Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Debunking the Bhagat Dhanna Idol Story

Debunking the Bhagat Dhanna Idol Story

... · 04 Dec 2005

http://www.panthic.org/news/132/ARTICLE/2050/2005-12-04.html Bhagat Dhanna Ji: Story of Worshipping a Stone? Sunday 4th December, 2005 Panthic Weekly Columnist (KP) - Bhagat Dhanna Ji’s father’s name was Bhai Maahee Ji. His family belonged to the MaarvaaR area in Rajasthan. They were simple land-owner farmers. Bhagat Dhanna Ji obtained a ‘Saalgaraam’ (small stone idol) from a Brahman, and began doing its pooja (worship). He decorated the idol and prepared food, which he placed before it. However, the idol did not speak, nor did eat or do anything! Disappointed, he returned back to the Brahman and returned the stone idol. He said to the Brahman, “The stone idol god seems angry with me, as he is not eating the food I prepare.” The Brahman told him the real the truth of the matter to Bhagat Dhanna Ji: “This is a stone, it does not eat or drink, God is someone else.” This incident had a profound effect on Bhagat Dhanna Ji and eventually he joined the Sangat of Gurmukhs like Bhagat Ramanand Ji. Sadly, there are many stories told in our Gurdwaré by ignorant Katha-vaachiks and parchaariks (preachers). These distorted stories of Bhagat Dhanna Ji have been coined up by dubious individuals and groups who have an agenda. Gurmat is clear that idol-worship is fruitless and by worshipping a stone, one drowns with it! So, how can we have a story that says that Bhagat Dhanna Ji made food and put if before the stone idol. The stone idol did not eat the food and Bhagat Dhanna Ji remained hungry, as he was not going to eat until the Lord eats first. Not being able to see His devotee go hungry and go through this torment, God revealed himself through the stone statue and ate the food. Seeing this miracle Bhagat Dhanna Ji became happy. This version of the story is nonsense. When our Guru is alive and with us, then why do we place such faith in such distorted stories? Why not ask Guru Sahib for the answer? Well, if we placed more faith in Guru Granth Sahib Ji rather than twisted historians, ignorant parchaariks and RSS propaganda then we would not bee in this confusion. ਨਾਮਾ ਜੈਦੇਉ ਕੰਬੀਰੁ ਤ੍ਰਿਲੋਚਨੁ ਅਉਜਾਤਿ ਰਵਿਦਾਸੁ ਚਮਿਆਰੁ ਚਮਈਆ ॥ ਜੋ ਜੋ ਮਿਲੈ ਸਾਧੂ ਜਨ ਸੰਗਤਿ ਧਨੁ ਧੰਨਾ ਜਟੁ ਸੈਣੁ ਮਿਲਿਆ ਹਰਿ ਦਈਆ ॥7॥ "Naam Dev, Jai Dev, Kabeer, Trilochan and Ravi Daas the low-caste leather-worker, blessed Dhanna and Sain; all those who joined the humble Saadh Sangat, met the Merciful Lord, Waheguru. ||7||" (Bilaaval, Ang 835, SGGS) Guru Raam Daas Ji is clear of how Bhagat Dhanna Ji met and experienced Waheguru. Is it through worshipping a lifeless stone? Is it through God revealing himself through a stone? No. It is through the “Saadh Sangat”, the company of the Holy. Furthermore Guru Arjan Dev Ji has also said in Gurbani how Bhagat Dhanna Ji became a devotee of God and became absorbed into Waheguru. And the answer is not that he saw God in a lifeless stone idol. ਮਹਲਾ 5 ॥ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ ਸੰਗਿ, ਨਾਮਦੇਉ ਮਨੁ ਲੀਣਾ ॥ ਆਢ ਦਾਮ ਕੋ ਛੀਪਰੋ, ਹੋਇਓ ਲਾਖੀਣਾ ॥1॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ ਬੁਨਨਾ ਤਨਨਾ ਤਿਆਗਿ ਕੈ, ਪ੍ਰੀਤਿ ਚਰਨ ਕਬੀਰਾ ॥ ਨੀਚ ਕੁਲਾ ਜੋਲਾਹਰਾ, ਭਇਓ ਗੁਨੀਯ ਗਹੀਰਾ ॥1॥ ਰਵਿਦਾਸੁ ਢੁਵੰਤਾ ਢੋਰ ਨੀਤਿ, ਤਿਨਿ ਤਿਆਗੀ ਮਾਇਆ ॥ ਪਰਗਟੁ ਹੋਆ ਸਾਧ ਸੰਗਿ, ਹਰਿ ਦਰਸਨੁ ਪਾਇਆ ॥2॥ ਸੈਨੁ ਨਾਈ ਬੁਤਕਾਰੀਆ, ਓਹੁ ਘਰਿ ਘਰਿ ਸੁਨਿਆ ॥ ਹਿਰਦੇ ਵਸਿਆ ਪਾਰਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ, ਭਗਤਾ ਮਹਿ ਗਨਿਆ ॥3॥ ਇਹ ਬਿਧਿ ਸੁਨਿ ਕੈ ਜਾਟਰੋ, ਉਠਿ ਭਗਤੀ ਲਾਗਾ ॥ ਮਿਲੇ ਪ੍ਰਤਖਿ ਗੁਸਾਈਆ, ਧੰਨਾ ਵਡ ਭਾਗਾ ॥4॥2॥ “Fifth Mehl: Naam Dayv's mind was absorbed into Waheguru, Gobind, Gobind, Gobind. The calico-printer, worth half a shell, became worth millions. ||1||Pause|| Abandoning weaving and stretching thread, Kabeer enshrined love for the Waheguru's lotus feet. A weaver from a lowly family, he became an ocean of excellence. ||1|| Ravi Daas, who used to carry dead cows every day, renounced the world of Maya. He became famous in the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy, and obtained the Blessed Vision of the Waheguru's Darshan. ||2|| Sain, the barber, the village drudge, became famous in each and every house. The Supreme Lord Waheguru dwelled in his heart, and he was counted among the devotees. ||3|| Hearing this, Dhanna the Jaat (farmer) applied himself to devotional worship. Waheguru, the Lord of the Universe met him personally; Dhanna was so very blessed. ||4||2||” (Aasa, Ang 488, SGGS) “Hearing this, Dhanna the Jaat (farmer) applied himself to devotional worship” (ਇਹ ਬਿਧਿ ਸੁਨਿ ਕੈ ਜਾਟਰੋ, ਉਠਿ ਭਗਤੀ ਲਾਗਾ ॥) Hearing what? Guru Sahib gives the answer to this question by reading the full shabad together. By reading the shabad by using the line “Hearing this” (ਇਹ ਬਿਧਿ ਸੁਨਿ ਕੈ). Bhagat Dhanna Ji heard the praise of Bhagat Naam Dev Ji, he heard of the state of Bhagat Kabeer Ji, he heard the way of Bhagat Ravidaas Ji, and he heard of the popularity of Bhagat Sain Ji. Hearing this, feeling of loving-devotion and wanting to do Bhagti welled up within Bhagat Dhanna Ji. Guru Arjan Dev Ji placed this shabad purposefully in Bhagat Dhanna Ji’s Bani, illustrating that the ignorant people of Guru Sahib’s time were being misled on how Bhagat Dhanna Ji began his Bhagti (devotional worship) through ridiculous stories about idol worship. Those stories have been dismissed with this shabad, as it is written in the shabad that the real reason for Bhagat Dhanna Ji being absorbed in Waheguru was through being inspired by hearing the spiritual state of Bhagat Naam Dev Ji, Bhagat Ravidaas Ji, and Bhagat Sain Ji. If we try to find the truth from Sri Guru Granth Sahib, and instead of following stories passed down from others, which are mixed with lines of Gurbani, we should take the benefit of going straight to the source of truth. If we did this, then there would be no confusion or duality over Bhagat Dhanna Ji. If Bhagat Dhanna Ji met Waheguru through worshipping a stone, then this means that as a result of Guru Arjan Dev Ji including the Bani of a someone who has supposedly found God by worshipping a stone, Guru Sahib has accepted that one can meet and experience God through a lifeless stone. But Guru Sahib’s Hukam (order) is: ਜਿਸੁ ਪਾਹਨ ਕਉ ਠਾਕੁਰੁ ਕਹਤਾ ॥ ਉਹੁ ਪਾਹਨੁ ਲੈ ਉਸ ਕਉ ਡੁਬਤਾ ॥2॥ ਗੁਨਹਗਾਰੁ ਲੂਣ ਹਰਾਮੀ ॥ ਪਾਹਨ ਨਾਵ ਨ ਪਾਰਗਰਾਮੀ ॥3॥ “That stone, which he calls his god, that stone pulls him down and drowns him. ||2||” (Soohee, Ang 739, SGGS). Therefore, it is clear that Bhagat Danna Ji did not experience Waheguru through worhsipping a stone, but instead through the Saadh Sangat and being inspired by other Bhagats.

