Forum
NamDhari response
NamDhari response
jugroop singh · 06 Jan 2006
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh sangat Jio,
althought the Namdhari thread is long gone, i received this email recently - the author did not treply within the thread but chose to contact me privately...this thread began in a forum so i think i should continue here...
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
(if you are reading this Veer Ji, pls note that my comments in response are preceded by an arrow):
>>>
Dear Veer Ji,
I have come across your post. You claimed that people should not listen to namdhari kirtan and they are Guru-less. Did you even think twice before posting such offensive comment.
Namdhari Sikhs keep Guru Gobind Singh jis maradayda. They respect the Granth Sahib, Dasham Granth and Adth Granth pretty well. What knowledge do you have about history? You are going to believe only what you were taught. If you were taught to believe in the Guru Granth Sahib, then believe in it. What right does it give you to vituperate the Namdhari community without any prior knowledge?
> to dismiss the whole NamDhari group, i need know only one thing - you do not accept Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji as the ONE and ONLY SatGuru. there is nothing more to discuss regarding this point.
Look at Sant Bhinderawala who was criminal and committing illegal activities in the holy city of Amritsar front of your Guru Granth Sahib. I have a documentary of the whole incident which would be too painful for you watch of what type of person Binderawala is. I see sikhs like Bhinderwala committing illegal activites in various Gurudawaras in the wold front of yor Guru Granth Sahib. I think it makes you people more Guru-Less than the Namdharis. At least the Namdharis would not dare to do any illegal activies front of their Guru Jagjt Singh Ji.
> your statement above only proves what i just wrote - you are not Sikhs of Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji so it follows that your 'Kirtan' is not addressed to the SatGuru of the Sikhs...therefore your Kirtan is not acceptable to Sikhs because you are not addressing our SatGuru. i won't even address your point regarding Shaheed Baba Janranail Singh Bhinderanwalae...lets leave Dharam Rai to decide between who has the better jeevan - you or him.
You should be praising the Namdhari Sikh's for starting the freedom movment to remove the British out of the country. If it was not for the Namdhari's effort to revolt and sacrifice their lives against the British Government, you would not be here vituperating the Namdharis today. What is also surprising is that the fact that there were only 2 and half sikhs of Guru Gobind Singh Ji was left when Guru Ram Singh Ji discovered that. Do you not have any shame for the Namdharis who sacrificed their lives for their motherland? I really pitty you and your ancestors for thinking the
opposite way instead of looking at the good of people.
> Baba Ram Singh strikes me as an amazing GurSikh personality. history attests to the fact that those who grouped around him were very courageous and as you say, opposed the Biritish. to me he was a GurSikh - to you he was something else. i'm not sure what the NamDhari stance is concerning his 'i am not The Guru' letters but something tells me you think they were either pure humility on his part or fake letters concocted by the British to stop Sikhs from recognising the True 'human' Guru. you have your path and we have ours. what more cna be said
Sincerely,
Jasbir Singh Budwal
Re: NamDhari response
Shaktishali Sha Soora · 06 Jan 2006
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
Whoever that person is that spoke so badly about Sant jarnail Singh Bhinderawala, I hope you go to Saachkhand because after you have now slandered Sant Jee you will be severly punished in hell if you there. So you better ask for forgiveness from Vaheguru Jee due to the fact that Sant Jee is in Saachkhand right now and slandering him was the biggest mistake you've made.
Sant Jee was brought to earth at that time for a special reason, as to uphold the honor of the Sikhs, since the Hindus were killing innocent people, raping Singhnis, they shot a bullet into Guru Granth Sahib Jee, destroyed the Harminder Sahib, etc.
Sant Jee was amazingly special in every way.
sa(n)th kai dhookhan narak mehi paae ||
Slandering the Saints, one falls into hell.
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
Re: NamDhari response
fly fast · 06 Jan 2006
"Sant Jee was brought to earth at that time for a special reason, as to uphold the honor of the Sikhs, since the Hindus were killing innocent people, raping Singhnis, they shot a bullet into Guru Granth Sahib Jee, destroyed the Harminder Sahib, etc. "
The "Brahmanistic Snake" has destroyed many faiths in the past such as jainism. buddhism and the scythian religion of the inavaders of northern india.
The brahmanisitc snake has always seen sikhi as threat to its self hence from day one when sikih (gurbani) came into existence at the will of god, it has been targetted by the brahmanistic snake.
the attack had been further stepped up when the brahmanistic snake became the leaders of the state.
all aspects of sikhi has been targetted, one of thme being the multi proged attack of its temples and the destruction of its temporal head of authroity (akaal takht) the looting and destruction of its history (the refference liabrary and toskhana) and massacres of its people (at the sites of the temple within that week of june and the government organised pograms in delhi november 1984).
one shameful thing has been exposed in the panth is that in delhi massacre those who didnt know sikhi much didnt have the khalsa spirit, thats why the poor souls either tried to run, cut their hair or beg for their lives, those who had the khalsa spirit faught like lions, stories written by both bystanders and media are on this forum.
the brahmanistic snake is the main dusht of the panth, they are the ones who support all these nakli groups like the radha swamis , narakdharis and naamdharis.
Re: NamDhari response
Harcharan Singh · 07 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ka Khalsa,
Jugroop Singh, could you please give the e-mail address of the person to whom you replied, I would like to put a few points accross to him.
Thank you.
Harcharan Singh
Re: NamDhari response
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Jan 2006
BOTTOM LINE...LITMUS TEST...anyone who DOESNT ACCEPT GURU GRANTH JI and GURBANI as GURU is NOT a SIKH.
They can PLAGIARISE/PIRATE... GURBANI and say it is KIRTAN....i say its NOT...because GURBANI is about the TRUE SATGURU..not the human 'jagjit".who will DIE and be replaced any time soon..by another. The TRUE SATGURU of GURBANI is FOREVER. The Radhasoamis also pirate and hijack Gurbani for their own twisted ends...doesnt make their "KATHA"..katha of Gurbani...
Re: NamDhari response
jeeta jattan da · 07 Jan 2006
>>Look at Sant Bhinderawala who was criminal and committing illegal activities in the holy city of Amritsar front of your Guru Granth Sahib. I have a documentary of the whole incident which would be too painful for you watch of what type of person Binderawala is. I see sikhs like Bhinderwala committing illegal activites in various Gurudawaras in the wold front of yor Guru Granth Sahib<<
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
This type of filthy language can come out from a filthy mind.I think this man who has vomitted such a dirty language against Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, either d'not know anything about Sant ji or is mis-informed. This is the fact beyond doubt that he was a stern man of high character and strong standing. In general you will never find an indulged man of high standing of that caliber. What to talk about others, even his own wife could not dare to talk to him after he left over his house. Though I subjectively support his ideology, but I have great regard for his high character. Next in line comes the money that can distract a man. As regards money, he could have amassed loads of money, if he would have ever desired so but you can see for yourself that his sons are plying the same bullock cart he left over while departing his village.
So far as the man has written" your Guru Granth Sahib." Then what right you and your baba ji are left with, to sit cross legged side by side Guru Granth Sahib ji and tell cat and dog stories to the audience.To taste a pitch, ref. Daily Ajit Jalandhar of 3rd instant, how in a serial story baba ji is telling, that a muslim saved a cow and in turn cow saved the muslim as he kept holding the tail of that cow. This was all due to the full kirpa of baba ji. What a compromise!! enacted by the baba ji between the cow and the muslim. Cheap popularity.
This type of language can lead to spark a row that can aggravate the situation beyond control, that all of us witnessed some time ago. So try to avoid it, ders
Re: NamDhari response
A sikh · 07 Jan 2006
Namdharis are doing bad to sikh qaum.
Jagjit singh cant be satguru. Hes a saint, we can agree but not guru.
Re: NamDhari response
ok · 07 Jan 2006
Asikh wrote:
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Hes a saint, we can agree but not guru.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Veerjeeo, with the uttermost respect, DO NOT state anything like this ever again - this is DISGUSTING.
Could you really agree that jagjit is a saint?!
Re: NamDhari response
Gurpreet Sumra · 07 Jan 2006
waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki Ftaeh,
well said fly fast.I think most of the people haven't understood what you are trying to say.This is the problem with Sikh religion at present,We ourself dont read Gurbani, I agree if we can't understand then there are tikkas out there read them, One point I want to say is I am not against anybody, but not all tikkas are supposed to be followed blindly.
We are educated and living in 21st century, so we should figure out ourself that Guru sahib gave us this knowledge 500 years ago and put us on a progressive path, that dont believe in karam kands,narak swarg, everything is here.just remember waheguru all the time and we are now going 1000 years back by asking how can my soul leave body by doing simran.This Sant is in sachkhand,this baba is in khand which is below sachkhand.
Where exactly is this sachkhand, where these sants and babas are enjoying life.
Gurbani says just immerse yourself into waheguru.waheguru is sachkhand .In japji sahib"sachkhand vase nirankar,kar kar vekhe nadar nihal"
Stop listening to stories use your mind, you have Sahib shri Guru Granth Sahib ji.
I know many people will not like what I have written.So I say it in advance that if I have said something wrong forget it and forgive me, but no one can convince me except Guru Granth sahib ji.
Gurfateh
[%sig%]
Re: NamDhari response
Gurdial Singh Virdee · 09 Jan 2006
Where was the "Naamdhari Satguru" when tens of thousands of Sikhs were being murdered during the 1980s and 1990s?
What statements or activity was he making against the autrocities committed on Sikhs? Any of the naamdharis respond? What's the naamdhari viewpoint on 1984 etc?
Re: NamDhari response
Swinder Singh · 09 Jan 2006
Author: Gurpreet Sumra
Date: 01-07-06 16:43
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Piare jeo I think you have gone wrong track. I observe your this post relate to some other thread. Sorry, if I am wrong seeing this.
[%sig%]
Re: NamDhari response
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 09 Jan 2006
Please do not write derogatory remarks/writings to each other, against Satguru Jagjit Singh Ji, Satguru Ram Singh ji of Namdharis organization; Baba Nand Singh Ji, Baba Isher Singh Ji of Nanaksar and Baba Isher Singh Ji of Rare Sahib wale.
It is not easy to hold such a position. It needs to take pains of others (disciples/followers), and to relieve them from their mental, physical and financial agaonies by offerings extra Jap and Tap of Guru Granth Sahib ji by such souls. In any way, these people flourish the naam/simran of Guru Granth Sahib only.
As far as I know, they (as referred above) do not give any Tantar/Mantra/Jadoo/Toona. Their own tongue gets tired by reciting Naam/Simran, for getting transformed others Dukh on them. Akal Purakh has sponsored some duty on them and they are performing inspite of your remarks.
Re: NamDhari response
Bazzer · 09 Jan 2006
Gurpreet Ji,
It seems from your post that you are a very educated person and can understand Guru Granth Sahib Ji very well, from what you say that Narak/swarag is all here, then there doesn’t seem to be any need for an afterlife. If Narak/swarag is all here and we reap what we sow here then what use is the afterlife? Surly the whole point of us doing naamsimran now is that we make a better ‘life’ for us in the afterlife.
There are nether worlds beneath nether worlds, and hundreds of thousands of heavenly worlds above.
The Vedas say that you can search and search for them all, until you grow weary. Guru nanak Dev Ji.
Gauree Gwaarayree, Fifth Mehl:
It torments us with the expression of pleasure and pain.
It torments us through incarnations in heaven and hell.
It is seen to afflict the rich, the poor and the glorious.
The source of this illness which torments us is greed. ||1||
Maya torments us in so many ways.
But the Saints live under Your Protection, God. ||1||Pause||
Re: NamDhari response
Beneras tugs · 09 Jan 2006
>>>You should be praising the Namdhari Sikh's for starting the freedom movment to remove the British out of the country. If it was not for the Namdhari's effort to revolt and sacrifice their lives against the British Government, you would not be here vituperating the Namdharis today.<<<
It would have been better if they never sacrificed anything, how well the British ran India was truley amazing, a far better job then what Indian goverment is doing right now. Atleast the British cared for the country and ran it like proper country instead of having the world's most corrupt leaders and politicains which just want to be seated in the highest positions in politics. People like Bhagat Singh and the Naamdhari movement done a waste by sacrificing their lives for such evidently corrupt and disgusting country such as India.
Naamdharis are not Khalsa they do not hold the true rehit mariyada of Guru Gobind Singh, for a start they don't believe that Keskhee is kakaar so that evidently tells us that they have took rehits from mainstream Sikhi.
Any Sikh of Guru Granth Sahib would never in his dream go to a dabaar of FAKE Guru Jagjit Singh. We have Guru Granth Sahib who is paras - kala. No one should associate with these benaras thug type people.
Sangat jio it is the time of Kaljug if people in Guru Tegh Bahadur's time were trying to take the Guruship then whats the difference now when our Guru is Shabad Saroop and moandhari. Our Guru has always been Shabad Saroop that is why Guru Nanak told the Sidhs "Shabad Guru Surat Dhun Chela," Guru Sahib was the chela of the Shabad himself, what Guru Sahib spoke, the giyaan, was the Guru.
Don't fall for these Guruship stealers. Going to such a Darbaar one will just listen to Gurbani which is being used for the praising of Jagjit Singh when it should be used for Satguru Granth Sahib jeeo.
[%sig%]
Re: NamDhari response
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Jan 2006
Author: Professor Mohinder Pal Singh
Date: 01-09-06 06:06
Please do not write derogatory remarks/writings to each other, against Satguru Jagjit Singh Ji, Satguru Ram Singh ji of Namdharis organization; Baba Nand Singh Ji, Baba Isher Singh Ji of Nanaksar and Baba Isher Singh Ji of Rare Sahib wale.
It is not easy to hold such a position. It needs to take pains of others (disciples/followers), and to relieve them from their mental, physical and financial agaonies by offerings extra Jap and Tap of Guru Granth Sahib ji by such souls. In any way, these people flourish the naam/simran of Guru Granth Sahib only.
As far as I know, they (as referred above) do not give any Tantar/Mantra/Jadoo/Toona. Their own tongue gets tired by reciting Naam/Simran, for getting transformed others Dukh on them. Akal Purakh has sponsored some duty on them and they are performing inspite of your remarks.
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
On the contrary...dear professor sahib jio, it is extremely DEROGATORY to the TRUE SATGURU..for a FAKE to claim the Title. The TRUE SATGURU is Guru nanak and only Guru nanak Ji. That Jyot now resides in the One and True Satguru Dhan Dhan Guru Granth ji Maharaj. all others are FAKES.
It is Extremely EASY to hold jagjit's position.... one just have to relive simple minded folks of their hard earned money, promise them sons, jobs, win court cases , buisness contracts etc etc, PLAGIARISE GURBANIand use it but DENY its position,in this way these fakes flourish their own multi billion dollar businesses of selling religion..
GURBANI says we MUST reap what we SOW....no way we can commit sins and then transfer the sins dukh etc to these FAKES...WE will BURN for our own SINS....no jagjit can take away my sins..
Akal Purakh has not sponsored anybody..its their own wish..IF this theory is true...then it is also true.....maybe Akal Purakh has SPONSORED those of us who EXPOSE these FAKES ??
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 11 Jan 2006
It seems like the bashing of the Namdhari's are not going to stop. I want people take a look at the link below just for knowledge. They do not have to believe what it says.
http://namdhari.faithweb.com/granthpanth.htm
Secondly a person who wished me to go hell for making remarks of Sant Bhindrawalay, I just simply stated it from watching the docmentary of 1984.
Also Veer Ji, I am not worried about hell because in the name of Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji Mahraja, I have nothing to fear. One who wishes someone bad ends up falling down themselves.
In the Gurbani it states: Jis Gobind Dunno Karay Kiskay Lagoo Piyee, Balharee Gur upnay Jis Gobind Deya Malay.
I got a question for everyone in this thread. If the Namdhari Guru Jagjit Singh Ji does come to Toronto Canada this year, what will you guys do about it? I challenge anyone in this room to face Guru Jagjit Singh Ji if they come to Toronto this year. Who dares to take the challege? Anyone?
Vahi Guru Jey Key Fateh!
Re: NamDhari response
... · 12 Jan 2006
Jasbir Budwal,
Your cult is a perverse disgrace.
According to your twisted logic, Guru Gobind Singh lived for 146 years, over 100 of those in hiding. Then he magically transferred the gurgaddi to Baba Balak Singh whom even your cult admits he never met.
Very sensible.
This is all in opposition to the Bhatt Vehis, Rehitnamas and historical texts which say Guru Gobind Singh left his body in 1708 and gave the gurgaddi to eternal Satguru, Satguru Granth Sahib.
Baba Ram Singh himself admitted that he was not any GUru. By the way, when will he be coming back? It's been a while hasn't it? If he's still alive, then how can you have subsequent Satgurus? You call them "jot ka jama" but the fact is that the jot can only reside in one Satguru. When will he be coming back?
Your cult has twisted Sikhi. They have gotten rid of Khalsa's Blue Bana and replaced it with white. You are so proud of your opposition to the British but isn't it true that you got rid of the Kirpan out of fear of the British? YOu replaced Sri Dashmesh jee's gift of Kirpan and rpelaced it with a small model embeded on the kangha and now make a cotton necklace your kakaar.
Your amrit sinchaars are conducted with brass and copper buckets. What happened there?
Your langars are segregated on caste lines. Is your Baba Jagjit Singh so ignorant of Sikhi that he allows caste segregation?
YOu lot are very proud of your sangeet. I would argue your sangeet is less Gurmmat sangeet than it is Indian RAsthri Sangeet. Big deal. Zakir Hussain is a great tabla player, Ravi Shankar is a great sitar player,, that doesn't make them any closer to Gurmat. The same applies to you.
You Kukas are a cursed bunch. You have turned your face from the true Satguru and this is perhaps your bad karma. I have no doubt that your leaders will be punished severely in Dargah for thier lies. Those of you who know the truth of Satguru Granth Sahib and out of simple stubborness and ego won't admit their glory, I would not be surprised if you end up as parasites living in the body of your leader who will be a snake.
You challenge the Khalsa to meet your Baba if he comes to Toronto. If Satguru Granth Sahib and Sri Dashmesh jee puts his hand on our head I(which they certainly will), even an unlearned person could challenge him.
Your own cult is fractured anyways. Fractured on caste lines (separate langars even), and also the Haryana group which only superficially accept your Baba. In the future, your cult will have so many "Gurus" and splinter groups, there will be nothing left.
YOUr stands and beliefs have no basis in anything. You are still waiting for Baba Ram Singh to come back and he never will. And the greatest wonder is that you aren't ashamed to still show your faces and protest that you are right. Absoluetly amazing.
Re: NamDhari response
Gsingh · 12 Jan 2006
Personally condemning people to hell/ punishment etc I believe only akal purakh has the power or judgement to do. So... if we leave punishment to Akal Purakh and IF Namdharis are wrong...i guess they will get punished. What I suggest is that you live your life and let them live theirs and God will take care of the rest ... remember there are a lot of 'religious' people out there following the more widely followed sikhi as well as the other forms - but are not necesarily 'good' people - which leaves the question....whats does it matter what you call yourself!!!!
There are too few sikhs in this world - and as we enter this era of kalyug (which is certainly being illsustrated by recent geo-political events) - it is certainly of grave concern that if we cannot get along or work with each other... this will certainly be detrimental to all parties and not benefit anyone!
[%sig%]
Re: NamDhari response
singh · 12 Jan 2006
"IF" Namdharis are wrong?
"IF"??? They are so clearly wrong, it's not even funny. Unless you yourself are a Namdhari, I'd seriously re-evaluate what caused to even consider "IF" they might be right.
As for them being Sikhs: they are not. A Sikh is a Sikh of Guru Granth Sahib. Not of any human. Namdharis are not Sikhs and there can be no unity with them nor any link.
Re: NamDhari response
ekta · 12 Jan 2006
K, i have to throw in my opinoin.
I would like to start out that I have nothing against Naamdharis, or Naamdhari gurus, what ever thats their buisiness...does'nt effect my jeeevan or yours. There has been no residing body that has said that Naamdharis are anti-panthic. Sure they are not part of the Panth, i totally agree with that they are not sikh, not khalsa, they are "Naamdharis". But that does not put the Khalsa or the SIkh in a position to curse at them. That is my position. I know further to this statement people are going to ask me do i hold the same view towards Nirankaris? I DO NOT,! The NIRANKARIS directly, and openly cursed at the Guru Sahiban, and Mocked Guru Gobind Singh ji, Guru Granth Sahib ji, Punj Pyaraye, and the KHALSA, they are true anti-panthic members. I do not put it beyond scope that the Naamdharis will also follow as such, but untill and IF they do, please do NOT curse at them for practicing what they believe. And yes agreed, a Sikh/Khalsa should only listen to Shabads, and Bani sung by people who believe in Guru Nanak Dev ji to Satguru Sahib Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji, and Khande Bate da Amrit.
And as per the Naamdhari brother( not spiritual but mankind) who cussed at Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa, PLEASE watch more then 1 documentary b4 you swear at PERFECTION, before you use such language at Raab da Roop poora. Sant ji wuz without blemish, he was Guru ji's man, and lived a strict Khalsa life style, in which he practiced both the Spiritual and Physical realms.
He fought for HUMAN RIGHTS (hindus/sikhs/muslims/etc.) not only for Sikhs...he has b'n shown saying that yes some hindu shop keepers are also treated bad, and that Hindu girls are brutally treated post-marriage, and that he will do what ever it takes to stop such disgusting acts. Sant ji again was the perfect manifestation of a human being, sent straight to earth from Saach-khaand by Guru ji themselves.
Re: NamDhari response
singhs · 13 Jan 2006
sadhsangat ji,
the sikhs who believes in gurbani as guru - are expected to read ,understand, respect gurubani than those who don`t . for non-namdharis let us be clear that the base for both thesises is same and only if you go through adi granth and since it is message is eternal ; then the its validity was , is , will always be eternal .i.e--
satgur ki mahima kiya kaha , gur bibek satsar
oh aad jugadi jugo jug pura parmeshawar
now if you think that it was valid only when it was written and as you say that there is no need for satgur now - then gurbani - fir jugo jug attal tan na hoi fir ? as aforementioned gurwak says aad -jugaad and in each jug he is and he is puraparmeshawar then taliking about a few centuries is immaterial . in all worldly affairs we have to seek a guide then how could you think of persuing path of salvation without a satguru?
moreover , the doha you guys recite after each' path' to describe aad granth as guru , who and when it was writtten ? please refer to bhai kahan singh nabha`mahan kosha.
as for as the term `sikh` is concerned it is not for those sikhs of guru gobind singh only . the sikh could be anybody who is deciple of any master
and if namdharis acknowledge satgur jagjit singh as their guru it is there own problem why should any body raise hue and cry ? if a person is a father to someone than it is not necessary for others to do the same , he could be any unlce for rest of the poeple or a respectable elder at least . LAST BUT NOT THE LEAST , AKALLIES HAVE NO RIGHT TO CURSE NAMDHARIS BECAUSE EVEN THEIR GURU BANI DESNOT ALLOW IT. IF THIS IS SO , QOUTE PLEASE . AS YOU SAY ABOUT BHINDRANWALE , LET AKALPURKH DECIDE ALL THIS , NOT YOU.
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 13 Jan 2006
First of all, if you guys cannot respect my Guru Ram Singh Ji, why should I even respect Sant Binderwala. If you guys had spoken in a polite manner about my Guru, I would have not said anything against Sant Binderwala. Do you now realise how much it hurts now whe one talks about a sant in their sect?
For a person who made dregatory comments about my cult being perverse disgrace, what about your cult. Buddy I could make so many negative comments about your cult and it is not even funny. At least in my gurdawara we do not fight over tables and chairs and use a Kirpan to slash someone over stupidity. A person was caught carrying Sri Granth Sahib Ji in his suitecase. In one incident, I watched a sant washing Sri Granth Sahib Ji with a soaked cloth. I could go on further if I want but before you make any pro and cons about one sect, please look yourself in the mirror first.
Where the hell were you guys when the British pretty wiped our your sect in the 1800s? If you are firm believers of Sri Granth Sahib Ji, why did the Granth Sahib who you considered so called Guru not assist you in a distressful situation? Sorry to say this, according to history your sect were the slaves of the British that were obeying every command of the British. What is even sad was the fact that Sri Satguru Ram Singh JI was disgusted to see only 2 and half sikh that time. All your sect forgotten the Marayda of Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji which Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji had to revive by recreating a new Sant Khalsa Panth known as the Namdhari's. I suggest you read Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji's Jevan Kutta and learn about what kind of Guru he was and what powers he had possessed.
Another question I got for you, When Guru Jagjit Singh Ji visited Amritsar many years ago, why did the preists of the golden temple bow to Guru Jagjit Singh Ji if they were so against him? The Nighangs are way better Sikhs that you people ever will be. The Nighangs have so much respect for the Namdhari's and get along pretty well.
If you cowards have so much problem with the current Guru, why do you not do something about it instead of having pointless debates and shooting your mouth like little boys. Do not worry, when Guru Jagjit Singh Ji do come to Toronto, it might be this year, I suggest you people get all your so called Sikhs and revolt against the Guru. Show me how much power you people have.
Even as a Namdhari I go to all the other gurdawaras as respect and I am not afraid of anyone or anything. I wear my golden necklace of Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji's picture without any fear. I have gone to Amritsar wearing my Namdhari Kurta Pajama and received a lot of respect from the Sikh's there.
I got some interesting news for you; the host of Sur Sagar Tv Ravinder Singh Pannu had fallen to Guru Jagjit Singh Ji's feet and he is not even Namdhari. Ravinder Singh Pannu had came to the Namdhari Gurduawara along with Gurbax Mali Member of Parliament a few times. Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh of India went to Sri Bhani Sahib to pay respect to Satguru Jagjit Singh Ji. We had few Nighangs of Amritsar come to Sri Bhani Sahib to pay respect to Guru Jagjit Singh Ji. We had people who were not Namdhari's had darshan of Satguru Ram Singh Ji and they became Guru Ram Singh Ji's Sikh.
Anyhow I have said enough, the best way to end all disputes is for someone who has something negative to say about the Namdhari's, I suggest that they come to one of the programs when Guru Jagjit Singh Ji is here and try to prove them wrong. It is a open challenge for anyone and please do make another posts of stating that I am not going to go blah blah blah etc.. I just want a YES or a NO answer to accept the challange that is all.
Vahi Guru Jey Key Fateh
Re: NamDhari response
... · 13 Jan 2006
Kukas,
You said, “for a person who made dregatory comments about my cult being perverse disgrace, what about your cult.”
Well, I’m glad you admit you’re in a personality cult. That’s the first step. I’m not in any cult. I believe in Satguru Granth Sahib jee and that’s no cult. You bring up examples of idiots doing stupid things. Those are exceptions. There are stupid people in every group. That doesn’t reflect the belief of the majority or the principles themselves. If some baba decides to wash Guru Granth Sahib, that reflects his stupidity, and I have no problem calling that stupid because it goes against the values and beliefs of Gurmat.
The British didn’t “wipe out” my “sect” (actually the majority is never called a sect, some off shoot group is the sect, not the mainstream). You ask why didn’t Guru Granth Sahib assist us in that situation. You must be awfully stupid. The fact that we exist today is proof enough that Guru Sahib did assist. The miracle at Sri Darbar Sahib (look that up on this site) started a process by which Sikhi was rejuvenated. If it was your cult (btw. I have full respect for Baba Ram Singh and think he was a Gursikh), then we’d all share your beliefs and practices. The fact that there are Sikhs in existence today and that we don’t’ follow your cult, shows that your cult was not solely responsible for the Sikh revival. If it was then we’d all be Kukas. Simple logic.
I seriously doubt the Granthis of Sri Darbar Sahib bowed to your Baba like you are claiming. Even if some ignorant people (Nihangs, babas, anyone else) did bow to your Baba, it doesn’t mean a thing. India is FILLED with ignorant people who will bow to anyone and anything. There are pictures of stupid Nihangs and regular people bowing to Bhainaravala Baba. Does that prove any point at all? No, of course not. It just means that stupid people will do stupid things.
You want us Sikhs to “do something” about your Baba. What do you propose? Your cult isn’t physically doing anything against the Panth, so there is no need to respond with any physical action. If you and your companions EVER try anything [i]physical[/i] against the Khalsa, then you’ll get a reply in kind. Otherwise, if you are doing false parchar you can expect that we will be doing Parchar of the truth to show that your group is wrong.
To be clear, I have no problems with people following cults. That’s their choice. But the moment they try to say that Guru Granth Sahib isn’t the real Guru, and their Baba is, that is something that is false and I will speak against it. If you happen to follow Baba Jagjit Singh, that’s great. I don’t care. But don’t try to say he is the real Satguru on the throne of Sri Guru Nanak Dev. Only Satguru Granth Sahib jee is.
“I wear my golden necklace of Sri Satguru Ram Singh ji’s picture” Are YOU even familiar with Namdhari principles? Namdharis are supposed to live simply and use of jewellery is not acceptable. The Namdharis were a good Jatha at first that kept good rehit. The moment they began to call Baba Ram Singh “Satguru”, all their “kala” began to disappear. Your use of gold necklaces with pictures is prime example. But who’s going to stop you from going to Darbar Sahib? Anyone can go there. You also fall into the category of “anyone”.
Then you mention Malhi and PM Manmohan Singh. They are politicians. They go wherever they can get votes. Manmohan Singh may have paid respect to your Baba but he also bows to Sadhus, pays respect to Yogis and Mullahs. That doesn’t mean a thing.
There are loads of Kukas who have become good Sikhs. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh has included one such jeevan in Rangle Sajjan. There are many others.
As for challenging your Baba: sure, why not. But I really don’t think your Baba would be willing to debate.
I suggest you answer the following questions:
1) How did Guru Gobind Singh live over 100 years in hiding?
2) How did he give Guruship to someone he had never met?
3) Why do Kukas have caste segregated langars?
4) Why have Kukas stopped wearing kirpans?
5) What do you say to all the historical evidence from Bhatt Vehis, Rehitnamas, Puratan Granths which all say the Guru is Sri Guru Granth Sahib?
6) Why do you use brass buckets for amrit sinchars?
That’s just a starting list. When you’ve answered these, I’ve got MANY more to go.
On a final note; singhs said “oh aad jugadi jugo jug pura parmeshawar” proves that Guru Granth Sahib cannot be Satguru. Do you even know what a Satguru is? Is a Satguru a physical body? Or is Satguru a jot? Satguru Granth Sahib is the aad jugaadi Satguru that will be here for eternity. Kukas don’t seem to understand even what Satguru is. If Baba Ram Singh is your Guru and he is still alive (according to you), then how can you have other Gurus? You call them “jot ka jama” but that doesn’t make sense. The jot can’t be in two places. Satguru Granth Sahib is the perfect Guru and the proof for this is not just in the “doha” you talk about, it’s in puraatan Bhatt Vehis of Bhatts who were present when Guruship was given to Guru Granth Sahib. It is backed up by rehitnamas and other historical Granths. Your beliefs however have no historical validity.
Re: NamDhari response
Gurdev Virdee · 13 Jan 2006
well who ever you are mate i am sure you did not do your home work well. all the 10 gurus of sikhs from Guru nanak to guru gobind singh ji left there bodies when they went to hevan and that goes for all human being. i am sure you have not been reading gurbhani, it say who ever is born will die, even you. if you believe in Guru Granth Sahib beleive it properly and do what is written in it. it teaches brother hood and love but i feel you just learn to hate. Guru Gobind Singh ji say we are all sons of one father then how come you say this type of things. i say beleive in whatever you want. all religions teachs us love humanity. i am namdhari and i am proud of that as i learnt what does gurbhani says and how we should follow it. if you keep of shouting and saying who are sikhs and who are not sikhs then you are wasting your time. read about Bhai Kaneyia and learn something, he was giving water to muslims and sikhs as he saw them all alike. that is true sikh not you. what is your maryada, do you follow what is written in Guru Granth Sahib. i have worked with Ramgariha Temple in Nairobi for six months and we worked as brothers. this type your comments are dividing us all and making us weak. so if you are real sikh and follow it, am sure you will stop talking like this in future and respect all. may god give you gursikhi
Re: NamDhari response
... · 13 Jan 2006
Gurdev Virdee,
I'm not sure I understand your point.
The Gurus did not go to "heven". Heaven is not for Gursikhs so it certainly cannot be a place for our Satguru. I believe that Satguru Nanak came from Sach Khand, always was in Sach Khand and will always remain there. They came to reveal naam.
As for hate: I don't hate Kukas. I don't consider them Sikhs and I would not have said anythign about them had some Kukas not been so arrogant to say there was no reply to their points and we Sikhs are in the dark about who the real Guru is. You are free to beleive in what you want, but the moment you publicly declare that Guru Granth Sahib is not Satguru, then be ready for your view to be attacked.
Re: NamDhari response
harjeet singh · 13 Jan 2006
waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh.
dear brothers and sisters i have been reading these messages and i am disgusted in what i have been reading. does it matter what religion you are? if god is the father of all, then what r u all quarrelling for? ur slaundering each other for no reason. i believe that all religions divide the world but the khalsa panth was created as the true religion because guru gobind singh ji maharaj said himself:
"hum eh kaj jagat moh ayye, dharam het gurdev pataiye" the sole belief of the khalsa panth is to believe in one god and no other. guru nanak dev ji maharaj also said that people shouldn't put importance to religious more to god. but it was god's will to have all these religions. personally i think god did this as a test to see whether human beings can live together in harmony but you people are showing me that you have failed this test.
i am 16 years old and i feel ashamed to have elders of the sikh community saying these kind of things.i don't represent anybody i am here for one reason to dedicate my life to waheguru ji.
waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: NamDhari response
akalyoga · 13 Jan 2006
Let's shed some light on Namdharis. Namdharis claim that they follow the rehit of Guru Gobind Singh, first Guru Gobind Singh made the Siri Guru Granth Sahib and the Khalsa the Guru, one the shastra Guru containing the Guru Siddhanta or teachings of the Sikh panth and the other the Khalsa to perform the duties of the Gurus Deh-body. Saina Pat an intimate disciple of Guru Gobind Singh reports this in gur sobha. This book was written a few years after the ascension of Guru Gobind Singh, and no scholar disputes it.
The Namdharis believe in caste and having caste-jati as a condition for liberation.
The Namdhari Satguru Jagit Singh was heard telling an America Sikh two years ago that all Western people are in effect untouchables and they as well as mazabhi Singhs cannot obtain liberation from the Holy Name Harnam until they are reborn in a Namdhari family from one of the four varnas. He further rejecting the example of Guru Gobind Singh who embraced the Ranghetra who became Jivan Singh for returning the Beloved Head of the Ninth Guru to Guru Gobind Singh by saying touching Westerners and mazabi-chamar-chura Singhs makes one liable to take a bath as one becomes polluted. This in effect denies that Harnam that is God, non-different from God Sat Nam has the power to overcome karma and makes mundane the actual presence that Harnam is.
Caste pollution is not part of Gurmat of Guru Gobind Singh or any other Guru and is the reason why the ''polluting'' words of Namdev appeared in the Guru Granth Sahib, or why in non Namdhari Gurdwaras all inter dine.
In the namdhari meditation hall at Sri Bhaini Sahib their main center there is a brass rail enclosing an area of the gurudwara to the left of the palki their Satguru sits under. This area is designated as the area for mazabhi Singhs so they will not pollute others. Namdharis have separate Amrit for Mazabhis untouchable Sikhs and separate langar. In the times of the Gurus there was one langar that the foreigner untouchable sat at the Gurus invitation.
The present Sat guru is in fact not the actual Satguru of the Namdharis, that is Baba Ram Singh who they understand did not die in British custody but escaped and will live 250 years as he predicted. Satguru Jagit Singh is in fact officially according to Namdhari teaching jot ka jama not Satguru and is acting in the place of Satguru Ram singh who will soon return to take up his gaddi.
Namdharis practice Havans one of the few to do so in the Sikh panth as well as marry around fire sacrifices which was the practice of the Sikh Gurus.They believe in gau rakha and vegetarianism which are Guru Gobind Singh not unique either in the Sikh panth as some writings of Guru Gobind Singh not in Dasam Granth which say good things about havan-homa and gau rakhsha cow protection. They hold all of the dasam granth is of Guru Gobind Singh and have even other of his writings. They also hold that the present edition of the Siri Guruu Granth Sahib has many mistakes and only the Satguru knows them. the give Gur-mantra either by their Satguru or his representatives known as Subhas. They give it easily to almost anybody and anyone who is around them will have it whispered in their ears. they regard only Guru mantra received this way is effacacious.
Namdharis meditate and listen to kirtan in homes and dharmasalas around the world. The bow before a picture of Satguru Jagit Singh in these centers. These gatherings are very meditative and the non argumentative nature of Namdharis reminds one of how the Gurudabars must have been.
By me it is unfortunate that they hold caste in such high esteem and treat someone their own teachings say in not Satguru as Satguru.
Satguru Jagit Singh has done wonderful things to revive kirtan and is a dedicated elderly man. During the Indian goverements attacks on innocent Sikhs and various Sikh shrines and houses of worship and raping of women and girls he kept his loyalty with the congress party. this was sad for such a noble person. He is a loyal congressmam and one of his dear disciples is head of the Panjab Congress.
Sri Bahini sahib has a peaceful mood sactified by decades of japa which bring tap and sanjam contentment. One cannot but be impresed by them but their almost secret caste understandings are contrary to Guru Gobind Singh's rehit and one who teaches other than that rehit cannot be Guru in my humble opinion. Namdharis are Sikhs of either Baba Ram Singh or Satguru Jagit Singh who trace their lineage back throught Satguru Balak Singh to Guru Gobind Singh who they believe did not die at Nanded but disappeared and became Ajaypal singh remaing in seclusion while the mughals devastate the panth and Indian religion, not my idea of Guru Gobind Singh .
I have tried to make this as neutral as possible yet still express my opinion as I loved my time in Namdhari Sangats but cannot abide their unjust treatment of Mazabhi Singhs. To sit by while this was done is in my opinon is to not be an honorable Khalsa. There is much good example in Namdhari Sangats and much bad practice. May we pray for them in our Ardas and may our intentions be pure so that we may agree to disagree and that we both attain Waheguru's kirpa which depends on one's love not one's sect.
We as Sikhs are honor bound to be kind to them as they too look to the Gurus for inspiration and hopefully that inspiration will allow them to see the truth of what the Guru's teach in all it's completeness and purity.
Re: NamDhari response
sarbjit · 17 Jan 2006
bhai sahib ji ,
waheguru ji ki fateh .
where did you find written that aad granth is guru of sikhism? where is this written in granth sahib that it replaces satguru after 10th master`s demise?
do you think that guru gobind singh was not farsighted enough to judge about the controversy and write something about this in granth sahib?
did you ever read bhai kahan singh nabha`s mahankosha where he has mentioned about rahatnama you refer to about granth sahib as satguru for your thesis?
ARE YOU AWARE THAT GOD ALMIGHTY IS OMNIPOTENT ,OMNISCIENT AND MATTER AS WHOLE IS NEUTRAL? FOR A BALANCE - EQUAL AND OPPOSITE FORCES ARE INTEREACTING IN THE NATURE AND TO UNDERSTAND GOD ALMIGHTY NOT ONLY YOU SHOULD PRESENT YOU OPINION BUT HAVE PATIEMCE TO LISTEN TO WHAT YOU CONSIDER AS OPPOSITE VIEW?
DID YOU EVER RECITE AAD GRANTH SAHIB YOURSELF AND TRY TO CONSIDERED ITS MESSAGE WRITTEN IN SIMPLE PUNJABI ? OR YOU ARE JUST PROPAGATING WHATEVER YOU WERE TOLD ?
I AM OF THE FIRM OPINION THAT YOU WILL FIND YOUR THESIS ON DIFFERENT FORMAT THAN IT IS NOW ON , JUST DONOT GO THROUGH IT WITH PRE-CONCEIVED NOTION . FIND IT FOR YOURSELF WHAT SAYS AND I AM SURE THAT YOU WILL GET THE MESSAGE VERY CLEARLY BECAUSE FOR YOU GURUBANI IS GURU.
SAT SIRI AKALL.
Re: NamDhari response
.... · 17 Jan 2006
Sarbjit
When there was debate over who was the true Satguru have Guru Harkrishan Sahib, why didn't Guru Sahib simply write down in Guru Granth Sahib who would be next? The argument is stupid. Guru Granth Sahib doesn't have who will be the next Guru written anywhere.
This "controversy" is not that big a deal. It's a handful of Kukas making an outlandish claim that Guru Sahib lived to 146 years old (over 100 in hiding) and then gave Guruship to Baba Balak Singh (someone he never even met, even according to Kukas).
This is no "controversy". It's just a few people who are being confused by their leaders.
All puratan rehitnamas and sources say Guru Granth Sahib was given gurgaddi. Kahn Singh Nabha believed in Guru Granth Sahib. He was not a Kuka.
Although it's not relevant here and it's none of your business, I have read Sri Guru Granth Sahib multiple times and I try to consider the message. The message is clear: Shabad is Guru. It's not some human body.
If you want to continue this discussion, please answer:
1) How did Guru Gobind Singh live over 100 years in hiding?
2) How did he give Guruship to someone he had never met?
3) Why do Kukas have caste segregated langars?
4) Why have Kukas stopped wearing kirpans?
5) What do you say to all the historical evidence from Bhatt Vehis, Rehitnamas, Puratan Granths which all say the Guru is Sri Guru Granth Sahib?
6) Why do you use brass buckets for amrit sinchars?
Re: NamDhari response
WANT ANSWERS · 17 Jan 2006
I was going thru all the msg above and i learn alot about what all the bhai sahabs have to say, both parties i mean. Well i want the kukas bhai sahab to answ all the question that the previous bhai hv asked?
If you want to continue this discussion, please answer:
1) How did Guru Gobind Singh live over 100 years in hiding?
2) How did he give Guruship to someone he had never met?
3) Why do Kukas have caste segregated langars?
4) Why have Kukas stopped wearing kirpans?
5) What do you say to all the historical evidence from Bhatt Vehis, Rehitnamas, Puratan Granths which all say the Guru is Sri Guru Granth Sahib?
6) Why do you use brass buckets for amrit sinchars?
GURFATEH,
MALAYSIAN SIKH
AWAITING FOR THE ANSWERS NAMDHARIS
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 18 Jan 2006
Dear Veer Ji,
The questions you asked above, you can seek answers by joining this group on yahoo called http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Namdhari/. Post these questions on the site there and the whole Namdhari clan will be happy to answer your questions in a polite manner.
(Aad Granth Sahib - Page 1013)
While advertising Sri Aad Granth Sahib as Guru, many times the Dohra 'Aagya Bhei Akal Ki..' (along with other fake/altered banis) is reinforced in order to influence the audience.
This Dohra was first introduced in the third publishing (which was named appropriately as 'SECOND edition') of the Great Sikh Literature; Panth Parkash by Giani Gian Singh Ji.
-*It is also worth noting that in this third publication, the fact that Guru Gobind Singh Ji transferred Guruship to Guru Balak Singh Ji was also left intact.*-
Today, this Dohra is being sold in two flavours:
1. As a Sri Mukh Vaak (Gurbani Spoken by Guruji).
2. Rehitnama of Bhai Prehlad Singh.
However, it is widely accepted that the first flavour is a definite fake, since it is found neither in Dasam Granth nor any other Historical Literature.
Thus, the claim for it to be a Rehitnama of Bhai Prehlad Singh, a Sikh who served Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji, should be investigated.
Like many other ordinary fibs, it takes only a few seconds to find out the authenticity of this bani.
The date of composition mentioned in this bani is 1752 Bikarmi, a date that was 4 years prior to Creation of Khalsa in 1756 Bikarmi (1699 AD)! This fact certainly does not add up. According to the Singh Sabha leaders, it's believed by them that Granth Sahib became guru in the year 1708 AD. (When Guru Sahib left Nander), but this bani says that guruship was transferred about 13 years before the incident!
The next issue is: When was guruship given to Aad Granth Sahib?
There are FOUR other dates that are claimed to be the time when guruship was transferred:
1. Katak Sudi 2nd, according to 'Takhat' Sach Khand and as printed on most volumes.
2. Katak Sudi 3rd, according to the SECOND edition (Third publication) of Panth Parkash.
3. Katak Sudi 4th, from an altered version of Sri Guru Sobha.
4. Katak Sudi 5th, mentioned by Munshi Sant Singh.
-*Gurgaddi was transferred to Guru Balak Singh in 1812 AD (1869 Bikarmi, Vaisakh Sudi 10th). And there's only ONE date to this Fact!*-
This difference in date probably happened because of the inability of Singh Sabha leaders to co-ordinate with each other as well as the Pujaris sitting at different Temples to fix a single date.
The next issue is: 'How' was guruship transferred?
Some say that when Guru Sahib gave guruship to the volume of Aad Granth Sahib, He Verbally Dictated the entire granth which was recorded by Bhai Mani Singh. It is also further fabricated that the specific volume contained only 1 letter that was different than that of the Original Aad Granth Sahib. This entire fabrication is not mentioned in any Sikh Literature written before the creation of Singh Sabha Lahore and neither is there any other valid proof to support it.
According to Bhai Kahn Singh of Nabha, a famous Singh Sabha scholar whose great-grandfather served Guru Sahib when Guruji disguised Himself as Baba Ajaypal Singh Ji, it was admitted that such an incident never took place. In fact, Bhai Kahn Singh even accepted that there was no volume of Aad Granth present at Nander when the incident happened! But he, being an englishmen-influenced person (Singh Sabhia) said that Guru Sahib transferred Gurgaddi in the similar manner as Guru Harkrishan Sahib Ji transferred Guruship to Guru Tegbahader Sahib Ji.
