Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
Its all good · 25 Nov 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ke fateh
Sangat ji please clarify for me, Is it ok for us to associate with non-amritdharis, with monay, with people who cut their kesh, eat meat, maybe dont believe in god.
by associations i mean, in our daily living, like, say at work, school, ir even home.
what if Your parents are not amrtdharis, they eat meat, drink and cut kesh, should you stop talking to them?
but then what about the piyaar, the love, the jot of god tht resides within them?
or does iit not reside within such people?
i understand sangat is a big influence on a person, and obviously its great if you can remain within the company of gursikhs.
what about allowing non-amritdharis to cook for you? If they doing it with as much suchham as they can and importantly with LOVE?
'sach kahoo sun lehoo sabeh jin prem kioo tin he prabh paeooo'
CK, LEh EMi - (sory just had to throw these in)
Awaiting your responses
manjit Singh
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
amarjeet singh · 25 Nov 2005
try not to eat from none amritdharis
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
Concerned Singh · 25 Nov 2005
Waaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
if that particular person does not believe in the existence of Waaheguru then you don't want his/her company(Gurbani made many references regards to the company of manmukhs) , but do not hate them. It'll be great if you can get them to listen, they may change. Sikhi can only flourish if all sikhs become ambassadors of it. if we start to avoid these Bhule-Bhatke people then are we to believe these so called pakhandi babe can save it from what sikhi has become?
Waaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
Its all good · 25 Nov 2005
Sorry Amarjeet Singh ji, could you please elaborate on why we should try to not eat from non-amritdharis?
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
Kulbir Singh · 25 Nov 2005
Association should be done with such individuals who are “Hum-khyaali” and “Hum-safar” in the Gurmat sense. The true seekers of Vaheguru say:
“Santan siyon meri leva devi, santan siyon biyohaar||”
(My giving and taking is with Gursikhs and my association is with Gursikhs only).
Why do Gursikhs associate with Gursikhs only? Because, sangat is the deciding factor on what a person is going to become. One becomes like his sangat. If one does sangat of thieves, one is not going to become a Saadhoo by doing so. One doing sangat of Gurmukhs will surely one day become a Gurmukh himself.
“A man is judged by his society.” This quote is so true. If a person hangs out with loafers and scoundrels, he (or she) can’t be a Gurmukh and by the same token if a person always hangs out with Gursikhs, he or she can’t stay a Badmash.
Bhagat Kabir jee goes as far as suggesting that one should just flee even at the sight of a saakat (a bad peson).
Kabir, saakat sang na keejiye, dureh jaayeye bhaag||
( O Kabir, don’t do sangat of saakat; flee away from him ).
Guru Sahib orders us to do friendship with Gursikhs only and to focus on the Satguru jee only. He further admonishes us that if we do dosti (friendship) with manmukhs, we should not ask for happiness then. Please ponder upon the following pankiti:
Manmukh siyon kar dosti, sukh ke puchheh mitt||
Gurmukh siyon kar dosti, Satgur siyon laye chitt||
Now the following questions arise:
1) What about manmukhs at work or school?
Then answer to this question is that business dealings or dealing of general nature with manmukhs cannot be classified as associating with them. At work or at school, if you are dealing with non-Gurmukhs, that does not mean that you are associating with them. Associating with manmukhs means having biyohaar with them i.e. going out with them, having friendship with them and having personal relationship with them, eating with them and from them etc.
2) How would you do parchaar if you don’t associate to non-Gursikhs?
Gursikhs know who are the gaahaks (candidates) of Parmaarath (spirituality). Gursikhs are like hans birds who are able to distinguish and separate milk from water. They don’t bother to change an incorrigible manmukh but if they see a potential candidate, they surely do parchaar of Gursikh on that person. Associating with manmukhs with the aim to do parchaar is perfectly in accordance to Gurmat.
