Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

War in Iraq

War in Iraq

Kulbir Singh · 28 Mar 2003

What should be the Sikh stand on the US-Iraq war? Who should we support?

Re: War in Iraq

Mkhalsa · 28 Mar 2003

Veer jee, I think we should stay out of it, but still be against the war. I think guru sahib made that clear with the hukamnama on March 20th at Darbar Sahib.

Re: War in Iraq

Japnaam Singh · 28 Mar 2003

Vaaheguroo jee kaa Khaalsaa, Vaaheguroo jee kee Fateh! Obviously both sides are not perfect, and have done many unrighteous things in the past, but for the following 3 reasons I think it would be best to support the United States. 1) Hope: Saddam Hussein runs Iraq very much the same way Joseph Stalin ran the Soviet Union, dissenting opinions are not allowed at all. Dissidents who have left Iraq have come with many stories about how Saddam has killed any person who he suspected of being unloyal, etc. Plus, we (Most Sikhs who are out of the Punjab) are very lucky that we live in democracies, we have the right to religion, speech, and many other things. All of these rights are greatly infringed upon in Iraq. If one of the Middle Eastern countries is made into a democracy, this will surely cause other nations to follow suit. More nations with democracies will ultimately lead to more stable governments, and more freedom for the people. 2) Humanitarian: The people of Iraq are starving. Partly because of sanctions, but also due to the fact Saddam Hussein obviously does not care about the welfare of the Iraqi people. If Saddam wanted he could still easily prevent starvation and disease in his country if he directed funds towards those issues, however he is obviously more interested in lavish palaces and his military. 3) Safety: A terrorist network by itself has killed 3,000 people, if the means were available they would have had no problems killing 30,000 or even 300,000. When a terrorist network gets links with a terrorist state bad things will happen. The terrorist network will have many more resources and ways to inflict casualties on western democracies and their interests. Saddam Hussein has admitted links to Palistinean terror organizations (Who hate America) and suspected links to other terrorist organizations which hate America even more. War in itself is not a good thing, it will cause destruction, death and many other bad things. However, it is definitely in the longterm interests of the Iraqi people and the people of the world to change the regime of Saddam Hussein and implement reforms in Iraqi Society. Vaaheguroo jee kaa Khaalsaa, Vaaheguroo jee kee Fateh! [%sig%]

Re: War in Iraq

singh · 28 Mar 2003

yeah Mkhalsa we should stay out of it, and let saddam kill innocent people whenever he feels like. The Americans are doing what sikhs used to do many years ago, which is to protect the innocent

Re: War in Iraq

VikariSingh · 28 Mar 2003

"Je Sakta Sakte Ko Mare, Tan Man Ros Na Hoi" Don't need to support or criticise(openly) anyone. If you really want to, think few times before doing that and talk to some Gurmukhs(may be at Tapoban). No jumping like Simaranjit Singh Maan.

Re: War in Iraq

Mr. Singh · 28 Mar 2003

WAheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji kee fateh I agree with certain points that Japnaam singh made. Although i do have certain misgivings about the stuff that Bush is getting away with. I mean we all know about Aghanistan and the oil pipe line etc. We also know that America is the one that put Taliban into power until they got in the way of the pipe line... which by the way will go through now , big surpirse. If we are really worried about safety and humanitarian issues then why not work through the UN. And what about the people in other countries who die everyday, Congo for example why doesn't America take the generals out of power in certain other countries. I think that Sikhs shouldn't support the war either way. From a karmic point of view both are bad and supporting either gives us bad karma. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji kee fateh.

