Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Bhopinder Singh · 01 Dec 2005

Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’ Amritsar, December 1 Akal Takht Jathedar Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti today gave a call to Sikh sangat to boycott the ‘Spokesman’ newspaper, started by Mr Joginder Singh, who has been excommunicated from the Sikh fold. In a statement here today, the Jathedar said the Editor of the newspaper had earlier, through his writings, misinterpreted the history, maryada and hukamnamas for which he was excommunicated.

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 01 Dec 2005

The Spokesman is the First Sikh National DAILY.... Bilingual - English and Punjabi.... that speaks the mind of the Guru Khasa Panth..and EXPOSES the dharam de thekedaars who have had a stranglehold on Sikhi for decades..and are bent on destroying it from the Apex of Sikhism. There can be disagreement about certian articles and writings..BUT not about the Entire Paper..especially when the Sikhs DONT have any other Voice..the Spokesman gave a call of ONE FULL ISSUE to Vedanti and others opposed to it to EXPLAIN matters to its readers. None accepted. God knows why ??

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Kulbir Singh · 02 Dec 2005

As per hukam of Siri Akal Takhat Sahib we should not read Spokesman and Indo-Canadian Times. Joginder is excommunicated from Panth and to read his views in his magazine - Spokesman is also prohibited as per the edict. Kulbir Singh

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Jagjit Singh · 02 Dec 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I have been been an avid reader of Spokesman for many years. It is a very high quality Sikh magazine. I fully supported the movement to reform the SGPC. I even attended their conference in Chandigarh a few years ago. However I pointed out to Joginder Singh then. While I support Spokesman and their objectives, I feel they are making a huge mistake by involving themselves as part of the kala Afghana issue. They had started creating an alliance with the Khalsa Panchayat, IOSS, Kala Afghana, Dr Jagjit Chohan, and others. I feel as a result they have created too many issues and too much complex personalities to achieve anything. The Akal Thakht hukamnama is political, we cannot deny that. But as Bhai Kulbir Singh said we have to abide by it. There are times we may not agree with hukamnamas, but we cannot ignore them, and have to accept them. I did a benti to Bhai joginder Singh to stop pushing the Kala Afghana issue, and maintain the magazine. I think it has all become far too personal now, from all sides. Like I said, it is a shame, because the magazine has some really good articles, and they did good seva in the past. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru jike fateh

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Bhopinder Singh · 02 Dec 2005

Joginder is a very cunning and deeply anti panthic,I know you will doubt this. Independent body of sikhs 'Gursikh' and many of it workers are witness to his statement of changing ardas and removing PRATHAM BHOUGTI SIMAR KE . They want to delete BHOUGTI and use akal. He further went on to add that amrit is not compulsory and people taking are a firka (sect),but you can be with kase or without it doesnt matter. He is the editor of sokesman not spokesman in itself.He is basically a communist who penetrated deeply into sikhs using this magzine.I remember years ago Satti a singh of Khalistan intelligence who later became martyr telling me in1990 that he is sure and as sure as death that joginder is working for the Indian intelligence ,I like you doubted him but his answer to my question was " he has no sharda in sikhi and has no belief in basic tenets of sikhi which are most important let alone important are must for being a spokesman of our bload soaked freedom struggle" .He indeed had more association with the media being a M.A english from Punjab University and was working for K.c.f a millitant outfit not as millitant but an annalist. Our dissusion ended with his conclusion that no sooner this campaign of armed struggle for freedom slows down you will see his true face .His remarks were, their will be questions on sikh belief system like taking bath in sarovar at Amritsar ,washing by milk the place of darbar sahib and Indian intelligence will be supporting those views and propogate it withall its might. The most important hurdles in their way are these actions of sikhs as they have no such thing and are astonished at the bravery and the ressistant of sikhs barely armed.Indeed he was right. He wanted me to look at his background and see how he got into the position that he had and their he said will lie the answer.Which was also correct. As Indian officials started worrying about the struggle and they carried out one of the largest troop assembling after the second world war in a exercise code named 'Brasstacks' to threaten pakistan in 1987 .we all remmember Zia was in India during those days ,it is now known that Pakistanis showed Indians the nuclear stuff they had and were right in doing so,as is clear from the sanctions imposed by US in 1989 on Pakistan although it never did a hot test. Zia made it clear to the indians that thay were not training sikhs as they were training Afghans as only a hot test of nuclear weapons would have given them the confidence to say and do the opposite,but he served his country,at the same time Indians were astonished at the level of fight sikhs were giving without any external help ,which made them look deeper and i guess you all can conclude what they came up with,exactly what kala Afghana and others are doing.

