Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

kurehits

kurehits

the edison twins · 27 Nov 2005

a question for those who knoe... if someone committs a kurehit, and they are sincere in learning from it and they feel bad about it and get pesh, is the saja from the panj alone enough, or should the kurheti person need to in a sense 'repay his debt' and go above and beyond to society/guru for what he did, because he feels that the shame of the kurheit is unacceptable....? i guess theres two scenarios. person A committs a kurehit and feels bad and gets pesh and continues their normal amritdhari life then theres person B who feels guilt and feels that because of his mistake, he owes it to the guru to repay him by doing alot of extra seva/paath/simran, as a sort of 'punishment' if you will. some people do a kurehit and feel guilt and shame and feel they cannot live a regular life....but what truly shows the real sign of sincerity in it...? anyone have any comments....?

Re: kurehits

singh · 27 Nov 2005

I'm divided on the issue. If someone commits a kurehit, they can be forgiven by the Punj Pyare and given amrit again. But at the same time, they can never do seva in Punj Pyare after that point. So is it total forgiveness? It serves as a warning to all amritdharis never to make such a mistake. If someone has done it, then maybe it was in their karma. There's no point in dwelling on it now. Do extra bani and naam and try to move past the mistake. Guru Sahib is forgiving and I believe that if someone sincerely lives their lives as a Gursikh after making such a mistake, it will not be held against them.

Re: kurehits

ekta · 27 Nov 2005

if amrit is re-birth then how can a ex-khurethi not do seva of punj? does that mean western sikhs who are born christians and become khalsa cannot be punj.....blasphemy and bologny thats what that is.

Re: kurehits

singh · 27 Nov 2005

Ekta, Someone can do every single kurehit multiple times before chakking amrit, BUT, if they become amritdhari and then do a kurehit, they can be forgiven by the punj pyare at their discretion, but they cannot do seva in the punj pyare. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh has written this in "Amrit Kee Hai". If a bata gets a hole, it can be filled, but the scar never goes away. I wish people would try to understand and reflect before they start going on about "blasphemy and blogny" (blogne).

Re: kurehits

ekta · 27 Nov 2005

i dunno man...that means one is truley not forgiven.

Re: kurehits

Guruvah · 28 Nov 2005

Singh jee, Dass has read the book ''Amrit Kee Hai''.Can u let me know at which page does it say this,and are there any rehitnameh supporting.Just curious as I *MIGHT* have missed the page where Bhai Sahib mentions this.Also,personally I do believe Guru Sahib is like a Mother,no matter how much disgracefull a childs action may be...but when he comes to his mother(Guru Sahib) and ask for forgiveness...A mother forgets(the mistakes) takes the Child in her arms...... If there is no forgiveness in the House of Guru Nanak Dev Sahib Maharaj...........then where would a sikh go? Guru Ang Sang.....

Re: kurehits

Pulsar · 28 Nov 2005

True .. how can oen be forgiven if you are considered as a stain, therefore you arre nor forgiven, i personaly don't think it matters as long as the person has moved forward and and now has a high jeevan , Gankika was a prostitute she got liberation did she have amrit ???, sujjan tag was a muderer, ajamal was a proper paapi player he got liberation by saying his sons name. If Guru ji forgive he forgives properley not half hearted

Re: kurehits

:) · 28 Nov 2005

Singh, if the scar never goes away, you used the bata as an analogy, then you are not truly forgiven. I don't think I agree with this. The Panj are the roop of Guru Sahib, so if Guru Sahib can forgive us for our mistakes, why should there be any scars left?