Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

why cant you wear red HELP!!!

why cant you wear red HELP!!!

H · 29 Nov 2005

why cant you wear red?? in gurbani does it mention anything about it ??

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

singh ji · 29 Nov 2005

khalsa has a uniform that guru sahib gave us blue, black, white and kesri are the khalsa colours green and red are the colours of the mughals and the hindus

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

. · 29 Nov 2005

singh ji - where in Guru Sahib's bani is red and green banned? i can understand that they would be banned during battle time, when hindus wear red and muslim wear green, but today when theres no war?

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Karnail Singh Barshi. · 29 Nov 2005

Blue - agreed. Keseri - agreed. White - agreed. It may be popular and some jathas make like it, but where does it say that black is a sikh colour ? [%sig%]

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

singh ji · 29 Nov 2005

Blue, Black, White and Saffron These four colours are to be worn. Other colours excite the mind and lure it to vices, and are therefore prohibited. Amritdhari Singhs/Singhni’s are specifically not to wear red or green at anytime. One is to dress humbly, any simple colours can be worn. http://www.damdamitaksal.com/lit_rehat_17.htm

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

vichar · 29 Nov 2005

. sed - "singh ji - where in Guru Sahib's bani is red and green banned? i can understand that they would be banned during battle time, when hindus wear red and muslim wear green, but today when theres no war?" well '. ji' where in guru granth sahib does it say to wear 5 kakkars, do keshi isnaan, comb hair twice a day etc etc????

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

thug life · 29 Nov 2005

black is a shia' colour, nihangsinghs refuse to wear it, askem

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

... · 29 Nov 2005

wer does it say any colour is acceptable? we just assume these colours are cuz the khalsa wore them unless their a quote from bani that say some colours are forbidden with reason then people will stop arguing

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

ghetto · 29 Nov 2005

colours lure the mind? abit narrow minded dont u fink ?

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Single Singh - still single · 29 Nov 2005

Now what about Sikhs in the Army and what about people who need to wear a work uniform that requires a red shirt?????????????

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

simple singhani · 29 Nov 2005

i thought we just weren't allowed to wear red because it makes people think of lustful thoughts etc. but whats green about??

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Sehajvir Singh · 29 Nov 2005

Just wondering is it written in the rehit maryada about not wearing these colors?

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

learning Singh · 29 Nov 2005

The PANTHIC Sikh Rehat Maryada, approved and passed by SRI AKAAL TAKHT SAHIB, the Sikh's supreme authority does not MENTION or ENDORSE Colour Rehat on Panth. Yes. Kesri, White, Blue, and Black are TRADITIONAL Khalsa colours. Just as red, white and blue are TRADITIONAL british colours corresponding to the the british flag

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Jasmin · 29 Nov 2005

If you can't wear red because its too exciting, then why kesri? I mean kesri also seems like a simulating color. I understand blue and white, through. For one thing their calm colors. When I was 8 and insisted on keeping kesh, I told my parents I was in the wrong place. I said that I was living with them by accident, and I come from people who keep hair. I associated blue and white with growing hair, and the color red with the "others" people that would cut hair very short. For many years I believed I was just an imaginative child ---- and now I'm thinking------has to be past life memory. I didn't learn about Sikhs till junior high. Even then I didn't learn that much. What about pink? Its a form of red, but so diluted, does it matter? What about purple or lavender? How is a simple color defined? If some say black is not good, what of grey?

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

LionKing (LK) · 29 Nov 2005

Author: vichar Date: 11-29-05 09:12 . sed - "singh ji - where in Guru Sahib's bani is red and green banned? i can understand that they would be banned during battle time, when hindus wear red and muslim wear green, but today when theres no war?" well '. ji' where in guru granth sahib does it say to wear 5 kakkars, do keshi isnaan, comb hair twice a day etc etc???? ***************************** I think they were talking about Dasam Granth, as that is when most of the battles occured (accept 6-7th Guru Ji times) It seems, to me tha tth reason those colors were banend by SIKHS was that during the time, muslims used Green, and hindus used red - tha's it - ther is NO other reason, unless you can support it by anything in GURU SAHIB or Sri Dasam Granth - thne there's no debate out it. Today if it's more practicle being in jungle wearing Green dastar, wil you wear Green or kesri so that enemies can spot u from afar distance?

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

singh · 29 Nov 2005

i tink it is to do with red being a colour of SHAME and a colour of SLAVERY...... along with wearin a patka and wearing earings, which were worn by slaves bak in the day.

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Singh · 29 Nov 2005

The reason is that the Khalsa is Akaal Purakh's army. An army has a uniform and standar issue gear. The four colours are the colours the army sticks to. White kacherra is what is the traiditional. Red and Green have different reasons to wear or not wear, but simply put, they're not part of the uniform. If you have to wear it according to a work uniform, then so be it. It's not a bujjer kurehit to wear either.

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

singh · 29 Nov 2005

the sgpc rehit maryada does not mention that a sikh cannot wear red or green...other parchalat rehit maryadas do, such as the damdami taksal's (which is linked above). as far as gurbani goes, gurbani does not state that a particular color should or should not be worn, but it does state that that emotions evoked by colors can all be found in naam...those who have naam and become engulfed in the "rang" of waheguru, are the fortunate and for them the "rang" of naam never fades...all other "colors" fade. (taken from two shabads..."lal rang tis ko lagaa" - sggs 808 and "ram rang kadhe utar na jai" - sggs 194) it seems that guru sahib doesnt say one color is better or worst that another, but does teach that colors are indiffernt...in front of the color/rang that naam can create. as for the three/four colors mentioned being "sikh" colors...color is used to unify people and bring a common identity. The sikh identity is manifested in blue, white, and orange/saffron - these colors are meant to unify sikhs thats my half a loon worth of insight... fateh ji

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Manjot Kaur · 29 Nov 2005

The colors of the Khalsa uniform all have a meaning that go with them Orange- Chardi Kala White- Peace Blue+Black- Can't remember now Some mahapurkhs don't like black/red because it's usually used to symbolize evil (think devil;satan;demons;etc)

