Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Singh · 01 Dec 2005

I thought I would share this. Some Sikhs go on about all religions are equal and the same. What does Bhai Gurdas think? Here it is (vaar 38, pauri 10) [gurbani]bhu suMnI SIA rwPzI mzhb min Bwxy] mulihd hoie munw&kw sB Brim Bulwxy] eIsweI mUsweIAW haumY hYrwxy] hoie iPrMgI ArmnI rUmI grbwxy] kwlI pos klµdrW drvys dugwxy] guru isK rom n pujnI gur hit ivkwxy ]10][/gurbani] There are many Sunnis, Shias, Rafazis and (followers of) religions that please their minds. Many hypocrites become atheists deluded by illusion and go wandering about. Followers of Jesus (Christians) and Moses (Jews) are confounded by their pride. They are English, Armenian and Roman, (stuck in) Ego Some are blackclad recluses and dervishes, of little value. They are not equal to even a single hair of a Gursikh, who has sold himself to the Guru (by offering his head in return for naam) [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Singh · 01 Dec 2005

[gurbani]muslmwxw ihMdUAW duie rwh clwey] mjhb vrx gxwieMdy guru pIru sdwey] isK murId pKMf kir aupdys idRVwey] rwm rhIm iDAwieMdy haumY grbwey] mkw gMg bnwrsI pUj jwrq Awey] rojy vrq nmwj kir fMfauiq krwey] guru isK rom n pujnI jo Awpu gvwey ]9][/gurbani] The two paths of Hindus and Muslims have been created. They count their setcs and castes and call themselves Pirs or Gurus. Through hypocrisy (fakeness) they make followers and give them instruction. They meditate on Ram and Rahim but are conceited in ego. They go to worship at Mecca, Ganga and Benaras. They observe Rozas, fasts and Namaaz and bow down flat. They do not equal even a single hair of a Gursikh, who has lost his sense of ego.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

.... · 02 Dec 2005

pretty clear that Sikhi is the highest path. Should be a slap to all the Sikh apologists out there.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

vichar · 02 Dec 2005

yeh absolutely can we have some more? ive come across many similar shabads which explain how hindu and muslim religions are false, and by practising falsehood, one ends up in hell.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

LionKing · 02 Dec 2005

Exactly, who has lost his ego not just anyone- but someone who ahs lost hsi ego. If Guru Nanak Dev JI coudl do Namaz in a maszjid - are we sayign he was wrong. Are we saying Sia Mia Mir (a sufi saint at Guru Arjan Dev Ji's time) could nto meet Kartar due to his faith? Are we saying that Guru Nanak Dev ji was wrong when saying that No koi Hindu Na Musalman - in the eyes of God. [i]A couple of years after the death of Guru Arjan, his son and successor Guru Hargobind, a lad of thirteen, called on Mian Mir at Lahore. In the monastery (Khanqah) there were many disciples of Mian Mir including a young girl Kaulan. She was the daughter of Rustam Khan, the Qazi of the Capital. Being religious-minded from childhood, she became a disciple of Mian Mir. She had made up her mind to become a nun, but in Islam there was no room for a woman to lead the life of a nun. She therefore decided to become a disciple of Guru Hargobind: Her father grew furious at such a proposal. He tried his best to dissuade her from her intention. Having failed in this. attempt he began to persecute her. She fled to Mian Mir who sent her to Amritsar under proper escort. She was given a separate house to live, and she was immortalised by the construction of a tank named after her Kaulsar[/i] She was a follower of Mia Mir, yet a muslim - if Sai Mia Mir completly followed Sikhi, then why call him a muslim, and why runa monastry.... WHy ddi Guru Gobind Singh Ji say - Jin PREM kiyo tin hi Prabh Payo. har ko naam lai ootam Dharmaa. Chanting the Name of the Lord is the highest religion. Just read what Bhai Sahib Bhai Gurdas JI is saying - And I don't think that, in today's world, Sikhs are very different from the Muslism and Hindu's of the time, stuck in blidn rituals. After all Guru Gobind SIngh Ji himself said that- Jab Lag Khalsa Rehe Nyara Tab lag Tej diyo meh Sara Jag e Gehe Bipran Ki Reet Mai na Karo in Ki Partit. When the Gurmukh, stops getting rid of hsi ego, and isntead beginns filling it by practising blind rituals, whcih we've begun doing, then the case is exactly the Same for Sikhs. As you mentioned - the whole becomming of a SIkh requires you to kill your "Mai", I I I, Me Me me. As a conclusion - Bhai Sahib Bhai Gurdas Ji is clearly saying that a Gurmukh that defeats his ego as a lot better of spiritually, than someone else from other religion, especially those claiming that their religion is better, and is full of that pride..... Bhull Chukkk Maaf Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

uksingh · 02 Dec 2005

parr parr pa(n)ddith baedh vakhaanehi maaeiaa moh suaae || The Pandits, the religious scholars, constantly read and recite the Vedas, for the sake of the love of Maya. dhoojai bhaae har naam visaariaa man moorakh milai sajaae || In the love of duality, the foolish people have forgotten the Lord's Name; they shall receive their punishment. jin jeeo pi(n)dd dhithaa this kabehoo(n) n chaethai jo dhae(n)adhaa rijak sa(n)baahi || They never think of the One who gave them body and soul, who provides sustenance to all. jam kaa faahaa galahu n katteeai fir fir aavai jaae || The noose of death shall not be cut away from their necks; they shall come and go in reincarnation over and over again. manamukh kishhoo n soojhai a(n)dhhulae poorab likhiaa kamaae || The blind, self-willed manmukhs do not understand anything. They do what they are pre-ordained to do. poorai bhaag sathigur milai sukhadhaathaa naam vasai man aae || Through perfect destiny, they meet the True Guru, the Giver of peace, and the Naam comes to abide in the mind. sukh maanehi sukh painanaa sukhae sukh vihaae || They enjoy peace, they wear peace, and they pass their lives in the peace of peace. naanak so naao manahu n visaareeai jith dhar sachai sobhaa paae ||1|| O Nanak, they do not forget the Naam from the mind; they are honored in the Court of the Lord. ||1||

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Kulbir Singh · 02 Dec 2005

Excellent quotes from Bhai Gurdaas jee's baani. Some complain that Gurbani has totally ignored Christians and Jews and mentions mostly Hindus and Muslims. Yogis, Jains and Buddhists are mentioned. In some cases there are allusions to Jews and Christians but they are not directly mentioned. What I derive from this is that Christianity and Judaism was not deemed worthy of even mention in Gurbani. Some foolish people claim that Guru Sahib had not heard of Jews and Christians since the British had not arrived in India at that time. This is such an absurd thing to say. There are mentions of Jesuit priests and preachers in Tozake Jahangiri (Autobiography of Jahangir) and in Tabakat-e-Akbari (biography of Akbar) and their presence in India was definitely known at Guru Sahib's time but Guru Sahib did not consider them even worthy of mentioning. Besides, Guru Sahib had travelled extensively in the Middle East and must have come in contact with the Jews and Christians but Guru Sahib did not mentionen them. Bhai Gurdas jee did mentioned them but only very few times. I think the most important group after Sikhs are the Yogis (Naaths) and Guru Sahib has several shabads addressed to them. There is even a whole baani (Sidh Gosht) dedicated to showing differences between Gurmat and Yogmat. Yogis must have been the most spiritually elevated beings at that time. There is no doubt that Gurmat is the greatest Dharam in the world and only through Gurmat can one reach Vaheguru. Those who recite baani with understanding don't have any doubts about this. No one has ever reached Vaheguru without the true Guru. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

uksingh · 02 Dec 2005

simrith saasath baedh vakhaanai || They recite the Simritees, the Shaastras and the Vedas, bharamae bhoolaa thath n jaanai || but deluded by doubt, they do not understand the essence of reality. bin sathigur saevae sukh n paaeae dhukho dhukh kamaavaniaa ||7|| Without serving the True Guru, they find no peace; they earn only pain and misery. ||7|| aap karae kis aakhai koee || The Lord Himself acts; unto whom should we complain? aakhan jaaeeai jae bhoolaa hoee || How can anyone complain that the Lord has made a mistake? naanak aapae karae karaaeae naamae naam samaavaniaa ||8||7||8|| O Nanak, the Lord Himself does, and causes things to be done; chanting the Naam, we are absorbed in the Naam. ||8||7||8||

