Re: Nirankari Centre opens in UK
Gurcharan Singh · 09 Dec 2005
As I have said elsewhere, I know Dr Jagjit Singh ji Taunque , as I have met him at fellow professional conferances and the last at the Sikh health Check Conferance in Chigwell, about a month ago.
Having known him and his Sikhi pyar, I was shocked at the news item put out.
I decided to ring him, and report back to the Sikh discussions group.I spoke to him about the issue.
He was SHOCKED I spoke to Dr Jagjit Singh Taunque, and appraised him of the mail and allegations.
He was very shocked and at once pointed out that he attended it in the capacity of the Deputy Lord Lieutenant , and not personal capacity.He says he is obliged to carry out his official duties.He has pointed out that he also attends gatherings at mosques etc in official capacity, and fuctions of many other faiths.
He asked me to forward the mail to him, which I will do so shortly, when I receive his son's email, as he does not have his own mail.
I have asked him to respond, and I will forward the reply as he is not a member of this group.I hope he does respond.
I hope this explains for the moment.
However, a thought arose , I would like to ask the forum to give their views...I understand the Hukamnama from the Akal Takhat, and respect it.
What happens in circumstances where if a Sikh doctor has to attend to a patient, and the patient turns out to be a Nirankari?
Does he refuse,and allow the patient to die and bring upon himself the wrath of the governing body and public opinion or does he attend to the needs of the Nirankari patient as his professional ethics demand, and goes against the hukamnama of the Akal Takhat?I would hate to be in those shoes.
In my own professional capacity I meet many people of different faiths, in one instance I was asked to give advice about the security arrangements for a group of people, who have been ostracised from the Panth.I gave my view, although I did not have direct dealings with them.
This is a real dilemna, I would not want to face.Any learned views without getting personal and "bad mouthing " anyone for simply asking very delicate view to be discussed responsibly.
Please ensure that ownership of the article is known or it is just not worth wasting your time and mine on anonnymous views!
Gurcharan Singh Kulim
Re: Nirankari Centre opens in UK
Harjinder Singh · 10 Dec 2005
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa
Vaheguru ji ki Fateh
I knew this explanation would come up that he attended in his official capacity as Deputy Lord Lieutenant, but sorry who comes first Guru or Queen, I know where my loyalties lie. The question of treating a Nirankari patient is irrelevant as the storry of Bhai Kaneya illustrates.
The Hukamnama is about Sikhs actively pursuing relationships and eating with Nirankaris and in this case Mr Taunque actually attended a grand opening of an anti-Sikh organisation. If Mr Taunque would like I'll set up meetings for him to meet the children, grandchildren of the Shaheeds of 1978 Bloody Vaisakhi and the Singhs in the UK who were actually present in Amritsar on the day.
Harjinder Singh
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa
Vaheguru ji ki Fateh
Re: Nirankari Centre opens in UK
LionKing (LK) · 10 Dec 2005
Does he refuse,and allow the patient to die and bring upon himself the wrath of the governing body and public opinion or does he attend to the needs of the Nirankari patient as his professional ethics demand, and goes against the hukamnama of the Akal Takhat?I would hate to be in those shoes.
************
No there's nothing wrong to treat a human being in need.
ofcourse he doesn't refuse!
BHai Kanaya Ji didn't refuse giving water to Muslims did he?
Likewise, no matter how much of an enemy of the Panth, the Human being is a human being in need, and in that situation it's a DUTY of a SIKH to cure him, no choice.
Regards
Re: Nirankari Centre opens in UK
LionKing (LK) · 10 Dec 2005
not if the nirankarie's leader is the son of the narakdhari leader
Re: Nirankari Centre opens in UK
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 11 Dec 2005
If in his "official capacity" Taunque had told his employers that he refused to go to this cess-pit of a place (Narakdhari centre) because they are a heritical cult, responsible for the cold-blooded murder of Sikhs in 1978- I am sure they would have found a way for him not to attend.
Re: Nirankari Centre opens in UK
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 11 Dec 2005
To date I have had no response from him apart from the verbal , so i cannot go on any further.