Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhai Kanhaiya ji???

Bhai Kanhaiya ji???

Mandeep Singh · 19 Nov 2003

I was just reading on sikh-history.com and came accross this: Bhai Kanhaiya ji was founder of Sevapanthi or Addanshahi sect of the Sikhs. He was born in a Dhamman Khatri family of Sodhara near Wazirabad in Sialkot District (Now in Pakistan). His father was a wealthy trader, but he himself being of a religious bent of mind left home when still very young and roamed about With sadhus and ascetics in search of spiritual peace. His quest ended as he met Guru Tegh Bahadur 1621-75) and accepted initiation at his hands. Kanhaiya established a dharamsal at Kavha village in the present Attock district of Pakistan. Which he turned into a preaching centre. His special mission was selfless service of humanity with no distinction of nationality, caste or creed. In 1705, he was on a visit to Anandpur when Anandpur was invested by a combination of hill troops and the Mughal imperial army. During the frequent sallies and skirmishes, Bhai Kanhaiya used to roam around serving water to the wounded and the dying without distinction of friend and foe. Some Sikhs complained to Guru Gobind Singh that Kanhaiya had been resuscitating the fallen enemy soldiers. As Guru Gobind Singh summoned Bhat Kanhaiya and told him What the Sikhs had said, he spoke, "Yes, my Lord, what they said is true in a sense, but I saw no Mughals or Sikhs in the battlefield. I only saw the Guru's face in everyone. " The Guru, pleased with the reply, blessed him and told his Sikhs that Kanhaiya had understood his teaching correctly. Guru also give him medicine to be put on the wounds of fallen soldiers(Sikhs and Enemies). What I found a similar story after searching on google on various hindu sites also. What i find interesting is that the above states bhai sahib started a sect??????? I find it hard to belive such a sevadar of the panth would branch off into a sect. Is this yet again an example of hindu rubbish, or did bhai sahib start a mission society of some kind which was later hijacked and turned into a sect. Vaaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh

Re: Bhai Kanhaiya ji???

Kulbir Singh · 19 Nov 2003

I agree with Bhai Mandeep Singh jee. I don't think Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj would have asked Bhai Kanhaiya jee to create a new organization. The problem is that every organization in Sikh Panth today, tries to connect to Guru Gobind Singh jee and if they all had been started by Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj, shouldn't their rehit be same? Why is there a huge difference in their rehit? The reality is that Guru Gobind Singh jee started the Khalsa Panth and that is it. Little is known about the later life of Bhai Kanhaiya jee. Maybe he left for Sach Khand before the battles of Siri Anandpur Sahib. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Kanhaiya ji???

confused · 19 Nov 2003

I was under the impression that nirmalas, seva panthis, udasis and khalsas are four sects of the panth - and they are all equal sects. seva panthis, nirmalas and udasis are sehajdharee sikhs who mostly perform their individual functions - but some take khande-ke-pahul and become khalsa. true false?

Re: Bhai Kanhaiya ji???

Mandeep Singh · 19 Nov 2003

assuming these bodies are equals as your suggesting therefore can they really be sects, would it not be better to classify them as jathas or something along that. reality is that the above groups are not sikhs at all because they dont belive in sikhi to a basic fundamental level? i not claiming to know much about these groups but for example radaswamis have a human guru, some consider themselves sikhs. this is cotradiction to sikhi as guru granth sahib jee is the sikh guru and since they cannot even recognise this they therefore are not sikhs. so my point being is there a similar fundamental flaw within nirmalas, seva panthis, udasis which basically makes them non sikh but just another group trying to pass off their own watered down sikhi?

Re: Bhai Kanhaiya ji???

confused · 20 Nov 2003

Well see the thing is even guru gobidn singh jee wrote a rehat maryada for sehajdharee sikhs who came from brahmin families i think sevapanthis and nirmalas and udasis are .. i duno what they are bhai kulbir singh ji please care to give ur insight?

Re: Bhai Kanhaiya ji???

Kulbir Singh · 20 Nov 2003

Siri Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj gave everyone the same maryada. There is no separate maryada for bibiyaan and men or for different castes. Everyone after amrit becomes Khalsa of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj and as such are obligated to keep the rehit of Khalsa. As for Nirmalas, Sewapanthis and Udaasis, they have done some good work in the past but it is wrong for them to not take Khanday daa Amrit and stay non-amritdhari. Some Udaasis and Sewa Panthis now cut their hair but Bhai Kahn Singh jee Nabha writes that in the past no Udaasi used to cut hair. Udaasis were part of Sikh panth and even took part in the battle of Bhangaani, near Paunta Sahib. Many took amrit when Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj introduced it but some did not and they started their own sect, now known as Udaasi. Same way, Nirmalas have done. They created a distinct sect from Khalsa Panth. Such sects are not acceptable to Guru Sahib. If Udaasis had not been part of Sikh Panth, Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib jee would not have offered his eldest son Baba Gurditta jee to Baba Siri Chand, for parchaar of Sikhi. Baba Siri Chand jee did not start any new religion as some argue. If he had done so, Guru Sahib would not have given support to him. The reality is that Baba Siri Chand jee was a good Gursikh of Guru Nanak Dev jee and stayed in bhagti all his life. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Kanhaiya ji???

jagjit singh · 20 Nov 2003

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh pyare jio, I think we do need to be very careful here. The rehat of the khalsa is clear. The khalsa is complete and has every guun in it. Yes individual Nirmales and udassi may have done great deeds in the past, but that was there karams. To say whether these sects are acceptable to be part of the khalsa Panth is dependant on whether they satisfy the basic tenets of the Sikh rehat Maryada, which most do not. Furthermore, in terms of abyass, you will find many abyassi people in the world, look at sufi saints, buddhists, and some sadhus. All deserve respect, and if nirmallas and udaases do not have to follow basic rehat, then equally then they are sikhs aswell. The reality is abyass is just part of the jigsaw, rehat, hukam, panth are equally important. Concepts completely ignored by them. I am currently working on a book about Babar Akali movement. It interested me when I found out my grandmothers father was a babar akali and was hanged by the British. The more I have done research on this, the more I have seen the highly sinister role Nirmalas and Udasis have played against the khalsas. They were the ones running the Sikh institutions, and they were the one grassing up the Sikhs. I believe to really be part of the Khalsa Panth, you have to have Panthic Dard (pain ). So aswell as asking whether they are part of the Panth, we should also ask are we? Guru Ji is always jaane jaan. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Bhai Kanhaiya ji???

Kulbir Singh · 20 Nov 2003

>>>>> It interested me when I found out my grandmothers father was a babar akali and was hanged by the British. >>> Veer Jagjit Singh jeeo, What was the name of your grandfather, who was hanged by the British? You are so fortunate to have taken birth in a shaheed's family. I request you to do more research on the life of your great-grandfather and post it here for the benefit of sangat. You may find information not available in books and as such the whole sangat would benefit from it. Recently a gursikh posted a very interesting life of her great great grandparents. From that we realize how great the lives of gursikhs in olden days was. Here is the link for that: http://www.tapoban.org/gursikh%20great%20grandparents.pdf Thanks, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Kanhaiya ji???

warrior*princess · 20 Nov 2003

>>>> I believe to really be part of the Khalsa Panth, you have to have Panthic Dard (pain ). So aswell as asking whether they are part of the Panth, we should also ask are we? >>> Seriously, I TOTALLY AGREE!!!!!! 110% (lol)