Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

kps · 29 Oct 2003

Vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa Vaaheguroojeekeefatheh! Khalsa jee, Below is pasted the "Song of the Khalsa" written by Livtar Singh Khalsa. Sikhs in 3HO popularized this song by singing it at kirtan darbars wherever they went in the last 20 years. It is currently sung at our local Sikh youth camp. It reminds me of a dhaadee vaar. I do not get much laahaa from this or from dhaadee vaars, but I do not mind when they sing it. Is it against gurmat to sing this in Guru Sahib's darbar? What is the difference between this and dhaadee vaars or kavitaas ? Thanks for your gurmat-oriented opinions and advice. Chardee kalaa jee, Vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa! Vaaheguroojeekeefatheh! _________________________________ _________________________________ Song Of The Khalsa ------------------------- Many speak of courage. Speaking cannot give it. It's in the face of death that we must live it. When things are down and darkest, that's when we stand tallest. Until the last star falls, we won't give an inch at all! Stand as the Khalsa, strong as steel, steady as stone. Give our lives to God and Guru, mind and soul, breath and bone. Guru Arjun gave His Life, to stand for what was right. He was burned and tortured, five long days and nights. He could have stopped it any time, just by giving in. His Strength a solid wall, He never gave an inch at all! Sons of the Khalsa, remember those who died. Stood their ground until their last breath, so we who live now, might live free lives. A princess is not royal, by her birth or blood inside. But if her family's home is Anandpur Sahib, She'll walk with such a grace and strength, the world will bow in awe. Until the mountains fall, she'll never give an inch at all! Daughters of the Khalsa, in your strength our future lies. Give our children fearless minds, to see the world through the Guru's Eyes. Baisakhi we were thousands, but only five had the courage for dying. Then one brave man, one flashing sword, turned us all to lions. And now we live His Legacy, to die before we fall. And like the five who answered the call, we can't turn back at all. Stand as the Khalsa, strong as steel, steady as stone. Give our lives to God and Guru, mind and soul, breath and bone. The Tenth Guru gave even His Sons, to give the Khalsa life. His Words stand like mountains, against the winds of time, That Khalsa will rule the world, all will be safe in its fold. But if the Khalsa falls, there won't be a world at all! Stand as the Khalsa, strong as steel, steady as stone. Give our lives to God and Guru, mind and soul, breath and bone. Many speak of courage. Speaking cannot give it. It's in the face of death that we must live it. When things are down and darkest, that's when we stand tallest. Until the last star falls, we won't give an inch at all! Stand as the Khalsa, strong as steel, steady as stone. Gives our lives to God and Guru, mind and soul, breath and bone. Sons of the Khalsa, remember those who died. Stood their ground until their last breath, so we who live now, might live free lives. Daughters of the Khalsa, in your strength our future lies. Give our children fearless minds, to see the world through the Guru's Eyes. Stand as the Khalsa, strong as steel, steady as stone. Give our lives to God and Guru, mind and soul, breath and bone. Mind and soul are His alone.

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

kps · 31 Oct 2003

PLEASE REPLY SANGAT JEE.

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

hjhjhjh · 31 Oct 2003

kps...i dont know how much 'laha' you are supposed to get from dhadee. it was instituted by Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji to hype the warriors up, if im not mistaken. i dont think its purpose is to meditate peacfeully to it, but it should rather excite you for battle.

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

.... · 01 Nov 2003

lol at hjhj i think the purpose of the question was whether it's anti gurmat to listen to this

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

poem · 01 Nov 2003

no, it can be considered similar to a poem.

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 01 Nov 2003

why would it be anti gurmat cause its in a langauge other then punjabi? man the songs great, is amazing, it shows the shaheediya the kurbaniya singh singhnia of thi spanth has given the greatest of all the shaheedi of our guru sahiban.

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

? · 02 Nov 2003

is tadi and sarangi the same??

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

Gaiani · 02 Nov 2003

it shudnt be sung cuz its kachee Banee, unless u want to agree about that.

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

poem · 03 Nov 2003

Gainani can you explain how writing a poem about the Jagat Guru can be called kachee BAnee. Saying that is insulting the person whom the poem is written about.

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

Gaiani · 03 Nov 2003

24th pauree Anand Sahib. In other words are you saying that I can say Waheguru is great and that would be considered Banee?