Re: War in Iraq

pro-Neutral · 28 Mar 2003

Sikhs should stay neutral in this war. If we side with the American then we are going against the Europeans who in the future will be a super power. But if we go with the Europeans then we are going against the Americans. Sikhs do not have a country of their own, we have no nation to voice our concerns and to protect us. That is why we need to make some friends around the world. By staying neutral in this war we are certainly not going to make any enemies. That is why acting, as a neutral party in this conflict will be in the best interests for the Sikh community long term. [%sig%]

Re: War in Iraq

Kulbir Singh · 28 Mar 2003

Who is going to win this war? Americans apparently under-estimated the Iraqis and this miscalculation can lead to them being stuck in a quagmire. Read the following news section from bbc: >>>>>>>>>>> Here on the frontline this conflict is taking its toll on morale. I can see the signs in the US marines I am with outside Nasiriyah. Quite a few of the troops have said to me that this isn't what they were expecting. They have had a tiring week of guerrilla-style fighting and it continues. They are frustrated that their political masters gave the American public the impression that it would be easier than it's turned out to be. But, also that they should have given them more expectation about Iraqi resistance like this. They don't want to admit they can't deal with it, but I think there is definitely a sense that it is not the kind of fighting that they were really trained for. One Marine told me: "I've had enough of being fired at from all directions, I just want to go home". I thought it quite a surprising thing to say. >>>>>>>>> Looks like this is going to be a difficult war to win for the Americans. Even if they win it, it will be at the cost of a lot of civilian lives. Again, we all know that Saddam is no saint. Vaheguru knows the best. I agree with Vikari Singh that there is no need to jump like Simranjit Singh Mann who in the last Guelph war, offered to send 100,000 Sikhs to help the Americans against the Iraqis. We are better off staying neutral in this war. But by the same token, we must voice our anger at atrocities committed by either side. A Sikh cannot be a silent spectator of atrocities. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: War in Iraq

NJ Singh · 28 Mar 2003

We should support Americans. This is because Singhs are supposed to help eliminate evil from this world and the people who lead unlawful acts against innocent. Sadam has weapons of mass destruction and has history of misusing his power against others. If we had a up and running Fauj, Singhs would definitely support the removal of Sadam's regime. Removal of Sadam's regime will bring much releif to Iraq's oppressed people, and remove the future threat to the world. This is the only way to live in Peace. Just my humble opinion. NJ Singh.

Re: War in Iraq

Pro-er Neutral · 28 Mar 2003

I agree with the view expressed above by "Mr.Singh" about karmic consequences since neither side is completely righteous in their actions. There are pros and cons on both sides, and since the lives taken by Saddam while "ruling" over the people aren't any more tragic than those lives taken by Bush while "protecting" the people, neutrality is best. I don't think however that Sikhs should stay neutral with our own strategic interests in mind as "pro-Neutral" suggested above. If we see wrongdoings going on, we can't possibly remain silent just for the sake of securing our position in the political realm. It's good to look ahead to the future, indeed, but not if that requires one to turn a blind eye to atrocities occurring in front of our faces. In this Iraq case though, I think blood stains the hands of both parties, so there is no truly righteous side.

Re: War in Iraq

member · 28 Mar 2003

In all honesty who really cares about this war. The only thing beneficial about it is that i get to watch something on TV when im bored now. America doesn't have the right to go INVADING other countries yet at the same time, saddam had it coming and deserves to have his butt kicked... shame about the poor civilians in the middle. Oh well.

