Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

Parts: Part 1 · Part 3 · The Tegh · Extracts

Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

Admin · 21 Nov 2005

Following is a translation of a part of a book by Bhai Kaur Singh. This translation has been done by a very loving Singh from UK. This is the 3rd part of the translation provided to us by this veer. As we get more translations, we will post them on this forum. Please read this book carefully. It may change your life. Admin. Translated from ‘Khalsa Vidhaan’ by Bhai Kaur Singh Jab Lag Khalsa Rahe Niaara || Tab Lag Tej Dheeyo Meh Saara || Have faith that when the Panth comes to fully recognising and drilling this pure Mukhvaak of Kalgeedhar Guru Gobind Singh Ji they will immediately come to abide in Chardi Kala. One should contemplate over every word in this Mukhvaak, it is not so hard to understand. If the Khalsa stays distinct then Guru Kalgeedhar says ‘Mai Poora Saaraa Tej Bakhshaa gaa, Devaa(n)gaa’, meaning I will give the Khalsa my complete blessings (and power). The Khalsa is a distinct nation, its birth was most distinct, the lifestyle of a Khalsa is distinct, the food and clothes the Khalsa wears is distinct and the love the Khalsa has for the almighty is most distinct. In ‘Singhaa Da Panth Niraala’ Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji says why can’t every limb of a Sikh be pure? Only when ‘Khalsa Akal Purakh Kee Fauj || Pragatio Khalsa Pramaatam Kee Mauj ||’. We are only pure if we stay distinct, we can only get blessings if we stay distinct. How can a Khalsa stay distinct? This is a big principle that we must all take steps to understanding. It has already been said [in another chapter] that Gurmat virtues have a heavy affect on daily life, but we must be ready to follow the Rehat, thus making us distinct from others. In order to follow this, one must adopt the total and true Rehat. [An effort has been made in the books ‘Ram Raj’, Tos Ekta’ and ‘Sarbloh Bibek’ to explain the Maryada]. The next line of this Mukhvaak reads, ‘Jab Eh Gahai Bipran Kee Reet || Mai Na Karo In Kee Prteet||’. When we come to abide and make friends in the society of Niguray and Be-Amriteeai then we loose all our blessings. Tying a Dastar (turban) plays a big role in our distinctness. An English historian writes: - “The Sikh women are distinguished from Hindoos of their sex by some variety of dress but chiefly by a higher TOP knot of hair” by J.D. Cunningham. (Appendix XIV History of the Sikhs). Sikh Females are easily recognisable from Hindoo females. In olden times all Singhnia adorned a top knot of hair on the Tenth Gate (Dasam Dwar). Cunningham also writes that during battles these turbaned women would fight along side their brothers.

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

moorakh · 23 Nov 2005

May I please request admin and others to kindly include links on previous postings when they are made in parts...thank you [%sig%]