This tremendously confuses one who wants to know the truth, even those who believed whole-heartedly in granth-guru. For firstly there are 4 different dates, and secondly there are 2 different fairy-tales to go along with those dates!
*In order to prove beyond the smallest trace of doubt that Sri Aad Granth Sahib was never given Gurgaddi by Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji, the following Historical Books may be quoted:
1) AmarNama: This Book was successfully written by Nathmal Dhadi, a Hazuri Ragi in The Darbar of Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji, on 31st October 1708. Only 24 days after Guruji's Actions at Nander. In this book, he has written the following regarding Satguruji's last Thoughts and Hukam:
(Translation: My Wish is to follow the Path of Amar Jeevan(Immortal Life). May The Almighty Spread Happiness. My Sikhs should stay to themselves and listen to Kirtan from Dhadis. [No where is it written that Guruji gave Gurgaddi to Aad Granth Sahib])
2) Sri Guru Sobha: This book was successfully written in 1768 Bikarmi, about 3 years after Guruji's actions at Nander. Though some believe it to be completed in 1798 Bikarmi it still does not make much difference since the author, Kavi Sainapat, was a Hazuri Kavi(Poet) in The Darbar of Satguru Gobind Singh Ji and his work is considered a highly reliable source of Sikh History. Regarding Satguruji's final Actions at Nander, Kaviji has written the following:
(Translation: At that time, the Singhs woke up. When Guruji Announced Vaihguruji Ki Fateh the final time. The Singhs were all in a shock. Whatever questions they had in their minds, remained unanswered, and nothing could be asked from The Guru. [No where is it written that Guruji gave Gurgaddi to Aad Granth Sahib])
3) IbratNama Swaneh: This book was written by Mirza Muhammad Harsi in Farsi. The volume was completed in 1718 A.D. covering The History of the Sikhs from 1703 A.D. to 1718 A.D. but again it is no where mentioned that Guruji gave Gurgaddi to Granth Sahib. Rather, he has written that Baba Ajit Singh, an adopted son of Mata Sundriji, was the next guru after Guru Gobind Singh Ji.
4) IbratNama 1722 A.D.: This book was written by Syed Muhammad Kasim Hussein of Lahore. He has written similarly as the older IbratNama and again, there's no mention of Granth Sahib being proclaimed guru in this book.
5) IbratMakaal: Written in Farsi by the same author, Muhammad Kasim, in 1731 A.D. He has written that The Guru was attacked by a Pathan and His Sikhs conducted His funeral using Chandan wood. Again, no mention of Granth Sahib being proclaimed guru.
6) Chahar Gulshan Akhbaar Al Nivadaar(Chatur Gulshan Khulasa Al Nivadaar): Written in Farsi in 1759 A.D. by Rai Chatarmaan. He has written very clearly that Guruji DIDNOT give Gurgaddi to anyone at Nander but many of His Sikhs believed guru Ajit Singh to be the person on the Gurgaddi.
7) A few pamphlets, as admitted by dr. ganda singh - a singh sabha writer, had also been written on the Sikhs in eighteenth century by men like Antoine L. H. Polier(in 1780 A.D.), William Franklin(between 1798-1803) etc., and none of them contain any information regarding Sri Aad Granth Sahib being given The Gurgaddi.
8) A Journey from Bengal to England: Written by George Forster in 1798 A.D. has the following regarding Sikh History and belief:
"...and a tradition delivered to the Sicques(Sikhs) limited their priests to teh number of ten, induced them to appoint no successor to Gobind Singh."
Again, no mention of Sri Aad Granth Sahib being guru.
9) Majma Al Akhbar: Written by Harsukh Rai starting from 1214(1709 A.D.) Hijri and ending in 1220 Hijri(1805 A.D.). He had the following to say about Sikh's Gurus:
(Translation: Guru Gobind Singh was the final Guru after Guru Nanak. [No where is it written that Guruji gave Gurgaddi to Aad Granth Sahib])
10) Miratul Ehvaal: Writen by Ahmed Bin Muhammad Ali in 1810 A.D. He has written that all of The Guru's sons were Martyred and hence there was no successor of His after Him:
[No where is it written that Guruji gave Gurgaddi to Aad Granth Sahib]
11) Twarikhay Sikha: Written by Khusvakat Rai in 1812 A.D. He has again written similarly as the other writers of the time stating that The Sikh's Gurus were only from Guru Nanak to Guru Gobind Singh. No any other:
[No where is it written that Guruji gave Gurgaddi to Aad Granth Sahib]
12) The Court and Camp of Ranjeet Singh: Written by W. G. Osborne in 1840 A.D. He had the following to say about about The Sikh's Gurus:
"The tenth and the last of their spiritual leaders was called Gobind Singh, whose plans of ambition were different from those of his predecessor Nanak (Page XIX)"
[No where is it written that Guruji gave Gurgaddi to Aad Granth Sahib]
13) Khalis Nama Min Tasneef Rattan Chand Bal: Written in Farsi in 1846 A.D., it clearly stated his belief that The Guru left His Body in 1765 Bikarmi in the month of Bhadon on the Blessed land of Sri Abchal Nagar. Again, nothing about Granth Sahib being given Gurgaddi is mentioned.
14) Twarikhay Punjab Az Tasneef Gulam Muhiudeen Uraf Butay Shah: Written in 1848 A.D., it only states that The Guru Remained on His Throne for 32 years and 11 months and left His Body in 1765 Bikarmi on Katak Sudi 5th. No mention of Guruji giving Guruship to anyone or anything is made in this publication.
15) Travels in Kashmir and the Punjab: Written by Baron Charles Hugal in 1845 A.D., who stayed as a guest of the Maharaja, Ranjeet Singh, and had the following, written on page 263, to say about Sikh History:
"The office of the Guru, however, was not filled up; first, because the Sikhs long expected the return of Gobind Singh, of whose death they never received any certain information; and also, when after so long time had elapsed since his escape, that the fact of his death could no longer be doubted, the whole of their society, if I may so express it, had undergone a change, Gobind Singh has remained up to this time the last acknowledged spiritual head of the Sikhs."
So here it is crystal clear that The majority of the Sikhs did not believe in any other Guru other than Guru Gobind Singh even so long after the incident at Nander in 1708 A.D.!
16) Sketch of the Sikhs: Written by Malcolm Lt. Col. in London in 1812 A.D. He has the following to say about Sikhism:
"This sect, as has been before stated, have never admitted a spiritual leader since the death of Guru Gobind Singh." (Page 89)
17) The History of The Sikhs: Written by W. L. McGregor and published in London in 1846 A.D. He has written 'Banda Bairagi' to be the next guru of The Sikhs after Guru Gobind Singh.
18) Panth Parkash: Written by Rattan Singh Bhangoo in 1841 A.D. in which he stated The Names of all Sikh Gurus. But no where is 'guru granth sahib' or 'guru panth khalsa' ever found after Guru Gobind Singh.
19) Sri Gurpartap Suraj(Suraj Parkash): Written by Kavi Bhai Santokh Singhji in 1843 A.D. He has infact written that it was the Eighth Avatar of Guru Nanak, Sri Guru Harkrishan Sahib Ji, who once attempted to give Gurgaddi to Sri Aad Granth Sahib but It was rejected by The Sikhs of the time who requested Him that people such as Dhirmal would all sit with a Bir(Volume) in their hands and fabricate Its translations in order to control people!
Regarding Guru Gobind Singh Ji's Actions at Nander, however, Kaviji had clearly written that The Guru told Kavi Alam Singh how He would secretly take care of The Khalsa and remain incognito in The Eleventh Avatar:
Therefore, considering all the above mentioned reliable literature, all written well before The Initiation of The Sant Khalsa(Namdhari) by Satguru Ram Singh Ji Maharaj(In 1857 A.D.), it is clear that The Sikhs themselves were very much hopeful that The Guru would surely return. Whereas the muslims were led to believe that there was either no other guru or that either Banda Bahader or Ajit Singh was the next guru. No where is it ever mentioned that Guruji Gave Guruship to Sri Aad Granth Sahib or Panj Pyare or Panth Khalsa!*
So What really is the Truth? How were the Granth, Panj Pyares and Panth proclaimed gurus by the singh sabha and "WHY"? To fully understand the truth, one must know the history of Punjab after Satguruji were sent to exile in 1872.
Re: NamDhari response
.... · 18 Jan 2006
Kuka “Dead Man Walking”,
Unfortunately your training kicked in and you started to rail against the “Guru Maniyo Granth” quote when I haven’t even mentioned it. I don’t need to. The number of other sources which say the exact same thing make it just one amongst many.
Although I could argue with you over this doha (which in fact was spoken by Sri Dashmesh jee and recorded after), but it’s not worth it.
You then mention different dates about the gurgaddi divas of Sri Satguru Granth Sahib jee. That’s a silly point. There is no consensus on the birth date of Guru Nanak, Guru Gobind Singh or the real date of Baisakhi 1699 (some say 1698), so if there is difference in the date of Sri Guru Granth Sahib jee’s ascension to Gurgaddi, it is no surprise at all. Just because there are different dates for Guru Nanak’s birth and birth of Khalsa, would you also argue these events didn’t take place?
Your cult has a definite date for the fairy tale of Baba Balak Singh because it is a lie you concocted. If you made up the story, without ANY source mentioning it, you could have picked any date you wanted.
Then you start going on about Bhai Kanh Singh. No doubt he was a great scholar, but he was not perfect. He made mistakes. Every source out there says that Guru Granth Sahib was present in Nander. Why wouldn’t Guru Sahib take the Adi Granth Sahib with him from Damdama Sahib when the sangat shifted? You are making up stories.
Before I begin to debunk your essay of lies I want to say, you are headed for very severe punishment. It is one thing to have no knowledge and then preach the wrong facts, it is another to have the sources and then try to twist them to support your lies when they clearly cannot be easily twisted.
1) Amarnamah: This document was amended to Guru Sobha and was written before Sri Guru jee’s ascension. It makes no mention of Guru Sahib’s final day. It does not describe Guru Sahib’s Shahidi it does not describe how they pyre was made, nothing. It is instructions to Sikhs on not to follow Hindu rituals. Because it was written before the stabbing and amended after, it does not contain any mention of Guru Sahib’s last day or giving of Gurgaddi.
The quote you provided from Amarnamah DOES NOT EXIST. If it does, please provide the verse number. The account does not contain any mention of Guru Sahib’s last words. He does mention that when a Sikh dies (not his own ascension), [i]“Do not summon the Brahmin priest to perform the last rites, nor invoke his ancestors." Instead, Dhadis be asked to sing vars (heroic poem) composed by Nathmal (73).[/i]” He says many times that Dhadis are important and that they should be included in divans: [i] “One mode of worshipping God is also listening to poems of heroic deeds from the Dhadis or traditional singers side by side with the exposition of the Guru's word (129)”.”When Sikhs hold celebrations, it is proper for them to listen to vars by Dhadis (135).”[/i]
2) You next mention Sri Guru Sobha. Sri Guru Sobha contains the quote, “The Khalsa are my form and I am close to them. My eternal abode is the Khalsa. Likewise the true Guru is in the shabad and in the bani”. Pg. 134 of Shamsher Singh Ashok version. Clearly Guru Sahib gave Guruship to Khalsa Panth and Guru Granth (shabad).
Next you list off a bunch of texts by non-Sikhs. Muslims, etc. Christians and Muslims could not understand the concept of Guru Granth ie. a scripture being Guru. Sikhs were the first to have this. No where before had anywhere a Granth been Guru. They said there was no “spiritual leader” because in their eyes, only a human is the spiritual leader.
The number of SIKH sources that call Guru Granth Sahib jee Guru is HUGE.
1) Gurbilas P: 10 by Koer Singh written in 1751: He refers to Guru Granth and Guru Panth
2) Bansavalinama Dasan Pathshahihan was completed in 1769: In this work Kesar Singh makes reference to Guru Gobind Singh giving guruship to Guru Granth Sahib. He writes, that Guru Gobind Singh jee said, “The Granth is the Guru and take refuge in Akal. The Guru is the Khalsa and the Khalsa is the Guru” (pg. 163-4)
3) Guru Kian Sakhian: By Saroop Singh Kaushish, completed in 1797. This is a very important piece of literature since it is based on Bhatt Vehis ie. eye witness accounts by Bhatts in Guru Sahib’s darbar. Sakhi 112 in this Granth is ALL ABOUT THE GURUSHIP. It says Guru Sahib told Bhai Daya Singh, “Bhai Sikha go and feche Cri Granth jee we have to endow Guruship”. On getting the command Bhai Day aSingh brought Sri Granth jee and auspiciously opened and displayed it. …After the ARdas, Satguru jee prepared to pass on Guruship. Guru Sahib took five paise, and a coconut in his hand. Sat on the bedstead and asked Daya Singh, “place them in front of Sri Granth jee”
Guru Kian Sakhian also makes no mention of the Kuka myth of Guru Sahib riding off on their horse. The body of Guru Sahib was bathed by Bhai Daya Singh and it was cremated.
4) Prashun Uttar Bhai Nand Lal: Also calls Guru Granth Sahib Satguru: Dohara “come with reverence and sit in my presence. Humbly bow and hear the words of the Guru Granth” The person who wishes to hear my words should devoutly hear and reflect on the Granth. Acknowledge the Granth as my visible presence, rejecting the notion that it is other than me” verse 11.
5) Desa Singh rehitnama: also acknowledges Guru Granth Sahib: “When food is ready think within of the form of the Guru. IF the Guru granth is present prayer should be offered in its presence” 110.
6) Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama: “He who carries the Guru Granth ji on his head will spend as many years in surag as the number os steps which he has taken” (37). Also, “Believeing that the Guru was present in both Granth and Panth entire families crossed over and achieved spiritual liberation” (45).
We also have the first hand account of Bhai Narbad Singh Bhatt who saw the GUruship go to Guru Granth Sahib.
What do you find more reliable? Sikh sources specifically mentioning Guru Granth Sahib as SAtguru, or Muslim/Christian sources saying there was no spiritual leader after Guru Gobind Singh and simply not understanding Guruship can belong to a Granth. There was no human leader of the Sikhs. Even your historians acknowledge that the Sikhs knew there would be no more human spiritual leaders.
Dead Man Walking, reflect on the above evidence. IT is conclusive that Guru Granth Sahib is Satguru.
Which source says that Baba Balak Singh was given Guruship? Any puraatan source say this? NOT ONE.
You tried to shift the debate back to me, but please do answer the questions posed to you. I am very interested to know why you have caste segrated kuka langars
Dhan Satguru Granth Sahib.
Re: NamDhari response
singh · 18 Jan 2006
after getting a mooh(n) toaR javaab to their historical "evidence", the Kukas should answer or admit that they believe in a lie.
1) How did Guru Gobind Singh live over 100 years in hiding?
2) How did he give Guruship to someone he had never met?
3) Why do Kukas have caste segregated langars?
4) Why have Kukas stopped wearing kirpans?
5) What do you say to all the historical evidence from Bhatt Vehis, Rehitnamas, Puratan Granths which all say the Guru is Sri Guru Granth Sahib?
6) Why do you use brass buckets for amrit sinchars?
Re: NamDhari response
Angad Singh · 18 Jan 2006
Gur fateh!!
I do agree that the namdharis do not believe in SGGS as the guru and tts whats makes us different frm them..
but we have to be thankful to them for maintaing the kirtan maryada..if not for them we would have lost almost all our gurmat sangeet traditions..
to give u an example..the only professional taoos player today is a namdhar..
take the best leave the rest.
guru ang sang
angad singh
Re: NamDhari response
singh · 19 Jan 2006
Bhai Avtar Singh Ragi plays taus, what about him?
No one should associate with Kukas, regardless of what vidya they may have. They deny that Guru Granth Sahib is Guru. This is the same sin as Dhirmalias, Ram Raiyas and other apostate groups. If we can't associate with them, what is the justification to associate withi Kukas? They are the same thing.
Anyone who associates with Kukas is commiting a violation of rehit and should ask for forgiveness from teh Punj Pyare and the Panth.
Re: NamDhari response
Harcharan Singh · 19 Jan 2006
Singh Ji,
I was not aware that you had been made the Jathedaar of Akaal Takht.
If and when a hukumnama is released from Akaal Takht regarding communicating with Namdhari, those who follow Akaal Takht as their temporal authority will listen.
Those who don't, won't.
Please stop giving high level orders to the Sikh Nation:
"Anyone who associates with Kukas is commiting a violation of rehit and should ask for forgiveness from teh Punj Pyare and the Panth."
With all due respect, I doubt you are a highly recognised and respected spiritual person with authority to issue such commands.
If you feel a certain way, please state that it is YOUR opinion, and stop patronising and speaking on behalf of the Sikh world.
That is your opinion, and possibly the opinion of others, but not of everyone.
Thank you to the namless Veerji/Bhenji who used an intelligent arguement to get his point across by refering to historic evidence.
Sat Sri Akaal
Harcharan Singh
Re: NamDhari response
seek · 19 Jan 2006
so guru ji after sacrificing their whole family, then as you are basically suggesting 'lost their bottle' and went into hiding, basically being scared? you people are real jokers.
Re: NamDhari response
singh · 19 Jan 2006
Harcharan Singh,
reading your sermons on this site one would think YOU are the Jathedar.
Namdharis are not Sikhs. That much is established because they don't believe in Guru Granth Sahib as Guru.
Now, using logic (aww...not that thing again! right Harcharan Singh?), if Dhirmalis and Ramraiyas are considered apostate groups and we cannot deal with them because they started their own Guruship line, how would you justify associating with Kukas? BEcause there are no formal declarations by the Akal Takhat on Sacha Sauda cult or Narinder cult or many many others, does that mean associating with them is OK?
All Sangeet Academies and others who use Kuka teachers or otherwise associate with Kukas are in fact committing an offence.
Harcharan Singh it's you that needs to get off his high horse and start thinking critically.
Re: NamDhari response
Harcharan Singh · 19 Jan 2006
Thank you veer Singh Ji.
Let's leave the decision of whether a so called "offence" is being committed to Waheguru. Don't worry yourself.
Veer ji, I try to think critically, but not judgementally, discriminately, with hatred or in representation for the whole panth.
Guru Kirpa
Re: NamDhari response
wonderer · 21 Jan 2006
dead man walking,
you say that at one point there were only two and a half sikhs left. My question is that what is half a sikh?
Re: NamDhari response
Swinder Singh · 21 Jan 2006
Author: Dead Man Walking
Date: 01-18-06 17:25
19) Sri Gurpartap Suraj(Suraj Parkash): Written by Kavi Bhai Santokh Singhji in 1843 A.D. He has infact written that it was the Eighth Avatar of Guru Nanak, Sri Guru Harkrishan Sahib Ji, who once attempted to give Gurgaddi to Sri Aad Granth Sahib but It was rejected by The Sikhs of the time who requested Him that people such as Dhirmal would all sit with a Bir(Volume) in their hands and fabricate Its translations in order to control people!
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
Thank you dead man walking for this valuable information, it is also containing answer for your doubt of passing of the gurudom to SGGS ji.
This is good informataion I have accessed to first time. Now set aside the other things at rest that happened or not happned, if we take into account this information of history, then it can safely be concluded that this move of passing on of the gurudom to Sri Guru Granth Sahib was already on cards even before the 10th guru ji. Or say it was the DIVINE ORDER, which was carried out by Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji.
Gur Fateh ji
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 22 Jan 2006
Dear Author,
I am not going to argue or dabte with anyone because there is no point of doing that. I am just feeding other gursikhs other historical information on the site for their own knowledge. It is up to them if they want to read and believe in it or if not that is okay tp.
Author no matter how much you critize the Namdhari's, believe me we would still consider to be you a sikh brother. If any of our sikh brothers were in danger, the first thing we are going to do his assist him not look what he believes. If he belives in the Sri Granth Sahib as a Guru, we do not care. We would care more about his life than what he believes. Namdhari's also read the Sri Granth Sahib do not think that Namdhari's do not.
It makes me happy that you are Gursikh that is really strict in his principles of Sikhi which I praise you for. I personally do not care if you believe in the Granth Sahib as your Guru, But I do care about the fact that you should not critize what others believe. At the end the truth will shine.
I am going to write some information Guru Gobind Singh Ji below this page just general information. Again I am not influening anyone on the website but just trying to make them understand about namdhari's fundalmental beliefs.
Anyhow I am not going to keep particpating in these discussions that often. I will just convey any posts or messages that I am not sure of to Namdhari Yahoo Groups. I just do not have the time to partipate in lengthy discussions which I would love to but it is time consuming. All I want is for all my Sikh Brothers Namdhar or not Namdhari all the best and that we unite again if not in this Kulyug time I hope in Satyug.
(Sri Gur Sobha Granth - Kavi Sainapat)
Nar-Natak, is what Guru Gobind Singh Ji's Actions at Nander in 1708 were called. The name was given by Giani Gian Singh Ji, author of the great Historical Literature: Panth Parkash.
Considering all Reliable Historical Sources such as Panth Parkash, Suraj Parkash, GurBilas Patshahi Dasvi, as well as Historical events that were recorded by Sikhs, Hindus and muslims, the following briefly describes what actually took place at Nander in 1708 A.D.:
After entering Nander, Guru Gobind Singh Separated His Residence from that of Badshah Bahadur Shah.
Guru Sahib kept a Pathan whose grandfather, Panday Khan, was killed by the Sixth Master Guru Hargobind Sahib, as a servant.
The story of this Pathan was known to the Sikhs and they warned Guru Sahib about it.
Guru Sahib, who already had the knowledge of this, said that He would require the Pathan's SERVICE in the future.
Guru Sahib had Ordered a few of His Sikhs to start collecting 'Chandan' Wood and other funeral-related materials.
Many days had passed when one night, as feared by the Sikhs, the Pathan attacked Guru Sahib.
Whether it was his own idea or Guruji's Hukam for his SERVICE, it all ended when Guru Sahib, using His Sword, killed the Pathan.
Guru Sahib were injured, stabbed in the chest, but after ten days, the wound was not causing any trouble anymore and Guruji started to Grant Audience to His Sikhs again during Congregations.
After a few days, Bahadur Shah sent two of his officers to check on Guruji's health. The officers came to Guruji's Residence and seeing a large bow lying around, whispered to one another that such a large bow could only be used as a show-piece, no human-being would be able to shoot an aero with it.
Hearing the officers' remarks, Guru Sahib seized the opportunity, lifted up the bow and attempted to shoot an aero. This action reopened the wound in His chest and blood started to flow through.
Guruji Refused any hospitality offered by The Sikhs.
Seeing this, the officers' minds were made up that Guru Sahib did not want to live anymore and it seemed like His end was near. And so they left with the idea stuck in their heads.
That night, Guru Sahib ordered the woods that were collected to be set into place and a funeral pyre was constructed which was screened so that no one could see what would happen inside.
Guru Sahib took a bath, wore His weapons along with new clothings. His horse was geared up ready for traveling.
He ordered that no Sikh of His shall look at the funeral pyre and they should all stand with their backs facing it.
He also ordered that no monument should be erected, nor should any house of worship be constructed where the funeral pyre was.
-*The Hazoor Sahib Gurdwara, built by Maharaja Ranjit Singh in memory of Guru Gobind Singh Ji was not built on the exact location where all the burning took place*-
Bhai Santokh Singh was ordered to put any money collected into The Langar and Guru Sahib continued with His Plans.
He then Entered the funeral pyre, either by Riding the horse or by Foot, and after a little while a fire was seen burning, but no one could see what was happening inside.
All this took place during the night before Sun rise.
After the fire burnt down the entire construction, the Sikhs went in to investigate.
Noticing no hard objects that resembled bones or weapons or even the golden coins embeded in Guru Sahib's Aeros were found, and also keeping in mind that Guru Sahib's horse, dogs and hawk were missing from the stable, the Sikhs were relieved and Guruji's Livelihood was promised.
The next morning, Sikhs in charge of bringing woods reported they saw Guru Sahib traveling on His horse towards the opposite direction when they were heading back.
About 6-7 miles away from Nander, at RattanGarhr, Satguruji Granted Audience to a Sadhu and Ordered him to assure The Sikhs at Nander that Guruji would continue to Assist The Khalsa. On The Spot where Satguruji Granted the Sadhu His Darshan(Audience) a House of Worship was also constructed.
A few months later, two Rajputs, Bala Rao and Rustam Rao reported that they were freed from Sitara Fort by Guruji. (Picture below.)
(The picture of Guruji helping the two Rajputs is framed in a House of Worship (Gurdwara Gupatsar Sahib) at Manmaar built on the spot where they were released by Guruji to regain freedom)
Many other occasions when the Sikhs were blessed with Guruji's Pressence are recorded in various Sikh Literatures such as His Assistance given to The Singhs of Sialkote who once fought against the muslims and were Rescued by Satguruji accompanied by An Army of Singhs.
In the Year 1812 AD(1869 Bikarmi, Vaisakh Sudi 10th), He Transferred His Holy Guruship to Guru Balak Singh Ji, Stating that He would Return to Retrieve His 'Belonging' in The Twelfth Avatar Whose Name would be Ram Singh Taking Avatar in The House of a Carpenter in The VIllage of Bhaini.
A few days later, He Traveled back to Nabha, and in the disguised name of Baba Ajapal Singh Ji, on Jeth Sudi 5th 1869 Bikarmi, Left His Body, after which none of His Appearances were ever reported nor recorded again. A House of Worship (Gurdwara Baba Ajapal Singh Ji) was also constructed on The Spot by Baba Saroop Singhji(Great-grandfather of Bhai Kahn Singh of Nabha) who was a Faithful devoutee of Guruji who was once shown the very wound Guruji received at Nander with which all of Babaji's(Baba Saroop Singhji's) doubts were cleared and he believed whole-heartedly that Baba Ajapal Singh Ji were none other than Guru Gobind Singh Ji.
-*In order to prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that Sri Satguruji did infact Live in Nabha in the guise of Baba Ajapal Singh Ji, the following translated article taken from Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha's 'Ittihaas De Anlikhe Pattar' is being provided for the benefit of the readers:
Ittihas De Anlikhe Pattar
Who was the Great Personality Baba Ajapal* (*Baba Saroop Singhji [Great-grandfather of Bhai Kahn Singhji Nabha], who had ordered the writing of these notes, translated this Name as “the Supporter [Pal] of the poor [Aja]”) Singh Ji Sahib? From which lineage or in which house was He born? Nobody knows. His Life-Story which was noted down by my good father (Baba Narayan Singhji Sahib, is being presented to the readers after obtaining the signature of Giani Hira Singhji ‘Dard’.
Physical Appearance
Baba Ji’s height was neither too short nor too tall. His body was neither too heavy nor too thin. His limbs were strong and beautiful. He had light complexion and a radiant Face. His beard was spotless white as long as His Torso, His big Eyes had a significant glow in them. The shape of His nose was also sharp.
Attires
His Kachera (Traditional underpants) was two fingers above the knees, His white Kurta (Traditional shirt) was four fingers higher than the Kachera, upon His Head a white Gurmukhi Dastar (Straight Turban), in the Gatra (Carrying belt) was Sri Sahib (Sword), and in His Hand was a Sarbloh (All-Iron) Arrow, sometimes a Gulal. One white Rumal (Handkerchief) was always tied upon the Head in such a way that it covered half of the Mustache, Face and Beard at all times.
Inclination
He remained soaked in Naam Simran (Meditation). He had great Love for horses and weaponry. Whichever Sevak (Sikh) was given the permission to stay at the Dera (Residence), He would make him/her memorize Gurbani (Scriptures) and study Shaster Vidya (Art of Weaponry). Numerous trees such as Nim, Pippal, Pharr etc. were planted by His orders. Whoever watered them would receive much Affection from Him. Even today many of the trees planted by Him can be seen in the area of the Gurdwara. Baba Ji were very much against deforestation. Once seeing the need for cutting trees to make an addition to the House, He ordered the Sevaks to plant two replacement trees instead of one and then cut the (old) tree as needed. This Hukam (Order) was followed to the extent that from then on there was no tree cut without planting two more in its place. Sometimes after the Path (Recitation) of Rehras, Baba Sahib would start playing Naubat (Musical instrument) until the sun rose the next day. The Naubat was also not of ordinary sound quality. In fact it was played so precisely down to the musical notes (according to the ancient concept of Raga and Tala) that it mixed perfectly well with the sound of Mirdang (Type of Drum) and was absolutely hypnotic to the listener.
Speech/Language
His speaking language was a mixture of Hindi and Punjabi. His Voice was heavy, firm yet sweet. And the word ‘Guru Singh’* (*Baba Sahib used this word as a third person noun for Dasmeshji [Guru Gobind Singh Ji]) was used often times. For example: - “This is the Hukam of Guru Singh Ji”, “Guru Singh Ji has Ordained this”, “Guru Singh Ji will take care of the Manmatias (wrong doers who do not follow the Hukam of the Satguru)”, “Those who live by the rules of Guru Singh Ji will be happy in this world and the next” etc. were some of the noted phrases of Baba Ji which were understood fully by none other than the five Singhs.
Five Gurmukh Sevaks
Five Singhs, whose real names and information is unknown to us, stayed close to Baba Ji. And they were called upon using disguised names. At all times they would take turns to patrol the House.
These Singhs were fully absorbed in Gurbani and were superb and strict Shasterdharis (Soldiers/Wearers of Arms). Taking care of the horses and weapons, preparing Langar (Free Kitchen), reciting Gurbani, learning and teaching Shaster Vidya to others was their job.
During the time of Baba Saroop Singhji, two of the Singhs passed away. But at the loss of one, no more than two days would pass that another would arrive as replacement. Other than these five, there was an old lady, who may have had a different real name, who was called by the name ‘Senda’. She wore men’s clothing and Sri Sahib (Sword). She stayed in front of a hut as a guard. Other than the five Singhs, she would not allow anyone else to pass through without Baba Ji’s specific Hukam (Order). The story of this lady will be told later.
Expenditure
In order to obtain money required for Langar, clothing for Sevaks, fodder & saddles for horses, expense for Sikligars (Weapon Polishers) etc. was called one ‘Baghra Singh’. From where does he (Baghra Singh) obtained money? Nobody knew.
Sevaks
Some of the beloved Sevaks who were allowed to stay nearby were Baba Saroop Singhji, Bhai Rattan Singh, Bhai Sukha Singhji, Prohit Singh of the Phool clan, Bagh Singh Dharamdhari, Bhai Kesra Singhji etc. who banded together to do Sat-Sang (Congregation of Truth). But they were not allowed to stay inside Baba Ji’s main Residence. They lived a bit far away in a hut. After several years of doing Seva (Service to Guru), Baba Saroop Singhji, Bhai Sukha Singhji and Kesra Singhji were granted permission to do Darshan (Audience) of Baba Sahib in a room on certain occasions and say their Prayers.
The Residence Complex
Baba Sahib’s main House had a round shape. The ground floor was made of cement and upstairs was three rooms.
In one room stayed Baba Sahib, in another was weapons and (Sri Aad/Dasam?) Guru Granth Sahibji, in the third room was kept Naubat musical instruments.
On both sides of the rooms were galleries with ranges to practice shooting. Infront of the main House were two more constructions in which lived the five Singhs. In a construction infront of the strongly forted main entrance on the right hand side was the residence of Mai (Lady) Senda. And on the left side was a construction that housed a flourmill and storage area.
Daily Routine
Baba Ajapal Singh never went out of the House to meet (strangers/unknown) people. The devouted Sikhs looking from the outside only get to receive His Darshan (Sight) when He stood up in the room. And nobody knew when Baba Ji would give His Darshan. Sometimes the devoutees came for five or seven consecutive days but would not attain Darshan (Sight of Guru). Then sometimes (He) would give Audience all of a sudden. Near the house on the left side was an attached shelter in which lived five very beautiful horses and two ponies. On the right hand side was the Langar area in which other than the five Singhs and Mai Senda, no one else was permitted to enter. In front of the Langar, on a tall pole was a Basant (Yellow) Pharra Nishan (Flag).
Baba Sahib’s diet and bathing routine were very secretive. So much that Baba Saroop Singhji never had a chance to observe them. Everyday Asa Di Vaar Kirtan would be performed at Amrit Vela (Before Sunrise) inside the walls. At dawn, the recitation of Rehras Sahib would be performed sitting at the Nishan Sahib. Karrah Parshad (Cooked Sacred Food invented by Guru Nanak Dev Ji) would be prepared in the Langar after recitation of Jap Sahib (Scripture of Guru Nanak Dev Ji) and no addition of dry fruits was used as ingredient. After recitation of Anand (Sahib), the Ardas (Common Prayer) of the Parshad would be performed in the Langar itself. At the conclusion of the Ardas, the following words were used:- “Hay Akal Purakh Kartar Karhah Parshad Di Degh Tiar Hae| Aap Nu Angikaar Hovay| Kla Guru Singh Ji Di Vartay | Tav Parsaad|” [“Oh Almighty The Timeless Creator, Karha Parshad Has Been Prepared. May It Be Used/Consumed By Thee. May The Power of Guru Singh Ji Spread/Grow. With Your Grace/Blessings.]. Nobody could prepare Karha Parshad without covering his mouth with a Rumal (Handkerchief). Similarly one whose hand had any kind of skin condition was not thought of as suitable to prepare Langar. The Karha Parshad was not removed from the Langar to the outside. Every Sikh would go to the door of the Langar to receive It from the distributor. Similarly Langar was not organized in Pangat (Seating formation in rows with Sevaks going around distributing food, commonly used today). Every Sikh would approach the distributor in front of the door and obtain wheat/bread according to one’s hunger level.
Amrit Sanskar (Ceremony)
Whenever someone would want to receive Amrit, he would seek permission and stand infront of the House wearing clean clothes and weapons. The bowl of Amrit would be taken from Baba Ji’s room by five Singhs and would be administered to the recipient in accordance to the Rules and from inside the room Baba Sahib would raise His Voice and announce the new name of the Singh. None of the Sevaks knew if Baba Ji were ever part of the five Singhs. There may be one or many Singhs who came to receive Amrit, but Baba Sahib never put more than five Patasas (Sweeteners)*. (*Regarding this fact Baba Ji had given specific instructions to Baba Saroop Singhji)
Shaster Vidya
Nobody had ever seen Baba Sahib use sword or other close range combat skills but shooting of Gopis (ball of dried mud), Gulals (Ball of powdered color), Guns and Archery was many times seen as being practiced. Hanging a coin on one end of a thin piece of thread and shooting at the thread with a gun, throwing one Gulal into the air and hitting it with another, perfect shooting of Gopi as if it was shot from a gun, shooting down flying birds with arrows were His normal performances. These weapons were used as per His wishes on certain occasions from inside the room, and (He) would also watch with Passion, the practice of weaponry and horsemanship by the Sevaks. If there would be any mistake, it would be brought to light and made known to them. It was Baba Sahib’s Hukam that when one is to hold weapons in his hands, he must recite ‘Akal Hi Sahai’. And when one is about to ride a horse he must say ‘Vaihguru Ang Sang’ before putting foot on the saddle. Baba Sahib’s beautiful weapons of great variety can be seen at the Gurdwara even today. Along with weaponry, carpentry was also very important for the Singhs, so that they could craft wooden instruments themselves. Baba Sahib said many times that a Singh who cannot sew clothes, use weapons, walk horses, craft wooden instruments, sharpen and store Weapons, prepare Langar and write Gurmukhi, is not worthy to be admitted into the Jatha (Army) of Guru Singh Ji.
Gurpurab (Gurgaddi Anniversary of Guru Angad Dev Ji)
Baba Ji celebrated Gurpurab on Asu Sudi 10th. On this day Karha Parshad would be distributed and Kirtan would be performed and Naubat played. Guns would be fired (in celebration). One day Baba Sahib told Baba Saroop Singhji the following “Sikha Da Gurpurab Asu Sudi Das Toe Vadhkay Koi Nahee|” [“For Sikhs, There Is No Grander Gurpurab Than Asu Sudi 10th”]. Because on this day Satgur Nanak Dev Ji started the custom of passing upon the Throne to the most deserving (Satguru Angad Dev Ji). Other celebrations on the 10th are like other smaller footprints in the footprint of an elephant. It comes to one’s understanding that Baba Ji meant that Guru Nanak Dev Ji passed on His Divine Jyote (Light/Spirit) to Angad Dev Ji on Asu Sudi 10th. Other writers have written this occasion as Asu Vadi 10th, which is against Baba Ji’s Words.
Updesh (Discourse)
Whenever it would be time to do Updesh, then Baba Sahib would do Updesh according to questions asked, but His normal Updesh was this:- “Dharam Di Kirat Karo| Daswand Dio| Naam Jappo| Vidya Parho| Vartakay Chako| Shastra Da Abhias Karo| Ghorhay Atay Baela Di Nasal Vadhao| Birch Lao| Aapo Vichi Sakkay Bhaia Vala Prem Rakho| Des Di Seva Karo Nirbhae Atay Nirvaer Raho| Swarath Tiago| Jay Tusi Is Updesh Tay Amal Karogay, Ta Guru Singh Ji Day Darbar Da Dar Tuhaday Lei Khula Hae|” [“Follow The Dharma (True Religion). Give Daswand (10 percent of income as charity). Recite Naam (Gurmantra). Seek Knowledge. Distribute Then Eat. Learn Weaponry. Breed Better Horses And Bulls. Plant Trees. Love Each Other As Real Brothers. Serve The Nation Remain Unafraid And Unparanoid. Reject Junk. If You Live Up To This Updesh, Then Guru Singh Ji’s House’s Door Is Open For You.”]
Baba Ajapal Singh Ji never told His story to anyone, but His close Sevaks believed for certain that Kalgidhar Ji (Guru Gobind Singh Ji) did not merge with the Divine Jyote (i.e. left His Body) at Dakhan because Dasmesh Ji’s weapons and bones were not found in the ashes that remained and from the shelter was also missing one special horse. (Hence) Guru Sahib is living secretly in Punjab under the Name Baba Ajapal Singh.
They came to this conclusion from the fact that on the side of Baba Sahib’s Body was an old scar that was seen at the time of His bodily end and from the fact that His Behavior and Rules as well as Grace were inhuman and there was definitely some connection between Baba Ji and the nation’s politics. Many Singhs would come to Him in different types of fancy clothing and many times from the five Singhs one or two would go along with his respective horse to give news and information to someone without telling anyone else. Also many Singhs would leave taking weapons with them. I have not made any kind of determination of my own regarding this.
But if Baba Ji’s Sevak’s deliberation is to be believed as being correct, then Baba Ajapal Singh Ji would have the total age of 146 years. Because Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji’s Birth took place in Sammat 1723 (Bikarmi). The act at Abchalnagar happened in 1765 (Bikarmi). And Baba Ajapal Singh Ji’s Death occurred on Jeth Sudi 5th 1869 (Bikarmi). Without analyzing the above mentioned facts any further, I will present some of Baba Sahib’s brief and rare biography that was noted by the order of my good father, which (I believe) will be beneficial to the Panth. Before Sammat 1811 there is no available information in my notebook. In 1812 (Bikarmi) it is recorded that Baba Ji helped a Rajput of Bhadra in battle and captured for him treasure and throne. After this some say that Baba Ji lived at Rohi near Jeend for a short while and then for some years in a house in Patiala. But there is no solid evidence that can be found to confirm this. Baba Ji came to stay at Nabha in the Sammat 1830 (Bikarmi). At that time it was a very small city. At the place where there is now Baba Ji’s Gurdwara used to be thick jungle, the size of the city was about 2.5 furlongs.
Taking Care of One’s Parents
From Bhai Roop Singh’s lineage, Bagh Singh came to serve Baba Ji. One Natha Singh of Tajo was traveling to spread his father’s ashes in the river Ganga. He stayed with Bagh Singh in Nabha at Baba Ji’s compound.
Natha Singh told Bagh Singh that he wanted to have Darshan of the MahaPurakh (Great Man) he (Bagh Singh) was serving.
Bagh Singh took Natha Singh to Baba Ji’s door. After some time Baba Ji stood in the room above and said, “Bagh Singh Eh Chandal Ithay Kiu Lianda Hae?” [“Bagh Singh Why Have You Brought This Wicked Person Here?” Bagh Singh politely explained that “This is a farmer and my good friend, Natha Singh.” Baba Ji ordained – One who doesn’t take care of his/her parents is a wicked person. Then He educated Natha Singh and said “Rogi Baap Nu Chad Kay Ta Tu Mele Ja Varhia Ar Oh Vichara Tihaia Hi Mar Gya| Hunn Hadia Lae Kay Ganga Nu Gat Karaun Janda Hae| Tu Bhari Tankhahia Haen|”[“The Sick Father Was Left Behind When You Went To See The Mela (Celebrations/Festivities), The Poor Man Died Longing For You. Now You’re Taking His Bones To Ganga To Be Blessed. You Are An Absolute Tankhahia (One who is to pay religious fines).”] After saying this Baba Ji Read a Pauri (Couplet) of Bhai Gurdas’s.
For the benefit of the readers, Vaar (Ballad) number 37’s 13th couplet is given below:
Ma Pio Parhar Sunae Vayd Bhayd Na Janay Katha Kahani|
Ma Pio Parhar Karae Tap Van Khand Bhula Phirae Bibani|
Ma Pio Parhar Karae Pooj Dayvi Dayv Na Sayv Kamani|
Ma Pio Parhar Nhavna Athsath Teerath Ghuman Vani|
Ma Pio Parhar Karae Daan Bayiman Again Prani|
Ma Pio Parhar Vart Kar Mar Mar Jammay Bharam Bhulani|
Gur Parmaysar Maar Na Jani|
Natha Singh folded his hands, paid obeisance and asked that he be forgiven! For this Baba Ji gave the Hukam that “Asthia Jameen Vich Gad Kay Vapas Ghar Nu Jah| Tu Gurmukhi Vidia Parhia Hoia Hae, Is Lei Panj Balka Nu Gurmukhi Parha Atay Guru Granth Sahib Da Pathi Bana|”[“Bury The Ashes In The Ground And Go Home. You Have Learnt Gurmukhi (Punjabi Alphabets) Hence Teach Five Children And Make Them Reciters Of Guru Granth Sahibs.”]* (*Whenever Baba Sahib fined a person, He would never take money. He would give the wrongdoer something to do that he already has knowledge and capability of doing. If someone is without any special knowledge, then he’d be ordained to do simple chores).
Removing The Sorrow Of Sorrowfuls
The lady whose name is mentioned as Senda**(**Baba Saroop Singhji had once heard from Rattan Singh that the lady’s real name was Nihal Kaur) was a resident of Bulahde. She was inflicted by a serious disease and had to live in a tent outside the village. One day Sant Phula Singhji came and sat down near a pond of water next to her tent. The lady begged him to help cure her disease. Phoola Singhji told her, “Go to MahaPurakh Baba Ajapal Singh Ji, He would restore you to health.” Senda came to serve Baba Ji and with His Kindness became free of all diseases. The lady spent the rest of her life in service of Baba Sahib. This lady disguised herself as a ‘Singh’ and stayed as a guard at the gate and was blessed with love and spirituality. Baba Ji’s small bag that was full of medicines, which was called ‘Sada Jhola’, was under her responsibility. Whenever a person inflicted with disease would come by, Mai Senda would give the remedy as prescribed by Baba Ji. Numerous people were cured this way.
Marriage Ceremony
Baba Saroop Singhji witnessed two different occasions of marriage ceremonies with his own eyes. One was for the daughter of Rattan Singh called Anand Kaur and the second was for the daughter of Sukha Singh called Prem Kaur. At the request of their father, Baba Sahib gave them Blessings and asked for them to be presented (for marriage). When both (bride and groom) are presented (before Baba Sahib), they were questioned via Mai Senda if their marriage was sanctioned by their parents or if it was their own decision. To this both replied that their relationship was approved by their parents. Baba Sahib then gave the Hukam for them to appear the next day at Amrit Vela (Before Sunrise). After Asa Di Vaar an Ardas was performed at the end of the Divan that said such and such Singh had given his daughter to such and such Singh to live in accordance to the Grehsat (Household) way of life in the Divan of Guru Singh Ji. And that both are reminded to live according to the teachings of the Satguru. After Ardas the scripture of Anand (Sahib) was sung and Parsad (Cooked Sacred Food) distributed.
At both occasions there was no ritual of walking or reading of Lavans involved. Only Ardas and recitation of Anand took place.
Bartering A Female Child
From the Nishan Misl, Sardar … Singh came to seek Darshan of Baba Ji for many days, but to no avail. One day Mai Senda requested that “Maharaj … Singh has come many times, but always leaves disappointed.” Baba Sahib Said “Oh Kanjar Saday Darshan Da Adhkari Nahi, Osnay Raja … Nu Jageer Day Lalach Nu Aapni Putri Dittee Hae|”[“That Pimp Is Not Worthy Of My Sight, He Gave His Daughter To Raja ... In Greed Of Inheritance.”]
Kirtan
In Baba Ji’s Darbar (Court), no Ragis (Minstrels) were hired to perform Kirtan (Singing The Guru’s Hymns). The Hajoori Singhs and Sevaks joined together to perform Kirtan of Asa Di Vaar. But if any Ragi came, he would sit at the Nishan Sahib (Flag pole) and perform Kirtan, which was sometimes also listened to by Baba Ji while standing in His room. Baba Ji were not pleased with any other instrument other than Rabab and Saranda. One day a Rababi who used his own words while singing was removed from the Divan by the Orders of Baba Ji. He said that whatever is in the Gurbani is the utmost Truth. Anyone who uses any replacement words, or adds even a single letter of his own, is a Tankhahia and Manmatia and whoever listens to his Kirtan is an Agiani (foolish) Sikh.
