Youth creating divides
Concerned Singh · 06 Dec 2005
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh
I have been fortunate enough to have seen many youngsters enter sikhi within the last few years. Many of these boys may have been monaeh, drink smoke etc before, but are now taking amrit, listening to keertan etc.
However there is a number of problems which I have seen developing with some of these youngsters, which may be similar to all 'new groups of singhs' but seeing that this is the first time I have seen them, i wish to bring them to your attention.
1) Some of the singhs have no idea what the keertan they are listening to means (this is not said offensively they really dont understand it!) they do not understand the shabads etc, and yet they will only listen to keertan of certain jathe. E.g some will only listen to rehnsbahi keertan and refuse all else. An example of this was recently while listening to my mp3 player a youngster asked if he could also listen, to which i gave him one earphone.. i was listening to some keertan by bhai nirmal singh (hazoori ragi), the youngster asked if i had any akj keertan as that was all he listened to.. as i only had a few 'tracks' he walked away.
what bothered me wasnt the fact that he didnt like nirmal singh!! but that he insisted that he ONLY listened to akj keertan! again he understood none of it but admitted that he liked the beat!!
is this something we see in the people that ONLY attend programmes organised by their jatha or group? Or where their favourite keertani is performing etc?
2) As Jagjit Singh has mentioned in another topic recently, the youngsters seem to miss out the importance of gurbani. Some i know will not do any gurbani path but will happily walk around all day listening to keertan.
Im not saying that keertan is not important, just that our nitnem and gurbani NEEDS to be stressed! It is much easier to listen to catchy music with fast beats or simran etc while ur on the bus than it is to sit down and read your gurbani!!
3) Convert to my Jatha!
Finally this is a point which has unfortunetly made me very sad as of late. I believe myself to be a fairly nuetral person in that i try and have full respect for all sikh jathe etc and that my rehat is my own personal rehat which my panj pyareh gave me. I also believe that where possible it is unwise to create friction on controversial issues where those involved are not of the ability to discuss or understand the issues correctly.
However, I have witnessed some youngsters who for whatever reasons have started to see their amrit as membership to a 'group' or as one called it 'our side or our crew'. Where one young singh is approached by another and is told that he should take his amrit again and join his crew. While others have been been referring to other people who have taken amrit from the same jatha as 'my boys'. In fact one young boy was virtually hounded by a group of others and teased that his amrit wasnt 'proper'amrit! No matter what ur views on amrit sanchars may be, we should all agree that this is not appropriate beahviour.
I find this very disturbing as these are kids who have not been in sikhi for more than a few months and yet already they have this 'us' and 'them' attitude!
For us older singhs who have struggled to find understanding and tolerance of each others slightly differing views it is so saddening to see the new youth going through the same intolerant behaviour!
I believe we all need to take time out and stress on the youngsters the need for equality and understanding! It will do the panth no good at all to have groups of young akj, taksalis, nishkan sevadars, etc etc who only see their own group as 'their boys' and are constantly making jatha based comments at each other.
For those of us doing parchar, lets make sure we do SIKHI parchar not our groups parchar! yes talking of gursikhs and of groups is ok, but not where we insult other peoples sikhi. There is a fine line here and we need to be careful what the impressionable youngsters are taking away with them!
Re: Youth creating divides
Guru Bhallaa Kare · 07 Dec 2005
Some youngsters have a chip on their shoulder.
Find difficult socialising with fellow amritdharis (who are not from their jatha) forget mone or non-amritdharis.
As gursikhs we should be able to be friendly, and socialise with amritdharis, non-amritdharis, sikhs and non-sikhs. They can't do this, yet they expect to recruit people to join their jatha and this that the other.
Its bit depressing.
Where's good old Sikhi gone?
Some people are not interested in Gursikhi but interested in this person's Sikhi, this Jatha's Rehat, this Kirtani's Kirtan...... what about the GURU!
When we ALL accept Guru Granth Sahib as our Guru
When we ALL join with the Shabad Vichaar of Gurbani.
When we ALL reflect, contemplate and understand the Shabd Guru.
Then EKTA in the Panth and amongst youth will itself come about.
to end with i like jagit_waheguru bhaji's signature on SikhSangat forum. It says:
One God: Waheguru
One Guru : Sahib Siri Guru Granth sahib Ji.
One Group : Guru Khalsa Panth!
This should be the Motto of Our Generation
"
Re: Youth creating divides
Karnail Singh Barshi · 07 Dec 2005
---- If someone wants to go to an amrit sinchar where amrit is given out in cups or is prepared in advance and then administered later or where a Sant is brought in to give the gurmantar, then it is the responsibility of someone knowledgeable to warn that person. -----
You say you have done research of rehit, please enlighten us which Amrit Sanchar is :
1. prepared in advance
2. amrit given in cups
3. Sant "brought in" to give gurmantar (ie not part of the panj)
--- Of course we shouldn't hate or exclude anyone who doesn't agree with or follow "our" rehit, but that doesn't mean that if we believe something is wrong or right, we should keep it to ourselves. ----
This smacks of exactly what Concerned Singh is pointing out.
[%sig%]
Re: Youth creating divides
Karnail Singh Barshi · 07 Dec 2005
Singh, these kind of stories exist adnorsium, look a little deeper and they don’t make much sense. This baba, gave amrit to your mate all by himself? There were no panjPiaray? If there were, did no one tell him about Naam? Which is one of the first and most important things that the panjpiyaray give, what kind of amritsanchaar was this?
About the plastic cups and already prepared amrit. This is true then this was not an amrit sanchar no matter who administers it.
On a similar topic
A new guy started employment where I work. I saw him from afar and he was a gursikh, with blue goal pag and flowing beard. It was good to see another Sikh at work so I thought I would go and say hello. I said “hello I am xxxxx how are you.” This guy said hello, took one look at me and never looked at me again and carried on doing what he was doing. I felt really weird and in the end had to walk off. Even now, whenever we meet in the corridors he will nod his head and that’s it. On the other hand there is a young musllmaan who I meet occasionally in the corridor; he will make a point of smiling and saying hello. A Sikh can’t even greet a Sikh properly these days !
[%sig%]
Re: Youth creating divides
bibek daan... · 07 Dec 2005
i cant help but think that this is just another excuse to call yourself or you jatha better...where you took amrit,
it has become like a university...no one has ever questioned where i took amrit and it doesnt matter...what matters is how my jeevan is evolving to be more gumukh (with kirpa i hope it will at least)
the notion that someone needs to take amrit "again" is wrong...as a S I K H you are to keep learning...where you took amrit is a beginign....not an end!
fateh!
Re: Youth creating divides
Concerned Singh · 07 Dec 2005
Glad to see that sangat agrees that this is a real problem.
I know differences exist within amrit sanchars as far as 1 kakkar is concerned and how naam is given. But lets see in an event which can last hours and during which so much rehat and gyan is given should 2 aspects cause such problems? Anycase the differences in the amrit sanchars is not the point.
The point is that due to our (older singhs) mentalities the youngsters are picking it up without even realising what the issue is! I mean how does a kid who has never done a full japji sahib stand and argue that another kids amrit is worthless unless he took it from a certain jatha? Without having full information i would pray that it was not from either overhearing or participating in a discusion with older singhs which led him to have this view.
Yes different rehats exist and yes they can be discussed. But to dismiss another singhs or singhni's amrit just because he is 'not one of your boys' is disgraceful! What we need to understand is as singh above has said we do give an impression to the youngsters!! If we act superior to other panthic sikhs then kids who always want to be in the 'IT group' will take on that attitude.
If this continues then how long will it be before these youngsters are fighting openly in the streets? For some of you this may sound absurd. But if you insult somebodies amrit which is THE most important thing to them in their lives, if you insult their love of the guru despite the fact that the rehat they follow is probably 100% the same as yours, then how long before that kid snaps? Who then will we blame?
I think it is true to say that kids and us included have attached ourselves with jathe, and keertan styles and beats but not to the gurbani!!!! Not to the pyaar for guru ji, but to our 'gangs'.
There are plenty of chardi kala gursikhs from all the different jathe who are excellent role models for the youth. These are the singhs fully engaged in naam kamai. But lets be honest for many kids seeing a singh sitting quietly in the corner somewhere in his samadhi is probably not as intresting as the loud mouths walking around outside strutting their stuff and talking the politics! Are these the people who are going to inspire the new breed of singhs?
The issue i think goes beyond that of the amrit sanchar and where one takes amrit from. The shame is that by taking amrit from somewhere we assume that we belong to that group! As mentioned where are the khalsa panth panj pyareh becuase that is what i want to join! The panj pyareh say you belong to the khalsa so the fault is not with them at all ... however somewhere along the line we create this feeling that we need to belong. I dont even are is someone does say i am akj or taksali or nanaksari etc, but it does when they say you akj's are like this, or you taksalis are like this!
Another point which i failed to mention in my first post was that all gangs need places to meet, chill and gossip! When kids start saying lets go to this rehnsbhai cus all the other 'boys' are gonna be there and we can go chill ... then you know you have a problem!!
I hope i havent offended anyone as this isnt my intention, i just hope we can all take a look at the way we speak and act as rolemodels to young singhs and singhnian. Lets try and inspire them to join the guru!!! not the 'groups'!!
Re: Youth creating divides
bibek daan... · 07 Dec 2005
i am happy for the singh/kaur who had a great experience the second time, but in sikhi there is no second time...its like getting married twice? because you didnt feel anything the first time....
i think you are to grow and taking amrit is indeed important, but certainly not IT...
if you take amrit from chardi kala panj and then you see one of them do somthing wrong/anti gursikh later...is it OK to take amrit again? b/c you feel cheated?
i mean where do we draw the line.
for me it is ONE amrit ONE time...peshi is a different topic.
fateh
Re: Youth creating divides
Jagjit Singh · 08 Dec 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, I think the veer who started this topic has raised a number of important points which need to be looked at. The discusioin has gone at bit at a tangent, but just going back to the original points.
SHABAD GURU & IMPORTANCE OF PAATH
Pyare jio, the first point veer ji made was about people listening to only AKJ style keertan, or dismissing other. This is new to me, because I find most Gursikhs listen to every type of keertan, whether AKJ style, raag, popular tunes, etc. However if this is the casse, then it is a worrying development. Youth needs to understand Shabad is the Guru. It does not matter what style of keertan, kirtani, or whether paath or keertan, that Shabad is the Guru. "Shabad Guru Soorat tun chela".
It is the Shabad that we bow and submit to. It is the Shabad that we implement into our jeevans. The power, shakti, parras kala, knowledge, everything is in the Shabad.
I know most youth still have "kahn rass" (melody sweet to the ear) when listening to keertan, we all did when we started on this path. Which is why when listening to bani, they should consult sikhitothemax, and then as we develop, learn Santhiya. Bani is so much sweeter when we understand it fully. Plus if we do not understand it, then how can we implement it in our jeevans?
Until we do not understand bani, then we are blind to sikhi. Because although we still have kirpa on us, from listening to bani and keeping rehit, which is good. But we are walking on a path without knowing where it is leading. It is essential we put as much effort in as possible to understand bani, and implement it in our lives as much as possible. Plus do ardas for more knowledge, understanding and virtues of Akaal.
Veer ji, also mentioned Nitnem. Any Gursikh that does not do nitnem is naked. The nitnem is the armour with guards the spiritual jeevan of a Gursikh. It is the minimum requirement. Bhai Jasvir Singh at a previous Khalsa Camp did an extensive lecture on the importance of nitnem to our Spiritual jeevan. Anybody who does not do it, is naked and open to lust, anger, greed,attachment and ego at anytime.
This leads on to the second point of veer ji. As mentioned before doing Sehaj path for an Amritdhari Gursikh is just as important as everything else. That is what brings knowledge and balance to a Gursikh. Even if it is just one shabad a day on a PDA, at least your doing it and implementing it. Ideally we should be doing much more.
A good test for Gursikhs is to try and sit and listen to paat, i.e. Akhand paats. To listen and concentrate is very hard. It hard to keep up, and not fall asleep. Listening to keertan darbaars are much easier, which I why keertan is so important. But in a ideal world, it would be wonderful to have Gursikhs who can sit through whole Akhand Paths like in the old days.
GRANTH & PANTH
Payre jio, veer jis third point is also very valuable. He has made some excellent observations.
As a Gursikh, we only have one group that is created by Sahib Siri Guru Gobind Singh ji. Guru ji created no other group than the Guru Khalsa Panth. I personally use the signature on some mesageboards :-
One God: Waheguru
One Guru : Sahib Siri Guru Granth sahib Ji.
One Group : Guru Khalsa Panth!
This should be the Motto of Our Generation
I, fundamentally believe in this. I always have from the day I kept my kesh. As a Gursikh, our mind is totally submitted and dedicated to the Granth (sahib Siri Guru Granth sahib ji ) and our body is submitted and dedicated to the Panth ( Guru khalsa Panth). Hence the saying "Granth and Panth".
When a Gursikh is Shaheed, he is not Shaheed for any group, be it AKJ, Taksal, Babbar, ISYF, etc. No, they are Shaheed for the Panth.
The problem is that many see the Panth as Akal Thakht Rehit Maryada. No, the Panth is much larger a concept then just the maryada. Even the maryada, we have to respect as the minimum standard of a sikh in the Panth. In the Panth, you are completely free to keep more rehit as per building your jeevan, which most jathas do. That is fine, but respect the Panth. Please note one thing, never did Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh ji, Baba Gurbachan Singh ji, Baba Kartaar Singh, Sant Jarnail Singh ji, Bhai fauja Singh ji, or any other Gursikhs, ever utter one word against the Panth. Everything the Panth said, they took it as Hukam, and adhered by it.
The Panth is far beyond all of us. It is far beyond even the 5 jathedars, who are open to corruption and power abuse. No, the Panth is the whole Sense of community, spirit, history, and complete physical embodiment of everything do with Gurmat.
So the motto of Granth and Panth is fundamental to every Gursikh.
YOUR GROUP AND MINE
In this greater Panth, there are many groups, call them jathas. They are collectives of Gursikhs with fundamental common beliefs, aims and objectives, whether keertan based, paath based, political, or seva based. This is fine and much needed. To obtain results on a mass level, you have to work on a mass level. We need more seva, and cannot walk backwards.
The problems comes from inter-jatha politics which are wrong. All these jathas were initially led by Gursikhs with fantastic jeevans, and we should work on building jeevans such as that, rather than waste your time on negative things. Sometimes the inter-jatha wars and attachments are no different to tribalism that we see in elders with caste.
Some youth are now thinking being neutral is the way forward, and do not associate with any group. I have found they often become more political that the others because they have to more knowledge of politics to always stay neutral. Plus if you want achieve social change and do seva on a mass level you have to use the structures already in place. Rarely have I come across any jathbandie, which has an anti-panthik agenda. They are all different, some have self-interests, but want good things. They all want youth to work for them. We as youth, just use that to get the group to work for the Panth.
On a more spiritual level. We have to get indifference outside of our minds. Guru ji tells us to collect the virtues of akaal. One way in which we learn virtues is by interaction with the sangat. So we should do sangat with all and collect the virtues. It is a simple rule. Collect the good, and leave the bad.
Plus unless we mix we do have understanding. Personally, I try and do as much sangat as possible. Recently, the mother of the young black man who was killed in Liverpool by racists. She made an amazing statement. When asked if she hated the killers, she replied "no, I forgive them, hatred is a life sentence imposed on myself." I thought that was amazing. It is so true. If we hate others, we place a sentence on ourselves, and limit ourselves. Forgiveness is so important in everything we do, and especially as Gursikhs in the Panth, indifference in our minds and actions is essential for a pure mind, and pure concious. We should do whatever we can, and find Guru jis blessings, what others do, that is for Guru to bless them.
Sometimes different sangats are excellent, othertimes I wonder. But at least I know where I am, and what I need to do and need to avoid. The groups I do seva with such as AKJ, Sikh missionary, Akal Academy, and various youth projects in India, plus the two books published by damdami Taksal and writing jeevans of Gursikhs. It has made me appreciate the groups I do seva with more, especially when we meet UK Nihangs, SGPC corruption, udasies/nirmala fans, etc.
In the end, Guru jis tells, "saadh sangat kasee jania, jittee iko Naam vakaneea" (the sadh sangat is recognised by the insignia of Naam). That is so self-explanatory.
AMRIT AND NAAM
It ia amazing how much time we spend discussing this issue. I know it is fundamental to sikhi, and one the four important events in our life, with physical birth, spiritual birth (Amrit), Anand karaj, and death. But considering it is only one of these four, we must spend the most time discussing it.
Firstly, I believe there is only One Amrit. "Nanak Amrit ek hai, dooja nahin Ko". This Amrit is only blessed by puran tyaar par tyaar Panj Pyares. Some the stories above as very sad. This is why we have to be so careful about who does this seva, and how highly important it is.
I was once asked by my local gurdwara to do seva. They told me to Pehradaar de seva, because I was well built and look good in a bana. I was shocked. I asked them, do you not do Shood sudhhea of Gursikhs who do seva? They said, we have already chosen them. I asked how? They said the Pardan of the Gurdwara has to be in, because he is the Pardan, and then this person and that person. I was totally shocked. Not looking at anyones jeevan, just typical punjabi style. I walked away, and I did a benti to all the youth ablakhees to take Amrit at the the next rainsbhai, which they all did, and have done since.
We all know AKJ does Amrit sanchaars properly with jeevan wale Gursikhs. People highlight them as a result. But the tragedy is not that the jatha does it right, but that so many others do it so badly? When we are asked to do this seva, we have to ask ourselves, Am I worthy? Do I have a suitable jeevan? Can I explain Naam? The most important question of all is "Am I doing justice to the sharda of the ablakhyee?" Personally I have never considered myself worthy of this seva. it is such a high seva to do.
Every jatha needs to look at this, and even AKJ needs to constantly review this to maintain the standard of "Bhai Daya Singh, Bhai Himmat Singh, Bhai Mokham Singh, Bhai Dharam Singh, Bhai Sahib singh". Essentially only then are we doing justice to the ablaakhyee who comes to give their head to the Guru.
As far as naam drittha, I am completely convinced by it. This is by personal experience of what happened to me in the Amrit Sanchaar. Plus sangat of Jeevan Wale Gursikhs. Bhia Rama Singh ji once said something to me, which became imprinted on my mind from that day. He said "Never compromise on Amrit vela and Naam". Similarly when Gursikhs ask, me I say the same thing. Naam is the essential component of Gurmat. Guru ji mentions it in almost every shabad. How can we compromise on it?
As far as Gursikhs who do not have naamdhirr. I still do sangat of them and have utmost pyaar and satkar for them. When they ask me about Naam, I tell them what I think. The rest is up to them. When they do simran, I do it with them, but do it internally, or on the lips. Where are they with Naam? Only Guru ji knows and I leave that to him. One thing I know, I am not higher or better than any of them. I need to learn from them and would never try to judge them. That is the worst thing, and I just wish I never do that in my jeevan. I am just glad, my Guru brought me on the path he has, and am ever thankful.
AFTER AMRIT
Pyare jio, we spend so much time talking about Naam and Amrit. But what about afterwards. If a person is even naam dhriir, but after Amrit he/she does not do Amrit vela, then being naam dhrirr is of little value.
Once you have the gift of naam, this priceless jewel, we have to jaap it.
"Support structures" are required in every town, that everytime someone takes amrit, they are supported to do Amrit vela and sangat. Otherwise we are just like sants, who come and give Amrit and then leave. So many people then do not have the support and flounder in their jeevans.
Far more important than preparing people for Amrit is supporting them after it. Set up Amrit velas seesions at gurdwaras, or at your homes, and invite Gursikhs. If they do not come phone them wake them up, and keep the motivated. You watch how Guru ji breaks our haumai. Because we always think we are supporting them, but in essence they support us more, and we will share Gursikhi virtues & kamai with each other.
So I apologise, a very long post, but please Gursikho, all the effort you put into preparing people for Amrit, spend it supporting them afterwards aswell.
Forgive me if I have spoken too much, and feel free to disagree with me, if you feel I am wrong.
Waheguru ji kekhalsa, wahegurujike fateh
Re: Youth creating divides
bibek daan... · 08 Dec 2005
ajk uk,
ummm...divides are not a solution...they only create more problems.
over time wounds heal and as a gursikh you should not choose division over brotherhood.
remember...gunna di sanj...sharing in good attributes...is important too and if you cant find something good about the people (you dont have a problem iwth the kirtan, just the people) then you should not hold yourself back from the kirtan.
only when you are looking at the avguns will you be deterred.
again, i really think this is the wrong message...its OK not to go to this smagam or that b/c you dont like the people...i would ask why you go in the first place...for the people or the guru?
Re: Youth creating divides
bibek daan... · 08 Dec 2005
lol,
ok...i suppose you're views are yours and mine are mine. but in time, i hope you see what i do...(no haumai, just that i've been there on a very personal level)
just some question...are the people that "split off" non-gursikh? is your group better than them? and would you/do you tell others that they are bad?
if you answer to any of these questions is YES, then i think you need to re-evaluate...again, just what i think.
bhul chuk maaf
Re: Youth creating divides
bibek daan... · 08 Dec 2005
akjuksingh,
maaf karna jio,
i meant no disrespect to you or the "top" gursikhs that you associate with. my questions are more general than that and are to be asked by every sikh who thinks they are better or has chosen to not associate with other sikhs.
again, you're views will not change b/c of what i am saying, that is between you and the guru, but i will not back down from saying that gursikhs can be wrong. the majority is not always right. you have to also ask, why did the people split, what i haumai? or could it have been that they didnt feel thier voice was being heard? from what you say it just seems like you think a majority is always right...the essence of the khalsa way is concensus, not majority minority...when a sarbat khalsa was called (in the old days) singhs could not leave angry but had to comprimise on what they were going to do, so that all views were at least heard out. anyhow
i too stopped going to certain programs b/c the top gursikhs in my are stopped going. then i realized i was missing out on a lot of good kirtan (lots of naam ras) and lots of sangat, b/c not everyone who attends the "other side's" programs is "bad"...there is a lot of prem on BOTH sides...so i would go and guess what...now a few years later, everyone goes.
this is why i think i know what you are going through - not that i know better, but that i know that there is a state of mind that follows where you are currently(or what you are perpetuating)...i could be wrong though, but time will tell...chances are in a few years, tempers will cool and people will begin to re-associate.
im curious though...this post started with a plea to the "elder gursikhs" to not create divides...it seems to me that you have become the perfect example of a youth divided by the elders...your "top" gursikh role models have lead you to stop going to the "other" side's programs. lol...its interesting.
chalo,
bul chuk maaf
Re: Youth creating divides
simple singhani · 09 Dec 2005
lol..jagjit singh has said what has to be said.. he is TOTALLY right! i think everyone should follow his way of thinking cus its totally gurmukh! we shud go anywhere where ther is sadh sangat... we dont need to speak to the other youths about politics.. jus go to the keertan programmes, listen to the keertan, and come home. simple.. and easy. no arguments. Its when youth start chatting in langar halls and outside these converstation crop up. If everyone jus keeps themselves to themselves and doesnt say bad about anyone.. we wudnt have this issue. stay in chardikala.
WJKK WJKF
GURSIKHA KEE HAR DHOOR, HAM PAPPI BE GHAT PAE