Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Good News for Kirpans on Planes

Good News for Kirpans on Planes

G · 02 Dec 2005

http://www.tsa.gov/public/display?theme=40&content=090005198018c349 "Beginning December 22, scissors with a cutting edge of four inches or less and tools such as screwdrivers, wrenches and pliers smaller than seven inches will be permitted on board. Scissors longer than four inches and tools such as crowbars, drills, hammers, and saws will continue to be prohibited from carry-on bags. Lighters will continue to be banned from the cabin of aircraft and in checked baggage." This is good news for American Sikhs! Perhaps they can get a similar exemption for smaller Kirpans? Chardi Kala!

Re: Good News for Kirpans on Planes

LionKing (LK) · 02 Dec 2005

Thing of it is, that if another agent acts as a Sikh and does terrorist activities, Sikh's name are going to be blackened again....

Re: Good News for Kirpans on Planes

.............. · 02 Dec 2005

Here is the full news: TSA Unveils Enhanced Security Screening Procedures and Changes to the Prohibited Items List U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY Transportation Security Administration FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE - December 2, 2005 TSA Press Office: (571) 227-2829 WASHINGTON, D.C. – Beginning December 22, airline travelers can expect to see more random screenings, fewer prohibited items and a Transportation Security Administration (TSA) workforce more dedicated to detecting and defeating more serious threats, such as explosives. These changes are part of an update to security procedures announced today by Assistant Secretary Kip Hawley, to address the ever-evolving threat to commercial aviation. The specific changes include more additional screenings of passengers and their bags using a variety of methods selected at random. Passengers will also once again be able to carry small tools and scissors on-board aircraft. These changes will allow TSA to focus resources on more serious threats. “It is paramount to the security of our aviation system that terrorists not be able to know with certainty what screening procedures they will encounter at airports around the nation,” said Kip Hawley, Assistant Secretary. “By incorporating unpredictability into our procedures and eliminating low-threat items, we can better focus our efforts on stopping individuals that wish to do us harm.” Passengers will continue to walk through a metal detector and have their carry-on and checked baggage screened. However, these measures may now include a brief additional search of their person or their property. Examples of this additional screening include: explosive screening of shoes, hand-wanding of passengers, enhanced pat down searches and inspections of carry-on bags. These searches will be generated at random and will take only about a minute to complete. They will allow Transportation Security Officers (TSOs) to better screen passengers for explosives and other threats to the aviation system. Beginning December 22, scissors with a cutting edge of four inches or less and tools such as screwdrivers, wrenches and pliers smaller than seven inches will be permitted on board. Scissors longer than four inches and tools such as crowbars, drills, hammers, and saws will continue to be prohibited from carry-on bags. Lighters will continue to be banned from the cabin of aircraft and in checked baggage. In addition to these changes, the agency’s 43,000 Transportation Security Screeners have been re-classified as Transportation Security Officers (TSOs). This new classification illustrates that TSOs will be more empowered than ever before to use their knowledge and training to detect and defeat terrorists and to focus their attention to areas where the threat is greatest. For more information regarding TSA, please visit our Web site at www.TSA.gov.

Re: Good News for Kirpans on Planes

jss · 02 Dec 2005

so how do we know if kirpans are allowed?..and will canadian authorities follow suit??

Re: Good News for Kirpans on Planes

moorakh · 02 Dec 2005

Kirpans are not allowed. all self defence and martial arts weapons are still banned. only scissors and other miscellanious items are allowed. kirpans are still banned. please write to the FAA and TSA

Re: Good News for Kirpans on Planes

mai jan Tera · 03 Dec 2005

What about this Kirpan: http://www.sikhgifts.com/pages/products-desc.php?productId=1187 Description A Very Small Kirpan and special design Finished outside in Brass and inside Steel Blade, Ideal for travelling purposes. Dimentions: Length 9cm width 2.3cm with 4cm long 1.5cm blade size. Do you think Airport staff would allow this small kirpan? (and its a gatra kirpan, not necklace kirpan).

Re: Good News for Kirpans on Planes

singh · 03 Dec 2005

it is doubtful that this kirpan (above) will even be allowed, as it is still like a weapon. i have witnessed people have trouble with the "around the neck represenation of a kirpan" kirpans...so i dont think so. additionally, just because it can have a gatra does not mean that it is sufficient...remember the purpose of a kirpan... someday sikhs will have the right to carry kirpans free of hassel and although this law may be a small step in the right direction, it is by no means a "victory" for the right to carry a kirpan. fateh ji!

Re: Good News for Kirpans on Planes

G · 03 Dec 2005

I'm pretty sure this doesn't signify 'acceptance' of Kirpans, but couldn't a strong case could be argued? Maybe the Sikh Coalition or some other American Sikh org. can get involved and try pressing the issue. Also, if we keep calling a Kirpan a 'weapon' then of course we won't be able to carry it on-board, but I think we should first realize that its a bit more than that ourselves, and then explain that to the authorities. If they can understand that a small Kirpan is no more a 'weapon' than scissors or screwdrivers, then it's an easy victory. Gur Fateh!

Re: Good News for Kirpans on Planes

singh · 04 Dec 2005

fateh ji! we as sikhs are in a precarious position, to call the kirpan a weapon or not...i guess ultimately each individual is going to classify the kirpan as they wish, but one this is certain, the kirpan granted to the sikhs by the gurus is meant to be a weapon by all means. noted, it is not a weapon of offense, we do not attack people, but a kirpan is a weapon of mercy and defense. the sikh coalition and such groups are having issue with this as well and such organizations have differing views on what to call the kirpan. the coalition uses the term "benign weapon" or "weapon of benign use" i believe (but only when they can't get away with saying its not a weapon). and other groups like SMART/SALDEF that call it a symbol all together. i personal feel that a sikh should have a right to wear a kirpan that is useable. this is the purpose and this purpose is still relevant today, otherwise the kirpan would be non-issue. swords/daggars/knives still serve a purpose in our modern society and this cannot be forgotten. perhaps "G" ji is right and this can be taken positively...I mean a victory of any size is a victory, but i would like to caution that any precedent set today may have adverse effects on sikh rights in the future - i.e. if we say that a 1.5 cm kirpan is sufficient for sikhs to carry now, then this will become the norm and will be used as guiding precedent for future cases. this could infultrate all aspects of life: school, work, public places, government buildings. anyhow, these are just some of the things that came to my mind when i read about the airline industry loosening its restrictions. i am not saying that the new exceptions are bad for the kirpan, just that as sikhs we should be caustious about what WE are willing to call a kirpan and how WE are willing to classify it. whatever we as a panth/faith/community decided to call the kirpan and what we will accept as a kirpan affects every individual...so my response is based in part on the suggestion that maybe a 1.5 cm replica of a kirpan is a good idea for sikhs to call and kirpan and wear on planes. anyhow, i mean no disrespect to people who choose to wear the replica, but i dont think that for the panth as a whole, such exceptions can lead to a freedom to carry a 7, 9, 12 inch kirpan (and these are "small" by old standards). since these are what most sikhs wear, it would make sense to fight for a right to carry a kirpan of an adiquate size. bhul chuk maaf, guru raka! fateh ji! [%sig%]

Re: Good News for Kirpans on Planes

G · 04 Dec 2005

Fateh Singh ji! What you say makes a lot of sense...I agree that a kirpan should be useable, but at the same time we haven't really defined what the use is on a panthic level. I guess I'm coming from the view that the primary use nowadays is for religious purposes such as 'kirpan bhet' of degh/langer and a symbol of sovereignty/justice/shakti, and its secondary use is as a shaster if needed. So to me, the 6" blade I carry is enough for these purposes, definitely not the neck symbols. I think a kirpan is more than a symbol and more than a weapon. If we call it either of these things, we get into dangerous territory. But maybe I'm wrong? Also, I agree with you that "it is not a weapon of offense, we do not attack people, but a kirpan is a weapon of mercy and defense". But then there's articles like this in the paper which ruin it for us: http://www.tribuneindia.com/2005/20051027/cth1.htm "The police said Joginder Pal Singh, a resident of Sohana village, was on a scooter when he was hit by another scooterist coming from the opposite direction near the Sohana octroi point. The two got into an argument following the accident. Then the other person reportedly took out his kirpan and stabbed Joginder Singh in a fit of anger. " How do we deal with this? Frankly, some of us are not responsible enough to carry kirpans nowadays. I was hoping we can get a small victory out of this, but maybe you're right. If some of our veers/bhens do not believe in 4 inch kirpans, then maybe we're better off not setting this precedent until we've decided ourselves as a community. But then again, reaching consensus is not something we sikhs do particularly well! Thanks for the thoughts, got me thinking! Bhul chuk maaf Wjkk Wjkf! [%sig%]