Paying For Wishes
One day a resident of Sirhind, Prem Singh, brought a hundred and twenty five Rupees and presented them before Baba Ji and said “My son’s breaths were saved by Your Blessings, I had made a wish and as such am presenting this.” Baba Sahib said that making such wishes is forbidden by Guru Singh Ji. For any request an Ardas should be performed by the person himself or by Gurmukhs before Kartar (Creator/God). And once the wish is fulfilled, being thankful is not a mistake, but saying that if successful he would present such and such amount of money is against the tenets of Sikhism. Prem Singh was ordered to put the one hundred and twenty five Rupees into the Langar at the Gurdwara of Fatehgarh.
Baba Ajapal Singh Ji were very much against untidiness. If anyone was seen with untidy clothes or weapons or horse’s ornaments, he would be heavily scolded. One day Kesra Singh took off his shirt and was killing lice with it in the blazing heat of the sun. Baba Ji gave an order to beat him five times on his back with the nearby horse’s whip. This Hukam was quickly followed. Kesra Singh cried a lot and said his wrongdoing didn’t deserve so much punishment. Baba Sahib said “Tayra Thorhee Saza Naal hi Chutkara Ho Gia Hae| Guru Ji Nay Sareer Atay Bastar Maela Rakhan Valay Sikh Nu Tankhahia Atay Dand Yog Thehraia Hae|”[“You Have Been Let Go With Just A Minor Punishment. Guru Ji Have Condemned A Sikh With Dirty Body Or Clothe As A Tankhaia And Deserving Of Religious Fine/Punishment.”]
Baba (Saroop Singh) ji’s doubts turned into absolute certainty
Baba Saroop Singhji served at the Residence very lovingly. (He) woke up at 1.15am to broom the place, massaged the horses, brought fresh sand everyday to spread under the horses. (He) brought large heaps of special hay for them. Whatever service that was required, was done with love. One day a thought came across Baba Saroop Singhji’s mind, whether Baba (Ajapal Singh) Sahib Ji were Dasam Guruji (Guru Gobind Singh Ji) or the Sahibjada (Son of The Guru). He wanted to ask but was afraid. This thought did come to his mind many times before but on that specific day he just couldn’t stop thinking about it. From the room above Baba Ji exclaimed “Ree Senda Saroop Singhji Nu Upar Saday Paas Bhayj Dio|”[“Listen Senda, Send Saroop Singhji To Me Upstairs.”]. Mai Senda went and told Baba Saroop Singhji “Maharaj has ordered for you to meet in the room.” Baba Saroop Singhji went upstairs and paid obeisance at Baba Sahiub Ji’s Feet. At that time Baba Sahib Ji were lying on the bed. Baba Saroop Singhji stood with his hand folded after paying obeisance and said “Maharaj Ji what is the Hukam for me?” Baba Sahib said “Saday Khurak Hundi Hae, Aap Dekho Koi Jeea Na Hovay|”[“I Feel Itchy, You Take A Look Perhaps There’s An Insect.”] Baba Saroop Singhji started looking closely at the bed. (He noticed) very long hair on the Body of Baba Ji. No insect was found. But on the side of the body was a very serious scar that looked like it was caused by a weapon in the past. Seeing the scar Baba Saroop Singhji asked “Maharaj Ji where was this wound received?” Hearing this Baba Sahib Ji said “Eh Uhi Ghao Hae Jo Dakhan Mae Pathan Nay Maria Si|”[“This Is That Wound That A Pathan (Muslim) Caused In Deccan (Sri Abchal Nagar/Nanded).”]
Hearing This Baba Saroop Singhji became certain that The Tenth Pathshah Kalgidhar (Sahib) were with the Panth. Never again did he have any doubts. He came downstairs after paying obeisance at The Divine Feet.*-
Re: NamDhari response
Harcharan Singh · 23 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh,
Veer ji thanks for the information.
In my opinion, it seems clear that Baba Ajapal Singh Ji was a great Gursikh -Mahapurkh, and 1 or 2 tiny points aside (which could be put down to human/historical/tranlatory error) , it seems quite clear they were a true Sikh and true sevadaar of Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj.
Although I unquestionably believe Guru Ji ordained "Guru manyo Granth", I have found the story of this Gur-Sikh Baba hugely inspiring. Especially the accounts of shastar, horses, Kirtan, maryada and their principles. They fit perfectly with my understanding of Guru Ji's early Khalsa.
Thanks again.
Guru Kirpa
Harcharan Singh
Re: NamDhari response
Bob Singh · 23 Jan 2006
One thing you got to hand to the naamdharis, they really know how to cook up a good story!
Re: NamDhari response
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 23 Jan 2006
Sdaly, though the Kuka movement led the libveration of the country, the kuka movement has alsoled the birth of many similar cults.
In todays, climate, no Sikh can blame the Namdhari cult and their human guru , as the so called mainstream Sikhs are no better in their belief of the dozens of Babas, Saadhs and sants.
However,It is still not Sikhi for a human gurship to have gone.Although it is no human Sikhs right to call another lesser Sikh or better sikh thanthe next.But here we are adhering to the panthic matyada and agreed values of the direct orders of Guru gobind Singh ji.
The namdharis declared bagawat from the Panth of Guru Gobind Singh ji.There is no evidence , but word of mouth taht Guru Gobind Singh ji lived till 146; which if beleived at the best is a diservice towards the mahaan Guru Gobind Singh ji, as he was not one to go into hiding.can the namdhari brothers explain why did he need to hide?why did he need to pass on a gruship in hiding ,rather than like when he openly declared the magnificent Panth of the khalsa?
Is it possible that Balak singh was in the pay of the of the mughals or british, and was urged to do so to distract the Sikh power?I say he was , as I have uncovered some evidence, which I am finalising to print.
I would humbly request Namdhari brothers to refute this claim, as I i have in my years of studying the conflict of the panth, uncoverd some significant gaps in the gurgaddi of Balak singh and the circumstances leading to the Gur gaddi.Tell me why did Guru gobind Singh ji contradict himslef by appointing Guru granth sahib, and changed his mind 135 years later ?WHY?Surley your baba has an explanation for this ?Are you saying guru Gobind Singh ji contradicted himself ??Please answer rationally You will find some interesting answer in that .
I admire Sant Bhindrawala,and committed to the Sikh Bol bala at this stage, but at the same time, I beleive he was no military genius.That is the cost he paid for with his life and thousands of Sikhs followed.That is a fact, many will agree with and many more will abuse my beleive, but that is their view.Admiring the man for his boldness and bravery is not complete justice to hhim, if one continues to choose to denty his weak points.He had unwittingly, unleashed a very potent force that got out of hand, and unfortunately brought the undesirable elements into play.With one stroke of his , he built it up, and also inadventently in a fit of tunnel vision, contributed to destroy it , just as well as the 'enemy' of the panth.
A sher is a sher outside with freedom.But a single sher in a pinjra is helpless, and can be destroyed.But put a number of shers in a pinjra, they can break that pinjra and achive freedom.
I do not wish to prolong this, but my sincere request to Sikhs is stop , these lowly acts of being paper and computer tigers, let us create a movement that will becha our pagrri, sikhi and the panth from the clutches of anyone else, and with numbers we can achieve almost anything.
My appeal to the Namdhari cult is , reflect upon the shared history of Sikhs, reject the human guru ship, regard the namdhari cult leader as simply any holy man , just as many in the main stream panth, and return to the panth and let us unite to work together.
Guru Granth sahib is the final Guru as ordained by Guru Gobind Singh ji, no other.
Sikhi bechao, Paggri sambhalo- lehar chelao- but have the vison of Guru Gobind Singh Jis teachings..
Re: NamDhari response
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Jan 2006
Author: Bob Singh
Date: 01-23-06 13:26
One thing you got to hand to the naamdharis, they really know how to cook up a good story!
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<
they are not the only "Grimm Brothers"..mate....just look up any DERAWALLAH website..and see how they "connect" to Guru Gobind Singh Ji..Guur nanak ji..Baba Sri Chand Ji..Bhai lehna Ji..Bhai Daya Singh Ji..etc etc etc...twist and turn..produce nicely drawn charts/flower pots ( so called called family tree!!! )...you will be SURPRISED...how many can actually "trace" their lineages back and back..BUT authentic SIKH HISTORY is lost...
Re: NamDhari response
Singh · 24 Jan 2006
So Namdharis cooked up 'Ittihaas De Anlikhe Pattar' and NOT Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha?
So Namdharis cookedup that the Dohra 'Guru Manio Granth' is unauthentic not Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha in his Mahan Kosh? (Lookup Prahlaad Singh)
And Namdharis also cookedup that Rahitnamas of Bhai Nandlal written in Gurmukhi are also unauthentic and this wasn't clearly written by Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha in his Mahan Kosh as well?
Namdharis also decievingly cookedup themselves being Sikhs and even put one of their 'cultish follower' into the pages of Mahan Kosh under the heading 'Sikh' despite Akal Takhat's 'hukamnama' and the rejection of all 'Tyar bar tyar chardi kala sri 108 mahakaal Gursikhs'.
Namdharis also cookedup Rattan Singh Bhangoo forgetting to mention the name of Guru Granth and Guru Panth in his Pracheen Panth Parkash?
Namdharis also cookedup Kavi Bhai Santokh Singh writing that Guru Harkrishan Sahib once told Sikhs to follow Adi Granth Sahib as Guru and forget about Dehdhari Guru lineages but it did not sit well with the Gursikhs at the time?
It is amazing that Namdharis are cooking up stories right in the books printed and reprinted by the SGPC. Someone needs to stop them!
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 24 Jan 2006
It is interesting that these are cooked up stories. I suggest you not that say that because same could be said about the historical facts that you have. The facts that we are getting are from books written in the prolong period of 1700s and 1800s.
Again I keep saying this over and over, follow your Granth Sahib. No one is stopping you from doing that. I am not going to reveal my own experience of what Akal Purkh showed me but if a person cannot experience anything in this world, they are going to have doubts of what is authentic or not authentic.Best thing a person can do at this stage is just continue on their path and whatever destiney you are choosen for.
Mr. Singh, if you feel that our information is made up then that is your problem to believe it or not. If you really believe in Sri Granth Sahib Ji as your guru, this debate about Namdhari's should have not started in the first place. A person who meets his true Satguru does not stoop at a lower level. From What I have seen on this thread, it is just amazing how deep the conversation has gone to.
I have posted much information as I could on the website by being patient. I posted the information for others to learn and understand. For those Singh's who praised me for putting up the information, I did not mind doing it at all. I do thank those singhs for being generous and polite to the information I have posted. I got nothing to lose in these discussions. It shows me that you really have not met your true satguru. I mean if you have, you would not be bashing or telling anyone that they are wrong. If we were to compare Christanity to Sikhism, can you honestly say that Sikhism is the only correct religion in the world without recieving any critism, attacks or insults from the Christian religion. Think about it logically. You are in similar situation with another Sect of Sikhism.
Wahi Guru Jey Key Fateh!
NamDhari response
Raja Hindustani · 25 Jan 2006
In response to 6 questions :-
ANyone may ask any question. It must be considered how relevant is the question to address main issue.
Dear brothers & sisters,
I consider that the main issue is concerned with Dasam Patshah handing over Gurgaddi to Scripture or Human Guru.
First we need to establish that Guru Gobind Singh ji had compelling reasons to sit on his burning pyre. Is anyone in the world can justify it? If yes, please, come forward, we are waiting for you.
Next, He had compelling reasons to change the already existing tradition of Human Guru. Pls come forward to enlighten us.
Let us discuss these basic issues first, then I'll answers all your queries pertaining to Namdhari Sikhs. Pls back up your point of view with relevant references. Also pls mention the shalokas, which clarifies that Guru is Granth Sahib.
Some one has mentioned Shabad Guru Surat Dhun Chela ( Mehla 1):
Guru sahib has also mentioned
" Pavan Guru Pani Pita Mata Dharat Mehat" ( Japji Sahib)
"Wah Wah Bani Nirankar Hai Tis Jevad Avar Na Koe" - Mehal 3 page 515
If you consider Shabad as Guru as per first tuk, WHy don't you consider Pavan as Guru or Bani as Nirankar as per other tuks as mentioned in Sri Adi Granth Sahib.
If I believe that Shabad is Guru, Which Shabad is Guru out of over 2850 pages of Sri Adi Granth Sahib & Sri Dasam Granth Sahib or from any other Granth. How can Shabad means Sri Adi Granth Sahib & not Sri Dasam Granth Sahib? Pls enlighten me in this context.
Seekers of truth, Let us discuss in a more civilised & organised way. Pls back up your view point with relevant references.
Raja Hindustani
[%sig%]
Re: NamDhari response
Bobby · 25 Jan 2006
Like I said before the naamdharis really know how to cook up a good story! I love it....LOL
Re: NamDhari response
Raja Hindustani · 25 Jan 2006
Very intelligent response of Mr Bobby!
Bobby ji pls back up your view point with suitable references. Don't make casual comments. Can you pls mention which of my comment is cooked up story? If not then give chance to intelligent seekers to put forth some real arguments.
Many Thanks
Re: NamDhari response
amarjeet singh · 25 Jan 2006
bin satgur kinai na paio, bin satgur kinai na paiaa
satgur vich aap rakhion kar pargat aap sunaiaa
satgur miliai sada mukat hai jin vichoh moh chukaiaa
utam ehu beechar hai jin sache sio chit laaiaa
jag jeevan data paaiaa
Re: NamDhari response
Bobby · 25 Jan 2006
Sorry Raja Hindustani, I am a bit of a stupid moorakh. Please carry on with the intelligent arguments.
So who is the next satguru? Is it Jai Singh aka "prince" (maternal Grandson of the present satguru). I know him as he went to my College.....he told me somethings.... Ask him if he remembers Bob ;-)
Bobby Virdee
Re: NamDhari response
akal yoga · 25 Jan 2006
No one is saying why Saina Pat in gur sobha said that the khalsa panth was made Guru and why Guru gobind singh said Khalsa mere rup khas khalsa is my special form. Why did bhai Mani singh and other disicples of Guru gobind singh not know of this Ajaypal singh as Guru? what to speak of guru gobind singh's wife who had his seals ans and gave advice thinking the Guru had ascended?
why did this ajaypal singh abandon the khalsa and sikhs?
Why did Ajaypal singh standby and watch the Sikhs get slaughtered after Nanded and do nothing. Is this the Guru gobind singh we know?
Why was nothing said by any of the current group at Sri bhaini Sahib during gold star and the slaughter of Sikhs.
Re: NamDhari response
rana · 25 Jan 2006
Ok sadhsangat ji both Namdhari Khalsa, khalistanis and the rest
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa waheguru Ji ki Fateh
According to gurbani...this argument we are having and nindya we are doing of each other is not gurmat at all...
please tell me where in Gurbani does it state to do nindya of each other?
I was reading The Janam sakhi, in which Guru Nanak Dev Ji was giving updesh that if one does nindya of even a sinner then that person will be equally punished as well as the sinner.
Now it is up to you people if you want to still continue such worthless debate which will only result to more hatred and anger.
If any of you read gurbani and followed what is written in the sri guru adi granth sahib then you would have never continued this debate to such an extent or even never replied.
The biggest truth is that guru ji said that as kaljug gets older the more worse things are going to get...guru ji also mentioned that the khalsa will fall apart which u can see happening today. We are all fighting against each other and have forgotten the path guru ji showed us. Guru ji said that only those will survive who will follow the Satguru jis hukam..and there will be only few singhs left who will follow the correct path rest will rot and die in the fire of hatred, ego and anger. And if one thinks that they can undoo these words of what guru ji said then that person is a fool. Doesn’t matter how much debates u do, u cant convince anyone on this world because we are weak our selves. How are we going to preach to people the true path when we are weak and lost our selves? If you want to convince someone then convince your mind who is our biggest enemy. If u want to fight, then fight the five demons inside you who are making you do nindya of different panths and religions.”jin mil mareh panch soormeh, aiso kon bali re” we have to accept the fact that what ever is happening today is happening because it is Sri Akaal purakh jis raza...and we fools who are arguing over worthless things and think that we can change someones point of view. We are lost in our ego and blind as a bat. We must sort our selves up first before pointing at different different panths faults. If you want to find faults in someone then you your self are the best person. find faults in your self rather than saying that "oh look that person believes in dehtari guru or guru granth sahib, lets do their and their gurus nindya" we should be ashamed of calling our selves even sikhs of Satguru Nanak Dev Ji and Guru Granth sahib ji after doing nindya of other panths and religions....if you disagree then I think it is about time you start to read Guru Granth sahib then. I can give u many permaans e.g.
..." Manda kise na akhiye per akher eho bujiye".. ."per ninda kareh, anter mal lae, bahar mal dhowe, man ki joot na jae"..the biggest thing is that i doubt guru ji wud ever forgive us because we do nindya of others and speak rudly about sants and mahapursh dosnt matter which panth they belong to. Doesn’t matter if its a Namdhari or what ever. here if u don’t still agree then I'll tell you what Guru Amar Das sahib jis hukam is about us fools . "kubudh doomni kudeya PER NINDA ghat Choohri muthi krodh chandaal"........"nindak moowa, upaj vad taap" .lets see what Guru Arjan Dev ji has to say about us so calling our selves khalsa.."nindak ki prab pat gwai"..akal purakh is never on the side of nindaks. It is also written in gurbani that people who don’t follow their gurus hukam are bemukhs.."prai jo ninda chugli noh vemukh ker ke bhejya, othe bhi muh kala duha vemukha da kraya".guru ramdas jis hukam is "nindka ke mooh kale kreh, har karte aap wdhai, jio jio nindak nind kareh, tiyo tiyo nit chareh swai"..I mean come on even muslims follow their quran more than us following gurbani now. We cant even follow simple instructions. .. fight blood for blood .. I mean what is this… whilst Guru Granth sahib ji is saying (present guru) that" asankh gal vad hatya kmahe, asankh paapi paap ker jahe"..dhuol dharam deya ka poot". Guru Gobind Singh jis times were different...and now that Guru Granth sahib ji is ur present Satguru who are instructing u not to kill, and to have mercy in our minds and do good for even ur enimies..Then how can we ignore our own gurus hukam by doing perchar to fight and kill etc..ppl might disagree and give permaans such as soora soh pehchaniye jo lareh deen ke heth…well 1st of all we are not a soora, forget soora we are not even half khalsa then how we going protect the poor. We cant even protect our selves from kaam krodh.etc.according to gurbani only those people are true worriors who win over their mind 1st ..Those percharaks are a practical example of what guru gobind singh ji said in granths such as sarab loh granth that " my khalsa will dress in bhana shaster but not follow a single maryada and gurbani and will put shame to my panth"...
..."nanak nam chardi kla, tere bhane sarbat ka bhala" wa wa dhan are we calling our selves sri guru granth sahib ji de sikh who ignore what we chant everyday in the ardas and think that we can do what ever pleases us even if it is forbidden by guru ji..What kind of sikhs are we.....forget talking about namdharis.. half of u people don’t even know the maryada of going jangal pani and ishnaan 4 get everything else lol..yet namdharis have preserved guru gobind singh jis puratan rehat maryada ..nindaks can say what ever they want but this is a fact. I wanted to give more permans from Sri Guru Adi Granth sahib ji but looking at the level we are at and the way we talk to each other so rudly, its not worth it..."moorakhe naal na lujiye"...talking to bemukh is also wrong so i don’t wish to write back and continue this debate or argue about what I have said. no matter what any ninadak writes back to me...if we have any sharam and akal left then we should follow the path guru sahib ji is showing us rather than debating and doing nindya on this board thing which will benefit none of us.
It is a piyaar bhari benti to the sadhsangat to avoid such chat groups and debates on the internet which is a great distractions which leads us to the wrong path and causes us to do nindya etc which is paap and will do nothing but bad to us. Doing nindya is the same as washing away your good deeds. Even if u do veechaar or discussion about any panth or religion or polotics it always leads u to debating so why start such debates and waste our times.
It is a benti to end these debates about namdharis and other sampradawas etc and rather than waisting time of yours and others here, let’s rather spend this unique time in simeran & gurbani. "audh ghate dinso renareh, man gurmil kaj swareh" "peei prapat manukh dehuriya, gobind milan ki eho teri bariya, aver kaaj tere kite na kaam, mil sadsangat bhaj kewal naam"
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa waheguru Ji ki Fateh
rana
Re: NamDhari response
Singh · 25 Jan 2006
No one is saying why Saina Pat in gur sobha said that the khalsa panth was made Guru and why Guru gobind singh said Khalsa mere rup khas khalsa is my special form.
Because it does not say that perhaps?
Why did bhai Mani singh and other disicples of Guru gobind singh not know of this Ajaypal singh as Guru? what to speak of guru gobind singh's wife who had his seals ans and gave advice thinking the Guru had ascended?
why did this ajaypal singh abandon the khalsa and sikhs?
Why did Ajaypal singh standby and watch the Sikhs get slaughtered after Nanded and do nothing. Is this the Guru gobind singh we know?
Why was nothing said by any of the current group at Sri bhaini Sahib during gold star and the slaughter of Sikhs.
This is all your blind assumption. If you had spent a milisecond reading the article of Bhai Kahn Singh mentioned above you would know what kinds of connections Baba Ajapal Singh had and how he assisted the Khalsa. "Is this the Guru GObind Singh we know?" you asked. That's a funny question a lot of people use when they have nothing to say. Do you even know Guru Gobind Singh at all? What research have you done aside reading from english translated copies of spoon-fed distorted history?
Re: NamDhari response
Raja Hindustani · 26 Jan 2006
" Jo Seh ratte aapne Tin Bhave sab Koi" - Guru Nanak Dev Ji
" ...Jin Prem Kiyo Tin Hi Prabh Payeo" - Guru Gobind Singh Ji - akal Ustat
Rana ji,
I agree with you.
Thats why we did not start this argument; and I wont continue, unless someone provokes me. ( I'm a weak person). I wont comment on Mr Bobby ji's last remark either.
Guru Sahib has given us two master pieces of phiosophy, to enlighten our path. We should read Sri Adi Granth Sahib & Sri Dasam Granth Sahib. Lets us make a pledge that we will read both these scriptures at least once in 2006. We all should preach Gurbani.
Khandan nahin Mandan rahi prachar hove.
Sat Sri Akal
Raja Hindustani
Re: NamDhari response
K.Singh · 26 Jan 2006
Sat Guru Dee Payaree Sadh Sangat ji Sat Sri akal
After reading all these questions and answers i don't see any end of this topic. Why don't all of u think about the present situation of sikhs .
Don't u think sikhi is moving (hijacked ) to a new direction i mean Sants and deras . They are using SGGS for their own favour. I have seen most of the amritdhari sikhs as their agents giving Boys ,Treatment ti sicks, helping for their cases in the court etc. Do we sikh doing anything to stop these pakhndi's not to use SGGS for their business. Even our Akali leaders are going to these pakhandis.
Re: NamDhari response
Bobby · 26 Jan 2006
Why is it when a intelligent discussion starts against naamdharis, people get accused of being khalistani? Where is khalistan! What does a khalistani look like? I don't care for khalistan but I care for the fake stories naamdharis keep creating about Guru Gobind Singh and then dress it up with a non-namdhari angle.
Also naamdharis are not a sampradawas, they are not Sikhs full stop. They are great script writers though, and boy can they write a long post......
Re: NamDhari response
Singh · 26 Jan 2006
Bobbyboy, intelligent discussion is when you actually listen and give respect to people's views and comments and spend time trying to understand their point of view and then weighing it facts and knowledge.
Insulting other's Gurus, Panth, calling them 'pakhandees' etc. is intelligent discussion to you? Yeah sure they can write long posts but the fact is there is something written in those long posts. Those historical information can be double, triple, quadruple checked. The Namdharis have always been very open. In all their Parchaars, if someone can show them a better path, a VERIFIABLE, more historically correct path that should first of all be accepted by the non-Namdharis themselves not things like Bhatt Vahis and forged Rahitnamas of Bhai Nandlal and Bhai Gurdas the second which are rejected by the non-Namdhari scholars themselves, they're more than happy to accept it.
How can you expect Namdharis to follow 'Guru Manio Granth' when your own Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha is saying it is a cookedup stanza?
K. Singh, so Namdharis are using SGGS for their benefit and the Akali leaders and other Jathas are not? That is ridiculous. Since its creation people of all Jathas have been trying to twist the message of Gurbani into different meanings. And this is why Namdharis cannot accept what others say because there is no 'Maryada' in the non-Namdhari 'sikh' sangat. The issue of meat-eating is unclear amongst all non-Namdharis. Why is this? One cannot imagine such a problem to ever exist if the non-Namdharis actually believe Granth Sahib is their real Guru or if they have a Guru at all for that matter. Rather than following Guru Granth, non-Namdharis interpret the meaning of the Granth Sahib based upon the understanding of the leader of their Jathas. So you end up with the UK Nihangs that are called Nangs by some and you get AKJ's who are viewed as taliban by the others. Where is 'Gur-Maryada'?
Until today the non-Namdharis cannot decide if Sri Dasam Guru Granth Sahib Maharaj is Gurbani or not. There is fighting in every 'discussion' forum about meat eating and Raagmala and Bhagtan Di Bani that fuels aminosity amongst each other. Big deal is made earlier in this post about Namdharis having separate langar for Majbis, but the non-Namdharis on the other hand have a SEPARATE GURDWARA itself for Majbis and for almost every other caste from Ramgarhias to Jatts. What does this show to a Namdhari? Namdharis are Sikhs of their Guru and not of Akal Takhat or AKJ or DDT. That's the end of discussion. If you cannot deal with it then tough luck your childish views cannot change the glorious history of the Namdhari Sikhs, the pioneers of freedom movement, revivers of respect for Guru Granths, initiators of Khalsa Anand Karaj, saviours of Darbar Sahib's honor, pioneers of printing Gurbani with lithography type prints, saviours of Gurmat Sangeet, revivers of Dasve Patshah's Khalsa Maryada and the true Sikhs of the Satguru.
Akaaaaaaaaaaal!
Re: NamDhari response
LionKing (LK) · 27 Jan 2006
********
The Namdharis have always been very open. In all their Parchaars, if someone can show them a better path, a VERIFIABLE, more historically correct path that should first of all be accepted by the non-Namdharis themselves not things like Bhatt Vahis and forged Rahitnamas of Bhai Nandlal and Bhai Gurdas the second which are rejected by the non-Namdhari scholars themselves, they're more than happy to accept it.
*********
I have not read through all posts, therefor if any of my questions/answers have been responded to, I apologize in advance, but I've read half of the discussion =)-
****
How can you expect Namdharis to follow 'Guru Manio Granth' when your own Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha is saying it is a cookedup stanza?
****
Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha is not a SIkh Guru. Just because a man suddenly starts saying something is made up doesn't mean it is. How authentic is the work of Kala Afghana to you?
Kala Afghana makes a lot of statements - does he belong to naamdhari's ? No - does thta make him a non-naamdhari? yes - do most Sikhs accept him? No. So your logicl of saying that some non-naamdhari's don't accept is doesn't mean anything. That's a pathetic argument, as most Sikhs don't agree with Kahn Singh nabha on other things as well..
*******
The issue of meat-eating is unclear amongst all non-Namdharis. Why is this? One cannot imagine such a problem to ever exist if the non-Namdharis actually believe Granth Sahib is their real Guru or if they have a Guru at all for that matter.
*******
Point to be noted. But Again logic fails.
no not all non-naamdhari's argue about meat. The Panth has made a decision about meet. Some still argue against it - are they Naamdharis? No - do they then class as Non-naamdhari's? yes - does tha mean that Sikhs accept what they say? No it doesn't.
Guru Sahib made Guru Panth Guru Granth. Guru Panth has made a decision and most people stick to it. Do you have the guts to say that although your naamdhari Guru says that meat is not allowed- there are not those who eat meat?
Again logic is flawed. Just because some sects or cults decide to go against what "mainstream Sikhs" or Guru Panth de Sikh - doesn't mean most Sikhs don't have an opinion.
****
Rather than following Guru Granth, non-Namdharis interpret the meaning of the Granth Sahib based upon the understanding of the leader of their Jathas. So you end up with the UK Nihangs that are called Nangs by some and you get AKJ's who are viewed as taliban by the others. Where is 'Gur-Maryada'?
****
You have touched upon the subject of Nangs, whom i have a long experience with. Again you bring the same flawed logic again and again. You have no argument that is different. You keep on providing examples of how Panth is not in ekta - who's fault is that? Guru Granth Sahib Ji's?
History tells us that GOI agents such as R.S.S have a MASSIVE hand in disrupting ekta in Panth. Why do you think they're mkaing photos of Guru Sahib wearing Rakhri, Marring around fire and other dodgy stuff? What has Jagjit Singh done to prevent this?
What has Jagjit Singh done to stop galt parchar (all sorts of galt parchar, including RSS propaganta) Where was jagjit Singh when the house of Guru Arjan Dev ji was burning? Where was Jagjit Singh when thousands upon thousands of innocent people - whether they agreed with jagjit SIngh or not - were burning- where was he? Guru Nanak Dev ji spoke out against an oppresive tyranny. Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib ji give his head for a people he didn't agree with. When Sikhs were burning on the streets of Amritsar - or in fac ton the streets of Delhi, Knapur, or other cities - where was Jagjit Singh and what was he doing? Was he doing ass-parchar that the gov is wrong- was he doing peacefully demonstrations like the Akalis (despite the longowal dodgy stuff). The Akalis were doign peaceful protests - they were doing something - what was jagjit Singh doing against the oppresive tyranny. Bhai Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindrawale throughout his life did massive parchar, miri-piri parchar. Untill death he did not waver - he kept on opposing tyranny . If Jagjit SIngh did not do anything 20 years ago against tyranny - against the oppresor - how many peaceful protests is he planning on holding in near future?
IS THIS THE GURU? The Guru Panth has been standing up against tyranny and is still in one way or another doing it. You'll still see Panj Pyaarey walking infront of every peaceful protest heald, whether in Uk, or India where they're bound to be killed in encounters.
*****
Until today the non-Namdharis cannot decide if Sri Dasam Guru Granth Sahib Maharaj is Gurbani or not.
*****
No Panth has not amde a decision on this yet. What is Jagjit Singh's view on this (seeing as most of you probably can't have an opinion opposing him - please share his view on this topic) - supposedly being the same jyot as Guru Gobind Singh he would easily be able to tell whether it's Gurbani or not - what has he said? Has he made any decision for naamdharis on this issue. Although I'm ignorant - I can only guess that he has not express his opinion on this. Has he? If not - why not.. he's the same jot as Guru Gobind Singh ji isn't he??? So he should easily be able to answer that?
****
There is fighting in every 'discussion' forum about meat eating and Raagmala and Bhagtan Di Bani that fuels aminosity amongst each other.
****
Bhagtan di bani - no-one in panth rejects at all. yes there is a discussion about Raagmala, and this could be understood as it is the laast Ang of Guru Granth Sahib ji, so it IS possible (though not plausible) that someone could have added it - but no-one rejects, Shabads from Raag Suhi, Raag Gauri, Raag Malar, Raag Devgandari - because there is NO "Shaak" in their authentity.
Please tell me what view Jagjit Singh has given on Raagmala - seeing as he's supposedly the same jyot as Guru Arjan Dev ji he should EASILY be able to answer if it is written by his jyot or not. After all if Guru Gobind Singh Ji could repreat WHOLE of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, from Ik oankar till the end - then surely Jagjit Singh supposedly being is jyot shoudl be able to the same thing, including answer the questions you have posed to us - is Raagmala bani? is Dasam Granth Bani? But I doubt very much that he's given an answer to these questions. Please enlighten me if he has.
Guru Gobind Singh Ji's jyot never rested in peace until the very root of tyranny was chopped of. Guru Nanak Dev ji spoke out against Tyranny, Guru Arjan Dev ji Gave Shaheedi against tyranny, Guru Hargobind Sahib took up shaster against tyranny, Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib again gave Shaheedi, Guru Gobind Singh ji fought 15-16 battles against the tyranny, and today Guru Granth Sahib je echoes inevery Gurdwara around the globe-
[gurbani]Kurwswn Ksmwnw kIAw ihMdusqwnu frwieAw ][/gurbani]
Every single Gurdwara aroudn the globe echoes -
[gurbani]
jYsI mY AwvY Ksm kI bwxI qYsVw krI igAwnu vy lwlo ]
pwp kI jM\ lY kwblhu DwieAw jorI mMgY dwnu vy lwlo ]
srmu Drmu duie Cip Kloey kUVu iPrY prDwnu vy lwlo ]
kwjIAw bwmxw kI gl QkI Agdu pVY sYqwnu vy lwlo ]
jwiq snwqI hoir ihdvwxIAw eyih BI lyKY lwie vy lwlo ]
KUn ky soihly gwvIAih nwnk rqu kw kuMgU pwie vy lwlo ]1]
[/gurbani]
As the Word of the Forgiving Lord comes to me, so do I express it, O Lalo.
ringing the marriage party of sin, Babar has invaded from Kaabul, demanding our land as his wedding gift, O Lalo.
Modesty and righteousness both have vanished, and falsehood struts around like a leader, O Lalo.
The Qazis and the Brahmins have lost their roles, and Satan now conducts the marriage rites, O Lalo.
The Muslim women read the Koran, and in their misery, they call upon God, O Lalo.
The Hindu women of high social status, and others of lowly status as well, are put into the same category, O Lalo.
The wedding songs of murder are sung, O Nanak, and blood is sprinkled instead of saffron, O Lalo. ||1||
Up till today, the maryada of speaking against tyranny is alive and kicking. Guru Granth and Guru Panth are doing massive resistance against root of tyranny where possible – where is Jagjit Singh?
*****
Big deal is made earlier in this post about Namdharis having separate langar for Majbis, but the non-Namdharis on the other hand have a SEPARATE GURDWARA itself for Majbis and for almost every other caste from Ramgarhias to Jatts.
I’ve never seen a single Gurdwara where no-one except Raamgharias are welcome, or no-one but jatts are welcome. I’ve been to quie a few Gurdwara up and around the globe, but have yet to be thrown out of a single one. Yes Some “Sikhs” have gone corrupt and made the Gurdwara into their profit place – but why you throwing the blame on all “non-naamdharis” for?
***
Namdharis are Sikhs of their Guru and not of Akal Takhat or AKJ or DDT
I have yet to see a single individual calling himself a Sikh of the DDT, AKJ or Akal Thakhat – the ones I’ve met say they’re Sikhs of the Guru and not of a group of Sikhs preaching Sikhi :S
If you cannot deal with it then tough luck your childish views cannot change the glorious history of the Namdhari Sikhs, the pioneers of freedom movement, revivers of respect for Guru Granths, initiators of Khalsa Anand Karaj, saviours of Darbar Sahib's honor, pioneers of printing Gurbani with lithography type prints, saviours of Gurmat Sangeet, revivers of Dasve Patshah's Khalsa Maryada and the true Sikhs of the Satguru.
I agree with you that a lot of Sikhs are hostile towards Naamdhari’s, which I disagree with as Sikhs are taught to love all no matter if you disagree with them or not. Although I do disagree with Naamdhari’s on the Guru-dum issue I personally do acknowledge Naamdhari’s for being involved in freedom movements, reviving Gurmat Sangeet. It might seem as if I’m hostile towards naamdhari’s, but if you read my other posts you will see me acknowledging naamdhari’s for the good they have done – no doubt about that. Right is right. Wrong is wrong. That is why I’ve posed a few questions about why Jagjit Singh, supposedly being Guru Nanak’s jyot has not raised his voice against the mass killing of Sikhs, against the Darbar Sahib burning. You mention that Naamdhari’s are saviours of Darbar Sahib – where were they when the whole of Amritsar was on fire, and women were being raped inside the Gurdwaras? Where was Jagjit Singh Back then? Where is Jagjit Singh today? What is he doing against the oppression against Sikhs today? What is he doing against the fake encounters in Punjab today. How many families of the victims of Punjab Crisis is he funding, how many Gurdware has he rebuilt? WHERE IS JAGJIT SINGH WHEN IT IS TIME TO CHOP THE ROOT OF TYRANNY?
I hope my post isn’t ignored or seen as a an “un-intellectual-post” as I’ve tried to answer most of you’re questions without resorting to insults, “falto bolna” etc.
Also, due to personal ignorance I do not know the stance Naamdharis have on Bhai Gurdas Ji (the first one @ Guru Arjan Dev Ji’s time) diya Vaara. Do you accept these and revere them as much as Guru Arjan Dev Ji did- do you even read them – what significance to they have for a Naamdhari. Again this is purely out of ignorance and I hope some Naamdhari veer can clarify this for me
Thanks =)
Please accept my apology if I have offended you in any way
Vaheguru Ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 27 Jan 2006
Dear Lion King Paji,
You have raised some key questions about where was Guru Jagjit Singh Ji in the time of distress when the innocent Sikh's were being killed during the operation blue start incident. If I were in your shoes, I would have been asking the very same question.
Since your knowledge with Namdhari panth is not that much, but I can try to answer the question the best way I can. As you aware that in our Sikh History that all the Guru's had their own tasks to fulfil. From Guru Nanak Dev ji To Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji. After Sri Satguru ram Singh Ji gave the Gurgadi to his brother to take care of the Panth since Satguru Ram Singh Ji were being exhiled. Satguru Ram Singh Ji's brother's orginal name was Maharja Budgh Singh Ji which was changed to Hari Singh Ji by Satguru Ram Singh Ji. In a Hukumnama send with one of his closest disciple, Shri Darbara Singh, Satguru Ram Singh Ji declared " From now onwards Budh Singh should be called Hari Singh. I vest him with all the spiritual powers to deal with any situation. All the Namdhari Sikhs should follow his command. Even I will honor his decisions. He will keep the flame of Independence burning and spread ideals of Sikhism". Satguru Ram Singh Ji needed their brother to keep the flames of Independence burning when Satguru Ram Singh Ji were taken away from Pardas (Country).
Satguru Hari Singh Ji did passed away on 5 June 1906. Satguru Hari Singh Ji ( Maharja Budh) Ji had three sons. The eldest son was Sri Satguru Partap Singh Ji who were given the responsibilties of keeping the panth a live since Satguru Ram Singh Ji disappeared from Prision For The Guru had Told The Sikhs who accompanied Him in the bullock-cart when He Left Sri Bhaini Sahib in the year 1872 repeatedly NOT TO BELIEVE WHAT THE ENGLISH GOVERNMENT WOULD ANNOUNCE ABOUT HIS LIFE OR DEATH. HE RESTATED THE ORDERS OF SATGURU GOBIND SINGH JI THAT HIS 'DEH'(BODY) WOULD SUSTAIN FOR 250 YEARS.
After Satguru Partap Singh Ji passed away the current Guru Jagjit Singh Ji were entrusted to the responsibilties. The Primiary duties of these Satguru's after Satguru Ram Singh Ji were to instruct the Sikh's to do Nam Simron and Bani. Their duties were not to save the world. Only person that will save the world will be Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji once they return. It is a possibility that Sri Satguru Jagjit Singh Ji themselves will give the gurgadi back to the 12th Guru Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji.
People must understand that we are not here to crtisize or do nindaya against anyone or their beliefs. I hope everyone read Rana's post. What Rana said about the Sikh's is true.
Wahi Guru Jey Fateh!
Re: NamDhari response
LionKing (LK) · 27 Jan 2006
How does that answer any of my posed questions? Yo have basically given me a 5 paragraph essay on how naamdharis gurudum has been transfered from one perosn to another :s
You write -
*******
After Satguru Partap Singh Ji passed away the current Guru Jagjit Singh Ji were entrusted to the responsibilties. The Primiary duties of these Satguru's after Satguru Ram Singh Ji were to instruct the Sikh's to do Nam Simron and Bani. Their duties were not to save the world. Only person that will save the world will be Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji once they return. It is a possibility that Sri Satguru Jagjit Singh Ji themselves will give the gurgadi back to the 12th Guru Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji.
********
Jagjit Singh interpreted saving a people being butched as saving the world?
Saving 2% of Indias' populatin from beign burnt alive seemed like saving the world? Also you say tha his duty was to instruct Simran and Bani, and not to save the world - does this mean that Naamdharis don't believe tha simran and bani can't save the world?
Again That is a pathetic excuse as to why he didn't stand up. Sikh history is known for valour and the Guru's have given examples by giving Shaheediya and by standing up and chopping the root of tyranny, if Jagjit Singh didn't even make a statement against the government, than I think that is (not making a statement - not the man himself , but him not making a statement) is truely pathetic.
Bhagat Puran Singh of the Pingalwara, probably did a LOT more Simran Bani, Bhagati, at the same time as he spent his entire life on doing seva - RETURNED his award to the government and boycotted. That is the true spirit of the Khalsa. Saint Soldier. It is truely a Pathetic scene to see someone supposedly being the jyot of Guru Nanak, yet not screaming out against oppression.
Guru Nanak Dev Ji did it, Guru Arjan Dev ji gave Shaheedi against it, Guru Hargobind Sahib lifted the Kirpan against it, Guru Harrai Ji had an army waiting for it, Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib ji gave Shaheedi against it, Guru Gobind Sahib Jeeo gave up his WHOLE FAMILY against oppresion.
Clearly the Guru's have illustrated that they will not approve living under oppression, and did not rest until the roots of oppresion and tyranny had been chopped of. Guru Nanak Dev ji did not save the world by speaking against tyranny, Guru Arjan Dev ji did not save the world by speaking against tyranny - they gave an example to Sikhs of hwo to be - Will Jagjit Singh simply speaking agianst the government, or doing something for the victims wounded, raped, abducted by the government make him save the world?
A bit off-topic, but - I hear he's well good on Raag kirtan....=D
Conclusion -
If Jagjit Singh was the jyot of Guru Nanak, surely he would have raised his voice against oppression, just like the other Guru's did (1-10). If he is the 15(16 or 17th, or whatever it is) Nanak, then surely he would behave like it? He might be sant-suba de (i.e saintly) but that is not enough as Gurdev Pita ji (Guru Gobind Singh Ji) taught us to keep shaster, and stand out against oppression. First in a non-violent way. Jagjit Singh hasn't done that at all. Please educate me if I am mistaken.
Bhull chukk maaf
Re: NamDhari response
kds · 27 Jan 2006
i have a question to namdharis.if namdhari concept of living guru is true
then why majority of sikhs beleive guru granth sahib as their guru.who replaced living guru with guru granth sahib
Re: NamDhari response
Singh · 28 Jan 2006
kds,
So 2 Billion people believe in Islam and about the same in Christianity. Does that make Sikhism a fake religion?
Lion King,
First and foremost your knowledge about Namdharis is HORRIBLE. ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE. It is just like... well if I was you.. I wouldn't even be writing a paragraph here and show the lack of knowledge. You do not even know if Namdharis believe in Raagmala Sahib and Dasam Granth Sahib or not and you easily assume that Satguru Jagjit Singh has 'no decision' about this? I really admire your bravery in trying to enter a discussion knowing absolutely zero about the subject matter. But just for your information Namdharis do, and have always believed in both as Gurbani.
Namdharis have nothing to do with Operation Blue Star. They were just as much the victims as the non-Namdharis. The fact of the matter is the militant sikhs brought it upon themselves and all the innocent persons the carnage of 1984. The same question can be asked about Granth and Panth Guru. What are they doing? The SGPC has billions in revenue yet only a fraction of people know about the atrocities of 1984.
*********
Jagjit Singh interpreted saving a people being butched as saving the world?
*********
No. So the rest of your post is just baseless venting. Besides anyone can very easily raise the same question where was the Guru Granth and Panth and why did half of them also accept help from the government and half did not but went ahead and broke the entire old structure of Akal Takhat down and build a new one using bathroom tiles and whitewashing old frescos? THE MOST CRUCIAL FACTOR WAS that the militant portion of sikhs who were the main root of the destruction of Darbar Sahib in 1984 did not consider Namdharis as their brothers and felt no need in asking for or accepting the help from Namdharis. Had they, like the Brahmins of Kashmir, approached the Satguru for help, in the same way Master Tara Singh did in 'Guru Ka Bagh' Morcha, the Satguru would have without a question given them full help. But even today the majority of pro-khalistani and militancy sikhs act like they are big shots and are hostile towards Namdharis, so may whoever their Guru is bless them.
To say that Namdharis do not give a hoot about 1984 is just ignorance and insensitive.
********
due to personal ignorance I do not know the stance Naamdharis have on Bhai Gurdas Ji (the first one @ Guru Arjan Dev Ji’s time) diya Vaara. Do you accept these and revere them as much as Guru Arjan Dev Ji did- do you even read them – what significance to they have for a Naamdhari.
********
Yes they do. And that is another reason why they believe in Dehdhari Guru.
You should seriously evaluate your knowledge of Sikhism in general. The point I'm raising is not that there is no 'Ekta' in non-Namdhari sikh world. But the ABSENCE OF KNOWLEDGE or Gurmaryada. There are always bad seeds in every community. The Chali Mukte at one point did appear as cowards and deserted Guru Gobind Singh. Dheermal was a Sahibzada of the Satguru etc. However, it was clear to the Sikhs of the Satguru what the true Maryada was. But today NOBODY KNOWS anything. NOBODY KNOWS if Raagmala is Gurbani or not. NOBODY KNOWS if meat eating is ok or not. NOBODY KNOWS if women can perform kirtan and Sewa in Darbar Sahib or not. NOBODY KNOWS if Nanak Shahi calendar is to be used or not. There is nothing but confusion and indecisiveness in the non-Namdhari sikh community. WHY? There was never any need for Sikh Rahit Maryada to be ever spelled out on a piece of paper just so that certain words like 'Kutha' can be twisted to mean different things so people may do as they please.
