Daily Express front page sensationalises the Kirpan in Schools
Jagjit Singh · 06 Dec 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguruji ke fateh
Pyare jio, on the way to work this morning I saw a pictire of a kirpan on the front page of the Daily Express. The Daily Express has in recent years taken the mantle from the Daily Mail, as the most right-wing daily newspaper, with often stories against Muslims, questioning political correctness. This is their favourite subject, with immigration.
Todays headline is "Now the Cross is Banned". I would have cut and paste it, but the newspaper website does not allow that function. But it can be seen on the top corner of their website.
http://www.express.co.uk/index.html#
It is about a young girl called Sam Morris, who has been banned from wearing a crucifix to her local Sinfin Community School in Derby. The paper claims the situation is "crazy" compared to the fact that male Sikhs are allowed to wear Kirpans to the same school. Then it has a picture of a large 2-3ft kirpan. The front page is very sensationalist to outrage as much as possible. The article is continued on page 7 of the paper, with another picture of the necklace and the big kirpan next to it.
The article has numerous quotes from Christian organisations and Derby Council. It also has two line quotes from harmander Singh and Bhupinder Singh for Sikhs.
I have complete sympathy for the girl, but the manner is which the kirpan is being used is wrong. Further the sensationalist way in which it is depicted with only create alarm in parents of children who are ignorant of Sikhs.
It is typical tabloid article designed to cause outrage, sell newspapers, and care little about its affects and aftermath.
Call all Sikhs write to the editor and comaplin at the following
[address removed]
Please write sensible letters. Do not swear and threaten,. otherwise theis right-wing paper that loves to denigrate minorities, whill just carry the headline, -"Sikh extremists threaten editor". So please write in an articulate that most sikhs use everyday. Below is the email I sent - if you need a guide.
Please do not cut and paste and send, please write in your own words.
...........
Dear Sir/Madam,
I am writing about your depiction of the kirpan on your front page article, "Now the Cross is Banned".
I have complete sympathy with Sam Morris and her case to wear her cross, and I have often wondered why Christians are not more forthright in their expression of religion. I have never come across any ethnic minority that is offended by other religions, or their festivals, in the manner of stories that today frequent newspapers.
However the manner in which you have used the Sikh kirpan is highly irresponsible. Young sikhs do face a hard time in Schools, especially due to their distinct appearance. Bullying and name-calling is common. It is not that many years since a talented young sikh boy called Vijay Singh in Manchester was driven to suicide to escape the bullying. Today we see children helplines busy dealing with these problems. I personally I think your article will just cause disafffection in youth, and create unneccessary alarm in parents of all school children.
Your pictures of the kirpans are larger size, probably a 2 or 3 foot one, which is nothing like a small 5 inch kirpan which baptised Sikhs wear. I feel this depiction will just create alarm in those who are ignorant of Sikhism. Especially in todays climate wear even a pencil sharpener is a dangerous weapon. I had expected better from a national daily newspaper.
Sikh organisations have spent many years consulted with the department of Edication, Health and Safety groups to ensure the small kirpan is acceptable and is represented in the correct manner.
Young baptised sikhs, who are male and female, (you just mentioned males) are highly disciplined in conduct and meditation, which is why you do not get incidents with use of the kirpan. They are incomparable to the "hoody culture" and hoodlums who prey on kids in schools, with knives.
Your choice to wage war on political correctness is your perogative, but bringing Sikhs into it is highly irresponsible. This kind of behaviour and sensationalistic journalism only creates more tension in communities, rather than educates.
Sikhs are an integral part of Modern Britian. The Audit Office recognises them as the most successful ethnic group, and with over 85,000 Sikh giving their lives in World Wars, I would hope they are accepted as such. Very few ethnic groups have made such a contribution to Britian.
Your Sincerely,
Mr Jagjit Singh,
Horbury,
West Yorkshire.
Re: Daily Express front page sensationalises the Kirpan in Schools
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 07 Dec 2005
Dear editor,
I have just seen a story on 5 News, in connection with a student from Sinfin
Community School, who was not granted permission to wear a crucifix attached
to a necklace, while present at the school.
It was mentioned (also on the 5 News website), a quote from the Daily Express,
that Sikh students were allowed to wear a steel bangle (kara) and kirpan
(dagger) at the same school without being questioned.
Please can I take this opportunity to point out that the kara and kirpan
are not merely "symbols" of the Sikh faith, but are a compulsory part of
the Sikh identity and are considered as important as the limbs of one's body.
These are 2 of a total of 5 items that clearly distinguish a Sikh from members
of other faiths and have been bestowed upon Sikhs by the tenth and final
living guru - Gobind Singh, upon the initiation of the Khalsa, on April 13th
1699.
Sikhs have fought alongside the British in both world wars and now we form
an important part of British society.
I fully understand the importance of adhering to the rules of any institution,
be it an educational one, or otherwise.
Wearing a necklace with a religious symbol- be that may a crucifix OR khanda
(Sikh religious symbol) would and should, be treated as jewellery.
I would humbly ask that your reporters thoroughly research the reasons and
justification behind such subjects, before any comments are made in the press,
as we are all too aware of the current situation regarding religious and
cultural intolerance.
I would greatly appreciate some feedback to my e-mail.
Yours,
Pardeep Singh Sanghera
Re: Daily Express front page sensationalises the Kirpan in Schools
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 07 Dec 2005
At least some papers have sensible reporters/columnists- This is from Sue Carroll of the Daily Mirror
CHRISTIAN BELIEFS
IN A school where Sikh pupils are allowed to wear a bangle, compulsory to their religion, 16-year-old Sam Morris was ordered to remove her gold crucifix because Sinfin Community School's jewellery policy forbids anything other than a watch and small stud earrings. Cue her furious mum Debra Saunders, who says: "Sam has just as much right to celebrate her own religion."