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

vichar · 02 Dec 2005

manamukh parrehi pa(n)ddith kehaavehi || The self-willed manmukhs read and recite; they are called Pandits-spiritual scholars. dhoojai bhaae mehaa dhukh paavehi || But they are in love with duality, and they suffer in terrible pain. bikhiaa maathae kishh soojhai naahee fir fir joonee aavaniaa ||1|| Intoxicated with vice, they understand nothing at all. They are reincarnated, over and over again. ||1|| ho vaaree jeeo vaaree houmai maar milaavaniaa || I am a sacrifice, my soul is a sacrifice, to those who subdue their ego, and unite with the Lord. gur saevaa thae har man vasiaa har ras sehaj peeaavaniaa ||1|| rehaao || They serve the Guru, and the Lord dwells within their minds; they intuitively drink in the sublime essence of the Lord. ||1||Pause|| vaedh parrehi har ras nehee aaeiaa || The Pandits read the Vedas, but they do not obtain the Lord's essence. vaadh vakhaanehi mohae maaeiaa || Intoxicated with Maya, they argue and debate. agiaanamathee sadhaa a(n)dhhiaaraa guramukh boojh har gaavaniaa ||2|| The foolish intellectuals are forever in spiritual darkness. The Gurmukhs understand, and sing the Glorious Praises of the Lord. ||2|| akathho kathheeai sabadh suhaavai || The Indescribable is described only through the beauteous Word of the Shabad. guramathee man sacho bhaavai || Through the Guru's Teachings, the Truth becomes pleasing to the mind. sacho sach ravehi dhin raathee eihu man sach ra(n)gaavaniaa ||3|| Those who speak of the truest of the true, day and night-their minds are imbued with the Truth. ||3|| jo sach rathae thin sacho bhaavai || Those who are attuned to Truth, love the Truth. aapae dhaee n pashhothaavai || The Lord Himself bestows this gift; He shall not take it back. gur kai sabadh sadhaa sach jaathaa mil sachae sukh paavaniaa ||4|| Through the Word of the Guru's Shabad, the True Lord is known forever; meeting the True One, peace is found. ||4|| koorr kusath thinaa mail n laagai || gur parasaadhee anadhin jaagai || The filth of fraud and falsehood does not stick to those who, by Guru's Grace, remain awake and aware, night and day. niramal naam vasai ghatt bheethar jothee joth milaavaniaa ||5|| The Immaculate Naam, the Name of the Lord, abides deep within their hearts; their light merges into the Light. ||5|| thrai gun parrehi har thath n jaanehi || They read about the three qualities, but they do not know the essential reality of the Lord. moolahu bhulae gur sabadh n pashhaanehi || They forget the Primal Lord, the Source of all, and they do not recognize the Word of the Guru's Shabad. moh biaapae kishh soojhai naahee gur sabadhee har paavaniaa ||6|| They are engrossed in emotional attachment; they do not understand anything at all. Through the Word of the Guru's Shabad, the Lord is found. ||6|| vaedh pukaarai thribidhh maaeiaa || The Vedas proclaim that Maya is of three qualities. manamukh n boojhehi dhoojai bhaaeiaa || The self-willed manmukhs, in love with duality, do not understand. thrai gun parrehi har eaek n jaanehi bin boojhae dhukh paavaniaa ||7|| They read of the three qualities, but they do not know the One Lord. Without understanding, they obtain only pain and suffering. ||7|| jaa this bhaavai thaa aap milaaeae || When it pleases the Lord, He unites us with Himself. gur sabadhee sehasaa dhookh chukaaeae || Through the Word of the Guru's Shabad, skepticism and suffering are dispelled. naanak naavai kee sachee vaddiaaee naamo ma(n)n sukh paavaniaa ||8||30||31|| O Nanak, True is the Greatness of the Name. Believing in the Name, peace is obtained. ||8||30||31||

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

.... · 02 Dec 2005

LS The pauris are clear. These other religions don't even equal a HAIR of a Gursikh who has sold himself to the Guru. All Gursikhs are sold to the Guru, not just some special ones. You can't be a Gursikh if you aren't sold to the Guru. Guru Gobind Singh said "jin prem kiyon tin hee prabh paiyo" for sure. But in the very first stanza of svaiyay he also says that he has seen ALL the religions and NONE is the path to God. "saray hee des ko dekh rahiyo mat, kouoo na dekhiyaat pranpati ke". You really think Bibi Kaulan was a Muslim? She was a Gursikh. I'm not sure what point you are trying to prove with the quote you provided. It says she became a follower of Guru Hargobind and Mian Mir sent her to him. It's high time Sikhs realise that Sikhi is the highest of all paths and feel priviliged to be following this path, as opposed to saying, "all paths lead to God" and confusing themselves and others as to why not just follow another easier path then?

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

singh · 02 Dec 2005

"No koi Hindu Na Musalman " theres nothing in this world except for god, god and his name (nam) are one therefore there is only sikhi which is a religion devoted to chanting the lords true name (nam) "har ko NAAM lai ootam Dharmaa. Chanting the Name of the Lord is the highest religion. "

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

LionKing · 02 Dec 2005

Veer Kulbir SIngh Ji, you writ e- ********* What I derive from this is that Christianity and Judaism was not deemed worthy of even mention in Gurbani. ********* Your sayign that Hinduism and Islam are more worthy to be mentioend in Gurbani than Judaism and Christianity? Please re-read the Koran and the bible, and notice the differences... ******** The pauris are clear. These other religions don't even equal a HAIR of a Gursikh who has sold himself to the Guru. *********** EXACTLY- who has abdondoned his ego. I'm saying i'm not equal to a HAIR of a CHRISTIAN (or a Hindu, i.e Bhagat Dhanna ji) who has totally abandoned his ego, and has sold himself to Kartar... Care to explain why Bhagat Dhanna Ji was able to become one with Akaal (timeless) by innocont love, without being a "Sikh" Was it the innocent love that made Bhagat Dhanna Ji or anything else. Through innocent love meet the immortal :)

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Kulbir Singh · 02 Dec 2005

Lionking jeeo, ----------- Your sayign that Hinduism and Islam are more worthy to be mentioend in Gurbani than Judaism and Christianity? Please re-read the Koran and the bible, and notice the differences... ----------- Please let me know the differences. I see that Koran is more authentic than Bible that I believe has been tampered with. At least the translations are tampered with and all we see are the translations. Koran on the other hand is in its original shape and all sects have the same Koran. All denominations of Christians don’t have the same Bible. There are differences. ---------------- EXACTLY- who has abdondoned his ego. I'm saying i'm not equal to a HAIR of a CHRISTIAN (or a Hindu, i.e Bhagat Dhanna ji) who has totally abandoned his ego, and has sold himself to Kartar... Care to explain why Bhagat Dhanna Ji was able to become one with Akaal (timeless) by innocont love, without being a "Sikh" ------------ By meeting Saadhsangat i.e. by meeting Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Bhagat Dhanna attained the spiritual high status. ------ Was it the innocent love that made Bhagat Dhanna Ji or anything else. ------ Innocent love – yes but not love for Pathar. He never attained Vaheguru from a Pathar (idol). No one can get to Vaheguru by worshipping stones and idols. Only by meeting the true Guru and then obeying the true Guru’s commandments, one can reach Vaheguru. -------- Through innocent love meet the immortal :) -------- Through Innocent love (for Satnaam – true Naam) – Yes. Through Ignorance (love for idols, false gurus) – No. Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Bhopinder Singh · 02 Dec 2005

foxyking jeo You never answer the questions on the other hand change the topic. Answer jin premkeo ten he prabh piao as the singh asked read the lines before and i hope you are not the one reading it monthly ( like once in a month) read it kahan bhaio these lines written by singh mean exactly what bhai Gurdas ji is telling