The only reason I see is that the non-Namdharis simply cannot agree to believe in someone or something as their Guru and accept his/its/their hukam as the true hukam as has always been the case since the inception of Sikhism where the Sikhs believed fully in the word of their Gurus. Or do you blame this on RSS too? How long is it going to take the Panth to make a decision on Dasam Guru Granth Sahibji, Raagmala, meat-eating, and all other crucial issues? It has been almost, if not more than a hundred years since these issues have been pending?
I would do a year's worth of research before answering if I were you. Please don't ask questions that can be thrown out in an instance like 'Where was your Guru during the years.... to... ' etc. etc. because the same question can be used against you and as a matter of fact you will have a much tougher time answering when asked about the absence of Guru Granth and Guru Panth from 1708 - 1874 AD.
Re: NamDhari response
Bhagwant Singh Virk · 28 Jan 2006
Khalsa Ji
I as a non namdhari am grateful that the namdhari's have maintained the Gurmat Sangeet tradition. That I would give the community and community elders credit for. I enjoy the kirtan, for the the use of stringed instruments and in the correct raag give me some indication of how kirtan may have been performed at the times of Guru's.
However I would be interested what was the offical stand of the community on the events of June 84, not just someone's opinion but the offical line. On a personal note I would be very dissappointed to learn if they were in favour of the attack of Darbar Sahib. What protest was made by the communityif they were against the attack
Also what help or assistance did the Namdhari give the Sikhs in the aftermath of the Dehli riots.
WJK,WJF
Bhagwant Singh Virk
[%sig%]
Re: NamDhari response
kds · 29 Jan 2006
So 2 Billion people believe in Islam and about the same in Christianity. Does that make Sikhism a fake religion?
singh ji i am not saying that because the number of namdharis is low thats why they are fake.i want to know according to them who replaced living guru with guru granth sahib and why majority of sikhs beleive guru granth sahib as their living guru.as far as islam is concerned we all know what method they applied to convert people thats why their population is so large
Re: NamDhari response
Harcharan Singh · 29 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh,
Veers Singh Ji/Dead man walking,
Purely for my own education, and not to provoke a defensive response, would you be kind enough to answer a few questions which will help fill the gaps I have of the Nkadhari viewpoint, please give honest widely eccepted Namdhari opinion as the answers:
1 - Why did Guru Gobind Singh Ji decide to trick the Khalsa Panth by faking his death?
2 - Why did Guru Gobind Singh Ji not help his Khalsa during the Ghallughaara?
3 - Why did Guru Gobind Singh Ji never contact his wife again?
4 - Why did Guru Gobind Singh ji create the Khalsa so that no Sikh could never hide again as they did during his fathers shaheedi, and then go into hiding himself?
5 - Why did Guru Gobind Singh Ji assume a different name (Baba Ajaypal Singh Ji)?
6 - Why do Namdhari not beleive that Guru Ji said Guru manyo Granth, do they really thing Guru Ji would have disapeared or died without giving the panth a leader/direction - Guru?..
7 - How does raagmala fit into Gurbani - the raags do not all equate with those in Gurbani, and Guru Granth Sahib does not use a raag-raagni music system for rendering and composing raags? Please do give some kathaa of ragmala.
8 - Is Baba Ram Singh Ji not supposed to now come back and reclaim the Namdhari Gur-Gaddi from Jagjit Singh Ji? Is there any search underway, what will happen if Baba Ram Singh Ji does not show before the 250 physical life span ends?
Please do not see these questions as a challenge or an attack, I do not presume I will change your views, I simply would like to learn the Namdhari's views on these matters. Thank you.
Sat Sri Akaal.
Harcharan Singh
Re: NamDhari response
Singh · 29 Jan 2006
Dear Harcharan,
Thank you for your intelligent questions.
Here are the answers:
1 - Why did Guru Gobind Singh Ji decide to trick the Khalsa Panth by faking his death?
To avoid the direct attention of the Mughals. Sikhs, especially Khalsas, are sworn to speak the truth. Even if you read British accounts about Namdharis, they say that a Namdhari a) Does not tell a lie, b) does not eat meat, c) can never be loyal to its enemy, the Briths and d) is Guru Gobind Singh's true Sikh. These were their words in the Encyclopaedia Brittanica published in early 1900s. That is why Guru Gobind Singh left an element of doubt within them. However I personally do not believe the Khalsa Panth was 'tricked'. In one of the posts above, deadmanwalking mentions 'Travel in the Kashmir and Bengal', a book written by Barron Charles Hugel which can still be purchased off amazon.com today. The author clearly states that the Sikhs still expected return of Guru Gobind Singh. And this book was written during times of Maharaja Ranjit Singh. So whether the Khalsa was 'tricked' or not, is up to you as the readers' own understanding and judgement.
2 - Why did Guru Gobind Singh Ji not help his Khalsa during the Ghallughaara?
Whether he indeed did send army to help or not is highly debatable and no one can say for sure.
3 - Why did Guru Gobind Singh Ji never contact his wife again?
Again this is something nobody knows for sure. In certain Hukamnamas of Mata Sundriji there are mentions that certain Hukams have been given by 'Sri... ji' For some reason there is a space left blank between 'Sri' and 'ji'. Could this be that they were from Guru Gobind Singh in the same way Baba Ajapal refers to himself as 'Guru... Singh'? Also if we are to believe in Panth Parkash of Giani Gian Singh about the history of Banda Bahadur, it is said that Mata Sundri sent a Hukamnama signed by Guru Gobind Singh via Bhai Nandlal to tell Banda to stop raising arms. The fact of the matter is this is an 'unwritten' part of Sikh history. There is very little credibility about anything that happened. Your guess is as good as mine. But the fact remains that there are 'bits and pieces' that seem to show that Guru Gobind Singh did have a direct influence after 1708 A.D.
4 - Why did Guru Gobind Singh ji create the Khalsa so that no Sikh could never hide again as they did during his fathers shaheedi, and then go into hiding himself?
Did Guru Gobind Singh not use the same strategy to escape from Chamkaur and then as Uch Da Pir? If one does more research on Baba Ajapal Singhji one would know that on certain occassions when going to meet certain important persons he would infact be fully attired in battle armour and had a pressence that no one could look direct onto his face. These things are written in the booklet passed down in Bhai Kahn Singh's family.
5 - Why did Guru Gobind Singh Ji assume a different name (Baba Ajaypal Singh Ji)?
It is a 'signal name'. Ajapal means caretaker of the people. When Guru Ram Singh went into exile, to communicate with the Namdhari Sikhs in India, he also used a 'signal' name 'Dyal Singh' in Hukamnamas to avoid direct suspicion by the government as much as possible.
6 - Why do Namdhari not beleive that Guru Ji said Guru manyo Granth, do they really thing Guru Ji would have disapeared or died without giving the panth a leader/direction - Guru?..
Because Namdharis do not believe Guru Gobind Singh died in Sri Abchal Nagar. He remaind the leader of the Sikhs until 1812 A.D. There was a Nihang who became a Namdhari and some other Nihangs were not fond of this. So they reported him to the police that the Nihang is helping Namdharis raise arms and wear Kirpans that were banned for them in Punjab. When the police guard, who was also a Sikh, came to arrest the Nihang and asked him to give up his Kirpan, the Nihang asked "Whose Sikh are you?". The Sikh did not say Guru Granth or Guru Panth. He said "I'm a Sikh of Guru Gobind Singh". Similarly, before the 1870's, there has never been any mention of Guru Granth or Guru Panth raised against the Namdhari Sikhs. Those who despised them raised the issues like their turbans falling off when becoming intoxicated with Naam and that their Guru, who took 'birth' (there's an interesting account to how Guru Ram Singh came to be as well) in the house of a Tarkhan, which accordint to them was a 'lowly' caste, could be Guru Gobind Singh. Nobody ever questioned Namdharis or their Guru if they believed in Guru Granth or Guru Panth or not because they all know the respect they give to Bani and Sadh Sangat.
As long as Guru Ram Singh remained in Punjab there was never a mention of Bani or Shabad being Guru. Only after he was exiled and Namdharis severely oppressed was it heard and the Namdharis also reported this to Guru Ram Singh in Rangoon that the Singh Sabha and Nihangs of Akal Bunga (It was not Akal Takhat yet back then) were doing this and not allowing Namdharis into historical Gurdwaras etc. The Namdharis were in a similar situation as Banda Bahadur. Their enemy was the British and they considered all the other Sikhs as their brothers of the same Father beliving in the same Holy Book. So being attacked by those who viewed as their own was quite disheartening. One can only imagine.
7 - How does raagmala fit into Gurbani - the raags do not all equate with those in Gurbani, and Guru Granth Sahib does not use a raag-raagni music system for rendering and composing raags? Please do give some kathaa of ragmala.
Does a Khalsa carry each and every shastar written in Shastar Naam Mala? Raag Vidya, Shastar Vidya, i.e. Vidya (Knowledge) is the basis of Sikhism and highly advocated by the Satgurus. Khalsa Amrit ceremony is also not written in Sri Adi Granth Sahib but every Sikh, including Namdharis, believes in it.
8 - Is Baba Ram Singh Ji not supposed to now come back and reclaim the Namdhari Gur-Gaddi from Jagjit Singh Ji? Is there any search underway, what will happen if Baba Ram Singh Ji does not show before the 250 physical life span ends?
Namdharis strongly believe their Guru will return. When the correct time is, only their Guru knows. Their entire religion is based upon this. The question should be 'What will the non-Namdharis do when Guru Ram Singh returns?' in Namdharis' opinion. Unlike the non-Namdhari community which has always had contradicting views whether the Satgurus were just mere humans who had the mission of 'delivering the message of God' or if they were Avatars of God itself, Namdharis wholeheartedly believe in the latter that God takes form of a Man to save those who believe in him and show the people the correct path to spread the true knowledge and dismiss doubts. If their Guru does not return then you may call them liars and they would gladly join the non-Namdhari community.
Re: NamDhari response
Singh · 29 Jan 2006
Bhagwant Singh Virk,
In regards to 1984, as mentioned: THE MOST CRUCIAL FACTOR WAS that the militant portion of sikhs who were the main root of the destruction of Darbar Sahib in 1984 did not consider Namdharis as their brothers and felt no need in asking for or accepting the help from Namdharis. Had they, like the Brahmins of Kashmir, approached the Satguru for help, in the same way Master Tara Singh did in 'Guru Ka Bagh' Morcha, the Satguru would have without a question given them full help. But even today the majority of pro-khalistani and militancy sikhs act like they are big shots and are hostile towards Namdharis, so may whoever their Guru is bless them.
If you require an 'oficial' answer then write to the Namdhari Darbar Sri Bhaini Sahib.
Re: NamDhari response
LionKing (LK) · 29 Jan 2006
*******
Lion King,
First and foremost your knowledge about Namdharis is HORRIBLE. ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE. It is just like... well if I was you.. I wouldn't even be writing a paragraph here and show the lack of knowledge. You do not even know if Namdharis believe in Raagmala Sahib and Dasam Granth Sahib or not and you easily assume that Satguru Jagjit Singh has 'no decision' about this? I really admire your bravery in trying to enter a discussion knowing absolutely zero about the subject matter. But just for your information Namdharis do, and have always believed in both as Gurbani.
********
I apologize =)
******
Namdharis have nothing to do with Operation Blue Star. They were just as much the victims as the non-Namdharis. The fact of the matter is the militant sikhs brought it upon themselves and all the innocent persons the carnage of 1984. The same question can be asked about Granth and Panth Guru. What are they doing? The SGPC has billions in revenue yet only a fraction of people know about the atrocities of 1984.
*******
How Mischievous of you!
That is an extremely easy way out by turning the discussion arround to a discussion about operation Bluestar - Although your assumption is wrong, and i recommend you read
Citizens for Democracy's -
"Report to the Nation: Oppression in Punjab"
A report prepared by 4 hindus, and one Sikh, lead by the respected Justice Tarkunde..
I really recommend you read it, and you will see who was responsible for it.
But who is responsible is completly irrelevant to this discussion, and hopefully you wont try to change subject by discussing who was respionsible for the army action further in this thread.
As to what are Guru Panth and Guru Granth doing?
I shall tell you -
Who did raise their voice against oppression to begin with? Panth
Who stood there protecting the Darbar Sahib when the temple was being stormed? Panth
Who was filling their spirit, and keeping them in "Chardikala" in order to be able to stand up and fight against oppression? Guru Granth Sahib Ji's Bani =)
*******
*********
Jagjit Singh interpreted saving a people being butched as saving the world?
*********
No. So the rest of your post is just baseless venting.
********
Earlier on you yourself said that theres not point in doing it if non-naamdhari's can't do it intelectually - when asked what intelectual is - you mention RESPECT- is that the respect you've got for my arguments?
is this not pakhand? Kehna Koch Karna koch...
********
Besides anyone can very easily raise the same question where was the Guru Granth and Panth and why did half of them also accept help from the government and half did not but went ahead and broke the entire old structure of Akal Takhat down and build a new one using bathroom tiles and whitewashing old frescos? THE MOST CRUCIAL FACTOR WAS that the militant portion of sikhs who were the main root of the destruction of Darbar Sahib in 1984 did not consider Namdharis as their brothers and felt no need in asking for or accepting the help from Namdharis. Had they, like the Brahmins of Kashmir, approached the Satguru for help, in the same way Master Tara Singh did in 'Guru Ka Bagh' Morcha, the Satguru would have without a question given them full help. But even today the majority of pro-khalistani and militancy sikhs act like they are big shots and are hostile towards Namdharis, so may whoever their Guru is bless them.
*********
I ahve alaready answered your question about what Guru Granth and Guru Panth was doing. the rest is just a mischievious way to change subject. Let's for one moment assume these "hard-core, fanetic, Anti-hindu Sikhs" were responsible for it - why was Jagjit Singh ot helping the innocent who were being butchered. I'm NOT ASKING WHO WAS RESPSONIBLE FOR IT!!!! So stop changing the subject- I'm asking what he was doing when the situations had become like it had become..
Did Brahmans have to come to Guru Nanak for Guru Nanak to say -
[gurbani]pwp kI jM\ lY kwblhu DwieAw jorI mMgY dwnu vy lwlo ]
srmu Drmu duie Cip Kloey kUVu iPrY prDwnu vy lwlo ][/gurbani]
Bringing the marriage party of sin, Babar has invaded from Kaabul, demanding our land as his wedding gift, O Lalo.
Modesty and righteousness both have vanished, and falsehood struts around like a leader, O Lalo.
Up till today jagjit singh or any other naamdhari has not publicly critisized the governments attack onthe holiest seat of Guru Ram Das Ji - why?
Bhagat Puran Singh Ji, did not have a mission to save the world, he was doing prem naal seva - he was doing SImran - but when the Panth was being attacked - did he stand up ? yes he did! He threw back the award he was given by the government - what has jagjit SIngh done to boycott the government.
Everyone knows Khuswant Singh is a shady character - EVEN HE RETURNED HIS AWARD!!! Simranjit Singh Maan resigned!!!!
THese are the true people - who boycotted the government - what has Jagjit Singh done up til today?
Guru Panth and Granth have always stood against oppression whether of Kaley, Piley, Niley, Sudhr or whatever!!!
*****
To say that Namdharis do not give a hoot about 1984 is just ignorance and insensitive.
*****
So what has Jagjit Singh publically done to boycott, and speak out against the government?
Why was he standing quitely by when the Singhs were doing peacefull protests (Rasta Roko, Kaam roko etc)
If you do not know of the movement please do not post anything about it here as this is a post about the Guru. Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Guru Panth stood up against the tyranny and not only spoke against it, but actually spilled life to chot of the rooy of the oppressor - if Jagjit Singh has done anything about it then tell me. I'm not talking about picking up guns, or helping ayone - i'm simply asking for one SINGLE instance, where he pbulicly spoke out against the government, like most Sikhs have done so Far. Guru Granth Sahib Ji doe not remain silent on the oppressor either, Read Babbar Bani.
****************
********
due to personal ignorance I do not know the stance Naamdharis have on Bhai Gurdas Ji (the first one @ Guru Arjan Dev Ji’s time) diya Vaara. Do you accept these and revere them as much as Guru Arjan Dev Ji did- do you even read them – what significance to they have for a Naamdhari.
********
Yes they do. And that is another reason why they believe in Dehdhari Guru.
*****************
---------------------
(From Guru Nanak to Guru Arjan Dev) Five pirs were there who drank from the five cups(of truth, contentment, compassion, dharama, discerning wisdom), and now the sixth great pir is holding the Guruship.
Arjan (Dev) transformed himself into Harigobind and sat majestically.
Now the Sodhi lineage has started and they all will show their selves turn by turn.
This Guru, the vanquisher of armies, is very brave and benevolent.
The Sikhs prayed and asked that they have seen the six Gurus (how many more are to come) .
The true Guru, the knower of the unknowable and seer of the invisible told the Sikhs to listen to.
The lineage of the Sodhis have been established on the sound foundation.
Four more Gurus will come to earth (yuga 2, yuga 2 i.e. 2+2=4)
-------------------------
Please pay extra attention to the last sentance.
**********
You should seriously evaluate your knowledge of Sikhism in general. The point I'm raising is not that there is no 'Ekta' in non-Namdhari sikh world. But the ABSENCE OF KNOWLEDGE or Gurmaryada.
**********
What Gurmaryada - doing havans?
Standing and watching by when innocent people are being burnt?
That seems pretty much brahman Maryada more than GURMARYADA
****************
There are always bad seeds in every community. The Chali Mukte at one point did appear as cowards and deserted Guru Gobind Singh. Dheermal was a Sahibzada of the Satguru etc. However, it was clear to the Sikhs of the Satguru what the true Maryada was. But today NOBODY KNOWS anything. NOBODY KNOWS if Raagmala is Gurbani or not. NOBODY KNOWS if meat eating is ok or not. NOBODY KNOWS if women can perform kirtan and Sewa in Darbar Sahib or not. NOBODY KNOWS if Nanak Shahi calendar is to be used or not. There is nothing but confusion and indecisiveness in the non-Namdhari sikh community. WHY? There was never any need for Sikh Rahit Maryada to be ever spelled out on a piece of paper just so that certain words like 'Kutha' can be twisted to mean different things so people may do as they please.
******************
There is not point in repeating. I have already responded to this in my previous post. Did you even read it, or did u read between the lines?
I shall quote for you -
--------
****
There is fighting in every 'discussion' forum about meat eating and Raagmala and Bhagtan Di Bani that fuels aminosity amongst each other.
****
Bhagtan di bani - no-one in panth rejects at all. yes there is a discussion about Raagmala, and this could be understood as it is the laast Ang of Guru Granth Sahib ji, so it IS possible (though not plausible) that someone could have added it - but no-one rejects, Shabads from Raag Suhi, Raag Gauri, Raag Malar, Raag Devgandari - because there is NO "Shaak" in their authentity.
-------------
----------------
*******
The issue of meat-eating is unclear amongst all non-Namdharis. Why is this? One cannot imagine such a problem to ever exist if the non-Namdharis actually believe Granth Sahib is their real Guru or if they have a Guru at all for that matter.
*******
Point to be noted. But Again logic fails.
no not all non-naamdhari's argue about meat. The Panth has made a decision about meet. Some still argue against it - are they Naamdharis? No - do they then class as Non-naamdhari's? yes - does tha mean that Sikhs accept what they say? No it doesn't.
Guru Sahib made Guru Panth Guru Granth. Guru Panth has made a decision and most people stick to it. Do you have the guts to say that although your naamdhari Guru says that meat is not allowed- there are not those who eat meat?
Again logic is flawed. Just because some sects or cults decide to go against what "mainstream Sikhs" or Guru Panth de Sikh - doesn't mean most Sikhs don't have an opinion.
-----------------
Guru Panth has made a decision on all of those above mentioned subjects. Yes certain people choose not to follow it - Just like Kala Afghana chooses to reject Dasam Bani. That's his choice.
Meat
Women Seva
Nanak Shahi Calandar
All of these subjects are decided. Just because certain individuals or cults decided not to follow it doesn't mean the PANTH hasn't made a decision so it is naive of you to say
NOBODY KNOWS, NOBODY KNOWS - because it's pointless- these subjects have been responded to by Panth.
*****
There is nothing but confusion and indecisiveness in the non-Namdhari sikh community.
******
THe problem is that you have grouped all non-naamdhari's as one. This is wrong because although Panth has made a decision, doesn't mean someone can't disagree. Kala Afghana has his views - fair enough - no-one is going to kill him for that. To me it seems like one cannot be Naamdhari and yet disagree with certain things Naamdhari's do, either is none or all. Either you believe in it all or nothing. THe Panth has, jsut liek Naamdharis, made decisions on issues, just because some individuals and cults disagree doens't mean Sikhs are confused or NOBODY KNOWS, as you keep on repeating.
**************
The only reason I see is that the non-Namdharis simply cannot agree to believe in someone or something as their Guru and accept his/its/their hukam as the true hukam as has always been the case since the inception of Sikhism where the Sikhs believed fully in the word of their Gurus. Or do you blame this on RSS too? How long is it going to take the Panth to make a decision on Dasam Guru Granth Sahibji, Raagmala, meat-eating, and all other crucial issues? It has been almost, if not more than a hundred years since these issues have been pending?
***************
Most issues have been solved already by Guru Panth. as for Raagmala and Dasam Granth, due to lack ofcredible leaders of the Panth today no decision has been able to be mad. But that again you cannot blame on Guru Panth, but it is due to the political crisis in Punjab, where government is running everytihng and has peneterated pretty much everything, which has made these issues pending. These are not small issues that "okay, someone says they are bani, so let's accept it"
I'll give you another controversial one which you can use in future - Sarbloh Granth. It is controversial, due to it's historical evidence. Smae with above. the Panth will not simply accept it as bani or not Bani because one single individuals dictates it to believe so. Panth is not a pile of blind ritual and dogmatic beliefs valey, but is made of intellectual saint soldiers.
******
I would do a year's worth of research before answering if I were you. Please don't ask questions that can be thrown out in an instance like 'Where was your Guru during the years.... to... ' etc. etc. because the same question can be used against you and as a matter of fact you will have a much tougher time answering when asked about the absence of Guru Granth and Guru Panth from 1708 - 1874 AD
********
I doubt so, because the History of the Panth has been recorded by far more and credible historians than those of the naamdharis.
Read, The Sikhs in History Sangat Singh, The Sikhs Patwant Singh..
before asking tha question as they will most likely satisfy you.
Panth has had great leaders like Bhai mani Singh Sahib, Bhai Banda Singh Bahadur, Baba Deep SIngh ji etc after Akal Charana of Dasam Guru.
THere is not credible evidence or historians saying thta Guru Gobind Singh ji living for hundred and what years naamdhari's claim..
On the other hand, you happily quote Kavi Santokh Singh and other istorians early. From that I assume you see these as reliable historians - will you accept their word if they say Guru Gaddi Was given to Guru Granth and Guru Panth? Or do you only accept things that fit you the best?
Kavi Santokh Singh definetly says that Guru Gobind SIngh Ji told his Panth that they were the roop of the Guru, the GURU PANth, and this Guru Ji also showed when obeying the Panj Pyaarey In Anandpur, and Chamkaur when he had to bow down to the Panj Pyaarey's hukams!!!
So do you accept my challange?
If I can give credible evidence from above historians you have provided (Kavi Santokh Singh etc) Will you accept the Guru Gaddi of Guru Panth Guru Granth?
As For Nand lala Rehitnamey who you happily claim are false - are not the only rehitname claiming Guru Panth Guru Granth.
Bhai Prehlad Rehitnama is completly clear and So is Bhai Daya Singh Rehitnama.
Again just because one person says is false doens't mean tha whole Panth automatically accepts it. You have been able to provide one scholar who doesn't believe in Nand Lal's Rehitnama, but there are several, including Piara Singh Padam, Mcleod (an anti Sikh writer) and other schoalr who accept the Prashan-uttar dedicated to Nand Lal.
Again, out of Six Rehitnamey, three of them are completely crystall clear about the doctrine of Guru Panth Guru Granth, and some of them only mention Guru Panth
******
I as a non namdhari am grateful that the namdhari's have maintained the Gurmat Sangeet tradition. That I would give the community and community elders credit for. I enjoy the kirtan, for the the use of stringed instruments and in the correct raag give me some indication of how kirtan may have been performed at the times of Guru's.
********
Couldn't have said it bette rmyself.
*******
However I would be interested what was the offical stand of the community on the events of June 84, not just someone's opinion but the offical line. On a personal note I would be very dissappointed to learn if they were in favour of the attack of Darbar Sahib. What protest was made by the communityif they were against the attack
**********
Thank you, I was wondering about this too. let's see what our naamdhari brothers reply to this as this shoudl be extremely interesting. Please answer the question and don't jump around it. Answer the question - what is the Naamdhari's OFFICIAL stand on events of 84 [i.e what has Jagjit Singh said about it, was he in favour or against it...] and waht did has he done TODAY in order to remove the shackles of slavery of the Sikhs.
Don't ask me what Guru Granth and Panth has done - because you can read back 22 years, of what Sikhs have done and are doing in order tog et rid of the shackles of slavery.
please forgive me if i have offended anybody
Re: NamDhari response
Singh · 29 Jan 2006
kds,
Singh Sabha Lahore, aided by British Government helped them with the propaganda and they remained allies until the British made the fatal mistake of messing with their Gurdwaras and the non-Namdharis also seeked help of Namdharis and were given full support to eradicate Englishmen from India. If you do some research about Sikh community, our way of preaching hasn't always been civilized. The Singh Sabhas were extremely hostile against Namdharis, insulting and demeaning them in every possible ways: From reporting their congregation to the police and interrupting their Akhand Paths and landing them in jails to physically driving them away from Gurdwaras that they gave their own heads to save. Some Namdharis who were already disheartened about their Guru being in a foreign land naturally succumbed to the pressure.
The original Tat-Khalsa that was out to eradicate Bandei Khalsa was just as ruthless, actually they were far worse, putting their own Khalsa brothers to sword.
Who was right and who was wrong is in the eyes of the beholder.
Re: NamDhari response
LionKing (LK) · 29 Jan 2006
3 - Why did Guru Gobind Singh Ji never contact his wife again?
Again this is something nobody knows for sure. In certain Hukamnamas of Mata Sundriji there are mentions that certain Hukams have been given by 'Sri... ji' For some reason there is a space left blank between 'Sri' and 'ji'. Could this be that they were from Guru Gobind Singh in the same way Baba Ajapal refers to himself as 'Guru... Singh'? Also if we are to believe in Panth Parkash of Giani Gian Singh about the history of Banda Bahadur, it is said that Mata Sundri sent a Hukamnama signed by Guru Gobind Singh via Bhai Nandlal to tell Banda to stop raising arms. The fact of the matter is this is an 'unwritten' part of Sikh history. There is very little credibility about anything that happened. Your guess is as good as mine. But the fact remains that there are 'bits and pieces' that seem to show that Guru Gobind Singh did have a direct influence after 1708 A.D.
****************
I had a look at Hukamnamas by Mata Sundri Ji.
Out of the eight Hukamnamas bby mata ji, this happens in ONE Hukamnama.
in all other hukamna,as at the exact same please, with the exact same wordings after the "sri..ji"
So before and after the text is examtly the same. In one Hukamnama it is instead written "sri...ji" and in the rest of the Hukamnamas is says
a few names "Sri AKAL PURAKH JI Ke Vasi"
a few names " Sri Akal Purakh ji Ka Vasi
In the hukamnama you're talking about it's writen -
Gurbaks Singh Sarbat Khalsa Sri.. Ji ke vasi
so exactly the same as all other hukamnama, just that "Akal Purakh"
is missing from one single hukamnama.
Therefore it woudl be ludicrous to say they were from the Guru.
****
He said "I'm a Sikh of Guru Gobind Singh".
****
Sikhs still say I'm a Sikh of Guru Gobind SIngh - Just like some Say I'm a Sikh of Guru Nanak, Dhan Guru Ram Das.
They are all oen and the same, thus it doesn't matter if you call yourself a Sikh of Guru Granth, Guru Nanak , Guru Hargobind or Guru Gobind, because' it's the aatma that matters, the parkash of the Shabad, which resided in them al, not inthe physical but the aatma - the Shabad parkash.
*******
As long as Guru Ram Singh remained in Punjab there was never a mention of Bani or Shabad being Guru. Only after he was exiled and Namdharis severely oppressed was it heard and the Namdharis also reported this to Guru Ram Singh in Rangoon that the Singh Sabha and Nihangs of Akal Bunga (It was not Akal Takhat yet back then) were doing this and not allowing Namdharis into historical Gurdwaras etc. The Namdharis were in a similar situation as Banda Bahadur. Their enemy was the British and they considered all the other Sikhs as their brothers of the same Father beliving in the same Holy Book. So being attacked by those who viewed as their own was quite disheartening. One can only imagine.
*******
If I can provide you with historical evidence from the such as Max Arthur MacAuliffe, Ernest Trumpp (1850's)
How about Kavi Santokh Singh who you seem to trust as a reliable reference?
How about other Rehitname (not the Nand Lal one, as you obviously have an allergy against it).
Would there be soo many Rehitname if this never happened?
*****
Namdharis wholeheartedly believe in the latter that God takes form of a Man to save those who believe in him and show the people the correct path to spread the true knowledge and dismiss doubts.
*****
Which goes totaly against Gurbani.
*******
Bhagwant Singh Virk,
In regards to 1984, as mentioned: THE MOST CRUCIAL FACTOR WAS that the militant portion of sikhs who were the main root of the destruction of Darbar Sahib in 1984 did not consider Namdharis as their brothers and felt no need in asking for or accepting the help from Namdharis. Had they, like the Brahmins of Kashmir, approached the Satguru for help, in the same way Master Tara Singh did in 'Guru Ka Bagh' Morcha, the Satguru would have without a question given them full help. But even today the majority of pro-khalistani and militancy sikhs act like they are big shots and are hostile towards Namdharis, so may whoever their Guru is bless them.
If you require an 'oficial' answer then write to the Namdhari Darbar Sri Bhaini Sahib.
*********
You have avoided answering the question and instead started rambling the government version of it. Who has told you this? Every single Naamdhari I talk to says the same - is this something your Guru preachers (out of curiosity) because it seems to be that most Naamdharis blindly trust the Government, whereas most HINDUS don't even trust the government version thus the
Report to the nation: oppression in Punjab by Citizens for Democracy ...
regards.
Re: NamDhari response
Harcharan Singh · 29 Jan 2006
Thank you veerji, I will not respond to the answers which I believe you are probably set as stone, this would be a pointless exercise, but please answer the following:
Although shastermala is a bani of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, it is accepted by some that Dasam Granth Sahib was a collection of Guru Gobind Singh Ji's personal works, put together and venerated after Guru Ji's death. Where as Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is a complete embodiment of the 10 Guru's and for us, the eternal Guru.
So that is not a comparable example.
What I would like to know is the Namdhari Guru Jagjit Singh Ji's personal view on this, I have not heard what it is.
Also, I would like you to act in the tradition of all Sikhs, and not accept anything (raagmala) blindly. Please learn about Indian Musical History, learn about the raag - raagni system of music, and find out why it would be included int eh Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and then not used to perform kirtan. Namdhari do not perform kirtan using the raag ragni system either, only the title raag, and I also believe that Jagjit Singh Ji has given a hukum to only perform in title raag, although many Namdhaari mix raag (I have seen this).
Every ang of gurbani serves a purpose, answers a question, gives hope, but I have yet to see what purpose raagmala serves.
If you do know then please enlighten, if not then please ask some elder Namdhari and then enlighten.
Please do not give an answer easily, think about this, ask around and try and give a complete answer.
Raagmala does not include many raags from the Guru Granth Sahib, and I believe doesn't even include raags that were around during the times of our Guru's (but I have yet to research and verify this).
It uses a complimentary music system where by raags form relationships with each other musically, but Gurmat Sangeet is done only in the 1 hukmi raag for the said shabad, so raagmala does not have a purpose their.
I simply would like to know the purpose of raagmala.
Thank you.
Sat Sri Akaal
Re: NamDhari response
Singh · 29 Jan 2006
Lion King,
.................... check 'publishing dates' of the version of books you are trying to quote. It is general knowledge that most 'rahitnamas' are unreliable and have been tampered with just like modern verses of Sau Sakhi. Suraj Parkash Granth like Panth Parkash has gone through good deal of altering as well. In certain publishings of Panth Parkash by Khalsa Tract Society, the entire 28 Kabits about Namdharis have been taken out and similar alterations with books 'PUBLISHED' after 1870's. At the end of the day, given your level of knowledge and arrogance it is a waste of time entering a discussion with you. I cannot spoon feed every bit of information to you. All I can say is read from original sources not 'complied' sources like the modern history books and anti-Namdhari arguments. Good luck.
RE: 1984, I did not avoid answering any quetions raised by Bhagwant Singh. And no this is not an answer preached by the Satguru etc. and I doubt if you honestly ever got this response from anyone else. Namdharis consider both Hindu and Sikh population as their brothers and whoever seeks their help for the sake of betterment and peace receives it. If you cannot accept this or it goes against your version of 'Gurmat' then tough luck.
Harcharan,
Namdharis believe in Raagmala as Gurbani. They believe it was dictated by the Guru. Whatever is Ucharan by the Satguru is Gurbani. How is Sri Adi Granth Sahib embodiment of 10 Gurus when it has Verses from only 6 Gurus and a single salok of Guru Gobind Singh? If you do not mind may I ask if you believe in Dasam Guru Granth Sahib as Guru Granth (Gurbani)? If not then again that is just one of the points where we differ and no matter how much I explain if you are not wlling to accept an answer then there is no use. In your opinion what is the purpose of Shastar Naam Mala? What questions does it answer, what hopes does it give etc as you mentioned?
What prevents you from asking 'elder Namdharis' yourself?
Re: NamDhari response
Bhagwant Singh Virk · 29 Jan 2006
Singh Ji
Bhai Sahib Ji Your reply to my question is not satisfactorily answered
"In regards to 1984, as mentioned: THE MOST CRUCIAL FACTOR WAS that the militant portion of sikhs who were the main root of the destruction of Darbar Sahib in 1984 did not consider Namdharis as their brothers and felt no need in asking for or accepting the help from Namdharis. Had they, like the Brahmins of Kashmir, approached the Satguru for help, in the same way Master Tara Singh did in 'Guru Ka Bagh' Morcha, the Satguru would have without a question given them full help. But even today the majority of pro-khalistani and militancy sikhs act like they are big shots and are hostile towards Namdharis, so may whoever their Guru is bless them."
There were many sikhs who whatever reason may not have agreed with Sant Jarnail Singh yet vehemently protested at the actions of the Indian Government in attacking the Darbar Sahib. Were the Namdhari's in that category. If so please enlighten and if not please enlighten?
Also the second part of my query is what material help did the Namdhari community give those unfortunate Sikhs who suffered because of the riots in November 84
Please do not take personal offence - my query is more for the sake of the record rather than anything else.
Again I am indedbted to the Namdhari community for maintaining the Gurmat Sangeet tradition. I know that anyone who has ever attempted to learn an instrument or sangeet knows what a labour intensive task that can be. I will be honest to say that I have failed miserably on that score.
WJK,WJF
Bhagwant Singh
[%sig%]
Re: NamDhari response
Singh · 29 Jan 2006
Lion King,
Sorry I missed your earlier post.
In regards to 1984 issues I'm afraid no answer will be good enough for you. Namdhari Panth has nothing to do with politics. They are not binded with the Congress or any party. They condemn the attacks and sympathize with the victims, Hindus and Sikhs alike.
Since the events of 1984 Namdhari Panth, under the Hukam of Satguru Jagjit Singh has done what it can to unite the Sikhs and Hindus and get over the attrocities that have divided them. What did the 'rasta roko' (which were also participated by Namdharis FYI) achieved? More destruction and aminosity. Who suffered from it? The government or the innocent people?
Clearly we see things differently in regards to proper response to the carnage of 1984 so the only sensible thing to do is praise your own and respect the other's actions as Namdharis are not in any way shape or form against the victims of 1984.Also your claim of Namdharis standing by and just looking as others are burnt etc is simply out of line and very childish. Namdharis were themselves victims of 1984 why is it so difficult for you to understand?
You do not see Havan as Maryada of Guru Gobind Singh where as other Sanatan Sikh groups including Nirmalas, Nihangs do and so does part of your own community. So clearly your words don't hold much weight and only express your personal view.
As for the translation of the Verse from Varan of Bhai Gurdas you quoted, Namdharis translate Jugi Jugi as in every Yuga, i.e. the Guru will assist the Sikhs in every eternity as he did in Satyuga, Treta Yuga, Dwapar Yuga and Kali Yuga. So either you are twisting the Bani or Namdharis are. Depending on who you ask.
Your answers on the various issues is not good enough for me unfortunately just like how some of my answers are not good enough for you. How clear is the Maryada in the non-Namdhari world is a whole entire new topic: http://sikh-heritage.co.uk/research/sikh%20rehit/sikh%20rehit.htm
But for me personally the pressence of the Satguru equals absence of doubts and ignorance. So to convince me I would need to know who your Guru really is. Is it just the Granth Sahib as the Dohra 'Guru Manio Granth' goes, or also Panth? Also please understand that Namdharis also consider Khalsa as 'IMAGE' (ROOP) of Guru Gobind Singh. But NOT that Guru Gobind Singh gave Gurgaddi to Panth or Granth Sahib.
You again quote books by singh sabha writers: Sangat Singh, Patwant Singh etc which are way after 1800's and unreliable.
The debate about Gurgaddi can go on and on. At the end of the day only time will tell who is right and who is wrong or if both are right or both are wrong.
For the sake of research and understanding of true history, one must read from all sources and then weigh the facts. Only reading a one sided arguments is not the way of a scholar.
In the end I would really like to know which group do you belong to? Are you AKJ, DDT, Nihang, Nirmala, 3HO, Singh Sabha or something else? Many non-Namdharis say they are just 'Sikhs' and yet these very 'just sikhs' don't agree on any of the issues like meat-eating or Dasam Bani so clearly it is not true that there is such thing as 'just sikhs'. Everyone seem to belong to one group or another. The reason I'm asking this is then it will be easier for me to understand where you are coming from as clearly you do not believe that the Guru Sahibs were Avatars of God yet many Sikh group who are non-Namdharis do believe so.
Re: NamDhari response
LionKing (LK) · 29 Jan 2006
´
*************
How is Sri Adi Granth Sahib embodiment of 10 Gurus when it has Verses from only 6 Gurus and a single salok of Guru Gobind Singh?
**************
Because even if the bani of one Guru was in it, it would still be the ambodiment of 10 Gurus, as they were all one anyway. Just as we consider Guru Nanak Patshash's Bani same as Guru Tegh Bahadurs - they were one..
The physical never was important, it was always the parkash of the Shabad.
*******
Lion King,
.................... check 'publishing dates' of the version of books you are trying to quote. It is general knowledge that most 'rahitnamas' are unreliable and have been tampered with just like modern verses of Sau Sakhi. Suraj Parkash Granth like Panth Parkash has gone through good deal of altering as well.
************
So why do you suddenly find these sources reliable yourself?
These texts are not unreliable and tempered with when you have a point to make, but when it doens't suit you, they've been tampered with and are stamped as unreliable.
Although I agree the generally speaking some Rehitname are not very reliable, but looking at the fact tha most Rehitname acknowledge the doctrine of Guru Panth and Guru Granth - and COMPLETLY FAIL to mention of any Baba Ajaypal Singh or Baba Ram Singh.
Most historians, whether british or muslims have commented in history that indeed the guru of the Sikhs is Guru Granth. I have refered to seveeral historians in my earlier post which you blatently ignored.
*********
In certain publishings of Panth Parkash by Khalsa Tract Society, the entire 28 Kabits about Namdharis have been taken out and similar alterations with books 'PUBLISHED' after 1870's. At the end of the day, given your level of knowledge and arrogance it is a waste of time entering a discussion with you. I cannot spoon feed every bit of information to you. All I can say is read from original sources not 'complied' sources like the modern history books and anti-Namdhari arguments. Good luck.
**********
I agree there is absolutely no use of arguing about the doctrine of Guru Panth Guru Granth, as you yourself have proved that you decide what is reliable and what has been tampered with. Whenever it suits you to refer to some scholar you do that, but when someone else uses your sources that contradict your ideas, they are completly unreliable and tampered with..
Please take a look at your arguments.
You have stated several arguments by several historians. I challange you that I can find where these historians you find reliable, refeirng to the doctrine of Guru Panth Guru Granth.
I have refered to other historians in history who ahve acknowledged the doctrine of Guru Granth and Guru Panth, I have asked you several times of how a Guru can sit there and watch and not raise his voice against the oppressor yet claim to be onthe Gaddi of Guru Nanak, I have offered to source several other Rehitname, including Rehitnama Prehliad, Rehitnama Daya Singh (who by the way was the first in Punj), I have refered to several historical events where the Guru has bowed to the Hukam of the Punj and the Khalsa. I do not see any reason to keep on arguing as you have blatently ignored these above sources,, and after having used them yourself for you own motive, concluded that they are all unreliable.
What an intellectual debate.
As Harcharan SIngh ji said - you have set everything on stone and will not change you mind no matter how much evidence is shown, no matter how much is questioned [which is good you ave DriR wishwash in your Guru - keep it up =) ]
Bt do remember tha when refering to a historian except people to refer to them if the historians write anything that you might disagree with, therefore think twice before refering to i.e Kavi Santokh SIngh who frankly writes about the doctrine of Guru Panth
So, as I said - be careful, and keep doing more paath and Bani, and keep it up with the Kirtan =)
Biggups for reviving the raag traditions =)
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 29 Jan 2006
One of the sings asked me a few questions earlier about the Namdhari Lungar and caste system in one of the posts. Here is some information him to read and understand.
Sat Sri Akal.
In regards to Guru Gobind Singhs life goto
namdhari.faithweb.com under nander 1708 which also has
Bhai Kahn Singh Nabhas article.
As for historical resources. it should be asked
otherwise. Bhatt Vahis and rahitnamas of Bhai Nandlal
etc or Prehlaad Singhs Rahitnama are all forgeries.
See Mahan Kosh under Prehlaad Singh and Nand Lal.
Kirpans size was reduced as the strategy of fighting
against the current evil is not by force/killing them
physically as was during the time of Guru Gobind Singh
when the Singhs were physically threatened.
in regards to langar. We can ask back why
non-namdharis have different Gurdwaras for castes? We
are taught the Such Sodh Maryada and so we follow it.
But there is much difference between segregation and
discrimination. The Majbis sit in front rows in Divans
and they can be Ragis, Granthis etc and as a matter of
fact if anyone discriminates i.e. in physical or
verbal form against them, Sri Satguruji always
straightens out such persons if anyone Arj HIM.
Amrit is Made in Iron Bowl.
Wahi Guru Jey Key Fateh!
Re: NamDhari response
LionKing (LK) · 29 Jan 2006
Sorry I missed your earlier post.
In regards to 1984 issues I'm afraid no answer will be good enough for you. Namdhari Panth has nothing to do with politics. They are not binded with the Congress or any party. They condemn the attacks and sympathize with the victims, Hindus and Sikhs alike.
Since the events of 1984 Namdhari Panth, under the Hukam of Satguru Jagjit Singh has done what it can to unite the Sikhs and Hindus and get over the attrocities that have divided them. What did the 'rasta roko' (which were also participated by Namdharis FYI) achieved? More destruction and aminosity. Who suffered from it? The government or the innocent people?
**************
I am sure they do, but I am asking if Jagjit Singh has made a public statement condemning the attack, because as I see it the Gurus did not waver when opposing tyranny.
*********
You do not see Havan as Maryada of Guru Gobind Singh where as other Sanatan Sikh groups including Nirmalas, Nihangs do and so does part of your own community. So clearly your words don't hold much weight and only express your personal view.
*********
You are again grouping all non-naamdharis as one, which i earlier on cautioned you from doing as that is not going to get us anywhere.
Panth has made decisions and see havans as bahamnistic rituals.
yes some put coconuts, some put red cloth - does tha make it a Sikh doctrine accepted by Sikhs?
To say that would be ludicrous as 100% of Panth is against it- Just because a few CULTS do it don't mean it's accepted...
Havans are definetly bahman activities.
*****
Your answers on the various issues is not good enough for me unfortunately just like how some of my answers are not good enough for you. How clear is the Maryada in the non-Namdhari world is a whole entire new topic: http://sikh-heritage.co.uk/research/sikh%20rehit/sikh%20rehit.htm
*****
How good, someones made research on all jathebandis in the Panth.
I will read it later on =)
******
But for me personally the pressence of the Satguru equals absence of doubts and ignorance. So to convince me I would need to know who your Guru really is. Is it just the Granth Sahib as the Dohra 'Guru Manio Granth' goes, or also Panth? Also please understand that Namdharis also consider Khalsa as 'IMAGE' (ROOP) of Guru Gobind Singh. But NOT that Guru Gobind Singh gave Gurgaddi to Panth or Granth Sahib.
You again quote books by singh sabha writers: Sangat Singh, Patwant Singh etc which are way after 1800's and unreliable.
**********
Ernest Trumpp, MaX Aurthur MacAuliffe, Kavi Santokh Singh, prehlad Rehitnama, Daya Singh Rehitnama, Nanalala prashan uttar
I can get you a list if you want, but i doubt it's going to change your midn in any way..
****
The debate about Gurgaddi can go on and on. At the end of the day only time will tell who is right and who is wrong or if both are right or both are wrong.
