Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Sher Khalsa · 22 Jan 2006

Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag Bhai Jeeta Singh used to be a Raagi that would accompany Sant Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji. One time in Lahore, there was a Muslim Smagam for Raags. He, being a Raagi himself, was really curious what the muslim Raag smagam would be like. After, listening to some of the program he went up to the organizers and asked for their permission to get some time to do keertan because he knew shabads in Raag. The muslims started laughing at him saying “you Sikhs haven’t been blessed with Raag, go get out of here and go do what you typically do…and…listen, we, muslims, are only blessed with Raag.” Bhai Jeeta Singh got so hurt, he went all depressed to Sant Baba Gurbachan Singh and said, “Ji, today I got really embarassed.” Sant Baba Gurbachan Singh said to him, “I want you for 40 days to stay in this room, food and clothes will be provided inside, for 40 days don’t leave this room and do 125,000 paats of Raag-Mala. Only after completing, this are you to come out” Bhai Jeeta Singh did so as Baba Ji said, and then when the time came for another smagam, he went again. And again He asked them for time, surprisingly the parbandak decided to give him 2 minutes of their smagam time. He got on stage and after touching some keys in Basant Raag, the Harmonium started to play by itself and continued playing for the rest of the shabad! He was given only 2 minutes, however the Raag took 4 hours to complete (b/c of the raas of the keertan no one wanted him to stop him and listened in complete amazement and silence). The Muslims started saluting Bhai Jeeta Singh out loud at the smagam, and some came to him and said, that “God has blessed you people with Raag”. Sant Baba Gurbachan Singh Singh said “You were victorious today on behalf the Sikh Panth, ask for anything you want.” He said, “I do have one thing I really want, when my end comes, I want it to come while I am doing keertan.” Baba Ji said “then that’s how it will be” The day Bhai Jeeta Singh left his body, he was sitting doing keertan in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji’s Hazoori. He was doing it so much love, he would lift his arm up affectionately, and while looking towards GuruJi he would recite “jio bhaavai thio raakh lai” and at that moment Bhai Jeeta Singh left his body. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh http://www.ikonkaar.blogspot.com/