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Kulwinder Singh · 30 Nov 2005

You Can ! Read below, No need for me to say anything. Look at Sikhitothemax for Punjabi text as well Guru Arjan Dev Ji Raag Aasaa 384 ========================================== <> siqgur pRswid ] ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh || One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: rwgu Awsw Gru 7 mhlw 5 ] raag aasaa ghar 7 mehalaa 5 || Raag Aasaa, Seventh House, Fifth Mehl: lwlu colnw qY qin soihAw ] laal cholanaa thai than sohiaa || That red dress looks so beautiful on your body. suirjn BwnI qW mnu moihAw ]1] surijan bhaanee thaa(n) man mohiaa ||1|| Your Husband Lord is pleased, and His heart is enticed. ||1|| kvn bnI rI qyrI lwlI ] kavan banee ree thaeree laalee || Whose handiwork is this red beauty of yours? kvn rMig qUM BeI gulwlI ]1] rhwau ] kavan ra(n)g thoo(n) bhee gulaalee ||1|| rehaao || Whose love has rendered the poppy so red? ||1||Pause|| qum hI suMdir qumih suhwgu ] thum hee su(n)dhar thumehi suhaag || You are so beautiful; you are the happy soul-bride. qum Gir lwlnu qum Gir Bwgu ]2] thum ghar laalan thum ghar bhaag ||2|| Your Beloved is in your home; good fortune is in your home. ||2|| qUM sqvMqI qUM prDwin ] thoo(n) sathava(n)thee thoo(n) paradhhaan || You are pure and chaste, you are most distinguished. qUM pRIqm BwnI quhI sur igAwin ]3] thoo(n) preetham bhaanee thuhee sur giaan ||3|| You are pleasing to Your Beloved, and you have sublime understanding. ||3|| pRIqm BwnI qW rMig gulwl ] preetham bhaanee thaa(n) ra(n)g gulaal || I am pleasing to my Beloved, and so I am imbued with the deep red color. khu nwnk suB idRsit inhwl ]4] kahu naanak subh dhrisatt nihaal ||4|| Says Nanak, I have been totally blessed with the Lord's Glance of Grace. ||4|| suin rI sKI ieh hmrI Gwl ] sun ree sakhee eih hamaree ghaal || Listen, O companions: this is my only work; pRB Awip sIgwir svwrnhwr ]1] rhwau dUjw ]1]52] prabh aap seegaar savaaranehaar ||1|| rehaao dhoojaa ||1||52|| God Himself is the One who embellishes and adorns. ||1||Second Pause||1||52|| [%sig%]

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Kulwinder Singh · 30 Nov 2005

Another one ! Guru Arjan Dev Ji Raag Soohee 739 The meaning of Soohab is Red ! the Colour of the bride. Again no need for me to say anything. ================================================ sUhI mhlw 5 ] soohee mehalaa 5 || Soohee, Fifth Mehl: lwlnu rwivAw kvn gqI rI ] laalan raaviaa kavan gathee ree || How have you enjoyed your Dear Beloved? sKI bqwvhu muJih mqI rI ]1] sakhee bathaavahu mujhehi mathee ree ||1|| O sister, please teach me, please show me. ||1|| sUhb sUhb sUhvI ] Apny pRIqm kY rMig rqI ]1] rhwau ] soohab soohab soohavee || apanae preetham kai ra(n)g rathee ||1|| rehaao || Crimson, crimson, crimson - this is the color of the soul-bride who is imbued with the Love of her Beloved. ||1||Pause|| pwv mlovau sMig nYn BqIrI ] paav malovo sa(n)g nain bhatheeree || I wash Your Feet with my eye-lashes. jhw pTwvhu jWau qqI rI ]2] jehaa pat(h)aavahu jaa(n)o thathee ree ||2|| Wherever You send me, there I will go. ||2|| jp qp sMjm dyau jqI rI ] jap thap sa(n)jam dhaeo jathee ree || I would trade meditation, austerity, self-discipline and celibacy, iek inmK imlwvhu moih pRwnpqI rI ]3] eik nimakh milaavahu mohi praanapathee ree ||3|| if I could only meet the Lord of my life, for even an instant. ||3|| mwxu qwxu AhMbuiD hqI rI ] maan thaan aha(n)budhh hathee ree || She who eradicates her self-conceit, power and arrogant intellect, sw nwnk sohwgvqI rI ]4]4]10] saa naanak sohaagavathee ree ||4||4||10|| O Nanak, is the true soul-bride. ||4||4||10||

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

singh2 · 30 Nov 2005

singh who wrote this"as far as gurbani goes, gurbani does not state that a particular color should or should not be worn" i totally agree with your whole post

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

KS · 30 Nov 2005

I seem to remember that during various katha I learned that during Guru Hargobind Sahib Jee's time, the moghul emperor banned people from wearing a dastar. The exception to this ban was that a red pag could be worn, hence red pags worn by the brahmins (hindus) - now diluted to various shades of pink etc. The brahmins accepted this ban and chose to wear red pags as a symbol of slavery under the moghul rule. On the other hand the Sikhs , under the Guruship of Guru Hargobind Sahib Jee did not accept this ban and it was declared by Guru Hargobind Sahib Jee that if the moghuls are banning the people from wearing a dastaar then from now on the Sikhs would wear two dastaars, hence the rehat followed by meany Gursikhs upto today. Conclusion - my understanding is that the colour red was imposed as a colour of slavery by the moghuls which was never accepted by the Sikhs. [%sig%]

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Rainbow · 30 Nov 2005

I think the statements that colours can invoke feelings (lust etc) is rather lame explanations. The way in which a colour impacts a person (i.e when someone says to the other "that colour looks good on you") differs between each person. What looks good on me will not be true of another person..... I appreciate that signifcance of saffron, white and blue as Sikh colours of identity but the constant statements that "you can't wear red etc" are really naive. We can wear what colour we chose to but clearly we need to be mindful of the Sikh identity colours and adorne them as appropriate. I think that saffron and blue are particularly lovely colours but does that mean I have lustful thoughts about them? The answer is derrr.... no!