****
If I am not misatken Bhai Ram Singh is thought to come back when - is it 250 years or ? [please excuse my ignorance]
In other words, as Naamdhari's believe he will be given back Gurgaddi by Jagjit Singh - is that something that is set, or is it a *might* thing and might be returned by the next?
Please tell me how this works, as I'm ingorant on this. Please forgive my igonrance.
*****
For the sake of research and understanding of true history, one must read from all sources and then weigh the facts. Only reading a one sided arguments is not the way of a scholar.
*****
agree totally, and I hope you do too, and instead of citing scholars and then later on calling them unreliable when their work doens't please you is not the way of a scholar either =)
*********
In the end I would really like to know which group do you belong to? Are you AKJ, DDT, Nihang, Nirmala, 3HO, Singh Sabha or something else? Many non-Namdharis say they are just 'Sikhs' and yet these very 'just sikhs' don't agree on any of the issues like meat-eating or Dasam Bani so clearly it is not true that there is such thing as 'just sikhs'. Everyone seem to belong to one group or another. The reason I'm asking this is then it will be easier for me to understand where you are coming from as clearly you do not believe that the Guru Sahibs were Avatars of God yet many Sikh group who are non-Namdharis do believe so.
************
I belong to the Guru Panth and Guru Granth Sahib Ji. I find some things appealing that are said by various jathebandis but only associate myself to Guru Panth and Guru Granth.
I follow the Panth, and it's decisions and believe for the good or Bad, there are groups that disagree, but there's always space for dialogue, and not just blind faith in what a man sitting somewher te other side of the planet says =)
bhull chukk maf
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 29 Jan 2006
Sat Sri Akal Sant Ji,
, I would try my best to answer the questions raised by
some Malaysian Sikh as follows.
1. This is generally preached by Akalis that Guru Gobind Singh Ji
gave up His body at Nanded Sahib in 1708 Bikram Samvat. Do you
believe that a great personality like Guru Gobind Singh Ji would
attempt suicide when He had already sacrificed His whole family
for Sikh religion? This is misinformation that is being propagated
by Sikhs who were worried about their income coming from
Gurdwaras. Keeping in mind the present circumstances at that time,
when even the personal security of Guru Gobind Singh Ji was not
upto mark since His Holiness was stabbed by Pathans at Nanded, it
is not surprising that Guru Gobind Singh Ji went into hiding.
2. Are we questioning the ability of Guru Gobind Singh Ji as being
a Satguru over here that His Holiness was not good enough to
choose His Successor?
3. Firstly, there will always be difference between a cow and a
buffallo and secondly, one should always have proper knowledge
about the subject before asking this type of question. This is
simply like asking a medical student how does the nuclear reactor
works.
4. Namdharis always wear the Kirpans albeit it is of a small shape
and embedded into comb ( Kangha ). If Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji
could wear two Kirpans and tell his sikhs to do the same instead
of doing Naam Simran with Mala and same Kirpan has been shortened
to 6 inches by Akalis , then where is the problem?
5. Regarding Sri Adi Granth Sahib Ji as a Guru, Kindly be specific
and give the example clearly where ever it is written that Sri Adi
Granth Sahib Ji has been declared as a Guru after Guru Gobind
Singh Ji.
6. Namdharis do not use Brass utensils for Amrit Sanchar. This is
totally wrong information. The Amrit Sanchar is done in an Iron
vessel by Namdharis.
If there is any other clarification, then you may revert back.
Re: NamDhari response
Singh · 29 Jan 2006
LK,
*************
The physical never was important, it was always the parkash of the Shabad.
************
I wonder how many of your Panthic followers believe the same. So Tuks like 'Tera Mukh Suhawa Jio Sahej Dhun Bani' and 'Satgur Ke Charan Dhoey Dhoey Peeva' and 'Bal Bal Jao Syam Sundar kou Akath Katha Jin Baat Suni' and 'Naam Diya Gur Par Upkari Dhan Dhan GURU KA PITA MATA' and countless other that praise the Satguru's Physical form and even goes on to praise the Guru's PARENTS are just decorations? Should they be taken out of the Granth Sahib then since they do not fit your version of Gurmat?
So WHO is this Panth you follow? WHO makes up this Panth? If Nihangs, Nirmalas, Namdharis are not part of this Panth then who is? Do these people have names? How many are they? Do they give you a collective Hukam? If you have doubt, say you don't understand a meaning of Gurbani or don't know if eating meat is good or bad or Raagmala is Gurbani or not, WHO in your Guru Panth do you approach for enlightenment?
In regards to Havans, read Bhai Gurdas' Varans and Dasam Guru Granth Sahib, but perhaps you won't because Panth has no decision about Dasam Granth Sahib yet. But they both, including the Sri Adi Guru Granth Sahib if you look up the word 'Hom' associate Havan with 'Good Deeds' and virtues. Which Guru Panth has decided Havan is Brahminical? Is Panch Khalsa Divan your Panthic organization? If it is then I can quote its leader who wrote a poem in praise of Havan. Ofcourse if he is not part of your Panth then please let me know.
I do not pick and choose historical resources. If books written AND PUBLISHED pre 1800's say Guru Granth was given Gurgaddi then I'm ready to believe it. You still are mentioning sources like Rahitnama Prehlaad Singh which is according to Bhai Kahn Singh a fake bani, so I don't know what to tell you.
I didn't want to embarass you so I let it slide at first but it appears that you really have no clue that Trumpp and McCaullif's work are not Pre Namdharis and were infact published with great help from Singh Sabha. Namdhari or Sant Khalsa Panth began in 1857 A.D. Suraj Parkash CLEARLY indicates Guru Gobind Singh would return. I wonder if you have even read any of the text you are mentioning.
The fact of the matter is if someone of a respectable position from Singh Sabha community, from a community that historically founded preaching of Guru Granth and Guru Panth tells me that the text that they themselves published is fake, what reason do I have to give that piece of text any credibility? Why are you discounting the words of Bhai Kahn Singh? True that he is not a Guru and is far from perfect but if a Namdhari scholar publishes something that is approved by the Namdhari Darbar regarding their history, then it should be, at least by the Namdharis, believed as true. Why is Bhai Kahn Singh's research and work not believed by people of his own Panth? Is he a person in your Panth or not? He too claims Guru Granth and Guru Panth are Gurus, is this the same Granth and Panth or any different?
Re: NamDhari response
LK · 30 Jan 2006
DMW
AGain you have failed to answer any quwestion above and revert the subject totally.
Singh earlier on refered to Nirmallas and Nihangs doign Havans -
They also believe in Guru Granth Sahib Ji as the Guru - why don't you accept that?
If they are authorative - then why only accept what suits you best???
Re: NamDhari response
LK · 30 Jan 2006
5. Regarding Sri Adi Granth Sahib Ji as a Guru, Kindly be specific
and give the example clearly where ever it is written that Sri Adi
Granth Sahib Ji has been declared as a Guru after Guru Gobind
Singh Ji.
************************
I have answered this earlier on -
----------
Ernest Trumpp, MaX Aurthur MacAuliffe, Kavi Santokh Singh, Prehlad Rehitnama, Daya Singh Rehitnama, Nand lal prashan uttar
I can get you a list if you want, but i doubt it's going to change your midn in any way..
----------
THese abvoe are goign from 150 ears old to the time of Guru Gobind Singh Ji - are all of these fake?
I cang et you some mroe evidence, which you yourself have used to prove your point - I can use your historians (which you have tried proving your poitns with) and show you that most acknowledge the doctrine of Guru Panth Guru Granth
Re: NamDhari response
Harcharan Singh · 30 Jan 2006
Veer Ji,
"Namdharis believe in Raagmala as Gurbani. They believe it was dictated by the Guru. Whatever is Ucharan by the Satguru is Gurbani. How is Sri Adi Granth Sahib embodiment of 10 Gurus when it has Verses from only 6 Gurus and a single salok of Guru Gobind Singh? If you do not mind may I ask if you believe in Dasam Guru Granth Sahib as Guru Granth (Gurbani)? If not then again that is just one of the points where we differ and no matter how much I explain if you are not wlling to accept an answer then there is no use. In your opinion what is the purpose of Shastar Naam Mala? What questions does it answer, what hopes does it give etc as you mentioned?
What prevents you from asking 'elder Namdharis' yourself?"
Veer Lion King Ji (wish you would use your Guru given name Veer ji) has answered your 1st question, Ek Jagdi Jot. Thank you Veer ji.
I do beleive the works contained within Dasam Granth Sahib Ji were written by Guru Ji, so for me they are bani. But how Dasam Granth differs from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is (in my uneducated opinion), is that Dasam Granth and even Sarbloh Granth were compiled post Guru Ji' life, by his close Sikhs, possibly Akalis/Nirmaley.
So I do not personally believe Guru Ji wrote the works to be worshipped, I think they reflect Guru Ji's life experiences, wordly, political, war, relgious, historical and artistic knowledge and interests. Which to me is priceless and is bani, and of course I use 3 of Dasmesh Pita's Ji's baniyan in my NITNEM.
Shasternaam Mala, this is very complicated, but it is known that Guru Ji was a master of Shaster Vidya, he was unmatched warrior, it is not a big surprise to me that Guru Ji wrote a composition on Shaster, it is way above my understanding, so I won't comment any further, but in anser to your question it makes complete sense. The Khalsa are warriors (well supposed to be at least, wouldn't think it today), so I can see that the Shasternaam Mala Ji has a purpose.
You have avoided my raagmala question completely, I will take this as a sign that you do not have much knowledge on that particular subject.
I would ask elder Namdharis, but I only know one, and his area of expertise is something else. Plus, religion is a sensitive subject to older people, they don't like their beliefs to be questioned, so out of respect I wouldn't ask anyway, it would be different for you to ask someone older with whom you have a trusting relationship.
It was simply out of respect and diplomacy within indian culture that I sought to seek this view from yourself, I was not attacking you, there ws no need to be so defensive.
Thank you for your help.
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh.
Harcharan Singh
Re: NamDhari response
kds · 30 Jan 2006
Singh Sabha Lahore, aided by British Government helped them with the propaganda and they remained allies until the British made the fatal mistake of messing with their Gurdwaras and the non-Namdharis also seeked help of Namdharis and were given full support to eradicate Englishmen from India. If you do some research about Sikh community, our way of preaching hasn't always been civilized. The Singh Sabhas were extremely hostile against Namdharis, insulting and demeaning them in every possible ways: From reporting their congregation to the police and interrupting their Akhand Paths and landing them in jails to physically driving them away from Gurdwaras that they gave their own heads to save. Some Namdharis who were already disheartened about their Guru being in a foreign land naturally succumbed to the pressure.
The original Tat-Khalsa that was out to eradicate Bandei Khalsa was just as ruthless, actually they were far worse, putting their own Khalsa brothers to sword.
Who was right and who was wrong is in the eyes of the beholder.
------------------------------------------------------
singh ji so according to namdharis singh sabha along with britishers replaced living guru with guru granth sahib.sorry but one cannot beleive on
this.first of all not all sikhs were associated with singh sabha.what about the common sikhs.did they also changed there guru.how could more than
90% of population of a religion changed their guru.what about the sikhs that were not living in punjab.did they also changed their guru.
Re: NamDhari response
Bobby · 30 Jan 2006
Well the naamdharis think I am just an immature fool, not worth holding a discussion with. The naamdharis may be further shocked to believe that I was born into one of their families.
I grew up in East Ham within the naamdhari sangat, spending my Saturday evenings in Upton Lane. I had the "phook" in my ear done to me as did dozens of my relatives who just turned up to the temple for a family programme.
I have sat in the naamdhari conversations most of my life. I bought the fake £10 notes for £5 from one of the present main guys in Birmingham (not the accountant, but the doctor brother) and could pick up the fake £1 coins to use on the dartford toll bridge so that a certain someone (one who has a bright future in the naamdhari panth) could get to Grenwich Uni. I am Gurbaksh Singh Virdee (Bobby), you will know who my Grandad.
The fact is the constant discussions of superiority and hypocrisy of the naamdharis (UK, Afirca and India) drove me to doubt. I can go on about a lot, my history is weak, my knowledge is poor, but my bais opinions are based on my personal experiences of growing up in the naamdhari sangat.
Re: NamDhari response
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 30 Jan 2006
Dear Veer Harcharan Singh jeo
This is what I had written in my post that religion is a personal subject. Now, You have written correctly that religion is a sensitive subject for the elders. You are learned personality at this phorem with large knowledge.
Bravo.
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh
[address removed]
Re: NamDhari response
LionKing (LK) · 30 Jan 2006
--------------------------------
LK,
*************
The physical never was important, it was always the parkash of the Shabad.
************
I wonder how many of your Panthic followers believe the same. So Tuks like 'Tera Mukh Suhawa Jio Sahej Dhun Bani' and 'Satgur Ke Charan Dhoey Dhoey Peeva' and 'Bal Bal Jao Syam Sundar kou Akath Katha Jin Baat Suni' and 'Naam Diya Gur Par Upkari Dhan Dhan GURU KA PITA MATA' and countless other that praise the Satguru's Physical form and even goes on to praise the Guru's PARENTS are just decorations? Should they be taken out of the Granth Sahib then since they do not fit your version of Gurmat?
---------------------------------
Sorry to blow your bubble, and thanks for moulding Gurbani for your own benifit -
[gurbani]siqgurU ky crn Doie Doie pUjhu ien ibiD myrw hir pRBu lhu ry ] rhwau ][/gurbani]
[gurbani]hy myry mn ! prmwqmw dy gux gwieAw kr [ gurU dy crn Do Do ky pUijAw kr (Bwv, AhMkwr C`f ky gurU dI srn ipAw rhu) [ hy mn ! ies qrIky nwl ipAwry pRBU ƒ l`B lY [rhwau[[/gurbani]
http://www.gurugranthdarpan.com/1118.html
[gurbani]qyrw muKu suhwvw jIau shj Duin bwxI ] icru hoAw dyKy swirMgpwxI [/gurbani]
[gurbani]hy DnuK-DwrI pRBU jI ! qyrw mMUh (qyry mMUh dw drsn) suK dyx vwlw hY (TMF pwx vwlw hY) qyrI is&iq-swlwh (myry AMdr) Awqmk Afolqw dI lhr pYdw krdI hY [ hy DnuK-DwrI ! qyry drsn kIiqAW icr ho igAw hY [ hy myry s`jx pRBU ! hy myry imqR pRBU ! auh ihrdw-dys BwgW vwlw hY ijs ivc qUM (sdw) v`sdw hYN [2[[/gurbani]
Do i need to post an explaination to each shabad or will you be able to do so yourself?
************
So WHO is this Panth you follow? WHO makes up this Panth? If Nihangs, Nirmalas, Namdharis are not part of this Panth then who is? Do these people have names? How many are they? Do they give you a collective Hukam? If you have doubt, say you don't understand a meaning of Gurbani or don't know if eating meat is good or bad or Raagmala is Gurbani or not, WHO in your Guru Panth do you approach for enlightenment?
************
Do ardaas infrotn of Guru Ji. read the pangtees. Read them again. Read English translation, Read Prof Sahib Singh's explaination, that should do the trick =)
Guru Gobind SIngh Sahib founded schools such as Dam Dami Taksal for these questions.
Guru JI was not stupid that he's left Sikhs just alone do go and make it themselves. Guru ji started Gurbani Schools such as the one of DDT, with Baba Deep Singh ji and Bhai Mani SIngh ji as theri jathedars.
*********
In regards to Havans, read Bhai Gurdas' Varans and Dasam Guru Granth Sahib, but perhaps you won't because Panth has no decision about Dasam Granth Sahib yet. But they both, including the Sri Adi Guru Granth Sahib if you look up the word 'Hom' associate Havan with 'Good Deeds' and virtues. Which Guru Panth has decided Havan is Brahminical? Is Panch Khalsa Divan your Panthic organization? If it is then I can quote its leader who wrote a poem in praise of Havan. Ofcourse if he is not part of your Panth then please let me know.
**********
Whats up with "go and read Bhai Gurdas Ji's diya Vaara, or Dasam Granth"
I asked for specific quote where it was an acknowledged practise don't just go - "Go Read his Vara and you'll find it somewhere" - is that how intellectuals refer to theri sources?
Be specific, Vaar Pauri and then u might get somewhere.
Also post any reliable historical account where this was acknowledged by the Guru. It completly contradicts the Guru's teaching of rejecting blind rituals, and other dogmatic doctrines...
**********
I do not pick and choose historical resources. If books written AND PUBLISHED pre 1800's say Guru Granth was given Gurgaddi then I'm ready to believe it. You still are mentioning sources like Rahitnama Prehlaad Singh which is according to Bhai Kahn Singh a fake bani, so I don't know what to tell you.
***********
You said Nand Lal was said to be fake. Fair enough let's assume Prehlad Rehitnama was false. Bhai Dya Singh Rehitnama- the original Panj Pyaare.
Also please refer to the source where Kahn Singh claims these are false.
Also if you agree with Kahn Singh that these are fake - will you agree with him that Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the Guru, or will you select what suits you the most?
You say you do not choose historical sources- that's EXACTLY WHAT YOU DO. You tell ME to find books pre 1800s, yet you yourself refer to scholars who are post 1800's to PROVE YOUR POINT! TALK ABOUT HYPOCRACY!!!
You Refer to Kahn Singh, You refer to Kavi Santokh Singh, yet when someone else refers to these text they are post 1800 - are they not when you try to prove a point?
Again before we carry on with this I request you to find an exact location where this is stated. For the cause of an intellctuall debate you need to site your sources and not just - "look in Kahn Singhäs 4000 page Kosh, and you'll find it"
Tell me the EXACT location before refering to something, and so shall I.
**********
I didn't want to embarass you so I let it slide at first but it appears that you really have no clue that Trumpp and McCaullif's work are not Pre Namdharis and were infact published with great help from Singh Sabha. Namdhari or Sant Khalsa Panth began in 1857 A.D. Suraj Parkash CLEARLY indicates Guru Gobind Singh would return. I wonder if you have even read any of the text you are mentioning.
*************
Clearly indicates are two opposite words. Make up your mind - does it clearly state so or does your understanding from it indicate??
Also, even if it does you yourself earlier on refused to believe in Kavi Santokh Singh's doctrine of Guru Panth.
Kavi cleary mentions doctrine of Guru Panth - yet you decide to reject it. Yo cannot have your pick. If I accept that Guru Gobind SIngh will come back - will you accept kavi quoting Guru ji about the doctrine of Guru Panth.
Have you accepted the Guru Sahib couldn't refuse Panth's hukam on leaving Anandpur and Chamkaur???
What's your opinion on that?
Will Jagjit Singh similarily be unable to refuse the hukam of Panj Pyaarey?
*********
The fact of the matter is if someone of a respectable position from Singh Sabha community, from a community that historically founded preaching of Guru Granth and Guru Panth tells me that the text that they themselves published is fake, what reason do I have to give that piece of text any credibility? Why are you discounting the words of Bhai Kahn Singh? True that he is not a Guru and is far from perfect but if a Namdhari scholar publishes something that is approved by the Namdhari Darbar regarding their history, then it should be, at least by the Namdharis, believed as true. Why is Bhai Kahn Singh's research and work not believed by people of his own Panth? Is he a person in your Panth or not? He too claims Guru Granth and Guru Panth are Gurus, is this the same Granth and Panth or any different?
***********
So why do you decide to prove your point using his texts, but completly reject the other things he claims.
You have refered to Kavi Santokh SIngh to prove your point - yet you do not give two hoots when he acknowledges the doctrine of Guru Panth Guru Granth - why is that so? Is this not hypocracy, where you at one point trust his credibility and at another point decide to ignore the rest?
Is this not Hypocracy???
You have yet to answer how Jagjit SIngh could be a Guru even though he didn't raise his voice against injustice like Simranjit Singh maan, BHagat Puran Singh, and many other (EVEN HINDUS) from the PARLIAMENT RESIGNED THEIR SEATS TO BOYCOTT - yet they do nto call themselves a GURU - yet Jagjit SIngh who claims to be a GURU, the same jyot of Guru Nana, did not raise his voice against tyranny.
Earlier on one of our brothers gave the excuse that he's not here to save the world - well then he's not the jyot of Guru Nanak because that's what Guru Nanak Came for - Jagat Jalanda Rakh Ley Apni Kirpa Dhar. That's EXACTLY What Guru Nanak Dev JI came for - if you yourself reject tha that's the function of Jagjit Singh, then there is NO WAY he can be the true Guru.
(although from what I hear, he's WELL GOOD in raag kirtan =D )
Re: NamDhari response
... · 30 Jan 2006
Kukas,
So you all admit that you have a caste system. You take great pride in that Mazahabis can sit in the front rows. What if they want to sit in the back?
You claim all rehitnamas, historical documents and bhatt vehis are forgeries. Right. Your Cult is a forgery. Your pio is a forgery.
What debate can possibly be conducted with fools like you who simply dismiss all history as fake?
Partap Singh had a divan at Bhaini and Panthic Ardas was recited with 10 Guru Sahiban and Sri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Partap Singh when asked about being Guru said, "baba oh baba...I'm not even the dust of the Guru's feet. But what can I do about those people outside?"
Because the kukas are spiritually and it seems even physically blind, I'll repost a portion of the "evidence" given above:
1) Gurbilas P: 10 by Koer Singh written in 1751: He refers to Guru Granth and Guru Panth
2) Bansavalinama Dasan Pathshahihan was completed in 1769: In this work Kesar Singh makes reference to Guru Gobind Singh giving guruship to Guru Granth Sahib. He writes, that Guru Gobind Singh jee said, “The Granth is the Guru and take refuge in Akal. The Guru is the Khalsa and the Khalsa is the Guru” (pg. 163-4)
3) Guru Kian Sakhian: By Saroop Singh Kaushish, completed in 1797. This is a very important piece of literature since it is based on Bhatt Vehis ie. eye witness accounts by Bhatts in Guru Sahib’s darbar. Sakhi 112 in this Granth is ALL ABOUT THE GURUSHIP. It says Guru Sahib told Bhai Daya Singh, “Bhai Sikha go and feche Cri Granth jee we have to endow Guruship”. On getting the command Bhai Day aSingh brought Sri Granth jee and auspiciously opened and displayed it. …After the ARdas, Satguru jee prepared to pass on Guruship. Guru Sahib took five paise, and a coconut in his hand. Sat on the bedstead and asked Daya Singh, “place them in front of Sri Granth jee”
Guru Kian Sakhian also makes no mention of the Kuka myth of Guru Sahib riding off on their horse. The body of Guru Sahib was bathed by Bhai Daya Singh and it was cremated.
4) Prashun Uttar Bhai Nand Lal: Also calls Guru Granth Sahib Satguru: Dohara “come with reverence and sit in my presence. Humbly bow and hear the words of the Guru Granth” The person who wishes to hear my words should devoutly hear and reflect on the Granth. Acknowledge the Granth as my visible presence, rejecting the notion that it is other than me” verse 11.
5) Desa Singh rehitnama: also acknowledges Guru Granth Sahib: “When food is ready think within of the form of the Guru. IF the Guru granth is present prayer should be offered in its presence” 110.
6) Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama: “He who carries the Guru Granth ji on his head will spend as many years in surag as the number os steps which he has taken” (37). Also, “Believeing that the Guru was present in both Granth and Panth entire families crossed over and achieved spiritual liberation” (45).
We also have the first hand account of Bhai Narbad Singh Bhatt who saw the GUruship go to Guru Granth Sahib.
Re: NamDhari response
Singh · 30 Jan 2006
...
I'm not even going to stoop to your low level.
Quoting from Ganda Singh's book is a waste of time dear boy. Grow up and face the music. Ganda Singh had NO ANSWER to any of the replies made by Namdharis. He wrote back saying "I need more time to research!".
THE QUOTE ABOUT SATGURU PARTAP SINGH JI IS A DAMN LIE. IF YOU HAVE SOME COURAGE IN YOUR BEING YOU WOULD HAVE READ THE NAMDHARIS' REPLY TO GANDA SINGH'S FANTASY BOOK. BUT WHAT TO SAY OF PEOPLE LIKE YOU. IF IT WAS TRUE WHY DID GANDA SINGH HAD TO WAIT FIFTY YEARS TO PUBLISH IT IN HIS ANTI-KUKA BOOK? FOOLS THAT YOU ARE YOU MISQUOTE HISTORY OF THE KHALSA. THE SATGURU WAS KIND ENOUGH TO LET YOUR LEADERS PERFORM YOUR OWN VERSION OF ARDAS AND NAMDHARI ARDAS WAS PERFORMED IN THE EVENING WHY DID YOU AND YOUR GANDA SINGH FORGET TO MENTION THIS? MISQUOTING, TELLING HALF TRUTH, THAT'S ALL YOU FOOLS CAN DO.
The books you quoted are reprinted versions published by SGPC. This fact was clearly mentioned to Ganda Singh by Namdharis and he could not give a straight answer why what he quoted was different than the books found in the library at Darbar Sahib itself. I wonder if they still preserved those books or have already shreaded them so no one will find out the truth like they did with Gianni Gian Singh's works.
If nothing else atleast Namdharis KNOW who their Guru is. Who is YOUR GURU? Is it Granth Sahib or Shabad? In your poem 'Guru Manio Granth' I don't hear 'Guru Manio Panth'. So is Panth even your Guru? What about Jaap Sahib? Is it your Guru too? Why is only Sri Aad Granth Sahib respected as Guru if 'SHABAD' is the Guru? Many Puratan Granths differ in number of Pages and also number of Banis even though they contain Banis of Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib. So which is the real Guru?
The fact of the matter is even your own community doesn't know who their Guru is. Much is said about 'Damdami Bir'. Where is Damdami Bir? Taken away by Mughals? RIGHT! The Singhs did not let the Muslims touch a hair of their Pooran Guru would they ever let the Granth Sahib that recieved Gurgaddi ever slip away and there's not even a Sakhi to be found about this? Here is what your own leaders, the Khalsa Samachar of Amritsar published in 1950:
"Damdami Vali Bir Bannan Vali Koi Sakhi, Na Ta Sanu Prapat Hoi Likhti Pothi Vich Hai, Na Sar Sardar Attar Singh Ji De Niji Kalmi Nuskhe Vich Hai, Na Uhna Day Angreji Tarjme Vich Atay Na Hi Gur Partap Suraj Granth Vich Kavi Santokh Singh Ji Nay Ditti Hai"
Can you REALLY accept what KESAR SINGH CHIBBAR WROTE????? Then Banda Bahadur and Ajeet Singh, adopted son of Mata Sundri is YOUR GURU! NOT GURU GRANTH or GURU PANTH!
This is what he write:
Granth Sahib Ji Nay Sammat Sola Sae Athvanjvay Janam Hai Dhara.
Guru Arjan Ji Kay Dhaam Khidava Bhai Gurdas Bhala Likhara.135.
So Granth Sahib Di Aarbla Mae Samaj Kay Hae Kahi.
HAE VADI PAR BHOGAY GI NAHI!!!!!
Bavanja Sae Oopar Athaanvay Khay.
Par Itnay Bogayga Nahi Thorhay Vich Janda Rahay. 136.
ADAB JASI GHAT SHABAD NU MANNANGAY NAHI.
Eh Vast Hae Adab Di Uth Jasi Tahi.
Sammat Athara Sae Chabi Ajay Bhali Sikhi Athva Singhi Hai.
Ago Dino Din Ghatdi Jasi Shabad Bichaar Kay Samaj Lae.137.
HOW ON EARTH DO YOU EXPECT ANYONE TO BELIEVE KESAR SINGH CHIBBAR BELIEVED IN GURU GRANTH SAHIB AS ETERNAL GURU WHEN HE IS COMPLAINING ABOUT HOW SIKHI IS WILL CONTINUE TO DEPLETE AND GRANTH SAHIB WOULD NOT LAST!!!!!!!!!!!!!??? I did not quote the rest which goes into further details how he complains Granth Sahib would be GONE IN A COUPLE OF YEARS!!!!!!! Will ANY SIKH of Granth Sahib ever say such a thing????
This is what he wrote about Gurgaddi:
Dohra
Doi Ravi Doi Bias Nadi Dui Keeratpur.
Doi Dilhi Ik Khadoor ik Nander Khat Aasan Samanay Das Gur.104.
Chaupei
Agay BANDA SAHIB BAIRAGI ATAY JEET SINGH SAHIBJADA KAHAI.
SOLA BARSA VICH PANJI SAAL GURYAI PAI.
NAU BARS BANDAY SAHIB GURYAI PAI VAER GURU KAY LEI.
SAHIB BANDA DELHI JEET SINGH DONO GURU KAHAVAT BHEI.105.
Sure from here you will say 'Oh well Banda and Ajeet Singh may claim all they want but they weren't the real Gurus because they were corrupt bla bla bla...' and i know you would even go to the lengths of rejecting Kesar SIngh Chibbar's admittance of accepting Banda and Ajeet Singh as Guru because I know your kind of thinking... fine.. I will play your game and even give you that point.. but how about THIS:
MATA KAHIA MAE TAENU JEET SINGH BETA KAR HAE ANDA.
TOO BANIU JEET MAL JO LARHNAY LAGO HOI KAY VANDA.5.
SANGAT SABHO TERI CHARNI HAI LAI!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SODI JAAT TAENU HAI DILAI!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
MAMA KIRPAL SINGH BHEE PAAS AAHE.
TIN BHEE DITTEE EHU SALAIH.
But that's not the best part yet my boy. After this Koer Singh writes that after Mata Sundri went to Sach Khand, Mata Sahib Deva gave the Sikhs guidance:
Sikha Ral Mata Ji Paas Keetee Ardas.
GAREEB NIVAAJ TUSI HO SACHAY SIKH BHEE SACHAY JAAVAN KAIDAY PAAS??!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Mama Kirpal Singh Tay Bebe Gulabo.
Hor Sehjo Lachmi Tahalna Sabho.5.
WHY DID NO BODY SING "GURU MANIO GRANTH"? WHY DID THEY CALL MATAJI GAREEB NIVAAJ? WHY DID THEY ASK "WHO SHOULD WE TURN TO?" Did they not know Guru Granth was their Guru? Or did they all had an attack of alzeimer?
Next time trying actually reading or having some miniscule amount of knowledge about what you are trying to quote.
We have been respectful of you and your Guru on this website but please DO NOT EVER MISTAKE OUR CALMNESS WITH PATIENCE.
As for Bhatt Vahis and all other sources you quoted, your own scholars don't fully credit them. So why should I? They probably even knew who cooked it up the same way Bhai Kahn Singh did with the 'Guru Manio Granth' a.k.a. Prehlaad Singh's Rehitnama.
I don't think there's anything left to be discussed or that can be discussed in a civilized manner seeing how more and more buffoons are showing up and only one person with some manners and knowledge can be found on this entire forum.
Let me know when you figure out who your Guru is because apparently you don't really believe in any or you would not have the need to insult anyone else's Guru.
Re: NamDhari response
LK · 31 Jan 2006
As for Bhatt Vahis and all other sources you quoted, your own scholars don't fully credit them. So why should I? They probably even knew who cooked it up the same way Bhai Kahn Singh did with the 'Guru Manio Granth' a.k.a. Prehlaad Singh's Rehitnama.
********************
4) Prashun Uttar Bhai Nand Lal: Also calls Guru Granth Sahib Satguru: Dohara “come with reverence and sit in my presence. Humbly bow and hear the words of the Guru Granth” The person who wishes to hear my words should devoutly hear and reflect on the Granth. Acknowledge the Granth as my visible presence, rejecting the notion that it is other than me” verse 11.
5) Desa Singh rehitnama: also acknowledges Guru Granth Sahib: “When food is ready think within of the form of the Guru. IF the Guru granth is present prayer should be offered in its presence” 110.
6) Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama: “He who carries the Guru Granth ji on his head will spend as many years in surag as the number os steps which he has taken” (37). Also, “Believeing that the Guru was present in both Granth and Panth entire families crossed over and achieved spiritual liberation” (45).
We also have the first hand account of Bhai Narbad Singh Bhatt who saw the GUruship go to Guru Granth Sahib.
Bhaji forgot to mention BHai Daya SIngh Rehitnama.
You ahve onyl amanaged to refute one of them.
Good Job!!!
Re: NamDhari response
Bobby · 31 Jan 2006
Ease up "Singh"! Take a few deep breaths......
Re: NamDhari response
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 31 Jan 2006
Dear Lion King (LK), Please try to mend your ways. You are not the authority on Sikhism to say, whatever you like. Because of your adament attitude, we find the disrespectful wordings to Guru Sahiban and insulting words from one Sikh-brother to another Sikh brother. Why?
The time is changing at a fast speed. The Sikh community is enlarged enough and sikhs brothers are living in different circumstances and conditions, highly educated and Sikhs are the intellectual class in the world. Even our Singhnis (Sikh Ladies) are working hard and contributing a lot with various manners. We are required to face inter and intra problems. Let us give respect to each other and recite:
EK PITTA EKAS KE HUM BARIK
NINDA BHALEE KISSEE KI NAHI MANMUKH MUGHAD KARANN
TERE BHANE SARBAT DA BHALLA
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh
[address removed]
Re: NamDhari response
LionKing (LK) · 31 Jan 2006
Dear Lion King (LK), Please try to mend your ways. You are not the authority on Sikhism to say, whatever you like. Because of your adament attitude, we find the disrespectful wordings to Guru Sahiban and insulting words from one Sikh-brother to another Sikh brother. Why?
**************************
I do not see myself as an authority of Sikhism, but it pains me when some Naamdhari's come and give reference, show double standard, yet no-one is answering them?
There are children on this phorum - how will they be affected if they keep on seeing that some people come and throw their whole dientity into the bin?
Please forgive me if I ahve in any way used any disrespectful words to Guru Granth Sahib Ji or Guru Panth - please point out these mistakes so that I do not make these in future. As you know, I am a Moorakh, so please show me where I have made these mistakes, where i have disrespected Guru Ji and his Gurmukh Pyaare and I will try to not make them in future. Daas has only tried to put forward evidence that shows Guru Granth Sahib Ji as our only "pita". I have to the extent possible, tried to respond with respect without any insults to even the naamdhari brothers or the person they call their Guru, so how would i disrespect my own. Again please forgive me and point out to my mistakes.
Bhull chukk maaf
Re: NamDhari response
paji · 01 Feb 2006
There are children on this phorum - how will they be affected if they keep on seeing that some people come and throw their whole dientity into the bin?
*******************
It was a non-namdhari who began this whole discussion in the first place (pls read the very first post) so i do not understand why the sudden worry for the children. That thought should have crossed the mind of the person who started all this. He brought all this upon himself, his own doing.
Re: NamDhari response
LionKing (LK) · 01 Feb 2006
Author: paji
Date: 02-01-06 01:03
There are children on this phorum - how will they be affected if they keep on seeing that some people come and throw their whole dientity into the bin?
*******************
It was a non-namdhari who began this whole discussion in the first place (pls read the very first post) so i do not understand why the sudden worry for the children. That thought should have crossed the mind of the person who started all this. He brought all this upon himself, his own doing.
-----------------------------
Point noted - but my point is that if these people are now coming, their questions should be answered and not remain unanswered, as THAT is something that will confuse children - questions that no-one knows answers to. It seems like most of the Chardikala Singhs are doing namabhyaas, so this moorakh thought of answering some of the unanswered questions and respond by returning question to which my naamdari veers have not responded to.
I am not trying to act arrogantly and I apologize if this is ow it seems
bhull chukk maaf
Re: NamDhari response
Kulbir Singh · 01 Feb 2006
The story concocted by Kukas is very childish. I was very reluctant to get into debating this childish story with them but we must not let their lies go unrefuted. It is said that if a lie is spoken with conviction and is repeated again and again, general public starts believing it. The last thing we want is for people to start believing this story.
-----------
A few months later, two Rajputs, Bala Rao and Rustam Rao reported that they were freed from Sitara Fort by Guruji. (Picture below.)
------------
Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj even to this day helps his Bhagats. There are many references to Gursikhs in the last century receiving help from Siri Guru jee. As the matter of fact, when ever his bhagats call out to Satguru jee, Siri Guru jee does arrive without delay. In Ranglay Sajjan we read the account of a Singh who was tied with chains by manmukhs and Siri Dasmesh jee arrived physically to help him. Indeed Guru Sahib helped these Rajputs but this does not mean that Siri Guru jee did not jyoti-jot sama in Naded.
The whole question is that what did Siri Guru jee gain by hiding his identity for so many decades? What was the result of doing so? Sikh quom through out the 1700s suffered immensely and that was the time when Singhs needed Guru Sahib’s leadership. Why did Guru Sahib deny them this leadership and why did Guru Sahib live a life in hiding.
Guru Sahib has done a bachan in his baani:
Mrit Lok tey maun na reh hau||
( I will never keep quiet (against injustice) in this world).
Kuka friends, pray tell us, would Guru Sahib go against his own bachan and hide for so many years? Also, does it befit Guru Sahib to abandon the Khalsa Panth he created?
Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha may have believed that Ajapal Singh was Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj but this does not mean that we all should start believing this white lie. It would be worthy of mentioning that Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha took back his statement later on. Also at the end of this article (quoted by Dead Man), Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha mentions:
[gurbani]
“mY ies muAwmly qy AwpxI koeI p`kI rwie kwiem nhIN kIqI”[/gurbani]
(I have not formed a firm opinion with respect to this matter).
Finally, Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha found out the truth and recorded it in his book Gurmat Sudhaakar:
[gurbani]
“bwbw Ajwpwl isMG swihb ijnW ny klgIDr svwmI qoN AMimRq CikAw qy aumr dw bfw ih`sw prm ipqw nwl rihky ibqwXw”[/gurbani]
(Baba Ajapal Singh who drank amrit from Kalgidhar Swami, spent a big portion of his life with Param Pita jee (Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj)
Swami Kaliyan Das did profound research about Baba Ajapal Singh and found out that Ajapal Singh was born in village Pithoval in the house of Ramo-Bakriyan wala.
The word Aja means a goat and paal means to take care of. Ajapal means one who takes care of goats (Bakri-paal). This explains his name as well. His father kept goats and naturally Ajapal Singh took care of the goats and hence his name “Ajapal” Singh. Today, there is a big dera in place of his old dera and it’s written there that Baba Ajapal Singh was the “Nagarchi” (one who plays nagara) of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj. If you read the later life of Ajapal Singh, it becomes clear that he was very fond of Nagara and kept Nagaray in his dera.
Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj would have never chose this name for himself. Guru Sahib was forever in Chardi Kala and he mostly chose names with Bir Rass. Just look at his Sahibzaaday names. Out of all the names at his disposal, would he ever choose such a loser name as "Ajapaal" for himself. Ajapaal means Bakri paal i.e. one who takes care of goats.. This point alone is suffice for me to convince me that Siri Guru jee could have never been Ajapaal Singh.
It would be worthy of noting that Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha did write that article about Baba Ajapal Singh but no where did he mention that he gave gaddi to Baba Balak Singh in Hazro. Interesting this is that Siri Guru jee jyoti jot sama in 1708 and for the next 208 years, no one wrote anything about Siri Guru jee living in hiding under the name of Baba Ajapal Singh.
Two contemporary Shaahi sources mention the Jyoti Jyot time of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj – the Roz-mancha of Bahadur Shah and in Akhbaare Mualla. Another contemporary source that mentions is Khafi Khan in his book Muntakhib-ul-baab. He clearly writes how Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee got injured and jyoti jyot sama in 1708. There are numerous other sources that mention Guru Sahib’s jyoti jyot sama and these will be produced if required. In the light of these facts, only a fool would believe that Guru Sahib lived as Ajapal Singh.
Baba Raam Singh jee as written by puratan Singhs was a very good Gurmukh who wanted to bring back the lost pride of Sikhs. According to Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee, he remained a faithful Singh all his life but according to Dr Ganda Singh jee historian, he did falter off the path of Gursikhi and this is why his ardaas was not done in Siri Anandpur Sahib and at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib. But whatever the case, he did come back on the path of Gursikhee as it’s evident from his letters, published by Akali Kaur Singh jee. So beautiful are these letters that one cannot help bowing before Baba Raam Singh jee. The language used is very much puraatan. In these letters, Baba jee has indicated many times that Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is the Guru.
Kulbir Singh
Re: NamDhari response
LionKing (LK) · 01 Feb 2006
Veer Kulbir Singh ji, that was an incredible post!!!
****************
Two contemporary Shaahi sources mention the Jyoti Jyot time of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj – the Roz-mancha of Bahadur Shah and in Akhbaare Mualla. Another contemporary source that mentions is Khafi Khan in his book Muntakhib-ul-baab. He clearly writes how Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee got injured and jyoti jyot sama in 1708. There are numerous other sources that mention Guru Sahib’s jyoti jyot sama and these will be produced if required. In the light of these facts, only a fool would believe that Guru Sahib lived as Ajapal Singh.
*****************
Are all of these in Farsi? Is there anyway one can get hold of these (I doubt I'll find it in normal book stores like chattar singh jeevan Singh - so where in punjab would i be able to find it , if in punjab at all)
Thanks a lot - made my day =D
Re: NamDhari response
Harcharan Singh · 01 Feb 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh,
Veer Kulbir Singh Jeeo,
Excellent post. Thank you, it was hugely educational.
p.s. I am still awaiting your e-mail.
Sat Sri Akaal
Harcharan Singh
Re: NamDhari response
Kulbir Singh · 01 Feb 2006
One of the prominent writers of Namdharis writes the following lines about Baba Raam Singh jee:
[gurbani]
rPl sutI dirAw ivc bYTy ho AtMk [
ikhw ieh vI sI ipAw swfy gl klMk [[/gurbani]
(He threw the gun away in the river and sat in the boat straight. Then he said, this rifle was a Kalank (spot of stigma))
After the Anglo-Sikh wars, Baba Raam Singh jee got frustrated and deserted the Khalsa army. He threw his rifle in a river. A true soldier could have never done this. He served well in the army of Kanwar Naunihal Singh the grandson of Maharaja Ranjit Singh jee but later he deserted the Khalsa army. This was wrong (if it's true he deserted the army).
Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj called Shasters (weapons) his Pirs and how could Baba Raam Singh whom Kukas believe to be the 12th Guru throw rifle in the river and call it a kalank? To call weapon a Kalank was not befitting a person of Baba jee's stature.
Another really heartbreaking account is written by this Kuka writer (Inder Singh Chakravati) goes as follows:
[gurbani]
mhwrwj buD isMG dy hQ imSwl PVw [
kihMdy lwau AsW nUM lihxw isMG buJw [
lihxw isMG jI AwiKAw ieauN nw swVo kys [
AWhdy ieh nw rKxI isKI AsIN mlyC [
Coty Coty rih gey bwvrIAW ijauN vwl [ [/gurbani]
Giving mishaal (torch) to Budh Singh, Baba Raam Singh ordered him to burn his hair. Lehna Singh pleaded with him not to burn his hair but Baba Raam Singh said that he is not going to keep this “Malech Sikhi”. He ended up burning his kesh.
This is the account written by a Naamdhaari himself in his book “Malvender If this is true, then how he be the true Guru. He does not even qualify to be a Sikh then, let alone Guru. Can you imagine burning your hair? How could he have done so and how can Kukas justify this? This is against the basic Sikhi requirements.
Third very painful thing that Baba Raam Singh did as per these foolish Namdhari writers is that Baba jee burned a saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee:
[gurbani]
lYky bIV drbwr swihb dI aupr bwlx pwie[
sPw PUhVIAW ivc Dr qIlI idqI lwie[ [/gurbani]
(Then he (Baba Raam Singh) took the Bir of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee (Darbar Sahib) and placed charcoal over it and burned it by igniting it with a match stick).
This is the kind of ool-jalool (bakwaas, nonsense) that they ignorant Namdhari writers are writing. Instead of praising Baba jee, they are actually doing his ninda. I think they have made up these stories to reduce faith and love Sikhs have for Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and for Kesh. The first story seems to have been concocted in order to please the British. It shows Baba jee throwing away his rifle thereby trying to impress upon Sikhs to give up their struggle against the British.
The fact is that Baba jee used to wear only Blue clothes and always had a Khanda on his Dastaar. In 1930s an old Pujaari of Siri Akal Takhat Sahib made the statement that Baba jee used to wear Blue Clothes and kept a Khanda on his Dastaar. Baba Harnaam Singh of Neeldhaaris also stated the same thing.
The Saka of Malerkotla
What was the purpose of the saka of Malerkotla? By killing women, children of Butchers what did the Kukas gain? It was a vain fight and they did not kill even a single British personnel in this fight. The strange thing is that 150 Kukas attacked Malerkotla but were pushed back by the Muslims there and they managed to kill only a few of them. Some Kukas died too. What was this all about? Kukas blame Singhs for 1984, but forget their Waterloo in Malerkotla. At least Singhs gave the govt a resistence that is not unbecoming a Khalsa. What resistance did Kukas give the British after the Malerkotla Saka? Did they do a single militant action after that saka?
Baba Raam Singh kept telling them not to go after the butchers but the Mastana Kukas were not listening. One of them said that he was seeing Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib ordering him to go. Baba jee kept quiet. After the Kukas were caught, they were mercilessly killed by the British and they offered no resistance at all. Baba jee was sent to Rangoon and that was the end of this movement. Ever since that time, the Kukas stayed faithful to the British.
There is no doubt that Kukas have some very good things. They have retained the concept of japping Naam and every Kuka is supposed to japp one pakki maala of Naam everyday but where they have made a mistake is that they have stopped doing nitnem. They are not required to do nitnem everyday. Their only requirement is Gurmantr jaap.
Another good thing about them is that they have retained the baana up to some extent. Its sad that the later Kuka leaders gave up Blue color but nevertheless, they still have maintained baana. They are strict in Bibek rehit (at least some of them) and this is definitely a plus point. And as per our brothers like Veer Harcharan Singh, they have kept alive the Raag Kirtan maryada.
Kukas would be a great asset to us, if they give up their claim on the Gurgaddi. Once Baba Nand Singh and Partap Singh (Kuka leader before the current one) met and Baba Nand Singh advised him to come to the fold of Gursikhee by accepting the supremacy of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Partap Singh did not argue and for once it was hoped that they would come back. But all in vain.
Again, it’s an appeal to all Kukas to come back into the fold of Khalsa Panth by accepting the supremacy of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. You would be an asset if you come back.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 01 Feb 2006
Namdhari Sikh Information Book
Re: NamDhari response
Truth · 01 Feb 2006
I think Kulbir Singh just made an excellent point.
Kukas have many great qualities and would add a strong 1-2 million into the SIkh fold. Knowing thier rehit of keeping kesh, and vegetarianism, they would easily fi into the khalsa fold.
why don't some Gursikhs go talk to their current guru and try and persuade him to come back into the Sikhi fold?
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 01 Feb 2006
Dear Truth,
You are free to talk to my Guru about that if you wish. If my Guru comes here in Toronto Canada, we will glady accept your invitation of your joining your panth if you can presuade my Guru to say Satguru Ram Singh Ji is not a true Guru. If any of you can do that, then there is a posibility of joining you guys.... By the Year of 2012 or 2013 we will have to see where the Namdhari's stand.
Sat Sri Akal!
Re: NamDhari response
jugroop singh · 02 Feb 2006
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Dear NamDharis,
the thread has been very interesting - but one notable thing hasn't been discussed or mentioned by yourselves...
please give some information regarding Baba Raam Singh's letters - do you believe them to be false...what is the single/various NamDhari stance concerning these letters.
thanks in advance.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: NamDhari response
Bobby · 02 Feb 2006
Dead Man Walking,
Has you the namdhari satguru made a prediction that everyone will become a namdhari in 2012? Just curious as I remember similar things being said about 2001
Re: NamDhari response
Hmmmmm..... · 02 Feb 2006
Kulbir Singh says:
>Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj even to this day helps his Bhagats.
bhagath haeth narasingh bhaev!
kehi kabeer ko lakhai n paar
prehalaadh oudhhaarae anik baar!
siree sathigur suprasan kalajug hoe, raakhahu dhaas bhaatt kee laaj....................raakhahu dhaas bhaatt kee laaj!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 02 Feb 2006
Dear Juroop Singh,
Satguru Ram Singh Ji's letters are true. Read the below.
The Raiat-Namas of Satguru Ram Singh Ji
These selected Hukum namas (instructions to obey) have been issued by Guru Ram Singh Ji from Rangoon and written with blessing and for the benefit of all Sangats of Bhaini and for all Namdhari Sikhs.
From Guru Ram Singh to the Khalsa of Bhaini, Wahiguru ji Ka Khalsa, Sri Wahiguru ji ki Fateh.
Rise during the last watch (phase) of night (early in the morning) and taking a pot of water, for cleansing, go out into the fields to relieve yourself in the natural surroundings. On your return scour the pot twice and remove the clothes you were wearing in the fields while you are out, and clean your teeth, and have a bath, and recite the prescribed Nitnem (Simran 'meditation' and portion of 'bani.').
If you don't know these banis by heart you should learn them, every one should do this, including women both old and young, recite complete both Japji and Jap by memory and also Shabad Hazare of two Gurus. You must also learn Rahiras and Arti Sohila by heart.
All should lead a life of restraint and contentment. Offer praise to the Lord, throughout the day and night. Respect the daughter or sister of another man as you would your own; respect all the ladies as their relationships with you.
We have been told how we should preserve and respect the rights and privileges of the others (respect the human rights), that is our moral duty: 'Violating another's rights, 0 Nanak!, should be treated with the same abhorrence as a Muslim would feel for eating pig or Hindu for killing a cow'.
He who has received "Bhajan" and then does not recite (meditate on it) is as per (Hukam) instructions - will have his face blackened in this world and in the next. Whosoever does not do his daily prayers and meditations he will suffer there and here.
Let no one speak maliciously of another and practicing forgiveness towards the others, take no heed of what another may utter about you. Even the person who puts a hand to strike against you must be forgiven as the attacker. Satguru ji is your protector. Try not to take revenge; the Guru is on your side. Always beware not to show off your own good deeds and hide your goodness from the others.
Daily early in the morning gather at Asa di Var and in the afternoon/evening at Divans regularly, and participate in the proceedings at congregations
When a Jug (HAVAN) has to be performed purify the place where it is to be held by cleaning the place. Bring earthen vessels, which have not been used before and wash your feet before entering the Jug square. Then perform the Havan or Horn. Use wood from either the palah or ber tree; do not fan the fire by blowing on it with human breath. During the course of the Havan five officials should read the following Banis from the Scriptures, Chaupai, Japji, Jap, Chandi Chariter, Akal Ustat. (Later Satguru Hari Singh Ji gave instructions (Hukam) later on Chandi di Vaar and Ugar Danti should also be read). A sixth official should mean while pour incense made of ghee with Havan Samaghari on the fire and a seventh official should periodically sprinkle a few drops of water on the fire.
Do not let join and admit to religious assemblies any one who commits an evil deed such an adultery or theft, if the culprit happens to be a powerful person then all should pray to the Almighty Satguru together that he will be rendered unable to enter the congregation
But my understanding is limited; you may yourselves know all that need to be known. Let all stand reverently with (folding hands) palms joined before Satguru Ji and pray to Him, 'Sustain our faith 0 Lord'.
Always wear the approved breeches (Kachh). When taking off a Kachh withdraw one leg only and put it in the leg hole of another pair before withdrawing the second leg.
Never conceal an evil deed committed by another person.
Do not sell or barter a daughter or a sister.
Constantly repeat the Guru's name.
Never eat meat or drink alcoholic liquor.
Continue always in the fear of the Guru.
Bodily pains, epilepsy, attack by the evil spirits, injuries, which men receive at the hands of others, starvation and destitution etc. will all be removed by "bhajan" of God. It has been ordered by the Guru that the name of God is the remedy for all diseases. To read "bani" and repeating the name of God is productive and rewarding. 0 Khalsa ! be firm in your morning worship of the creator, not only one but all other agonies will be removed. Be assured of this truth, for the Guru Sahib has said that ailments can be removed by the worship of the creator.
Naam and Bani are priceless treasures; it is not possible to estimate their value. O Khalsa ! the Guru Sahib has been graciously pleased to confer upon you this Naam and Bani, therefore, be firm in reciting the Naam and Bani day and night, whether moving or working; always strive to step forwards, never backwards.
0 Khalsa ! if a relative dies, you should not mourn or grieve after him, but in keeping with your means perform, in the name of your departed relative, acts of charity, Bhog, Path, feeding and clothing of the brethren. Mourning and grieving is rebellion against God, and torturing the body without any advantage. I have also heard that a person mourned for his occasioned grief; the tears and nasal mucous of the mourners fall upon the soul of the departed, and makes him cry out "0 God, may someone else of the mourners man die, so that I may dwell in peace".
0 brethren of the Khalsa ! make use of the pure food and drink. 0 brethren it is the order of the Tenth Badshah ( Guru Gobind Singh) that eating with a person whose tenet of belief is not known or who does not practice the Gur-Mantar (mystic sectarian whisper) results in estranging the affection of God.
Without the Gur Mantar man is like a pig, the dog, the ass, the snake; for this reason I always impress upon you to receive Gur Mantar and leam Gur Bani by heart.
If a person being a Sikh sells barters (infanticide) his daughter, he should be boycotted.
We shall not always be Surrounded by Hornets; it is only for a short while, which will soon pass away.
If you want to see the actual handwritten Hukhamana's of Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji, please go to Sri Bhani Sahib which is located in the district of Luadaina.
Prior to Satguru Ram Singh Ji's banishment, this was quoted by them in these words "The Government will fasley declare me dead. The fire cannot burn me, and the water cannot drown me, I will come back in the same form. Do not believe that I am dead", came out to be true. Satguru Gobind Singh Ji had prohecised in 'Sau Sakhi' that Satguru Ram Singh Ji will for 250 years.
There is also a book called Satguru Belas which could also be found in Sri Bhani Sahib. That book gives details of Satguru Ram Singh Ji's Jeevan and Kutak's that they showed their Sikh's in that time.
Dear Bobby
I cannot really talk about the year 2012 and 2013 for any reason. Those years may be crucial years for the Namdhari's.
Sat Sri Akal.
Re: NamDhari response
LionKing (LK) · 02 Feb 2006
When a Jug (HAVAN) has to be performed purify the place where it is to be held by cleaning the place. Bring earthen vessels, which have not been used before and wash your feet before entering the Jug square. Then perform the Havan or Horn. Use wood from either the palah or ber tree; do not fan the fire by blowing on it with human breath. During the course of the Havan five officials should read the following Banis from the Scriptures, Chaupai, Japji, Jap, Chandi Chariter, Akal Ustat. (Later Satguru Hari Singh Ji gave instructions (Hukam) later on Chandi di Vaar and Ugar Danti should also be read).
From another forum (post by Bijla Singh) -
-----------------------
Tell me what exactly is the purpose for performing havan? What good does it do? putting ghee into the fire does nothing. I rather eat it and get some strength. Guru Gobind Singh Ji performed no havan to get Bhagautee. When pandits bragged about their pankhands, Guru Ji wanted to teach Gursikhs and the society a new lesson by proving those pandits wrong which He did. No goddess appeared. Rather, Guru Ji called His sword a "Chandi, and Durga". God is called "Bhagwaan" and His power is Bhaguatee. Guru Ji referred Waheguru as "Bhagaute", "Bhawant" and "Bhagwat". Guru Ji says:
[gurbani]ipRQm DrNo Bgvq ko DXwnw [
gRMQ skl pUrx kIXo Bgvq ikRpw pRswid ]ññ][/gurbani]
Notice how Guru Ji praised Waheguru in the beginning of His Bani and then again at the end. This is true for all of the Dasam Bani.
--------------------------
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 02 Feb 2006
Dear Lion King Paji,
You may do whatever you wish. I do not question the authority or hukham of my beloved Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji. Once a Satguru writes a hukham, a sikh must try to follow it the best he can.
I got a question for you all the Non Namdhari Sikh's. According to tradition and customs, all the Sikh Guru's including Guru Gobind Singh Ji and Guru Ram Singh Ji's wedding took place by walking around the sacred fire. Why is it that the non Namdhari Sikh's walk around the Sri Granth Sahib Ji instead of the sacred fire?
Sat Sri Akal!
Re: NamDhari response
... · 02 Feb 2006
where have you read that the Sikh Gurus' weddings took place around a fire? Do you have proof of it?
I'm still baffled by the fact that Kukas have NO problem with the fact that their langars are caste segregated. They ask castes and place people in different places according to those castes. This defeates the entire idea of langar.
Jagjit Singh once told a Gora Sikh that they were untouchables and that to be liberated they would have to be born again into the 4 varnas.
How can such casteist people call themselves Sikhs?
Re: NamDhari response
*********** · 02 Feb 2006
why have namdhari stopped responding to the questions asked by kulbir singh and others?
Re: NamDhari response
LionKing (LK) · 02 Feb 2006
***************************
Dear Dead Man Walking veer jeyo -
Guru Sahib has taught us to do that exactly- QUESTION. Guru Nanak Sahib Ji did it, Khalsa Panth did it when Guru Sahib was testing their faith (when lowering theri teer infront of a grave) - Khalsa Panth DID quesiton the Guru, and that's exactly what Siksh are meant to do in order to ensure we're not at the same place Guru Nanak Dev Ji tried pulling us out of (blind rituals, dogma etc)
You mention Anand Karj. Joga Singh is a perfect example
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 02 Feb 2006
Okay Mr. AUthor Singh Ji,
How did the weddings of the Guru's take place. Can you please tell me in details?
Do you have proof that such weddings never took place by walking around the fire?
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 02 Feb 2006
To Kulbir Singh please learn to respect the sacrifices the Namdhari's made. I suggest you to the United Kingdom and look up the actual history of the Namdhari's and Guru Ram Singh Ji. Please get your facts straight about history. Read this breif history below of Guru Ram Singh Ji just to give you the understand the sacrifices that the Namdharis made under the guide of Guru Ram Singh Ji.
The significance of the above mentioned GurBani isn't only because it is recorded on page 1218 in The Holy Aad Granth Sahib Praising The Akal Purakh Satguru, but it also has another historical significance. It was this very GurBani that Sri Satguru Balak Singh Ji were reciting when He first Gave/Received Darshan of Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji in 1841 A.D.
Satguru Ram Singh Ji, as Ordered by Sri Satguru Gobind Singh Ji, took Avatar in The House of Baba Jassa Singh Ji, a Carpenter, and Mata Sada Kaur Ji on Magh Sudi 5th 1872 Bikarmi in the village of Bhaini-Raian.
Satguruji's early career started in the military where He blessed Maharaja Ranjit Singh's Naunihal Regiment with His Pressence. Satguruji were very much devouted to The Almighty God that He would many times become very deeply absorbed in The Grace of God and reach 'Mast Birti'. It was believed, not to mention experienced, by the officials serving in the Army of Maharaja Ranjit Singh that whatever Satguruji says when He reaches The State of 'Mast' would become true, to the extent that even the Regiment that Satguruji worked in was called 'Bhagtan Di Regiment'(The Regiment of The Bhagat/Devouted One)
It so happened that once Satguruji reached The State of 'Mast' and Ordered that there would be english musical instruments playing inside Maharaja Ranjit Singh's Sheesh Mahel. The officials reported this incident to Maharaja Ranjit Singh. The maharaja was sorrowful, for it meant that his reign would come to an end and his enemies, the british would conquer his kingdom. However, in order to fullfill Satguruji's GurVaak(Words), the maharaja ordered for an english musical instrument to be played inside Sheesh Mahel and an official was sent to inform Satguruji that His Orders have been fullfilled. However, Satguruji further Ordered that not only Sheesh Mahel but the streets and markets would be buzzing with english musical instruments. The Message was delivered to Ranjit Singh and he once again ordered for english musical instruments to be played in the streets and markets. The scene was reported to Satguruji but this time Satguruji made it clear Ordering that consumption of liquor and meat and commitment of various other sins are not Deeds of The Khalsa and that the so called 'sikh-raj' would be demolished!
In 1841 A.D. Satguruji, along with His military friends were sent on an official mission to Pashaur. Their journey directed them to cross through the city of Hazro where Satguruji Heard about Sri Satguru Balak Singh Ji and decided to Pay a Visit in order to receive Satguru Balak Singh Ji's Darshan.
Satguruji were reciting the Prayer mentioned above when He First Gave/Received Darshan of Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji. Upon The Darshan of Satguru Ram Singh Ji, Satguru Balak Singh Ji stood up and embraced Him saying that He has been waiting for Thakurji(Satguru Ram Singh Ji). Satguru Balak Singh Ji Gave Gurmantar to Satguru Ram Singh Ji as well as about 25 of His military friends that were present with Him and after Seating Satguruji on The Throne, He bowed down at Satguru Ram Singh Ji's Feet according to The GurMaryada with a coconut and 5 Paise and Transferred The Gurgaddi which He received from Sri Satguru Gobind Singh Ji to Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji. Then He explained to the Sangat that it was Satguru Gobind Singh Ji Himself who Ordered that He would be back to retreive His Amanat(Belonging) in The Form of Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji.
After Retreiving His 'Belonging', Satguru Ram Singh Ji threw away His gun in the river Satluj and returned to Sri Bhaini Sahib to meditate on The Holy 'Naam' and allowed the englishmen to take full control of India, destroying any trace of Sikhism that remained within the people.
Then, in 1914 Bikarmi (1857 A.D.) on the day of Vaisakhi, The Sun finally Rose. Sri Satguruji revived The Khalsa Panth, Giving Amrit to Five Sikhs and Raised The Flag of Freedom.
His Holiness spread The Teachings of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji as well as the Maryada of Sri Satguru Gobind Singh Ji which was totally forgotten throughout Punjab. For the smallest trace of Sikhism found on the surface of this planet today, it is the Divine Kirpa(Blessing) of Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji Maharaj.
Satguruji's Teachings covered all aspects of life from the day a person is borned to the day he/she leaves the earthly body, and those who followed them found themselves to be in no less than heaven.
Many writers, even government officials who have had The Darshan(Sight) of Satguruji all admit that there was some kind of force that would draw a person towards Satguruji. Indeed there was some kind of force involved, a force that many described as:
With this force Satguruji Created 700,000 Sikhs within 10 years, the fastest growing population of Sikhs within the range of 10 years ever recorded. Preaching peacefully with The Weapon called 'Naam' which was feared by the englishmen perhaps as much as some fear the nuclear bomb today.
How lethal was 'Naam'? The following is a small sample:
Dr. Gokal Chand Narang wrote in one of his articles about his grandmother's brother who was an opium addict and would always be seen consuming the drug. This action went on for years but then one day when he appeared at Dr. Narang's house, no one could recognize him! He was wearing white traditional clothes with rosary around his neck with the Sidhi Dastaar(Straight Turban) on his head holding a Garwa and under his feet were the traditional wooden sandles. His appearance, to the family members resembled a priest from The Satjug! Upon questioning, however, they discovered that the transformation took place when he Recieved GurMantar From Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji and became a Kuka Sikh.
There were literally countless other incidents where Satguruji Blessed ordinary people with The Weapon of 'Naam' and transformed them into completely different beings, some say Saints. And those who possessed Naam, were not afraid to challenge neither the englishmen nor death; The True Nihangs, In The Khalsa's Uniform!
Other factors that attracted the public towards Satguruji were His Divine Teachings of pure, simple yet strict and peaceful living.
Satguruji ruled out against consumption of meat, liqour, addictive drugs, thievery and gangster behavior that disturbed peaceful living.
Satguruji prohibited selling, murdering and trading of female child as well as marriages at exceptionally young ages. Satguruji also allowed widows to remarry and rejected numerous other brahministic and muslim norms and rituals developed by people.
On the day of Pooranmashi in June of 1858 at the vllage of Siarhr, for the very first time, Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji gave Amrit to women and the word 'Kaur' was suffixed to their names regardless of them being of any caste or social level.
Satguru Ram Singh Ji were The Pioneer of The Sikh(Khalsa) Anand Maryada(Marriage Ceremony). On June 3rd 1863 at the village Khote, for the first time in The History of Sikhism, Anand Maryada was invented and performed for 6 couples. This caused the brahmin pundits to speak out against Satguruji and many reports were filed with the government. Even though this led the government into finding ways to restrict Satguruji within the range of Sri Bhaini Sahib, it did not have any effect on the Guru's Defined Anand Maryada.
Regarding the Authenticity of Khalsa Anand Maryada, it was also recorded by Giani Gian Singh on page 30-31 in his book called Bhupindranand:
Satguruji Taught His Sikhs to wake up at Amrit Vela(Before Sunrise), to take a bath from head to toe and Recite The Holy Naam. Performance of Shabad Kirtan as well as Reading of The Granth Sahibs were very much encouraged. Satguruji Ordered for old houses-of-worships to be reopened and after cleaning the Volumes of Granth Sahibs using His Dastaar(Turban), Taught His Sikhs to read The Granth Sahibs with their hands folded and to give Them utmost respect as Collections of Guru's Banis. The existence of Aad and Dasam Guru's Granth Sahibs today are exclusively The Kirpa(Blessings) of Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji Maharaj.
And The Teachings of Satguruji that can never be compromised were ofcourse His political involvements. Satguruji Ordered His Sikhs to boycott schools built by englishmen. His Sikhs were encouraged to use their own postal service which is now being called by many historians as 'Kuka Postal Service'! Satguruji Taught His Sikhs to stay away from englishmen's judicial systems and solve their conflicts using their own intelligence. Satguruji also encouraged His Sikhs to seek help from governments of other countries such as Nepal and Russia.
As Satguru Ram Singh Ji's reign was spreading throughout The Nation, so was the fear in the hearts of englishmen who ruled the government of India.
Yet they were unable to stop Satguruji for they did not have any hard evidence that would allow them to do so. As one would find in numerous government reports filed during the time, The Kukas were a great problem for the englishmen since they were not available to be used like the other sardars, hindus or muslims to the extent that the englishmen agreed that an attempt to convince a Kuka and make him a friend to the english was a futile effort, whereas the other sardars were viewed as 'the most loyal subjects of her majesty'!.
But the english were not ready to give up either. They tried every way possible such as trying to restrict Satguruji within the range of Sri Bhaini Sahib, but even then they could not stop Sikhism from growing.
Satguruji, very much like Sri Satguru Gobind Singhji, would many times talk about things that would be happening in the future and Tell His Sikhs what to do or expect.
During Hola Mahalla Celebration at Manawale, Satguruji again mentioned that He would be captured by the englishmen and that they would keep Him away from The Sikhs for a very long time. However, He also Told The Sikhs what to expect, that is - His Return.
Satguruji mentioned to the extent that it was impossible to sink Him in the sea nor was it possible to burn Him with fire! He Foretold The Sikhs about the rumors that would be spread by the englishmen about the death of their Guru, but The Sikhs should never believe it.
-*The rumor was spread in 1885 A.D. that Satguruji had left His Body. However, a document signed by Mr. Bernard, british chief commissioner in Burma, in August 1886 has been found stating that Satguruji had been sent to a 'remote' place in the country where no one had access to because in spite of being kept in strict imprisonment He had managed to keep contacts with the freedom fighters in India.*-
Ofcourse Gurbani cannot be wrong, and so Guru Ram Singh's Bani (words) were bound to come true eventually as well.
It all started after the struggle at Amritsar and the Namdhari Sikhs were watched more carefully than ever. Then in 1872, after The 80 Khalsas laid down their lives at Malerkotla, the british saw an opportunity.
January 18th 1872 A.D., the day when the second batch of Sikhs that remained imprisoned at Malerkotla were set to meet their demise, kernel Bailey was given an order by the commissioner to arrest Satguruji, even though they did not have any real evidence to link Satguruji with the incident at Malerkotla since Satguruji Himself sent Baba Lakha Singhji to inform the english officials in advance about what was going to happen!
This was no surprise to Satguruji Who had Discussed this with Sikhs numerous times before. On the particular day, Satguruji was ready at 4 A.M. wearing a black shawl waiting for the englishmen's arrest order. With Him, His Sevak(follower) Nanu Singh along with other Subas were arrested and transported to Allahbad.
Satguruji along with His Sikh Subas remained in Allahbad until midnight of March 9th 1872 before Satguruji and Nanu Singh were transported via train to Calcutta.
March 11th 1872: Satguruji and Nanu Singh were transported to Rangoon, Burma via sea.
March 16th 1872, They reached Rangoon and Satguruji along with Nanu Singh were imprisoned in a 2-story house located in a separate section of Rangoon's central jail. The government also provided a cow for milking and a well in the imprisonment area.
When the chief commissioner paid a visit to Satguruji at the jail, Guruji protested about being detained in a jail when he did not commit any crime. Satguruji also pointed out that the place was not well ventilated and was too hot for comfort.
The chief commissioner of Burma talked this over with the governer general of Calcutta and they decided to move Satguruji to the spacious bungalow where Badshah Bahadur Shah 'Zafar' was imprisoned until the emperor breathed his last in 1862.
After about 5 months in the separate section at the central jail, Satguruji were sent to the mentioned bungalow.
The bungalow where Satguruji were detained, was a sort of 'super-security-prison' of the time.
Roughly about 27 feet away from each side of the bungalow stood fences as high as 8 feet 6 inches. Outside the fence was a 5 feet wide moat. Leaving some space for patrolling purposes away from the moat was another layer of wall. Beyond this wall were huts occupied by the guards who were on patrol at practically all times. During day time were the black guards and the whites after sunset.
The bungalow had 2 stories. The ground floor was used for storage purposes and the second floor became The Gurdwara(Place of the Guru).
However, Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji would also many times sit in the veranda of the house on the ground floor which was built facing the market street and Grant Audience to The Kukas who dared their lives to Attain a 'Glimpse of God' and when needed transmit Ardas(letter/message to Guru) or receive Hukamnamas.
If it weren't for these Great GurSikhs, the above mentioned GurBani would have been left hanging and never fullfilled since there has never been any other Guru for whom The Sikhs had to get across seas to Meet Him.
After being detained for a while, Satguruji were also permitted to a sort of 'sight-seeing' where He would be accompanied by a sergeant traveling with Him in a buggy.
Thus whenever Satguruji would travel around in the buggy, The Singhs who were waiting in the way for Their Beloved King would get their words across to Satguruji in Punjabi which the sergeant could not understand.
Countless other methods were used by The Sikhs to communicate with Satguruji. Even some of the guards allowed The Sikhs to talk freely with Their Guru for a few moments. There was also a Faqir who lived near the bungalow and assisted in exchanging of Hukamnamas.
However, the government was also not oblivious to notice this. In fact it was a great concern to them that even after imposing such high levels of imprisonment and security, they still could not stop Sikhs, many of whom went to the extent of selling their lands and belongings in order to pay for traveling expenses, from crossing the sea and Meeting Their Guru.
What happened next is anyone's guess and the englishmen continued with their propaganda that The Akal was dead in 1885, even after the report mentioned on the previous page was found!
In 1891, Satguruji Met Sardar Alam Singh who wrote his story in a newspaper in 1921 about The Meeting with Guruji.
From 1914 onwards until today, Satguruji has been Granting Audience to many Namdhari Sikhs as well as non-Namdhari Indians and europeans, in the range of Germany to Russia, who have reported their stories to The Namdhari Darbar Sri Bhaini Sahib.
Though decades have passed since the last official Hukamnama was received, The Guru's Khalsa is confident that Baba Raam Singh, for whom Sri Satguru Gobind Singh Maharaj has Written:
The Guru who would spread Satjug in Kaljug. The Nar-Avatar who is defined as 'Siam Sundar' with physical appearance that remarkably resembled the previous 2 Satgur-Rai's(Emperor Gurus-Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib and Sri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib),
Will Fullfill His Promise and Return to His Beloved Country.
Re: NamDhari response
... · 02 Feb 2006
Dead Man Walking,
you wrote, "for the first time in The History of Sikhism, Anand Maryada was invented and performed for 6 couples. "
What are you talking about? Again you are concocting history. Bhai Daya Singh Rehitnama and others along with Prashan Uttar with Guru Gobind Singh (Sehajdhari one) all say that a Sikh must have marriage by Anand ceremony.
You asked for proof that Guru Sahib didn't go around a fire for marriage. Let's play by the rules. You stated as a fact that they did, I asked for ANY proof that this is correct. The onus is on you to show it.
You still are too ashamed to comment on the caste-system in place in Bhaini where low castes sit apart. Doesn't that defeat the whole point of langar? Why did Guru Sahib make Akbar sit with everyone else if your Baba is now separating them?
You also didn't comment on Jagjit Sinh's remark that white Sikhs will have to be re-born into the 4 varnas. Does that make any sense? Naam is powerful enough to turn the lowest into the highest yet your baba thinks these new Sikhs need to be born again?
Your Baba used to shake hands with Beant Sinh Chief Minister of Punjab and butcher of hundreds of thousands of Sikh youth. Your Baba is close to Congress politicians. Your Dera at Bhaini is guarded by CRPF and other Police Forces.
Finally you're still sticking to your story about Baba Ram Singh coming back. I remember in 1996 I talked to a Kuka on a bus and he was saying that the return is very close now. You people have some akhand jot and continuous paaths. Jagjit Baba keeps saying every so often that the return is not far now and comes up with random dates. Keep waiting folks. It's not happening.
You still haven't explained how if the jot of Guru Nanak is in Baba Ram Singh, that your present Baba also has the jot and is called "Satguru" it doesn't make any sense at all.
Re: NamDhari response
jaspreetsingh · 03 Feb 2006
jagjit is pakndi guru because i visited in 1988 to Bhaini(dara) i saw him playing badmenton with protecton of CRPF,PUNJAB POLICE.
if he is guru he should do shaster vidya . why he was under protecton
bere pena,srabee,sergum.
Re: NamDhari response
Angad Singh · 03 Feb 2006
Come on guys..get a life..
learn to mind your own business..look at your self..are you perfect..then why u pointing fingers at other..and trying to tell them you are right they are wrong..does it serve any purpose..no one is going to give in..
go use this time do sewa to simran..SLEEP man..wht do u get buy swearing and cussing at the naamdhari dude..
and as for avtar singh yah he is one guy who does kirtan on the taoos...how many of us have access to him..
also ..to some one who said keski is a kakkar..then can i ask you a simple question
we work on the principal that keski is a kakar..so that means kesh is not a kakar and i can cut my kesh and still be a practising amritdhari..suprising henna..2ndly there was nothing like a keski back then..they wore dumallas and dumallas have persion origins..so if Dumalla is a kakkar..no room for pointed/round turbans etc..then how come so many of the akj guys wore the pointed/round turbans..
like i said..take the best leave the rest.
guru ang sang!
angad singh
Re: NamDhari response
... · 03 Feb 2006
Angad Singh,
Your post was unfortunately completley useless.
Kukas have come forward with utter arrogance suggesting that they have the right history and in fact sent emails to individuals challenging and heckling them saying that the previous discussions were stopped because we ran out of "resources" to debate them.
The Kukas have no basis to say anything. Their principles make no sense and they should be ashamed of them (Caste System enforcement being case and point).
I don't expect the Kukas to admit their faults but at the very least they are exposed to the Sangat and maybe the honest-hearted amongst the Kukas will reflect on the truth and accept it.
Then you move on to Keski. Old rehitnamas say to wear a big dastaar over a smaller. Bhat Vehis say that Keski is the kakaar. If someone believes keski is a kakaar, you suggest,
" i can cut my kesh and still be a practising amritdhari..suprising henna.."
The only thing surprising here is your ignorance. Cutting or tampering with kesh is a bujjer kurehit. Of course you can't cut your kesh and be a practicing amrithdari. Wy would Guru Sahib say "don't cut your kesh it's a bujjer kurehit" and then say "keep your kesh, it's a kakaar". Well of course if you can't cut them, you have to keep them. It's redundant.
Next time, before posting, take a few moments to reflect on what's comin out of your brain.
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 03 Feb 2006
Mr. Author,
Have you gone to the Namdhari Sangat in Toronto to find out about if there is an existing caste sytem? Have you even talked to the Suba of the Namdhari Gurdawara about Sodh Marayda? If you have so many questions about the Namdhari's, I will say this again, please go to the Namdhari Gurdawara on Weston and Highway 7 road.
You had mentioned that Guru Ram Singh Ji is not going to return in the post. Read what I wrote earlier In 1891, Satguruji Met Sardar Alam Singh who wrote his story in a newspaper in 1921 about The Meeting with Guruji.
From 1914 onwards until today, Satguruji has been Granting Audience to many Namdhari Sikhs as well as non-Namdhari Indians and europeans, in the range of Germany to Russia, who have reported their stories to The Namdhari Darbar Sri Bhaini Sahib. Oh you are going to say that is fake or bull ****. I know people like you very well.
When Satguru Jagjit Singh Ji came in the year of 2000, we had so many non-Namdhari's show up the program every day to have darshan of Satguru Ji. Sur Sagar TV Ravinder Pannu would come regularly. I really suggest you straighten out the people who are non-Namdhari's coming to our program when Satguru Ji is there.
Again, this chat and conversation is not going to go anywhere. Since most of the Namdhari's are not in this post, I really cannot help you much. If you were to join the Namdhari Yahoo groups and posted such things, you would be getting so many answers to your questions and you will not be able to handle them. Since the majority on this forum are non Namdhari's I can give you much knowledge as I can. Do not get me wrong, the questions you have asked could be answered by the Namdhari Suba of the gurdawara or by joining Namdhari Yahoo Groups.
Also I would like to take this opporunity to wish guru Ram Singh Ji their Janam Din. guru Ram Singh Ji was born n Feb 3, 1816 Lack Lack Kusheya of Satguru Ji's 190th Janam Din.
Wahi Guru Jey Key Fateh!
Re: NamDhari response
Rashpal Singh · 03 Feb 2006
VaheguruJiKaKhalsa
VaheguruJiKiFateh
It would be interesting if someone could put up small translations of baba ram singhs letters.
VaheguruJiKaKhalsa
VaheguruJiKiFateh
Re: NamDhari response
... · 03 Feb 2006
"I really suggest you straighten out the people who are non-Namdhari's coming to our program when Satguru Ji is there. "
Dead Man Walking,
I dont' need to straighten anything out. It is a Punjabi village phenomena that whenever any "Sant" comes, they go to see the program. It's a spectacle people go to see. Check out Malton Gurdwara whenever any Sant comes. I don't know why you keep going to Ravinder Pannu. It's not as if he's a religious leader. If he went to your darbars, who cares?
You have no answers to any of these questions that have been asked. You are unable to refute any of the facts presented. Every single fact you brought forward and every argument has been thoroughly demolished. Look at the truth:
Shabad is Guru and the jot of Guru Nanak resides in one place (not two as Kukas seem to believe).
Hukams of Guru Gobind Singh jee cannot be altered. His orders for kirpans, nitnem and other rehits cannot be changed.
All puratan Sikhs and sources recognised Guru Granth Sahib as Satguru.
From an anti-establishment movement, look where the Kukas have gone. Rubbing shoulders with manmukh rulers in the Congress, even those who have butchered Sikhs, use of CRPF and Punjab Police at your deras, and overall acceptance of Hindustani domination.
There are so many other points, but like you said, Kukas are too brainwashed to recognise it.
At any rate, may Guru Sahib bless you with bibek budhi and may your karam open and let you recognise the true nature of Guru Nanak's jot.
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 03 Feb 2006
I thoght I would never say this Author Paji. Usually we are forbidden telling any miracle incidents that occure in our lives. I hope Akal Purkh Satguru Ram Singh Ji will forgive me telling this.
This is a story about my uncle who had a great vision of Satguru Ram Singh Ji. My uncle lives In Jalander he used to be a half Namdhari. My uncle worked as a farmer in the fields wearing a non namdhari pug. He was having doubts that Guru Ram Singh Ji was not even a true Guru. He told everyone in his family and friends that he will never wear white Namdhari pug unless Satguru Ram Singh Ji themselves gave them partakh darsan.
One day my uncle became so occupied with doing his field work when something caught his eye. He saw a divine figure with some sort radiant light. He realized that it was Satguru Ram Singh Ji who blessed him. Satguru Ram Singh Ji themselves told my uncle that he should wear a Bana and a Namdhari Pug. With those words all the doubts my uncle gone and fell to Satguru Ram Singh Ji's feet. My uncle described the details of his darshan with Satguru Ram Singh Ji to the curren Guru Jagjit Singh Ji in details at the Namdhari Darbar in Sri Bhani Sahib.
I also had my own personal experience near death experience when I was a cihld, so therefore I will not discuss anything about my near death experiences of what I saw and who I saw. This is the game of Akal Pukh and I leave it to him. You guys may consider the Granth Sahib your Guru but thanks to Satguru Ji themselves who saved me from my sickness. I will always be indebted to Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji and Sri Satguru Jagjit Singh Ji forever.
One thing I should tell you Author Paji, the path that are we living in was already been chosen for us by Akal Purkh and there is nothing you can do to change that. You cannot change my mind or neither can I change your mind about what is happening.
I like your last quote where you wrote" At any rate, may Guru Sahib bless you with bibek budhi and may your karam open and let you recognise the true nature of Guru Nanak's jot. Author Paji I have recognized it and so has my uncle.
Wahi Guru Jey Fateh
Re: NamDhari response
... · 03 Feb 2006
Dead Man Wallking,
The number of miracles involving Sri Guru Granth Sahib are countless and almost daily. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh has written some of his experiences where Guru Granth Sahib showed who the true Guru is.
You are right, you and I cannot convince each other. Not through this medium anyways.
What I would like is for you or any of your friends on the Kuka List to answer the questions that have been asked. Particularly a justification for Caste-Based langars.
Re: NamDhari response
js · 04 Feb 2006
Vaahegurooo ji ka khalsa, Vaahegurooo ji ki fatehhh
Ok at first i was not going to respond but this post has been going on forever.
I would like to share my own experiences. I am a dedicated sikh to my guru .. Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Guru ji was my guru in the past, he is my guru now and will always be.
From my dads side i have some namdhari blood running in my veins. Baba ram singh ji (same namdhari guru) had a sister named chanda kaur, she is my grandmothers grandma! I was completely shocked myself but i found this out when i went to my grandmas's pind (bhaini) to meet some of my family. Everyone on my dads side is all namdhari affiliated and including my late grandfather who passed away when my dad was 5 yrs of age.
I visited Bhaini sahib as a curiousity of what they do there, and to experience myself if all rumours are true or not. I went to visit my dads bhua ji, who isbelieve it or not between 110 - 120 yrs of age !! She is soo chardi kala and just sitting beside her, her love and tears were unmatchable. She lives at the asthram for elders at bhaini sahib (this is one of many great things they do there for elders). She reads from sanchia of guru granth sahib in her room without glasses !!
They do not do prakash of Sri guru granth sahib ji there, but rather their satguru ji, but they have the 'utmost respect' for guru granth sahib ji.
But lets face it sangat ji. We both do the exact same things. Read the same bani. Sing the same bani. Praise the one lord vaheguroo ji. Believe in the same sangat, seva, simran aspect of sikhi. The only different is we believe in guru granth sahib ji and they believe in a 17 guru lineage. We will never be able to change their minds and they cant change ours.
I talked to some namdhari singhs at bhaini sahib and they are so welcoming. They saw me in my blue dastaar and were like you look amaazing. They said we know you may not want to follow the namdhari tradition of sikhi but we are happy to say you are following something and to never back down. Bhaini sahib like any other holy place you can say you feel a different vibe there. I felt a really nice opening vibe, filled wit pyaar in the air. Everyone is hard at work with seva. Everyones remembering vaheguroo ji like 24/7!
For those who know me, guru kirpa naal i dont like affiliating myself in no particular jatha, caste or anything. I know i wont turn my back towards my guru but it doesnt hurt to go out and learn about everything ourselves. If we have to look at them another version of a religion like christianity, islam that we look at as equal ways reaching guru sahib.
Take the good stuff, leave the wrong back. Lets all just let live, and concentrate more on our own gursikhijeevan, which is sangat, seva and simran which both sides can admit to be true.
bhul chuk maph
Re: NamDhari response
RS · 06 Feb 2006
js veerji,
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!
What is naamdhari blood (which you claim you have)? What colour is it? How does it differ from normal blood?
Also, what is the "utmost" respect of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Mahraj mean? My version of "utmost" respect is that Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji be treated as KING OF KINGS. How can there be "utmost" respect if there is parkash of a living satguru over the eternal SATGURU!!
Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji......
Re: NamDhari response
js · 06 Feb 2006
RS veerji,
I understand your reasons for being like this. Rather than jumping back at me i was only explaining to "non-sikhs" that eventhough im coming frm a background of mainstream namdharis, i am following dhan dhan guru granth sahib jis way.
I have mentioned that they DO NOT prakash guru granth sahib ji at their main darbar at bhaini sahib. They do have utmost respect for bani as not only panj banian but they do many other banis as part of their nitnem. And like kulbir singh ji mentioned they still uphold the respect for puraatan raag kirtan.
Yes they do not understand that Guru Granth SAhib ji is our one and only guru but looking at us sikhs today they are upholding many of the sikh aspects that we are completely forgetting.
But like i said, i am a sikh of guru gobind sing ji and guru granth sahib ji is my guru. I will never forget that. But that does not mean i hate i hate everyone else. All are equal to me, if you think otherwise then i cant change that.
bhul chuk maph.
Re: NamDhari response
RS · 06 Feb 2006
There's no hate here. This has been a very healthy debate, probably the most informative about naamdharis I have come across. There's certainly things I have learnt from this discussion and what is ironic is my grandfather was a naamdhari from East Africa.
I would be lieing to you if I said my grandfather was not an influence in my life. I grew up seeing him do his nit-nem and waking up at amrit-vela. Yes, you are right there are banis which the strict naamdharis do, which many GurSikhs are not doing. There is also some strong rehat within naamdharis.
However, there is a lot of confusion when it comes to naamdharis discussing Sikh history and I seem to remember new and new naamdharis based theories coming up everytime my grandfather met up with relatives. There are odd practices of astrology and other things such as poojas in mandirs (Neasden Temple and the Swami Naryan Jatha have a number of naamdhari followers).
To me my Guru (Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji) is complete. To a naamdhari my Guru is incomplete.
Like someone said earlier naamdharis are disciples of their Guru and Sikhs are disciples of their Guru.
I see it like that. Each to their own. God bless the naamdharis....
Re: NamDhari response
js · 06 Feb 2006
hunji veerji
that is the point i was trying to get to "Like someone said earlier naamdharis are disciples of their Guru and Sikhs are disciples of their Guru.
I see it like that. Each to their own. God bless the naamdharis...."
challo .. vahegurooo bless everyone wit gursikhijeevan wit lots of simran, seva and sangat.
bhul chuk maph!
Re: NamDhari response
jugroop singh · 08 Feb 2006
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Dear 'Dead Man Walking',
pls give us your views about 'those' letters - the ones where Baba Raam Singh denied being the SatGuru. i wish to know how NamDharis view these letters...
also i'm afraid that someone needs to break-up this wishy-washy 'lets learn to love our NamDhari brothers' thing. personally, i don't love them or hate them. i see no difference between them and RadhaSoamis i.e. i think they're extremely deluded. the fact that they join Nagar Kirtan's in honour of a SatGuru they do not believe is a SatGuru sums it all up. this is especially sad when one considers the fact that this group of NirGuray have in the past ripped Angs from Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji - that's how much they respect Maharaaj Sahib.
if i have been misinformed about the Ang-ripping pls can the NamDharis correct me.
ps - i also believe that once 'satguru' jagjit 'singh' passes away, there will probably be a a split where atleast two 'satgurus' emerge, splitting the followers into two sects. then theywill be even more similar to RadhaSoamis.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 09 Feb 2006
Dear Jugroop Singh Ji,
Answer to Satguru Ram Singh Ji not claiming themselves to be Satguru is found in the below information.
One of the many criticisms in modern times about Sikhism is regarding Satguru Ram Singh Ji's Hukamnama in which He Praises His Sikhs and Humbly Calls Himself not a Guru.
Though it is True that Sri Satguru Ji Mentioned in a Hukamnama that He's not a Guru, its meanings are not being interpreted correctly by the singh sabhas who try to use this as a point to deny the True Guruship.
It is a shame indeed for the singh sabha writers who have not only mistranslated The Sacred Hukamnamas, but even added outrageous lies such as Satguru Ram Singh Ji refering to Aad Granth Sahib as 'Satguru' etc. These are pure fabrications and CANNOT be thought of as reliable. Authentic Hukamnamas of Satguru Ram Singh Ji have been compiled into a Granth and may be obtained from either The Namdhari Darbar, Sri Bhaini Sahib or Namdhari Sangat world-wide.
In order to interpret Guruji's Words in the same way that the singh sabha leaders are trying to fool its devoutees, the following question must first be answered:
Has there been ANY Satguru Who Calls Himself a Guru?
The answer is, ofcourse, NONE.
What did Satguruji mean by that sentence and what was He trying to accomplish? The answer to this question may lie in the Bani of Sri Satguru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaj:
Regarding one's self to be lower than others appears to be a uniform fashion with which all the Satgurus have been teaching The Sikhs not to count themselves as higher beings. Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji Maharaj also wrote in His Hukamnama Ordering His Sikhs to always hide their Good Deeds.
The same method was also Preached by Sri Satguru Gobind Singh Ji who did not include His name in His GurBani - Chandi Di Vaar. But ended the counts of Satgurus at Sri Satguru Teghbahader Sahib Ji.
Since there has never been an incident where any of the Gurus ever proclaimed themselves as Gurus it becomes clearly pointless for the singh sabha and its followers to continue with their meaningless criticism of an Akal Purakh Satguru as warned by the Holy Sikh Scriptures mentioned on the preceeding page.
The battle between Truth and Falsehood has been around for as long as anyone could remember, and sometimes looks like a never-ending battle of Good versus Evil.
Most of the fabrications and distortions of Sikh History in existence today, during this age of 'information', are due to 2 major reasons:
1. Sincere unknowingsness of the truth.
2. An effort by a group of people to hold their social positions and to control people.
The first reason, many times, is infact the result of the second, and together they form a chain that cannot be easily broken unless the truth is told. The most practical example is perhaps how the Singh Sabha Movement, with support of british-controlled government, fabricated Banis as well as Sakhis(history of Sikh Gurus) in order to control the people of Punjab.
The Following are a few of the major fabrications/misunderstandings that are found today in various medias:
I hope this answers your question without being disrciminiative or influencing anyone in a negative way.
Wahi Guru Jey Key Fateh!
Re: NamDhari response
Raja Hindustani · 09 Feb 2006
Jugroop singh ji,
Has all Guru ji s declared that they were the Guru? Also Sri Adi Granth Sahib ji mentions that "Nirjeeo Pujae Marha Sareveh Sab Birthi Ghal Gavave". Nirjeeo means lifeless, Can you explain the meaning of this tuk?
Sri Adi Granth Sahib is readily available in 4 saincheeya (volumes), published by SGPC. Different Banis are available in different combinations as a unit, Gutka. What do you think about these in context of "ripped ang" remark? Anyway, what is your opinion abt the Bani on CD. By the way, who was the first one to get Sri Adi Granth Sahib Published in a printing press?
Regarding the split, What do you have to say about the actions of sons of Guru Nanak Devji, Guiru Angad Dev ji, Guru Amardas ji ......
My dear,
I consider that the main issue is concerned with Dasam Patshah handing over Gurgaddi to Scripture or Human Guru.
First we need to establish that Guru Gobind Singh ji had compelling reasons to sit alive on his burning pyre. Is anyone in the world can justify it? If yes, please, come forward, we are waiting for you.
Next, He had compelling reasons to change the already existing tradition of Human Guru. Pls come forward to enlighten us.
Let us discuss these basic issues first. Pls back up your point of view with relevant references. Also pls mention the shalokas, which clarifies that Guru is Sri Adi Granth Sahib.
Lets us start with Gurbani,
"Satgur Bani Sabad Sunaye, eh Jag Hareya Satgur Bhaye"
Faridkoti teeka explains it as - By using his Bani, Satguru narrates God's Shabad (Hukam). So this world is in high spirits if Satguru likes it to be.
Which clearly depicts the distinction among Staguru, Bani & Shabad. What do you have to say about it?
Sat Ari Akal
[%sig%]
Re: NamDhari response
... · 09 Feb 2006
All Hukumnamas by the Satgurus began "Sri Guru jee kee Aggyaa hai...." and had their nishaan on it. No Guru ever claimed to not be the real Guru.
Re: NamDhari response
Duki · 09 Feb 2006
i NEED TO MAKE SOME FACTS CLEAR i WAS A NEMDHARI AND INFACT VERY CLOSE TO TEH NAMDHARI LEADERSHIP BUT SADLY NEED TO SAY THE SPRITUALNESS HAS GONE AND NAMDHARI PANTH IS ONLY A BUSINESS NOW
SATGURU RAM SINGH JI WAS THE ONLY NAMDHARI SIKH WHO DID POSITIVE THINGS FOR THE SIKH COMMUNITY AND INDIA BUT FROM THERE ON HIS NEPHEWS JUST USED HIS NAME FOR THEIR OWN BENEFIT
SATGURE RAM SINGH'S NAME AS ALL BUT DISPEARRED AND HIS NEPHEWS AND THEIR CHILDREN ARE NOW MORE KEEN TO PROMOTE THEIR OWN NAME
IT IS SAD BUT TEH FACT IS THERE IS NO LEADERSHIP AND AFTER THE PASSING OF THE CURRENT NAMDHAIR LEADER IAM AFRAID TO SAY THERE WILL BE BLOOD AND AT LEAST TWO PEOPLE CLAIMING TO BE NAMDHARIO GURU'S OR IN OTHER WORDS BUSINESS MANAGERS WHO WILL DEMAND 10% OF THEIR INCOME WITH FORCE
Re: NamDhari response
Duki · 09 Feb 2006
hOW TRU i FULLY SUPPORT BEING AN EX- NAMDHARI
I WAS DISGUSETED TO LEARN THAT SODI'S AND NAMDHARI LEADER HAD THEIR OWN KITCHENS AND THEY DO NOT UNDERSTAND THE PRINCIPLE OF LANGER
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 09 Feb 2006
Dear Author Duki,
It is easy to critisize the Namdhari community very easily without understand the Non-Namdhari Sikhs. I do not want to stoop at your level because if I did, I would be doing Nindya which is against Guru Sahiba's hukham and it clearly talks about Nindaya in the Gurbani. I could bring up so many incidents about non-namdhari making profits in other gurdawara's. I suggest we not go to this deep about the Sikhi sect because the things that I say are going to sound so bitter and make you angry so therefore whatever remarks you made about the Namdhari's above I will forgive you and I will not do Nindaya in return. It seems like you do not want to have a respecful conversation instead you want to bash the Namdhari's.
Since you claim yourself to be a Ex-Namdhari, it shows what kind of person you are. To me, I have doubts in your loyalty in the Sikh Religion all together. To me you are a disgrace to the Sikh community all toether. When things become corrupted in the non-namdhari community where will your loyalty be then? are you going convert into Radawami? Are you going to convert to a Muslim? Or are you going to convert to a Hindu? If you cannot say anything positve about other peoples beliefs, I suggest you not say anything at all.
I am not saying that the Namdhari religion is a perfect religion. Neither are the non-Namdharis either. Every religion in the world to my understanding has some sort of flaws. Honestly even talking to you is compeletely waste of my time. I hope as a ex-Namdhari you will start to read Gurbani more often then doing Nindaya. That is for you own welfare.
Hear what Kabir says to God's faithful followers:
" All other wealth must decay.
All must relinguish this wordly existence
When God sends the call to depart:
(Bhagat Kabir- Sri Adi Granth)
Wihtout a Guru to guide us, we alk in the darkness,
Without the guru, we have no discernment.
The Shabad of the Sat-Guru is light,
His words light leads to the truth.
There death has now sway,
His light is merged into Light.
Thou art our gurbhai, Thou art wise,
Thou blesses the woth with union
Through the Teaching of the true Guru,
Exalated by Thy Name, O Boundless Being.
That to which the deathless Shabad of the Guru
Bears enternal witness
Is the asylum of immortality.
By His Will, all is created,
Through his Will, all life pulsates;
Under his Will, death has rulership
Over all creation and all life.
By his Will also repose the blessed.
In His Enternal truth;
Omnipresent, Omnipetent, is His Will.
Such, O Nanak, is the predicament of Man.
(Sri Rag Asa- Sri Adi Granth Sahib Ji)
Jug, Jug Guru Dhare Avtara"
By his own command, and embodiment (Word),
God Manifested Himself in millions of forms (Avtaars).
Fusing the five elements of air, water, fire, earth and sky together,
He began the drama of universe.
He created the innumerable living creatures who inhabit the waters, lands treats and mountains.
God is one, and He is capable of creating millions of worlds in the twinkling of an eye.
No one can estimate the immensity of Nature,
Who can then know their greatness of its Creator?
God is limitless and infinite, and vastness of God's Creation is endless.
And the Guru's sovereignty is and will be for all Ages.
(Bhai Gurdas Jee)
In Dasham Granth Guru Gobind Singh Ji stated,
O Saints do understand well
I have taken birth Only for the mission
To flourish religion, uplift the sages and uproot the wicked.
(Bachiatar Natak- Sri Dasham Granth)
Guru Gobin Singh was omnisicient and made many prophecies which have come out to be true. In reply to a question by one of his close disciples Aalm Singh, he prochesied as follows:
When I desent the eleventh time,
only a few might understand me,
The Sikh community is my crop,
I will look after it then.
(Bhai Santokh Singh Ji-Suraj Prakash Page 5642)
Wahi Guru Jey Key Fateh!
Re: NamDhari response
Duki · 10 Feb 2006
My Veerji you sound like a Namdhari to me and do not want to hear any critism of the Pant. We should be able to debate openly the downfalls of the pant to ensure what Guru Ram singh ji did is adered and kept at least by the Guru Sikhs although the present Namdhari Guru wants to eliminate the name of Guru Ram Sugh ji.
It is time you came out of your tunnel vision thinking. Secondly Iam a Sikh and will remain a Sikh. Your points on conversions are a disgrace. Namdhari is a fantical sect is on its way out.
In this society you can choice to believe in what one is happy with and your points on loyality are without foundation. If you see with your own eyes the corruption one has the right to question.
Re: NamDhari response
Admin - Akaal Images · 10 Feb 2006
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Veers 'Dead man walking',
you wrote, regarding 'Gurus' not calling themselves 'Guru':
"Has there been ANY Satguru Who Calls Himself a Guru?
The answer is, ofcourse, NONE...there has never been an incident where any of the Gurus ever proclaimed themselves as Gurus"
your response is pointless; you have knowingly or unknowingly avoided the issue.
Siree Guru Nanak Sahib Ji has never or will never need to praise Himself since His Jyot, which resides within Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji, is the very form of VahiGuru...VahiGuru alone knows VahiGuru's praises.
however, please understand that proceeding SatGurus naturally praised SatGuru Nanak Sahib Ji which was the very Jyot working within them. despite the fact they did this drenched in humility for Sikhs it is irrelevant which SatGuru was praising which previous SatGuru because they are One - One Jyot = One SatGuru. that is the only way to understand this conundrum. Sire Guru Sahib Ji alone knows Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Praises.
now to return to the central issue - in order to deal with the issue you have raised, it is better to approach the problem in the following way:
> Did any of the SatGurus, from Siree Guru Nanak Sahib Ji to Siree Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Ji, DENY that they were the SatGuru?
by your own admission, Baba Raam Singh did which marks him out as 'different'. now, why would the 'SatGuru of the Sikhs' all of a sudden start to deny who he was?
show us one GurShabad from GurBani where any of the SatGurus reject their position as SatGuru...and no you cannot take Shabads were SatGuru Sahib Ji is showing His utter humility and referring to himself as 'dust', 'a sinner', 'a dog within VahiGuru's Darbaar', etc. that IS NOT rejection of the GurGaddi.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: NamDhari response
jugroop singh · 10 Feb 2006
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Veer 'Raja Hindustani' Jio,
you wrote:
"Sri Adi Granth Sahib is readily available in 4 saincheeya (volumes), published by SGPC. Different Banis are available in different combinations as a unit, Gutka. What do you think about these in context of "ripped ang" remark? Anyway, what is your opinion abt the Bani on CD. By the way, who was the first one to get Sri Adi Granth Sahib Published in a printing press"
so firstly i take it that the Ang-ripping did take place and that NamDharis are guilty of desecrating MahaRaj Sahib's Swaroop. if this wasn't the case i guess lots of NamDharis would have flooded this message board with denials. instead, we have you launching into defensive mode instead of denying or defending the actual charges made. anyhow, lets look at the veracity of the points you've generated...
firstly producing Saincheeya or Gutkae of GurBani is not the same as taking the INTACT AND FULLY ASSEMBLED Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji and ripping pages from it here and there. there is no element of damaging something sacred and tearing apart or desecrating it. anyone who thinks these things are even in the same ball-park is frankly very silly.
likewise regarding putting GurBani onto CD's: please grow-up and atleast use intelligent arguments. regarding printing-presses, you have a point here Veer Ji; i think most printing-presses are not or have never been supervised adequately to ensure SatKaar is maintained. ideally, the Panth would only allow RehitVaan GurSikhs to hand-write Swaroops of Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji. i think the Jews do this with their Torah but i could be wrong...maybe they've also given into 'modern methods'. however, i'm beginning to digress...
You also wrote:
"Regarding the split, What do you have to say about the actions of sons of Guru Nanak Devji, Guiru Angad Dev ji, Guru Amardas ji ......"
Veer Ji, what's your point? i'm not sure i fully understand what you are getting at here so please elaborate; i'm not going to assume you mean one thing when you could be alluding to something else completely.
You also wrote:
"I consider that the main issue is concerned with Dasam Patshah handing over Gurgaddi to Scripture or Human Guru"
you see this is the problem with people such as yourselves and others such as RadhaSoamis - this fixation with a HUMAN Guru which is not backed-up by GurBani. let me bounce this point back at you - you all like using the term Dehdhari, Human Guru etc. do you think SatGuru Sahib in His Infinite Brahm Gyaan would not have de-lineated regarding your pet concept by SPELLING-OUT the need for a PHYSICAL SatGuru?...
instead, SatGuru Sahib Ji does the reverse on many occasions, placing the The GurShabad upon the highest pedestal. now you tell us where the body has been placed upon some sort of pedestal, as of 'utmost importance' despite the parallel importance of The GurShabad. do you not think that SatGuru Sahib Ji would discuss within GurBani the fact that the Shabad must be expressed through a human being to qualify as 'SatGuru'?
i find this concept completely dualisitic and alien to GurMat...and all the while the DehDhari 'Gurus' continue harping on and on about it while anyone who does Paath or Simran with even a little concentration realises that Siree Guru Sahib Ji is getting closer to them in the form of their Surti/Consciousness joining with the GurShabad i.e. SatGuru.
You wrote:
"Satgur Bani Sabad Sunaye, eh Jag Hareya Satgur Bhaye...
Faridkoti teeka explains it as - By using his Bani, Satguru narrates God's Shabad (Hukam). So this world is in high spirits if Satguru likes it to be".
well, keeping in mind what i just wrote, let's bounce this issue back off you. please tell us what you think the following Panktis mean:
bani guru guru hai banee , vich banee anmrit sarae
gurbani kehai sevak jun manai , purutakh guru nistharae
tell me, why is SatGuru Ji saying that by surrendering to the Hukams of GurBani The Guru will save His Sevaks IN PERSON? is this not Siree Guru Sahib Ji also LITERALLY saying that The Guru and The GurBani are One!? or are you saying that only when the Hukams are followed will the 'Human Guru' come and use his GROSS MATERIAL BODY to do something a little extra so that the Sevak can be saved...!?
the issue can be summed-up as follows: NamDharis rigidly believe that SatGuru Sahib Ji must have a human form to have any effect upon this material plane of existence. anyone even with a little sharda in SatGuru Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji understands how false this belief is.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 10 Feb 2006
Dear Dukhi,
I do not care what religion you choose that will make you happy. Read my last post very carefully. I did mention in my last post about corruption in the non-Namdhari community which I did not want to discuss about.
Corruption is everywhere my friend. I could careless what another Namdhari does as along as it does not effect my Bani and Nam Simron. If you are a ex-Namdhari you must be aware of Guru Ram Singh Ji's words in the 1800s. Guru Ram Singh Ji quoted " My Sikh's please do any bad deeds that will have a bad name for the panth. Your reputation is not going to be ruinied, it will be my reputation. People will say the word Guru Ram Singh Ji's Sikh are corrupted".
Dukhi regardless of all the corruption that is going on anywhere or even in the Namdhari Panth, Ram Singh Ji is aware of it. If people are taking advantage of Guru Jagjit Singh Ji, let them because at the end, it is their own downfall is going to be near. There have been few Singhs in Sri Bhani Sahib that were corrupted and Guru Jagjit Singh Ji removed them. We do nam simron for ourselves not for others. Do not think that I do not see corruption, I see it very well from all different faiths. Unlike others, these corruptions were meant to happen in this Yug of Kaliyug. Dukhi Ji if this was the Satyug obviously there will not be any corruption where truth prevails.
You may question corruption many times as you want, but you are not going to get anywhere by questioning it. As a Sikh your duty is to pray to the all mighty akal purkh that whatever is happening in this world right now, let all the bad deeds and sins disappear.
Wahi Guru Jey Key Fateh!
Re: NamDhari response
Admin - Akaal Images · 10 Feb 2006
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Veer 'dead man walking'
your most recent post does nothing to prove the burning need for a human 'Guru' nor does it refute the idea of Shabad as Guru and Guru as Shabad.
i did enjoy reading the following from the Vaar of Bhai Gurdaas Ji that you quoted:
"Through the Teaching of the true Guru,
Exalated by Thy Name, O Boundless Being.
That to which the DEATHLESS SHABAD of the Guru
Bears enternal witness
Is the asylum of immortality"
so, thanks for pointing-out to us that The Shabad is beyond birth and death...unlike the human body. whoops, that indirectly debunks some of the stuff you mentioned in earlier posts!
You also wrote:
"I am not saying that the Namdhari religion is a perfect religion. Neither are the non-Namdharis either. EVERY RELIGION in the world to my understanding has some sort of flaws".
although by your own admission the NamDharis may not have access to 'the perfect religion', with which i would agree, i request that you do not foist such ideas upon GurMat Dharam. you quoted Bhai Gurdaas Ji earlier; i suggest you look at some of his other Vaars very closely in order to understand the very purpose for which SatGuru Nanak Sahib Ji appeared in KaalJug.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: NamDhari response
help · 12 Feb 2006
16 year old harjeet singh seems to be the only person to have said anything worth while.
I have a question?
What is a Sikh??
I endeavour to be a true sikh but know I am not.... therefore i would never even think of saying anyone is not a sikh or is a sikh.
also should we not have any communication with any human being who is a non- "sikh"??
All of us were created by akhal purakh, we are all sparks of the divine flame, Akhal purakh resides in all of us so how can we hate or judge anyone?
I love you all! lol
Re: NamDhari response
Raja Hindustani · 13 Feb 2006
Dear Jugrop Singh ji,
I'll come to other questions later, first let us talk abt Bani mentioned in Sri Adi Granth Sahib.
You have quoted "Bani Guru.................."
Despite writing it, Guru Ramdas ji gave Gurgaddi to another human Guru! Do you want to say that Guruji said one thing & did exactly the opposite?
He has also written "Nirjeeo Pujae Marha Sarevae, Sab Birthi Ghaal Gavave" means "Those who pray lifeless, serve graves, waste their entire effort." Lifeless means anything which is not a living being. We may respect the scripture, gets enlightened by reading it and may address it as Guru, but it is still not a living entity.
Can you explain this paradox ? If yes, pls enlighten me.
Do you realy think that "Pratakh Guru" as mentioned in "Bani Guru........" is addressing Sri Adi Granth Sahib, which was not even compiled by that time.
Not embodied Guru.
To proove that Creator & creation are equal, you say that embodiment of Guru is futile. My dear, the task of writing/ compiling Bani in Sri Adi Granth Sahib was done by Guruji in human form itself.
By the way, Japji Sahib includes "Pawan Guru Pani Pita Mata Dharat Mehat". So accordingly, do you also consider Pawan as your Guru?
I'll realy appericiate if we can keep our discussion to the point.
Many Thanks
Raja
Re: NamDhari response
Harpreet Singh · 13 Feb 2006
True Akal Purakh jot is in all, low caste to medium caste to high caste. That's why GuruJi showed us that langer and be eaten together. Not seperate langer for low-caste.
Re: NamDhari response
Admin - Akaal Images · 14 Feb 2006
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Veer 'Raja Hindustani' Jee,
You wrote:
'Despite writing it, Guru Ramdas ji gave Gurgaddi to another human Guru! Do you want to say that Guruji said one thing & did exactly the opposite?'
what kind of logic is this? where did i say that GurGaddi passing to another 'human' SatGuru in the past nullifies the concept of Shabad Guru as SatGuru?! you have imposed a completely illogical idea regarding my point.
You also wrote:
'He has also written "Nirjeeo Pujae Marha Sarevae, Sab Birthi Ghaal Gavave" means "Those who pray lifeless, serve graves, waste their entire effort." Lifeless means anything which is not a living being. We may respect the scripture, gets enlightened by reading it and may address it as Guru, but it is still not a living entity. Can you explain this paradox ? If yes, pls enlighten me'.
i may not be able to satisfy you but i'll give it a bash...a stone idol or a grave denotes that someone is worshipping something other than Nirankar - The Formless. how can a stone save anyone; how can worshipping at the grave of a dead person save anyone? however, Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the lighthouse of the universe because Maharaj Sahib relates to human beings the Divine Knowledge of All-Pervading Nirankar. to worship Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji is to worship VahiGuru. perhaps this is why Siree Guru Sahib Ji in His human form did not encourage portraiture.
to be frank, i do not expect anyone who currently believes in a Human 'Guru' to understand that all power lies within the GurShabad. i think this is because it is easier for someone to develop sharda in a human than GurBani which is why Santdom/Gurudom is currently so prevalent.
You also wrote:
"Do you realy think that "Pratakh Guru" as mentioned in "Bani Guru........" is addressing Sri Adi Granth Sahib, which was not even compiled by that time.
Not embodied Guru."
from the Pothis that Siree Guru Nanak Sahib Ji compiled through to the later Gurus, GurBani was something which was continuously being recorded and collected. my point does not concern itself with whether or not Siree Adi Granth Sahib had been compiled. GurBani existed before this point.
You also wrote:
"To proove that Creator & creation are equal, you say that embodiment of Guru is futile. My dear, the task of writing/ compiling Bani in Sri Adi Granth Sahib was done by Guruji in human form itself."
again, you have a strange sense of logic when you tell me GurBani was written by a human. how does this detract from GurShabad as Eternal Unchanging Guru?
You also wrote:
"By the way, Japji Sahib includes "Pawan Guru Pani Pita Mata Dharat Mehat". So accordingly, do you also consider Pawan as your Guru?"
what kind of childish point is this! my interpretation of this Pankti is that the atmoshphere/air, the very life-breath of this world that makes any life possible is our Guru...that is the importance of SatGuru - without Guru there can be no life - so, all is barren, dead and lifeless without SatGuru. water is akin to the sperm of the father...the water that inseminates the womb of mother earth, giving rise to all earthly creation; and so the Dharamsal of earth was created and positioned as a plane upon which through good Karam the human form is obtained and a hence a chance to merge with VahiGuru is there for the taking.
you have simply tried to impose an innappropriately 'literal' interpretation here knowing full well that this Salok is metaphorical. for instance lets understand the next line of the Salok with your method: if day and night are really nurses, they probably work long hours for short wages in hospitals and always go on strikes to get higher pay!
please use useful arguments to make your point. issues have been raised including the following:
> NamDharis practice caste-distinction regarding Langar
> NamDharis have ripped Angs from Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji in the past
> Baba Raam Singh did something which no other SatGuru had done before him and denied the GurGaddi that was allegedly passed to him stating that 'i am not the Guru'.
please let's discuss these issues now. the issue of Human and GurShabad SatGuru has been discussed very much; i am sure people reading this thread have made up their minds either way.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: NamDhari response
jugroop singh · 14 Feb 2006
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
apologies about the alternate 'Akaal Images' id; i keep using it by accident! have sorted the problem now.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: NamDhari response
Jagjit Matharu · 14 Feb 2006
You cannot blame Namdharis for trying to pick on the most pathetic points to justify their existence. These silly justifications have come from Jagjit, he sells these lies to the brainwashed Namdhari who justifies to himself that it is the truth.
Wake Up!!!
Lies on to of lies to justify the existence of Namdharis, come on.......isnt it time you burst your bubble Mr Namdhari?
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 14 Feb 2006
Dear Jagjit Singh Ji Matharu,
Your last post was just pointless. I have not idea what you are trying improve by saying that. I got a question of my own since there are alot people questioning the non-Namdharis.
In one of my posts I wrote this below:
Sri Gurpartap Suraj(Suraj Parkash): Written by Kavi Bhai Santokh Singhji in 1843 A.D. He has infact written that it was the Eighth Avatar of Guru Nanak, Sri Guru Harkrishan Sahib Ji, who once attempted to give Gurgaddi to Sri Aad Granth Sahib but It was rejected by The Sikhs of the time who requested Him that people such as Dhirmal would all sit with a Bir(Volume) in their hands and fabricate Its translations in order to control people.
If the non-namdhari sikhs believe in Kavi Bhai Santokh Singh Ji's writting, you would also understand why the Namdhari's do not believe in the Granth Sahib as the Guru. Why would Guru Gobind Singh Ji even give the Gurgadi to Sri Aad Granth Sahib when Sri Harkrishan Ji did not give the Gurgadi to Sri Adath Granth Sahib Ji? Do the Non-Namdhari Sikhs actually believe that there would not be any fabrications after Guru Gobind Singh Ji?
Anyways Kavi Bhai Santokh Singh Ji's writtings have made a good point in the debate of GurShip.
Wahi Guru Jey Key Fateh!
Re: NamDhari response
... · 14 Feb 2006
If we take the story from Kavi Santokh Singh to be true (doesn't make much sense as it is up to the Guru to chose his successor and not up to the Sikhs), it still supports the contention that a Granth can be Guru. Kukas make a big argument that a Granth can never be a Guru. You have disproven your own arguments here by saying Guru Harkrishan Sahib wanted Adi Granth to be Guru during his time.
Guru Hargobind Sahib didn't give the gaddi to his own son, Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib, but later on, Guru Har Krishan Sahib did. In the same way, if the story is true, just because it wasn't given by Guru Harkrishan Sahib when he could have, doesn't mean Guru Gobind Singh didn't.
Guru Granth Sahib was made Guru by Guru Gobind Singh. So many sources say it. How much extraneous material has been added? Is it a constant problem now? Of course not.
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 14 Feb 2006
Dear Author Ji,
I am not saying that it is up to the Sikhs who their next Guru is going to be. Obviously it is the Guru's decision. I just do not think you understand the point here. The point is Sri HarKrishan did not pass the gurgadi to the Granth Sahib because they wanted to see the reaction of what the gursikhs think and they very well knew that this world will not survive with out a Guru.
Let me ask you a few questions Author Paji and think about it logically.
1. Do you honestly believe that after the death of Guru Gobind Singh Ji that we are not going face anymore undue hardships?
2. Do you honestly believe that the road ahead for the Sikhi is going to get any better?
3. Do you think the world in the near future is going to survive when all these sins are happening?
4. Since we have all these nuclear capabilites, and there is a huge war? who do you think will save those people who meditate in the Nam God?
According to Satguru Ram Singh Ji's Hukhmana they quoted: "He who has received "Bhajan" and then does not recite (meditate on it) is as per (Hukam) instructions - will have his face blackened in this world and in the next. Whosoever does not do his daily prayers and meditations he will suffer there and here.
On top of that in Satguru Ram Singh Ji Jeevan Katta (Satgur Belas book)they told their sikhs long before the British started to rule India, that they would be captured and exiled from them. Satguru Ram Singh Ji talked about their disappearence and what to expect for and what the Sikhs should be doing in their return. Satguru Ram Singh Ji emphasized more on doing Nam Simron than anything but also told the Sikhs to continue to doing all the Bainis mentioned in their Hukhamana.
In the Satguru Belas book, Satguru Ram Singh Ji talked about nuclear devices that were goin to be created long before they even existed. They stated that the countires are going launch each other bombs and start blow each other up. They said they will save those do nam simron.
Well to all the Veer Ji I am just saying what Sri Satguru Ram Singh Ji themselves said.
Wahi Guru Jey Key Fateh.
Re: NamDhari response
... · 18 Feb 2006
Dead Man Walking,
I think we take very different things from the Guru Harkrishan Sahib story. I take that Guru Harkrishan Sahib acknoweldged that Granth can be Guru. Even if he chose not to give the Guruship at that point, it was given later. Just like Guru Hargobind Sahib could have given Guruship to Guru Tegh Bahadur, but he did not and it was given later by Guru Harkrishan Sahib when the time was right.
The time was right and Guru Gobind Singh gave it.
After Guru Gobind Singh left, he said he would reside in the Khalsa. That's why Khalsa Panth is enough to handle any hardship. He has made clear that he resides in it when 5 rehitvan Singhs are together.
Re: NamDhari response
Singh · 20 Feb 2006
WJKK WJKF
Dead Man Walking
Your arguments are becoming quite repetative and boring. The point is Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the the only Guru for the sikhs and no living being.
What is the problem why can't the NaamDhari sect just accept this rather than using stories and other methods to dislodge the true sikh essence. There have been so many questions put to you about the NaamDhari sect which you have failed to answer.
Just bring this to an end as no one will agree with you unless you're on a forum dedicated totally to the Naamdhari's.
Re: NamDhari response
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 20 Feb 2006
Dear
Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi
Thank you very for responding to my response and your counter ideas.
Basically, you feel jealousy with Satguru Jagjit Singh. If he is faque, then, why so many sikhs are his followers, and believed in him, to whom he could link them with Guru Granth Sahib and are doing Nitnem and daily Assa Di Waar, Panj Bania, Rehras Sahib etc. Have you every met him or you have written out of the information collected from different friendssources.
I agree with you that Guru Nanak Sahib is and Guru Granth Sahib is our Satguru and there is no denying the fact for a sikh. And all the Sikhs on this earth will give respects till the life remains on the earth.
But please write back, if Satguru Jagjit Singh has harmed you or harass you, or anbody else, in any form, at any place. Why you are prejudice. Hearsay pinches to heart. If you do not want to listen him or do not want to see, just keep silent. Talk to him directly and get clarifications. Guru Sahiban say:
NINDA BHALEE KISSEE KI NAHI
MANMUKH MUGHADH KARANN
MOOH KAALE TINNA NINDKA.............
People are ready to say and honour other saint and sages as Baba ji, that looks nice, then, if his followers say him Satguru, what is the problem.
I request you to kindly use his name properly, instead of just using nickname, it reflects your personality and does not effect to his name. I wish that you should have respect from all corners and should indicate your nice behaviour for the old people at least. He is above Eighty and is like our grand-father.
In his personal capacity, has he replied you in any form, inspite of your filthy language against him, which you have flourished world-wide through this Phorem. I wish through this Phorem, the people of our community should be an example, otherwise, people shall de-link themselves to talk through this Phorem. Hope you know the Essence of Sikhism.
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh
[address removed]
Re: NamDhari response
skaur · 21 Feb 2006
Yes, I have a question. My family and me are the only ones that are not nam dharis buh all my relatives are. now is it wrong if we go meet the sant but not bow heads to them, is this wrong. Because i have gone to go meet them everyone i know bows there head to them but i dont so is this wrong. We dont believe in them but we go there to meet the sant? So i need to know what i did was wrong or not.
Re: NamDhari response
... · 21 Feb 2006
I suggest that you not visit namdhari sants. They don't believe in Guru Granth Sahib as Guru and consider that the real Guru is someone else.
In the future I would avoid going to such people.
Re: NamDhari response
Harpreet Singh · 21 Feb 2006
i aint no "Sant/Baba" worshiper, but if some "Sant/Baba" treats Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Mahraj as their Guru and preaches proper Sikhi then i have the utmost respect for them.
Naamdharis are on some next planet, we should not do sangat with them even if we are related to them.
I am from the ramgharia/kenyan background and we got a lot of relations who are part-time naamdharis and a few full timers. I don't really mix in with them. Don't really see the need to, I get beant laha doing Sangat with Singhs.
Some of my relatives feel obliged to do sangat of naamdharis because they are related and worried they will fall out. Most of the time they cuss the naamdharis. I don't really bother with them either.
Naamdharis also eat paan and sapari. I have seen them buying and eating paan in Green Street. My dad says it's because they hang around classical music performers and have picked up their habits.
They also hang around the Swami naryan Gujrati Samaj temples and do sangat of their bhagwaan. They were on a zee tv programme doing matha tek of the hindu swami.
I think naamdharis are a bit confused. well that's the way it looks to me. i ain't heard their kirtan but i know they use loads of string instruments and they perform with people like Ravi Shanka and Zakir Hussain and Stone roses. I don't really think they do gurbani kirtan, they are more music performers.
Re: NamDhari response
Sherbahadar Singh · 21 Feb 2006
WJKK, WJKF
Dear Professor Sahib Ji,
I think if you re-read your last post, you'll realize that your first comment is very flawed.
"If he is faque [fake], then, why so many sikhs are his followers, and believed in him, to whom he could link them with Guru Granth Sahib and are doing Nitnem and daily Assa Di Waar, Panj Bania, Rehras Sahib etc."
This is a very myopic way of looking at things. The points that you've made here are also adressed by many dera babas and various other cults including the RSS, Nirankaris and Radhaswamis. Just because each of them has a huge fan base, that isn't a certificate of authenticity of their blasphemous claims.
Futhermore, for example, Jagjit Singh is no different from Harbhajan Singh Yogi. They both fit the criteria that you've laid out in your comment, but they are both selfish imposters as far as I'm concerned.
Jagjit Singh is just profiteering from selling his lies about being the true Satguru, which he obviously isn't. I even doubt that most Kukas believe in his claims; most are probably too scared or reluctant to do anything about it. He's cooked up a few good fairy tales full of half-truths and blunt lies to justify his religious profiteering business, all at the same time while claiming to be the Satguru.
Harbhajan Singh Yogi is in the same boat. Although he never declared himself a Satguru, he didn't seem to care that he was being treated that way from his followers despite him knowing that its againt gurmat. Although he introduced to the west his twisted version of Sikhism, he was nothing more than a businessman who hijacked Sikh principles for his own agendas, just like the Kukas.
I have nothing against you Professor Sahib but this comment (and a few others that I'm not going to point out) I found particularily annoying.
Bhul Chuk Maff
WJKK, WJKF
Re: NamDhari response
Amrik · 22 Feb 2006
Who is this namdhari ...how they can compare wid sant bhindrawala ...who hve given a great sign to sikh community.
Namdhari do everything as per sikh who says that ...
they r not pbeying the hukam of guru gobind singh ji that only guru granth sahib is our gurus ...no deehdhari guru is accepted...
Re: NamDhari response
Suun_Mandal_ek_jogi_bayse · 22 Feb 2006
WGJK Khalsa
WGJK Fateh
no where The GurBani said that 'Ek O'angKar Satguru Nanak Ji sahay' or 'SatGuru Gobind Singh Ji Sahay'
But these cults use 'Ek o'angkar SatGuru ram singh ji sahay', what the message they r trying to spread.
In Gurbani 'Ek O'angkar SatGuru Parsaadh' is the short of MOOL MANTRA.
Akal Sahay
Re: NamDhari response
Dhanwant · 22 Feb 2006
shut dis discussion.its not rite.a truesikh will neva do nindiya of neone.dis is not rite.to the person who runs this website.its causing too much friction.doesnt follow the maryadha Guru Gobind Singh Ji blessed upon us.Doesnt follow the example of Bhai khanaiya ji...seeing enemies and folk alike.i suggest you take off this discussion its not rite.
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 22 Feb 2006
Dear Veej Ji,
I was most impressed with Professors post about doing Nindya against other people. I am still amazed that people are choosing to ignore that the professor ji wrote.
I just a got a quick question. I have heard most of the Sikh's do not believe in Dasham Granth? Is this true? In the Dasham Granth it mentions the names of Lord Vishnu, Bharma and Mahesh. There has been a controversy with some of the Sikh's in punjab of wanting to revise the dasham granth which Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji Marharaja wrote. They want fabricate the dasham granth and its authencity. There are even some Sikh's who even say that Guru Gobind Singh Ji's writings in the Granth Sahib are wrong.
In the last post Sherbahadar Singh Ji crtisized about Guru Jagjit Singh Ji and Yogi Harbhajan Singh Ji. I am just stunned that you would make insutling remarks about these two great souls. Sherbadar Singh Ji you have the right to form your own opinion about whether Guru Jagjit Singh Ji is Guru or not. It does not mean that your opinion is 100% right. What good have you done in the Sikh community? Yogi Harbhajan Singh Ji is well regonized and he had many followers. He did good for the Sikh community by teaching Sikh's about Nam and meditation. It disgusts me the fact that you would say these horrible things to such a soul.
Guru Jagjit Singh Ji is the great newphew of Guru Ram Singh Ji who stood up against the British Raj. People like you should be thankful that Guru Ram Singh Ji's Namdhari's Sikhs sacrificed their lives for the indepence of India and in the name of Sikhism. Instead you like to crtisize Guru Jagjit Singh Ji. Its funny that people like you never get anywhere or progress in life by insulting Guru's, Sants, and Rishi's. Are you aware that it is a huge sin to do Nindya against Guru's, Sants and Rishi's. If you do not believe that they are real Guru's, Sants and Rishis, then keep silent. I highly You d even follow your Guru Gobind Singh Ji's Maradya. Do you ever see a Namdhari Sikh insutling you or your beliefs? Did Yogi Harbhajan Singh Ji insult in way that deeply wounded your heart and left you in tears? Did Guru Jagjit Singh Ji commit any serious crimes? Can you please tell me if you met any of them in person? Have you asked Guru Jagjit Singh Ji any questions that were bothering you? Did you bother to do any research or get any information?
Even Sikhs in your own community are critiszing the Dasham Granth that Guru Gobind Singh Ji wrote. They want to fabricate the whole thing They are upset that Lord Vishnu, Bharma, Mahesh are mentioned in it. If you people cannot have faith in Guru Gobind Singh Ji's writing then who can you have faith in? I want the Sikhs here to answer my questions about the Dasham Granth. Read my paragrah of above.
Re: NamDhari response
... · 22 Feb 2006
Dead Man Walking,
Some Sikhs (not most as you put it) say that some of Dasam Granth is not by Guru Gobind Singh. It is not becuase of Brahm, Mahes or Bishen (these names are in Guru Granth Sahib as well). It is a fact that Bhai Mani Singh compiled Dasam Granth and not Guru Gobind Singh himself. At any rate, I'm not at liberty to comment further on this as Akal Takhat Sahib has said this issue should not be debated.
Re: NamDhari response
Sherbahadar Singh · 22 Feb 2006
WJKK, WJKF
Dead Man Walking Ji,
"I am just stunned that you would make insutling remarks about these two great souls."
Get prepared to be stunned ever more.
"Sherbadar Singh Ji you have the right to form your own opinion about whether Guru Jagjit Singh Ji is Guru or not."
Exactly and I chose the latter of the two options. I believe 100% without doubt that Jagjit Singh is not the Guru.
"It does not mean that your opinion is 100% right."
Opinions, contrary to what you think my friend, are not objective; they are completley subjective to the person giving them and therefore your concept of rightness and wrongness is superfluous.
Whether the Sri Guru Granth Sahib is the Guru or not is not anyones' opinion. It is a historical fact that you and your community have chosen to ignore and systematically planted fabricated lies and half-truths to pursue your own agendas. You have not been able to prove, beyond reason of doubt, that Jagjit Singh is the Guru and your fairy tales honestly make me laugh. I especially like the part where Guru Gobind Singh supposedly lived for 146 years with over 100 of those in hiding. What a pathetic joke.
"What good have you done in the Sikh community?"
And what have you? And why is that relevant to whether Jagjit Singh is the Guru or not? To answer your foolish question, I do seva at my local Gurdwara weekly and I am an active member of the Sikh Students Association at my University. And yes, an actual, non-secular (to my best extent), practicing Sikh who tries to teach youth the principles of our religion by portraying the greatness of our Gurus (1 to 11), rather a roda just giving a list of do's and don'ts (which they themselves breach) and shouting pro-Khalistan slogans.
"Yogi Harbhajan Singh Ji is well regonized and he had many followers. He did good for the Sikh community by teaching Sikh's about Nam and meditation."
And yes, let's not forget the yoga, the tantric and kundalini yogas he was so fond of.
"It disgusts me the fact that you would say these horrible things to such a soul."
And it disgusts me even more that you blindly follow blind people. Don't even get me started with Yogi (bear) Harbhajan Singh. He was "Baba" Daljit Singh on steroids. His whole organization is a massive fraud and if you look around on the internet there numerous sexual misconduct cases he's had to deal with with his scantily-cald secretaries for his cracking business empire. There are numerous articles that have exposed this cult all over the internet written by ex-3ho members. You can start reading here:
http://www.rickross.com/groups/3ho.html
Once you're done reading all that, you can use google and search for "3HO Cult". Don't get me wrong; there are some excellent Gursikhs in 3ho and they just aren't aware that they are being manipulated.
"Guru Jagjit Singh Ji is the great newphew of Guru Ram Singh Ji who stood up against the British Raj. People like you should be thankful that Guru Ram Singh Ji's Namdhari's Sikhs sacrificed their lives for the indepence of India and in the name of Sikhism. Instead you like to crtisize Guru Jagjit Singh Ji."
I have nothing against BABA Ram Singh and I believe he was an excellent Gursikh and I respect his efforts for fighting against British oppression. Instead of accepting the letters written by him declaring that he is not the Guru, you try to desperately explain to us how we've all misinterpreted the meaning of Guru in that letter. In addition, you are unable to provide any satisfactory, straight, factual answers to the various questions that have been posed to you.
"Its funny that people like you never get anywhere or progress in life by insulting Guru's, Sants, and Rishi's. Are you aware that it is a huge sin to do Nindya against Guru's, Sants and Rishi's."
Yes, I am aware it is Nindya do speaks ills of Guru's, Sants and Rishis, how I and most other Sikhs define them. The true Gurus are from Guru Nanak to Guru Gobind and the current (and eternal) Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. I think the only Sant is the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and I'm not sure exactly what a Rishi is (perhaps you can help). Yogi (bear) Bhajan and Jagjit Singh are neither of the above (they may be Rishis, I don't know). They have both used and abused Sikhism for their own selfish purposes, but this isn't anything new. Like the Meenas and the Dhir Mals, they will come and go just like the leaves on a tree. Also, don't worry about how I progress in life, first worry about yourself.
"If you do not believe that they are real Guru's, Sants and Rishis, then keep silent."
No thanks, I choose to expose those who try to exploit others by using religion. Maybe you have a problem with that, but I don't.
"I highly You d even follow your Guru Gobind Singh Ji's Maradya."
I'm not sure what you're trying to say here. Are you trying to say "I highly doubt you even follow your Guru Gobind Singh Ji's Maryada."?
"Do you ever see a Namdhari Sikh insutling you or your beliefs?"
You'd be surprised. I've debated with several Kukas throughout my life and when I pose questions to them, they give me the same scripted answers using circular arguments and half truths. You can see it in their eyes that they even doubt their own fabricated stories but just don't have the courage to admit it. Yes, Namdharis have insulted my beliefs and the beliefs of 98% of the total Sikh populace by propagating unsubstantiated lies throughout history to justify themselves.
"Did Yogi Harbhajan Singh Ji insult in way that deeply wounded your heart and left you in tears? Did Guru Jagjit Singh Ji commit any serious crimes?"
Propagating lies and using Sikhism for selfish, religious profiteering are, in fact serious crimes. The only reason bigots like them have gone unpunished all these years is because the current Sikh administration is full of bigots just like themselves. Both are controllers (whether directly or indirectly) of numerous money-funneling corporations that the Sikh administration has a stake in.
"Can you please tell me if you met any of them in person? Have you asked Guru Jagjit Singh Ji any questions that were bothering you?"
Why is it necessary that I meet them in person? I've never met George Bush and neither has most of world and yet almost everyone outside America thinks his actions are completely asinine. I never met Guru Nanak Dev Ji (physically) either but I know from his bani and Sakhis what kind of person he was and what he believed. I don't have the time this stage in life to ask him questions that are bothering me.
"Did you bother to do any research or get any information?"
Plenty. As I said previously, I've debated with several hardcore Kukas without satisfactory answers. I've done most of my research online from namdhari-world.com and various other Namdhari affiliated websites, which I view as nothing but a perversion of Sikhism. I'm sure Jagjit Singh's views were used as input (more or less) on that website regarding most questions a lot of us here want answers for.
"Even Sikhs in your own community are critiszing the Dasham Granth that Guru Gobind Singh Ji wrote. They want to fabricate the whole thing They are upset that Lord Vishnu, Bharma, Mahesh are mentioned in it. If you people cannot have faith in Guru Gobind Singh Ji's writing then who can you have faith in? I want the Sikhs here to answer my questions about the Dasham Granth. Read my paragrah of above."
Most Sikhs of "our" community don't criticize the Dasam Granth because it mentions Vishnu, Bhrama and Mahesh. These deities are also mentioned in the SGGS. The criticism comes mostly from the infamous Charitropakhyan and other passages. Then, you've got people like Virsa Singh who wants us to believe that all of the Dasam Granth is written fully by Guru Gobind Singh Ji, just because he says so. What a clown.
WJKK, WJKF
Re: NamDhari response
Singh · 23 Feb 2006
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Dead Man Walking
You said " Do you ever see a Namdhari Sikh insutling you or your beliefs" and the answer damn right YES.
I have seen many Namdhari's speak against Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji and when anyone speaks against the Namdhari's then all of sudden its not on.
You go ahead and keep on believing in a living Guru which is against Sikhi Maryada but its obvious your not too bothered about this. You continuously mention how Baba Ram Singh fought the British for India and how he liberated, fair enough I agree, but so did the likes of Bhagat Singh does that mean they should also be referred to as Guru??
The Dus Pathashai's from Dhan Guru Nanak Dev ji to Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Ji made countless sacrifices for the welfare of humanity. Guru Gobind Singh sacrificed the whole of his family his Sahibzaadas at their young age made a sacrifice that most of us at that age couldn't even imagine.
Therefore rather than coming out with same debate over and over again please stop. Its getting boring and to be honest rather frustrating, rather than answering questions put to you, you are in return putting forward further questions.
What the hell do you mean by "Even Sikhs in your own community are critiszing the Dasham Granth that Guru Gobind Singh Ji wrote". Again this quote shows you are segregating, why do you like to divide people into agendas as done with NaamDhari Langars.
The bottom line is Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is Guru and will be Guru, people like you have come and gone and tried their best to dislodge sikhi but have never succeeded. If you want to carry on believing in your DEH DHARI GURU go ahead but don't impose it on others with your nonesense.
You continuously mention "Nindya" when the someone disagrees with your response to the naamdhari sect, and how they shouldn't be insulting Jagjit Singh. I have heard and seen so called Naamdhari's insulting Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. I agree that Nindya is not good but this applies to both sides and therefore you should apply to yourself and others like you.
Siri Guru Gobind Singh Ji has said "once all means of peaceful negotitations have been exhausted, then it is one's right to take up the sword" Countless Singhs and Singhnees have sacrificed their live's, homes, children familes for others and that is because of their eternal belief in the One true Guru.
I urge admin to close this post because this debate is not going to end and their is no way anyone is going to agree with your pathetic arguments. If you Naamdhari's believe in the Guru Sahibaans from Guru Nanak to Guru Granth sahib ji then why this debate. Why is it that you guys don't greet each other with "Guru Fateh" why have you done away with the "Sri Sahib". You can go on and on till your blue in the face but you are fighting a losing battle and poeple like you are not even worth the effort.
One of the biggest mistakes made was when Singh Sabha Southall allowed the Naamdhari's to have their own float behind that of Siri Guru Granth Sahib - this has just helped in promoting your poisonous ideas.
Admin I request this post be closed. And maybe 5 sings should get together and approach Jagjit Singh and question him on what he says.
still waiting...for a NamDhari response
jugroop singh · 23 Feb 2006
Central issues that have been raised include the following:
> NamDharis practice caste-distinction regarding Langar
> NamDharis have ripped Angs from Siree Guru Granth Sahib Ji in the past
> Baba Raam Singh did something which no other SatGuru had done before him and denied the GurGaddi that was allegedly passed to him stating that 'i am not the Guru'.
please let's discuss these issues now. the issue of Human and GurShabad SatGuru has been discussed very much; i am sure people reading this thread have made up their minds either way.