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Kulbir Singh · 23 Jan 2006

I think this saakhi of Bhai Jeeta Singh is “Koori Koorai Thees” i.e. a Gapp. Let’s do some math here: In order to do 125,000 Raagmala Paaths in 40 days, one has to do 3125 paaths a day. There are total of 1440 minutes a day. In other words, Bhai Jeeta Singh had to do one Raagmala paath in 27.6 seconds. I don’t think that’s possible. Besides, he must need some time to sleep too. If we assume that he slept an average of 5 hours a day, he is left with only 1140 minutes a day. This reduces our Raagmala time down to 21.8 seconds. I have not yet counted time for eating, doing for nature's call, doing your own regular nitnem etc. These are the kind of stories are narrated in favour of Raagmala. I don’t think this story needs further refutation. Here are two more pro-Raagmala stories refuted: Two fairy tales about Raagmala: Pro-Raagmalas veers themselves don’t know who wrote Raagmala. It does not contain any heading or stamp of author to prove that it is Gurbani. No baani in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is without either author’s stamp or heading like Mahalla. The stories we hear in relation to Raagmala are such that it does not take a rocket-scientist to figure out that these are false tales. Below are two saakhis we hear about origin of Raagmala: 1) The story goes like this. When Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee Maharaj concluded Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and even wrote the seal or stamp of Gurbani i.e. Mundawani, Guru Sahib heard someone crying outside. They found out that Raags took embodiment of humans beings and had come to Guru Sahib with a request. They humbly requested Guru Sahib to give them respect as no one had ever given them respect and they were wandering from place to place. Guru Sahib had mercy on the bewailing Raags and decided to give them respect by writing Raagmala in the end of Mundawani. What a joke this saakhi is. Here are some points to ponder upon: 1) I don’t think Raags are living beings. Raags are simply different combinations of keys of keyboard. 2) Even if we believe that they are in fact living beings, how did they get respect by creation of Raagmala? According to Gurbani only those who do simran have respect – Prabh ko simrae, sey Patwantay. If anything, Guru Sahib would have given them Naam and not create Raagmala to give them respect. 3) Now even if we believe that with creation of Raagmala, Raags got respect, then what happened to all the Raags that did not get mentioned in Raagmala? What happened to Raag Ramkali and other such Raags that are not mentioned in Raagmala? There are only 84 Raags mentioned in Raagmala. 4) Did Raags not get respect with getting included in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee already? Most of the baani is written in Raags. They already got respected this way. What was the need for Raagmala then? We should not believe this kind of fairy tale. Guru Sahib has made his Sikh much wiser than this. 2) Second Story goes like this. After Guru Sahib had concluded Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee and had written the seal or stamp – Mundawani – some gursikhs approached Guru Sahib with full humility and with folded hands they implored Guru Sahib to now create such “Prem Mala” through which “saadi chauraasi kattee jaavae” i.e. we may become free of cycle of birth and death. Guru Sahib got pleased with them and created Raagmala. What a joke this story is! Here are some points to ponder upon: 1) Which Guru-fearing gursikh would dare say that Guru Sahib’s work is incomplete. 2) Is Gurbani from Ik-Oankaar to Tan Man Theevay Haria, not capable of cutting our chauraasi? How could have Sikhs dared to tell Guru Sahib that their already created baani is not capable of cutting their chauraasi and that they need another “Prem Maala” to cut their chauraasi? 3) How does Raagmala cut their chauraasi when it does not have even one updesh or hukam or content of spirituality. It is simply an index of different families of Raags. How can counting names of Raags give us Mutkee and cut our chauraasi? I request our pro-Raagmala veers to not get upset at reading this. We need to think with open mind as to what is right and wrong. Just because some mahapurakhs believe in Raagmala does not mean that we too should start believing in it. And to those who say that we should keep quiet for the sake of unity, I request them with folded hands that unity does not come by burying important issues. Raagmala is a very important issue for Sikhs because in the opinion of most scholars and learned gursikhs, the presence of Raagmala in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is disrespectful to Guru Sahib. For this reason, it is now time to solve this issue for once and for all. Siri Akal Takhat Sahib should step in right now and have an open debate on this issue. An arbitration of gursikhs should sit and decide at the end of the debate whether to keep Raagmala or not keep it. We should not let this issue lingering for too long now. It must be resolved. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Harcharan Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khasla Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer Kulbir Singh ji, You points and logic on raagmala are very interesting. I personally am looking into the origins of raagmala (at my slow pace), so have not formed any noteworthy opinions yet. I wholeheartedly agree that this issue is a divisive one and should be researched and a panthic decision made so that the various factions of sikhi can be one step closer to unity. Like yourself, I can't see a huge amount of complexity on the subject, through some careful research and histroical investigation the right people can put this issue to rest. I just have one point to make with regards to your post: 1) I don’t think Raags are living beings. Raags are simply different combinations of keys of keyboard. First sentance I agree. Second sentance - Wrong. Raags gifted to us by our Guru's are such a divince and spirituality cultivating tool that it is not fair to undermine as has been done. Raags are translate as "colour". Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj speaks to us about many different aspects of life, hapiness, sadness, longing, seperation, depression, lonliness, hope, courage, truth, caveats, warnings... and so forth. Guru Ji has instructed us to sing Kirtan every day - to express our love, learn humility, understand and feel our Guru's message. When Kirtan is sung in raag as per Guru's hukum, we not only talk to our mind, we also talk to our soul. Our mind understands and our sould feels. Raag helps us to understand the exact emotion Guru Ji is feeling and want us to fel, when doing kirtan without raag, using our own tunes, I believe there is no way we can understand and feel Guru Ji's message as Guru Ji intended. Raag creates the correct environment, background, emotion, depth, sound, translation and colour i nunderstanding Guru Ji's hukum. It has not been placed before every Ek Oankar for nothing. Secondly, it has nothing to do with combination of keys. Harmoniums are a con, cleverly introduced by the British in 1900, in order to take away a huge courage invoking tool from the Sikhs, the British saw how one man with Guru Ji's saaj singing one small shabad could transform a village of passive folks into courageous freedom fighters. SGPC/Singh Sabha did not help the cause, they fell into line with British, thus destroying our Guru given heritage. So, back to the point, harmoniums have nothing to do with raag, they have been designed to play set western scales, not Sikh Kirtan. They cannot replicate the human voice which uses meend (sliding from one scale to another) like the Saranda, Sarangi, Taus and Dilruba (which Guru's gifted us with) and provide the ultimate accompnyment to help a Sikh perfom Kritan to his Guru. Also, raag is not simply a combination of notes. It is a deep felt, correctly understood and passionately expressed story, which we translate musically in order to portray Guru Ji's words in the highest form. Sorry to go off the original (important) topic. But obviously, Guru's Kirtan (Raag) is also an important topic, which I hope this sangat will also take as seriously some day. ਨਾਨਕੁ ਕਹੈ ਸੁਨਿ ਰੇ ਮਨਾ ਕਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਹੋਇ ਉਧਾਰੁ ॥੪॥੧॥੧੫੮॥ naanak kahai sun ray manaa kar keertan ho-ay uDhaar. Says Nanak, listen, people: sing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises, and you shall be saved. Guru Arjan Dev Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Harcharan Singh