Oh dear. Without wishing to cast any doubt on the strength of her Christian beliefs, you do wonder how many girls wear the crucifix as a symbol of their religious commitment. I'm reminded of the supposedly true story of two chavs overheard admiring crucifixes in a jeweller's window. "Have you got any," one asked the shop assistant, "without that little bloke on?"
Re: Daily Express front page sensationalises the Kirpan in Schools
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 07 Dec 2005
Ssd- stop your silly gora talk- the goray are self-centred- they never cared about us in India and they definitely don't care about us here...
Loof after no.1 - SIKHS
Re: Daily Express front page sensationalises the Kirpan in Schools
Gurcharan Singh · 07 Dec 2005
SSd this is the mentality some people have sadly, such droppings will never make khalistan ..no matter how they shout ..until their tongues hang dry ...it is just the big wide unwashed mouth that fires off..not an iota of mantality.
Re: Daily Express front page sensationalises the Kirpan in Schools
Jagjit Singh · 08 Dec 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare ssd - most of letters amd emails that sikhs have been sending, state they are sympathetic to the girl. Also the quotes in the paper of the Sikh representatives, also state the same.
Sikhs are sympathetic, but we cannot help if wearing a cross is not fundamental to christian religion. that is something Christianity has to sort out. This is what the headmaster is saying, what is fundamental and whatis not?
I think a middle way can be sorted out quite simply, but that is for the people at the heart of the matter to sort out.
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Daily Express front page sensationalises the Kirpan in Schools
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 08 Dec 2005
Gurcharana wrote "SSd this is the mentality some people have sadly, such droppings will never make khalistan"
here you go again- you are like a kutta with a haddi- clinging on to one little thing "let's support the goree"...
you pathetic excuse for a Sikh- if you even bothered to read people's letters to the newspaper- you will notice that nobody was AGAINST the crucifix- I mentioned in my letter that it would be justified to ask a Sikh at the school to remove a chain with a Khanda- because at the end of the day it is JUST JEWELLERY. Jazzy B wears a large Khanda on a thick gold chain- that doesn't make him a gyani!!!!....
Re: Daily Express front page sensationalises the Kirpan in Schools
GurdeepSingh · 09 Dec 2005
I have just emailed the express about this article being unacceptable.
And yes, Khalistan can only take place if we have strong political leaders.
GurFateh
Re: Daily Express front page sensationalises the Kirpan in Schools
Gurcharan Singh · 09 Dec 2005
here goes KUDOS for the ADMINISTRATORS who allow their own paalle hoye dheeths to do their propoganda against individuals; as this so calledpardeep singh,who has the language of a lowly animal -reflective as he has displayed, I guess education of no more than from a pendu school.
Is this what tapoban practcises?I have noticed a number of times they shut out any views that they have no answer to.But continue to allow ..to carry their vulgarity.
Tapoban has not done this for the first time.Instead of stopping such dogly language from the lowly of the lpw like Pardeepa bilgoos mentality, they shut others out.
I ask the adimnistrators explain, or face the baring of their own dheeth akal.
Re: Daily Express front page sensationalises the Kirpan in Schools
Gurcharan Singh · 09 Dec 2005
Re: Daily Express front page sensationalises the Kirpan in Schools
Gurcharan Singh · 09 Dec 2005
BilKo ji stop sending mails under my name and attributing it to me.
I have seen enough filty language being used here by you.
Be as BIG as you want in your litle net world, I dont think either you are born to be any bigger and mmore talented.
<Admin Note: The IP address "proxy.aol.com" is the same for this post, your earlier posts and the post that was deemed too disgusting to allow. Please correct yourself and do not make false allegations>
Re: Daily Express front page sensationalises the Kirpan in Schools
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 10 Dec 2005
Gurcharana- YOU are the coward who doesn't even give his e-mail on any posts to the forum. I write what I need to on the site- I do not resort to typing filthy e-mails. I am sure you will find that Admin have never had to cut anything from my posts.
EVERYBODY- PLEASE SEE BELOW THE KIND OF LANGUAGE OUR EDUCATED GURCHARAN "SINGH" LIKES TO USE. I AM SORRY FOR HAVING TO POST THIS ON A GURDWARA SITE, BUT THIS FAKE "SIKH" NEEDS TO BE EXPOSED:
*****Admin Note: Sorry we could not allow this through. It will spoil the atmosphere of this site. Pardeep Singh jee whoever wrote to you such filthy email has disgraced himself. *******
Re: Daily Express front page sensationalises the Kirpan in Schools
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 10 Dec 2005
This is my reply to "Dr Kulim":
[address removed] Add to address book
To: [address removed]
Cc:
Subject: RE: (no subject)
Send: Sat, 10 Dec 2005 12:36:18 +0000
Listen idiot- I won't stoop so low as to use disgraceful language as you
have done- like I said- I am man enough to post on the Forum as I've got
nothing to hide. You obviously like to send sly e-mails, which expose you
for what you really are, nothing more than an illiterate pervert. You call
yourself a Sikh, but let me tell you, a true Sikh does not even think of
using such disgusting words- Mr. "Dr" Kulim.
You think I am an "armchair" Khalistani- that is your view. I would love
nothing more than to be honoured with sacrificing my head for Khalistan.
When we do get Khalsa raj (we will get Khalistan, with the grace of Akal
Purakh), may dasam pita ensure that fools like you are not allowed anywhere
near that land.
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh!!!