Re: about HAIR
princess of power · 01 Nov 2003
lol you must remember that Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is for Sikhs, ...not just amritdhari/keshdari sikhs, i know peeps would have everyone beleive that you must keep your hair to unite with Vaheguru Ji (or be a sikh for that matter) ...but our own Bhgat Kabir ji is giving us sikhia, that perhaps Vaheguru Ji is in the cut hair woman as well as the uncut hair woman..... and perhaps whats really important is what u feel inside, what you feel about naam, and what your relationship is with Vaheuguru Ji. The rest is down to dharam and if/what dharam u choose to follow....by dharam i mean path.
But let me just say.....nothing as beautiful as long hair, I do find though that i have homai as far as my hair is concerned..... *blush* down to my knees last time i looked....and it is beaaaaaaaaatiful.
:o)
what do i do about the homai??
Re: about HAIR
warrior*princess · 01 Nov 2003
kabeer preeth eik sio keeeae aan dhubidhhaa jaae ||
Kabeer, when you are in love with the One Lord, duality and alienation depart.
bhaavai laa(n)bae kaes kar bhaavai gharar muddaae ||25||
You may have long hair, or you may shave your head bald. ||25||
---------------------
I am no accurate translater and neither do i have the virtue to know for sure...but personal attempt...
I think it means that no matter how you choose to look - none of those looks matter (i.e. the word given 'alienation'). BUT if you truly love Vaheguru ji, you will ONLY do what is right and therefore dress in the TRUE or correct roop/ baana.
I certainly do not believe that either of the Gurbanee you have mentioned gives the green light for being allowed to cut hair! This goes against Sikhi/ reht/ rehtnama's.
Guru ji seems to be addressing to the ridiculous appearances/ hairstyles people choose to have instead of being in love with God and doing whats right. (Therefore this Gurbanee is given to explain that >Some look hideous, with their uncut hair matted and dishevelled.)
For example, buddists shave their heads and assume that they are spiritually very high but even they reject to believe in God and therefore cannot find/ reach God.
Hukamai Aandar Sabh Koe, Bahar Hukum Naa Koiee
Whereas there maybe other religions who choose to keep their hair long to a certain length - but these practises are empty and worthless.
The one who truly loves God will not be doing either of these.
BUT that does not mean Sikhs are wrong!...Sikhs keep hair in the correct form, i.e. via Dastaar/ turban. This is what Guru Sahib asks of his GurSikh, i.e. that is what Vaheguru ji wants. And Sikhs keep that hair as given at birth just the way Vaheguru ji wants it!
People can shave their beard everyday, but how comes it always grows back! Sikhs keep hair the way Vaheguru wants them to be kept. And whether its beard, hair on the head, or on body, all is treated with the same respect because cutting hair as per reht is a Kureht (sin).
Please forgive me for any mistakes as per Gurmat.
Re: about HAIR
princess of power · 02 Nov 2003
sister warrior princess, could you please tell me whether any of Guru Ji's wives wore turbans? esp Mata Sahib Kaur Ji, the mother of the khalsa, and why they have not written any advice for Sikh women? The rehitname for men seem just that....for men, they are not aimed at women when i read them, I thought they should have at least something about women in there... I was very confused.
i know about Mata Bhag Kaur, but I was told she was very masculine, ie like a man, this means she also had the physique and wore a turban to disguise herself as a man in the battlefield so that the enemy would not know they were facing women as well as men (helped with numbers)
surely the point of sikhi is no to have women looking like men, surely the Guru Ji's wives must have taken amrit? there is no mention of them wearing turbans......
forgive my ignorance...
Re: about HAIR
Balpreet Singh · 03 Nov 2003
There are no physical descriptions, as far as I know, of Mata Sahib Kaur or Mata Sundar Kaur jee. Mata Bhag Kaur looking like a man is a new theory that I've never heard before. Do you have a source?
As every discussion on this topic has said, hukams for a "Khalsa" is not gender specific. They apply equally to all Khalsas. No such thing as a Khalsee exists.
