Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

... · 21 Dec 2005

Below is an article from Punjab Monitor, reporting comments on Sikhi by "Sikh" University students in Punjab. Very disappointing.... >>>>>>>>>>>> FRUSTRATED, THE SIKH YOUTH CUT HAIR After the defeat of Sikh rising many of our young boys [and a few girls also] are rebelling right against the religion and cutting their hair though some of them feel that they look smarter that way. Gurinder Singh Johal has carried out a survey to know the reasons. We find they are disgusted with their leaders though most have respect for humanitarian religion of Nanak. We give students' views followed by our comments in italics.. 1.Sikhism has very lofty concepts and I confess I can't reach to that height.-Gurdip Singh Padda, BA-III Khalsa Col, Amritsar. [So you want to be a bad man.] 2. Religion means observation of certain principles. It is not necessary that you attain those principles after you are baptised or you show your externals.-Swinderpal Singh B. Tech. GNDU Amritsar. [Principles will have to be practised while externals is a part of the discipline, like a soldier obeys and wears uniform as well] 3. Humanism is the best religion. How to live life, should we learn it from your leaders? -.Iqbal Dhillon, MA [Pol.Sci.] GNDU Amritsar. [Every religion has its own values. For example Mannu's Brahminism is very discriminatory towards the so called shudras. Then Islam is very harsh towards unbelievers or kafirs. It is Sikhism that says every living being is a part of the greater God and the body is the real temple/church/mosque/Gurdwara.] 4.It is none of my concern what the religion says. But as a girl I know we have to present an attractive personality for matrimonial prospectuses.-Miss Rajbir Dhillon-MBA GNDU Amritsar. [Even the modern beauty contests have ultimately come to the realise that real beauty lies inside, in the intellect, in the behaviour and your outlook. Religion teaches you the secret of life.] 5.I am proud of Sikhism but at the same time I am disgusted to see our preachers who give a very distractive image. -Harry Gill, E.Com Khalsa College, Amritsar. [Search your ideals in Guru Nanak or Guru Gobind Singh or Sahibzada Fateh Singh [Who voluntarily laid down his life at the raw age of 7 years] and not those corrupt jathedars.] 7.I am devout Sikh and I do path everyday. I believe Guru never prohibited cutting hair.-Mandeep Kaur, BA-III, S.N.College Amritsar. [No you are mistaken. Our lords have very categorically commanded through their 'hukamnamahs' not to defile the hair; a gift of nature.] 8.I come from Mukatsar where there is no preaching of Sikhism. Our preachers are in a race for money. Unfortunately whatever the little number of our preacher, they are all illiterate. .-S.S.Sandhu, MBBS SGRD Medical College, Amritsar. [We are happy you have hit at the root of the problem. Guru said only the blessed intelligent will understand Gurbani. The one who could not get proper education and thereby no job finally learns to read and recite Gurbani and becomes granthi. Jatha raja tatha praja. As the ruler so are the ruled. There is overall degradation in values because people have forgotten religion.] 9.Guru Gobind Singh ordered his Sikhs not to cut hair because it was the need of the hour. Now where is the need?-Gurinder S. Sahota; MBBS -Govt Med. Col. Amritsar. [The concept of Nanak is beyond the boundaries of time and space. In what way the world is different today? The religion or the good was then under attack whereas the invasion is now intensified but in a very concealed way. You see all the films and TV serials show Sikh a cleanshaven man while his name bears the suffix of Singh.] 10. Guru's main command to the Sikhs was to shed their ego. Are not our baptised Sikhs more egoistic? So what is the use of hair?