Re: War in Iraq

Singhnee · 30 Mar 2003

Please read below a very interesting article from www.rediff.com. This article talks about some hard facts about this war. Coalition losses a lot more: Web site (www.rediff.com) Russian Web site about the war in Iraq, which offers an alternative to the daily diet of propaganda by coalition officers, is fast becoming compulsive reading throughout West Asia. Criticised for getting information from Russian spies, http://www.aeronautics.ru has claimed that the US and Britain have had heavier losses, fewer Iraqi surrenders and more complications than their leaders suggest. Author "Venik" says he is translating reports on the war by "journalists and military experts" who use a Russian-language site called http://www.iraqwar.ru to pass on information from the GRU -- "the all-seeing eye of the Russian military". For its part, the GRU gets information from wiretaps, radio monitoring, satellites and thousands of agents. On Saturday, the Web site reported how "coalition troops have so far failed to take An-Nasiriyah despite categorical orders from the command and more than 800 combat missions by strike aircraft. All attempts to break through the Iraqi defence were met by Iraqi counterattacks. After 24 hours of fighting the coalition troops only managed to advance several hundred meters in two sectors near An-Nasiriyah at the cost of 4 destroyed armoured personnel carriers, no less than 3 Marines killed by sniper and mortar fire, 10 wounded and 2 missing in action. The exact Iraqi losses are being determined". It added, "The Americans have also failed to advance near An-Najaf. Every coalition attack was met by massive artillery barrages from the Iraqi side. Later during the day, the Iraqis mounted a counterattack throwing the US forces back by 1.5-2 kilometres. No fewer than 10 Marines were killed or wounded. After exchanging fire for six hours both warring sides remained in the same positions. Iraqi losses in this area are estimated to be 20 killed and up to 40 wounded." "Radio communications intercepted during the last five days suggest that the coalition is using Israeli airfield" to conducts air raids on Iraq, it said. "Combat aircraft taking off regularly from Hatzerim and Navatim [Israeli airbases] do not return to the same bases, but fly toward the border with Jordan while maintaining complete radio silence. Possibly, these are just Israeli Air Force exercises, However, [Russian] radio intercept and radar units observe increased intensity of radio communications coming from the Jordanian Air Force and air defence communication centres during such overflights, as well as changes in the operating modes of the US Army "Patriot" tracking radars deployed in Jordan. "This indicates the Israeli airbases as used as forward airfield or that some of the coalition air force units are based there. Normally, the IAF F-15I fighter-bombers and A-4N strike aircraft operate from the Hatzerim airbase and the F-16 fighter-bombers operate from the Nevatim base." Last week it described how coalition forces were preparing for a big push on several fronts, which might include the capture of the Saddam Hussein Airport, near Baghdad. A Russian aviation expert known for his military contacts is vouching for these reports. When the official news was upbeat more than a week ago, his sources reported that the Iraqis had been gravely underestimated and that US Central Command chief General Tommy Franks was in danger of being replaced as commander of the coalition forces. Last Tuesday they predicted the massive American reinforcements, which have since been announced. They also reported that American defence chiefs were horrified at the number of "smart missiles" they had spent for thin results, and were preparing to switch to conventional bombing. Here is a sample of some reports: March 26: "The shock of the first days of war among the coalition troops is wearing off. Coalition actions are becoming more coherent... [and] gradually taking the initiative away from the Iraqis. "However... massive numbers of disabled combat vehicles and other equipment becomes a strategic problem. Over 60 per cent of available spare parts have been used. The sand is literally eating up the equipment." March 25: "Aerial bombardment of Baghdad has failed to produce the expected results. All targets designated before the war have been hit three to seven times, but this had almost no effect on the command and control structure." The report quoted US generals, at a Pentagon meeting, saying "we are literally dropping gold into the mud" and "the enemy is using... cheaper weapons to reach the same goals for which we spend billions". The result is that smart weapons will be kept for top targets and there will be a greater use of "scorched-earth" and "carpet-bombing" tactics. March 24: "Several US field commanders stated their troops are unable to advance due to their soldiers being demoralised by fierce resistance and high losses. The US military intelligence and the CIA failed to uncover the true potential of the Iraqi forces and, in essence, misinformed the military and civilian leadership of the coalition countries." March 22: There is anger in the Pentagon because of the disastrous start to the war and "if during the next 3-5 days Gen Franks fails to achieve any significant results, it is entirely possible he would be replaced".

Re: War in Iraq

Gurumandir Singh · 31 Mar 2003

Support America, Saddam needs to go... Americans are obviously going to win the war... Iraq doesnt stand a chance, its only been a week and a half... and ppl are sayin they underestemated... ITS ONLY BEEN a week and a half... there was no underestimation its all media... This will be a good thing... but since Arabs say America is evil for supportin isreal... alot of bad will come out of it

Re: War in Iraq

g · 02 Apr 2003

this war is not a 'just' or 'truthful' war it is a war of power and politics so for this reason Guru ji's khalsa should stay out of it but keep a watching eye on it as who knows what future direction the war will go in