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Anjaan · 23 Jan 2006

Gyani Arsey Ji and fellow chelay shoudl get up from behind the chairs and try to do something rather than doing Nindiya and Chuglee on these sites.... They are always saying that this is wring etc etc...they should write a letter to the Akal Takht Sahiban and get clarification and post it on here so we all know what the results are....... Come on then...what are we waiting for.....

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

singh · 23 Jan 2006

The first story is such a joke, that I cannot believe pro-raagmalias would even believe it. It goes to show how blind our faith and knowledge are? Bhai Kulbir Singh has already said everything. Clearly from the posts after, any sane person cannot even thik of propogating such silly stories in the name of Gurmat.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

LOL! · 23 Jan 2006

LOL! This post really made me laugh! And Veer Kulbir Singh, you made me laugh even more! hahaha, nice!

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

...Singh... · 23 Jan 2006

As always, Bhai Kulbir Singh Jee, your logical method of refuting such fairy tales is an eye opener. I cannot beleive that anyone can beleive in the first story about Bhai Jeeta Jee! the other ones are just as false as the first one. Again, lets think logically. We are Sikhs i.e. learners, it doesnt mean we are Jaahil. God gave us Aql to use, so lets use it.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

...Singh... · 23 Jan 2006

I hope people act a little more respectful and not make up stories like this and add Sant Gurbachan Singh Jee name to it. A similarly silly story has also been spread in the book chittaa chola in which the writer claims that Bhai Randhir SIngh Jee started to beleive in Ragmala. By creating such false stories, they are only doing a diservice to the memory of Sant Gurbachan Singh Jee. A Sikh is a Shachaa Insaan. So let us remain Sachay and not use Jhoot to win an argument.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

..... · 23 Jan 2006

"Siri Akal Takhat Sahib should step in right now and have an open debate on this issue" Kulbir Singh im quite suprised by this comment, an issue such as Raagmala should only be touched once we have Raaj Whats the point in debating now, the panths enemies will use this issuse to divide us even further, where will than leave us Sant Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwale many a time said these controversial issuses need only be addressed once we have our own Raaj. Had this issue been addressed in 1978, emnity could have easily have been created between DDT & AKJ, who would have been laughing Gurbachana, Indira etc I too agree this issue needs to be sorted out once and for all. But now is NOT the time

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Jan 2006

Akal Takhat Maryada already declares in Black and White...."Read or DONT READ..Raagmaala as one Wishes.." DARE anyone..write such a Hukm about GURBANI ? NO. I request "Anjaan" and his cohort chelas to get up off their arm-chairs and find any other GURBANI that is recommended to be "NOT READ" by Akal Takhat. The "conclusion" is thus OBVIOUS... Raagmaala is NOT GURBANI... we may or MAY NOT read it. Due to some constraints the Akal Takhat was not able to come to a Definite Conclusion....BUT this "CONCLUSION" is already there and it points to ONLY ONE DIRECTION => Raagmaala is NOT GURBANI. Rest my case. PS. Anyone wishing to hear more of such FAIRY TALES as Bhai jeeta Singh..go to the websites of the Pro raagmaala "mahapurakhs". ( Personally i wonder why these fairy tale creators CANT do some Maths first BEFORE they write these stories.... they could have easily made Bhai jeeta Singh read raagmaala for 80 days or 120 days...But then I guess the 40 Day CHALISA stone hangs around their neck...how to satisfy chalisa rule with 125,000 raagmala paaths ?? Alternatively they could have only read say..25,000 raagmaalas..but then the Magical 125,000 "Stone" also has to be satisfied..what a Dilemma ?? but then all the pro-raagmaal people NEVER do any MATHS/SCIENCE/GYAAN..they just beleive WHATEVER the Mahapurakh says.....pathhar te lkeer hai !!!..people like Kulbir Singh Ji always throw a spanner in their works by doing Maths ??? BAN MATHS. Mahapurakhaan ki Jai Ho..BAN MATHS.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