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

singh · 23 Nov 2005

PART 1 Following is a translation of a part of a book by Bhai Kaur Singh. This translation has been done by a very loving Singh from UK. This is the first part of the translation provided to us by this veer. As we get more translations, we will post them on this forum. Please read this book carefully. It may change your life. Admin. kuJ zrUrI AsUl Translated from ‘Khalsa Vidhaan’ by Bhai Kaur Singh. 1) Without the Rehat of Sarbloh Bibek, one cannot heed to the Shromanee Panthic Maryada of “Amritdhari dee Saa(n)j Amritdhari naal” (with this the Panth becomes inAwrwpn and distinct). 2) The person who follows the principles of Amrit – Rehat is an Amritdhari. The meaning of Rehat is to have unparalleled faith in the word of Gurbani and to follow Seenaa-Baseenaa Rehat also, some people stress on Gurbani Rehat and some on Seenaa-Baseenaa, both are mandatory side by side. 3) One that is not BibekDhari, he is not Amritdhari. He may have had Amrit, but he has not taken heed to it. (Us Ne Amrit Chakkia par Amrit Dharn nahee keetaa). In other words, he has taken amrit but has not accepted or adopted amrit from heart. 4) Only he is an Amritdhari who keeps Bibek and complete Rehat. 5) Bibek or Sarbloh Bibek, they are both the same Rehat, you cannot make two Rehats out of one, thus without Sarbloh you cannot have Bibek. 6) Without Sarbloh Bibek, the Panth cannot be distinct (Niarapan). An English writer, Mr. Edmond Kendler praises Sarbloh in his book ‘Metal of East’, he writes that Sarbloh Bibek gave the Khalsa an appearance of a nation :- To the Khalsa it (srb lOh) gave a cause and welded them into a nation. This is a truth. Without Sarbloh Bibek we will not be distinct, only distinctness will give the Khalsa the appearance of a nation. In the Akhand Keertanee Jatha, Sarbloh was mandatory to begin with, but now this Rehat has been stopped because in this day and age, the majority of people do not deem it necessary to have Sarbloh, but in the rest of the Panth Sarbloh is not even heard of. There are just a few Sarbloh Bibekis left within the Nihang Singhs; you will only get a handful that adheres to this Rehat. Even within the Nihang Singhs, there are them who do Sukha (Marijuana) and Chatka (ritual slaughter of meat), and therefore their Gurbani and Naam all goes to waste. This is why they have been unable to do any sevaa for the Panth as of yet. In the Panth, the Akhand Keertanee Jatha is nearest to Kalgidhars Rehat. The weaknesses that have crept in came after Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh stopped doing sevaa in the Panj. They are :- 1) Sarbloh Bibek is not stated as mandatory, so the person who is weak in Sarbloh – how are you going to tell him that he is kurehati? 2) Bana is not stated as mandatory, it is the slavery of the English that shows why we take Amrit wearing Pants and Shirt. 3) Small Kirpan (approx. 9”) big Kirpan (approx. 2 and a half to 3 foot), both Kirpans are not stated as mandatory, you can get Amrit with just a small one nowadays! This Rehat started from the times of 6th Paatshah (Guru Hargobind Sahib), this Rehat is still alive at Hazoor Sahib, only when you have 2 Siri Sahibs do they give you Amrit (Even there weakness has crept in, they take the Siri Sahibaa off afterwards). 4) To keep the enemy at bay, do justice and use the sword it is a must that Singhs and Singhneeaa alike learn Gatka. What can we do to ward off these weaknesses? The Jathedar Sahib should drill these Rehats within himself and tell them in the Amrit Sanchaar also; it is a must for all the Singhs and those that do Panjaa dee sevaa. In yester years, whatever weakness’ there were, the Singhs and Singhniaa would get Pesh and do Sudh Sudhaaee, they would then try and keep complete Rehat (as stated above). Rehat is the same for Singhs and Singhniaa. (Bhai Sahib has done Peshinagoee (prediction), “Keep in mind, that time is near where our Singhniaa will have to show themselves in battle also (they will have to fight along with Singhs in the battlefield”). In the Jatha after complete Rehat is being given the Jathedar Sahib from Panj should talk with the Pardhaan from Shiromini Committee about the Rehat Maryada, Sudh Sudhaaee should be done, and then all the Panth can follow commonness of Gurmat Rehat Maryada. The Panj Rehatvaan Sikhs should be given authority at the Takhat Sahib, whose hukam goes for all the Panth; all other organisations should be closed down. [%sig%]