Re: War in Iraq

Gurumandir Singh · 02 Apr 2003

all wars are about power and politics... even if singhs went to war for khalistan still the same thing power and politics.... we dont need khalistan to practice sikhi... so why would we need to go to war for it ? this war might be about power and politics... but it will take saddam hussien outa power and he has been torturing and killing his own ppl for years and years... using chemical weapons on them... plus he would love to send a nuke into america and he would if he could... So thats wut good will come out of it, even though thousands of lives are gonna be lost in the process, but dont you think its a better war than... the jews and muslims been fighting forever? killing each other because they dont like each others religion? I think these "political wars" are more moral than these religious wars... so wut do you think is worse sumone strappin bombs onto there chest killing them selfs and others in the name of GOD? or takin a evil man out of power that would love to kill millions of innocent ppl if he could, so i guess considering the alternative it is a pretty "Just" war I mean what would you do... if somone is threating to kill your family and would jump at the chance too ? I think you would do the same.. I know I would, So maybe next time its not best to judge sumone until you have walked a mile in their shoes?

Re: War in Iraq

warrior*princess · 06 Apr 2003

waheguru ji ka khalsa-waheguru ji ke fateh To 'singh'... Americans- i mean president Tree, oops i mean Bush, are/is not protecting innocent people...that is rubbish...u know that..u really think the president cares about his ppl....he must be after the oil, the wealth!....Look at him, he can't even keep a straight face, he looks like a comedian...lol Sorry, but dont start on him. I dont believe anything he says. He is not trust worthy at all. He was ready to attack from the start with or without other countries help. And there are many people out there who are protesting against the war, WHY? Some are honestly protesting bcoz they think the war is wrong against iraq, but some are doing it just to save their own necks. There is no larger percentage from the good/bad. Having said that, it is incorrect for anyone to attack on a country if they havent even been attacked first! And dont forget they are going against the legislation, whatever its called. I am not stating that saddam is a good person either... BUT innocent people are dying here!! And I rather side for those people in iraq. At the same time, we should not get involved. Our duty is to help the needy, and thats where we come into the equation! This automatically is Sikhi Parchar. Politics is nonsense in the end, one must be careful not to get caught up and remember what our true purpose on earth is, so according to that, bush's conduct is absolutely incorrect. As Guru Gobind Singh ji wants, we must only use the kirpan as the last means, when ALL else fails.... The president does not even have any good enough reason for his moves against iraq. Don't america also hav weapons?...any country should have a right to defend their country even if that means keeping weapons...america are the same as what the british did when they invaded country after country in the past!!!! WHATS THE DIFFERENCE!!! They are hypocrites and are after power. Anyway, america and britain forgot something... 'what you sow is what you reap' They made the weapons NOW they can have them back!!!!!!! via war! wahegurujikakhalsa-wahegurujikefateh

Re: War in Iraq

satnam · 07 May 2006

We should support America as they have given equal rights to Sikhs in america. We have more freedom in America than in India. America has given political asylam to hundreds of thousand sikhs. Iraqis dont want to have our Gurdwara in Baghdad where as in USA we have hundreds of Gurdwaras. America gives green card to sikh priechers also. People with turbans dont get discriminated at work. If some body does he has right to go to court.

Re: War in Iraq

singhsaab · 07 May 2006

I see this thread was started a while back, to those who posted..are your views still the same on this war?

Re: War in Iraq

some12 · 07 May 2006

jiski lati uski bance.

Re: War in Iraq

PTE SINGH · 08 May 2006

Pro neautral, The Vast majority of Sikhs and those with any influence in Europe reside in the UK. The only country that the US needs to care about in Europe is Britain (the rest of europe hate the US regardless). People should do what they feel is right, this is not a Sikh issue as much as a nationalist or personal issue. The rights and wrongs of the Iraq war can be argued either way. All of my family in India are against the War, My family in the UK is split. I too am split, but i still support my countries service men and women (UK) who are out there on my behalf. [%sig%]

Re: War in Iraq

PTE SINGH · 08 May 2006

Actually Satnam, compared to alot of western countries, Sikhs are alot worse off in the US. America is in no way shape or form an example for treatment of Sikhs. Sikhs in Britain, Canada and Scandanavia are allowed to observe their religion with much more freedom than in the US, particularly in the Army, Police and even Prison. Most americans can't tell the difference between a Sikh and an Arab Where as Iraq is one of the most secular muslim countries in the world and has a Sikh community. Infact you may have heard the story of Sadam Hussein taking a huge personal interest in rebuilding a Gurudwara that was destroyed by US missiles during 1998. I certainly would not use the US's treatment of Sikhs as a Justification for anything. [%sig%]

Re: War in Iraq

kk · 11 May 2006

the invasion of iraq is wrong. america produced no evidence that iraq were producing these so called wmd. but an issah mussah yud is destined to take place no matter what. A sikh should stand up for what is right, and first of all keep strong reht, help unify the komb and then be in a better position.