M S Nijjar · 24 Jan 2006

I agree, NOW IS NOT THE TIME, it will only cause further problems and divisions in the Guroo Pyara Khalsa Panth. For the time being we should all respect each others views. Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!!

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Anjaan · 24 Jan 2006

Gyani Arshi Ji - Mahapurkh I have no chelas. My Guru is GuruJi himself. I am a lone person who is 100% Anjaan and am sitting behind my computer trying to give my views on certain aspects of Sikh life. Now on the aspects of Raag Maala. Those people who are at the forefront at Akaal Takht have vast amount of knowledge and are blessed people (if you like it or not..also are Mahapurkh.....people like you Gyani Ji) who are blessed to be given such sewa. Now, people like me (not you Gyani Ji as you are perfect in all aspects of life), are sitting behind our computers trying to express our views on various aspects and topics on these forums. Why cant we just accept what has been issued by the Akaal takht over the past couple of hundred years (i think) and be happy with that. Raag Mala has no words in which say anything bad about anything. Some people may accept and some people may. But we have to think about that we all do Namaskar to maharaj Ji. So you are telling me that when you go to the Gurdwara, you do not bow to Maharaj Ji which has the Raag Mala in? I hear in another thread Gyani Jo that you sit there when Raag Mala is being read that youoccupy your mind with other thoughts? Isnt that wrong? Shouldnt we be listeing to what Hukum Maharaji have given? Correct me Mahapurkh JI, but dont you think you are being unreasonable? I do not have the power that you have MahapurkhJi, as I dont bear the title of GyaniJi. As you seem to be a person of great influence, people like you should be writing or contacting the relevant people and talking to them and trying to resolve such issues. These forums are not for arguments. Anjaan

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Anjaan · 24 Jan 2006

now they say, "We should read Raag Mala or not?" What is it you are reading? You are reading so many pages -- one page is going to hurt you? No, it's not whether that page hurts or not, it is just to create a doubt on the Guru. "Is Guru perfect, or is Guru not?" That's all it is. Even the most dedicated rehitdhari Gursikhs do not argue over such petty things. This is what our corrupt politicians seem to do.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Anjaan · 24 Jan 2006

I would like to share the following with my fellow Gursikhs (especially those who I have shared views with lately). "If you can't see God in all, you can't see God at all." Very much Anjaan

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Singh · 24 Jan 2006

Sikh's are blessed with raag from the Guru himself, however despite this even those who consider themselves Tat or true Sikh's appear to overlook this and take the easy option and not use raags, despite Guru Sahib himslef using raags, and speciafying every shabad in Guru Granth Sahib against a raag.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

me · 24 Jan 2006

Gyani Jarnail Singh *****Admin cut: Please stick to the topic. The topic of this thread is Ragmala, not keski ******

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Roopkaur · 24 Jan 2006

It is really sad that people, in order to justify a practice based on fairytales, have fallen to the low level of spreading lies, such as Bhai Sahib had changed his mind about raagmaalaa. If Bhai Sahib had changed his mind, he would not have kept this hidden. If you read his books, you can pick up on the type of personality Bhai Sahib had, and to hide his beliefs on raagmalaa totally goes against it. It is one thing to make up fairytales about why we should read raagmaalaa, it is completely another to spread lies about prominent anti-raagamaalaa gursikhs. Another despicable comment was that the reason Bhai Sahib went to jail was because he did not believe in raagmaalaa. This must truly be ghor kalyug when the mahaan sevaa of a Gursikh is blasphmized in such a way. As for the raagmaalaa debate, I do not think the necessity to resolve this problem is Khalsa Raaj, for that will eventually come. The necessity now is to leave our old attachments for sants, mahaapurshes, jathebandees etc. and think about this debate logically. On one hand we have solid proof against it not being raagmalaa. i.e. the numbering system is wrong, there is no author mentioned, it is not present in many puraatan birs, and when it is present, there are sometimes numerous other tets before it, there is no real meaning to it, etc. On the other hand, we have so and so mahapursh said this, and so and so got keeray in his mouth for not reading raagmala. Let us use the power of logic here instead of our natural inclination to believe what someone else has told us. After all we are Sikhs, it is our obligation to do vichaar of something before we follow it fullheartedly.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Prabhjoyt singh · 24 Jan 2006

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" wrote: > Akal Takhat Maryada already declares in Black and > White...."Read or DONT READ..Raagmaala as one Wishes.." > > DARE anyone..write such a Hukm about GURBANI ? NO. > > I request "Anjaan" and his cohort chelas to get up off their > arm-chairs and find any other GURBANI that is recommended to > be "NOT READ" by Akal Takhat. > > The "conclusion" is thus OBVIOUS... Raagmaala is NOT GURBANI... > we may or MAY NOT read it. Due to some constraints the Akal > Takhat was not able to come to a Definite Conclusion....BUT > this "CONCLUSION" is already there and it points to ONLY ONE > DIRECTION => Raagmaala is NOT GURBANI. > > Rest my case. > > PS. Anyone wishing to hear more of such FAIRY TALES as Bhai > jeeta Singh..go to the websites of the Pro raagmaala > "mahapurakhs". ( Personally i wonder why these fairy tale > creators CANT do some Maths first BEFORE they write these > stories.... they could have easily made Bhai jeeta Singh read > raagmaala for 80 days or 120 days...But then I guess the 40 Day > CHALISA stone hangs around their neck...how to satisfy chalisa > rule with 125,000 raagmala paaths ?? Alternatively they could > have only read say..25,000 raagmaalas..but then the Magical > 125,000 "Stone" also has to be satisfied..what a Dilemma ?? but > then all the pro-raagmaal people NEVER do any > MATHS/SCIENCE/GYAAN..they just beleive WHATEVER the Mahapurakh > says.....pathhar te lkeer hai !!!..people like Kulbir Singh Ji > always throw a spanner in their works by doing Maths ??? BAN > MATHS. Mahapurakhaan ki Jai Ho..BAN MATHS. However Akaal Taakhat Sahib also says no one is allowed to do parchar against Raagmala so Arshi Jee why are you doing so?

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Roopkaur · 24 Jan 2006

>However Akaal Taakhat Sahib also says no one is allowed to do parchar against Raagmala so Arshi Jee why are you doing so?< Akal Takht Sahib says not to attack another and condemn them for reading or not reading raagmala, nowhere does it stop the parchaar.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

singh · 25 Jan 2006

There are so many youth that say respect raags, but then we should respect the right raags. The raags in the raagmala clearly do not correspond to the raags in the Guru Granth sahib.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Jan 2006

Bhen Roop kaur Ji....interesting point....those who advocate that raagmala is NOT Gurbani...STOP right there. But those who advocate that raagmala is Gurbani...go on to CURSE and CONDEMN their opponents with such things as keerreh in the mouth/ keerreh in this organ and that organ/ JAIL time...suffering..blah blah blah blah.. Which group is following Gurmatt....your guess is as good as mine. ********************************************************* Anjaan jio, i am not a Mahapurakh... and neither am i "Giani" like the ones you admire..far from it. In my vocabulary..the ones i admire are BHAIS/Babas and Gurmukhs....beginning with Baba buddha Ji...Bhai gurdass ji...and so on. None of them is a Mahapurakh/SANT/MAHARAJ/Sri 108/Sri 1008 etc..and None of them ever claimed such titles or had their chelas bestow such on them.. I am mere dust of the feet of these Bhais and babas..and admire them, aspire to be like them....follow in their footsteps. If you Dont MIND..please STICK to the TOPIC....please dont drag in myself..many do that all the time..and when Itt da jawab patthhar nall aunda hai...its hard and also time WASTER for everyone concerned. Gurfateh Jarnail Singh.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

...Just a Singh... · 21 Feb 2006

Waheguroo.... So much of arguement over one silly squabble...Maharaj Kirpa Karen...as i dun think this thread will ever end with every1 believing in ONE answer...waheguroo..