Re: about HAIR
my thoughts... · 03 Nov 2003
To "Question":
You may want to double check the translations, I'm no katha vachik...but most of the translation out there aren't very good and can never translate the exact meaning of Gurbani. So I suggest you double check the tranlation with learned Gursikh.
Secondly, I agree with Balpreet Singh that hukams for a "Khalsa" is not gender specific. Every rehit that applies to a Singh, also applies to a Singhnee. In the case of dastaar, Guru Sahib's gave the double dastaara(keski and another dastaar on top) to the Khalsa for the better up keep of the hair. Think about it logically, why would a Singh's kes be more important than a Singhnee's kes when Guru Sahib has promoted equality for both genders? It is pretty clear from that standpoint that both genders should wear a dastara, I'm not sure how anyone else could say otherwise. Personally, this shouldn't even be an issue for an argument.
Re: about HAIR
warrior*princess · 04 Nov 2003
Sikhi allows equality of BOTH genders just as Bhai Balpreet Singh veerji has stated. And Khalsa is beyond gender! Whatever man can, so can woman. So there is no need for separate distinction about females...there isnt any for man! Gurubanee is reflected for Khalsa.
THIS IS THE BEAUTY OF SIKHI!
Re: about HAIR
warrior*princess · 04 Nov 2003
Since this is a gurmat message board, i was referring to that statement religiously...i had a feeling someone wont like that statement, esp males! BUT men can take care of kids aswell as women.
Secondly, about Singhnia like Mata Sahib Kaur, yes she went to the battlefield with the upmost Chardee Kaalaa...
You said not MANY women do NOT go to war...BUT Guru ji's teachings leads a Sikh to become disciplined, prepared, alert...this is both Spiritually AND Physically. Sikh = male/female!
Make no mistake, Gurbanee refers to how one become Khalsa, there are no limitations, and hence the womens role is completely equal to the mans religiously!
No one has the right to put down any Woman, Guru Sahib ji gave women the equal rights via the finalisation of Sikhi by Dhan Guru Gobind Singh ji.
WHAT ABOUT:
[] Mata Sundri was Guru Gobind Singh's wife. She nurtured and guided the Khalsa for forty years after the Guru's death. She was deeply spiritual, as well as intellectual, and was responsible for making scholarship a central part of Sikh life.
[] Rani Sada Kaur is aptly described as a first woman commander-in-chief. She became a young widow when her husband was killed in battle. She used this crisis to transform herself into a woman-warrior, donning a high turban and battlefield garb with full weaponry. She commanded numerous battles and eventually laid the foundation for the Sikh empire. Maharaja Ranjit Singh was her son-in-law and his
later successes were primarily due to Rani Sada Kaur's military and political strategies.
--------
It is not just the typical war-like battlefield that counts. What about our everyday life. Do you realise that women have to endure more injustice when they wear the Khalsa bana and try to pursue according to life demands? If those brave Singhnia can live as per true Sikhi, then do not under-estimate about whether they can go on the battlefield or not!
If a Sikh needed to fight, Guru ji will give them strength through kirpaa depending on the intentions of the 'fight' whether that Sikh/ Khalsa is a man or woman.
Now read 'some' of the history of what Chardee Kalaa Singhnia can do....
[] http://allaboutsikhs.com/women/gursikhwomen.htm
[] http://www.sikhifm.com/Sikhism/update1/The%20Great%20Sikh%20Women.pdf
[] http://www.khalsapride.com/Strength/
Re: about HAIR
warrior*princess · 04 Nov 2003
I meant Mai Bhago when referring to Mata Sahib Kaur in the beginning
Re: about HAIR
warrior*princess · 04 Nov 2003
I do not understand why are u debating like this. I cannot understand why you have started this issue about males being different, we can all see the physical aspect being different, which does not need discussing any further.
I did not make any statement as to what you are implying.
I only pointed out the equality issue 'religion-wise' and still Firmly believe in what i posted. I do not wish to discuss any other matter outside religion and thus goes beyond the scope and aim of this Gurmat message board.