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

singh · 23 Nov 2005

Author: Admin Date: 09-02-05 14:32 Part 2 of Khalsa Vidhaan Gurmat Lifestyle Translated from Khalsa Vidhaan by Bhai Kaur Singh ‘For a Sikh, only Kacherra and Dastaar are needed, it does not matter what else you wear. A Sikh women can choose to wear a Dastaar or not.’ Next we will say you can choose to wear a Kacherra or not – It is up to you. This is just an excuse to let go of other Rehats. Soon the committee will be saying Sikh women can take Amrit if they want to, but they don’t have to. When we have taken birth in the house of the Guru, our past life is gone. Before, the lifestyle the world had in accordance with the three virtues (Sato-Rajo-Tamo) is gone. Every bit has changed. Now we have to acknowledge and accept the traditions of Guru Sahibs house. Bhai Sahib Khan Singh Ji Nabha in his book ‘Mahan Kosh’ has told us who we should love and idolise, what to eat and drink, we start loving Gurus baNa. Our dress becomes like Singhs (all worldly fashions stop). Which BaNa is this? BaNa is alike for both Singhs and Singhneeaa. On the head there should be the round Dumaalaa (Not Nokhdhaar Pagh; I don’t know when this fashion started, originally the Pagh was round. See Bhai Khan Singhs ‘Mahan Kosh’ and the photo at the back of Ram Raj tract). Chola should be worn along with Kamar Kassa (belt around waist) and Kacherra (up to knees). In the olden days when the Khalsa was fighting many battles, Singhs and Singhneeaa had the exact same baNa. Even the Singhneeaa fought like the Singhs. (See "Ram Raj" book). Dumaalai with Chakars ( iron quoits) were worn to fend off blows from the Sword and kept the Dumaala strong and steady. They also work as Shastars (weapons). Until Raja Ranjit Singhs reign all women were donned in turbans – whose name, according to Rehatnamas was ‘Keski’ (5th Kakkar). Afterwards, we don’t know what happened, but weakness has crept into this Rehat also. The person who brought this weakness in the panth is Gianee Gurmukh Singh Musaafar. When he was Jathedar of Akaal Takhat, he stopped women from wearing Dastaar at the Takhat Sahib, before this it was seen mandatory for women to wear Dastaar. Amrit was not given without the Dastaar. Gurmukh Singh Musaafars wife did not wear Dastaar either. It would have been something else if he made her Tyaar-Bar-Tyaar and donned her with turban, instead he followed her and so much so, he decided to alter the Maryada at the Takhat Sahib. If a normal Sikh becomes weak then it affects him and his family, but if a leader becomes weak in Rehat then it affects the whole nation (panth).

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

singh · 23 Nov 2005

Author: Admin Date: 09-21-05 09:04 Part 3 of Khalsa Vidhaan. Gurmat Lifestyle 2 Translated from Khalsa Vidhaan by Bhai Kaur Singh ‘These are the 5 Kakkars [Kes, Kirpan; (with Gatra), Kacherra, Kangha and Kara] that an Amritdhari must bear.’ Now tell me, how can you bear Kes (unshorn hair)? When it is a limb (ang) of the body? Also, cutting ones Kes is seen as a Bujjar Kurehat, the one who does Beadbi (disrespects) the Kes is seen as a Bujjar Kurehati. So…how has one Rehat come to be in two places? Kes are the first stamp of Guru sahib and the person who disrespects them cannot be called a true Sikh. Then what is the reason for keeping them? What is the outcome of taking Unshorn hair as the fifth article of faith? Well, it is our narrow mind that says the word ‘Kes’ begins with a ‘K’ and therefore must be the fifth article of faith, how absurd! Don't be blind and think kesh are kakaar. Use your thinking. If you are going to accept Kesh as kakkar just because the word begins with ‘K’ then you are better off accepting the Kamar Kassa (belt around waist) because it does not come into any Kurehat and it is an Ang (limb) of a Sikhs Uniform. We are not to hail to the letter ‘K’, we should hail to the Rehat which Guru Gobind Singh Ji gave us on the Vaisakhi of 1699. The small turban (Keski) has already been talked about [Translators note: It has been talked about earlier on in the book]. Guru Gobind Singh Ji with his own hands tied a beautiful Keski and Dastar on Mata Bhaag Kaur. For further reference please read ‘Keski’ tract by Sura Parivar, ‘Singha Da Panth Nirala’ Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh and ‘Gursikh Rehnee’ Professor Amarjeet Kaur.