Re: Debunking the Bhagat Dhanna Idol Story

Lionking · 05 Dec 2005

Nice article. thanks for posting =) A quick question though - [i]“Fifth Mehl: Naam Dayv's mind was absorbed into Waheguru, Gobind, Gobind, Gobind. The calico-printer, worth half a shell, became worth millions. ||1||Pause|| Abandoning weaving and stretching thread, Kabeer enshrined love for the Waheguru's lotus feet. A weaver from a lowly family, he became an ocean of excellence. ||1|| Ravi Daas, who used to carry dead cows every day, renounced the world of Maya. He became famous in the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy, and obtained the Blessed Vision of the Waheguru's Darshan. ||2|| Sain, the barber, the village drudge, became famous in each and every house. The Supreme Lord Waheguru dwelled in his heart, and he was counted among the devotees. ||3|| Hearing this, Dhanna the Jaat (farmer) applied himself to devotional worship. Waheguru, the Lord of the Universe met him personally; Dhanna was so very blessed. ||4||2||” (Aasa, Ang 488, SGGS)[/i] Another Shabad that comes to mind is - Trilochan says, O Naam Dayv, Maya has enticed you, my friend. Why are you printing designs on these sheets, and not focusing your consciousness on the Lord? ||212|| Naam Dayv answers, O Trilochan, chant the Lord's Name with your mouth. With your hands and feet, do all your work, but let your consciousness remain with the Immaculate Lord. ||213|| This brigns confusion. So I decided to look up at Guru Granth Sahib Ji Darpan, and I think that the first translation is a bit dodgy - Abandoning weaving and stretching thread, Kabeer enshrined love for the Waheguru's lotus feet. A weaver from a lowly family, he became an ocean of excellence. ||1|| Ravi Daas, who used to carry dead cows every day, renounced the world of Maya. [gurbani](k`pVw) auxn (qwxw) qxn (dI lgn) C`f ky kbIr ny pRBU-crnW nwl lgn lw leI; nIvIN jwiq dw grIb julwhw sI, guxW dw smMudr bx igAw [1[ rivdws (pihlW) in`q moey hoey pSU FoNdw sI, (pr jdoN) aus ny mwieAw (dw moh) C`f id`qw, swD sMgiq ivc rih ky au~Gw ho igAw, aus ƒ prmwqmw dw drSn ho igAw [2 [/gurbani] What Guru Jee is saying is, that he left the "lagan" or "attachment" of working i.e earnign mroe and more money, an instead attached himself to the Shabad. THe English translation implies that he litteraly elft work, to do Something else, i.e Bhagti, btu as mentioend above, a Gurmuhk doens't ned to leave hsi work, only the attachment and urge to make more and mroe money bhull chukk maaf Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Debunking the Bhagat Dhanna Idol Story

learning sikh · 05 Dec 2005

thanks for good post. Panthic weekly are seeming to be doing great sewa with their interesting articles on Gurmat. I learn a lot from the articles. bhula chuka maaf

Re: Debunking the Bhagat Dhanna Idol Story

Gareebi · 05 Dec 2005

Great post by Panthic Weekly.

