Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Panj singh Langar???

Panj singh Langar???

Sohan Singh · 28 Nov 2005

Vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fathe Can somone give detials of where the reet of giving pnaj singh langar has come from??? If asked to do this seva should one accept?? if this is gurmat then what is the correct marayda??? Vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fathe

Re: Panj singh Langar???

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Nov 2005

As it is performed today by most sikhs......I beleive this is an extension of the way a Brahmin Prohit was treated in the past. Hindus used to call in a Brahmin Pandit, feed him the best foods, give him a monetary gift...clothes etc etc and sometimes even a milk bearing cow etc...for his "prayers" in return....or that whatever fed to him or given to him would "reach" their dearly departed...blah blah blah. Many sikh families do this same "ritual" of feeding Five Singhs/ give them a monetary gift of 11/21/51/101/501/1001/ as the case may be/a set of dastaar/clothes etc etc...and then tell the Singhs to perform an ardass ( for whatever reason)...I should know since i was asked to do these ardasses many a time and its always..bless us with a son since we have so many daughters, a decent daughter in law..a good son in law.. soemone has been sick all the time..ask for good health..a good result in exams....blah blah blah. I have since stopped attending such and decline such invites. In our area it is "so difficult" to find five "Singhs"...that most of the time "any one will do" is followed......and in that case ONLY the "GRANTHI" will be able to do any paath/ardass as the other four can hardly speak punjabi much less do any paath !!they are roped in just to make up the magic number five !! MY personal opinion is that it would be far more as per GURMAT to do langgar sewa in Guru ka Langgar at the Gurdwara - just put in whatever amount one can afford - the sangat's ardass would be much more effective than a single person's. Gareeb da MOOH gURU dEE gOLUK....FEED SOME LESS PRIVILEGED PERSONS..WOULD ALSO BE AS PER GURMATT. apologies if anyone is offended.

Re: Panj singh Langar???

help me · 29 Nov 2005

But are there any references to this practise in history???

Re: Panj singh Langar???

NirVair Khalsa · 29 Nov 2005

I was recently asked to do this sewa of being in 5 Singhs for 5 Singh Langar. I did it as I did not want to decline sewa and they needed AmritDhari Singhs. This was my experience: The family made lavish foods, which was really filling and I definitely ate too much. But I didnt want to let the family down as they had put so much effort in preparing the food and they insisted on me having more. The Giani did Ardaas before the food was served and also afterwards. The family asked for good health of one of their sons, as he is always ill. The Giani did this Ardaas after the food had been served. My overall impression was that it felt like a very Brahmin-Vaad thing to do. The 2 Gianis, who were in the Panj, got cloth for new Kurta-Pyjamas and money. The other 3 of us got some money, but not as much as the Gianis. We put our money in the Golak. The actions of the Giani reminded me of what Brahmins did and they use this institution for self-serving purposes. As we left, me and another Singh told the family to Jap Naam and start doing Paath regularly, as this is the best way to become closer to Waheguru. We then spoke to the Gurudwara Parbandhaks. We put forward our concerns to them and how we felt that the whole setup was drifting towards BrahminVaad. We put forward the following suggestions: - Ideally, if the family wants to serve the Sangat, they should take Langar seva in the Guru Ghar. - If they haven't got capacity to serve the whole Sangat, then when serving 5 Singhs, they should prepare the food whilst reciting Bani and doing Simran. - It should be emphasised that the family themselves join with the Guru and follow Gurmat and Rehit. Serving 5 Singhs is not enough; each Sikh must establish their own relationship with Guru Sahib. - Each Singh should be treated equally in the Panj in the future. Giani should not gain extra favours. Committee-Wale were sympathetic to our views. Hopefully we'll see some action on this in the future.

Re: Panj singh Langar???

Parsad · 29 Nov 2005

What is this system about why do we do it??? how are the five selected ?? why jus five singhs??? didi Guru gobind singh start this system ?? are the five singhs who eat roti representing Guru ??

Re: Panj singh Langar???

Karnail Singh Barshi. · 29 Nov 2005

This is no way a criticism, but just some thoughts. <<<< The family made lavish foods, which was really filling >>> This was their prem, nothing wrong in that. <<< I definitely ate too much.>>> This is your own fault, you should have been more assertive. <<< My overall impression was that it felt like a very Brahmin-Vaad thing to do. >>> The shakaing of langar to panj sikh is an honour, for the guru resides in the panj. It is sad that you think this is another Brahmin-vaad reet. <<< The 2 Gianis, who were in the Panj, got cloth for new Kurta-Pyjamas and money. The other 3 of us got some money, but not as much as the Gianis. We put our money in the Golak. >>> If you were not going to take the money or any other gifts then why does it bother you that the gianis got more? <<< The actions of the Giani reminded me of what Brahmins did and they use this institution for self-serving purposes. >>> The gianis did not twist anyone’s arm to do the langar, the family presumably did it because they wanted an ardaas done for their ill child, nothing wrong in that. They could have gone and got a taga or taweet, or got some jantar mantar done but instead they had faith in their Guru and sought his blessing. <<< As we left, me and another Singh told the family to Jap Naam and start doing Paath regularly, as this is the best way to become closer to Waheguru. >>> This is good, if the gianis did not do this then they are at fault. They should have sat the family down and told then to do naam simran. <<< - Ideally, if the family wants to serve the Sangat, should take Langar seva in the Guru Ghar. - If they haven't got capacity to serve the whole Sangat, then when serving 5 Singhs, they should prepare the food whilst reciting Bani and doing Simran. - It should be emphasised that the family themselves join with the Guru and follow Gurmat and Rehit. Serving 5 Singhs is not enough; each Sikh must establish their own relationship with Guru Sahib. - Each Singh should be treated equally in the Panj in the future. Giani should not gain extra favours. >>>>> Good suggestions. [%sig%]