-R.S.Bhullar MBBS SGRD Medical College, Amritsar. [It is really sad if a baptised Sikh gives more importance to externals than the true behaviour. Keeping hair intact is the injunction of Guru.] 11.Religion should be flexible. Our Gurus were not fanatic.-Gagandeep S. Bhullar B.Sc. Agr. Khalsa Col., Amritsar. [A true religious person will not be fanatic. He loves all including his enemies even. But religion can't teach flexibility. It can't suggest that at times you can tell lies, steal or be corrupt.] 12. We want to look smart and younger and you know why? [To attract girls]--Maninder Singh,10th and Charanjeet Singh 10th SSSS School and Amardeep Singh 12th Khalsa College Amritsar. [You are mistaken if you feel that you look younger by cutting hair. Do you feel Vajpayee looks younger than Captain Amrinder Singh?. One can't hide ones age by cutting hair.] 13.Our those friends who had trimmed their hair would tease us and call us 'Baba'.-Vikramjeet Singh BA_II, Bhupinder Singh BA-II Khalsa College Amritsar [In fact some people cultivate jealousy towards those who are complete.'If I am corrupted why should he escape?' They don't want that you should be better than them. so they would coin such terms.] 14.There always have been revolutions against rigidity and fanaticism and there is a need for one in Sikhism too. Why are Radhasoamis flourishing because they are liberal.-Prabhjot Singh, BA_II Khalsa,College Amritsar [You are mistaken Guru Nanak raised his cry against fanaticism. Religion teaches love, truthful and rightful living. Even Radhasoamis prohibit their followers from drinking. But it is strange they don't forbid from smoking. Basic feature of Sikhism is submission to the will of God through good deeds and no special postures, dresses and ceremonies. But our respected Radha Soamis suggest certain postures and samadhis and their Guruji wears white cloths. What is that?] 15.I had health problem and I had to cut my hair. -Jaspinder Singh B.Sc. -II Khalsa College- Amritsar [Parts of our body are complimentary to each other. They are in perfect harmony. Skin is never allergic to its own hair. Some times people have nail disease. The hair glands can develop infections. Thus it is most likely that your problem is 'deep rooted'.] 16.You create some example and we will follow you. Sant Bhindranwale was a man and people flocked towards him. -Sukhdeep Singh B.P-II, GNDU Amritsar [Why you expect that some one of your class should come and lead you. Is example of Sahibzada Fateh Singh not adequate.] 18.I want to look smart. You convince me that I will look better with hair and I do that. I haven't come across a single book preaching the tenets of the religion where as others are distributing free. Jatinderpal Singh BPT-II,GNDU Amritsar [Arnold Toynbee the Nobel laureate scholar once wrote, 'The most handsome person of the world is a Sikh, the complete Sikh.' The same Toynbee when saw some clean-shaven Sikhs with the turban said, 'The ugliest person on the earth is a Sikh who has defied his face.' There have been several surveys in the West where the girls said that they liked bearded men more. Unfortunately the mainstream media in India is out to finish Sikhism and thus the media gives a very ugly image of the Sikhs. Most jokes are being coined on Sikhs. You are right. We have learnt that that the Govt doesn't the SGPC to start their own channel.] 20. Sikhism is the best religion of the world. But Sardar turban dealer in Amritsar is cheating the Sikhs.-Deshpal Singh 12th DAV college Amritsar [Would you give up food if your grocer is a cheat?] 21.What is special in Sikhism that is not there in other religion?-Roop Sidhu and Amanpreet Kaur B.Tech. GNDU Amritsar [A religion that tells you to love all and to live a respectful and happy life without any worries, illusions, ceremonies and rituals.]Ð