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

MISFIT · 04 Nov 2003

I think we have misunderstood this pankiti. I humbly request Bhai Kulbir Singh or Bhai Balpreet Singh to do vichar on this shabad. sathguroo binaa hor kachee hai baanee. baanee tha kachee sathguroo bajho, hor kachee baanee. kahdae kachae, sunNdae kachae, kachee(n ) aakh vakhaanNee. har har nith karehi rasnaa, kaheiaa kachhoo na jaanee. chith jin kaa hir laeiaa maaeiaa bolan pa-aei ravaanee. kahai naanak sathgur baajho(n ), hor kachee baanee.

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 04 Nov 2003

its praising guru gobind singh ji, how can it be bad?

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

poem · 04 Nov 2003

Gaiani, if you say Waheguru is great, I would not call that kachee bani. Because gurbani says: Sathguroo Binaa Hor Kachee Hai Baanee. You can call some things on tv, movies or some books kachee bani, but not if it praises God. Guru Gobind Singh Jee kept many poets in their hajooree. Even Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh wrote a book of poems called Darshan Chalkaa. So you cannot say that it is kachee bani.

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

Gaiani · 04 Nov 2003

Bhais sahibs book is Kachee Bani, Im not saying it isnt, use your head and think Satguru(i.e. Guru Sahib) Binaa(Without) hor(Other) Hai(Is) banee. in other words without Guru there is kachee bani. UNless your saying mere humans can create something equal to Guru sahib.

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

my thoughts... · 04 Nov 2003

Well here's my 2 cents, I think what Gainai jee is trying to say is that if the bani is not written by one of the Guru Sahibaans, this includes all the bani in Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji, then it is kachi bani. Obviously, it is good to praise Vaheguru, but the utmost best and only way to praise Vaheguru is through keertan, through Guru Shabad. A poem by a poet can NEVER meet the praises done through Guru Shabad. Lets just stick to basics and not try to be superstars here try to create our own bani, you will get no laha from singing it, it is like a dog trying to catch his tail...actually bad example dog is just stupid he probably knows he can't catch it but he still tries..he just has to leave it alone...not gonna happen people...i THINK, we have little bit of an advantage over the dog..we have little more brain power..i can't say that for myself, but I'm sure you all do...lets stick to guru shabad, it will takes us to places only Guru Sahib knows, and avoid this new 'cool' thing to do by creating our own 'bani'. You wanna read it, then read it on your own time, but, definately, you can't make it part of keertan in the hajoori of Guru Sahib Maharaj.

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

RoopKaur khalsa · 04 Nov 2003

Gurbani is only the bani present in Satguru Sri Guru Granth sahib ji. There is other banis written by Bhai Gurdaas Ji and Bhai Nand Lal Ji. The rest is not bani. It could be great poetry about guru ji, but it is not bani. If the rest was gurbani, we would be able to sing it in the form of keertan in front of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

poem · 04 Nov 2003

The argument is not whether it is gurbani or not. The question was if it is wrong to sing this in Guru Jee's darbar. "Is it against gurmat to sing this in Guru Sahib's darbar?" Obviously it is not as Guru Sahib kept many poets in their darbar.

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

Mkhalsa · 04 Nov 2003

Its not Gurbani but its also not kachee bani.. its just something that happens to praise god. its not bad, if anything its good. but its not gurbani. [%sig%]

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

wonderingkaur · 05 Nov 2003

Hanji is our satkar yog guru granth sahib jee has any less shabads? or u ran out of shabads? that u had to go write ur "own" song. just a thought. I mean guru granth sahib jee's each word is soo deep that we humans can never estimate what it "truly" means. not studying the granth we r going creating other songs. I don't know if that's right. I mean is guru granth sahib jee not enuf for us? why do we need songs like that? maybe bhai sahib kulbir singh or other veerjis bhenjis can enlighten us with their knowledge?

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

Gaiani · 05 Nov 2003

the above posts state that is is wrong to sing kachee banee in Guru Sahib's darbar. Its common sense really, whot would you do sing something Guru Sahib wrote or something some mere mortal using his or her own mat made up?

Re: SONG OF THE KHALSA !!!!!! ?

Balpreet Singh · 05 Nov 2003

As far as my understanding is, there is a place for kaveeshree and dhaaDee vaars to be sung in Gurmat. Historical songs about battles or Sikh Heroes are something that has existed amongst Sikhs for a very long time. At Sree Akaal Takhat Sahib, Guru Hargobind Sahib used to have dhaadee vaars sung to inspire the Sikh warriors. After 1984 many dhaadees sang about the battles Sikhs fought against their oppressors. I think nothing can beat GurbaaNee and it is supreme, but I also believe there is a place for historical dhaaDee vaars in Gurmat.