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

LionKing (LK) · 03 Dec 2005

Valiant heroes, demons killing gods, gods drinking nectar and assemblies of saints of various sects.I have seen the disciplines of the religious systems of all the countries, but seen none of the Lord, the Master of my life.They are worth nothing without an iota of the Grace of the Lord. 1. http://www.sridasam.org/dasam?Action=Page&p=39&english=t&id=1618 Exactly! It's another thing that they have not meet God, due to their ahankar, btu then agian - that's exactly what Bhai Gurdas Ji is saying Ahankar Na karo, Ahankar Chado...! As for how often I read it, none of anyoen else's business =) He spends his life in such performing evil actions and wastes his life in such pursuits I speak Truth, all should turn their ears towards it: he, who is absorbed in True Love, he would realize the Lord. 9.29. Someone worshipped stone and placed it on his head. Someone hung the phallus (lingam) from his neck. Someone visualized God in the South and someone bowed his head towards the West Some fool worships the idols and someone goes to worship the dead The whole world is entangled in false rituals and has not known the secret of Lord-God 10.30. ਕੈਨ ਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਬੀ ਕਲੇਰਰ ? He didn't say - that Sikh who is absorbed .. he said WHO IS absorbed Lest we forgot- Guru ji is universal and not just for the Sikhs- Guru Ji's message is universal, eternal and open to all humanity Again and again he's saying by doing false rituals you're not giong to get anywhere. Sri Guru Ji says in Guru Sahib too - Hindu Ana Muslim Kanna it's EXACTLY due to the fact that they have started accepting blidn rituals, just like we have now... Again, Guru Ji also says - Jabh lag Khalsa Rehe Nyara Tabh lag Tej Diyo Meh Sara Jabh e Gehe Bippran Ki reet Mai Na Karo In Ki Parteet That above quotes do NOT only refer to Muslims and Hindus - but Sikhs too, whenever we start following bind rituals instead of Gurbani ...

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

LionKing (LK) · 03 Dec 2005

----------- Your sayign that Hinduism and Islam are more worthy to be mentioend in Gurbani than Judaism and Christianity? Please re-read the Koran and the bible, and notice the differences... ----------- Please let me know the differences. I see that Koran is more authentic than Bible that I believe has been tampered with. At least the translations are tampered with and all we see are the translations. Koran on the other hand is in its original shape and all sects have the same Koran. All denominations of Christians don’t have the same Bible. There are differences. ************** I agree about that, but what I'm saying is, the Koran is pretty much 180 degress different to Guru Sahib, completly intolerant, gender discriminative... Atleast the roots of Christianity oreached - love thy neighbor, wherease Islam it would be - love thy muslim Brothers.. Sikhi Says - Nanak Naam Chardikala Tere Bhaney Sarbat da Bhula Which sound more Sikh-lik, the muslim or Christian version? I agree that the bible has been tampered with, and thus, a lot of intolerance, sexism ahs crept in. *********** ---------------- EXACTLY- who has abdondoned his ego. I'm saying i'm not equal to a HAIR of a CHRISTIAN (or a Hindu, i.e Bhagat Dhanna ji) who has totally abandoned his ego, and has sold himself to Kartar... Care to explain why Bhagat Dhanna Ji was able to become one with Akaal (timeless) by innocont love, without being a "Sikh" ------------ By meeting Saadhsangat i.e. by meeting Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Bhagat Dhanna attained the spiritual high status. ************* What about , "Dhru" or "Prehlad" or Ajamal ? There are many shabads in Guru Ji about Bhagat Dhanna Ji, whihc one mentiosn meeting Guru Nanak Dev ji? ******* ------ Was it the innocent love that made Bhagat Dhanna Ji or anything else. ------ Innocent love – yes but not love for Pathar. He never attained Vaheguru from a Pathar (idol). No one can get to Vaheguru by worshipping stones and idols. Only by meeting the true Guru and then obeying the true Guru’s commandments, one can reach Vaheguru. *********** I agree, not through a stone - I agree 100% Yet i stand on my point - Jin Prehm Kiyo tin hi Prabh payo - one who has a longing, the LOVE for Vaheguru - only he can meet the immortal =) *********** -------- Through innocent love meet the immortal :) -------- Through Innocent love (for Satnaam – true Naam) – Yes. Through Ignorance (love for idols, false gurus) – No. *********** Seems like we agree after all =)

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

... · 03 Dec 2005

LS Way to avoid the issues. In the first stanza of Svaiya Guru Gobind Singh clearly says he has seen all the religions and none is the path to god. Period. ਸਾਰੇ ਹੀ ਦੇਸ ਕੋ ਦੇਖਿ ਰਹਿਓ ਮਤ ਕੋਊ ਨ ਦੇਖੀਅਤ ਪ੍ਰਾਨਪਤੀ ਕੇ ॥ You asked which shabad talks about Dhanna jee meeting Guru Nanak. What an absurd point. Which shabad talks about Bhagat Kabir jee meeting? Or where is the shabad that talks about Sunder jee meeting? If the meeting isn't covered in Guru Granth Sahib it didn't happen? Love is a fundamental component of meeting God. But we also know that it's not the only one. To meet God, you need Gurparsaad (and thus by default you need the Guru) and you need Gurmat Naam. Where else but in Sikhi are these things available? Who else is the perfect Guru that can lead the soul to God? Can you name another besides Guru Nanak? There is none other.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Singh · 03 Dec 2005

[gurbani]ifTy sBy Qwv nhI quDu jyihAw ][/gurbani] ddit(h)ae sabhae thhaav nehee thudhh jaehiaa || I have seen all places, but none can compare to You. [gurbani] bDohu puriK ibDwqY qW qU soihAw ][/gurbani] badhhohu purakh bidhhaathai thaa(n) thoo sohiaa || The Primal Lord, the Architect of Destiny, has established You; thus You are adorned and embellished. [gurbani] vsdI sGn Apwr AnUp rwmdws pur ][/gurbani] vasadhee saghan apaar anoop raamadhaas pur || Ramdaspur is prosperous and thickly populated, and incomparably beautiful. [gurbani] hirhW nwnk ksml jwih nwieAY rwmdws sr ]10][/gurbani] harihaa(n) naanak kasamal jaahi naaeiai raamadhaas sar ||10|| O Lord! Bathing in the Sacred Pool of Raam Daas, the sins are washed away, O Nanak. ||10||

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

uksingh · 03 Dec 2005

lionking- "I'm saying i'm not equal to a HAIR of a CHRISTIAN (or a Hindu, i.e Bhagat Dhanna ji) who has totally abandoned his ego, and has sold himself to Kartar..." lionking, yes we should see ourselves as the lowest of the low, but you cannot deny gurbani like in sukhmani sahib where it goes a bramgyiani see's himself as lowest of low, but in fact hes highest of high breham giaanee ooch thae oochaa || The God-conscious being is the highest of the high. man apanai hai sabh thae neechaa || Within his own mind, he is the most humble of all. so gursikhs are above other religions, but we dont see ourselves personally as above others

