Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

3 punjabis convicted of murder

3 punjabis convicted of murder

viewer · 13 Jan 2006

there seems to be a disturbing trend in our punjabi youth where there is now a 'gangster' culture, especially in the toronto area. these youth are dressing and talking like kalay. these kids are [i]looking[/i] for fights in every situation as well. they roll in boatloads and have this perverted sense of 'honour' where they have to preserve honour for their friends and crew. this article is another sad example of kids who have ruined their life and their parents lives, and for what? if they had even a bit of sikhi in them they would have never done this. 3 convicted in Albion Mall death Jan. 13, 2006. 05:49 AM PETER SMALL STAFF REPORTER Three young men have been convicted of beating to death a 19-year-old man in a group confrontation at Albion Mall. But the jury assigned each of the three, charged with first-degree murder, a different degree of responsibility for the fatal attack on Raheel Malik, on the night of June 6, 2003. Amandeep Banwait, 23, who led a car convoy from Mississauga to the Rexdale mall to confront the part-time security guard, bowed his head as he was pronounced guilty as charged. Harjit Matharu, 21, slumped slightly as the jury foreman read a verdict of guilty to second-degree murder. He later wiped tears from his eyes. The jury unanimously recommended he serve the minimum 10 years of his mandatory life sentence before he is eligible for parole. Witnesses said he had hit the unarmed Malik with a metal pipe, while Banwait smashed his head with a hammer. Amar Sandhu, 23, smiled faintly as he was convicted of the least serious charge, manslaughter. Michael Moon, his lawyer, expressed disappointment nevertheless. "There was no evidence that he was any more than part of a group just standing around when the fight happened," he said. Sandhu had been accused of hitting Malik with a 2-by-4 in an attack abetted by up to 20 other young men. Malik died of head injuries 20 days later. Robina Riaz, 48, Malik's mother, present in court with her other three grown sons, said she was satisfied that justice was done but felt sorry for the killers' mothers. Asked to explain her tears at the guilty verdicts, she said: "Today I thought he died, not 2 1/2 years ago. I was in such pain and agony that I didn't cry for 2 1/2 years." The prosecution had argued that the three were involved in a planned and deliberate ambush in which they lured Malik to the mall and lay in wait. Defence lawyers argued there was no proof of planning or intention to kill; that Matharu had acted without thinking and Banwait had only planned a fight. Sandhu and Matharu's sentencing hearing is Tuesday. Banwait is automatically sentenced to life in prison with no hope of parole for 25 years. [%sig%]

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

Singhavelli · 13 Jan 2006

"these youth are dressing and talking like kalay" Kalay are victims as well..this prollem is a social problem, its the influence of media and so called role models in the media i also think the lack of discipline by parents plays a role. Its not so much acting like kalay, but acting out wut they are fed by our culture and society through its various tools of opression.

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

0.0.0. · 14 Jan 2006

our youth get very bad infulence. THey listen to music, wathc movies that have vilence in them.

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

ekta · 15 Jan 2006

O.O.O. ignorance is bliss I watch movies.....i listen 2 RAP, I WATCH GANGSTAH MOVIES... i'm a UNIVERSITY STUDENT....4TH GEOPHYSICS...NOT A GANGSTAH most my freinds do the same...and they all med schoolers.... it has nothing 2 do with waht u listen or watch...its who u hang with.

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

Confused Khalsa · 16 Jan 2006

music is a huge part of it, watching films not so much as most people arent constantly watching films all day. music is soo powerful, many people including myself dont realise just how powerful it is. if you listen to a song, it will effect you. some people more than others, but there will be some effect - from humming the lyrics in your mind to acting it out. but agreed, your company (sangat) will also mould you alot.

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

to close to home · 17 Jan 2006

the same thing is happining in vancouver and other cities in canada but rather then music and media the problems with punjabi youth in vancouver is the greed for money which has turned them into nothing but murderers and drug smugglers. [%sig%]

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

kuljit singh · 17 Jan 2006

vancouver is not as bad as you people always say it is.

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

ef · 18 Jan 2006

people argue its not music, but as mentioned, music is powerful. it has the power to calm us, sooth us, anger us, make us happy etc... as well, especially in toronto, the black culture is deep within our youth, much more so then in bc for i have seen both cities.

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

H · 18 Jan 2006

fully agree with ekta

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

singh · 18 Jan 2006

ekta you listen to rap music and watch "gangstah" movies and you are not embarassed to admit this on an internet forum which many rehatvan, chardikala gursikhs around the world visit?

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

rinku · 19 Jan 2006

i think we should get a few millionaire singh families together and start our own film productions and or music productions within the bounds of gurmat ie 6 foot 4 inch singh flowing thara big muscles big up dastar singing folk tale songs of warriors, reliving legends, subtly educating the youth at same time through music. 1 or 2 punjabi songs have begun talking about people running after money. Maybe sikh punjabi youth need role models to latch onto. the right kind of stuff emerging out.

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 19 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVaheguroojeKeFateh Bhai Sahib ekta Jeeo, listening to Rap and watching movies is only the play of Maya. Maya plays and the 5 demons inside of the body are enticed by the play and so they take control of the mind, ten body organs and the 5 senses to use your body to perform these actions. You make think that you're finding Maya’s tools enjoyable but in fact it's all just an illusion, as only the demons are finding pleasure from these things but the soul, which is you, thinks there is something there too. Even though there's nothing there but emptiness. Trickery to the mind to make the mind, which is evil, makes the soul agree but at the end this is all corrupting your soul and mind even more and preventing you from performing any good actions. Furthermore, it is also a rehit not to listen to Manmukhi songs. This is totally against Sikhi. maerae mohan sravanee eih n sunaaeae || saakath geeth naadh dhhun gaavath bolath bol ajaaeae ||1|| rehaao || O my fascinating Lord, may I never listen to the faithless cynic, singing his songs and tunes, and chanting his useless words. ||1||Pause|| Finally, if we wish to indulge in uselessness like this then we ourselves are Manmukhs and manmukhs in Gurbani has many times been called demons, this is clear due to the fact that we perform what the demons inside of the body want us to do. VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVaheguroojeKeFateh [%sig%]

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

PearlJamFan · 21 Jan 2006

In both canada and the united states all indians gangs are made of punjabi's youths. Punjabi's make up about 25% of the indian population in united states and half of it in Canada. Does anybody know why non-punjabi's indians who are in canada and the US don't go into gangs. It's only punjabi's youth almost always involved

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

michelle thind · 25 Mar 2006

Amandeep Banwait has been my neighbour for ages.... he dosent seem like someone who would kill someone... im only 14 and i bealive that he is inocent hes like an older brother to me...everyone has different storys the punjabi papiers say that they beat him up with liquir bottles and now this **** says hammers.. people whats next? he ran him over with a car?? in favour of Amandeep Banwait as his old neighbour i bealive he is innocent... i doubt he would do anything that stupied... he is a nice smart and young boy... he is like an older brother to me.

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

f · 14 Apr 2006

all these dumb kids who killed raheel malik are obviously BIG COWARDS. what kind of "men" need the help of 20 buddies to "fight" only one weaponless man ?

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

punny · 15 Apr 2006

y would etka be embrassed taht he listens to rap music and watches gangsta movies? Just because you do not believe in watching/listennig to this doesn't mean the whole world has to stop because taht is your idea of a gursikh, i kno many chardi kala gursikhs who listen to rap and watch scarface every other day

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

Robert Langdon · 15 Apr 2006

This problem is everywhere, Just yesterday I heard that there is a young 'gang' in west london calling themselves 'AK47 wale' apparently it is a mixature of young dastaarwale and mone. I saw one of these 'gang' members and spoke to him but when I spoke to him I didnt know that he is invloved in some little crew. This young boy was speaking like UK 'black' street talk and it seems as someone said earlier music does influence a huge amount. Daas admits when I was not in to Sikhi I myself was a huge lover of hip-hop and all the gangster rap lyrics does influence people who listen to it, along with the sangath you keep. However heres another interesting point when asked how did this gang get this name of 'AK-47 wale' a singh told me that they heard a track from a production of Shaheedi Immortality some track called AK-47 and got excited and took that name. I havent heard this production so I can not comment nothing on it but maybe someone whos heard can enlighten others who havent heard and explain what is it about it. Its interesting that the youth take some hip-hop gangsta culture mixed with Shaheedi Immortality. Its a shame that shaheedi Imortality was trying to do something positive for the youth but the youth took it to a negativity and made a gang of it Seems the youth are confused. Im sure these youngster gangs will die out but lets hope its not too late before something like the above happens again. [%sig%]

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

M · 16 Apr 2006

one question F ... how do you know raheel was 'weaponless'? Anybody can point fingers when it doesn't involve them personally. This incident is not about SIKH YOUTHS or RAP MUSIC ... the underlying issues related to this situation are far from everybody's knowledge. Every religious/cultural group has its ups and downs ... it is a component of the Modern day society for individuals to experience such things. Who knows, maybe God picked these 'GANGSTA YOUTHS' to set an example for all those who think about getting involved in such circumstances. It is always easier to side with the victim; I noticed only one person who thought about stepping to the other side in this forum. Michelle it takes courage to do what you did, and I whole-heartedly applaude you for that. I don't know of the individuals involved, but I am sure they come from similar families like yours and mine. Let's lay off the harsh comments and bizarre conclusions and pray to God to keep everybody protected from the evils of society and to guide all of us on the right path. Now that would do way more good than all these posts. [%sig%]

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

Jsingh91 · 26 Jun 2007

Listen, i knew Raheel personally, this guy was an all round nice guy, he was weaponless, he came to the movies with his girlfriend. Aman is no innocent guy. He was proven in the court of law.

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

confused · 27 Jun 2007

problem is some people are affected differently than others by music and movies...violence could be in their genes, their hormones, or just maybe vunerable to what others say [%sig%]

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

irvinder singh · 28 Jun 2007

sat sri akal ji, i've listened to quite a bit of tupac shakur and have black friends, on the whole they are the most friendly and humble people i have met i have much symathy for angst among black youth due to hundreds of years of persecution, the manmukh response is to strike out in violence...the gurmukh response is of course to go within and understand the roots of krodh the only gang i realy want to join is the sadh sangat...g fateh [%sig%]

Re: 3 punjabis convicted of murder

Amar_Sandhu · 20 Jul 2007

YO LISTEN I WAS ONE OF THE GUYS CONVICTED IN THIS CASE AND IF YOU GUYS ARE GOING AROUND BELIEVING THAT RAHEAL WAS THERE ALL WEAPONLESS AND EVERYTHING YOU ARE ALL WRONG HIS BOYS WERE THERE AND EVERYTHING. DONT BELIEVE EVERYTHING U READ IN THA PAPERS CAUSE ITS FALSE. [%sig%]