Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Who is Bhai Bala?

Who is Bhai Bala?

Concerned Singh · 24 Nov 2005

Guru Swaaree Sangat Jio, Waaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waaheguru Ji Ki Fateh It had been bugging me for a while that i finally decided to bring it up to the forum and let everyone take a swing at it. First of all it is wrong to have pictorials of Guru Sahibaan (I'm also guilty, but fighting with my parents to take off so called Sobha Singh's paintings). This by itself can become another thread to talk about. Regardless, you may have seen Modhi Baba Guru Nanak Dev ji in a company of Bhai Mardaana ji in many picitorials, but who is this third person that is also shown? Many may answer that he is the author of Janam Sakhi and was annointed by Guru Angad Dev Ji. But research does not point in that direction. To solidify the case i've posted some facts and at the end there's a link that shows made up pictures of Modhi Baba Guru Nanak Dev Ji found in Janam Sakhi. Baba ji is shown as wearing Janeo, Topi and Tilak on the forehead. The last picture shows baba ji with no hair and there are many other issues. This is probably the most popular and well known Janamsakhi, in that most Sikhs and their Janamsakhi knowledge comes from this document. This work claims to be a contemporarry account written by one Bala Sandhu in the Sambat year 1592 at the instance of the second Guru, Guru Angad. According to the author, he was a close companion of Guru Nanak and accompanied him on many of his travels. There are good reasons to doubt this contention: * Guru Angad, who is said to have commissioned the work and was also a close companion of the Guru in his later years, was, according to Bala's own admission, ignorant of the existence of Bala. * Bhai Gurdas, who has listed all Guru Nanak's prominent disciples whose names were handed down, does not mention the name of Bala Sandhu. (This may be an oversight, for he does not mention Rai Bular either.) * Bhai Mani Singh's Bhagat Ratanwali, which contains essentialy the same list as that by Bhai Gurdas, but with more detail, also does not mention Bala Sandhu. * It is only in the heretic janamsakhis of the Minas that we find first mention of Bhai Bala. * The language used in this janamsakhi was not spoken at the time of Guru Nanak or Guru Angad, but was developed at least a hundred years later. * Some of the hymns ascribed to Nanak are not his but those of the second and fifth Gurus. * At several places expressions which gained currency only during the lifetime of the last Guru, Guru Gobind Singh (1666-1708), are used e.g Waheguru ji ki Fateh. Bala's janamsakhi is certainly not a contemporary account; at best it was written in the early part of the 18tyh Century. http://allaboutsikhs.com/jsakhis/pics.htm Waaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Who is Bhai Bala?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Nov 2005

heres a summary from another forum....read on Dear All From the discussion so far about Bala two points emerge for thoughts. Did Bala exist in reality or he is fictitious character? Is the Janamsakhi written by Bala is the one from a person who accompanied Guru Nanak during his travels. Both questions are related to each other. Probably the answer to the first question is in the answer to the second question. It is best to seek internal evidence from a document to make any judgement about it. The language of the Janamsakhi said to be written by Bhai Bala suggest that it has been written after the death of Guru Gobind Singh. It uses words like Sat Sri Akal (Page 674) and it also uses the word "late" (page 559) which is an English word that is now used in Punjabi. Further the contents of this book are also misleading and anti Gurmat. For example it says the Guru Nanak had put on Janeo the sacred thread of the Hindus (page 34). It says that the name of Chak Ram Das (now Amritsar) has been named after God Rama. (Page 766) It says that Guru Angad Dev got infected with Leprosy at the time of his installation as the second Guru and Guru Amardas used to suck the pus out of his infected thumb the entire night so that Guru Angad can sleep. Further most of the Gurbani quoted in this book has incorrect reference to the Gurus. For example at page the verse written by Guru Arjan (Na Ham Hindu Na Muslman) has b een ascribed to Guru Nanak (Page703). This is also a proof that this book has been written long time after the death of Guru Nanak and cannot be by a person who accompanied Guru Nanak. If we have a book which denigrates our Gurus, then it does not take much to realize who has written it. All this leads us to only one conclusion that this Bala is a fictitious character. Regards Jarnail Singh . ( not "arshi" ) Note: the writer is another person with similar name and very knowledgeable and lives in Australia.

Re: Who is Bhai Bala?

The Khalsa Fauj · 25 Nov 2005

Bhai Bala Sakhi is totally messed up. It is the work of har bhagat niranjnee, the guy responsible for gettting Bhai Taru handed over to jakria. For more on this janamsakhi, please read kattak ke visaakh by Bhai Karam Singh Historian.