Bhul Chuk Marf Karnaa if you were offended personally.
vaheguru jee kaa khalsa vaheguru ji keee FATEH!!!!!
Re: about HAIR
RoopKaur khalsa · 04 Nov 2003
>>>i am aware of the examples provided, but did the women in the battles provide an equal role in all the jangs during and after Guru Sahibs time....i'm not talking about morally...physically? NO! ask yourself why! why were the khalsa armies made up of almost completely men if we are so equal in every sense as you think.<<<<
Have you seen mata Bhaag Kaurs gun? it takes about three men to pick it up it is soo huge. With guru ji's kirpa both men and women can do equal work.
If the women as well as the men started going to the wars, who was going to do the house work? It was more practical that one person stay home and take care of the house and children while the other person went out to fight the battles.
Although both genders have bodies equipped for different purposes, with guru ji's kirpa, anything can be accomplished by a gursikh.
Although there are physical differences, spiritually there is no difference between a woman and a man, and it is the spiritual battle that we have to fight everyday against the five bikaars.
Re: about HAIR
warrior*princess · 04 Nov 2003
'.' seems to have more of a superior complex and cant accept the statement or concept of woman being able to do tasks that men can, except some of the 'very very physically demanding' jobs.
'siiigh' is right, that it is society that supresses a women/ womans role through their ideas or demands..but in the end the woman can be twice as strong because of her will-power.
Kaur (Singhnee) = Lioness/ princess
Singh = Lion
No matter what, Guru ji overcame these problems of inequality through Amrit/ Sikhi!
Stop being stubborn '.', because in a way, we are 'all' women as per Gurbanee because we are referred to as soul-brides of Vaheguru jee! Heheeeeeeeee!
Re: about HAIR
domalla premee · 05 Nov 2003
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh
Sikhi goes a step beyond feminism which is secular in nature. Sikhi has a strong spiritual, mystical and moral component to it. Sikhi attaches the Khalsa straight to the Akal Purakh first and the priority is towards the Guru FIRST. The life of a Gursikh revolves around the Guru. Submitting to the Guru means submitting to His Hukam. The Hukam is gender blind and each of the Khalsa submits his or her ego and rather then following the ways of world maintain the outer and inner disciplines. This means maintaining the sanctity of the hair and maintaining them with a dastaar.
As far as what anyone is capable of doing is entirely up to the capacities of the individual's God given talents, capabilities, hard work and inclinations. Not everyone is as strong as everyone else, as fast as everyone else or as intellectually capable as everyone else. More and more women and men are taking on roles that were considered gender specific just a few years ago.
Women who are more hands on types are in construction, are maximum security prison guards, fighter pilots and yes soldiers. I see them all the time where I live (soldiers)A good portion of the Israli army at one time was female. We have an NBA female basketball team in my city, And they are quite good. If she is good at it why stop her? Provided her line of work does not comprimise her Sikhi principles should be the first consideration of engaging im a particular profession.
If that person has a particular strength or talent why be discouraged to persue. One parent can raise a child but it is better for the child's well-being to have both parents. They both have something to give that makes a child whole. And by the way I was not breastfed. She was physically unable to. Was she less of a woman? I think not.
Women need to be more involved. More Need to take amrit and need to be taught the martial arts. All Khalsa can build confidence, strength and discipline by engaging in these discipline.
Anyone for a women's Gatka team??
dass
Re: about HAIR
Gulzar Singh · 06 Nov 2003
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
Now I would just like to share my views... and please read carefully so we don't misinterpret things...., and ill say this before i start, that i am not this "men work and women cook" sorta person, so please read carefully...
Well some time ago at school, my teacher and the whole class got into this huge discussion that lasted for a whole lesson abt girls/guys, and i can say i learned a lot form it... So now i'll explain...
Well, like many people on this forum, I really hated the "punjabi" views about women and stuff, and i still do... But my views have now changed slightly. Well, in a nutshell, my view is that, men and women are NOT the same, HOWEVER this does not mean that one is better than the other (i'll explain this further later...)
