Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

Sohan Singh · 03 Dec 2005

Vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fathe Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ? Vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fathe

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

Singh · 03 Dec 2005

we are all disabled one way or another jo jo deesai so so rogee rog rahat maeraa satgur jogee

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

LionKing (LK) · 03 Dec 2005

Not according to the Panthic Rehit Maryada - probably due to practicle issue like holding the Batta etc

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

SRM · 03 Dec 2005

Not according to Panthic Sikh Rehat Maryada. All Panj Pyaare must be physically fit and not impaired. On top of knowing Nitnem off by heart, not having EVER committed any of the 4 Kurehats (in accordance to SRM) and are of high moral Gurmukh character (i.e. imbued with the color of Naam and follow rehat)

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

Jj · 03 Dec 2005

"Author: SRM Date: 12-03-05 07:00 Not according to Panthic Sikh Rehat Maryada. All Panj Pyaare must be physically fit and not impaired. On top of knowing Nitnem off by heart, not having EVER committed any of the 4 Kurehats (in accordance to SRM) and are of high moral Gurmukh character (i.e. imbued with the color of Naam and follow rehat)" What do u mean never having commited the Kurehats.. does that mean even if they went to pesh they can never be in th 5?

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

uksingh · 03 Dec 2005

panj must have same form as original panj

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

Gurcharan Singh · 03 Dec 2005

NOT acccording to the Panthic Rehat maryada.All organs and limbs and the person must fully intact of bodily components.. Someone who may have been circumcised for medical reasons or have an organ removed, may be a fully practising amritdhari, but he should not partake in the Panj Piaras.

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

uk singh · 04 Dec 2005

Do the physical qualites (tan) of the Panj Piyare affect the Amrit produced?

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

LionKing (LK) · 07 Dec 2005

Good question UKSINGH Also, how does the spiritual avastha effect the Abilakhe (I cany spell the word), I mean can Person A benifit more from "his Amrit" from another Jathebandi, than Person B with "his Amrit" from another jathebandi, that it is if person A's Panj were more spiritual, so is Person A's Amirt more Amrit? Is it mroe spiritual? I thought it was individual spirituality that counted, as you annot know chih Panj has What avastha, this wouldn't really be fair :s Can someone please shed light on this.

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

moorakh · 07 Dec 2005

so does that mean somebody who had a heart transplant, somebody who had blood donated to them, somebody who had a kidney transplant, somebody who had appendix removed, somebody who had tonsils removed, somebody who had a wisdom tooth removed, somebody whose skin naturally generated itself every 7 years like all human beings somebody whose kes naturally fell off when they did their kanga somebody who lost weight

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

Peak district · 07 Dec 2005

So are you saying that if a person has had there appendix removed but is in very much chardikala naam rang that they would not be considered over someone who is nto so chardikala but has all body function. Do the panj pyaaray have to beexactly the same as they where in orignal panj i.e ages, size sex etc.... or are we to look at there spirituality rather than there physical form

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

Gurcharan Singh · 07 Dec 2005

Bhai sahib, I am only telling you the what the rehat maryada says and what is defined as per tuks of guru Gobind Singhs bani. The rest of the arguments are simply like asking ...does it matter if we keep hair or not we are Sikhs internally.In our heart we are Sikhs.So does it matte rif we keep dharra or not or kesh or not.What happens next is someone will say, I am a khalsa, but becaus eof an accident and injury to my heard, i canot keep long hair but in all other rrespects I am fully amritdhari! Well , shall we say we make an exemption there?As he is a khalsa in all aspects but because medically he cannot keep longhair ...that is fine...really thinking about it ...he is right ...it is not his fault!

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

moorakh · 07 Dec 2005

Could you please show me which Gurbani of Guru Gobind Singh ji says that a disabled person cannot be in the Punj Pyare ? Thank you :)

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

moorakh · 07 Dec 2005

The only situation I can understand that you can't be in the punj pyare is if you don't have hands - to hold the khanda and to hold the batta Or if you don't have legs, to stand in pairadaar seva but if you're missing an ear, or an eye, or a tooth, or a finger, or a toe, but you're an amazing gursikh, i think you can be in the punj ??

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

Singh · 07 Dec 2005

moorakh, I'll show you where in bani it says disabled people can't be punj pyare after you show me where it says how to do an amrit sanchar. Show me where it says what bir asan is or how to administer amrit. All this rehit is oral. Someone missing a limb cannot do seva in the punj pyare. This has been a tradition. They can't participate fully in the sanchar and so they are not included. If someone is missingi an eye, they can't focus both eyes into the bata which is a fundamental part of the seva. A tooth missing doesn't matter.

Re: Can a disabled person be a panj pyaraay ?

Gurcharan Singh · 07 Dec 2005

Bhai sahib , go and read Gur bani, it is not here to be shown this persons own contention or that persons haume. the questions you ask, but none you answer. i suggest you write to the SGPC about it.