Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikhs in France in a limbo over identity

Sikhs in France in a limbo over identity

Saturday · 10 Dec 2005

Sikhs in France in a limbo over identity Saturday, 10 December , 2005, 12:52 Paris A Sikh who won the right to wear his turban in his driving licence identity photo only to see that right withdrawn a day later will pursue his battle to find out if "one can be both Sikh and French," a spokesman for the Sikh community has said. "Well get to the bottom of this," said Kudrat Singh, who acts as spokesman for many in the Sikh community. "Can you be both a Sikh and French considering the ethnic character of Sikhs," he said, contending that the Sikh religion is linked to the ethnic issue. "What we want from France is a yes or no." The Council of State, Frances highest administrative body, ruled Monday that Shingara Mann Singh, a French citizen, can wear his turban in the photo because a ban on covering the head in official photos came from the wrong ministry - the Interior Ministry. That decision was annulled, with the Council of State ruling that the Interior Ministry If Singh loses, the lawyer said he would go to other tribunals - the European Court of European Rights if need be - to ensure that fundamental rights such as freedom of religion and nondiscrimination were being respected. "There is a disproportion between what the Sikhs are subjected to ... and the goal of the measure," he said by telephone. "A Sikh can be very well identified with his turban .... If he takes it off, you just see a man with long hair and he will be less easily identifiable," Spinosi said. Sikhs have been caught up recently in legal duels with the French government. The small, quiet community began making its voice heard after France passed a law banning conspicuous religious signs in public schools in 2004. Aimed at Islamic head coverings, it also forced Sikh students to remove turbans or be expelled. Sikhs, who number 5,000 to 7,000 in France, slipped through the cracks during the marathon debate that preceded passage of the law banning head scarves. They were never consulted, and officials were caught by surprise when turbans became an issue in classrooms — which banned head coverings on official identity photos — did not have the right to decide an issue concerning the Transport Ministry. It said a Transport Ministry order was not precise enough to apply. The council said Singh must be given his licence within 30 days. The following day, the Transport Ministry changed its order, specifically saying that the Interior Ministry ban was applicable for driving licences. The move meant that Singh, could not receive his licence as long as he wore a turban. Singh’s lawyer, Patrice Spinosi, said he would take the case back to the Council of State to verify that such a manoeuvre is legal. If Singh loses, the lawyer said he would go to other tribunals — the European Court of European Rights if need be - to ensure that fundamental rights such as freedom of religion and non-discrimination were being respected. "There is a disproportion between what the Sikhs are subjected to ... and the goal of the measure," he said by telephone. "A Sikh can be very well identified with his turban .... If he takes it off, you just see a man with long hair and he will be less easily identifiable," Spinosi said. Sikhs have been caught up recently in legal duels with the French government. The small, quiet community began making its voice heard after France passed a law banning conspicuous religious signs in public schools in 2004. Aimed at Islamic head coverings, it also forced Sikh students to remove turbans or be expelled. Sikhs, who number 5,000 to 7,000 in France, slipped through the cracks during the marathon debate that preceded passage of the law banning head scarves. They were never consulted, and officials were caught by surprise when turbans became an issue in classrooms.