran and keertan are enjoyment, and should be to anyone even purporting to be a sikh, what other enjoyment can there possibly be?! i dont understand how anyone could say thats not pleasure and something else is :(
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
kulvinder kaur · 29 Oct 2003
bhangra singers r backed by the goi and rss to sing caste songs to divide up non educated sikhs.
bhangra steers youth in da direction of clubbing, drugs, illicet cheez.
bhangra is not jus manmutt it is rss, they are responsible.
we must not let the rss win by trying to mess sikhi up from the inside. today one thing is ok tomorow something else will be where do we end? they want sikhi destroyed.
make your choices either sikh religion or culture no two ways.
Khalistan zindabaaaaaaad
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
jank · 29 Oct 2003
Gurbani says Nachan Kudhan Mun Ka Chao.
It is the mun's interest to do these kinds of things. It is not our Guru's order. The mun needs to be brought under our Guru's hukam or else it will take us to places that can ruin our jeevan. It is difficult to build a jeevan, destroying it can happen very easily and quickly.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Sikh · 29 Oct 2003
((((((Could you please give examples of “changay songs” and how often these so called “Changay Songs” are sung?)))I I will provide you with a list very soon....I hope you enjoy them.
People seem to be having difficulty understanding my posts. For the umpteenth time - I AM NOT TALKING ABOUT OR REFERRING TO MUSIC, JUST THE ACT OF BHANGRA!
ref. Baba Deep Singh Ji - unless you or I reach that stage, we cannot possibly comment. Although you seem certain to know the mind of these greats??
(((If it is not in agreement with Gurmat, then why do it? Please justify it.
))) answered herein [[10-29-03 00:49]]
((Examples of Khalsa entertainment include:
1) Playing Gatka
2) Reading Gurmat books.
3) Doing Santhiya
4) Socializing with Gursikhs
Etc etc.
)))
Please explain your definition of entertainment as it certainly is not in line with dictionaries I've read. How are you amused when playing Gatka or Reading Gurmat books?
((What would you gain from having amritdharis do bhangra? What will you achieve from it? If anything, it should be avoided but you are propagating it and arguing that Bhangra is okay for amritdharis to do.))) You need to ask yourself, are all your activities Gurmat centered? Do you ever laugh out loud? Then again, our understanding of Gurmat will surely differ, as will the next persons. Do you agree?
I myself have nothing to gain by seeing anyone perform Bhangra.
((((Whom did I judge? I just wrote my understanding of Gurmat. I believe that ones who indulge in activities like movies, songs, and bhangra and doing manmatt. Can you provide any pankiti justifying this manmatt?)))
Setting a test for 'such' people is NOT judging? The way you judge is by comparing yourself and your routine to others!!
Can you provide me with a line from Maharaaj where it specifically states that Bhangra is not within Gurmat?
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
khalsa · 29 Oct 2003
Wahegurrooo Ji Ka Khalsa Wahegurrooo Ji Ki Fateh
FIRST OF ALL "JANK" U SAID NACHAN KUDHAN MAN KA CHAO... WHY DONT U FINISH THE LINE,,, THE NEXT PART ALSO STATES,, NANAK JIN MAN BHAO,, TINA MAN BHAO,,,, GURU SAHIB IS SAYING THAT,, NACHNA (BHANGRA,, GIDHA) IS ALL MAN KA CHAO,, BUT THE PEOPLE WHO HAVE FEAR OF WAHEGURROOOO (OF GURU SAHIB) DONT DO THIS,, BECAUSE LIKE MY VEERS AND BHAINJI'S HAVE SAID,,, GURU SAHIBS BANI SAYS IT,, WE ARE HEAR TO FIND WAHEGURROOO WE WANT TO BE ONE WITH WAHEGURROO,, WE CAN ONLY DO THAT BY NAAM ABIYAAS, KEEPING FULL STRICT REHAT, AND BANI. HOW ARE WE GOING TO MEET WAHEGURROOO BY LISTENING TO SONGS AND DANCING LIKE ANIMALS, SOME PEOPLE SAY... "WE DO IT FOR EXCERCISE",, THATS SOOO NOT TRUE,, TO DO EXCERCISE U DO GATKA,, PLAY OTHER SPORTS. FOR ALL THOSE BHANGRA LOVERS,, NAME ONE GURU SAHIB,, NAME ONE UCHI AVASTHA WALA GURSIKH,,, WHO DID BHANGRA.. NOONE!!!!!!! SO THERE I MADE MY POINT,, THAT BHANGRA IS DEF AGAINST SIKHI. WAHEGURROOO JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURROOO JI KI FATEH
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Balpreet Singh · 29 Oct 2003
Sikh,
You say that unless we reach the stage of Baba Deep Singh jee, we can't judge or know the minds of these greats. Today we are saying this about dancing about and doing bhangra. Tomorrow perhaps we won't be able to know the minds of these greats regarding issues like kakaars and whether Guru Granth Sahib is the Guru? I ask you again, can you see any Gursikh like Baba Deep Singh dancing? Which Gursikh can you think of who dances?
