Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Guru Ji neglected family?

Guru Ji neglected family?

Gkaur · 30 Nov 2005

GurFateh A lot of Muslims have said to me that Guru Nanak Dev Ji while undertaking his long udhasis neglected his family. They believe this was wrong as he himself encouraged gristhi jeevan, and one of his travels lasted 16 years according to 'the sikhs' by patwant singh. How do I answer this question? They also say this is why Baba Sri Chand Ji started up his own path. Please discuss. Fateh Jee

Re: Guru Ji neglected family?

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 30 Nov 2005

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh Nothing is wrong with what Guru Nanak Dev Jee did, as Vaheguru Jee is the true parent of Guru Jee, and also it’s called emotional attachment being stuck with your family. So what was Guru Jee to do, take his whole family with him on his journey to spread Sikhi, or stay with his family at home and not make a difference in life. The child can love their family but he/she still has to stay emotionally unattached to them, Guru Jees love for them was still there inside of him, remember that love is eternal, that’s the only thing the soul contains, and if Guru Jee was like Vaheguru Jee in a way, then he defiantly had love for his family. The religion Sikhi is the only religion that is above worldliness, this contains, emotional attachment, lust, ego, anger, worldly attachments, greed, also by reaching really high levels in Naam Bhagti we can also become above supernatural powers and good or bad deeds. Muslims believe that when they leave earth that there’s a realm where they can be lustful with females there, but they don’t know that lust is worldly, as five demons were placed in a human’s body from the beginning of time, lust, anger, ego, worldly attachments and greed. When the soul leaves the body, it doesn’t feel any of these evils. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh

Re: Guru Ji neglected family?

Truth · 30 Nov 2005

don't associate with Muslims. don't dine with them. avoid them as much as possible. there's a reason why old rehit-namas are so harsh on muslims.

Re: Guru Ji neglected family?

Sher b SIngh · 30 Nov 2005

Awalll Alaahai Noor Upaaeya Kudrat Key Sabh Bande, Aek Noor Te Sabh Jag Upjeya Kaun Bhale KO Mande! If someone doesnt know, we can try explianing to them, instead of just avoiding them.

Re: Guru Ji neglected family?

LionKing (LK) · 01 Dec 2005

Guru Nanak Dev ji lived as a Gristi a lot of his life. he did go on Udasia, but tha was not for salvation, like the yogis did, who left hoem for salvation - Guru Nanak left home to TEACH others the way of "Ik Baba Akal Roop". Naam, Sikhi, Gristi etc =)

Re: Guru Ji neglected family?

Bundha. · 01 Dec 2005

Muslims as normal make mischief. As was the norm is those days people travelled to find work. Guru Nanak Dev Ji stayed and worked in sultanpur and would always come home and look after his family and also send back money for their upkeep. When Guru Sahib Ji started his udassis his sahibzaday were not tiny children, they had grown up. I cannot recall how old Guru Sahib Ji was when he started the udassis but he did not leave a young family behind. Also, as was the custom then and to some extent now, the family was cared for by the extended family - Mata Sulukhanis in-laws, chachay, tai etc, so there was never a worry that the family would be left on their own. Any ways do you think that Guru Sahib Ji would neglect his family ? No. He made full provision for them.

Re: Guru Ji neglected family?

Singh · 01 Dec 2005

Guru Nanak had been given a mission by God to give a message of truth and worship of Akaal purakh to the whole of humanity. He was here to look after and love all, he did not consider his wife and sons more of his family than any of the people he met on his journies - so basically, the whole of humanity was his family, proved in the fact that everyone, regardless of religion, calaimed Guru Nanak as their own.

Re: Guru Ji neglected family?

learn · 01 Dec 2005

A lot of muslims learn a few things about other peoples religions, to try to shatter their faith. Their are many things which you can say to muslims to shut them up. Atleast Guru Nanak didn`t marry a 6 year old! Atleast he didn`t marry his cousin! Atleast he didn`t marry his child to their cousin! unlike prophet Mohammed, who did all of the above.

Re: Guru Ji neglected family?

Jagjit Singh · 01 Dec 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, Sahib Siri Guru Nanak Dev ji did not neglect his family. He worked during his life, first as a shopkeeper. But he did a Saacha Suada. During the times of his great journeys, the sangat looked after his children and family. But he also had his own lands aswell from which income was derived. In between each of his journey he worked on his lands. At the end of his journeys, he spent many years farming his lands. But Guru ji was beyond this, with a far greater field which he sowed. That field was humanity. He prepared it, and planted seeds of wisdom, humanity, truth, compassion, courage, Naam, humilty and pyaar. There was no greater example of a Gristi jeevan , because not only did he do his own gristi - but at the same time was the physician of of humanity. When discussing Sahib Siri Guru Nanak Dev ji, one should definately read "Baba Ved Roogian da", by Bhai sahib. waheguru ji kekhalsa waheguru ji ke fateh P.s. without causing offence to your muslim friends, but please ask them how many wifes Mohammed had? What was the age of his youngest wife? Is it acceptable for a man of a certain age to have such a young wife? Is that a good example of a Gristi jeevan... Just something for them to think about aswell.

Re: Guru Ji neglected family?

Bundha. · 01 Dec 2005

1.Guru Nanak Dev ji, born in 1469 was married around the age of 14-16 years. he was blessed with two sons, born around 1491 and 1494. He undertook udhasis only around 1500, which means when Guru Nanak Dev Ji was around 31 years, already 15-17 years in marriage. While he was married, he was respectfully working at ModiKhana at Sultanpur lodhi. Also, his elder sister and brother-in-law lived in the same city. This shows that Guru Ji was aware of his householder duties, undertook them diligently and only left for the udhasis, when it was appropriate with children little grown up, and entrusting day to day care/concerns to the family of his elder sister. In addition, every time after completing the udhasis, he would come back to his family. And finally, he settled at Kartarpur with his family. 2. It is generally said that as Guru Nanak Dev ji neglected his children, they went astray. I think we are wrong here. Baba Sri Chand Ji, did not lead a householders life, but was spiritually very high - He was the founder of the Udasi order and Fourth, Fifth and Sixth Guru Ji's met him with respect. The Sixth Guru also gave his son Baba Gurditta to Baba Sri Chand as the next leader of the Udasi order. Baba Sri Chand died and was cremated here in 1612 at the ripe old age of 118 years Baba lakhmi das ji lived a normal householders life. Now, I think, we sikhs, needlessly (and rather wrongly), like to belittle baba Sri Chand Ji because he was not selected for becoming the second Guru and we like to show everyting in black and white .

Re: Guru Ji neglected family?

Gkaur · 01 Dec 2005

Thankyou for the responses. Does anyone know how old Guru Jee's sahibzadey were when Guru Jee left for the first udhasi?