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

singh · 23 Nov 2005

Author: Admin Date: 10-12-05 06:27 Following is from Khalsa Vidhaan written by Bhai Kaur Singh Amritsar and translated by a Premi Singh for the benefit of sangat. Jathebandeeaa Translated from Khalsa Vidhaan by Bhai Kaur Singh There are many Jathebandeeaa at this moment in time, when we examine them we find they have positive points as well as negatives. When one Sikh or one Jathaa is in Chardeekalaa (high spirits) then it automatically attracts other seekers of truth. They have great faith in the word of God, which results in their spiritual state increasing tenfold. One must realise that the Sikh only becomes Chardeekalaa once they have adopted complete Rehat and meditated on the Name of the lord. The beloveds that give their love to the Panth forget that they have reached such a state due to adopting complete Rehat and so this becomes an area of weakness. These beloveds create a group of Gursikhs who hold similar views, in time they become a separate Jathebandee then even when the beloved passes away, his followers keep faith in him. When Gianee Gurbachan Singh Jee Khaalsaa was head of Taksaal there were less weaknesses. Candidates for Amrit were instructed to keep Sarbloh Bibek, Bibiaa were instructed to wear Dastaar. Giaanee Jee was Sarblohee himself and his family all wore the turban, including women. He especially had great love and affection for Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh. Believe it or not, both of their Rehats were almost exactly matching. After the passing away of the two Singhs, weaknesses crept in to both Jathebandeeaa, however, Dastaar is still prescribed to be mandatory in the Akhand Keertanee Jathaa. The head of the Naamdhaaree sect, Baba Raam Singh kept full Rehat, which included Sarbloh Bibek, Shastar and BaaNaa – he was a complete Khalsaa. Their Rehat did not stay, but the group is still around. Nowadays they are far from Gurmat ideals and have started their own line of Gurus, this is why they are rejected by mainstream Sikhs. It is evident that ritual has become their love rather than religion. Such as, the Neel Dhaarees who wear Blue Kamar Kassai (belt around waist). Even the women do not shy away from wearing the Kamar Kassai. They are followers of a Sant and do not hesitate to wear the Kamar Kassa, but yet they hesitate to accept the Rehat as laid down by Guru Gobind Singh Jee. None of them have adopted the five articles of faith (Panj Kakkar, including Dastaar), nor have they taken up Sarbloh Bibek. If one analyses these weaknesses, it becomes crystal clear that there is no Khalsaa spirit left within the Panth, with which all the Khalsaa would have adopted one Rehat and the Khalsaa itself would have been one Jathebandee, there would only be one Panth. Then all other Jathebandeeaa would have shut down.

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

singh · 23 Nov 2005

Author: Admin Date: 11-21-05 09:30 translated by anonymous premi. Our Duty to the World Translated from ‘Khalsa Vidhaan’ by Bhai Kaur Singh No matter what religion or social status someone belongs to, they can be blessed with Khande Dee Paahul (Amrit) and be given acceptance into the Guru house. There is no strict rule against this. We are nothing like the Brahmans, who restrict the Shoodras and other people from reading the prayers of the Vedaas. Also, no one must be forced into Sikhi, the Muslims are well know to label others as Kaafirs or non-believers. They believe it to be their duty to scare others and force them to embrace Islam. No one should be bought into religion through trickery and deceit, like the Christians do. Sikhs believe in the following Gurbaanee line – “Ek Pitaa Eks Ke Hm Baarik” and help everyone regardless of their religion. It is their moral duty to do so. Just like Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib sacrificed his head for the Hindu religion. The Singh warriors fought many battles against the Mughals, they rescued and sent home many Hindu Girls they had snatched. Any person can receive food, clothes and any other help they may need at any Gurdwara in the world. We can help the world in this true and righteous way.

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

A Singh · 23 Nov 2005

Gur Fateh! This is excellent material and big congratulations to all the Gursikh sevaks for undertaking this effort. Just wanted some of the more learned veers to perhaps help with some clarifications on some of the points: 1. Is Bhai Kaur Singh, the same as Akali Kaur Singh? 2. If the Chola and Kachera (i.e. no pjyama) are "the" Khalsa Uniform and my the answer to (1) above is affirmative, then one can understand this, however, I am surprised to see someone draw such a reference whilst concurrently citing the works of Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh or Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha. Bhai Sahib Jee is always wore a pjyama, even in the recent painting in which some suggest he looks like a Nihang, he is wearing a pyjama. 3. Following on from (2) above, if the dumalla is "the" only acceptable dastaar for the Khalsa, then surely this sits at odds with Bhai Sahib Jee and Bhai Kahn Singh who regularly wore dastaars more akin to the "Nokhdhaar Pagh" than anything even closely resembling a dumalla? Likewise, even the old pictures of the AKJ performing kirtan in the presence of Bhai Sahib Jee (for one such picture see the Tapoban homepage) and the Jatha Singhs wearing dastaars more akin to the Nokhdhaar Pagh than a dumalla - I find this comment by the author extremely strange, given that the Jatha of Bhai Sahib Jee's time would have been absolutely steadfast in their Rehit, surely then this statement cannot be correct? 4. Finally, whilst I have a lot of respect for the immense efforts and charisma of Baba Ram Singh Namdhari, I am surprised to find that the author has cited him "(keeping) full Rehat, which included Sarbloh Bibek, Shastar and BaaNaa and (that) he was a complete Khalsaa". Without any disrespect to Baba Ram Singh Jee, however the following points have to be noted as part and parcel of his teachings: - The wearing ONLY of white and total SHUNNING of Blue Bana - The maintenance of Havans as a genuine part of the Sikh practice (Chandi Paath) - The wearing of a Laathi in place of a Kirpan - The conduct of mass (i.e. more than one couple) Anand Karaj and that too around a Havan rather than Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Are these aspects also considered to be "completely Khalsaa"? Also there is no mention anywhere of Baba Ram Singh Namdhari being a sarablohi? The Namdharis practice bibek, but theirs (sodh) is more of a political statement than that in vogue amongst Nihangs, AKJ, DDT and others. Please could someone shed some light on these points? Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