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Dhiyalang Saroopae · 22 Feb 2006

Gyani Jee, That's one of the most exaggerated things I've ever heard. How can you say that all those who say Raagmala is Gurbani go on to say that if you don't read it this or that will happen. To make you feel better, I believe Raagmala to be Gurbani. ( FULL STOP) Rather, I find people such as yourself who can't simply say they don't believe in Raagmala and end it. You'll always have to drag in your tired old point of "Sant/Babas". How about ADMIN do us all a favor and just end this topic as this and EVERY OTHER THREAD BEFORE IT THAT TALKS ABOUT RAAGMALA GOES NOWHERE!

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

24/7 · 22 Feb 2006

is there any pro raagmala people that can explain why raagmala has diffferent raags than the Guru Granth Sahib? they do not match. Do you not this is important for an authentic raagmala? Think about, what is the point of having a contents page, if it different than the rest of the book? I am not saying Guru Ji a book, but just wondering why pro-raagmala people insist we must read something that is so blatantly incorrect.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

LionKing (LK) · 22 Feb 2006

We do we as SIkhs have such a hard time to agree to disagree?

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

gabroo · 22 Feb 2006

dear "...just a singh...", this arguement was untouched for a month. YOU just brought it back! and then complained about the arguement if it is better left... perhaps you should have left it alone, cos you've just helped continue it!!!

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Khalistan_zindabaad · 18 Dec 2006

the story of bhai jeeta singh can be confirmed from gursikhs that still remain from the time of sant gurbachan singh ji. . . if you dont believe dont, its your life do as you wish... but its wrong to say that this event did not occur. http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/video/files/TaksalRaagMaala.wmv http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/video/files/TaksalRaagMaala2.wmv do as you please. gurfateh

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Bachitar Singh · 19 Dec 2006

I really love this debate. Been a while I've seen this debate. Not because of the issues, but it really gets me going. Shall I begin 1 Where did all of this begin 2. Raag Mala's not baani - Bhai Randhir Singh 3. Sant Isher Singh wrote a letter to Bhai Randhir Singh asking him to explain himself. Now Sant Isher Singh was also a smart guy. 4. How dumb are people gonna get. When the Ragmala's read we don't read it as a novel or story we read it as baani. Now why do we read baani? I don't know my mom told me to. Wrong answer we read to get connected with the Guru. 5. The Guru is not Stupid Do you seriously think that The Guru would allow baani that was not his in the Siri Guru Granth Sahib. Now the age old question who is smarter. The Guru or man. 6. I'll gladly read ragmala and go to nark. Do you know why, cause there is a thing called trust. The only reason the Khalsa is having hardship now because you don't trust the Guru. I trust my Guru If it was not baani I believe the Guru would not let it get compliled in the Guru Granth Sahib. So therefore I read the Ragmala, to go to hell and meet my Guru who is also there according to you. What do I mean. What else do you read baani for? Of course to go to nark. 7. To the AKJ: Before you used to be a honourous bunch held to the highest esteem. I have noticed that time has made you into a cult. Being inside the bubble you might not notice, once out that bubble you get a new perspective on things. "Me being a former member." Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh was indeed a Singh. He was a Singh, you can say he was great or the best, but the best way to describe him would be a true Singh. Now why have you soiled his jatha... [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

jagroop singh · 19 Dec 2006

VahigurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahigurooJeeKeeFateh! Dear Veer Bachitar Singh Jee, you wrote: "5. The Guru is not Stupid Do you seriously think that The Guru would allow baani that was not his in the Siri Guru Granth Sahib. Now the age old question who is smarter. The Guru or man". i just wanted to point out that aside from Raagmala, other wiritings were historically present within many Puraatan Saroops yet these were expunged. 'Ratanmala' was one of these and along with many others (such as esteemed ink recipes), the Panth decided to remove it. Furthermore i believe there is at least one 'Puraatan' Bir which included the Bani of a female Bhagat whose name i forget. i think it was Meera Bai or something along those lines... All i am trying to say is that the issue of Raagmala should not be reduced to posing the question: "who accepts or doesn't accept the Bani found within Maharaj's Saroop?". It is exactly this approach which has caused antagonisms, the most remarkable being statements about who will go to nark for reading/not reading particular sections of Bani/non-Bani. Do we really think that Siree Guroo Sahib would send anyone to Nark for their faith within Gurbani, whichever side of the fence they stand? The issue of raagmala should be taken-up by the colelctive Panth via Akaal Takhat where scholars and respected Gurmukhs should meet and discuss the issue and arrive at a conclusion. Until then, we should all be respectful of those who read/do not read Raagmala, as per the currently sanctioned standpoint of Akaal Takht. If we call ourselves Panthic we should act as such. To act in any other manner would be unbecoming of the Khalsa Panth. We are not silly little children who have arguments in a playground, calling eachother names and other such things. Bhul chuk maaf karna Khalsa Jeeo.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Khalistan_zindabaad · 19 Dec 2006

If guru granth sahib jee wants some gursikh to do so many paats in a certain amount of time then it will happen. . . . e.g. sant jarnail singh ji doing more than 100 japji sahibs a day, ontop of nitenem, panj granthi and a regular sehj paat per day. . .. do the maths and it seems impossible. .. however it happened, same goes for bhai jheeta even if according to maths he did 1 in 21.8 seconds. im just saying anything possibe if guru jee wants gurfateh.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

singh5 · 19 Dec 2006

Bachitar Singh, Giani Gian Singh and Kavi Santokh Singh were WELL before Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh and both said Ragmala is NOT bani. Giani Gian Singh even writes that in a gathering of all the scholars of the Panth it was decided that Ragmala is not bani and in one saroop, Ragmala was actually erased that day. And as it has been mentioned before, there were countless fake banis added to the end of Guru Granth Sahib in the 1800s like Ratanmala and "Jit Dar Lakh Muhamada(n)" These were all taken out. Ragmala ALWAYS appeared at the end of these extra banis. It's common sense and logic that if it were Gurbani it would have come after Mundavani and then extra things after it. But because it is the last in the series of extra banis, it too is extra and should have been taken out. Do some research before commenting so strongly on issues like this.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Prabhjoyt Singh · 20 Dec 2006

Akaal takhat says read it if you want, if you dont wanna read it dont. Thats what the Panth decided, so why this issue even exists beats me. so read it if you beleive in it if you dont then dont. Dont say its kachi bani to those who read it and dont force it down anyones throat that dont belive in it. END OFF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Bachitar Singh · 22 Dec 2006

The only reason you guys don't read the baani is because Bhai Randhir Singh said it wasn't baani. Had he not you people would happly be reading ragmala.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