Re: War in Iraq

singh · 11 May 2006

the Americans use a lot of inhumane tactics. I read that the Guardian reported American troops used chemical weapons in Afghanistan. Sikhs should stand up for what is right (spreading freedom, equality) regardless of the 'side', but also we need to look at the methods. A lot of times US uses incredibly unethical methods. The Iraqi terrorists of course, unquestionably use unethical means.

Re: War in Iraq

LS · 24 May 2006

the jung to take place will reduce muslims to a small number. sant babey say muslims gaining a raj for a short period was an attempt to get more sikhs to be initiated out of fear. This is contrary to dasam granth which tells of how muslims will become reduced in future. There is nothing anyone can do the real war has not even begun.

Re: War in Iraq

;;;;;;;;;;; · 27 May 2006

earthquakes will hit large portions of muslim countries. pakistan indonesia turkey already happen. today newspapers claim global warming will increase earthquakes. machines in kaal yug which leave the west far more technologically advanced will move ahead fast pace for a nwo

Re: War in Iraq

..... · 28 May 2006

look how much bad stuff the ancestors of these muslim countries have done to india, that karma is being paid back now cos gods justice is perfect, this does not mean we support the war its just we have to accept gods will.

Re: War in Iraq

suki singh · 02 Jun 2006

I agree with the last posting- Sikh bibian and Hindu bibian were traded as slaves in the bazaars of Baghdad by these treacherous muslims...now they are getting whats due to them.... justice has come about...eventually

Re: War in Iraq

Kulbir Singh · 02 Jun 2006

Whatever the case, still we should not get stonehearted and should not ignore the suffering of humankind. If there are atrocities committed in war, by Americans or by the insurgents, we should condemn it. Of course they are suffering their karma but that's not for us to worry about. Kulbir Singh

Re: War in Iraq

some1 · 16 Jun 2006

stragiht up.. Iraqis are kaardamaag.. gulfwar 1 they had over 100 fighter planes...but they could'nt use them...instead their pilots deflected to iran and iran kep the planes... all they can do is cheap shots.. not saying america is rite... but this is the most ignorant thread.

Re: War in Iraq

Dalbir · 18 Jul 2006

American invading Iraq was wrong in my opinion. Firstly it was done on the premise of a lie regarding WMDs. Secondly the real motive is economical not anything to do with righteousness or human rights but oil. Thirdly look at the zulm that has been done in Abu Garib (??) prison since the invasion, is that the actions of liberators? Now I am against Islamic fundamental crap but a lot of the people fighting coalition forces are plain and simple Iraqi patriots who see that their country has been invaded. If a hypothetical Khalistan was ever invaded like this I would hope that Singhs would fight back in a similar vein. The few Sikhs who I have met who have been to Iraq have nothing but praise for its people. I remember one driver in India telling me that he worked as an illegal labourer there and that his site was shut down and all the foreigners arrested. From what he told me the treatment in prison was very good, i.e. they were fed properly, treated respectfully (he wore a pagh)and he even said that when they shipped them back they put a few notes in their pocket! Saddam was a despot jerk but so was Pinnocet, who never received similar treatment. And like someone said before there is a lot of trouble in the world i.e. Rwanda, why then choose this place specifically? Sadam had Islamic fundamentalists killed in his kingdom so he can hardly be labelled a Islamist. Plus from what I saw on the television, the country looked 10 times cleaner/modern than India. Sanctions caused as many if not more deaths than Sadam. Besides, don't you lot understand that Imperialism is wrong? Look at how Bush treated black people in the US in those New Orleans floods. From where I'm standing invading Iraq basically gave islamic fundamentalists a cause to fight and helped them get more recruits. Haven't any of you seen the photos of Rumsfeld with Sadam? They were well chummy at one stage. I think invading Iraq done muslim mullahs a favour, I'm sad that Tony "twat" Blair had to drag the U.K. into the mess. Sikhs should keep their nose out of this and as for the comment that Iraq is paying for Nadir Shah's deeds!!!!!! Maybe Sikhs in the Punjab have been paying for some of their bad karma in this way since 1984...............(detect my sarcasm).