Rashpal Singh · 24 Nov 2005

VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh 1) This book is written by Bhai Kaur Singh from Amritsar and not Akali Kaur Singh who was from Kashmir. Bhai kaur singh did sangat with Bhai Randhir Singh aswell. 2) I think it is fine to wear chola with pyjami. But, the puraatan singhs definately did wear chola with just kacherra, mainly if they were doing akhand paath rols or any other seva- to be clean. And the weather was different in India compared to here (uk). 3) The Nokhdhaar pagh is different from the Gurmukhi dastaar. Gurmukhi dastaar is without the larr at the back and without pooni. Bhai Randhir Singh definately wore the gurmukhi style dastaar, I am not sure about Bhai khan singh nabha. However, the dumaala and gurmukhi dastaara are only acceptable if they have keski on underneath. 4) A Singh said: '- The wearing ONLY of white and total SHUNNING of Blue Bana - The maintenance of Havans as a genuine part of the Sikh practice (Chandi Paath) - The wearing of a Laathi in place of a Kirpan - The conduct of mass (i.e. more than one couple) Anand Karaj and that too around a Havan rather than Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee.' Baba Ram Singh was a chardikala Gursikh, who declared that he was not the Guru (read his letters from jail), Bhai Randhir Singh ji also had alot of respect for Baba Ram Singh. The things that you have noted above only came into existance after Baba ram Singh passed away. VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh [%sig%]

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

Singh · 24 Nov 2005

A singh ji, this is first I have heard of baba ram singh doing havans. Especailly for anand karajs. Where did you get this info from?

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

A Singh · 24 Nov 2005

VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh Rashpal Singh Veer, Thanks for your feedback, however this doesn’t really solve the issue here, as Bhai Kaur Singh, despite having had sangat with Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Jee, clearly has taken a much different stance on a number of points. 1) This book is written by Bhai Kaur Singh from Amritsar and not Akali Kaur Singh who was from Kashmir. Bhai kaur singh did sangat with Bhai Randhir Singh aswell. Thanks for the clarification. 2) I think it is fine to wear chola with pyjami. But, the puraatan singhs definately did wear chola with just kacherra, mainly if they were doing akhand paath rols or any other seva- to be clean. And the weather was different in India compared to here (uk). I agree that wearing a pyjama is fine, however that is not what Bhai Sahib Kaur Singh is saying in his text above. Also when he uses the term chola, no doubt he refers to what is nowadays considered by most people to be a Nihang chola, however this would imply that wearing a Kurta Pyjama is not appropriate, again this sits at odds with the reality of many Singhs who did sangat with Bhai Sahib Jee and indeed many other mahapurkhs within the Panth. Is the author not restricting things a tad too far? 3) The Nokhdhaar pagh is different from the Gurmukhi dastaar. Gurmukhi dastaar is without the larr at the back and without pooni. Bhai Randhir Singh definately wore the gurmukhi style dastaar, I am not sure about Bhai khan singh nabha. However, the dumaala and gurmukhi dastaara are only acceptable if they have keski on underneath. I agree with you on the differences, however the author has not mentioned gurmukhi dastaar (which of course is what Bhai Sahib Jee wore), but stated that only a dumalla is acceptable – as I mentioned, this sits at considerable odds with the Bana commonly worn by Bhai Sahib Jee himself and many other Singhs during his time. I am not disagreeing with the authors underlying views (re: the influx of western attire etc) but he repeated seems to take things too far, to the extent that even Bhai Sahib Jee himself and many other Mahapurkhs who adorned what would imho still be classified as Gurmukhi bana. <<4) A Singh said: '- The wearing ONLY of white and total SHUNNING of Blue Bana - The maintenance of Havans as a genuine part of the Sikh practice (Chandi Paath) - The wearing of a Laathi in place of a Kirpan - The conduct of mass (i.e. more than one couple) Anand Karaj and that too around a Havan rather than Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee.' Baba Ram Singh was a chardikala Gursikh, who declared that he was not the Guru (read his letters from jail), Bhai Randhir Singh ji also had alot of respect for Baba Ram Singh. The things that you have noted above only came into existance after Baba ram Singh passed away.>> Veer, please let’s be serious. It is commonly known that all of the above was propagated by Baba Ram Singh, I have not mentioned his followers claims for him being a Guru – that is irrelevant for the discussion here. As per the white clothing, this is a clear instruction that can been found in Baba Ram Singh’s Hukamnamas and letters (including those in which he indicates that he is not a Guru). Read any source book on Namdharis or the Kuka movement, the above will clearly in referenced in ALL, also eye witness accounts, the references in the works of Gyani Gyan Singh and many others all clearly show that Baba Ram Singh was very particular about the white clothing element and his shunning of Blue (hence the episode with the Nihangs and Pujaris concering the blue Garment). The lathi was introduced by Baba Ram Singh, as there was a ban on the Kirpan in place by the British (and hence why Namdharis later came to be know for their use of the axe –techniques for fighting with the lathi and axe are very closely related). This is nothing something that was later introduced as ALL accounts indicate (pro and anti Namdharis). Likewise, the wedding ceremony popularised by Baba Ram Singh Namdhari and the use of Havans for Chandi Path (a practice common also within Nihangs and Udasis – who have close links to Namdhari Gurus, read about Baba Balak Singh and Baba Ram Singh’s time in the army of Kanvar Nau Nihal Singh) were not things that happened after his passing, there are clear accounts of this happening during his lifetime and him leading these practices. In addition to this, Baba Ram Singh, as is the practice common amongst the Nihangs, placed equal reverence to both the Sri Guru Granth Sahib and Sri Dasasm Granth Sahib. He also encouraged regular recitation of Chandi-ki-Var and also the Uggardanti (a text that many today, following the analysis by Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha, have problems with accepting). So, as much as I admire Baba Ram Singh Namdhari and agree that he was a Chardi Kala Gursikh, there remains elements of what he believed and practiced which by the standards set out by Bhai Kaur Singh, would clearly fall outside of he considers to be a puran Khalsaa. If Veer Jee, you honestly believe that Baba Ram Singh did not believe in this things, please could you indicate on what basis you feel this to be the case in spite of the many references that would indicate to the contrary. Bhai Kaur Singh’s works are very interesting, however they do not make a perfect fit with the practice and reality of the jeevan of even great souls like Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh and other rehitvaan Singhs of the Jatha from Bhai Sahib’s time, which makes me find it difficult to believe that this text is little more than Bhai Kaur Singh’s personal opinions and attitudes. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

Rashpal Singh · 24 Nov 2005

VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh A Singh, 2) Like i said, I think pyjama is fine. This point is about debating what can and cant be classed as bana. I think Bhai Kaur singh is implying that nihang chola is definately more akin to what the puraatan singhs wore than wearing a kurta pyjama. Kurta pyjama is traditional panjabi dress, rather than traditional Sikh dress. But I would not call it Manmat to wear it, after all it is much better than wearing pant shirt. 3) Bhai Kaur Singh is very explicit in his writings. But he doesnt specifically say that the style of dastaar (gurmukhi) that Bhai Randhir singh wore, along with other Jatha singhs of that time is wrong in anyway. As long as it is round, i.e. without the lar it is fine. The word dumaala itself means 2 dastaars - Keski and bigger one above. But of course, the puraatan singhs wore an uchaa dumaala (tall dumaala) like nihangs singhs wear. 4) As for Baba Ram Singh, I really can't comment because I don't know enough about him. I will leave this to a more knowledgable Gursikh. VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh [%sig%]