Re: Good News for Kirpans on Planes

singh · 04 Dec 2005

Fathe Ji, "G" Ji, points well taken, but i dont mean to discourage us. my point is simply that those of us who are able to make a difference and who are becoming educated in the western world need to make sure that we are protecting the rights of all sikhs when we are going out and setting precedents and declaring victories for sikhs. what we do and accept as good for sikhi affects all of us. one thing that i want to perhaps analyze is the kirpan's secondary purposeas a weapon. as far as i have analyzed it is not that there is one purpose over another, but that a kirpan is simultaniously a spiritual representation and a temporal instrament. this is what make the kirpan greater than any knife or any photo...THIS is what in my view make the kirpan such an awesone gift bestowed on us...its so cool that its better than either. i think the sikh community too often tries to put the kirpan (and many aspects of sikhi) into western-created boxes because we feel that we must. sikhi is beyond the boxes and cannot be defined in western terms. for instance defining a kirpan is like trying to convey what "joot" is in english...what do you call it? -somthing "tainted" "germ laden" "unholy" "dirty"? none of these words alone can capture the meaning of this one punjabi word. you have to go beyond using one word and use many to be able to even come close to conveying what it means in the punjabi context. until we are able to realize that sikhi cannot be fit into a western mold we will not be able to have full freedoms. this can only happen if we ourselves become part of the process of making decisions about defining and protecting rights in our home countries. we have to become the scholars and experts who will define what sikhi is. doing so is what the kirpan is all about...standing up for rights. we as sikhs cannot expect foreign countries and people of different backgrounds to be able to always stand up for us...we are to stand up for what we believe is right. often we hear that the pen is the new sword/kirpan and thought it may be true, it is quite an interesting paradox how the two are interrealted. the sword must be taken up if the pen does not work and the pen when the sword does not...but guru ji has put them both concepts int he same article and niether is inferior to the other. anyhow, i urge all sikhs who have the means to get involved and be the catalysts in your local communities. become the lawyers, the professors, and the policy makers who will decide the fate of the sikh nation (by sikh nation i mean the panth/kaum). being doctors and engineers is great, but i think that we need to move beyond subsistance now and create policy. only when we are involved and perpetuating the meaning of the kirpan will we be able to protect our right to carry it. bhul chuk maaf, fateh ji!

Re: Good News for Kirpans on Planes

Tad Brennan · 08 Dec 2005

"until we are able to realize that sikhi cannot be fit into a western mold we will not be able to have full freedoms. this can only happen if we ourselves become part of the process of making decisions about defining and protecting rights in our home countries. we have to become the scholars and experts who will define what sikhi is." I am not a Sikh--I found this website because my children are reading about the Sikh religion, and they wondered whether the kirpan is allowed on planes or not. (I hope in time it will be). I am writing just to say: in time, sikhi *will* fit into a western mold, because the "western mold" will change--it is very flexible. As people like me (and my children) learn more about the world, we change. As people all around America learn more, the entire system changes, and makes all of us more free. And you are right: these changes happen because you "become part of the process of making decisions". So--thank you for taking up the job of "becoming scholars and experts", and helping to educate random readers like me. (And if you have any recommendations for good books for children on Sikhism, I would like to hear them. We have been reading "Sikhism" by Kanwaljit Kaur-Singh.) [%sig%]

Re: Good News for Kirpans on Planes

G · 09 Dec 2005

Hi Tad, Thanks for the heartening comments! Here's a book that may aid you in understanding your Sikh neigbours a bit more http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0595271812/002-8291015-5111268?n=283155 Others may have suggestions as well (?) Take Care!