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

hm · 21 Dec 2005

sounds like a lot of punjabis.

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

jg singh · 21 Dec 2005

Great post, for clarification Arnold Toynbee was not a nobel laureate.

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

Jasmin · 21 Dec 2005

Every once in a while, I visit the Indianparenting message board, haircare section. That board is full of Hindu women who are always talking about shaving their heads and cutting their hair.That message board gives me the hebejebes. If I go there I have to come back here immediately. This is were the sane people are. If anyone questions bana-------let them google that message board. It's like Cruelal Deville form 100 and 1 Dalmations, if it doesn't scare you no evil thing will. Also check out the Women's Issue's section, some interesting comments there too. sogladamhere!!!! WjkkWjkf

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

gareeb_SIKH · 21 Dec 2005

Sometimes,I feel Guru Ji chose wrong set of people to make sikhs.All these people who acting so smart today,ask them what their ancestors were 300-400 years back.Lots of people in Punjab are just losers but yes there are and there always will be some charrdi kalla singhs.

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

khalistan zindabad!!!! · 22 Dec 2005

how are we gonna get khalistan when sikhs are as they are at the moment. there is far too few khalsa to start a country.reading those comments just makes me krodhi

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

confused · 22 Dec 2005

such a sad thing to read..the people in indian go round takin piss out of us "blethi" ppl for drifting from our roots but they seem so much worse! i think the jatheh that come from india to teach us sikhi here seriously need to open the eyes of those back at home and slap some sense back into them!!!

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

Mehtab Singh · 22 Dec 2005

RAAJ BINA NAHI DHARAM CHALEY HAIN We have seen this before and even now. DHARAM BINA SAB DALEY MALEY HAIN We are seeing this alot more clearly now.

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

Ashamed Punjabi! · 22 Dec 2005

Gareeb Singh, I agree. Sometimes I also wonder why Guru Jee chose Punjab as the birth place of the Sikhi. Although as a Punjabi I am thankful to Guru Jee for choosing Punjab to start this universal Dharm. But at the same time I wonder if Punjabis are ungrateful to Guru Jee for Sikhi. When I read the history of our people, we read how our people were oppressed, ignorant, and enslaved by invaders from Central Asia. But Guru Jee changed all that. He gave Sardari to us. From slaves we turned into masters of Punjab. That is why Punjab is known as 'Land of the Sikhs' even though Sikhs just constitute no more than 20% of the entire United Punjab population. I believe that the Sikhs from Jat Background the probably the most ungrateful. I wouldn’t be surprised if all of the above mentioned students are of Jat background. I myself am of Jat background, but I really feel ashamed at how Sikhs of Jat background are showing their ‘gratefulness’ by cutting their kesh out of total disregard of Guru Jee and his sacrifices especially Guru Gobind Singh Jee whose entire family was martyred for Sikhi. I remember when Kulbir Singh wrote his experience that he had with the Kashmiri Sikh cab driver. At first everyone here started to lash out at the views of the Kashmiri Sikh. But after reading the views of the ‘Sikh’ students above I feel the Kashmiri Sikh was absolutely right about Punjabi Sikhs in particular the Jat Sikhs. He was telling the bitter truth. From what I have noticed is that Jats, Labanas, Sainis are probably the worst when it comes to keeping kesh. Tarkhans are far better then them. But Khatris are probably the best when it comes to keeping Kesh. Hopefully Guru jee will do some kirpa on Punjabis and bring them back to the ways of the Gurus. An Ashamed Punjabi!

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

Singh · 22 Dec 2005

Its a fact that most sikh youth do not want to keep kesh. However other youth are doing very little to bring them into sikhi thriugh education, if anything with allot of people they are actually turning them more away by cominig up with things like a mona can't do this and that, rather then encouraging them. The way things are going the Khalsa will be very isolated, and suck comments will be the face of Sikhi

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

Ashamed Punjabi · 22 Dec 2005

Singh, so your opinion is that we should compramise on our asoools by allowing Monaas to do certain sevas which only an Amritdhari can do. I myself was a mona, and I can tell you for certain that most Monas are Monas because of peerpressure or because they want to look 'attractive' to girls, although alot of them do use Bahanas that 'oh we are turned off by Amritdharis who dont let us do this or that'. If they want to start doing seva, they can start by keeping their kesh and not insult the Qurbani of the Gurus by giving money to a barbar.