You ask "how are you amused when playing Gatka or reading Gurmat bbooks?"
Clearly you havn't done either of these. Playing Gata is like any sport and involves thinking and strategy and is overall just fun, like any sport. Reading Gurmat books about history or spirituality is also something I personally enjoy a lot.
har jan naacho har har dhhiai ||
Also see the shabad "vaja mat pakhaavaj bhao" on panna 350 which describes how other dancing is temporary pleasure and a Gursikh should dance in the love of Vahiguru.
At any rate, I and others have presented our cases as to why dancing doesn't seem like a Gursikh thing to do. Beyond that, I don't intend on tracking down everyone who wants to dance and puting shackles on them. Each person may decide what they want and do as they think is right. I personally do not think a Gursikh looks proper dancing about, and frankly, I never will.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Whatever · 29 Oct 2003
From reading some above discussive posts stating bhangra is a disease, i am quite amused. Personally, i feel that bhangra is [stupid].
Its not right.
Just a point for some dancing- is- a -sport -belivers
Dancing is not a sport.
Real sports include basketball and soccer, where there is an objective of the GAME.
DaNCING IS NOT A GAME AND THEREFORE, it is stupid.
i hope this post goes up, if it does THANKYOU
wjkk wjkf
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
bcurry · 30 Oct 2003
"khalsa":
"GURU SAHIB IS SAYING THAT,, NACHNA (BHANGRA,, GIDHA) IS ALL MAN KA CHAO,, BUT THE PEOPLE WHO HAVE FEAR OF WAHEGURROOOO (OF GURU SAHIB) DONT DO THIS,, SO THERE I MADE MY POINT,, THAT BHANGRA IS DEF AGAINST SIKHI. WAHEGURROOO"
What if someone had one of their prayers answered and started dancing in happiness. Would that be against sikhi?
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
ambala · 30 Oct 2003
a nice song? "nachdi panhdra saal di mutyaaar" ( 15 year old damsel dancing - more like peodophilia encouraging bhangra.
pelha lalkara chamkila fame
nach bhabieeyeh" "dance sister in law" what u gonna get out of watching ur brothers wife dance n jump up n down?
nachdi di got kolgi, kolgi killer gey baal, = her platt opened n her hair went loose.
"soormeyah na matta loan dushman kambdey nei, jatta dey putt yudhey jatta ghar jam dey nei" the enemies wont even face foreheads with the brave, sons of jatts are warriors born from the houses of jatts.
"daru bina na kittey bi gul bandi daru bina naal" without alcohol nothing works out anywhere without alcohol.
nain jatti dey parni do shraab dey need one carry on?
whats gonna happen to ur brain when u say "i like this song, i like the rytham" repeat it a few times?? whats gonna sit inside ur head??? what r u feeding ur subconcious???
bhangra is doing to sikhs what vipers did to the once glorious buddhism firmly seated in punjab, place itself on the inside and slowly rip up everything buddhism stood for while making itself look like the best friend under its own uniform.
note bhangra hit big in the late 80s early 90s , dont take a 10 year old to see when punjabi society began to fall down big time. this evil has destroyed families, entire cultures, and religions an d acts as if it is everybodies passion of panjab.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Amarjit Singh · 30 Oct 2003
Yep its wrong to listen to Bhangra tunes, but its fine to use them with Guru Ji's kirtan, and jump about in the sangat to the Bhangra beat used by the tabla. LOL
It's said that Singhs look funny danceing to Bhangra but they obviously look elegant when they hop up and down while in Guru Ji's Darbar.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Kulbir Singh · 30 Oct 2003
Thanks "Ambala" jeeo for bringing out some of the disgusting songs out there. Those songs about 15 years old girl and of bhaabi are so disgusting. This stuff is destroying our culture. Ones who listen to this kind of stuff are very much prone to committing these kind of mistakes as described in the songs. How can a Singh have anything to do with these Bhangra Songs? This is pedophilia and Incest. Is this the kind of stuff bhangra-lovers are preaching?