I'll go into the details now. Men and women are NOT the same, since, obvious physical differences and others as well. A man isn't a woman and a woman isn't a man, thats enough to prove WERE NOT THE SAME. So, obviously, we ARE DIFFERENT. Men have their innate qualities as do women have their innate qualities. A (average) woman cannot match the physical ability of a (average) male (fact, not being sexist...). Women typically have greater difficulty thinking in 3 dimensions were as men are better at it. Women have a much higher number of connections between the left and right side of thier brains were as men have much less. Thus, women can process much more information at one go than a man can. In terms of behaviour, this means that women can do / think of many things at the same time whereas men can't; men can typically do one thing at a time.
Now before i continue, PLEASE UNDERSTAND, that OF COURSE their are individual exceptions, im just talking GENERALLY
(e.g. a girl at my school has like A+ for physics/chem/bio/math b/math c !!, shes got no prob. thinking in 3D... btw, girls usually excel in humanities...)
Now, due to having fewer connections between the left and right side of the brain, men don't think things through as much as women, and hence they take greater risks. Women on the other hand, think things through much more rigorously (think abt many things at once) and hence take fewer risks.
An example, women (generally) make better drivers than men, since, they can think about many more things while driving, always cautious, checking carefully... Men, (again GENERALLY!!), would tend to take more risks, dont think things through as carefully.
Another example that my teacher said, which is also very true for me. You want to ride your bike to the railway tracks, dad's like, "yea son go ahead..." mum's like "be carefull, take your jumper, you'll catch a cold, dont go on the tracks etc" Also, you may notice that your mum can talk on the phone and cook at the same time... dad can only focus on the cricket on TV and nothing else...
THESE ARE JUST SOME EXAMPLES, OBVIOUSLY NOT ALL WOMEN/MEN ARE LIKE THAT, all i am saying is that, based on science / pyschology this is just what you'd expect...
Now, if EVERYONE thought like a WOMAN, civilisation wouldn't get anywhere, we'd be stuck since women don't take many risks and of course, progress requires risks to be made... eg. aeroplanes...
Conversely, if EVERYONE thought like a MAN, we'd probably be all dead since everyone would take so many risks and not think of the consequences... (ppl died while making progress...)
you need both man + woman minded ppl for things to work out properly...
SO NOW TO EXPLAINING MY MAIN POINT... :)
I said that men and women are DIFFERENT, but in being different we are not better than each other...
EG:
A plug and a socket, THEY ARE NOT THE SAME, THEY ARE EXACT OPPOSITES! However, is a plug better than a socket or vice versa? NO, they are different but in being different one is not better than the other...
A PLUG DOES NOT FUNCTION AS SOCKET AND A SOCKET DOES NOT FUNCTION AS A PLUG!!
Therefore, A MAN FUNCTIONS as their innate qualities make them do, and a WOMAN FUNCTIONS as their innate qualities make them do!! AND YES, it is in a boys INNATE nature to play with TRUCKS and in a girls INNATE nature to play with DOLLS!! I'm serious, they did an experiment, to see if society really affects a boys / girls complacancy, i.e., if a boy and a girl grew up without external influence, would the girl play with cars instead of dolls and vice versa... the results show that its just the innate nature for girs to play with dolls and boys... so on and so forth. However, this is a generalisation AGAIN, for the vast majority of the population...
EG #2: for the more mathematically minded...
+10 and -10 Are they the same? NO!!! Is -10 better than +10 ? NO!!! they are different but the differences don't mean one is better than the other!
Ok, now onto the gurbani views...
MEN AND WOMEN ARE SPIRITUALLY EQUAL! BUT, WE HAVE INNATE ROLES TO PLAY IN SOCIETY! HOWEVER, as mentioned by others, KHALSA WOMEN AND MEN HAVE THE SAME OBLIGATIONS TO SIKHI!!! (spiritual equalty; kirpan, daastar, defending the faith, cmmding wars etc) Also, please DONT BE LED into thinking that i am in favor of the "MEN WORK AND WOMEN COOK OPINION", cause ur missing the point...