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

confused · 22 Dec 2005

theres some seva that a non-amritdhari like myself shouldnt/cant partake in but theres also seva that we can do - shoes, cleaning, educating kids, participating in organisation of local events, helping with sikhi camps, collecting/distributing literature, providing a support network for our elderly and our youth...it mite not be preparing langar but its still seva. those that say they are turned off by amritdharis that dont let them do langar di seva are jst lookin for excuses as there is so much they can do. those in india need to stop watchin too much bollywood and come and take a look at some of our youth here, who have managed to keep their rehit, kesh n long flowing beards in a foreign western land where materialism and attachment is the drive for life...they will surely be put to shame. this is not what our forefathers gave their lives for

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

Jasmin · 22 Dec 2005

Yes peerpressure, and unfortunately pressure, in some cases from family--- which is worse, because it's harder to get away from. I'm not sure that anyone really wants to be a mona.

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

confused · 23 Dec 2005

UR RIGHT JASMIN ABOUT PEER PRESSURE...BUT SOMETIMES I THINK PEOPLE DO WANT TO BE MONEH...ONE GUY I KNEW AT UNI HAD GURSIKH PARENTS AND HE HIMSELF WAS A TRIMMED SINGH, HE'D TOLD THEM ON A NUMBER OF OCCASIONS PRIOR TO STARTING UNI THAT HE WANTED TO CUT HIS HAIR THEY NEVER LET HIM. ON HIS FIRST COUPLE OF DAYS AT UNI HE WENT TO THE BARBERS N GOT IT SHAVED OFF. I DONT KNOW IF IT WAS PEER PRESSURE FROM HIS FRIENDS OR TO ATTRACT THE GIRLS, BUT I KNOW HIS FAMILY WAS HEARTBROKEN

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

gareeb_SIKH · 24 Dec 2005

Pyare "Ashamed Punjabi" Veerji I am myself from a jatt background though IT DOESNT ANYTHING TO ME. I feel if some one has Guru ki bakshish,he will be a good sikh whatever his caste is.But for lesser sikhs,I feel culture plays an important role l as we cant expect all sikhs to be guru ka sikhs. I feel jatts if given proper schooling of sikhi can be devastating for their enemies and can be very good sikhs. THere is no doubt that there are many losers in Punjab but one other factor which has lead to the present situation is that we have been staying with a community that follows a blind religion and full of jealousy and betrayal.I am not trying to be angry or over excited and putting blame on others.But I feel its true to say that had sikhs in Punjab been living with some other community(even muslims)things could have been better in my view. Bhul Chukk Maaf KHALISTAN ZINDABAD

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

** · 24 Dec 2005

the thing is tho its true a lot of amritdharis are very arrogant and dont even like talking to mone, then y wud people wnt 2 get in2 it

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

fly fast · 24 Dec 2005

"BUT I KNOW HIS FAMILY WAS HEARTBROKEN" most Punjabi parents dont teach their kids gurbani or the meaning of khalsa and the kakkars. so why are we suprised to c punjabi sikhs cutting their hair????

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

gareeb_SIKH · 24 Dec 2005

<> That is true.But the problem is not of the amritdharis but of the sikh community only.We have made amrit cheap.Every pracharak and all these sadhs just say amrit chakko and then boast of the numbers. Bani is amrit.Naam is amrit.and yes then one should make a full committment and give head to the guru. At present what is happening is that there is a guy who drank,had loose character,took bribes and did haramkhori,then he goes to the divan of some sadh and gets impressed by the sadh and wears the five kakkars. The sad aspect is that monas question amritdharis and amritdharis question monas and in all this DAMAGE IS DONE TO SIKHI. Thats why it is true to say leaving some great sikhs,WE ARE A COMMUNITY OF LOSERS.We dont deserve to have got the the Gift of sikhi.But then Sikhi is above all these things and sikhi will always win. Someone will come in the near future who will set everything write and who knows he might have already come RAJ KAREGA KHALSA

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

Bikramjit Singh Bajwa · 24 Dec 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji Ki Fateh, I am really diaappointed to read this view of my brothers and sisters. Its all about knowledge. Our Religion is knowledge based religion. But unfortunately, its our fault that we counldn't spread Gurus teaching. This was the same feeling of Singhs in 70s and Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh said for such situation: The tenth Guru formed the Khalsa by shedding his blood. When this plant gets dried up, it needs more blood. Then the Guru`s beloved ones spill their blood to keep the Khalsa`s flag flying. This cycle comes approximately every 50 years. Now this situation has come after 20 years, its time to rise in the khalsa spirit. Gur Fateh...