Re: NamDhari response
Dead Man Walking · 24 Feb 2006
I came across the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Namdhari. This is a world wide encyclopedia.
Re: NamDhari response
singh · 08 Mar 2006
Sat Shri Akal
My friends who are in opposite Namdharis, can they put all their questions straight in front of Namdhari Guru, Guru Jagjit Singh Ji? If yes, then here is the address of Namdhari Headquarters:
Namdhari Darbar
Shri Bhaini Sahib
Distt. Ludhiana
Punjab
Please dare a little and ask your queries to them. If it is a darbar of true guru, then no body in question will be harmed.
Regards
[%sig%]
Re: NamDhari response
Duki · 31 Mar 2006
I need to ask does a Guru:
* Buy the latest car every year and spend £0.5Million on cars every year
* Only travel by Concorde when going from UK to USA and back
* Buy Stud farms and raise horses for Gambling purpose
* Take Land away for vunerable
* Buy Real estate properties in Australia
* Buy Shopping Mails in Canada
* Sell Gurdawar's in Kenya so that he can buy a Stud Farm
* Sell Prperty in Uk so that he can buy real estate property in USA
* Have his right hand man involved in brining illegal immgrants into UK
Just some of the List I ask above is of a Guru or a Business Man or whatever!!!!!!
Duki.
Re: NamDhari response
SK (Satnam kaur) · 02 Apr 2006
Dear Duki,
You are absolutely right. All these Gurus are Businessmen.
Their business is selling of shabads from Gurbani.
What you have written are known facts to all. But still more
business activities they have in more fields. But it runs with
the help of close circle friends, known as disciples. They are
linked to Politicians.
SATNAM
[%sig%]
Re: NamDhari response
. · 02 Apr 2006
DHAN DHAN SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE
ਗਉੜੀ ਮਹਲਾ ੧ ॥
ga-orhee mehlaa 1.
Gauree, First Mehl:
ਗੁਰ ਪਰਸਾਦੀ ਬੂਝਿ ਲੇ ਤਉ ਹੋਇ ਨਿਬੇਰਾ ॥
gur parsaadee boojh lay ta-o ho-ay nibayraa.
By Guru's Grace, one comes to understand, and then, the account is settled.
ਘਰਿ ਘਰਿ ਨਾਮੁ ਨਿਰੰਜਨਾ ਸੋ ਠਾਕੁਰੁ ਮੇਰਾ ॥੧॥
ghar ghar naam niranjanaa so thaakur mayraa. ||1||
In each and every heart is the Name of the Immaculate Lord; He is my Lord and Master. ||1||
ਬਿਨੁ ਗੁਰ ਸਬਦ ਨ ਛੂਟੀਐ ਦੇਖਹੁ ਵੀਚਾਰਾ ॥
bin gur sabad na chhootee-ai daykhhu veechaaraa.
Without the Word of the Guru's Shabad, no one is emancipated. See this, and reflect upon it.
ਜੇ ਲਖ ਕਰਮ ਕਮਾਵਹੀ ਬਿਨੁ ਗੁਰ ਅੰਧਿਆਰਾ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥
jay lakh karam kamaavahee bin gur anDhi-aaraa. ||1|| rahaa-o.
Even though you may perform hundreds of thousands of rituals, without the Guru, there is only darkness. ||1||Pause||
ਅੰਧੇ ਅਕਲੀ ਬਾਹਰੇ ਕਿਆ ਤਿਨ ਸਿਉ ਕਹੀਐ ॥
anDhay aklee baahray ki-aa tin si-o kahee-ai.
What can you say, to one who is blind and without wisdom?
ਬਿਨੁ ਗੁਰ ਪੰਥੁ ਨ ਸੂਝਈ ਕਿਤੁ ਬਿਧਿ ਨਿਰਬਹੀਐ ॥੨॥
bin gur panth na soojh-ee kit biDh nirabahee-ai. ||2||
Without the Guru, the Path cannot be seen. How can anyone proceed? ||2||
ਖੋਟੇ ਕਉ ਖਰਾ ਕਹੈ ਖਰੇ ਸਾਰ ਨ ਜਾਣੈ ॥
khotay ka-o kharaa kahai kharay saar na jaanai.
He calls the counterfeit genuine, and does not know the value of the genuine.
ਅੰਧੇ ਕਾ ਨਾਉ ਪਾਰਖੂ ਕਲੀ ਕਾਲ ਵਿਡਾਣੈ ॥੩॥
anDhay kaa naa-o paarkhoo kalee kaal vidaanai. ||3||
The blind man is known as an appraiser; this Dark Age of Kali Yuga is so strange! ||3||
ਸੂਤੇ ਕਉ ਜਾਗਤੁ ਕਹੈ ਜਾਗਤ ਕਉ ਸੂਤਾ ॥
sootay ka-o jaagat kahai jaagat ka-o sootaa.
The sleeper is said to be awake, and those who are awake are like sleepers.
ਜੀਵਤ ਕਉ ਮੂਆ ਕਹੈ ਮੂਏ ਨਹੀ ਰੋਤਾ ॥੪॥
jeevat ka-o moo-aa kahai moo-ay nahee rotaa. ||4||
The living are said to be dead, and no one mourns for those who have died. ||4||
ਆਵਤ ਕਉ ਜਾਤਾ ਕਹੈ ਜਾਤੇ ਕਉ ਆਇਆ ॥
aavat ka-o jaataa kahai jaatay ka-o aa-i-aa.
One who is coming is said to be going, and one who is gone is said to have come.
ਪਰ ਕੀ ਕਉ ਅਪੁਨੀ ਕਹੈ ਅਪੁਨੋ ਨਹੀ ਭਾਇਆ ॥੫॥
par kee ka-o apunee kahai apuno nahee bhaa-i-aa. ||5||
That which belongs to others, he calls his own, but he has no liking for that which is his. ||5||
ਮੀਠੇ ਕਉ ਕਉੜਾ ਕਹੈ ਕੜੂਏ ਕਉ ਮੀਠਾ ॥
meethay ka-o ka-urhaa kahai karhoo-ay ka-o meethaa.
That which is sweet is said to be bitter, and the bitter is said to be sweet.
ਰਾਤੇ ਕੀ ਨਿੰਦਾ ਕਰਹਿ ਐਸਾ ਕਲਿ ਮਹਿ ਡੀਠਾ ॥੬॥
raatay kee nindaa karahi aisaa kal meh deethaa. ||6||
One who is imbued with the Lord's Love is slandered - this is what I have seen in this Dark Age of Kali Yuga. ||6||
ਚੇਰੀ ਕੀ ਸੇਵਾ ਕਰਹਿ ਠਾਕੁਰੁ ਨਹੀ ਦੀਸੈ ॥
chayree kee sayvaa karahi thaakur nahee deesai.
He serves the maid, and does not see his Lord and Master.
ਪੋਖਰੁ ਨੀਰੁ ਵਿਰੋਲੀਐ ਮਾਖਨੁ ਨਹੀ ਰੀਸੈ ॥੭॥
pokhar neer virolee-ai maakhan nahee reesai. ||7||
Churning the water in the pond, no butter is produced. ||7||
ਇਸੁ ਪਦ ਜੋ ਅਰਥਾਇ ਲੇਇ ਸੋ ਗੁਰੂ ਹਮਾਰਾ ॥
is pad jo arthaa-ay lay-ay so guroo hamaaraa.
One who understands the meaning of this verse is my Guru.
ਨਾਨਕ ਚੀਨੈ ਆਪ ਕਉ ਸੋ ਅਪਰ ਅਪਾਰਾ ॥੮॥
naanak cheenai aap ka-o so apar apaaraa. ||8||
O Nanak, one who knows his own self, is infinite and incomparable. ||8||
ਸਭੁ ਆਪੇ ਆਪਿ ਵਰਤਦਾ ਆਪੇ ਭਰਮਾਇਆ ॥
sabh aapay aap varatdaa aapay bharmaa-i-aa.
He Himself is All-pervading; He Himself misleads the people.
ਗੁਰ ਕਿਰਪਾ ਤੇ ਬੂਝੀਐ ਸਭੁ ਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ ਸਮਾਇਆ ॥੯॥੨॥੧੮॥
gur kirpaa tay boojhee-ai sabh barahm samaa-i-aa. ||9||2||18||
By Guru's Grace, one comes to understand, that God is contained in all. ||9||2||18||
www.srigranth.org
Re: NamDhari response
Duki · 06 Apr 2006
Satnam Kaur ji u are right, I forgot in the late 70's early 80's I do remember the Namdhari Suba calling around saying that the Namdhari Guru wanted to weight Indra Gandhi with Gold and then give that Gold to the Congress Party. I do not know if it ever happened but my guess is it did because Indra Gandhi appointed a Namdhari to be India's representative at United Nations and later on this same persom became MLA.
Re: NamDhari response
A Singh · 07 Apr 2006
Gur Fateh!
Veer Akal Yoga, your first post is indeed a good account of the Namdhari sangat in present times - I personally second your views, in that I have also experienced positive and negative things (as I have in most Sangats), the end result is that one takes the positive and tries to ensure that they eliminate the negative from their own lives.
As per the caste-distinction, this is indeed a sad state of affairs in this day and age, however it is easy to understand where this comes from - the Sanatan Sikhs, of whom the Namdharis are effectively a reform movement, but Sanatan nonetheless.
This caste practice is directly in line with the beliefs of the Sanatanis who even put this in place within the Harimandir Sahib and enshrined it within their rehitnamas (Avtar Singh Vahiria et al). Interesting today, the Namdharis are not the only ones to keep such observance in their divans for Langar or Amrit Sanchar.
The Buddha Dal Nihangs are well known to have the identical practice within their Langers and their Amrit Sanchars - for what they term the Chautha Paur, not only this, but if a "Jatt" or other "non-achoot" Nihang is found guilty of some kurehit, as part of his peshi he is sometimes required to spend some time within the Chautha Paur Langar area and quarters.
In fact, one can find this attitude amongst all the so-called Sanatan Sikh sampradhas, even within their western contingents such as in the UK, where certain white converts to Sikhi were told that they were Mazhbis. Surprisingly, this discrimination during the Amrit Sanchar and Langar even existed within the Taksal about 50 - 100 years ago.
It is a shame that even in the West that we choose to hold on these values and then blame on "backward Punjabi culture" - we to me only indicates that most of today's Youth, despite their academic achievements know next to nothing about Punjabiyat or Bharati culture, particularly when comments like "Gora Sikhs are proper because they have no Indian hang ups" - ever considered that they have Gora hang ups?
Each community has hang ups, perhaps rather than slating Punjabiyat off for one or two idiotic things, how about we actually learn about the positive aspects and richness of our cultural aspects and emphasis them...or do we see this as yet another thing that only the Gora can do right, since they some how a superior race like the late YB tried to claim.
Re: NamDhari response
sk(satnam kaur) · 07 Apr 2006
Veer ji
Namdhari commited a heinous act once, by dis-integration all the pages, by handing over to their disciples, to read at different spaces, and it was caled 'Patra Path' (page path). Eh haige Namdhari, Guru Sahib de totei karan walei. They do not treat the Guru Granth Sahib as Dasan Guru Ki Deh. and do not give respect to that level.
It is publicly known to everybody.
Bhul chuk maaf karna.
Satnam kaur
Re: NamDhari response
Rashpal Singh · 07 Apr 2006
Mohinderpal Singh,
"I agree with you that Guru Nanak Sahib is and Guru Granth Sahib is our Satguru and there is no denying the fact for a sikh. And all the Sikhs on this earth will give respects till the life remains on the earth."
I don't believe what you have said at all here. You don't agree with Bhai Jarnail Singh at all that Guru Nanak Dev Jee and Guru Granth Sahib Jee is the Satguru. You are lying, since you also called Jagjit Sio 'Satguru'. Please can you tell me how there can be 2 Satgurus, as you like to believe?
[%sig%]
Re: NamDhari response
Duki · 09 Apr 2006
You all like to know about 7 years ago the Namdhari's removed from their Gurudawar's Siri Guru Granth Shaib. They mata-take down now to a Picture and hasan. This clearly shows they have no respect.
Re: NamDhari response
deadmanwalking · 12 Apr 2006
Your lack knowledge about Namdhari's are so insufficient. Dukhi where did you get information that Namdhari's removed Guru Granth Sahib from their Gurudawara?
Namdhari's have Guru Granth Sahib in their Gurdawara and the verses are read from itwhenver it is needed. About the bowing to the Ashan and a picture, the Ashan is for the Guru to sit on. If you have not noticed that Namdhari's believe in 12 Guru's. That Ashan is meant for Satguru Ram Singh Ji to sit on one day when they return according to Namdhari Beliefs.
I have noticed in other forms where people are debating about Sikh's are not Hindu and they come up with that assumption without understanding the roots. No offence it seems like you Sikh's have an issue with everyone here. By the way things are going with your sect at the moment, your sect could tumble down easily. If there are certain topics or subjects that you find offensive, why do you not get all the sects together and talk about them in a polite manner instead of getting hostile and jumping to conclusions that easily.
Another thing people have to notice, when Namdhari's sacrificed their lives for the independence of India, the first prime minister Neru visited Sri Bhani Sahib quite often to see Guru Partap Singh Ji. Whenever he was stuck in a problem, he would talk to Guru Partap Singh Ji before making any crucial decisions. All the great Prime Ministers who were elected all came to Sri Bhani Sahib and even the recent Prime Minister Mohan Singh came.
If people do have a problem with the current Guru Jagjit Singh Ji of Namdhari, why do you not all write to him like how one of the members of the form posted the address where you could write your inquiries. If you want, you can go visit the www.namdhari-world.com website where it has all the listings of the Namdhari Gurdawara;s and you can visit the Gurdawara's yourself to the location nearest to you. If anyone is interested of attending the Namdhari Gurdawara with their questions they can go to the Namdhari Gurdawara located at 410 Chrislea Rd. Major intersections are Highway 7 and Western Road.
I suggest to everyone who has a problem against the Namdhari's to be quiet because you people are not really getting anywhere in these debates and you are just wasting your time. What is even so funny to me is the fact that the Akal Takh has become so powerless and they cannot even do a thing to the current Gurur Jagjit Singh Ji who is believed to be sitting on Guru Nanak Dev Ji's gurgadi. If you think Guru Jagjit Singh Ji is fake, why are you sitting their like cowards. Since you guys claim yourself to be true Khalsa's of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, then stand up for your cult. How many years has it been since the Namdhari's are standing strong? It has been to many years and yet you people cannot even do a thing to the current Guru Jagjit Singh Ji.
See one of the reasons why I did not respond is the fact that whenever I wrote my historical facts people started ignore them and I started to ignore their facts. I came to the point where that these debates are not going to go anywhere unless you guys can remove Guru Jagjit Singh Ji from the Gurgadi. End of Story.
Wahi Guru Jey Fath.
Re: NamDhari response
Jagjit Matharu · 13 Apr 2006
deadmanwalking wrote:
>
> Another thing people have to notice, when Namdhari's sacrificed
> their lives for the independence of India, the first prime
> minister Neru visited Sri Bhani Sahib quite often to see Guru
> Partap Singh Ji. Whenever he was stuck in a problem, he would
> talk to Guru Partap Singh Ji before making any crucial
> decisions. All the great Prime Ministers who were elected all
> came to Sri Bhani Sahib and even the recent Prime Minister
> Mohan Singh came
And 1984 still happened?? Was your Jagjit sleeping??
You have come down to your level, looks like all the Namdhari bashing is breaking your confidence in Jagjit. Its simple the difference between Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji and Jagjit is massive. Jagjit is a thief of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji
Check these links out, sometimes its better to see pakhand with your own eyes than just write about it:
http://www.kukasikhs.com/kukasikhs/galleryBS.htm
http://www.namdhari-world.com/audio/28nov04balbir.m3u
http://www.namdhari-world.com/audio/28nov04jagjitguru.m3u
Who want to was time going after the frail Jagjit. His time has come and it will be the end of Namdharis. Ram Singh isnt coming back, Jai Singh is easily manipulated. Thakur Singh (Jagjit's big bro, who was originally offer the gaddi by Partap however he refused) wants his gaddi back for his kids. Oh they are fun times to come!!! Jagjit was not the one for the gaddi, he got it by default. Oh well its all within the Matharu family :o)
Re: NamDhari response
G Singh · 13 Apr 2006
Man.....these pictures are freaking me out!!!!
Re: NamDhari response
G Singh · 13 Apr 2006
I found these articles which are freaking me out even more.....These guys really think they are the Gurus of the Sikhs.......Check the pictures and the alleged sakhis out.....This is wierd.....It's not until I read these articles that I realised what namdharis actually are.....How come we have not ever done anything about this....& how come they do kirtan in our Gurdwaras.....
Namdhari Guru No 11
http://www.sikh-heritage.co.uk/gurus/Guru%20Balak/Balak%20Singh.htm
Namdhari Guru No 12
http://www.sikh-heritage.co.uk/gurus/Ram%20Singh/Guru%20Ram%20Singh.htm
Namdhari Guru No 13
http://www.sikh-heritage.co.uk/gurus/Hari%20Singh/satHarisingh.htm
Namdhari Guru No 14
http://www.sikh-heritage.co.uk/gurus/PartapSingh/Satpartap.htm
Namdhari Guru No 15
http://www.sikh-heritage.co.uk/gurus/JagjitS/SatJagjitS.htm
Re: NamDhari response
GSB · 13 Apr 2006
The namdharis (eventhough i myself am one through family but I am more liberal in views) do see Guru Jagjit Singh ji as a Guru but moreso as a Living Guru (spriritual guide) to the ultimate Guru (shabad guru) or SGGS ji. How so? well the way I look at it is yes he is the light but a guide to the ultimate light. I have been reading up on old historical texts and according to the old texts it has always been that the "living Guru" gives a path to the word. Also I have listening to his discourses and in it he always speaks of Gurbani and naam which is already in SGGS so to say that he would call himself over that would be hypocritical. I have talked to him in person and he always preaches sikhi....whatever path u follow, just follow it but faithfully and do bani and simran of gurmantar (waheguru).
If he was what people make him out to be, then why would the namdhari's do asa di vaar in raag and kirtan and preach simran of gurmantar or waheguru jaap?
In my belief, the ultimate word and power (Guru) is SGGS and its teachings but a spiritual guide is needed to help me stay straight and that is the whole ideology of the namdhari panth but u gotta remember sometimes it's the chela's who manipualte it to the wrong way. That's the case for any dera (any sant/mahapursh).
I was reading a sakhi of Guru/Baba Ram Singh Ji and that during his times whenever a sikh was reciting Gurbani and if the sikh read a tuk wrong by mistake/accident, Guru ji would stop him and make the sikh recite that same tuk 15 times or until he got it right. Now, may I ask you if that shows respect for Gurbani? or not?
So to sum up my point....I believe that SGGS is the ultimate word and guru jagjit singh is a guide to that just like as in a classroom, there is a teacher that teaches from the books or like how a Sensai is there to teach his martial arts class eventhough there are writings around in the class.
Re: NamDhari response
Gursa Singh · 15 Apr 2006
Please stop refering to Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj as "SGGS". Do you refer to Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji as SGND? or do you refer to your namdhari guru as SGJS?
Re: NamDhari response
a singh · 15 Apr 2006
hold on i have a few questions...plz explain thxxxx
ok
q1) IF Guru Gobind Singh Maharaj made BABA ram singh the 12 guru...then who was the 11th guru? Wouldnt the 11th guru have made baba ram singh the 12th guru..wouldnt that be more logical
q2) Why did Guru Gobind Singh Maharaj make the khalsa panth and the Punj Pyiara to give naam..then go ahead and make another sikh a guru?
q3) You believe that baba ram singh will one day return...why not any of the other 10 gurus? Why baba ram singh?
benti) Can a naamdhari that has passed the trikuti plz speak up..i will only accept that the naam given by a naamdhari is valid if a naamdhari that has passed the trikuti ...as per my knowledge this is only possible via the punj NO ONE OTHER CAN DO THIS.
Re: NamDhari response
babbar · 17 Apr 2006
dont no if u realise but u calling jagjit s guru ji is an offence to all gursikhs.and calling all gursikhs with bindrawale criminals is damn right disrespectful,didnt see any namdharis helping in the time for need around 1984.
Re: NamDhari response
dead man walking · 17 Apr 2006
GSB used words of wisdom constructively. GSB was being neutral as well and yet people attacked him on a very minor issue as calling Sri Guru Granth Sahib by adding the preffix Mahajara. That is just untterly insane.
Second note. Namdhari Raagis came from the UK and India few days ago. I know the raggies well since I have gone to India and I am the nephew of the Suba of namdhari Gurdawara in Toronto. On Sunday the Namdhari Raagi's were invited to the Ramgharia Gurdawara and Nankaksar Gurdawara to perform Sangat with the blessings of Guru Jagjit Singh Ji. These two Gurdawara's showed utomost resepect to the Namdhari Classical Kirtan which Guru Jagjit Singh Ji kept and they were praised for their performance. These Raagis will be here for a few days and if anyone is interested in watching them perform, please write in this form.
Author Singh asked a few questions.. Author Singh JI we did answer similar questions in the past. I will quickly answer them in pointform note and not go into details of it.
q1) IF Guru Gobind Singh Maharaj made BABA ram singh the 12 guru...then who was the 11th guru? Wouldnt the 11th guru have made baba ram singh the 12th guru..wouldnt that be more logical
ANSWER: According to Namdhari Beliefs Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharja did not make Satguru Ram Singh Ji the 12th Guru; it was Guru Balak Ji who made Guru Ram Singh the 12th Guru. Guru Gobind Singh Ji made Guru Balak Singh Ji the 11th Guru.
q2) Why did Guru Gobind Singh Maharaj make the khalsa panth and the Punj Pyiara to give naam..then go ahead and make another sikh a guru?
You have to understand the significance of the Panj Pyaree not many people do. Guru Gobind Singh Ji was facing adversity that time since the Muslim empire was powerful and the empire tried to convert everyone into muslims. No one was brave enough to face the empire. So Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji asked for 5 heads and who were ready to sacrifice their lives for the name of religion.
q3) You believe that baba ram singh will one day return...why not any of the other 10 gurus? Why baba ram singh?
The other Guru's passed away and left their heavenly abode so therefore those Guru's cannot return. Guru Ram Singh Ji on the other hand did not pass away. Guru Ram singh Ji was exiled by the British Govnerment in 1872. They entrusted the responsibilies to their brother who's name was Mahraja Budh Singh was later changed to Hari Singh in Guru Ram SIngh JIs hukahamana. Guru Hari Singh Ji was made the Jout Ka Jama Guru to take care of the Panth while his Brother Guru Ram SIngh JI faced exile or deportation. There are 5 original documents made by the British declaring Guru Ram Singh Ji dead in 1885. Here are they:
In the report of the civil surgeon of Mergui, No. 99, dated the 29th November, 1885, he wrote:
"I beg to report to you the death of the state prisoner Ram Singh, which event has taken place just this moment 4-30 P.M. The man has been in a decline some time past, and with the setting in of the cold weather, he had another attack of diarrhoea and complained of change very much.
Another blanket was purchased and added to the other two he already possessed.
The last attack of Diarrhoea set in on the 22nd, and all endeavours to induce him to take medicine having proved abortive, he was treated with small doses of opium, which he took readily. His diet was completely regulated and nourishment kept up at shorter intervals, his constitution already broken down from old age, frequent attacks of Diarrhoea off and on since the rains of 1883, an attack of general Dropsy in the earlier part of the current year and from general debility, he succumbed to the present attack and died quite exhausted at 4-30 P.M. in my presence, on 29th November 1885."
The civil surgeon's report can be easily denounced when it is recorded that as far back as 11th August, 1884, Satguru Ram Singh Ji were reported to be in good health.
According to the letter no. 221-226 S.P. dated Rangoon 11th August, 1884, the following report may be quoted:
"Of the Kooka prisoners, the most important, Ram Singh, is kept in confinement at Mergui. His health during the past year has been fairly good and his conduct much better than usual."
The above report certainly does not agree with the version of the Surgeon. This creates doubts. There is also a document signed by Mr. Bernard, british chief commissioner of Burma, in August 1886 that states Satguruji had been sent to a 'remote' place in the country where no one had access to because in spite of being kept in strict imprisonment He had managed to keep contacts with the freedom fighters in India.
For The Guru had Told The Sikhs who accompanied Him in the bullock-cart when He Left Sri Bhaini Sahib in the year 1872 repeatedly NOT TO BELIEVE WHAT THE ENGLISH GOVERNMENT WOULD ANNOUNCE ABOUT HIS LIFE OR DEATH. HE RESTATED THE ORDERS OF SATGURU GOBIND SINGH JI THAT HIS 'DEH'(BODY) WOULD SUSTAIN FOR 250 YEARS.
That is why the Namdhari's believe that Guru Ram Singh JI will return because of the information mentioned above.
Sat Sri AKal.
Dead Man Walking
Re: NamDhari response
a singh · 18 Apr 2006
q1) IF Guru Gobind Singh Maharaj made BABA ram singh the 12 guru...then who was the 11th guru? Wouldnt the 11th guru have made baba ram singh the 12th guru..wouldnt that be more logical
ANSWER: According to Namdhari Beliefs Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharja did not make Satguru Ram Singh Ji the 12th Guru; it was Guru Balak Ji who made Guru Ram Singh the 12th Guru. Guru Gobind Singh Ji made Guru Balak Singh Ji the 11th Guru.
^^
ok plz explain then why so many ppl dont want to accept this? I mean there were no problems up until baba balak ji? How can sikhs get confused over a major issue such as "who our guru is" ...
q2) Why did Guru Gobind Singh Maharaj make the khalsa panth and the Punj Pyiara to give naam..then go ahead and make another sikh a guru?
You have to understand the significance of the Panj Pyaree not many people do. Guru Gobind Singh Ji was facing adversity that time since the Muslim empire was powerful and the empire tried to convert everyone into muslims. No one was brave enough to face the empire. So Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji asked for 5 heads and who were ready to sacrifice their lives for the name of religion.
^^
that doesnt make sense....guru sahib was facing hardship so he thought he'll take 5 heads of 5 sikhs for what? explain abit further plz.
Re: NamDhari response
Khalistan_zindabaad · 18 Apr 2006
one question is the apparent guru of the naamdhari from the SODHI linage or NOT, there have been several incidents where naamdharis have shown disrespect to guru granth sahib jee.. i remeber the london nagar kirtan when some singhs were giving out flyers stating that guru granth sahib jee is the guru of the sikhs with a pic of naamdhari guru with a cross over it. . . the singhs gave it to a naamdhari and said dhan dhan sri guru granth sahib jee and the response from the naamdhari was dhan dhan satgur ram singh jee!!!!!!!!!! and this is whilst the nagar kirtan is taking place onwe cud say in guru sahib jees hajuri
Re: NamDhari response
ummm · 18 Apr 2006
man all i can say is the whole namdhari aspect is a joke, i have seen clips when they are using gurbani shabads and singing them directly to their guru, as though he will perform some karamaat and move their spirtual minds pass that stage, really is a joke that people find solace in this pakhandi.
Baba Raam singh was a gursikh of the highest order, no doubt, but his chelea have basically re- created his history to suit their selfish needs.
It's shame the panth is asleep with dicatators at the forefront, the time is near that there will be new blood pumped into leadership who will question all those hypocrites who on one hand pretend to be panthic and on the other are friends of these sects, singho tyaar hou, there is a serious need to get rid of the rotten apples within us, starting with niranakaris, namdharis, radhoswamis etc..... pakhandis of the highest order !!!!!
Re: NamDhari response
deadmanwalking · 19 Apr 2006
To Author: ummm
First of all what evidence do you have Guru Ram Singh Ji's Chelea has basicallyt re-reated history? You have no evidence what so ever. I suggest you to London England and go to one of their resource centre to read the history of Guru Ram Singh Ji. All documents have been recorded and are authentic.
Secondly why do you not have a live discussion about this if you think Namdhari are Parkhandi. I have challenged everyone in this room to have alive discussion but one wants to. Either they are afraid or they do not have the brains of have a civil disccusion with me. Again. Anyone who is intersted in chatting live with me, can have my msn address [address removed]
Third, three questions were asked about the author singh ji regarding why Namdhari believe Guru Ram Singh Ji will return. Those questions were answered to Author Singh Ji not for everyone in the room. He asked you questions in the polite manner. I do not know why people here got so hostile.
No one is telling you to follow the Namdhari Panth but what seems to be the problem here? I have noticed that most people in here cannot even follow their own Guru Granth Sahib because it says not to do Nindaya against other religions. So how can you guys justify your own actions if you are going against Guru Granth Sahib Ji of doing Nindays to others? Forgive me for saying this, you guys are no different from the Muslims who literally try to convert people into their beliefs.
Tapoban is the only Gurdawara so far in Toronto that I know that have serious issues with Namdhari's but rest of the Gurdawara's in Toronto seem to have utmost respect for Namdhari's. I had mentioned in my last post that the Namdhari's Raagi's have been performing to Various Gurdawaras here in Toronto. SO far they have peformed in Nanaksar Gurdwara, Ramgharia Gurdawara and Scraborough Gurdawara. So why is it that other Gurdawara's have more common sense than the Tapoban? Let me guess, you are the only outlaws here.
Sat Sri Akal,
Dead Man Walking.
Re: NamDhari response
ummmm · 19 Apr 2006
dead man walking, are you really mar jeevai sohe mariya ??? or do you just like names from films ??? regarding your jatha doing kirtan in the darbar of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, to me that is the hyprocisy that they show, on one hand you totally belive in your baba or whatever and on the other to show off to sangat your knowledge of raag you do kirtan in the Gurus darbar who you do not even believe in ?? please why the double standards ??? also i have read most of this thread and your houmai shines through no end, why would any gursikh who believes in Gurbani want to bang his head against a brick wall, paar akhar ehou bujiyea, moraakeh naal na lohyjiya, gal ban jann dee aa...
you are 100% firm in everything you believe, most of the sangat on this board are steadfast in their belief regarding dehdhari gurus and who the true Guru is, so to have a debate is pointless and for you to think that anyone has been influenced by all your katha, you are living in a dream world.
There is nothing you have said that makes me believe anything other than the truth, namdharis have lost the plot and until they accept that without Dhan Dhan siri guru granth sahib ji they will never achieve the purpose of life, this Jagjit singh will and can not give you mukti, who is he ??? seriously I suggest that you give up trying to convince people who will not be convinced by jarogon and stories.
Re: NamDhari response
Sulakhan Singh Flora · 20 Apr 2006
deadmanwalking wrote
"Tapoban is the only Gurdawara so far in Toronto that I know that have serious issues with Namdhari's but rest of the Gurdawara's in Toronto seem to have utmost respect for Namdhari's. I had mentioned in my last post that the Namdhari's Raagi's have been performing to Various Gurdawaras here in Toronto. SO far they have peformed in Nanaksar Gurdwara, Ramgharia Gurdawara and Scraborough Gurdawara. So why is it that other Gurdawara's have more common sense than the Tapoban? Let me guess, you are the only outlaws here."
--------------------
My friend, this is the opinion of the majority. Just because namdharis can sneak into Ramgharia run Gurdwaras due to being of Tarkaan backgrounds yourselves or entering the Nanaksar Gurdwaras (who in my opinion have now created their own maryada away from the panth) does not mean that Sikhs find in acceptable to allow naamdharis on our stages.
I have recenetly seen how namdharis seem to be entering the mainstream Gurdwaras via these classical musical achedamies. Prabandhiks need to be vigalant of the tactics of the namdharis. Don't sell your Sikhi for a performance involving some string instruments.
Sulakhan Singh Flora
Youth Co-ordinator
Forest Gate
London
Re: NamDhari response
Duki · 23 Apr 2006
http://www.nriinternet.com/NRIsikhs/India/Satguru%20_Jagjit_Singh/1_NRI_gave_%20Rs%205-18%20crore_CAR.htm
Two UK NRIs gifted high-end luxury, Rs 5.18 crore
Car to Satguru Jagjit Singh, Namdhari
The web link above will show the what the Namdhari Guru really likes
He says two NRI Namdhari sikhs gave him Maybach Daimler Chrysler worth RS 5.18 Croe or say around $350,000 or £250,000. No body in the Namdhari knows of these Sikhs and they are not on the Electrol register in Derby. I challenge the Namdhari's to bring these Sikhs forward and show they are genuie and they have paid Tax etc to buy a Car so expensive that only two othet multi Billionares in India have this Car.
The Fact is the Namdhari Guru came to Uk, Canada and USA and collected £5,000 per head for Appolo hospital which he claimed he is building. But this Hospital is being build by the Apollo Group and Namdhai's have only given the Land. Loads of money was collected there is no accountablitiy and nobody knows what has happened to the money. But I have heard from an internal source that this money was banked in a Swiss Bank. The Maybanh car is in fact bought out of the Proceeds collected for the money rasied for the Hospital.
This is not the first time money has been collected for Cars. 4 years ago The Namdhari Guru bought a Rollys Royce and this money according to the internal source came from selling the former Namdhari Gurdawar, Terrace Road, Forest Gate London.
In fact this goes back to Kenya where cars would be bought and anybody visiting India would be told to transfer the Car to their name and bring it to India
All I ask id how many homes would have been build for the poor for RS5 Crore is these actions of a Guru or an Industrlist. If he is the Guru would he not tell live by example and not indulge in Captalist things but simple humble leaving with enough items to provide a clean spritlist leaving.
Just a note on the earlier discussions Guru Ram Singh's Nephews have used his name to form a Religion which they now see is better than work, gives easy access to money and allows them to leave like a Royal Family. What more can they ask for Money defeinately grows on the trees for them.
Re: NamDhari response
ummmm · 23 Apr 2006
all i can say, maya ke sohba char dyarea, and these so call gurus are meant to be the real deal, give me a break man, the true satguru was above and beyond maya and its attractions, i think its fair enough to say that this discussion is at an end, it has been proven beyond doubt there is only one guru, dhan dhan guru granth sahib ji.
Re: NamDhari response
Leicester Lad · 24 Apr 2006
£250k on a car......wow.....kalyug.....
I remember in the 1980s the guru came down to UK and was given a new White Merc by some namdhari family in Leicester. The White Merc was custom-made so that the leather interior could be replaced with cloth upolstry, as this "sachay pasha" would not sit in a leather interior car.....!!
Money well spent .... LOL!!!
Re: NamDhari response
Jaz · 24 Apr 2006
They say too much indulgence can spoil a person.
In regards to the Namdhari Guru Jagjit Singh Ji, it is the sadh Sangat who donates these things to the Guru. Who care if the Guru has an expensive Car. The sikh's who have full sharda will donate pretty much anything they have. Remember one must not go to the GuruGhar empty handed. Although giving a expensive and luxrious car to the Guru is not a neccessity but luxury does not mean that the Guru is not living a simple asectic life.
A person here mentioned that the money that has been donated to build the Guru Apollo Hospital has been taken away. Yes that is true it has been and the person who was responsible for the mishap of this was thrown away from Sri Bhani Sahib by the Guru. Everyone must pay for their karama's. A Guru will give you the chance of straightening your life, but if you cannot striaghten it, then you might as well go to hell.
Recently I heard a new project is being started at Sri Bhani Sahib. The Ramsar is an old ancient place that dates back from the time of Lord Ramchader actually. The history is long but I will get to the point from what I was told. During the British Raj there was a dispute between the land by the British and Guru Ram Singh Jis brother Guru Hari Singh Ji. The dispute got resolved by the Guru making a prediction to the British that they will find some ancient tools in the time of Ramchander Ji underground. The Guru claimed that his brother was the same avtar. Basically what happened was, the British dug the spot and they did found the tools of the Havvan Yug that was conducted by Lord Ram and the Guru's predictions was correct. Later Ramsar was built.
The current Guru Jagjit Singh Ji of the Namdhari's had requested people to do donate money so that they can purchase 100 acres of land so that they can expand the ramsar. He is encouraging those people who living on the other side of the land to give up meat and alcohol They say that it is going to be expanded quite the length that could be seen across Luaidana. According to sources, the reason why the Guru wants to do this project before Guru Ram Singh Ji returns according to the Namdhari Beliefs.
Anyhow I thought I find that to be interesting. Although I am not taking anyones side here, but its nice to see how other Sikh communities do things with full sharda and belief. I do not care if you are from the Singh Sahib Movement, Nirkhani, Radawswami or Namdhari's as along they are worshipping Akal Purkh. At the end we are all winners.
Wahi Guru Jey Fateh
Re: NamDhari response
Gurmat · 25 Apr 2006
Is £250k better spent on a car or help in alleviating poverty?!
I will never understand how these modern dehdhari gurus, babas and sants justify their tangible asset growth.
I am sick of people justifying this by claiming Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj lived like a king. Yes he did, but he showed that it could all be given up as well. I wonder if this namdhari guru could give up his sons, grandsons, cars and land when the time comes.
Where was he when darbar sahib was being attacked, why did he not come out publically. What better time to come out if you are the "real" guru of the sikhs than 1984. Surely he should have given his life up in the conflict! I suppose he was too busy enjoying his wealth.....The proof of the puding is this wealth all stays in the family, we'll see who the successor is, I'm sure there's a grandson being prepared for this guruship....
These dehdhari gurus and modern day sants are so far from the humbleness they supposedly preach..... It's all about asset growth.....
Re: NamDhari response
Jagjit Matharu · 25 Apr 2006
Oh! my Namdhari friends, for how long will you try to cover for your Guru. Its getting boring and quite pityful. Open your eyes your defending postings are repetative and very weak. Actions of Namdhari Gurus do not stand up to what Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji did for the world.
Re: NamDhari response
Jaz · 26 Apr 2006
Dear Jagjti Singh Matharu Paji,
From the posts I have read in the from, I really don't think anyones covering up anything. People who are anti-Namdhari's will always say something bad about the Namdharis where it is mere rumour or gossip. This does not have to anything with the Namdhari's.
In my understanding, other Sikh Community aren't perfect either. Look at the Vancouver Incident where they were fighting over tables and chairs. Where is the Guru Maradya there? Some Granthis eat meat and read verses from the Sri Guru Granth Sahib? Can we as a Sikh community deny these things are not happening? Can we cover our up of all the negative things. I am trying to be netural here much as I can since I am not taking anyones side. There is saying: Before saying any thing negative about others, one shold look at himself first to see if he doesnt have any flaws or errors.
People here also shared their historical facts as well. Both sides had a valid point. I cannot say who is right or wrong because each side had their own legitimate belief why they should not belive in a dedhari Guru and why they should not be in Guru Granth Sahib as the ultimate Guru.
Sikh's are not the only one who are facing this religious dilmea, there are other religions as well. Chiristanity have different beliefs than Catholics Jews and Muslims. Majority of these religions believe that Jesus is son of god but Muslims believe that he is the prohpet of god. So who is right or wrong here? This is a similar case scenerio with the Sikh Community in general. Some Sikhs believe in Guru Granth Sahib as the ultimate Guru and the others believe Guru Ram singh Ji as their living Guru. Can we honestly distinguish between what is right or wrong here when it comes to a religious dilmea? I doubt we can. To resolve these things, a person must follow what he belives is right or wrong.
After writing this post, I could guarantee anyone right now that this debate is going to go on and on. If a debate has over 196 writtings, then something is wrong with the people here in general. As a neutral Sikh, no one is going to become victoris in these debates. I just suggest they just leave the things the way they are. What is happening in this world right now is happening for a reason.
Wahi Guru Jey Fateh. God Bless all the Great Sikhs here!
Sincerely,
Jaz
Re: NamDhari response
Jagjit Matharu · 27 Apr 2006
Jaz your are ignorant not neutral!
Where is the religious dilemea? Sikhism principles are Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the living Guru....end of story! From Sri Guru Nanak Dev i to Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji all dilemeas have been cleared up. The Path is Clear for a Sikh! The dilema is with a Namdhari who knows their So called Guru isnt Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji.
Re: NamDhari response
Mani · 27 Apr 2006
Jaz, you say "Some Sikhs believe in Guru Granth Sahib as the ultimate Guru and the others believe Guru Ram singh Ji as their living Guru."|
Sikhs only believe in Guru Granth Sahib "Ji" as the ultimate Guru and others who believe in dehdharis gurus such as radhasoamis, nirankaris, darshan dasis and namdharis are not Sikhs. Accept the fact, you guys keep coming up with the same discussion points.
No matter what state our Panth is in, there are no living human gurus involved. Any group that believe in a living human guru are not part of the Khalsa Panth.
Groups like AKJ, DDT, SANT groups, NIHANGS, SGPC, 3HO are all part of the Khalsa panth, regardless of their differences (big or small) simply because they accept Guru Granth Sahib Ji as the eternal Guru of the Sikhs.
Re: NamDhari response
lol · 27 Apr 2006
naamdharis are NOT sikhs..you are only sikhs when u accept satguru GRANTH SAHIB JI as ur guru. THERE is NO dilema as its clear that guru granth sahib ji is the true guru and naamdharis = nark vaasi.
Re: NamDhari response
Admin · 27 Apr 2006
Thread is closed
Re: NamDhari response
doesn matter · 23 May 2006
namdhari's your guru is a chor!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
try and say that about dhan shree guru tegh bhader ji, guru gobind singh ji, guru nanak dev ji, guru hargobind sahib ji,
you cant say that can you????me thoada gala wad da ga je kaya ta
Re: NamDhari response
Mohan · 23 May 2006
These namDhari threads are repetitive. Someone bashes them then the same indvidual namdhari comes back with another opportunity to promote his dodgy repetitive parchar. The grammer and content of the posts by the pro-namdhari posters always appears to be the same....
Re: NamDhari response
Singh Chana · 23 May 2006
So in 1984 or wot eva whn u lot were bein attacked, what did the Grant Sahib Ji do? U say our Satguru, Satguru Jagjit Singh Ji Mahraj didnt do anythink whn u lot were being attacked. Exactly wot did ur Guru, the Granth Sahib Ji do thn 2 protect u? ummmm..... nothing i guess..... oh welll i guess u lot r jus a bunch og idel Worshipers.
U lot put a glass of water next 2 the Granth Sahib at night... lol wots tht gna do? u lot put duthan next 2 it...... y? i dnt understand?
Can u non- namdharis explain this plzz im really confussed!!!!
This disscussion forum gives me laughs.
Re: NamDhari response
Jagjit Matharu · 15 Jun 2006
Khalsa gave shaheedi for Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji during 1984. Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji gave them the strength to live & die for Sikhi!
Namdharis hid in Panni Sahib begging for Congressi protection and cleaned their instruments.
It is amasing how foolish Namdharis can be!! Just accept that your "Satguru" isnt even capable of being Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji's shoes or a rumalla for Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji stood for the rights of Hindus, Jagjit couldnt even stand for the right of Sikhs, the religion he has supposed to have created....LOL!!!!
Re: NamDhari response
GSB · 15 Jun 2006
and it's still goin on................
Re: NamDhari response
kookar · 18 Jun 2006
mohinder pal singh ji u wrote....
"I request you to kindly use his name properly, instead of just using nickname, it reflects your personality and does not effect to his name. I wish that you should have respect from all corners and should indicate your nice behaviour for the old people at least. He is above Eighty and is like our grand-father."......
wanna say only 1 thin .....
he may b ur grand father ...if all gursikhs give me a chance to say somethin on their behalf.......the only thing i will say is we hav only 2 grandfathers in soul
"waheguru jio" and "dhan guru teg bahadar sahib jio"
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: NamDhari response
singh · 30 Jul 2006
sat sri akaal
some people have the perspective of a sikh is cannot be a follow of any human when the gurus where human? were the gurus followers not true sikh??
just to say it is writeen in gurbani not to argue about religion to me this whole site is about arguments and you people call urself followers of guru granth sahib!
Re: NamDhari response
Dilbagh Puri · 31 Jul 2006
Author: kookar
Date: 06-18-06 03:37
mohinder pal singh ji u wrote....
"I request you to kindly use his name properly, instead of just using nickname, it reflects your personality and does not effect to his name. I wish that you should have respect from all corners and should indicate your nice behaviour for the old people at least. He is above Eighty and is like our grand-father."......
wanna say only 1 thin .....
he may b ur grand father ...if all gursikhs give me a chance to say somethin on their behalf.......the only thing i will say is we hav only 2 grandfathers in soul
"waheguru jio" and "dhan guru teg bahadar sahib jio"
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
____________________________________________________________
Fateh,
Reading above post by kookar. He proved that he is a kookar but guru's. The language he is using is reflection, how his parents have brought him up. Some times they may also be using same type of abusive punjabi language. He has "haume" in his personality. He should not be allowed by admin to write any post further.
Bhool chook Muaf
Re: NamDhari response
raja · 01 Aug 2006
Nindya kisi ki bhali nahe
from my understanding everyone is wrong here.... a true sikh never insults any religion and any faith dosnt matter if they beleive in dehtari guru or sri guru granth sahib.....if we beleive that sat sri akaal is greatest then we should leave them to judge who is right and wrong rather than correcting eachother and insulting eachother.....
please end these debates between namdharis etc if you have faith in guru granth sahib ji cus this will no benefit anyone but make it more confusin ......
all we should say is nanak naam chardi kla tere bhane sarbat ka pla....rather than sayin kooke r wrong they did this and they did that and same applies to everyone
at this point no one here has any respect for guru granth sahib ji so we cant point out to anyone how much they disrespect guru ji.....
so please brothers and sisters if have respect and piyaar for guru nanak dev ji and guru granth sahib ji then please stop these debates and talk about how we should stick together and do paat
waheguru ji ki fateh