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

A Singh · 25 Nov 2005

Dear Singh Veer, GurFateh! Thanks again for your honest answers. <<<2) Like i said, I think pyjama is fine. This point is about debating what can and cant be classed as bana. I think Bhai Kaur singh is implying that nihang chola is definately more akin to what the puraatan singhs wore than wearing a kurta pyjama. Kurta pyjama is traditional panjabi dress, rather than traditional Sikh dress. But I would not call it Manmat to wear it, after all it is much better than wearing pant shirt.>>> Whilst this is something we agree to, clearly there are a number of point arising here. If, as you now say, the Nihang Chola is more AKIN to what the puraatan singhs would have worn – does that in itself make it a Sikh dress? There are many communities in India who adore garments like the Chola, but let’s say that it is (and I personally do believe to be a distinctively Punjabi Sikh Garment), then why do we accept that the Kurta Pyjama is acceptable? As you say, this is a more common dress, in fact the style worn by many prominent Singhs, like Bhai Sahib Jee (i.e. the Choorida Pyjama) is in fact a Muslim influence than one necessarily even India – how then is this acceptable if one is to take such a stance as the author is suggesting? Why and how is it better than a shirt and pants? <<3) Bhai Kaur Singh is very explicit in his writings. But he doesnt specifically say that the style of dastaar (gurmukhi) that Bhai Randhir singh wore, along with other Jatha singhs of that time is wrong in anyway. As long as it is round, i.e. without the lar it is fine. The word dumaala itself means 2 dastaars - Keski and bigger one above. But of course, the puraatan singhs wore an uchaa dumaala (tall dumaala) like nihangs singhs wear.>> I agree, the author is specific and explicit and as translated by our Veers above, he statement is: He is clear that the style should be a Dumaalaa, however let’s take your point and say that in this instance, the Dumaalaa is a loose term and refers to a double dastaar and one which is round – if that is so, I would like to understand how exactly any of the dastaar worn by Bhai Sahih Jee and the other rehitvaan Singhs of the Jatha of his time that is shown on the www.tapoban.org homepage qualifies as ROUND – all have a triangle (ala nokhdhaar) than anything even closely resembling a Dumaalaa or round round Namdhari/Taksali dastaar. 4) As for Baba Ram Singh, I really can't comment because I don't know enough about him. I will leave this to a more knowledgable Gursikh. I would like to understand more about this, you seemed to be quite certain that all the mentioned items above came in to being after his death. It would be a great find if our learned Veers here could prove this to be the case, in which the entire Namdhaari propaganda will cease to exist.

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

Rashpal Singh · 20 Dec 2005

VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh Baba Ram Singh definately did wear shastar and his Panj Kakkar. If you read Bhai Randhir Singhs autobiography you will note that he says Baba Ram Singhs Kakkars and Shastars were also forcibly taken off him like Bhai Sahibs were. VaheguruJiKaKhalsa VaheguruJiKiFateh [%sig%]

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

Rashpal Singh · 20 Dec 2005

*Were forcibly taken off him in jail that is.

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

A Singh · 20 Dec 2005

Veer Rashpal Singh, It is no surprising fact that Baba Ram Singh wore the Kakkars, however that is not what is being questioned here - as per the Bhai Sahib's autobiography, yes he is right to use the comparison as both were imprisoned for similar reasons and subjected to the same treatment in this respect - however this doesn't change the questions aired above, nor the fact that Baba Ram Singh replaced the Kirpan with the Laathi owing to the then ban imposed by the British Authorities. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

Singh · 21 Dec 2005

A singh - I am a bit confused... If Baba ram Singh changed the kirpan for lathi due to current circumstances at that time. Then this is something we should ask baba ram singh or namdaris. I do not see why you are questioning Rashpal Singh about this? he clearly has no link with namdharis.

Re: Khalsa Vidhaan Part 3

A Singh · 21 Dec 2005

Singh, I am not asking Rashpal Singh Veera, I'm asking the forum/cyber sangat, who collectively should be able to help me and possibly others understand why Baba Ram Singh has been referenced as a Chardi Kala Singh and Pooran Khalsa in the foregoing text, yet many of HIS practices are quite contrary to those being advocated by Bhai Kaur Singh as Gurmat proper. Seeing that we have many people who are quite familiar with Namdharis here, maybe they can help explain this notion. That's all...