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

Akaali · 24 Dec 2005

Who is to blame. Jathas. No one else. If every stupid illetarate didn't get up and made his own dera or gang and did parchaar of his own selfish beliefs. Parchaaraks would be better and parchaar would be one. Instead of people bein confused, they would know what to follow and what not to. I know a lot of you are part of jathas (gangs) here. First follow proper maryada and preach proper maryada and not of ur stupid dera. That would be very helpful. Monas run away if u talk about keepin hair and are always ready to debate on meat. So follow and do parchaar of one maryada, Akaal Takht maryada and if you think there is something that needs to be changed, present ur view to Akaal Takht and let them decide. Keep the unity. Don't hate Sikhs who are not part of ur Jahta. Don't think u are higher than them. Treat them as brothers too.

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

simran · 31 Jul 2006

well this is v disappointing....allthough i m not sure how f the far above survey is valid coz most of the people i cross checked dnt exist but still the fact remains that r generation needs to wake up n if it has decided to run frm reality then i think the only favour they shd do is atleast stop influences others with their concepts of sikhism n hair...v shd atleast except dat yes v cant follow r religion on the terms it is meant to b followed but v pledge v wont influence n wont give r misleading views abt it to others...... wrote:

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

fresno sikh · 31 Jul 2006

SSAKAL Max Arthur Maculiife who wrote Sikh history also said that it was unfortunate that even sikh of those those times do not know about their own religion and it would be disappear soon. That was about l1890-1905. But sants like Sant Attar Singh ji emerged who changed the entire stage by baptising more than a milion sikhs. Maculiffe dies while reciting Japji Sahib.

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

AB · 31 Jul 2006

Author: Jasmin Date: 12-21-05 18:49 Every once in a while, I visit the Indianparenting message board, haircare section. That board is full of Hindu women who are always talking about shaving their heads and cutting their hair.That message board gives me the hebejebes. If I go there I have to come back here immediately. This is were the sane people are. If anyone questions bana-------let them google that message board. It's like Cruelal Deville form 100 and 1 Dalmations, if it doesn't scare you no evil thing will. Also check out the Women's Issue's section, some interesting comments there too. sogladamhere!!!! WjkkWjkf ````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````Jasmin - What a foolish post. 1. You are a sikh. Why do you need to visit the "haircare" section every once in a while when you already know that they talk about cutting hair. 2. The site is called INDIANPARENTING.COM. If the board is not full of Hindu women, whom will it be full of? The women of Japan practicing Shintoism? 3. I personally went to this site after reading your comments but could not find a single instance of women wanting to "shave their heads". 4. If that message board gives you the "hebejebes", why do you go there in the first place? 5. What was the point of your post afterall?

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

Non-Sikh · 31 Jul 2006

<<>> Exactly. Well Said. I am getting tired of hearing people on these boards blaming all the Jatts for everything instead of blaming all those "Singhs" who are creating groups for own personal beliefs and benefits.

Re: Read Ignorant Comments by Sikh Students on Sikhi

Jasmin · 31 Jul 2006

Something I wrote last summer. It's a personal perversion / morbid curiosity, I don't know what it is , honestly, but a part of me most feel driven to look at car wrecks, however, I made it by New Years resolution to never visit the site again, because it's really better if I don't know. I am the only person in the world who ever felt morbidly curious? At any rate, it all helped bring me here.