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

safety s · 30 Nov 2005

ermm people woul djust like to add that Black and White are not official colours! They are the lightest shade possible and the darkest but do not count as proper colours!

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

RoopKaur · 30 Nov 2005

The reason why Khalsa does not wear red is because it is the rehit of the Khalsa to not do so. THe traditions of the Khalsa are the four colours mentioned above. Just like you wont find other outer rehit in Gurbani, such as wearing white kacheraa, dohraa dastaaraa etc, likewise this rehit can only be found within the panth. The best way to find out Khalsa rehit is to do sangat with Khalsa, and you will learn much of the seena baseena rehit that are being lost today.

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Kulwinder Singh · 30 Nov 2005

Just for you Roop Kaur Ji , I have already posted this in english fonts up but though let's make more easy for other readers too. ਰਾਗੁ ਆਸਾ ਘਰੁ 7 ਮਹਲਾ 5 ॥ ਲਾਲੁ ਚੋਲਨਾ ਤੈ ਤਨਿ ਸੋਹਿਆ ॥ ਸੁਰਿਜਨ ਭਾਨੀ ਤਾਂ ਮਨੁ ਮੋਹਿਆ ॥1॥ ਕਵਨ ਬਨੀ ਰੀ ਤੇਰੀ ਲਾਲੀ ॥ ਕਵਨ ਰੰਗਿ ਤੂੰ ਭਈ ਗੁਲਾਲੀ ॥1॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ ਤੁਮ ਹੀ ਸੁੰਦਰਿ ਤੁਮਹਿ ਸੁਹਾਗੁ ॥ ਤੁਮ ਘਰਿ ਲਾਲਨੁ ਤੁਮ ਘਰਿ ਭਾਗੁ ॥2॥ ਤੂੰ ਸਤਵੰਤੀ ਤੂੰ ਪਰਧਾਨਿ ॥ ਤੂੰ ਪ੍ਰੀਤਮ ਭਾਨੀ ਤੁਹੀ ਸੁਰ ਗਿਆਨਿ ॥3॥ ਪ੍ਰੀਤਮ ਭਾਨੀ ਤਾਂ ਰੰਗਿ ਗੁਲਾਲ ॥ ਕਹੁ ਨਾਨਕ ਸੁਭ ਦ੍ਰਿਸਟਿ ਨਿਹਾਲ ॥4॥ ਸੁਨਿ ਰੀ ਸਖੀ ਇਹ ਹਮਰੀ ਘਾਲ ॥ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਆਪਿ ਸੀਗਾਰਿ ਸਵਾਰਨਹਾਰ ॥1॥ ਰਹਾਉ ਦੂਜਾ ॥1॥52॥ ======================== ਸੂਹੀ ਮਹਲਾ 5 ॥ ਲਾਲਨੁ ਰਾਵਿਆ ਕਵਨ ਗਤੀ ਰੀ ॥ ਸਖੀ ਬਤਾਵਹੁ ਮੁਝਹਿ ਮਤੀ ਰੀ ॥1॥ ਸੂਹਬ ਸੂਹਬ ਸੂਹਵੀ ॥ ਅਪਨੇ ਪ੍ਰੀਤਮ ਕੈ ਰੰਗਿ ਰਤੀ ॥1॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ ਪਾਵ ਮਲੋਵਉ ਸੰਗਿ ਨੈਨ ਭਤੀਰੀ ॥ ਜਹਾ ਪਠਾਵਹੁ ਜਾਂਉ ਤਤੀ ਰੀ ॥2॥ ਜਪ ਤਪ ਸੰਜਮ ਦੇਉ ਜਤੀ ਰੀ ॥ ਇਕ ਨਿਮਖ ਮਿਲਾਵਹੁ ਮੋਹਿ ਪ੍ਰਾਨਪਤੀ ਰੀ ॥3॥ ਮਾਣੁ ਤਾਣੁ ਅਹੰਬੁਧਿ ਹਤੀ ਰੀ ॥ ਸਾ ਨਾਨਕ ਸੋਹਾਗਵਤੀ ਰੀ ॥4॥4॥10॥ ਸਾ ਨਾਨਕ ਸੋਹਾਗਵਤੀ ਰੀ ॥4॥4॥10॥

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Manjot Kaur · 30 Nov 2005

Uhmm ... Soul-bride for the husband lord is like a purre gursikh. Red is also worn traditionally in weddings. Henceforth binding the 'human' with the husband lord and another human for present terms with the laavan. Blue,Kesri,and white are the colors that are worn by a tyaar bar tyaar sikh. Surre some people wear a little bit of red...but not a fully red suit. Bana is traditionally orange/blue/white. Try finding a traditional gursikh wearing a red 'bana'

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Sehajvir Singh · 30 Nov 2005

Ok I would like to know where is written in the rehitnaama of bhai chaupa singh and other puratan rehtnamay that we can't wear these colors. I am not saying it is right or wrong. I personally don't care to wear particual colors i'm good wearing my fav colors which happen to be in this order, white, black, kesri and khalsa blue. But i don't like to belive unless their is solid proof or gut intincts telling me to believe. Maybe bhai KULBIR singh can shed some light on this. I personally don't think it is wrong to wear any color.