Re: Debunking the Bhagat Dhanna Idol Story

khalistani · 05 Dec 2005

bwmHx pUjY dyvqy DMnw gaU crwvx AwvY] baamhan poojai dhaevathae dhha(n)naa goo charaavan aavai|| A brahman would worship gods (in the form of stone idols) where Dhanna used to graze his cow. DMnY ifTw cilq eyh puCY bwmHx AwK suxwvY] dhha(n)nai ddit(h)aa chalith eaeh pushhai baamhan aakh sunaavai|| On seeing his worship, Dhanna asked the brahman what he was doing. Twkur dI syvw kry jo ieCy soeI Pl pwvY] t(h)aakur dhee saevaa karae jo eishhae soee fal paavai|| “Service to the Thakur (God) gives the desired fruit,” replied the brahman. DMnw krdw jodVI mYN iB dyh iek jo quD BwvY] dhha(n)naa karadhaa jodharree mai(n) bh dhaeh eik jo thudhh bhaavai|| Dhanna requested, “O brahman, if you agree kindly give one to me.” p`Qr iek lpyt kr dy DMny noN gYl CufwvY] paathhar eik lapaett kar dhae dhha(n)nae no(n) gail shhuddaavai|| The brahman rolled a stone, gave it to Dhanna and thus got rid of him. Twkur noN nHwvwlky Cwih rotI lY Bog cVHwvY] t(h)aakur no(n) nhaavaalakae shhaahi rottee lai bhog charrhaavai|| Dhanna bathed the Thakur and offered him bread and buttermilk. hQ joV imMnq kry pYrIN pY pY bhuq mnwvY] hathh jorr mi(n)nath karae pairee(n) pai pai bahuth manaavai|| With folded hands and falling at the feet of the stone he begged for his service to be accepted. hauN bI mUMh n juTwlsW qUM ruTw mYN ikhu n suKwvY] hou(n) bee moo(n)h n jut(h)aalasaa(n) thoo(n) rut(h)aa mai(n) kihu n sukhaavai|| Dhanna said, “I will also not eat because how can I be happy if you are annoyed.” goseIN prq`K hoie rotI Kwie Cwih muih lwvY] gosee(n) parathaakh hoe rottee khaae shhaahi muhi laavai|| (Seeing his true and loving devotion) God was forced to appear and eat his bread and buttermilk. Bolw Bwau goivMd imlwvY ]ñó] bholaa bhaao govi(n)dh milaavai ||aa|| In fact, innocence like that of Dhanna makes the sight of the Lord available. like ive said before, it is our prem and love for god that will unite us with him, our innocence that is the tru and only path to vaheguru jin prem keeo thin hee prabh paeoo bhula chuka maf

Re: Debunking the Bhagat Dhanna Idol Story

Guru Ji Himmat Baksho · 05 Dec 2005

hello? did you read the Gurbani shabads?? Gurbani is the truest of the true and PERFECT. "bhullan andhar sabh kau, ABHUL GURU KARTAAR" the key source of truth is Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji. period.

Re: Debunking the Bhagat Dhanna Idol Story

khalistani · 05 Dec 2005

r u sayin bhaagth dhanna je made a MISTAKE?:s okkk' im sure ure avastha is waaay higher than theres people jus dont get it its PREEM if we put the faith in the STONE itself then we will drown bhagath dhanna out of inncocence literally thought the stone was god he shows the stone so much devotion, which he thought was truly god, tha vaheguru cud not see his devotion go unnoitced read bhai gurdas jes vaar man at the end of the day bhagath dhanna je got darshan of akaal and became on wit him it was through there innocenece and prem amazing to see people jus discard things and look at other things to make ther epoints valid THIS IS Y we have contrevaries in our panth people jus like to think of w/e they want, no one listenes to gurbanee READ BHAI GURDAS JES VAARR bhula chuka maf

Re: Debunking the Bhagat Dhanna Idol Story

jss · 05 Dec 2005

khalistani veer is right bhai gurdas ji's vaars are very explicit..in that they leave no room for silly interpretations and over thinking.. and it is said that guru arjan devji proclaimed bhai gurdas ji's vaars the kunjee to guru granth sahib... that is why any gurmukh who has led a highly spiritual life of naam simran will also have been very familiar with bhai gurdas ji's vaars...as well as guru granth sahib...