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Niranjan Singh · 02 Dec 2005

[/gurbani] [gurbani] is`K kOm nwl iek hor DRoh spoksmYn [/gurbani] SPOKESMAN EXPOSED This booklet was released and distributed at the 5th Centennial Gurpurb Celebrations at Khadoor Sahib by the GURSIKH organization, to warn the Sangat at large about the nefarious designs of the so-called “Voice of the Panth” and its editor. It is available at the Khalsa Alliance Web site, along with other articles related to this topic [url]http://www.khalsaalliance.org/naastic/SpokesmanExposedBooklet.pdf[/url] [gurbani] ‘spoksmYn’ dy lwirAW dI khwxI ausdy Awpxy AMkW dI zubwnI [/gurbani] [url]http://www.khalsaalliance.org/naastic/sdldk_0304.pdf[/url] [gurbani] ‘spoksmYn’ is`KW dw jW is`K duSmxW dw? [/gurbani] [url]http://www.khalsaalliance.org/naastic/ssdsdd_0304.pdf[/url]

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Singh · 02 Dec 2005

Spokesman may be a good or bad paper But we do not follow hukam of AKAAL TAKHAT. We follow hukam of AKAAL. Following hukam of AKAAL TAKHAT is moorti pooja. Do we do pooja of the STONE that the TAKHAT is made out of ? Or do we do pooja of AKAAL PURAKH GURU HARGOBIND SAHIB who sits on the AKAAL TAKHAT ? And the takhat is AKAAL'S, not VEDANTI'S, so what are we doing blindly following VEDANTI like a mouse ?!?!? I am so disappointed in our gurmukh pyare who have turned away from our panthic traditions hukam from GURU KHALSA PANTH is hukam of AKAAL, hukam from VEDANTI, is hukam of a human being Bhai Gurdas Ji says: [gurbani]siqgur swihb Cf kY mnmuK hoie bMdy dw bMdw][/gurbani] sathigur saahib shhadd kai manamukh hoe ba(n)dhae dhaa ba(n)dhaa|| Manmukh, the mind-orientated, leaving away the true Guru Lord becomes slave of man. Yes, it is hukam of AKAAL that Kala Afghana is tankhaiya because MAJORITY OF THE PANTH agrees about this. Yes, it is hukam of AKAAL that langar should be on the floor because MAJORITY OF THE PANTH agrees about this. But we need to stop following the "MAN" vedanti and follow the "CREATOR" akaal !!!!!! AKAAAAAAAAAAAALLLLLL !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Niranjan Singh · 02 Dec 2005

[gurbani] ieik vlu Clu kir kY Kwvdy muhhu kUVu kusqu iqnI FwihAw ] [/gurbani][/gurbani][/gurbani](SGGSJ) [gurbani] T`g-E-vwc -------------- swrI aumr nw bxnw gUrU vwly, nw hI Dwrnw koeI kkwr BweI pMQ AMdr AYpr hY is`D krnw, AsIN pMQ dy hW ispwh-swlwr BweI rozwnw, vIklI, mwisk dy lw lwry, lokW qWeIN krWgy KuAwr BweI ‘Amr isMGw’ kox gogV BrU swfI, AsIN T`gW dy hW srdwr BweI p`qrkwr-E-vwc ------------------- bwkI sBnW nUM AwKdw jMglI ieko-iek hW mYN ivdvwn bIbw bwkI swrI kOm hnyr FoNdI mYN hI byby ny jMimAw Bwn bIbw qKq Akwl qy gurU gRMQ inMdwN myrI QkdI nhIN zbwn bIbw AMimRq B`tW BgqW nUM inMd C`fW myrI sB qoN v`KrI Swn bIbw [/gurbani] (These poems were written by Bhai Amardeep Singh 'Amar' on the back cover of the Spokesman Booklet mentioned in the above post)