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Sher b SIngh · 30 Nov 2005

infact, Guruji also stated in asa ki war that blue is also the colour of muslim, Neel Vastar Le Kappre Pehrey , Turk Pathanee Amal Keeya: Men began to wear blue robes and garments; Turks and Pat'haans assumed power. and also , Neel Vastar Pehar hoi parvaan : Wearing blue robes, they seek the approval of the Muslim rulers. Accepting bread from the Muslim rulers, they still worship the Puraanas. They eat the meat of the goats, killed after the Muslim prayers are read over them,

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

... · 30 Nov 2005

Blue *IS* A Khalsa Colour I applaud Bhai Amritpal Singh Amrit for his analysis of Snatani practices. But as they say, we shouldn’t, "throw the baby out with the bath-water". I was concerned to see him try to dismiss Blue as a Khalsa colour. Blue has traditionally been worn by the Khalsa along with orange and white. Black is also acceptable but became popular later on. I will try to give a preliminary reply to his article here Muslims & Blue I and some other Singhs were discussing Bhai Amrit’s article on blue clothes and one Singh asked why “neel bastar” were described as being Muslim colours and why the Khalsa now wears neela. Muslims are not discerned by blue clothes now. In the past Muslim dress has always thought to have been green (haideri) and Muslim Ghazis are known to wear Green clothing. Why does Gurbani say neela? A Singh from Kashmir (Poonch) was sitting with us and he said that where he is from, the locals call green “neela”. They call green chilis not “haree mirch” but “neelee mirch” they call green grass “neela ghaa”. This explains it. For people of that area (mainly Muslims), neela meant not blue, but green. What Did Guru Gobind Singh Wear? There has been an attempt to say that Guru Gobind Singh jee only wore blue when leaving the forest in Macchiwara. The oldest account of Guru Gobind Singh jee and the formation of the Khalsa is the Bhatt Vehis. What do the Bhatt Vehis say about what Guru Sahib wore when the Khalsa was created? The Bhatt Vehi "Multani Sindhi Pargana Thanaysar" is described by Piara Singh Padam as the oldest account of this event : >>>>>>>>>>> "Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji, tenth Guru, son of Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji, in the year 1752 on Tuesday-the Vaisakhi day-gave Khande ki pahul to five Sikhs and surnamed them as Singhs. First Daya Ram Sopti, Khatri resident of Lahore stood up. Then Mohkam Chand Calico printer of Dawarka; Sahib Chand barber of Zafrabad city; Dharam Chand Jawanda Jat of Hastinapur; Himmat Chand water carrier of Jagannath stop up one after the other. All were dressed in blue and he himself also dressed the same way. Hookah, halaal, hajaamat, haraam, tikka, janeu, dhoti were prohibited. Socialisation with the descendants of Prithi Chand, followers of Dhirmal and Ram Rai, clean shaven people and Masands was prohibited. All were given Kangha, Karad, Kesgee, Karhaa, and Kacheraa. All were made Keshdhaaree. Everyone’s place of birth was told to be Patna, of residence as Anandpur. Rest, Guru’s deeds are known only to the Guru. Repeat Guru Guru, the Guru will help everywhere >>>>>>>>>> So blue was the colour the Khalsa was first given according to the oldest source. Bhai Amritpal Singh has said: >>>>>>>> Furthermore, when Guru Gobind Singh Ji left for his heavenly abode, he was also in saffron ('Kesree') attire. 'Gur Bilaas Paatshaahee 10' written by Bhai Kuyer Singh clearly mentions the colour of Guru Ji's clothing, when he left for the 'Sachkhand': - Aap Snaan Karyo Sah Kesan, Kesree Khyom Patam Pahraaye. From the foregoing analysis of various texts, we can conclude that Guru Gobind Singh Ji wore clothing of various colours and that to assert that he wore only blue attire after the inauguration of the Khalsa in 1699 is wholly incorrect. >>>>>>>>>>>>>> No one denies that kesri is an acceptable colour. Punj Pyaaray today generally are all dressed in kesri robes. Kesri is considered a royal colour. The fact that Guru Gobind Singh jee was wearing kesri only says that kesri is an acceptable colour for the Sikhs as well, not that blue is not special or unacceptable (as the article seems to suggest). What would surprise me would be if Bhai Amritpal Singh could show me any reference to Dashmesh Pita jee wearing something besides Blue, White, Kesri or Black. That would be a find. Clearly, Blue was a special and acceptable colour of the Khalsa. Guru Gobind Singh jee being royalty, wore kesri as well (as our royal Punj Pyaaray still do today). This is not a surprise, but to be expected. Puraatan Sikhs and Colours Amritpal Singh has provided the quotation about the dress of the sahibzadas: >>>>>>> the Sahibzadas were in fact in saffron (Kesaree) clothing: - Kesaree Ang Paushaak Mahaabar, Moorat Pekh Kahai Eh Baanee. >>>>>>> As I said before, Kesree is the royal colour for the Sikhs. It is no shock that the princely Sahibzadas would have worn this colour. What I do take issue with is Bhai Amrit’s next statement: >>>>>>>>>> Bhai Sukha Singh speaks of Sahibzada Ajit Singh Ji, the eldest son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji being called into the holy court of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. He comes to Guru Ji and Bhai Sukha Singh describes his attire as consisting of red ('Arun') shoes which were shining on Sahibzada Ajit Singh Ji's feet, a red shawl, a red shirt and a red turban which graceful upon his head. The original lines read as follows: - >>>>>>>>> The colour red has been forbidden amongst the Sikhs since the start. It is not an acceptable colour for Sikhs to wear. Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama tells us that those “who use colour prepared from red ochre or the kusumbha flower” are tankhaiyas. It says plainly, “Bastr kusunbhay na pehray” or “Do not wear clothing which is coloured red. ”(verse 23). Bhai Prehlad Singh rehitnama also tells us, “soohay anbar pehn kar jo naasay nasvar…” “He who wears red clothing, or inhales nasavar up his nose will be beaten about the head and thrown into hell” (verse 12). So how is it that this description of Baba Ajeet Singh jee came about? It must be asked, Who was Sukha Singh? The fact is that he NEVER SAW Sahibzada Baba Ajeet Singh jee. On what basis is he giving such a detailed description besides his own imagination? Sukha Singh was born in 1768 and wrote this in 1797. After a hundred years, how would he know what Baba jee was wearing? This is clearly his own literary imagination at work, not a statement of fact. Bhai Amrit has also given a description of Baba Gurbaksh Singh and the Singhs with him who became Shaheeds. He quotes Pracheen Panth Prakash as following: >>>>>>>>> Giani Gian Singh writes in 'Panth Prakash' that Bhai Gurbaksh Singh wore saffron clothing, when he went to fight: - Tan Dhare Bastar Kesree, Dastaar Ooch Sajaaye. (He wore saffron robes and tied a high turban). In 'Pracheen Panth Parkash', Ratan Singh Bhangu speaks of the colours worn by other Sikh companions of Bhai Gurbaksh Singh Ji: Kisai Pushaak Thee Neelee Sajaayee. Kinai Set, Kisai Kesaree Rangvaayee. >>>>>>>>> This is no big finding. It goes with what has always been known. White, Orange and Blue are all Khalsa colours. The story of Baba Gurbaksh Singh in Panth Parkash (Bhangu) actually begins with a saying "neel bastar rakh, reh rehit changee" meaning Baba jee wore blue clothes and kept good rehit. It doesn’t say here that they wore green or red. Only Orange, Blue and White. This is in complete accordance with Khalsa Tradition. What I do find interesting that Bhai Amrit has not taken note of is that Baba Gurbaksh Singh jee is said to have an "ooch" dastaar. Perhaps in those days these type of dastaars weren't called dumallas, but by any name, it is the same thing. Baba jee's dumalla had different chakars and a kirpan in it(according to Panth Parkash). Clearly, even if it wasn't called a dumalla, it was indeed a dumalla. This is in contrast to Bhai Amrit's assertion that dumalla did not exist in those days. I’m not much moved by the descriptions of Singhs in only kacherras and blankets. Singhs in those times had very little. Depending on the condition of the weather and their own economic condition, it is possible they wore very little. But that does not go to say that Sikh dress is no dress at all. Clearly this dress was functional for the circumstances. Even today some bana-wearing Singhs will wear only a fatoohee (short kurta) when they are training for gatka or some other circumstance, but that doesn’t mean this alone in isolation is the dress. Clearly when the went to Guru Sahib's darbar they were not dressed in just a kacherra. Proof of Special Nature of Blue Dress Blue dress is not something recently invented for the Khalsa. As mentioned before, Bhatt VEhis tell us that Guru Sahib himself dressed the Khalsa in Blue. Furthermore, the old vaar“Vah Vah Gobind Singh Aapay Gur Chela” we all sing, by Bhai Gurdas II, tells us about the creation of the Khalsa as well. inj pMQ clwieE Kwlsw Dir qyj krwrw] isr kys Dwir gih KVg ko sB dust pCwrw] sIl jq kI kC phir pkVo hiQAwrw] sc Pqy bulweI gurU kI jIiqE rx Bwrw] sB dYq Airin ko Gyr kir kIcY pRhwrw] qb sihjy pRgitE jgq mY guru jwp Apwrw] ieauN aupjy isMG BujMgIey nIl AMbr Dwrw] See the last line. It says that “thus the Bhujangi Singhs were created, dressed in blue”. The puritan Rehitnamas also tell us that Blue is a Khalsa colour. Bhai Daya Singh’s rehtinama tells us that a Khalsa colour is “surmaiee” or dark blue (verse 23). He goes on further to say , “So Akali rooop hai neel bastar dherai” or “An Akali is known by the blue garments he wears”. Clearly blue clothing was a special Khalsa colour! Rattan Singh Bhangu in Pracheen Panth Parkash writes about the differences that lead to the split between Baba Banda Singh and the Tat-Khalsa. In regards to the clothing issue, he writes that Baba Banda Singh wanted his soldiers to wear red, which was unacceptable to the traditionally blue wearing Khalsa: “nIl pihrn qy dUr krwXo] smrw sUhw sIs bMDwXo] meaning, “he tried to wean them away from blue. He made them tie red on their heads” The Khalsa would not give up blue and could not wear red, so a split occurred. This also flies against Bhai Amrit's assertion that the Tat-Khalsa only took on blue after the split. They clearly were wearing blue before. Thus you can see that the Khalsa did indeed wear blue clothing and considered it their “special” colour, not just one colour amongst many others. Blue is a traditional Khalsa colour and we should feel proud to wear it. Blue isn't the only acceptable colour. Orange, White and Black are fine as well. But I do think that Blue was perhaps the one most Khalsa preferred. Just because some Nihang Singhs do corrupt practices like Bhang does not mean we should dismiss everything about them. They do have many traditions preserved like bana, sarbloh, gatka, etc. These should be appreciated. I have not written this to be a comprehensive article in support of blue. That would require a lot more research and that is something I don’t have much time for at the moment, but I did want to give an answer to the article on blue clothing