Kirpa karke Sikh Panth uppar taras karo? Go do your bhangra if you so please but don't poison others with your thinking.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Admin · 30 Oct 2003
This was a good discussion but we feel that it is now time to close this thread. The admins don't condone Gursikhs doing bhangra and hope misled Sikh youth will stop wasting their time on such activities and work for the chardi kala of Khalsa Panth.
No more messages under this thread will be entertained.
Admin.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
simran · 28 Apr 2004
gabroo khalistan u'll know
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
jagroop singh · 28 Apr 2004
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
What i learnt from this thread is that for some people Sikhi is about living a 'compatible' life amidst worldy activities/influences to the detriment of their practise of Gurmat.
For others, it is reaching Enlightenment and becoming one with Vahiguru in this very human life...regarding this objective, where is the room for compromise?
Blessed are such Gursikhs who never compromise Gurmat for 'compatibility'.
Dhan Siree Guru Granth Sahib Jee!
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Rashpal Singh · 28 Apr 2004
Kulvinder Kaur is Correct
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
Rochak Malang · 28 Apr 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
i must agree with everyone here...gabroo veer, i have felt it as a personal experience...i have done bhangra on stage 3 times in my life...once when i was 10, then when i was 21 and then 22...by Guruji's kirpa when i started keeping my kes and beard, and listening to gurbani on my computer (yes computer veerji :) ), i lost all of it...no i m not boasting about who and what i am, its the power of gurbani...i have quit tv and now my watching it is as good as not watching it coz i hardly do (not even news or discovery channel or history channel although sometimes i love some programs at history channel coz they are informative)...i dont watch movies anymore...dont listen to punjabi or stupid bollywood songs (i quit hindi songs YEARS ago)...there was a time when i used to go to bhangra parties and sweat myself out...i m not saying that i have done a great thing...it just happened by Guruji's meher...
a few weeks back i did listen to punjabi songs after a span of 4 months...believe me veer, i felt really disgusted...i was testing to see if i had changed...i tried to "move" a bit on their beats but i felt even more sick...something kept on telling me "no this is not me" and so i decided not to listen to it again, although its not my fault if someone else around me is playing it...however, my veerjees and bhainjees out there who do listen to punjabi/hindi music and dance to them, i got nothing against them...i still love and respect them without any judgements...Guru willing they too will quit in future, but i never force anyone to stop anything...
bottom line : REALIZE THE POWER OF GURBANI, AND FIND OUT WHAT MAGIC IT CAN DO !!!
;) ;) ;)
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
p kaur · 28 Apr 2004
some punjabi songs make me laugh because they're so STUPID. All these things about "dont' mess with Jatt people" and "the 16 year old girl in her jawani is blah blah" etc etc, I think 95% of the Bhangra I've heard is EITHER about kaam, ego, anger, attachment, daroo, patriotism to india or punjab or whatever, etc..
some of those songs are SO stupid they make me laughhh
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
singhsation · 29 Apr 2004
( cut off) cont....
or 'The Nutcracker'
With regards to the examples asking if we could see Baba Deep Singh ji dancing or Dasmesh Pita ji dancing, there are a number of other acceptable activities I can't see them participating in.
I cannot, for the life of me, picture Baba Deep Singh ji playing ping-pong or golf. I cannot imagine Dasmesh Pita ji snow-boarding. Does that now automatically mean that these activities are anti-gurmat? No, of course not.
If dancing keeps you from simran, then it's anti-gurmat; if gatka keeps you from doing simran, it's anti-gurmat; if playing tennis or any other sport keeps you from doing simran, then it's anti-gurmat. In the end, if any activity, no matter what it is, keeps you from simran, it is anti-gurmat.
As stated before, in my experience, 90+ % of dancing today occurs in an atmosphere which is anti-gurmat. However, that does not mean all dancing falls into the same category.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
singhsation · 29 Apr 2004
one last thing - hopefully others can comment on this as well.
In my own experience, I've noted that if I listen to songs, they DO interfere with my simran and will pop up in my head at the most unexpected times. On the other hand, if I keep kirtan going in the background, I find that it is gurbani which will 'pop up' unexpectedly in my head. As such, and this is not a knock on anyone else, I've found that limiting what I listen to does have a positive impact on my thoughts - one more reason to avoid ganday gaane.
Re: BHANGRA AND SARDAARS
.......... · 29 Apr 2004
although bhangra nowdays is pure manmutt, the old punjabi songs were casually based on folk, jungs, legends and celebrating basakh. It was not so much as todays perverted form. A person singing songs about a womans body in the old days would be digging himself an early grave.