Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Capital Punishment & Sikhi

Capital Punishment & Sikhi

thought · 05 Dec 2005

I was reflecting on whether capital punishment (execution) could be acceptable according to Gurmat. I don't think it can be. Where there is the ability or at least the opportunity to reform a wrong-doer, it is important to choose that route. Where that route is not availabe, then killing is just and appropriate. When there were Mughal or Afghan opressors, and the Singhs could not capture and imprison them, then killing them was the appropriate action. But where they could capture them and hold them I believe Singhs did choose that option as can be seen from the following extract: >>>>>>>>>> The present structure of the Harmindar Sahib was constructed by the Khalsa Panth in 1765. The old structure was blown up in 1782 by Ahmed Shah Durrani to subdue the Sikhs. He filled the pool with debris and dead cows to desecrate it. He was told by the Governor of Lahore that the pool and the Harimandar Sahib are the source of the life of the Sikhs. With the hope of ending Sikh power, he destroyed the holy place. The Sikhs stood up for their rights and within three years became strong enough to defeat the Afghans and to hold many of their soldiers as prisoners during 1764. To teach them a unique kind of lesson, they made those very soldiers clean Amritsar pool and then released them without any further punishment. No one was tortured or murdered for desecrating the holy place >>>>>>>>>>> So where the wrong-doer cannot be subdued then elimination is acceptable, but where capture is possible, then that should be the option taken. In the USA, murder is often punished by execution. But in Sikh history we know that even serial killers and cannibals can be reformed into good Gursikhs. Sajjan Thugh was a serial killer and robber. He went on to make the first Sikh Dharamshala and is remembered as a bhagat. Kauda Raksh was a cannibal but became a Bhagat. Execution does not allow for reform. If someone commits a horrible crime, is then sentenced to death but between the sentence and execution is reformed and becomes a good person, there is no accomodation. S/He is still killed. This is not justice. Even a totally new and reformed person is still killed. If even the worst criminal realises the error in his/her ways, accepts Guru Sahib and receives amrit, they are given a new life. It would not be possible according to Gurmat to punish this person with death after this. As Sikhs, we believe that [gurbani]pUrw inAwau kry krqwru ][/gurbani] Kartar (the creator) does perfect justice. Humans are not capable of doing perfect justice. Mistakes can be made. But to make that mistake permanent and final by taking a life could be a massive sin. Daya or mercy is fundamental in Sikhi. As Sikhs I don't think it is possible to support capital punishment.

Re: Capital Punishment & Sikhi

G · 06 Dec 2005

What about Guru ji burning the masands alive? Is that not capital punishment? Gur Fateh!

Re: Capital Punishment & Sikhi

?? · 06 Dec 2005

What about Guru ji burning the masands alive? Is that not capital punishment? Is it a historical fact or a myth. are u able to give any actual facts and dates of this happening. because there are too many things made up in the sikh history by the non sikhs.

Re: Capital Punishment & Sikhi

... · 06 Dec 2005

Even if Guru Sahib did burn the masands, it doesn't violate the argument presented in the above writeup. Guru Sahib could give perfect justice. He couldn't make any mistake and was perfect. We don't have that ability. Maybe keeping the masands prisoner was impossible, who knows? But as I said before, only Guru Sahib or Akaal Purakh are perfect. We make mistakes. We cannot give perfect justice. Still the points have not been addressed: what if someone sentenced to death reforms? Then what? What if a mistake is made in the trial and an innocent person is sentenced to death?

Re: Capital Punishment & Sikhi

singh · 07 Dec 2005

depends on the severity of the crime i reckon. if somone raped tortured then killed someone in you family then says " im gonna reform so allow me to live": like what do you do? what about kps gill indra ghandi mir mannu if they were caught put their hands up and said we will reform should we just forgive?

Re: Capital Punishment & Sikhi

LionKing (LK) · 07 Dec 2005

Yeah, what if Indhira Gandhi truelly, sincerely regretted what she did.. how would Sikhs act....? Also, I very much doubt the masand story, and would myself, liek to see histroical evidence for this, especialyl considering I first heard heard it from Maan su (the person accused of being a rapist)... [%sig%]

Re: Capital Punishment & Sikhi

... · 07 Dec 2005

KP Gill, if he became and amritdhari and openly said what he did was wrong and preached it, would definitely be worth more than a dead KP Gill. Same goes for Indira or anyone else.

Re: Capital Punishment & Sikhi

LionKing (LK) · 07 Dec 2005

"..." So what we force them to convert? lol So if Indhira Gandhi would confess she was wrong and preach she was wrong, but still wanted to be a hindu, she would still be shot? lol

Re: Capital Punishment & Sikhi

Harcharan Singh · 07 Dec 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh As an example of the short Khasla Raj (50 years) during Ranjit Singhs reign, it is a recorded fact that there was not even one example of capital punishment. Our Guru's or any famous Gursikhs thereafter have never partook in capital punishment. Satnaam. Harcharan Singh

Re: Capital Punishment & Sikhi

G · 08 Dec 2005

I haven't verified in a book anywhere, but have regularly seen it mentioned on this board. Here's a link to a post where it's detailed how Guru Ji treated masands http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=52290&t=51792#reply_52290 <> Btw, I personally do not condone killing someone for a crime that already happened and don't believe this story either. I was just being a devil's advocate to get the debate rolling. Bhul chuk di khima bakshni! Wjkk Wjkf! [%sig%]

Re: Capital Punishment & Sikhi

asdf · 08 Dec 2005

<< what if Indhira Gandhi truelly, sincerely regretted what she did.. how would Sikhs act....? >> That is impossible because she had a plan and would have eliminated all sikhs if given the opportunity. imho only guru or punj can hand out punishments because they are least likely to have any selfish motives.