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

vichar · 03 Dec 2005

mil maerae gobi(n)dh apanaa naam dhaehu || Meet me, O my Lord of the Universe. Please bless me with Your Name. naam binaa dhhrig dhhrig asanaehu ||1|| rehaao || Without the Naam, the Name of the Lord, cursed, cursed is love and intimacy. ||1||Pause|| naam binaa jo pehirai khaae || Without the Naam, one who dresses and eats well jio kookar joot(h)an mehi paae ||1|| is like a dog, who falls in and eats impure foods. ||1|| naam binaa jaethaa biouhaar || jio mirathak mithhiaa seegaar ||2|| Without the Naam, all occupations are useless, like decorations on a dead body. ||2|| naam bisaar karae ras bhog || One who forgets the Naam and indulges in pleasures, sukh supanai nehee than mehi rog ||3|| shall find no peace, even in dreams; his body shall become diseased. ||3|| naam thiaag karae an kaaj || One who renounces the Naam and engages in other occupations, binas jaae jhoot(h)ae sabh paaj ||4|| shall see all of his false pretenses fall away. ||4|| naam sa(n)g man preeth n laavai || One whose mind does not embrace love for the Naam kott karam karatho narak jaavai ||5|| shall go to hell, even though he may perform millions of ceremonial rituals. ||5|| har kaa naam jin man n aaraadhhaa || One whose mind does not contemplate the Name of the Lord chor kee niaaee jam pur baadhhaa ||6|| is bound like a thief, in the City of Death. ||6|| laakh adda(n)bar bahuth bisathhaaraa || Hundreds of thousands of ostentatious shows and great expanses naam binaa jhoot(h)ae paasaaraa ||7|| - without the Naam, all these displays are false. ||7|| har kaa naam soee jan laee || That humble being repeats the Name of the Lord, kar kirapaa naanak jis dhaee ||8||10|| O Nanak, whom the Lord blesses with His Mercy. ||8||10||

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

LionKing (LK) · 03 Dec 2005

What about , "Dhru" or "Prehlad" or Ajamal ? Gurbani mentions these to have been "mukt" What about Guru Nanak Dev ji going to mazjid to pray, showing love tolerance, and that all pathways lead to God if love exists? Again, I agre most religious scriptures have been tampered with, and that might perhaps by why the "edited" religions, can lead to God, however Was Guru ji lying when he said that, the one who LOVES God will make it? Also, I did not ignore th epoint, but actually posted the context with English tarnslation - ******* Valiant heroes, demons killing gods, gods drinking nectar and assemblies of saints of various sects.I have seen the disciplines of the religious systems of all the countries, but seen none of the Lord, the Master of my life.They are worth nothing without an iota of the Grace of the Lord. 1. http://www.sridasam.org/dasam?Action=Page&p=39&english=t&id=1618 but at the end of the Swaiye he endsit with LOVE, showiing that ultimately it's LOVE that matters, orelse he woudl surely have written Jera Sikh prem kiy tinhi Prabh payo - he didn't. Again, to say thay Bhagat Dhru, Prehlad, or Ajamal (Papi?) were not Mukt, woudl be goign against Gurbani. Also, there was a huge thread on apoban on whether all Bhagats met Guru Nanak Dev Ji or not, an there was a lot of evidence SOME DID MEET, and alot of evidence some DIDN'T. Regards

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

uksingh · 03 Dec 2005

dhru, prehlad and ajamal were born into non-sikh family but got blessed with gods name (naam), in other words they became sikhs of guru and it was naam which gave them mukhti only naam can save one from hell

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

uksingh · 03 Dec 2005

bhagats like prehlad, kabir ji, farid ji, nam deyv ji were all sikh they didnt cut their hair, eat meat, use intoxicants, etctec they all received naam directly from guruji and repeated naam 24/7 which is what makes a sikhs a sikh, refraining from commiting cardinal sins, and nam repetition 24/7

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

LionKing (LK) · 03 Dec 2005

Do Sikhs have monopoly over God's grace =)?

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

... · 03 Dec 2005

You said that Guru Nanak went to the Mosque and prayed. Did he pray? Not according to any of the stories I've read. Do you really think Guru Nanak would recite Moslem prayers including a declaration that Mohammed is his prophet? Guru Nanak has a monopoly on Naam. God is achieved only through the grace of the Guru. Like I asked before, who is another Guru? Who is the equal of Guru Nanak? Who can someone go to besides Guru Nanak to receive Gurparsaad? On Prehlad, Dhru, etc.: From reading Bhattan Kay Svaiyay, I know that Guru Nanak has existed through the 4 jugs. He revealed Gurmat Naam openly only in Kaljug. I also know from Guru Sahib's bani that Dhru and Prehlad were saved by "Gurmat Naam". Not any naam but only Gurmat Naam. "Dhroo Prehlaad Bidar Dasee Sut, Gurmukh Naam Taray" It seems to me (and I could be wrong) that Guru Nanak used to do kirpa on select bhagats and bless them with Gurmat Naam. Svaiyay M: 5 kay tell us "Siri Guru Sahib Sabh Oopar. Karee Kirpa Satjug jin Dhroo par. Sree Prehlaad Bhagat Udhreeang. Haso kamal mathay par dhareeang." This means that Siri Guru Sahib (this clearly means Guru Nanak since it is the Bhattan Day Saviayay and they are talking about glory of Guru Nanak), does kirpa on everyone. In Satjug he blessed Dhroo. He saved Prehlaad. He put his lotus hands on their forehead (I always take this to mean gave them naam, just like naam is give the same way now). In the same bandh it says "Gur parsaad prabh paieeai, gur bin mukat na hoi" meaning only by Guru's grace is Vahiguru found and without a Guru no one is mukat." The very next line says "Guru Nanak Nikat basai banvaree" and goes on to talk about Guru Angad, Guru Amardas and Guru Ram Das. This is all the same bandh, not a new one. It is clear that the Guru is only Guru Nanak. It is clear that without Guru Nanak no one can be saved. And it is clear that Guru Nanak himself did kirpa and gave naam to Dhroo and Prehlaad. This isn't totally restricted to previous jugs. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh writes about the prisoner in jail for life who wanted naam but knew he could never go to the Punj Pyaaray. Bhai Sahib asked him to do ardaas to Guru Nanak for the gift of naam. Bhai Sahib felt very sympathetic but could not reveal naam alone without the punj pyaaray. Soon after, that prisoner began to jap naam and Bhai Sahib was amazed that Guru Nanak had done kirpa and revealed it to him.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Harcharan Singh · 03 Dec 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Unless anyone can prove otherwise, I thought Bhagat Kabir, Baba Shiekh Farid were alive before Guru Nanak Dev Ji (around 1100-1200 AD). Guru tells us that there are millions of prophets, millions of granths on millions of planets in the universe, let alone our small planet, Guru Ji reveals to us the infinite power of Gods creation, yet we still assume we are the centre of the universe. I was waiting for the day when Sikhi would join the other main stream faiths in declaring "it's my way or the highway", from reading many posts on this forum, I would say that day is encrouching. Christians say, salvation can occur only through Jesus, Muslims say salvation can occur only through Mohammed, some Sikhs are saying salvation can occur only through Guru Nanak Dev ji. This may be so and true for a person of each respective faith, but that does not mean that the rest of the world is dammed, this is the sort of nonsense that started the Christian and Muslim crusades, trying to convert people for their own good, so they would achieve salvation via acceptance of their prophet. All of Gods given prophets never claimed they were the only saviour, but they all told us submission to God and truthful living was salvation. For all you fanatics, Guru Nanak Dev Ji spoke to all - this extracts of shabad instruct man what a real Muslim and a real Hindu is, in essence the same as a real Sikh: ਸਲੋਕੁ ਮਃ ੧ ॥ सलोकु मः १ ॥ salok mehlaa 1. Shalok, First Mehl: ਮੁਸਲਮਾਣੁ ਕਹਾਵਣੁ ਮੁਸਕਲੁ ਜਾ ਹੋਇ ਤਾ ਮੁਸਲਮਾਣੁ ਕਹਾਵੈ ॥ मुसलमाणु कहावणु मुसकलु जा होइ ता मुसलमाणु कहावै ॥ musalmaan kahaavan muskal jaa ho-ay taa musalmaan kahaavai. It is difficult to be called a Muslim; if one is truly a Muslim, then he may be called one. ਅਵਲਿ ਅਉਲਿ ਦੀਨੁ ਕਰਿ ਮਿਠਾ ਮਸਕਲ ਮਾਨਾ ਮਾਲੁ ਮੁਸਾਵੈ ॥ अवलि अउलि दीनु करि मिठा मसकल माना मालु मुसावै ॥ aval a-ul deen kar mithaa maskal maanaa maal musaavai. First, let him savor the religion of the Prophet as sweet; then, let his pride of his possessions be scraped away. ਹੋਇ ਮੁਸਲਿਮੁ ਦੀਨ ਮੁਹਾਣੈ ਮਰਣ ਜੀਵਣ ਕਾ ਭਰਮੁ ਚੁਕਾਵੈ ॥ होइ मुसलिमु दीन मुहाणै मरण जीवण का भरमु चुकावै ॥ ho-ay muslim deen muhaanai maran jeevan kaa bharam chukhaavai. Becoming a true Muslim, a disciple of the faith of Mohammed, let him put aside the delusion of death and life. ਰਬ ਕੀ ਰਜਾਇ ਮੰਨੇ ਸਿਰ ਉਪਰਿ ਕਰਤਾ ਮੰਨੇ ਆਪੁ ਗਵਾਵੈ ॥ रब की रजाइ मंने सिर उपरि करता मंने आपु गवावै ॥ rab kee rajaa-ay mannay sir upar kartaa mannay aap gavaavai. As he submits to God's Will, and surrenders to the Creator, he is rid of selfishness and conceit. ਤਉ ਨਾਨਕ ਸਰਬ ਜੀਆ ਮਿਹਰੰਮਤਿ ਹੋਇ ਤ ਮੁਸਲਮਾਣੁ ਕਹਾਵੈ ॥੧॥ तउ नानक सरब जीआ मिहरमति होइ त मुसलमाणु कहावै ॥१॥ ta-o naanak sarab jee-aa mihramat ho-ay ta musalmaan kahaavai. ||1|| And when, O Nanak, he is merciful to all beings, only then shall he be called a Muslim. ||1|| ਬੈਸਨੋ ਸੋ ਜਿਸੁ ਊਪਰਿ ਸੁਪ੍ਰਸੰਨ ॥ बैसनो सो जिसु ऊपरि सुप्रसंन ॥ baisno so jis oopar suparsan. The true Vaishnaav, the devotee of Vishnu, is the one with whom God is thoroughly pleased. ਬਿਸਨ ਕੀ ਮਾਇਆ ਤੇ ਹੋਇ ਭਿੰਨ ॥ बिसन की माइआ ते होइ भिंन ॥ bisan kee maa-i-aa tay ho-ay bhinn. He dwells apart from Maya. ਕਰਮ ਕਰਤ ਹੋਵੈ ਨਿਹਕਰਮ ॥ करम करत होवै निहकरम ॥ karam karat hovai nihkaram. Performing good deeds, he does not seek rewards. ਤਿਸੁ ਬੈਸਨੋ ਕਾ ਨਿਰਮਲ ਧਰਮ ॥ तिसु बैसनो का निरमल धरम ॥ tis baisno kaa nirmal Dharam. Spotlessly pure is the religion of such a Vaishnaav; ਸੋ ਪੰਡਿਤੁ ਜੋ ਮਨੁ ਪਰਬੋਧੈ ॥ सो पंडितु जो मनु परबोधै ॥ so pandit jo man parboDhai. He is a true Pandit, a religious scholar, who instructs his own mind. ਰਾਮ ਨਾਮੁ ਆਤਮ ਮਹਿ ਸੋਧੈ ॥ राम नामु आतम महि सोधै ॥ raam naam aatam meh soDhai. He searches for the Lord's Name within his own soul. ਰਾਮ ਨਾਮ ਸਾਰੁ ਰਸੁ ਪੀਵੈ ॥ राम नाम सारु रसु पीवै ॥ raam naam saar ras peevai. He drinks in the Exquisite Nectar of the Lord's Name. ਉਸੁ ਪੰਡਿਤ ਕੈ ਉਪਦੇਸਿ ਜਗੁ ਜੀਵੈ ॥ उसु पंडित कै उपदेसि जगु जीवै ॥ us pandit kai updays jag jeevai. By that Pandit's teachings, the world lives. ਹਰਿ ਕੀ ਕਥਾ ਹਿਰਦੈ ਬਸਾਵੈ ॥ हरि की कथा हिरदै बसावै ॥ har kee kathaa hirdai basaavai. He implants the Sermon of the Lord in his heart. ਸੋ ਪੰਡਿਤੁ ਫਿਰਿ ਜੋਨਿ ਨ ਆਵੈ ॥ सो पंडितु फिरि जोनि न आवै ॥ so pandit fir jon na aavai. Such a Pandit is not cast into the womb of reincarnation again. ਬੇਦ ਪੁਰਾਨ ਸਿਮ੍ਰਿਤਿ ਬੂਝੈ ਮੂਲ ॥ बेद पुरान सिम्रिति बूझै मूल ॥ bayd puraan simrit boojhai mool. He understands the fundamental essence of the Vedas, the Puraanas and the Simritees. ਸੂਖਮ ਮਹਿ ਜਾਨੈ ਅਸਥੂਲੁ ॥ सूखम महि जानै असथूलु ॥ sookham meh jaanai asthool. In the unmanifest, he sees the manifest world to exist. ਚਹੁ ਵਰਨਾ ਕਉ ਦੇ ਉਪਦੇਸੁ ॥ चहु वरना कउ दे उपदेसु ॥ chahu varnaa ka-o day updays. He gives instruction to people of all castes and social classes. ਨਾਨਕ ਉਸੁ ਪੰਡਿਤ ਕਉ ਸਦਾ ਅਦੇਸੁ ॥੪॥ नानक उसु पंडित कउ सदा अदेसु ॥४॥ naanak us pandit ka-o sadaa adays. ||4|| O Nanak, to such a Pandit, I bow in salutation forever. ||4|| ਕੁਦਰਤਿ ਵੇਦ ਪੁਰਾਣ ਕਤੇਬਾ ਕੁਦਰਤਿ ਸਰਬ ਵੀਚਾਰੁ ॥ कुदरति वेद पुराण कतेबा कुदरति सरब वीचारु ॥ kudrat vayd puraan kataybaa kudrat sarab veechaar. By His Power the Vedas and the Puraanas exist, and the Holy Scriptures of the Jewish, Christian and Islamic religions. By His Power all deliberations exist. And finally, something that can be true to any man on this earth: ਸਰਬ ਧਰਮ ਮਹਿ ਸ੍ਰੇਸਟ ਧਰਮੁ ॥ सरब धरम महि स्रेसट धरमु ॥ sarab Dharam meh saraysat Dharam. Of all religions, the best religion ਹਰਿ ਕੋ ਨਾਮੁ ਜਪਿ ਨਿਰਮਲ ਕਰਮੁ ॥ हरि को नामु जपि निरमल करमु ॥ har ko naam jap nirmal karam. is to chant the Name of the Lord and maintain pure conduct. ਸਗਲ ਕ੍ਰਿਆ ਮਹਿ ਊਤਮ ਕਿਰਿਆ ॥ सगल क्रिआ महि ऊतम किरिआ ॥ sagal kir-aa meh ootam kiri-aa. Of all religious rituals, the most sublime ritual ਸਾਧਸੰਗਿ ਦੁਰਮਤਿ ਮਲੁ ਹਿਰਿਆ ॥ साधसंगि दुरमति मलु हिरिआ ॥ saaDhsang durmat mal hiri-aa. is to erase the filth of the dirty mind in the Company of the Holy. ਸਗਲ ਉਦਮ ਮਹਿ ਉਦਮੁ ਭਲਾ ॥ सगल उदम महि उदमु भला ॥ sagal udam meh udam bhalaa. Of all efforts, the best effort ਹਰਿ ਕਾ ਨਾਮੁ ਜਪਹੁ ਜੀਅ ਸਦਾ ॥ हरि का नामु जपहु जीअ सदा ॥ har kaa naam japahu jee-a sadaa. is to chant the Name of the Lord in the heart, forever. ਸਗਲ ਬਾਨੀ ਮਹਿ ਅੰਮ੍ਰਿਤ ਬਾਨੀ ॥ सगल बानी महि अम्रित बानी ॥ sagal baanee meh amrit baanee. Of all speech, the most ambrosial speech ਹਰਿ ਕੋ ਜਸੁ ਸੁਨਿ ਰਸਨ ਬਖਾਨੀ ॥ हरि को जसु सुनि रसन बखानी ॥ har ko jas sun rasan bakhaanee. is to hear the Lord's Praise and chant it with the tongue. ਸਗਲ ਥਾਨ ਤੇ ਓਹੁ ਊਤਮ ਥਾਨੁ ॥ सगल थान ते ओहु ऊतम थानु ॥ sagal thaan tay oh ootam thaan. Of all places, the most sublime place, ਨਾਨਕ ਜਿਹ ਘਟਿ ਵਸੈ ਹਰਿ ਨਾਮੁ ॥੮॥੩॥ नानक जिह घटि वसै हरि नामु ॥८॥३॥ naanak jih ghat vasai har naam. ||8||3|| O Nanak, is that heart in which the Name of the Lord abides. ||8||3|| If all people of the world followed their prescribed faith correctly, we would all comply with Guru's hukum. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Harcharan Singh

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

... · 03 Dec 2005

Harcharan Singh, Sikhi doesn't condemn those who aren't Sikh. It says they will go so far as their religion will take them. Sachkhand is a concept only revealed by Guru Nanak, so is it unreasonable to say only his Sikhs can go there? If there is a map, someone can only use that map to go to destinations it has on it. The Christian map has no more than heaven. Is it discrimination to say that the Christian path/map is not able to direct someone to SachKhand? The shabads you have provided proove my point well about Sikhi. The shabad about being a true Muslim is not translated correctly for one. Where in that shabad is there any mention of "Mohammed"? There isn't any, so where did this translator pull that out? It warps the entire meaning. Guru Sahib has re-defined all the paths. If someone follows his instructions on how to be a true Muslim or a true Pandit or a true Vaishnoo, do they remain those religions? No. They become Sikhs. When Guru Sahib instructs that a true Muslim should believe, [gurbani]mkw imhr rojw pY Kwkw ][/gurbani] Let compassion be your Mecca, and the dust of the feet of the holy your fast. Is that acceptable to a follower of Mohammed? All faiths are not equal.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Typical · 03 Dec 2005

Harcharan Singh Thank you for referring to all those who do not agree with you as fanatics! I though abusing those who do not agree with you was the real definition of fanatic! Strange that we who try to follow Gurbani is totality are fanatics but you who, and I apologise here because this will cause you offence, you cannot even understand the message of Gurbani. ... said if you try and understand the underlying message in the quote you gave then the Muslim and the Pandit who follows the Guru's advice goes out from Islam and Hinduism and becomes a Sikh. ta-o naanak sarab jee-aa mihramat ho-ay ta musalmaan kahaavai. ||1|| And when, O Nanak, he is merciful to all beings, only then shall he be called a Muslim. ||1|| A Muslim is only allowed to be merciful towards fellow Muslims. You are a Sikh and as a non-Muslim are worthless in the eyes of a devout Muslim. If may show as much love and respect towards a Muslim but for him you will remain just a dirty kafir. If you want to experience the Islam as taught by Mohammed just take a trip to Saudi Arabia and take a gutka or even recite the mool mantar and your feet wont touch the ground. Rather than being merciful Muslims are taught to HATE for Allah. If you can equate the beauty of the Gurus teachings to be the same as the message of the Koran then you do not have a proper understanding of both. On a general note it never fails to surprise me when so-called Sikhs try and distort the message of Gurbani just so that they can portray Sikhi as just another religion. We have such people who will try and twist the word KHALSA to mean pure so that the Raj we are promised by the Guru becomes just the Raj of pure people who can be of any religion. We have Sikhs like Harcharan Singh who twist the sakhis to show Guru Nanak praying in a mosque when the sakhis clearly state that Guruji did not perform a prayer.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

LionKing (LK) · 03 Dec 2005

What was the reason for not preforming? He did agre to preform the prayer, the only thing that stopped him was that the Qazi wasn't doing it himself! But did Siri Guru Ji not agree to preform it, if the Qazi would have?

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

... · 03 Dec 2005

LS, So Nirankari Satguru, Guru Nanak Dev jee would have done a prayer acknowledging Mohammed as his prophet? Does that make any sense to you? Or would have just said it but not really meant it? And here Guru Nanak is telling Hindus not to bow to the sun and in Mecca, he told the Muslims bowing to the Kaabah is useless, but he would have joined in the bowing to Mecca in the mosque. Your story doesn't hold water no matter how you look at it.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Dec 2005

There is a huge magnificient Gurdwara called Gurdwara Antaryamta Sahib near the Bus Stand of Sultan Pur Lodhi Town. I just visited it recently. This Gurdwara commerorates the NAMAJ that Guru nanak Ji attended...to PROVE to the Kazi and the Nawab of Sultanpur that BOTH of them were just paying LIP SERVICE while doing Namaaz. The story goes that the Kazi put pressure on the Governor of Sultan Pur Lodhi, that the Nanak you have employed as your Storekeeper should be persuaded to read NAMAAZ with us just to "prove" that He is Impartial as he declares Himself to be..Guur Ji agreed. When the namaaz was over the Kazi complained that Guru Ji DID NOT read the namaaz...Guru ji asked him..With WHOM was I supposed to read it. With ME of course replied the Kazi....BUT my dear Kazi Sahib..you were roaming at your own home, where your mare had given birth to a foal adn you were worried the foal might fall into the well in the courtyard....and WHY didnt you read the namaaz with ME asked the Governor....OH YOU, replied Guru ji, You were in Kandhaar Horse fair busy selecting the best horses for yourself... BOTH were ashamed to Hera that although their BODIES were performing namaaz....their MINDS were elsewhere....that is why this Gurdwara is called ANTARYAMTA SAHIB. as a side note...MOST of us are no better...IF Guru Ji were to sepak up in any Gurdawra, He could find no shortage of "GURSIKHS" sittign there in BODY...but with their MINDS....miles away...maybe He could even find that the Granthi doing the ardass / or the Paathi reading the nauven mahelleh de sloks.....may be just rambling away..while they are actually BUSY elsewhere !!! another veer wrote: Author: uksingh Date: 12-02-05 05:02 parr parr pa(n)ddith baedh vakhaanehi maaeiaa moh suaae || The Pandits, the religious scholars, constantly read and recite the Vedas, for the sake of the love of Maya. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Absolutely CORRECT....out of the hundreds of thousands of Raagis/Granthis/Paathis/ etc who perform Paaths for MONEY, do Kirtan for FEES, etc...this Panktee is 100% correct....For many it is just straight forward BUSINESS..NO MONEY..NO KIRTAN/PAATH !!!

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Kaur · 03 Dec 2005

This discussion can go on forever as long as some Sikhs do not get over their inferiority complex and realize that Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji's path is the only true path. is there a monopoly on God's grace. Well, according to bani, yes. The moolmanter tells us that Akaal Purkh can only be obtained through GURPARSAAD. And the first references from Bhai Gurdaas Ji's vaars say it all. There is no mention of this haumai concept, of whoever gets rid of haumai is what is being referred to. IT clearly states those who have sold themselves to guru ji through giving their heads for amrit and naam. And as for haumai, Bhai Gurdaas Ji also says, Vaheguru gurmantr hai jap haumai khoee. SO the ONLY way to get rid of haumai is though GURMANTER, which is in the hands of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

khalistani · 03 Dec 2005

jus wanna letpeople kno, most bhagaths were hindoozs tha are mentioned in gurbanee, such as bahagth prahlaad je bhagath prahlaad jes sakhee has been around wau before the coming of guru nanak dev je and as for gurughar where guru je met bhagths idunt kno perhaps this did happen not sure i kno guru je in tha roop did not meet bhagath prhlaad and many others this way way before in times of vishnu this is mentioned in purans, the prhalaad sakhee GUR does not only mean guru nanak dev je guru is also akaal bhagath prhalads guru was who? vaheguru himself peoople juus dont getthe thuk JIN PREM KEEO THINK HEE PRABH PAEEO there is one god doesnt matter if u call him raam, hari krishna, alah, yaweh, there is ONE god he is the god of all thers one ONEEEEE sikhs dont own this god vaheguru is there for everyone who has love man bhagath dhannas aand bhagath prhalad jes sakhee shud be proof of this bhula chuka maf

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

... · 03 Dec 2005

Khalistani, this was posted before, but read it here. Guru Granth Sahib tells us that Guru Nanak was the Guru of Prehlad and Dhru. >>>>>> It seems to me (and I could be wrong) that Guru Nanak used to do kirpa on select bhagats and bless them with Gurmat Naam. Svaiyay M: 5 kay tell us "Siri Guru Sahib Sabh Oopar. Karee Kirpa Satjug jin Dhroo par. Sree Prehlaad Bhagat Udhreeang. Haso kamal mathay par dhareeang." This means that Siri Guru Sahib (this clearly means Guru Nanak since it is the Bhattan Day Saviayay and they are talking about glory of Guru Nanak), does kirpa on everyone. In Satjug he blessed Dhroo. He saved Prehlaad. He put his lotus hands on their forehead (I always take this to mean gave them naam, just like naam is give the same way now). In the same bandh it says "Gur parsaad prabh paieeai, gur bin mukat na hoi" meaning only by Guru's grace is Vahiguru found and without a Guru no one is mukat." The very next line says "Guru Nanak Nikat basai banvaree" and goes on to talk about Guru Angad, Guru Amardas and Guru Ram Das. This is all the same bandh, not a new one.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Dec 2005

Guru Granth Ji begins with...EK Oankaar... GURPARSAAD. This Formula is put down in WRITING 567 times in Guru Granth Ji...THAT is the reality Guru ji is trying to tell us....There is ONE OANKAAR and the ONE way to get to Him is through GURPARSAAD. PERIOD.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

typical · 04 Dec 2005

LK Yes, Waheguru so willed it that none of the Muslim participants were doing their prayers with their hearts in it. So Guru Nanak did not have to pray and by doing so accept Mohammed as a prophet. If it was in reality just the fact that Muslims did not have their hearts in their prayers as the reason for Guruji to not perform the Muslim prayers then why is it that we have no other Guru taking part in Muslim prayers. Were all the Muslims that the Gurus knew not earnest in their prayers.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

jugroop singh · 04 Dec 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Dearest Veer Harcharan Singh Ji, you wrote: 'If all people of the world followed their prescribed faith correctly, we would all comply with Guru's hukum' although that statement sounds very nice and positive, such a thing can never be. let's take the following quote from the Qu'ran for instance: 'Men are (meant to be righteous and kind) guardians of women because God has favored some more than others and because they (i.e. men) spend out of their wealth. (In their turn) righteous women are (meant to be) devoted and to guard what God has (willed to be) guarded even though out of sight (of the husband). As for those (women) on whose part you fear ill-will and nasty conduct, admonish them (first), (next) separate them in beds (and last) BEAT them. But if they obey you, then seek nothing against them. Behold, God is most high and great. (4:34) Siree Guru Sahib's Hukam can NEVER be that it is ok to beat your Singhni however, if a Muslim were to 'follow their proscribed faith correctly', then they would naturally in some circumstances beat their wife. there can be no other interpretation - please revise your opinion Veer Ji. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Harcharan Singh · 04 Dec 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Veerji, one of the main aspects that Sikhs are particularly blessed amongst the faiths of the worls is that our hukum was written by our Masters. No other faith makes this claim. Islam alongside all other religions have deviated from their original faith. Is said that the word of God was revealed to the Prophet Mohammed at the time of his meditation in a cave (as happened with Jesus in the wilderness and Guru Nanak Dev Ji at the river). - Please do not be offended, this is not a comparison of our Guru, simply a fact. Mohammed was illiterate, so he dictated the Quraan. The bible is simarly various devotees interpretations/recordings of Jesus's revalations. Both faiths fave been subject to change, political, economic, sociological etc. They have also been edited and added to by people with self-interest, not to mention translated many times. The differences that occur between faiths are exactly this, differences caused by people with self interest, Sikhi is not exempt from this. Look at the different Maryada we have, different Jathas, different interpretations of gurbani etc etc. Please don't look at the differences in faith, look at the similarities for there are many. Every time a faith has lost it's path Waheguru has sent another. Just because our word remains unchanged, does not mean that everyone who bows to Guru ji will be saved. We need to recognise the real message, the universal message, the uniting message, we have to submit, we have spread truth and ahrmony, not division and hate. Can you honestly not see the similarity that some of our people are having with other faiths? The beautiful thing about Sikhi is it does not condemn other paths, it simply shows how people of other paths have lost their way. If we start saying our way is the only way then what is the difference between you and the marauding crusading Christians, or the Mughals or Taliban? In essence you are saying you are all damned only I am saved. Guru Ji says God judges a mans actions, not his faith. Satnaam Harcharan Singh

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

... · 04 Dec 2005

Harcharan Singh, I wish you would take the time to read the replies to your point before posting. As was said to your point earlier: >>>>>>>>>>> Sikhi doesn't condemn those who aren't Sikh. It says they will go so far as their religion will take them. Sachkhand is a concept only revealed by Guru Nanak, so is it unreasonable to say only his Sikhs can go there? If there is a map, someone can only use that map to go to destinations it has on it. The Christian map has no more than heaven. Is it discrimination to say that the Christian path/map is not able to direct someone to SachKhand?

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Harcharan Singh · 04 Dec 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Veerji, Who goes where when we die? Heaven, Nirvana, Sachkand? It doesn't matter what different faiths call it, there is only one place, to think there is a different level or different place for each different faith is ludicrous. Sachkand means the realm of truth, for any human who has lived a life of truth, surely they will go to the realm of truth? We all waste our time arguing about who is better, who will achieve mukti, blah blah, isn't the point of Sikhi to focus on your life and how to live it? Rather than taking it upon yourself to decide who is damned and who is not? We have our revelation, our path, our maryada, be happy, be content, concentrate on yourself. Why waste time doing comparative studies with Zero knowledge as to the evolutionery change in other faiths to prove ours is the best? There is a lack of humility in this attitude. Every faith has a map that is 90% similar to the next faith, focus on the similarities and respect other faiths, Guru Gobiond Singh in his 52 Hukums has commanded us to learn about other faiths, not so we can laugh at them, but so we can genuinely respect and understand the true essence of them as this will help us to understand and respect our faith more. If you have nothing nice to say about other faiths, don't say anything at all. Our Guru's never slandered other faiths, they only identied the false practioners of other faiths. We are not so unique in this sense. You only have to see 90% of Sikh weddings to see how in line our people are with our Guru's hukums. Hindu rituals, pride, ego, show of, alchohol, meat, celeb status, dowry, filthy songs, filthy dressing up...just to mention a few things, what do you think our Guru's would have said about us if they saw us today, that we are the "chosen ones". Not to mention the besti we cause at our Gur Ghar, esp with episodes like that happening in Leamington in the UK, with a full out "Apna Punjab Hovai" party in the Gurdwara. We need to get off our high horses, get our own house in order and revive Gurmat practice accross our Gurdwarai and people before we can even think about critiquing other faiths. Too much time is wasted on negative topics, divisive topics. If we are to make this world a better place as our Guru's intented we need to join hands with all people on common grounds not cause more divisions. Our Guru's were respected by all people because they spoke a common language, a common truth that was recognised by all, be it formerly forgotten by some. Keep this principle. God loves variety, of course we should maintain our unique and distinct image, but we should respect that of other people also. Satnaam Harcharan Singh

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

... · 04 Dec 2005

Harcharan Singh, I am surprised to find you thinking that there is only one place to go when we die and that there are multiple places is ludicrous. When we die, we all go to Dharam Khand. There we are given account of our actions. If we are Gurmukh then there is no account and Dharam Rai gives his respect. Besides reincarnation, Gurbani tells us that there is heaven and hell but they are temporary and a Gursikh doesn't care for them. As for the rest, please reflect on Japji Sahib: Giaan Khand is above Dharam Khand where there are the likes of Buddha, Krishan, Mahesh, Brahama. Then there is Sharam Khand, then Karam Khand where there are great saints who enjoy the love of Vahiguru. Finally there is SachKhand which is above all description. Christians and Muslims know as much as Heaven and Hell. What more can they attain? In this discussion no one has yet explained to me who is the equal of Guru Nanak, from whom someone can get naam and reach Sach Khand? There is none.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

J singh · 04 Dec 2005

ਤਉ ਨਾਨਕ ਸਰਬ ਜੀਆ ਮਿਹਰੰਮਤਿ ਹੋਇ ਤ ਮੁਸਲਮਾਣੁ ਕਹਾਵੈ ॥੧॥ तउ नानक सरब जीआ मिहरमति होइ त मुसलमाणु कहावै ॥१॥ ta-o naanak sarab jee-aa mihramat ho-ay ta musalmaan kahaavai. ||1|| And when, O Nanak, he is merciful to all beings, only then shall he be called a Muslim. ||1|| --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mulims have never been merciful to all beings and never will be, They look with a badd eye on those who have not accepted mohammed.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Sohagani · 04 Dec 2005

"Mulims have never been merciful to all beings and never will be, They look with a badd eye on those who have not accepted mohammed." After reading this thread, Sikhs don't seem much different.

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

khalistani · 04 Dec 2005

it was guru nanak dev je in satjug that saved dhroo and prhlaad guru nanak dev je IS akaal roop guru je is vahegur himself that is y they were saved in satjug it was vaheguru that saved them juis like when bhaat say guru je u wwere vishnu in satjug is guru je vishnu? no guru je was the power behind the great things these devthai did it was GURU Je tha saved dhropadi, not krishna it was vahegurus power regardless of tha fact all these bhagaths had AKAAL as there guru there was no"sikhism" in satjug the path tha the bhagaths followed was the path of prem for one akaal that is the only and tru path in my opinion jin prem keeo thin he prabh paaeo guru je wil judge us on our deeds, actions, and our love for akaal and for his creation so if somenoe is muslim there is no way they can become one wit akaal even if they jaap alah with each and every breath, and show love to all creation? even if they see alah in all creation, they cannot be mukhth? i thought guru je showed us raam and gusaeea was indeed the same there is ONE raam and allah and yaweh and vaheguru is the SAME jin prem keeo thin he prabh paeeo anyone who remebrs vaheguru with each breath, doesn mtter wat e calls god, will become oe with vaheguur in the end if one can abandon there ego, panj dooths, etc. one will become myukhth that uis y naam is sopowerful gurmanta vaheguru is the fastest and most weffective way to do this but even if u jaap alah or nirankar, doesnt meanu will go to a lower realm, u will go to sach khand the thing is most memebers of other religions will not b able to do this w/e most sikhs right now arnt capable of doing this either naam is the highest path remebring vaheguur is the highest path of all alah raam gusaaea niranjan vaheguru the list goes on forever vaheguru has no name, form, etc. these are just expression of akaal gods name isnt vaheguru its the mantar given to us by guru nanak dev je, which is the most powerful mantar by far wat does vaheguru mean? we all prob kno the bhai gurdas jes desrcripiton vava stands for vishnu etc whocame in satjug, meaninng that vaheguur was the tru force behind all thes prohphets etc. and the simple aarth vahe and guru its just praising vaheguru and in deepr aarth saying u were the power tha has held this world together, u were vishnu who saved satjug, it wass U who did everything not the actual man it was VAHEGURU there is only one path and way to vaheguru the path of prem if we can walk on this path, ull beocme mukhth and one wit vaheguru i dunt really see anby point in debating this we all kno that sikhi is the most effective path we can feel this through naam simran and gurbanee if ure path is sikhi, go and keep on going on it no need to belittleothers path to make ure seem better in the end vaheguru will not judge u on if u were sikh, hindo, or muslim ull be judged on wat u have done here i can call myself a gursikh, but truth is, im far from it someone can say they are a muslim, but they cud be far from it we all need to lost our ego, our panj dooths, and jus become immersed in that opower that created us that is the goal i dun kno tha much well al see wa happens when we die, so dw so much jus be a good sikh ureself first tha shud be everyones goal first and foremost bhula chuka maf

Re: Bhai Gurdas on Christians, Muslims & Hindus

Lionking · 05 Dec 2005

Author: Sohagani Date: 12-04-05 16:16 "Mulims have never been merciful to all beings and never will be, They look with a badd eye on those who have not accepted mohammed." After reading this thread, Sikhs don't seem much different. ********************* THanks, what's te difference today? We're exactly the same. Yeah so you want to look it that way, fair enough Yes Guru Nanak, Akal Roop di save Dhur Prehlad, but essentially what I've been tryingto say is - Sikhi was not the onyl way, cause yes Guru anak, Vaheguru Roop, did save Dhru/Prehald/Ajamal/and all other Bhagats before Guru Nanak Dev ji PHYSICALLY CAME, i.e Before Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji PHYSICALLY came to this planet. which means that yes there is other ways. Get a True Guru. Sikhs have a true Guru, thus they don't have too look for one, but one who wants another path can try and fidn another True Guru. In the Bhagat Dhanna Ji thread (article from Panthic Weekly) it is clearly stated that Bhagat Ji become one with Kartar, Akal by joining in Sadh Sangat, and devotional worshipm, not through idol worshippin, but through Devotional WOrship and Sangat, of the Bhagats, before Guru Nanka Dev ji phyically came to this planet. Just to clearify my opinion - NOT ALL religions lead to God, because Some are fake and self-popularity produced (like Guru Gobind SIngh ji meantions in Batchitar Natak), however SOME OTHERS DO. Sikhi DOES, that's why I follow it, because I can say for sure, yes Sikhi Will lead me to merge with Akaal, but this does not mean that no other Paath leads you to Akaal. Apart from that, the TRUE DEVOTIONAL worship, the Sadh Sangat, from Akal Purakh, Vaheguru's, Kartar's Kirpa aalone it comes, and that is something Sikhs do not ahve monopoly over. Regards Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh