Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Misguided Sikh Girl

Misguided Sikh Girl

KS · 08 Dec 2005

Another misguided Sikh girl pays the price. Parents must teach their children some morals and ethics, Its all there in Sikhi but parents and children put cheap thrills, money and ego first and Sikhi does not get a mention I have noticed Hindus and Muslims teaching their children about their religion much more than Sikhs. 'Eminem' Killer Jailed for 25 Years Victim and killer: Law student Jagdip Najran and Eminem impersonator Christopher Duncan Eminem impersonator Christopher Duncan has been jailed for life for murdering law student Jagdip Najran. Judge David Paget said he should serve a minimum of 25 years but warned he might never be released. He told Duncan at the Old Bailey: "You have an abnormal and unhealthy interest in violence and in particular, sexual violence towards women. "It may be that you posed such a danger to women that it will never be safe to release you." Duncan, 21, who dressed like the American rapper and has the same tattoos, pleaded guilty to murder last Thursday. He was then remanded so the judge could consider the minimum term he should serve for killing the 26-year-old woman he met in a karaoke bar in May last year. Duncan battered Miss Najran over the head with a metal baseball bat and stuffed her body into a suitcase after she went back to his flat in Bethnal Green, east London. An attempt had been made to sexually assault her. It emerged after the case that Duncan is set to be questioned by officers investigating the 2003 murder of American artist Margaret Muller. Duncan lived close to Ms Muller at the time she was stabbed while out jogging in Victoria Park, Hackney, east London.

Re: Misguided Sikh Girl

BirRaas Singh · 08 Dec 2005

Its the victims fault that she died?? Next time a Singh gets battered, we'll blame him.

Re: Misguided Sikh Girl

Singh · 08 Dec 2005

from the reports I've read, she was smitten by him and her heart was "aflutter" and in her throat. She went with him to the apartment, and were intimate. He then flipped out and bashed her head. What's done is done, but she made a lot of very bad decisions.

Re: Misguided Sikh Girl

Jj · 08 Dec 2005

A agree with BirRass Singh however why was she going back to his flat??

Re: Misguided Sikh Girl

BirRaas Singh · 08 Dec 2005

In normal society it isnt expected that when you go home with someone they will smash you over the head with a baseball bat. No one knows the future, to say someone is misguided because they died from such an incidence is disgraceful. Whatever happened to Sarbat da Bhalla? Its a tragedy when innocent people are killed, no matter what faith, background, creed or race. I hate this hypocrisy which is abundant within Sikhs nowadays, they only feel hurt for people who are of their own kind.

Re: Misguided Sikh Girl

Singh · 08 Dec 2005

In normal SIKH society, a Sikh girl shoudlnt' be going home with some gangster wannabe who acts like he's a rapper. She shouldn't be having intimate relations with him. It's a tragedy, but it's stupid to say nothing should be learned from it. If you're going to make the same mistakes as Jagdip, then this tragedy is going to be repeated. Did she make the right decisions? No. And she paid for that. This isn't some random shooting or some girl being struck by a car. This is a misguided girl going home with a man she admired because he resembled a woman-hating rapper in looks and deed and then got killed by him.

Re: Misguided Sikh Girl

Gurpreet Singh · 08 Dec 2005

Was she a sikh girl? What makes you guys think that? Regardless if she was sikh or not thats messed up. But I thought a Sikh is someone who has given their head to GuruJi in the form of the Panj Piarey.

Re: Misguided Sikh Girl

Singh · 08 Dec 2005

Its just not street-smart to go to the house of a complete stranger, never mind completely immoral and Kanjar-ly (is Kanjar-ly a word?).

Re: Misguided Sikh Girl

BirRaas Singh · 08 Dec 2005

Funny how in any other cases she wouldnt even be called a Sikh, but now when someone wants to push the blame on her she is being called one. It isnt her fault that she got killed by him, if she knew he was violent and had such a history then your point would be valid. Whos Jagdip? Take your vandetta somewhere else.

Re: Misguided Sikh Girl

Singh · 08 Dec 2005

No one is saying it was good she died but she lacked any morality or common sense by going to sleep with a stranger at his house. It was a situation that could have been avoided.

Re: Misguided Sikh Girl

Be practical · 09 Dec 2005

This girls death is a tragedy irrespective of whether she was sikh or not. I think what BirRass singh is saying here is that it is not appropriate to be bringing up what her committment to Sikhi was or not. Just because she had a sikh name doesnt mean she is hell bound to following all the rules some of you adhere to. Religion is a personal choice. Her way of life was obviously not one of Sikh orthodoxy but one of westernism. So the only comments that need be made are that this is a tragic murder of a british girl by a psychopath living out some fantasy. Whether it is right or wrong to be engaging in illicit relationships should not be within the scope of this strand but could and is more than adequately discussed in other discussions. FInal point to everyone just have some compassion when discussing such topics. Its not the gurmat way, to start beating people down just because they dont follow the same lifestyle u ahve chosen to follow.

Re: Misguided Sikh Girl

Jasmin · 09 Dec 2005

Excellent post by be practical. Obviously she wasn't following Sikhi and was adulterous, but that doesn't make it less a crime. Would she have changed-----can't tell now. Yet didn't I read ----on this forum that everyone gets to live a set number of years? Is it all part of some plan we can't understand? At any rate her religion,------- her lack of it, her family background------all particulars that don't matter in cases like this.

Re: Misguided Sikh Girl

... · 09 Dec 2005

I think they only thing that was being suggested was that Sikh girls who live lifestyles like this realise that they are making bad and dangerous choices. It was a cautionary message. Jagdip's death was clearly a tragedy. It's just that we should learn from it and make changes as opposed to repeating it over again.