This may not sound politically-correct but this is what Gurmat is. Ultimately, we must realise that our aim in life is to meet Vaheguru and in order to meet Vaheguru, we must associate with others who are walking on this path. If we associate with ones who are walking on a different path, how can we reach Vaheguru then? To meet Vaheguru we have to walk on the path leading to Vaheguru. We can only associate with the ones we meet on this path to Vaheguru.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
Its all good · 25 Nov 2005
So if all good qualitites belong to god, who do the bad ones belong too? Not to god? If everything is his creation etc...
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
Gurpreet Singh · 25 Nov 2005
Guruji says to live in this world like a lotus in a dirty pond...even if we HAVE to be around people who are faithless or wrong doers...(though there are hardly too many perfect people out there)...we should live in such a way that it will inspire everyone...remember u being nice makes all the difference...ofcourse theres a limit but try ur best...don't go around looking down on people...thats the worse thing you can do.
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
Amritpal Singh · 25 Nov 2005
I ask the people who associate with non-amritdari's on a consistent basis...
Leh! for example.
Gursikhs get up at 2 am and jaap naam for 2 -3 hours, and then they do huge amounts of bani bhagti, and even then it takes years to make a jeevan.
Now your lifestyle right now, hanging with 'atheist' friends, are you even close to that?
I dont want this to sound like a personal attack, maybe you just dont realize how much work it takes to actually get anywhere with bhagti
We have a huge and hard task of meeting vaheguru. Gurmukhs like Bhai Sahib Randheer singh used to associate with gursikhs all the time, and spend every moment doing sewa.
How can time spent with somebody who does not belive in god help you in this path?
Their thoughts, views and opinions come onto you naturally. You dont even have a chance to fight them off.
Gursikhi is not about trying not to look "big headed" to other people. Who cares what others think of us. Gursikhi is about meeting vaheguru and being as close to guru sahib as possible.
How many sehaj paats, or how many amrit vela's can you maintain while keeping the company of atheists?
Dont want this to be a personal attack..just please think about it.
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
LionKing (LK) · 01 Dec 2005
1) What about manmukhs at work or school?
Then answer to this question is that business dealings or dealing of general nature with manmukhs cannot be classified as associating with them. At work or at school, if you are dealing with non-Gurmukhs, that does not mean that you are associating with them. Associating with manmukhs means having biyohaar with them i.e. going out with them, having friendship with them and having personal relationship with them, eating with them and from them etc.
**************
Throw out the Langar-tradition of Sikhi then, if you can't evne sit and eat with a Non-Sikh or manmukh.
As for having friendship with them - seriously Guru ji tells us to be lotuses
in this dirty pond, and not run to the himalyas and stay there avoiding manmukhs
lol
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
Amritpal Singh · 01 Dec 2005
Langar-tradition is actually Langar prepared by Sikhs (amritdari Khalsa) for the sangat that attends Guru Sahibs diwan. So there is no need to throw out the langar tradition, the langar tradition is fine.
Guru Jee tells us to be lotuses. Thus, living in this world (dirty pond) but staying away from the dirt of the pond. So by avoiding having relations with manmukhs we are living in the pond, and also not getting dirty.
the best way to achieve this is to keep your close relations with Gursikhs only.
I mean you can do parchaar to manmukhs, and u can interact with them at work, school , etc. But to keep CLOSE relatoins is not going to help you spritually.
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
LionKing (LK) · 01 Dec 2005
Amritpal I was talking about eating WITH, i wasn't evne talking about preparing Langar, but eating WITH
so yes, tha would imply - throw out the langar tradition,a s it's ment to be everyone sitting together and eating
As for close relations - depends on how close, adn waht you define as close relations....
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
Amritpal Singh · 01 Dec 2005
Theres nothing wrong with eating beside manmukhs in gurdwara sangat.
Nobody is saying that we cant sit together in langar.
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
LionKing (LK) · 02 Dec 2005
Somebody is however saying that it's wrong to eat WITH manmukhs.
******
Guru Jee tells us to be lotuses. Thus, living in this world (dirty pond) but staying away from the dirt of the pond. So by avoiding having relations with manmukhs we are living in the pond, and also not getting dirty.
******
I don't agree with you - I believe Guru ji is saying - live within the dirty pond, associate with people, learn from them (or are we too arrogant to learn from other people?), filter what you don't like = add the good tihngs to your own jeevan :). You can ALWAYS learn something from EVERYONE.
So my interpretation is - live in the dirty pond, associate and learn, but yet stay unattached, and uneffected by the dirt of the pond, which will happen through Naam =)
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
Jagjit Singh · 02 Dec 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, I personally think we should do sangat of everyone without difference, but do not let them influence you. Instead influence them about spirituality, good morals, and sehaj.
The strength of your personality is very important. Guru ji tells us to avoid manmukh sangat, but that also includes manmukh thoughts in our own minds.
Those who are deeply into abyass and gurmat become introspective anyway. Hence they aviod anything that affects their avastha with their own wisdom.
But we should not create paranioa about punjabis and non-sikhs, otherwise how will they come into sikhi. Sahib Siri Guru Nanak dev ji did not stop meeting people, but we also have to accept that he chose Bhai Lallo rather than Malik Bhaggo. This was his wisdom. When Malik Bhaggo came to him in anger, Guru jis used his humility, sehaj and pyaar, with a simple act to melt Malik Bhaggos heart and show him the truth.
Similarly, we should use our wisdom when choosing sangat, and realises "sadh sangat kasse janai, jitte iko naam vekhanea". But when we meet non-sikhs or pounjbais we should show them the qualities of a Gursikh, otherwise we are much worse than them.
In my office, when I first started, the conversations here were about sexual friendships, ninda, chugli, etc. Now I have come we spend alot of time talking about life and spirituality, and rarely they mention the subjects before. I find western people in particular are very receptive to talk about spirituality. It is the fastest growing interest group. Westerners are very anti-religion be it christian or any, but many want spirituality.
waheguru ji kekhals,a waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
Kam Singh Mate · 04 Dec 2005
WJKK WJKF
Bhai Sahib if associating with monay is wrong why is your epictone of inner sanctrums open to all. Humble request, please look into your Sikh history before asking silly questions. Was Pir Budan Shah Amritdhari? Was his brother Amritdhari? were his sons Amritdhari? Yet they all died for Sikhi fighting alongside Guru Gobind Singh Ji, who created Khanday batay da Amrit!
FOOLS
Guru Gobind Singh Ji said "Manas ki jaat sabhay eke pehchanoo"
Guru Nanak Dev Ji came into the era of darkness to destroy all boundries of social status and now you ask is it ok for an amritdhari to sit next to a non-amritdhari.
FOOLS
Why do you think Langar was introduced? So that all regardless of colour, caste, religon, Amritdhari or not can sit together and have Guru ka Langar. Look at the structure of Harmander Sahib, it has for gates for all four corners of the world, notice that this is the only sanctrums of sanctrums, where people of all faiths are allowed. The only one where you have to step down instead of up, to show nimerta!
FOOLS
The question shouldnt have been can Amritdharis associate with non-Amritdharis but if non-Amritdharis can associate with Amrithdharis!
Im sorry if i have offended anyone
Bhul Chuk Maaf
Dhan Guru Nanak
Dhan Guru Nanak
Dhan Guru Nanak
WJKK WJKF
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
Kam Singh Mate · 04 Dec 2005
...
You are right.
Puul Chuk maaf.
I also apologise for using the word Fools -
because it is I who is the biggest fool!
SORRY EVERYBODY!
Re: Associations with Non-Amritdharis (monay)
}{/-\R\/1ND3R · 05 Dec 2005
. . . parje i wanted to ask u summin
if u we cnt asssositate wid monay how is parchaar
yeessss it is rite in sayin tht we shud be wids gurmukh ratha thn manmukhs.
but wat kam singh mate has poste is also tru
The question shouldnt have been can Amritdharis associate with non-Amritdharis but if non-Amritdharis can associate with Amrithdharis!
n also if u hav a big gurmukh who is so strong willed tht the sutt of a manmukh cn nt gt on em is it alright
bhul chuk maaf
WJKK WJKK