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

LionKing (LK) · 01 Dec 2005

Author: RoopKaur Date: 11-30-05 12:09 The reason why Khalsa does not wear red is because it is the rehit of the Khalsa to not do so. THe traditions of the Khalsa are the four colours mentioned above. Just like you wont find other outer rehit in Gurbani, such as wearing white kacheraa, dohraa dastaaraa etc, likewise this rehit can only be found within the panth. The best way to find out Khalsa rehit is to do sangat with Khalsa, and you will learn much of the seena baseena rehit that are being lost today. ********** Roop Kaur - can you tell us WHY REHIT SAYS SO? could it be due to practicality of not being slaughters by your own brothers on a battle field? i.e uniform on battle field, because if it was sometihng permanent, then universal Gurbani would have mentioend it :)

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

amarjeet singh · 01 Dec 2005

red is not a gurmat colour

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

yes · 01 Dec 2005

please read all of these laal gulaal gehabaraa sachaa ra(n)g charraao || Like the poppies, they are dyed in the deep crimson color of Truthfulness. sachee bhagathee man laal thheeaa rathaa sehaj subhaae || In true devotion, the mind is dyed in the deep crimson color of the Lord's Love, with intuitive peace and poise. laal bheae soohaa ra(n)g maaeiaa || Instead of the pale color of Maya, I am imbued with the deep crimson color of the Lord's Love. laal cholanaa thai than sohiaa || That red dress looks so beautiful on your body. surijan bhaanee thaa(n) man mohiaa ||1|| Your Husband Lord is pleased, and His heart is enticed. ||1|| preetham bhaanee thaa(n) ra(n)g gulaal || I am pleasing to my Beloved, and so I am imbued with the deep red color. pir apanaa paaeiaa ra(n)g laal banaaeiaa ath miliou mithr chiraanae || I have obtained my Husband Lord, and I am dyed in the deep crimson color of His Love; after such a long time, I have met my Friend. ra(n)g thumaarai laal bheae hai raam naam ras maathae ||1|| They are dyed in the deep crimson color of Your Love, and they are intoxicated with the sublime essence of the Lord's Name. ||1|| gun haar thai paaeiaa ra(n)g laal banaaeiaa this habho kishh suha(n)dhaa || She, whom You have adorned with the necklace of virtue, and dyed in the deep crimson color of His Love - everything looks beautiful on her. thheevehi laalaa ath gulaalaa sabadh cheen gur meet(h)aa || You shall take on the deep and lasting red color of the poppy, contemplating the sweet Word of the Guru's Shabad. guramukh laalo laal hai jio ra(n)g majeet(h) sacharraao || The Gurmukh is the deepest crimson of crimson, dyed in the permanent color of the Lord's Love. yes.red is not gurmat(!)

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

gsingh · 02 Dec 2005

red is metaphoric in gurbani, means love (with guruji) ...is not literal guramukh laalo laal hai jio ra(n)g majeet(h) sacharraao || The Gurmukh is the deepest crimson of crimson, dyed in the permanent color of the Lord's Love. the deepest red = has the most love...permanent love, permanent colour [%sig%]

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

simple singhani · 02 Dec 2005

Is it gonna get in the way of ur goal to akal purakh..??????? If it was such a sin to wear red.. then our gurus would have told us that.. why are we makin a big deal out of the very small things.. i think we shud spend more time discussing important issues.. issues that actually have revelance and make a difference to our spiritual avastha.

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Jasmin · 02 Dec 2005

Sure, because red is a rather graphic discription of marriage, which is why it is often associated with marriage ceremonies.

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Harcharan Singh · 02 Dec 2005

Waheguru ji Ka Khasla Waheguru ji ki Fateh, To veerji/bhenji who wrote the descriptive/evidence based post at 22.49 11.30.05, thank you. This is the kind of evidence backed discussion we need rather uneducated, manmat, self justifying, anti'gurmat tradition opinions. I would like to talk with you if possible, my e-mail is [address removed], if you get a chance drop me a mail. This is not about what is right or wrong, this is about tradition and applies to people who wish to maintain the Khalsa tradition, to those who don't, thats fine. To add to the aforementioned post, Akali-Nihangs wear neela because according to their oral history, Guru Gobind Singh Ji ordered them to for practical and battle reasons. When injured, red (blood) cannot be identified on dark blue, it looks like sweat. On most other colours, red can be identified. This ensured the enemy never got a psychological advantage. Secondly, dark blue is a practical colour (esp in hard times), it does not show dirt/stains etc. It is also a somber colour. The word rang in Gurbani refers to mood/emotion, not colour. The reference to red in Gurbani is metaphorical, as in many other examples, the Guru's used common themes/beliefs of the time to give the populace something to relate to. Hindu brides traditionally wore red on their wedding day, traditionally this represents beauty, and the wife trying to look beautiful for her husband. Guru ji refers to the true red (acceptance of hukum), within us, which gurmukhs attain, and which looks beautiful to the eternal husband...Waheguru. In addition, historically (aside from the Sikh historical examples above), faranghi (foreigners) who visited Punjab during the Misl periods (mid to late 1700's) report only seeing Sikhs in blue attire and no other, they refer to a sea of blue. The few "original" paintings that exist of these old times also show Sardaars like Jassa Singh Ramgharia and various akalis dressed in blue and white only. Please read Sieks, tigers and thieves (Amandeep Singh Madra) for European observational references. Traditions start from somewhere, not all history can be wrong. To those who look to follow true Sikh role models (of Guru Gobind Singhs time and soon after)and maintain Khalsa tradition, there is more than enough evidence refering to Blue, Orange and White being Khalsa colours (black is not mentioned anywhere - this was a tradition started from Babbar Khalsa as far as I am aware). I knew Keshri was a Shaheed colour, but now I know the reason why - Thank you Waheguru for Guru's incomparable warrior saints like Baba Gurbaksh Singh Ji Shaheed - who turned Gurus words in to reality and gave no hopers like me a reason to believe the strength and power of Guru's kirpa. Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Harcharan Singh

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Sehajvir Singh · 02 Dec 2005

Thank you ... and Harcharn singh. I would personally like to say that your posts have enlightened me. And i am considering reviewing my stance on accepted colors, after i do further research of course. But apreciate your guys' posts.

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Kaur · 02 Dec 2005

taken from an old post by Balpreet Singh: The colour red has been forbidden amongst the Sikhs since the start. It is not an acceptable colour for Sikhs to wear. Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama tells us that those “who use colour prepared from red ochre or the kusumbha flower” are tankhaiyas. It says plainly, “Bastr kusunbhay na pehray” or “Do not wear clothing which is coloured red. ”(verse 23). Bhai Prehlad Singh rehitnama also tells us, “soohay anbar pehn kar jo naasay nasvar…” “He who wears red clothing, or inhales nasavar up his nose will be beaten about the head and thrown into hell” (verse 12). So how is it that this description of Baba Ajeet Singh jee came about? It must be asked, Who was Sukha Singh? The fact is that he NEVER SAW Sahibzada Baba Ajeet Singh jee. On what basis is he giving such a detailed description besides his own imagination? Sukha Singh was born in 1768 and wrote this in 1797. After a hundred years, how would he know what Baba jee was wearing? This is clearly his own literary imagination at work, not a statement of fact. Bhai Amrit has also given a description of Baba Gurbaksh Singh and the Singhs with him who became Shaheeds. He quotes Pracheen Panth Prakash as following: >>>>>>>>> Giani Gian Singh writes in 'Panth Prakash' that Bhai Gurbaksh Singh wore saffron clothing, when he went to fight: - Tan Dhare Bastar Kesree, Dastaar Ooch Sajaaye. (He wore saffron robes and tied a high turban). In 'Pracheen Panth Parkash', Ratan Singh Bhangu speaks of the colours worn by other Sikh companions of Bhai Gurbaksh Singh Ji: Kisai Pushaak Thee Neelee Sajaayee. Kinai Set, Kisai Kesaree Rangvaayee. >>>>>>>>> This is no big finding. It goes with what has always been known. White, Orange and Blue are all Khalsa colours. The story of Baba Gurbaksh Singh in Panth Parkash (Bhangu) actually begins with a saying "neel bastar rakh, reh rehit changee" meaning Baba jee wore blue clothes and kept good rehit. It doesn’t say here that they wore green or red. Only Orange, Blue and White. This is in complete accordance with Khalsa Tradition.

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

LionKing (LK) · 03 Dec 2005

There are many quotes in Guru Ji by Guru Nanak Dev ji that use the word HARA, so I see no reason Why Guru Ji would use the word neela, for green just have a search on srigranth.org on the word "green" you'll find loads of quote by Guru ji (Guru Nanak Dev Ji) that use the word HARA... As for red being banned - why so? okay, let's accept if ro for argument's sake - but coudl you tell me WHY? If it's something to do with Spirituality, It would be mentioned in Guru JI. If it's something to do with uniform - then it was due to practically in war. You wouldn't see any Singh wearing kesri during battle time, because you'd be easier to spot! Same way - Hindus wore red Muslism wore Green in battle for practicallity Singhs then wore other colors... If you've got any other reason why red is banned, then please let us know =)

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Kaur · 03 Dec 2005

Not all rehits are easy to understand on the Why level. What if someone asked you why as a Sikh you keep repeating one word over and over again. To the average person, this act of repitition may seem illogical, yet when a person knows the value of naam abhyaas they will keep doing it. The job of a Sikh is to obey rehit, which not wearing red clearly is (refer to the rehitnaamaa post). As for being in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, wear does it say we should wear panj kakaars? Or that we should comb our hair twice a day? NOWHERE! Now does that mean these actions are not imporatnat or have no significance?

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Kulwinder Singh · 04 Dec 2005

Dear Karu Ji, Very good argument you have put forward. Two points are raised in your comments, The first point you have raised is: 1. "What if someone asked you why as a Sikh you keep repeating one word over and over again. To the average person, this act of repetition may seem illogical, yet when a person knows the value of naam abhyaas they will keep doing it." Ans: The explanation is much more simpler then you think, repeating one word ( I am assuming you are talking about vaheguroo) is not repeated for the sake of it, it is repeated to make it as a routine in your life so that the emergence of GOD become automatic in your life, it is like teaching somebody how to drive a car, in order so they can drive car by themselves and go from one place to other without the need for an instructor to be with them in the start that instructor teach the trainee how to apply brakes, how to signal, how to do three point turn and how to do emergency brake …….. ….. , Now after the passing of driving test the responsibility of the instructor is completed and responsibility of the trainee start, now think if that trainee for next 10- 20 -40 60 -80-100 years keep on just practicing the Start, stop, giving indicators, doing stops for the sake of practice then this become a joke rather then what was intended to start with e.g. to make this trainee independent, so the process of Signalling, braking, stop and staring become automatic, but in this case it has become complete the opposite of that. Same thing with Nam Japna, it is repetition is required in the start to make it an automatic process, Like Nam Dev ji is saying do you regular work as required but the heart and mind should be linked non stop with GOD. The just repetition may have very mild benefits if done for the sake of doing repetition but the real benefits are when you become successful in achieving the automatic process. 2. “As for being in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, wear does it say we should wear panj kakaars? Or that we should comb our hair twice a day? NOWHERE! Now does that mean these actions are not importance or have no significance? “ ANS: Some things are traditions you are absolutely right on that, more over Some of the things are common sense, Some of the things are done because particular point in History it was required, Some things are done because they complement each other, Some things are done because some people feel great doing these things and it give them moral uplifting. But Guru Granth Sahib ji is our Guru and Everything else come second and Guru Sahib Comes first. The command of Guru Sahib is must and undisputed, Sikhs are very lucky to have a Guru Sahib which is 100% clear, 100% relevant, 100% Complete, 100% compatible to humanity, truly amazing, magnetic, Powerful, Simply Fantastic and above all THE MOST KIND GURU in the world. Guru Gobind Singh Ji gave us a most amazing and unique identity which till this day is unique. Part of this identity is a discipline which we follow as Rehit, ( let’s not go into debate about rehit , as there are number of arguments we can have on this), As Sikh We look at Shri Akal Takhat Sahib and take their guidance on rehit and which no Guru Sikh debate or at lease should not debate. The rehit is a discipline code which is their to make it easy for a human to become tuned in the Guru’s Way so they can make their life and after life success. ****** Your last line “! Now does that mean these actions are not importance or have no significance? “ ANS: The example you have given are keeping 5 Kakars and doing kesh sambahl both of these examples are absolutely crucial even today. Although some of the old traditions like keeping horses is no longer required or valid especially in western countries. Going Hunting use to be a great Sikh Tradition which is no longer valid. Getting good traditional Martial Art training (e.g Sashtar videya and getting expert in Kirpan, Neja , Bow and Areow ) was must for every Sikh which is no longer a must ( we all love learning Sashtar videya but not to a level which was a must in the olden days). Although Sikhs till this day have a very significant contribution in the Armed and police forces around the world. So Kaur Ji I hope this have cleared you doubts, As your points were very good I am still happy to provide even further discussion to this topic. [%sig%]

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

honestly · 05 Dec 2005

Honestly you'll rarely ever see a Sant or uchee avastha Khalsa Gurmukh wearing green or red. There *are* historical reasons for not wearing red as well as practical reasons including the effects colour can have on ones mind, and the impression this colour can give, but there are also historical reasons for why we do not wear red and if you think about it, most Gursikhs that are chardi kala will not be found wearing these colours. They just don't. Nihang Singh jathebandis don't wear it, same with Taksali people and many AKJ sangat people as well, even Tapoban people I would assume, & Nanaksar saintly people. Guru Jee's Bana was given to us for a reason, we should just respect it and respect the Khalsa colours I think we keep doubting every single thing & trying to use our own matt But most of us read no Bani what so ever So we have NO right to assume things and pull them out of no where Especially if we are going against the beliefs/practices of Chardi Kala Khalsa Gurmukhs or Bhagats or Sants in the past, who have asserted that these colours are not to be worn. Why do we still want to push it? Are we gonna die without wearing red? Does it matter? Why don't you just avoid wearing that stuff and move on with your life, try to do what you think is best. If you don't want to follow this maryada then you don't have to ji, it is upto you. Just please don't disrespect other people for following it because *you* may not know the whole truth . Sometimes *you* are not always right

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Lionking · 05 Dec 2005

Amazin post, Ia gree with you on most of it The last part on - Getting good traditional Martial Art training (e.g Sashtar videya and getting expert in Kirpan, Neja , Bow and Areow ) was must for every Sikh which is no longer a must ( we all love learning Sashtar videya but not to a level which was a must in the olden days). Although Sikhs till this day have a very significant contribution in the Armed and police forces around the world. I disagree here, a Sikh must be practised in Shastervidya - THere's apoint to the Kirpan - to use it, What you gonna do if you can't use it? thus it's essential for every SIkh to learn Shastarvidya, and be able to protect themself, and not just allow anyoen to pull the Kirpan out of your hand. Also in self decence Kirpan is last resort, untill last resort you'r mean tto use hand-to-hand battle, if sometihng happens. ******** Author: Kaur Date: 12-03-05 18:52 Not all rehits are easy to understand on the Why level. What if someone asked you why as a Sikh you keep repeating one word over and over again. To the average person, this act of repitition may seem illogical, yet when a person knows the value of naam abhyaas they will keep doing it. The job of a Sikh is to obey rehit, which not wearing red clearly is (refer to the rehitnaamaa post). As for being in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, wear does it say we should wear panj kakaars? Or that we should comb our hair twice a day? NOWHERE! Now does that mean these actions are not imporatnat or have no significance? *********** Bhai Kulwinder Singh ji has responded the significance. As for wearing Red, you wrote - ******* The job of a Sikh is to obey rehit, which not wearing red clearly is (refer to the rehitnaamaa post). ******* THe Job of the Sikh is to UNDERSTAND REHIT. to LOVE REHIT, to follow REHIT, which is according to Gurmat, which can be tested on the scale of our eternal Guru ji. Again, unless you can give me a reason why no to wear red, there is no reason why not to - yes the Rehitname Mention this, they also mention the bann of learning Farsi (which Our Guru ji did himself!!!), Rehitnamey also mention protection of Bramans, and having Anand Karj's preformed by Brahmans - after all it's all rehit - so let's follow it? Also you are not allowed to kill a black cow - just so that you are aware of it (Rehitname) I can quite all above mentioned Rehitnamey, if you wish. Point is - ALl Rehit's are for a practicle or spiritual signifiance. If for spiritual signifiance, then it would be mention in Guru Granth Sahib Ji, now some practicle Rehits are mentiosn in Guru Ji, and some are not, i.e Amritvela IS mentioned in Guru ji, but combing twice a day is not, neither is wearing Kashera, but the spiritual significance is - to stay modest etc. Kirpan- protecting yourself and other, as some Gurmukhs say - "anakh naal Jeena" So pretty much every real rehit has a spirutal signifnace which is mentioned in Guru Sahib, and unless you can give me a practicle or spiritual reason why not to wear Red, I don't see any raeson why not to. Yes in the Past it DID make sense not to wear red or green - totally due practicle reasons, temporarily, the red and green dresse's are taken up, by wearing a green or red uniform, you'd be thaught to be a Hindu or Muslim in war, and be chopped of by, potentionally, your own brother. In order to stop that scenario to happen, they banned Sikhs from wearing red and green, in order not to be mixed with someone else. If in future, Sikh's enimies decide to wear kesri and blue - will Sikhs wear it, and risk killing theri own brothers? Probably not. Bhull chukk maaf Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Lionking · 05 Dec 2005

Guru Ji says - [gurbani]AklI swihbu syvIAY AklI pweIAY mwnu ][/gurbani] akalee saahib saeveeai akalee paaeeai maan || Wisdom leads us to serve our Lord and Master; through wisdom, honor is obtained

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

deep · 07 Dec 2005

im a singhnee, proud and Wear Red. I think it IS narrowminded and a issue which is no issue when there SO much more to be done in this panth. Colours???? pleasee.........the khalsa colour are mentioned but the others were never dissed. Its our own wishes, so be it....DO not throw ideals onto others Chardikala Jeevan Deep Kaur Khalsa xx

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

LionKing (LK) · 08 Dec 2005

They were dissed, but for a rason, practicle reasons at the time.

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

deep · 08 Dec 2005

yep.....hanje "at the time" colours to me do not matter, i dont feel our guru ji willl look anymore differently at his servant if the servant is wearing white, red, yellow, kesri, purple black etc........ ....why? becuase all of us dont wear the same colours evryday, i may wear blue one day, white the nxt, then red another day and kesri or orange colour another day...... Understand what me is trying to say. deep kaur

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

singhz lets unite · 10 Dec 2005

ok if only red ang green are banned.. then how about gray,gold,silver,yellow,brown,awua,purple,violet,etc????? thyere not mentioned anywahere to be banned from Sikhi or are they??? and whats wrong with black??? black is a Khalsa colour given by the Guru Sahib...

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

singhz lets unite · 10 Dec 2005

k are these banned colours only banned for the Sikh Turban or are they banned for the clothees also?

Re: why cant you wear red HELP!!!

Kulwinder Singh · 12 Dec 2005

Dear Vir Lionking Ji, I accept your point of view as--- "a Sikh must be practised in Shastervidya - THere's a point to the Kirpan - to use it, What you gonna do if you can't use it? " ---- Valid and desirable, Although I did not meant to say that we should not get shastervidya , But I should have clarified myself that we at least should be able to defend our self and those who need defending. I agree with you Vir Ji. Thanks for pointing it out. Kulwinder Singh