Ok now, i'm quite sure that some may disagree with my views. If you think i'm talking trash, please help a fellow manmukh and convince me otherwise... :) srry if i offened anyone (i'm only 17 and only starting sikhi in the past 2 yrs, have mercy on me..., and plus i got this opinion from skool which is manmat anyway...) and srry for the long post...
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
[%sig%]
Re: about HAIR
Soormasher Singh · 09 Nov 2003
Actually ' . ' feminism and sikhi do go hand in hand.
Feminism, is not much about ‘equality’ as it is about altering the balance of power. The feminist want the power and seeking ‘equality’ is merely a camouflage. And so are the cries of ‘oppression’ that the feminists and other post modernist liberals make.
The Guru promises full spiritual equality to men and women, but nowhere in Sikhi would you hear anyone say – the Sikh revolution really wants to transfer the societal setup from patriarchy to matriarchy, or transfer the ‘power’ to women.
As you do know, the status of women in Sikhi is radically different from pretty much all other ‘civilized’ realms of religion, the ancient Stone Age matriarchal tribes excepted of course. The Guru exalted the status of women from the causers of the ‘original sin’ (Genesis), ,‘one-half of man’ (Quran) or ‘witch/Maya’(Hindu milieu) to the ‘honour of man’(Guru Hargobind Sahib) and the ‘creator of kings’(Guru Nanak Nirankar).
But based on my understanding, there really isn’t anything similar to the power driven feminism of the late 20th century in the message of Sikhi.
Women seeking power is a deviation from the normal feminine behaviour and against the basis of natural way in which heterosexual relations function. Man commands the power, and women nurture and submit, ensuring a compatible relationship. There is nothing bad about this setup; howsoever politically incorrect it might sound. That’s how the genetics has made men and women. Fighting against the Will of Vaheguru can’t take us far, thought it can certainly begin the decay of society as we see all around ourselves.
The, basic question that needs to be asked is this- if women don’t share ‘equal power’ with men, does it make them oppressed? Probably in the feminist worldview, but not in an objectivist rational order.
Let us say two Sikh kids-Ajaib Singh and Ayesha Kaur-are born in a Gursikh family. Both Ayesha and Ajaib receive similar education and both end up as physicians. Ajaib gets married and starts his family. Ayesha too starts her family and at around age of 27, gives birth to a baby girl. She takes two years off to nurture the young one. At the age of 31, she becomes a mom again and takes another two years off work to take care of the younger one. At age 34 she’s a mom again and she’s away from the workforce again for a couple of years.
Everything put together, while Ajaib continued to work non-stop, while his sister had to stop making ‘economic contribution’ for over six years to perform functions that only a woman could perform. Over their lifespan, Ajaib’s earnings will always exceed those of Ayesha, ceteris paribus. Will it mean that Ajaib has somehow made bigger contribution (to whatever) than Ayesha? To the contrary in my opinion.
There is one way though in which Ayesha can easily keep pace with Ajaib’s earnings. And that is if she chooses not to be a mom. That way she will not have take any breaks from work and will end up at the same level as Ajaib. And while this is a very common feminist lifestyle, it is antithetical to Sikhi, as anyone out there could point out. It is relying a hundred percent on our own distorted intellect rather than living in Guru’s Will (that is to first of all recognize what we are). Self-realization is the second step. If we don’t even know who we are, how will self-realization ever occur? Its illusions can occur, and that’s what has afflicted the feminist world. Women not remaining women and forgetting the natural things they have been blessed with-the ability to shape the next generation. But that is a menial task.
The ‘liberated’ women would take a huge pride in working a minimum wage job at McDonald’s rather than serving a hot meal to her husband and kids. That’s the distorted logic of this age.
Men and women have equal access to spiritual, political and economic realms. But that still won’t make women the same as men.
