Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

langar

langar

singh · 26 Nov 2005

kulbir singh this is a question for you.why did u not eat with everyone else-i mean in the samelangar hall aas every1 else at khalsa camp.i was rele sad cz i always wned to ask questons bt u was never there. u had ur own seperate place to eat langar.but diditn guruji say the whole point of langar is to show everyones equal.by eating in a seperate room didnt htat defeat the hole object of langar. not being rude.jus wondering. are us non-amritdharis that bad? lease allow this admin

Re: langar

singh · 26 Nov 2005

kulbir singh follows sarbloh bibek and as the langar at khalsa camp was not all made in sarbloh, not all served in sarbloh, not made and prepared by bibekis, kulbir singh to follow sarbloh bibek rehit had to eat in a separate place (which btw any one was most welcomne to join)

Re: langar

hmm.. · 27 Nov 2005

Author: singh Date: 11-26-05 15:54 kulbir singh follows sarbloh bibek and as the langar at khalsa camp was not all made in sarbloh, not all served in sarbloh, not made and prepared by bibekis, kulbir singh to follow sarbloh bibek rehit had to eat in a separate place (which btw any one was most welcomne to join) --- So a 'Sarbloh Bibeki' can't eat sitting with Sangat who may be partaking in Langar that isn't made the same way as their own? [%sig%]

Re: langar

LionKing (LK) · 27 Nov 2005

"Singh" If the food wasn't prepared and served in Sarbloh, still doesn't answer the question why Veer Ji didn't SIT IN THE SAME HALL. There is no reason why he would need to eat ina separate plate for the reason of being Sarbloh Bibeki... Let's wait and see, He probably has an explaination of his majburi :)

Re: langar

... · 27 Nov 2005

In Guru Keeaa(n) Sakheeaa(n) (one of the oldest texts on Sikh history), Bhai Dalla approached Guru Gobind Singh and asked him to come and stay at his fort. Guru Gobind Singh refuses at first but after Bhai Dalla begs, he agrees but says that his Khalsa will have to have their own langar. When there is a langar, everyone in that langar has to have the same food and the same treatment. Special food cannot be given to anyone. Doing so violates the entire purpose and principle of langar. Langar in general should be prepared according to puratan sarbloh bibeki maryada. Where it is not (which is almost always the case), Sarblohi Singhs usually make their own langar. That other langar is a langar just like any other and is open to anyone (whether sarblohi or not). It might be questionable if the Sarblohi Singhs sit in their rooms and eat apart like that, but in this case, there was a langar where anyone could come. If you look at the picture from Khalsa Camp of the langar, you'll see that not just-Sarblohi Singhs are eating in that room. So, it would be wrong to get different food in the same hall and receive differential treatment. It would go against everything the langar stands for.

Re: langar

singh · 27 Nov 2005

yeh but no one told us we could cum.loads of us neva even new there was a seperate langar. they shodve jus et with us

Re: langar

MOW · 27 Nov 2005

but if bh kulbir singh and crew sat with you guys, you would you have complained that he had different langar to you!

Re: langar

LOL! · 28 Nov 2005

Author: MOW Date: 11-27-05 10:28 but if bh kulbir singh and crew sat with you guys, you would you have complained that he had different langar to you! --- See its not about petty little points like that, Maharaaj started Langar so that one and all would sit together, even if some Sangat have food which is prepared differently according to their Rehit; is it not still Maharaaj’s Langar? Fair enough different people prepare food in different ways according to the Rehit one may follow, but what’s the need to sit separately, does that not defy the point of everyone sitting together? Phul Chuk Muaf.

Re: langar

Nihang Singh · 28 Nov 2005

Sitting it a different room is wrong, If one is sarbloh Bibek, theys no need to eat in a different room. Ones Food should be cooked in Sarbloh and one could have ate the Langar in the Same Room. About the Kulbir and friends eating different stuff from the rest of the sangat is rubbish, they could have had the same langar but made in Sarbloh. This would have been a good time to teach people about Sarbloh Bibek and the values of being Bibek.

Re: langar

singh · 28 Nov 2005

right, u suggesting that the food shouldve been brought from the kitchen that the sarbloh langar was made to the main langar hall ( about a 3 minute walk) so evry tym some 1 wanted a roti they wud have to walk 3 mins to go and get it and three mins bak??? it wasnt practical and the sarbloh cudnt have been cooked im same place (not enuff space, cookers, etc.) so thereforethe singhs had to eat in the room where the langar was being made, rather than sabji and roti being carried over from the other kitchen on the other side of the site stop moaning anyways

Re: langar

LOL! · 28 Nov 2005

Just because something has been questioned it does not mean that anyone is moaning. I’m sure if the tables were turned people would be quick to say it’s not right to change Maryada or something is happening due to ‘dhill’ on the persons part. Ok there was a time/place inconvenience but would it really have been THAT hard to have Langar with the rest of the Sangat? I’m not complaining about what happened as people like Bhai Kulbir Singh etc know better than myself, I just want to know whether its right to have Langar separately when everyone is having Langar..

Re: langar

singh · 28 Nov 2005

let's go over the facts again: 1) The one kitchen could not be used to accomodate the sarbloh langar. 2) The kitchens were about a 5 mintue walk apart. 3) The Sarblohi Singhs couldn't eat at the main langar because the food wasnt' prepared according to sarbloh bibek maryada (which at any rate should be the maryada for all langars). 4) It is against the principle of any langar to have special food for any one person or group. 5) The "sarblohi langar" was open to all that chose to eat there, sarblohi, mona, or any other person. 6) Historically, there have been two langars (Guru Keeaa(n) Sakheaa(n))BUT never has there been special treatment given to anyone in the langar. If someone wants to continue, ignoring all these points, and say, "yeah..but...they still should've eaten with everyone else", it's just insisting "I'm right and I don't care what the facts are".

Re: langar

Sense · 28 Nov 2005

Maybe the sarblohi singhs could have prepared all langar for everyone in sarbloh, that way all could eat together but only sarbloh bibeki singhs do langar seva, if that is an acceptable alternative then keep it in mind for next time all get together for chardi kala of panth.

Re: langar

Single Singh - still single · 28 Nov 2005

Wow this is really making me hungry................

Re: langar

Admin · 28 Nov 2005

The issue has been discussed now at length. Topic is closed. If there are general concerns about langar or anyother issue, a separate topic can be created.