wearing pants when reading guru granth sahib
Khalsa47 · 04 Nov 2003
i was thinking.... is it okay for someone to jhor sahib or read guru granth sahib when they are wearing pants? or do they have to be in bana. [%sig%]
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Khalsa47 · 04 Nov 2003
i was thinking.... is it okay for someone to jhor sahib or read guru granth sahib when they are wearing pants? or do they have to be in bana. [%sig%]Balpreet Singh · 04 Nov 2003
If someone is going to be in sevaa/hazooree of Sree Guru Granth Sahib jee, they should be wearing Khalsa Dress. Guru Sahib has a uniform and his sevaadaars should be dressed in that uniform at least when doing seva if not at all times. If we can wear a uniform for school and work, why not for our Guru?... · 05 Nov 2003
if this is so, then why do people wear pants when doing seva of guru ji? does it really matter as long as you are wearing your 5kakkars? [%sig%]... · 05 Nov 2003
Here's a question then: If Guru Sahib had been born in this era, in North America what would he have worn? What would Khalsa dress be then?Balpreet Singh · 05 Nov 2003
Why are we playing guessing games like the above? What if Darbaar Saahib was really in Anandpur Sahib and the Khalsa was created there and the Mughals didn't rule and then the Hill Chiefs became Khalsa? And what if then, the Sikhs ruled all of India....? There's no ends to "what if". Guru jee picked a time to come and picked a dress fo the Khalsa. As Sikhs of the Guru, we accept what the Guru Said. If we play "what if" we just end up confusing ourselves and frankly wasting time.does it really matter · 05 Nov 2003
i dont think it matters it should be the paath that countsdamdami taksal - jatha malton · 05 Nov 2003
to say kurtha is bana, is just as wrong as saying pants are bana. the point is, they both arent bana, but its just taht one has been gernally accepted over hte years because it is more relateable to the punjabi culture. the kurtha pajama is borrowed from muslims in pakistan, just as the salwar kameez has. but for some reason, we think its bana. there is no difference between pants and kurtha, because the chola is the what our gurus wore. a few years back, bhai ram singh damdami taksal wale was forced to leave his sewa as the head granthi of darbar sahib in amritsar. they said wear the new style kurtahs seen by ragis these days, or to leave. he checked with baba takhur singh ji, and then gave his resignation to the darbar sahib officials stating he was not going ot give up his bana to confide with the modernization of sikhi, and this 'new age' bana. so to say no to pants becuase its not 'sikh' is to say no to kurtas too. if you disagree, you should go to india and check the clothing actually worn by the gurus, and stop looking at these pictures drawn by people in the 20th centruy who have no clue what the gurus looked like. we have been brainwashed into believing that those images aer what are gurus looked like. another point, i dont see any 'designer' cholas coming out. i dont see any fashion shows for them either. but i do see latest fashions for salwars and kurtah-style clothing. i guess all this is if you really want to get deep into it. i guess if you look at it fom an unbiased point of view, you can wear anything thats not too flamboyant or eye-catching. we want focus on the bani, not the person reading it.I don't think it matters aswel · 05 Nov 2003
I don't think it matters as well. Guru Sahib gives us so many tukhs speaking to Brahmins and Mulas of their dress and ritualistic ways and says that all is useless without the love fot the almighty, I'm pretty sure it applies to us. Some of us don't have long cholas and long kacheray. I think to clean in full ishnaan is good enough. Plus I don't think the "Khalsa Uniform" was defined as the "kaliyan chola" all the rehitnaamaas just insist on Dastaar, and kakaars as the requirement. If you look at some of the old pics by the british field artists, most of the Singhs just had a shawl to cover thier body. Com'on Singhs we're taking the physical part overboard.... · 06 Nov 2003
the two posts by "I dont think it matters as well" and "damdami taksal - jatha malton" proved my point. what we wear doesnt really matter (as long as it doesnt invoke any of the 5 sins)designer chola · 06 Nov 2003
well said "damdami taksali - jatha malton". [%sig%]my thoughts... · 06 Nov 2003
A human being is like a vessel filled with milk...when you apply fire to the vessel..the milk starts to warm up and slowly boils over the sides of the vessel, covering the outside of the vessel...what was inside, spills to the outside...for a gursikh that fire is naam,bani and sangat...it awakens the gursikh from the inside like the fire heats the pot of milk...and the Gursikh begins to love Guru sahib more and more..and wants to try to do as much as he/she can to please guru sahib..and this leads to changes on the outside...their appearance and how they dress...they have 'sharda' to want to please guru sahib.......if one does not have 'sharda' on the inside to please guru sahib..then it will be okay for them to wear pants while doing any sewa of guru sahib..whether that be doing paath..or going to gurdwara sahib...and without 'sharda'..it will be harder for you to understand the idea of Gurmuki bana...I know alot of us might not know...but there are few of us that don't wanna know and accpet it...because we feel more comfortable wearing pants and shirts...there are no 'ifs' and 'buts' about it...you may choose to argue for as long as you want...no point in wasitng time...Guru sahib gave us a dress code..lets try to adopt it..at least (at minimum) for going to gurdwara sahib and doing any seva of guru sahibGABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 06 Nov 2003
why all these other additions 2 the punj kkakkars?... · 06 Nov 2003
you cant compare milk to a human a human has a mind....it can think.... milk reacts the way it does becasue heat is applied...Singhnee · 07 Nov 2003
---"a few years back, bhai ram singh damdami taksal wale was forced to leave his sewa as the head granthi of darbar sahib in amritsar. they said wear the new style kurtahs seen by ragis these days, or to leave. he checked with baba takhur singh ji, and then gave his resignation to the darbar sahib officials stating he was not going ot give up his bana to confide with the modernization of sikhi, and this 'new age' bana." if such an amazing singh would leave his position because he refuses to wear anything but bana shows the love singhs have for bana. at one point, i think that 'damdami taksal-jatha malton' is on the side that we should all wear bana while doing seva of guru ji, and at another point i think that he is against it. what is it eerji? This confusion occurs when you first state how bhai ram singh won't change his bana to a kurtah, and then when you stated your ending paragraph. ---"i guess all this is if you really want to get deep into it. i guess if you look at it fom an unbiased point of view, you can wear anything thats not too flamboyant or eye-catching. we want focus on the bani, not the person reading it." if i'm not mistaken your last paragraph states its okay to wear whatever as long as that person is reading bani I personally think that out of respect everyone should wear gurmukhi bana to gurdwara and especially when they are doing seva of guru ji. this is our guru ji, and we should show our guru ji all the respect and love in the world.. think about it this way, if you were to meet guru ji, or the 10 guru's. would you wear pants to go and do their darshan or will you wear bana (the dress that theyhave started for their khalsa, and want there khalsa's to be wearing it) to please them? when i went to india i never once seen anyone at harmandir sahib wearing pants and doin seva of guru granth sahib ji. this can hint off something to us dont you all think? if the singhs at akal takat dont wear pants when doing seva of guru ji why do the singhs of Canada/U.S/England, etc. ??? As 'damdami-taksal-jatha malton' has already said, go to india and see for yourself!!!! [%sig%]chola chola · 07 Nov 2003
"singhnee" bhainjee, i don't see 'damdami taksal - malton jatha' contradicting himself at all because to not "wear anything thats not too flamboyant or eye-catching." would be a simple chola would it not? To me it seems like the person is mentioning a chola can't be fancy and all, where as a kurta pajama has muslim origins and shouldn't be worn, so what else is left? A chola. Sorry I cant see where you are pulling the twists from? [%sig%]damdami taksal - jatha malton · 07 Nov 2003
Singhnee, i stated what it 'should' be like, but i also stated what the 'reality' of this situation is. Guruji has created Khalsa equally and undivided. There is no distinction between man and woman, this includes dress. All men and woman 'should' be wearing the dress of the Guru, but this isnt the case. The reality is that the kurtha and salwar, over time, have become the new dress of sikhism, and that cholas arent even allowed by sewadars in the HOLIEST of shrines, sri harimandir sahib. However, you can take this topic and look at it from both sides at many different angles, which was waht i did in my post...look at the otehr aspect of it. Bani itself is giving us both sides of the equation, and is allowing us to think with an unbiased point of view. We know both sides of the story and therefore can make a decision based on waht is true. On one hand, we can argue taht bana is important because it sets an example for the sangat taht is present, that its not as stimulating, taht its what our gurus wore, that being 'jeeo nirmal barhro nirmal' is importnat. We can also look at bani where it tells us of the negative reactions ones self, and otehrs have towards this misuse of this dress. This issue can be debated over and over, endlessly. To put it simply, its the mindset of the person that is important. Bana itself is indeed something that i personally feel is very important when doign sewa of SGGS infront of sangat, but at a general level, bana alone will not grant you instant mukti (salvation) to sach khand. Clothing shows a persons lifestyle, a persons thinking. Bana is a way to humble ones own mind, and to minimize ones own pride and to minimize negative feelings in and from otehrs. it used as a tool to help in the controlling of the mind. As stated earlier, its the direction in which you wnat to go, its the mindSET. It is up to taht individual person as to whether he/she is fooling other people, or even themselves. So to answer your questions of what side im on, its yes, i do believe in chola ONLY because i have read bani and history, and made my decision that for me, indivudally, it helps a great deal. I also personally believe while doing sewa of SGGS, the sewadaar should be in chola becuase it is waht gurus wore, but if the paathi has a kurta on i wont be distracted, becuase im there to concentrate on bani and not stare at him. I believe it shows disclipline and it maintains some type of order. But thas jstu me, otehr people might be jsut recently getting into sikhi, and his dress could somehow be effecting their thinking...who knows. The point is, i cant just tell everyone else to do soemthing without knowing why its done. However, I can tell everyone to study the situation, and make a decision based on waht bani tells us. Do it for the right reasons, dont do it just to go through the motions. as for going to india, i said go to india to look at the acutal cholas worn by the gurus, not ragis, which can be seen at historical gurdwaras actross punjiab. im sorry if i sounded confused in my first post, im not that bright. i probably still sound confused in this post as well but forgive me. this topic seemed straight forward but its more complex then appears. [%sig%]((((:-) · 07 Nov 2003
its wats on the INSIDE that counts when ur doing paathh.Singhnee · 07 Nov 2003
---""wear anything thats not too flamboyant or eye-catching."" this can mean a plain suit that isn't eye-catching aswell. i had mistaken him on that, i thought he was refering to a plain suit, something that wont catch the eye. i am sorry for my misunderstanding.. well said "damdami taksal-jatha malton" in your second post.Khalsa47 · 07 Nov 2003
---"its wats on the INSIDE that counts when ur doing paathh." so are you saying that it doesn't matter what we wear? from what i have read from all the posts above i think that one should wear bana before doing paath of guru ji or doin seva of guru ji, its just respect as everyone has stated above. i think it does matter what is inside a person but what is outside matters aswell. pleasing guruji is what we all want to do, so if wearing gurmukhi bana while doing seva will make guru ji happy why not wear it? [%sig%]I don't think it matters aswel · 12 Nov 2003
I just want to bring a point to your attention: "if wearing gurmukhi bana while doing seva will make guru ji happy why not wear it?" Guru Sahib is an existence beyond human comprehension. I don't think that an entity so High and real is pleased by a dress code. I said it before as well, nowhere in the Rehitnamaas is it written that the Kuliyaa chola or a kurtaa is part of the dress-code. Besides a dastaar, Kachera and the other kakaars aswell as some things not to where, no particular dress code is certain. Look at some of the hand-drawn pics of Emely Eden, Some Singhs just wore a shawl where as some Singhs had long cholay with artwork on the sides. Guru Sahib is only impressed with one's level of "jog". He is impressed at a level of "jut" (chastity) and "sat"(think speak and act truthfully). There is not a single line in Guru Granth Sahib ji explaing that the loard is impressed by ones dress-code. Indeed a dress-code gives us Identification and is necessary to be acknowledged in this modern society, but what I'm trying to say is, don't stay at the clothes, Guru Sahib is not impressed by cholay. Wearing cholay and dressing up in chakars and dumaalaay may benefit the panth and may increase inspiration to the watchers but a true heart impresses without effort "har ka bhagat pragat nahee chupay". The truthfullness inside a person will shine past his or her clothes "mundaa santokh saram pat jholee dhiyaan kee karay biboot" the earings of satisfaction are of more value overall.Khalsa · 14 Nov 2003
>>>>>”Guru Sahib is an existence beyond human comprehension. I don't think that an entity so High and real is pleased by a dress code.” <<<<< Why wouldn’t guru ji please with by a gursikhs uniform. Our guru ji had started bana, he did not start pants. Wouldn’t guru ji wants his gursikhs to be his dress instead of the dress of the goray people? >>>>>I said it before as well, nowhere in the Rehitnamaas is it written that the Kuliyaa chola or a kurtaa is part of the dress-code.<<<<<< Rehitnamaa doesn’t say a lot of things that we gursikhs follow ex: washing our hair everyday. Only reason it probably isn’t in Rehitnaamaa because the answer to this is common sense. >>>>>Look at some of the hand-drawn pics of Emely Eden, Some Singhs just wore a shawl where as some Singhs had long cholay with artwork on the sides.<<<<< you said it, “hand drawn” how can you believe a hand drawn picture? That’s just to funny. So then those hand drawn pictures of our guru ji must be how they really look, and guru gobind singh ji must have had worn a red chola because the hand drawn pictures show this. As for the part where some singhs wore shawl’s where probably because there wasn’t someone to make cholay really out there, and fabric must have had been expensive. These are just little excuses everyone uses to avoid wearing a chola. >>>>>Guru Sahib is only impressed with one's level of "jog". He is impressed at a level of "jut" (chastity) and "sat"(think speak and act truthfully). There is not a single line in Guru Granth Sahib ji explaing that the loard is impressed by ones dress-code.<<<<<< That is true, that guru ji is most pleased with his gursikh’s when they do path. As I said before there aren’t a lot of things that are written in the guru granth sahib that are common sense. Does guru ji say that once in the guru granth sahib ji that we should wear the 5 kakaars? Or does it say once in the guru granth sahib that we shouldn’t do bhangra? >>>>>Indeed a dress-code gives us Identification and is necessary to be acknowledged in this modern society, but what I'm trying to say is, don't stay at the clothes, Guru Sahib is not impressed by cholay.<<<<< Yes, bana lets everyone know who a gursikh is when they are in bana. But saying guru sahib ji isn’t impressed by cholay is just the stupidest thing that I have ever heard. Why wouldn’t guru ji impressed with his gursikh when they wear his uniform? I don’t think that he will be impressed if we wear the goray dress, or even the hindu/muslim dress code.