By its very origin, feminism is rooted in communism and is atheistic or at best agnostic. So if you choose to have feminism, it MUST be secular. Anything else will be a deviation from it. That’s a logically untenable state.
The real issue here is that Sikhi does not need feminism. Sikhi addresses the needs of both men and women alike - in the spiritual and temporal domains-and does not need any appendages of communist ideologies to effect social transformations.
And there is almost certainly going to be a backlash from amongst the men, like we see in today’s men’s movements. And we have a gender war.
Why create this rife in the Sikh domain (as if we don’t already have our share of troubles) when the situation doesn’t demand it.
Feminism can’t solve the problems of women anywhere. It just replaces one set of problems with another. And the society as a whole actually becomes worse of.
To help women in a real way, the ideal should be to take the message of Sikhi to them. And in Sikhi is their hope and an end to the problems. Not in Sikh feminism, as it is fundamentally in conflict with the Sikhi ethos.
Re: about HAIR
manjinder singh · 10 Nov 2003
So anyway,
kabeer preeth eik sio keeeae aan dhubidhhaa jaae ||
Kabeer, when you are in love with the One Lord, duality and alienation depart.
bhaavai laa(n)bae kaes kar bhaavai gharar muddaae ||25||
You may have long hair, or you may shave your head bald. ||25||
________________
this pankiti is from a section of the guru granth sahib where bhagat kabir ji is talking about the rituals of hindus.
he is talking about the sidhs and yogis and their different customs.
there is a sect of hindus / brahmins / munis that RETREATS / RUNS AWAY from society by wearing no clothing (or orange robes) and shaving all their hair off
there is another sect of yogis / rishis / hindus that RETREATS / RUNS AWAY from society by wearing orange robes (or no clothing) and growing long hair that they never comb
some smear ashes on their forehead, some carry prayer beads, some beg, some wear sandles while others go barefoot,
these are all meant to be stages of their commitment to god
guru jee says if those things don't remind you of your love for god,
it's alllll hogwash.
actions matter more.
those things should REMIND you of your actions, then they are holy.
therefore,
bhagat kabir ji is saying,
"MY DEAR HINDU / BRAHMIN / RISHI / MUNI brothers (it was mostly men),
I see that you smear ashes on your forehead
I see that you wear orange robes and carry prayer beads
I see that you have a beggers bowl and you wander here and there
Some of you are shaved head to toe
While some have fully grown hair
Some of you bathe several times a day at holy places
while some of you haven't bathed in months
despite this all,
I do not see your love for God.
what use are these things, then, if they do not connect you to God?
They must be mear shows, are they not?"
__________
THE KHALSA,
the Khalsa - Guru jee says a Sikh is the one who keeps REHIT
so that is a Khalsa - a pure and complete sikh of the guru , the guru suroop him/herself
So Guru jee gave the hukam to keep your kes,
many reasons,
when you keep rehit you get attached to Guru jee,
your love for god grows,
so your action of following guru's hukam and growing your kes is justified,
it is necessary,
and int he previous stanza Bhagat Kabir JI is NOT saying that growing your hair is bad,
he is saying that doing pakhand is bad.
sorry if i said anything wrong
that's all for now -
until next time,
m.s.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: about HAIR
warrior*princess · 11 Nov 2003
'.' you shouldnt be so stuck in your ways and you should listen to Singhnia that have explained to you via Gurmat (even Singhs did too), otherwise Vaheguru ji teaches us the truth from a tougher lesson.
Re: about HAIR
JUST DON'T ARGUE · 11 Nov 2003
OKay
so the original post was about - what does that pankiti mean.
now somebody has given the explanation.
a side issue started of womens rights.
the kaurs are right - there is no inequality allowed in our gurmat institutions, regardless of physical differences between any two humans.
that said,
if people want to start the females rights discussion, let's do it on another message - this message is called "ABOUT HAIR".
If you have more hair posts, please share.
Otherwise if nothing comes up, admin PLEASE close the topic!
in the spirit of panthic unity, chardee kalaa, and the eventual annihilation of useless chicken-fights between people over petty issues,
WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH