Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Chaa and Marayda

Chaa and Marayda

t h u g L i f e · 04 Dec 2005

What is tapoban's marayda on chaa? I heard some singhs are so strict that they dont drink it as they see it as a nasha. But are nashai rreally bad? 4th kurehat is tabacco not nashai, right? Im thinking of drinking like 5 cups of chaa (tea) before i go to a rainsbhee, so i will be able to do simran better, isnt this a good thing? Hearmenowrudeboy [%sig%]

Re: Chaa and Marayda

... · 04 Dec 2005

Bhai Sahib on Coffee & Tea By Bhai Jodh Singh in Soan ChiRee ChaRee GaiN Translated by Admin www.tapoban.org One day Bhai Sahib was sitting during a stay at Kumarhatti when Rattan Singh of Shimla (now Chandigarh), whom Bhai Sahib lovingly used to call Mastaana came and said, "Bapoo jee, you've stopped us from drinking tea, but can we drink coffee? Coffee is made from seeds and there's no trace of tobacco in it." Bhai Sahib, in a very humorous way said very sweetly, "Bhai! There's no difference! Tea is horse urine (ghoRay daa pishaab) and coffee is a donkey's urine (gadhay daa pishaab)!" Everyone doubled over in laughter. Bhai Rattan Singh was laughing the most after hearing this.

Re: Chaa and Marayda

anjaan · 04 Dec 2005

why did bhai sahib stopped singhs from drinking cha? i suppose there is a pamphlet by bhai sahib this jodh singh book yo guys qouting has incorrect facts and will point it latter on with reference

Re: Chaa and Marayda

... · 04 Dec 2005

Re: Chaa and Marayda

P walla! · 04 Dec 2005

So does that mean we can drink it lol??? Could of been a joke...!

Re: Chaa and Marayda

Guruvah · 04 Dec 2005

Then what should Gursikh have for breakfast??Choc milk??:P

Re: Chaa and Marayda

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 04 Dec 2005

Dear "t h u g L i f e" - grow up and stop trying to be some kind of kaala gangsta- your "bling bling fateh" is offensive to true Sikhs

Re: Chaa and Marayda

Kulwant Singh Sandhra · 04 Dec 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I know that Sant Bhindranwale did not drink tea. He served banafsha to people who would come to meet him (e.g. journalists, sangat) when he was staying in Guru Nanak Nivas. Still, I have no record or trace of him saying as to why he abstained from tea. Now as for the article published by Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh, I gather that the only reason he wanted Sikhs to refrain from drinking chaah was because of a conspiracy going on by the muslims (I suspect) to mix tobacco in with tea. If this was true, then that would be a valid argument for one to abstain from drinking chaah. Of course, this was true THEN but nowadays, this kind of stuff does not go on (mixing tobacco with tea). Plus, numerous Gurdwaras around the world serve chaah in langar, and it is an accepted practice. On another note, drinking tea was not a regular habit in Punjab till the British came. Before that time most Sikh people only drank milk or lassi. Later on these drinks were replaced by tea, as I guess it was considered being a sophisticated person. Still a lot of Gurdwaras in Punjab serve lassi with langar. Mmmmmm, I miss drinking fresh lassi from the chaati of the madhaani. [%sig%]

Re: Chaa and Marayda

... · 04 Dec 2005

Kulwant Singh, Bhai Sahib (in the story above) made it clear that the tobbaco issue just seals the debate, even without it, he wasn't in favour. Otherwise why would he not have said coffee was fine?

Re: Chaa and Marayda

singh · 04 Dec 2005

fateh ji! just some thoughts...the reason why cha was forbidden/"varjit" was b/c it was being mixed with tobacco. i dont think this is true in the US or CA but should be checked out. anyhow, one thing that i just want to point out is the REASON for not drinking chaa. it is not just b/c of the tobacco per se, but the notion that it is a drug - nasha. what is and is not a drug is an interesting debate. chaa by itself (assuming it is not indian tobacco laden chaa) is a form of caffine - nasha. so should sikhs stop drinking caffine b/c it excites the nervious system? if chaa for that reason, then what about soda...is soda also nasha? sugar has much the same effects on the body - hence lay people will often say "sugar makes kids hyper." it is not that it makes kids hyper, but that it makes everone hyper - so is sugar nasha? anyhow, the argument can easily be stretched to include anything and everything that gives our bodies any energy, b/c ultimately food is converted to glucose (sugar) so that it may be used by our bodies (though i would not call food - nasha). i am not saying that drinking chaa is good or bad, however, the modern arguement which is often made has more to do with caffine than it does with tobacco (which is where it started according to different sources - one is quoted above and there are other pamphlets - unfortunately i dont have any with me to post). so if the arguemnt is based in caffine as nasha, then and this bars us from drinking soda...then how far can we stretch the purpose of the "4th kurehit" - that nasha is banned... just some thoughts...what do you guys think? fateh ji! [%sig%]