Khalsaspirit · 28 Dec 2006

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, If I am not wrong the topic was about falsified stories made by some uneducated culprits. There is no doubt that to have Guru Sahib’s grace (kirpa) look (drishti) on you must have infinite faith in Guru but at the same time instead of listening to Guru and his Gurmat if someone just want to fool his or her faith on some so called racial based schools (so called taksals now serving as Deras) then no one can help him to understand the Gurmat at any given time in his entire life time. SIKHI can be achieved on individual basis and the Naam Russ can be attained from Guru kirpa and can not be attained from so called Principal’s (Mahapurakh/Sant and etc) of those so called racial based schools (Deras). To understand the authenticity of so called Raagmala (Writing of poet Aalam) one must at least knowledge of Sri Guru Granth sahib ji raag/sequence/mangla charan and etc. But unfortunately mostly the so called students of these so called taksals remain uneducated in most fields of Gurmat arcane and they believe in spreding rumors. This is because of lack of education most of those are from that family background which had not had enough resources to carry out daily living or from those families who have enough earning for living but their spoiled kids who do not want to go to their farm to cut crops, lazy enough do not dare to feed their cattles and etc. They runaway from home and join these so called schools of Sikhi (taksals). Please mind it I am not condemning Taksals but the way they behave now force me to write this. Since last 30-40 years most of them are thinking to become rich by coming to foreign countries thru roots of the Dears. The roots are Sikh General Public who do not have enough time to learn Sikhi and to show their love to Guru by practicing Sikhi in their daily routine which is of course very hard and they offer cash (out of dasvandh) to these uneducated culprits to have alternate route of Guru’s path. So what ever these culprits say they accept it more than Guru’s word and there are millions of Sikhs who believe them. Rahho vichar (come back to main Subject) some one here mentioned that Raagmala is gurbani because it written in Sri Guru Granth sahib ji, then question arises if every thing written in, is gurbani then you should also recite the name of printer and his publications written in Granth Sahib. Anyway these culprits have no facts since last 150 years yet have fake stories to justify Raagmala as Gurbani and I wonder they do this in the presence of Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji. The credibility of these so called taksals is very well known to entire Sikh world now. One of their Mahapurkh/Brahamgiani lied to panth for 21 years about a Shaheed and he did this in the presence of Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji. I have no idea how much tankhayia he will be and now when panth knew about the Saheedi and finally they accepted. So you can judge for their great great Mahapurkh how much they lied and finally these culprits have to accept this that Raagmala is not Gurbani but this will take another decades to happen till then just ignore them and do your naam kamayee honestly. Other thing I like to add that they rose under the name of Khalistan not under the influlense of Gurmat from which they are far far away and I am telling you Khalistan is better off with these culprits. I like to share an experience in U.S. with these culprits how much respect they have for Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji. There was Sri Akhand path sahib going on in a Gurudwara hall. The Granthi Singh asked a Dhadi jatha to perform in evening divan parallel to akhand path sahib and they started. Imagine a patit (dhadi singh has his beard dyed and bibiyan has facial done) dhadi jatha singing loudly in a speaker system just 7 yards on the side and in so much noise pathi singh was just scanning the pages. When approached to the Granthi he said it is Damdami Taksal Maryada and even dhadi jatha mentioned it. This Gurudwara was not a dera of these culprits. I was shocked to hear that what a Maryada which tells you how to speak against living Guru and recite kachee bani against dhur ki bani. If it is true that they have this Maryada then they are not gursikhs at all they are perfact fit to Guru sahib’s bachan in Anand sahib pauree 24. They are “katchey”. And they are tankhiyay. According to Gurmat it makes no sense to even talk at place of sri Akhand path sahib because Guru himself is talking and that is what the meaning of Akhad path sahib then how some one dare to sing dhadi vaars or even do keertan at that time. So Sangat jio use your discretion to judge their level of knowledge and respect about Gurbani. And dass has several other incidents which need lot of pages to write and wastage of time to share what they do. Putting all these events together this is very much concluded that no one has trust on these fakers. It’s just matter of time you will see the Gur shabad’s power spreading over entire Sikh world and this on this entire planet as well. And this my humble request to these self claimed parchariks that what you will achieve by these fake stories --- Nothing but hate---Please for the sake of gursikhi do your Amritvela, do naam simran do hard work or jobs for honest earning. DO NOT CASH OUT INVALUABLE SIKHI ON THE NAME OF MAHAPURKHS OR SANTS. Thanks, Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh Seeker of true khalsa and khalsa raaj.

Re: Bhai Jeeta Singh and Raag

k Singh · 29 Dec 2006

that is rubbbish. AKJ and other groups like Sikh missionary, plus all the vidvaans (scholars) of the Panth do not read raagmala because the raags in it are different to the ones in the Guru Granth Sahib. The raagmala controversy started centuries before Bhai Randhir Singh. Maha Kavi Sontokh Singh rejects raagmala and taksal base most of their katha on him. He lived along time before Bhai Sahib. Bachitar singh, please read up on a subject before you make silly comments. Your arguments on this thread just make Taksalis look thick. Guru ji invented raags, so it makes sense that he would make the raagmala accurate if he was the author. But it is not accurate and he is not the author. Even taksalis recognise that. There are poems before Raagmala which have been rejected by the Panth. This includes all sants and taksal. So if AKJ is questioning the Guru Granth sahib, then so are they? The reality is no one is questioning the Guru Granth Sahib which has its end at mandavni (the seal). Raagmala is an inaccurate composition compared to the Guru Granth sahib. Taksal can spread as much hate as it wants, but the reality is what is false is not going to become truthful. It tried with its history, and failed. It tried with Sant Jarnail Singh Shaheedi and failed. Now these fake stories, which increase the image of a once great jathebandie reducing itself to liars. You say those from the time of Sant Gurbachan Singh say these stories. That does not make them truthful. It was those from the time of Sant Gurbachan Singh who said Sant Jarnail singh is still alive. Bachitaar Singh, if you wish to have this debate, then I can list so many lies on which Taksal is based.