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Dec 2005

all i can say is that this has happened to sikhs before....remember the TRIBUNE.....it is a National Newspaper totally funded with Sikh money of Majhithia Sardars....and today it is Anti Sikh to the core and taken over by the RSS/aryasamajsits..... Sikhs sorely need a PRESS/NEWSPAPER of their Own...

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

S Singh · 03 Dec 2005

How many times has Vedanti been exposed ? HE let Dhanwant Su off for rape as his cousin Prithpal Sandhu took a backhander. This is common knowledge.

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Singh · 03 Dec 2005

NIranjan Singh ji I am not supporting Spokesman. I am saying Spokesman could be bad paper and Guru Khalsa Panth should organize to ban it But it's too funny how we follow the man vedanti instead of the Guru Panth

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Dec 2005

and....whats this ??...this is NOT a HUKMNAMA....its just a personal opinion of Vedanti Ji. : A statement issued by Harbir Singh Bhanwar, media advisor to the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC) President, said the Jathedar has asked the Sikhs ''neither to prescribe (read) nor work on any post with the daily''.The Jathedar has also directed the community neither to advertise in the daily nor give any form of assistance. According to the statement, the Jathedar has also prohibited all Sikh organisations from having any form of link, direct or indirect, with the 'Rozana Spokesman'. However, the statement by the Jathedar has not been issued on letter head of the Akal Takht which is the normal practice. Neither is the statement in the form of a 'hukamnama' (directive) to the Sikh community.... Looks like some are out to "kill" a paper that Flogs Badal and his cronies..

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Singh · 03 Dec 2005

Yes, but EVEN IF it was on Akal Takhat letterhead It could not be authenticated unless it had the approval of the majority of the panth the PANTH is the guru, not vedanti, not the stone that the takhat is made of, not the letterhead of the akal takhat SAT SRI AKAAL sits on akaal takhat, and SAT SRI AKAAL is on earth in two forms: Guru GRanth and Guru Panth I am NOT supporting this magazine - maybe this magazine IS BAD but i am saying when will we stop this blind followers routine this is not hukam man-na, or being gurmukh this is just "okay vedanti put it on a letterhead so now VAAHEGUROO must approve it because vedanti is the voice of VAAHEGUROO ?!?!?!" this is why people mix jathedar with pope

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

LionKing (LK) · 03 Dec 2005

Author: Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Date: 12-03-05 02:08 all i can say is that this has happened to sikhs before....remember the TRIBUNE.....it is a National Newspaper totally funded with Sikh money of Majhithia Sardars....and today it is Anti Sikh to the core and taken over by the RSS/aryasamajsits..... Sikhs sorely need a PRESS/NEWSPAPER of their Own... *************************** are you talking about India tribune or??

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Gurpreet Singh · 03 Dec 2005

I am pained to say the least after reading the response of"Singh" stating "Do we do the pooja of the Stone that the Takht is made of ?" I can assure you no Gursikh does pooja of any stone. Pooja Akaal Purukh di. But the Akaal Takht Sahib is not as insignificant as you make it out to be. It is the one place in the Sikh Panth that has withstood upheavals and has stood as a source of Spritual and and collective strength for us. It is the one place that even after being destroyed rose again and gives direction to the Sikh Panth on important issues. Coming to your comments on "Vedanti". No jathedar of Akaal Takht Sahib is a judge on common matters. Matters of corrupt sadhs and their likes should be handled like any other criminal matters and not involve jathedars. Kala Afghana or the Nirankari Hukamnama before him were Panthic matters and should definitely involve the Jathedars. "Hukum from Guru Khalsa Panth is Hukum of Akaal" I agree , but who will convey that to the Sangat. The Spokesman ? or Times of India ? maybe Jatha Bhindran or maybe AKJ or maybe Chief Khalsa Diwan but wait, the Sangat of Ranchi may not agree....... We are opening ourselves to a situation that has no end in sight. The purratan sikhs were no fools. They established a system that has withstood the test of time. We have for reasons best known to Akaal Purukh been unable to keep it insulated from corrupt politicians. It is not the Akaal Takht's or the jathedars fault if we as sikhs are too meek (I hate to use the word cowardly) to control our own house. Lets blame it on the jathedar. How many of us have kept only the Guru's mat ahead of our personal needs and gone against the tide of manmat and koor that todays politicians represent. How many times have we supported the jathedar;any jathedar; on important issues and given him our input. (I bow my head for those that do take the time to do so). The Akaal Takh Jathedar is only what we make him. His duties are not that of a policeman or a judge or fighting our little battles for us and God fobid if we should not agree with him. His duties as I understand should be:- To define the Rehit Maryada and to enforce it To put forward any Panthic decisions. To undermine the importance of Akaal Takht or its Jathedar will not help the Guru Panth but will instead take us in different directions with our own sikhism defined as we see it fit to serve our point. These are my views. Bhul chuk maaf Daas Gurpreet Singh NJ

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Singh · 03 Dec 2005

Gurpreet singh ji I respect what you are saying and I agree with you but I feel you misunderstood me. What i mean to say is the final word from Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib is final for all the panth, but if the Sri Akaal Takhat sahib is run by dodgy politicians and Badal-slaves then the hukams signed by any jathedar don't have significance. It is like Supreme Court of USA being run by the Mafia - would you trust the decisions of the Supreme Court ? Yes, the court is Supreme - but the court would need to be taken over by the right people. Same way Sri Akaal Takhat Sahib has been INVADED by thugs and masands and crooks like Badal, Jagiro and they have too much influence so we cannot just be blind and follow the hukams that THEY inspired.

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Dec 2005

lion king ji, Yes its the Tribune published in Punjab in English and also Punjabi. The Capital for it belongs to the Majithia Sardars Dyal Singh majhithia i beleive funded it 100%. Today it is in the hands of the arya smajists and has a virulentyly ANTI-SIKH stance on all matters related to Sikhs..and will publish anti maryada/anti sikh artilces instantly but not rejoinders or corrections sent in by other sikhs.

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Gurpreet Sumra · 04 Dec 2005

Pujari joginder Singh Vedanti has issued his self styled hukamnama to boycott Spokesman Magazine. WHY? Because it exposes Vedanti,beacuse it always writes against anti sikh practices and ritualisms that has seeped into Sikhism and has again turned our Gurdwara's into pre 1920 Gurdwaras.I am not saying that Spokesman is 100% right nor I have any thing in favour or against of it. I REQUEST PANTHIC WEEKLY AND EVERY SIKH TO PUT THESE QUESTIONS TO VEDANTI: 1)RSS printed calendars with Guru Nanak Sahib,indira gandhi and nanga gandhi(karamchand gandhi) photo and distributed in front of your eyes.Were you polishing Badal's shoes at that time? 2)RSS proved Banda Singh Bahadur(FIRST SIKH GENERAL) and hakikat rai as hindu.Nothing why? 3)Badal doing havan,ramayan ke path, No Hukamnama? why? 4)Tarlochan Singh of Minority Commission trying to make sikhs dastardhari hindus by saying that Ramayn ke path should be done by sikhs as ram,kishan comes so many times in Guru Grant sahib ji(I think he has not read Guru granth sahib ji).No Hukamnama? Is he your relative? 5)As per Sikh rehat Maryada Sikh women can do sewa, so why dont you issue a hukamnama?? why are you turning darbar sahib into hindu mandir? 6)BJP is preaching that Guru granth sahib ji is summary of Vedas.Is this true?If not then what step have you taken to stop this stupidity? 7)what have you done about Bhanu murti?Have you tried to find out who was behind all this conspiracy, well I am pretty sure it was you.

Re: Vedanti for boycott of ‘Spokesman’

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 05 Dec 2005

gurpreet samra asks so many questions.....??? but he wont get any answers...