Re: Chaa and Marayda

cyber singh · 04 Dec 2005

http://coffeetea.about.com/cs/whimsy/a/timsnicotine.htm i should point out i have heard that nicotine is contained in tea bags

Re: Chaa and Marayda

khalistani · 04 Dec 2005

it is cause of the caffine thas y some sikhs also dont drink coke, etc. caffine is a hugly addictive thing even ure techers can tell u y coke, etc. is bad because of caffine it gets u all exicted, its addictive,etc. if u actually take a tea bad and smoke it, ull get high bhula chuka maf

Re: Chaa and Marayda

singh · 05 Dec 2005

did you know that you could get drunk off of water?

Re: Chaa and Marayda

singh · 05 Dec 2005

There is no proof of Bhai Sahib stopping singhs from drinking coffee. Cha was stopped when Singhs found out that at Rajpura a gang was recycling USED chapatti (which has already been brewed once) as tea was an expensive commodity. This gang took USED cha patti and mixed all sorts of ingredients to make it just like normal cha patti. They mixed crushed leather pieces so that it leaches color when brewed and also added small amounts of nicotine to give a kick. This recycled patti was then dried in big tubs on smouldring coals at the rajpura railway station (those days steam engines got rid of expended coals at rajpura as rajpura was middle of the main line between ambala and ludhiana). That was the reason Bhai Randhir Singh Ji stopped cha. In the langar at narangwal before this cha was always available who ever wanted it. Even in jail chittian they used to prepare 'chata' (cha with many other ingredients) and have battey full of it.

Re: Chaa and Marayda

Singh · 05 Dec 2005

I have not drunk tea for a decade. It just punjabi lethargic and lazy. Some people cannot do anything without a cup of tea.

Re: Chaa and Marayda

-- · 05 Dec 2005

Khalsa Cha all the way guys, caffeine and therefore nasha free! yum yum for khalsa cha. no this is not an advertisement. haha, sorry.

Re: Chaa and Marayda

Lionking · 05 Dec 2005

Khalistani, although caffiene does have an effect, but it's nothing major at all. That would bann you from Chocolate, Coke, Cha, Coffee There are even, what we acll "nasha" in everything else to Just to clearify, I don't drink Cha, or Coffee, I think it's disgustign by, the reaason most old peopel drink it, is because it gives them energy from the Sugar, and yes the caff. lol about gettign high of smoking tea =D Thing of it, si that "nasha" is contained in everything, everything - there's no getting away from it - it's your intention of takign it - Is it to take it, and get high and do wrong things is it to fill ur stomach, or is it to getr the nice taste (even roti has nasha... - what's your intention?) Is it to get energy or is it to get high. I've one person high on Coke, and that person drink quite a lot of Coke, like a few liters a day. Bhull chukk maaf Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Chaa and Marayda

Gurnekh Singh · 05 Dec 2005

Most sants for eg...Sant baba Karam Singh Ji Hoti Mardaan,Santa Baba Jawala Singh Ji Harkhowaal even Sant Baba Jagjit Singh Ji Harkowaal wale dont drink tea becus it effects ur body n therefore state of mind..Ne fin that effects ur body is harmless for ppl who wish to go to the higher stages of bhagti.The body shud be at a point where the state of the mind is balanced,temperature shud not be too high or too low ,shud be balanced to enter intense samadhi.if temperatures differ,then hormones go abit crazy yeh and then trigger off thoughts n feelings of different nature to the ones of simran and bhagti.State of mind needs to be balanced..chaa doesnt help dats why seen as a nasha.for sum it becums a habit like alcohol .nefin dat becums a nasha apart from the real meditation is a drug ,a nasha!!

Re: Chaa and Marayda

Singh · 05 Dec 2005

Vaheguru Jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee fateh Simple answers are always the best. If you think yoou will further your sikhi by doing something then do it. If drinking tea/coffee makes you do more simran then drink barrells of it, but surely you will find that simran will stop. Let simran be your guide. Vaheguru Jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee fateh