Re: War in Iraq

Harjas Kaur · 18 Jul 2006

[quote]What should be the Sikh stand on the US-Iraq war? Who should we support?[/quote] We should support good things and condemn bad things, doesn't matter who is doing them. Same thing goes for current Israeli-Lebanese conflict. The moment you blindly support a side, you begin to complicitly tolerate the bad things they do. The moment you blindly condemn a side, you overlook the good things they are trying to do. So Sikhs should be people with their eyes wide open, and not stay committed to a side, but to a purpose. Wars are full of disinformation, lies and one-sided propaganda anyway. And people tend to be manipulated to support evil things with the best intentions. [%sig%]

Re: War in Iraq

Dalbir · 19 Jul 2006

See the problem with freedom is that people have to take it, if it is given to you, its not real freedom in itself. Plus like children who must grow and learn to stand on their own in this world, sometimes overprotectiveness even with the best of intentions can be a hindrence.

Re: War in Iraq

Dalbir · 26 Jul 2006

'Stunning victory' for war families - 27/7/06 The families of British soldiers killed in Iraq have won a dramatic legal breakthrough in their bid to force a full public inquiry into why Britain entered the conflict. In what their lawyers described as "a stunning victory", the Court of Appeal ruled they were entitled to apply for judicial review of the Government's refusal to hold an independent inquiry. The applicants are relatives of four servicemen who died in military action between 2003 and 2005. They say they want the Government "to be held accountable" for a war which "breached international law and was based on a series of lies". Lawyers for the Prime Minister, Secretary of State for Defence and the Attorney General had argued it would be an "unwarranted shift of power" for the courts to make pronouncements on the Government's right to go to war. The family's legal battle looked doomed last December when their application for a judicial review was blocked by Mr Justice Collins in the High Court on the basis that their case was "unarguable". However, on Wednesday the appeal judges overturned that decision and said it was arguable. But, instead of following the usual procedure of sending the case back to the High Court for further hearing, the judges said the appeal court would hear the full application. The decision was made by a panel of top judges - Master of the Rolls Sir Anthony Clarke, the President of the Queen's Bench division of the High Court Lord Justice Judge, and Lord Justice Dyson. Phil Shiner, the families' solicitor, said later: "This is a stunning victory. The Government now have to produce evidence to a full hearing in the Court of Appeal. That evidence needs to establish once and for all whether the decision to invade was lawful. "In particular, the Government must finally explain how the 13-page equivocal advice from the Attorney General of March 7 2003 was changed within 10 days to a one-page completely unequivocal advice that an invasion would be legal. My clients believe he impermissibly changed his advice because he was sat on by the Prime Minister and others in Government. In changing his advice, he sent these soldiers to their deaths." from - http://news.uk.msn.com/Article.aspx?cp-documentid=700171

Re: War in Iraq

Dalbir · 30 Jul 2006

Lately I've been hearing some people saying that the war in Afghanistan is causing heroin problems for the surrounding areas and that there is a bit of a heroin epidemic in the Punjab. Does anyone know if this is true?

Re: War in Iraq

Sevak Singh · 31 Jul 2006

well its pretty clear to see which of you live in USA. speaking from a neutral perspective what america did was disgusting. they do not give a crap about anyone. they invaded Iraq because of the oil not because of freedom and all that other stuff that bush is talking about. if freedoms so important why not go to the Ivory coast and help them out? invading countries doesnt exactly send out a good message to the world so it should be no surprise that there is so much hatred growing towards america. all you Sikhs who support this war ie Japnaam Singh should be ashamed of yourselves. where criticism is due it should be stated. Only Guru Ji knows how many people have been killed all because of oil, its just so hard to believe this is happening and yet no nation has the guts to stand up to the USA