tabla
s singh · 25 Jan 2006
wjkk, wjkf check out this tabla website http://tablamagic.tripod.com feel free to send any comments wjkk, wjkf
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
s singh · 25 Jan 2006
wjkk, wjkf check out this tabla website http://tablamagic.tripod.com feel free to send any comments wjkk, wjkf... · 26 Jan 2006
fantastic... a pro tabla player who is a singh!s · 27 Jan 2006
checked the website...he's a really good tabla player!!!........ but for me it has and always will be shri sukhwinder singh piki/namdhari................................... he has to be the current best in the world just thought id offer my two cents!A singh · 27 Jan 2006
lolzz yoooooooooo......that singhs raa bad boy at tabla, man kills it. look how he makes tin taal sound. i thought that was the most boring taal aswell, he makes it sound wikid [%sig%]a singh · 03 Feb 2006
wjkk , wjkf he is really an amazing tabla player, and this is a very interesting site, i would urge others to take a look at this site, so we can promote more people like this wjkk, wjkfdha · 05 Feb 2006
veer s ji, ive also heard sukhvinder singh pinki/namdhari....at a live concert aswell in barcelona.....he definatly is the best of the 'banaras' gharana.............id even go as far as saying as the best in india!!!!!tableji · 07 Feb 2006
LOL@best in india... check www.chakardar.com He's not the best in india, not by a long shot... Hes good, but not that good. in terms of Benaras gharana, at the moment Pandit Kumar Bose is prolly the best, student of Pandit Kishan Maharaj... Its all about the likes of Ustad Zakir Hussain (Punjab Gharana), Pandit Anindo Chatterjee (Farukhabad Gharana), Pandit Swapan Chadhuri (Lucknow Gharana). There is a student of Zakir Hussain, Rohan Singh Bhogal, aged 14 who is amazing http://video.google.com/videosearch?q=rohan+singh And over here, there is a rich lineage of tabla, in the punjab gharana, starting when the late Ustad Gurmit Singh Virdee game to England and used to take tabla classes with over 100 students at a time.. Now his best student, Ustad Hakirat Singh Rayatt, teaches and formed a tabla group called Chakardar..check www.chakardar.com His son Gurdain Rayatt is currently in india learning from who Zakir Hussain said is the best teacher in the world...Pandit Shankar Ghosh (Farukhabad Gharana). Hes been there for about 4-5 months....cant wait for him to come back oh for other information check www.tablaonline.com Fateh jiDarshan Singh Lyall · 07 Feb 2006
He's good, but not the best in the world, come on! If you don't know about tabla, and have'nt heard any players, obviuosly, you won't know. there are people much better, but he's not on a proffesional level, he's a good as some young Sikhs in England, ages 16-20. If you have'nt heard Sukhvinder Singh Namdhari, you have'nt heard anything. I would say Pinki is one of the best in the world in his league What this Singh is playing is very basic. Try to get Pinki's Rasphodic Rythem album, then you will know what tabla is.s · 07 Feb 2006
Veer Darshan Singh Ji, I totally agree with you!!! veer tablaji.....obviously ustad zahkir ji is one of the best in the world also.....ive heard harkirat ji and i can honestly say that he is a very experienced tabla player. at southall i once heard his jugalbandi performance with his group of young students....excellent!! it truly was. lol...but please do not compare these kinds of people to the likes of pinki......he is the ultimate best!!!..... he has accompanied the greatest ustads of our time.....ustad amjad ali khan sahib (sarod), amaan and ayaan khan (sons of amjad ali khan, sarod), Harisprasad chaurasia (bansari,flute), shivamani (Drummer..part of zakhir ji's team), ustad vilayat kahn sahib (sitar), viswa mohan bhat (mohan veena, guitar), pandit rajan &sajan mishra(vocal)...the list is endless. a friend from uni once showed me a recording of pinki in his younger days....around 14-17 years (he's just completed his training from pandit nihal singh) where he was accompanying bhai baljit singh....beleive me.....no one can compare.....you will never see a greater talent!!! but dont take my word for it.....ofcourse i would be bias.....recently towards the end of last year (september-october) yogesh samsi (disciple of abbaji (ustad allah rakha ji)) was touring europe and i met him in frankfurt before he was leaving to go to london.....he told me that along with abbaji and zakhir ji..... pinki is one the greatest of our time also maybe you should ask others about what they think...im sure they'll conclude with similar thoughts. please dont take this as any type of attack on you...if anything, im glad we are having these kinds of discussions....its a great topic to divulge into!!!!....... but it should be made clear that no one at present can compare to the likes of sukhvinder singh namdhari/pinki. regardsVeeru · 08 Feb 2006
Very interesting comments! lol Check out this site ! www.raag-online.comDarshan Singh Lyall · 08 Feb 2006
Singh, When I ment 'not the best in the world', I was'nt on about Pinki, I was on about the Singh on the website, who learnt from Ustad Allah Rakha. I was saying Pinki is one of the best in the world for his league, not the Singh who learnt from Ustad Allah Rakha. No-one can touch Pinki, He was the don when he was learning from Ustad (not Pandit) Nihal singh when he was a young kid. Harkirat is OK, he's not brilliant, he can play good with Kirtan, but I don't know about solo. Pinki will wax him anyday There will never be anyone as good as Pinki, or in his age group in ou time! Pinki is the only one to this day, who knows Pakhawaj properly, there is no one else who knows more Pakhawaj than him. Bhul Chuk Marf.s singh · 08 Feb 2006
wjkk, wjkf ummmm..... i only posted the original post in order to tell the sangat that there r singhs out there who r talented in the tabla world and that we should support them and others who would like to learn nowhere in the original post or on the website have i said that ustaad ji is the best tabla player in the world ustaad ji himself knows pinki and has great respect for his skills, and does not even think of comparing himself to anyone in his eyes, in punjabi gharana, ustaad zakir hussain and ustaad kulwinder singh ji (- who both learned tabla together, as ustaad kulwinder singh ji stayed with Ustaad Alla Rakha Ji at his house for about 8 years) they are one of the most talented and skilled tabla players in the world also, pinki had utmost respect for punjabi gharana and ustaad alla rakha - who in my mind was the greatest tabla ustaad of all time so yes pinki is a very talented tabla player, as is zakir hussain and just a few others at their callibre - but comparing benares and punjabi gharana is like comparing presciuos jewels - they are very valuable, yet different at the same times darshan singh lyall wrote: "What this Singh is playing is very basic. Try to get Pinki's Rasphodic Rythem album, then you will know what tabla is." singh ji, what ustad ishwer singh ji is playing here is very basic, we werer just listening to him play, when he started to play around with 'lall killa' - it is just a light look at teen taal if u or anyone would like to hear his solo performance, please go out and get 'Taal Sadhana' performed by ustaad ji along with three other tabla players and just to clarify once more, ustaad ji in no way believes that he is the best tabla player in the world, nor does he wish to be compared to the likes of his own ustaad kulwinder singh or any other accomplished tabla performer so if this discussion is going to go into naming the best tabla players, that's fine, but please just remember that ustaad ji is young and that he is still actually learning the tabla wjkk. wjkfZain · 08 Mar 2006
I heard that zakir hussain considers this kid one of the best from some people in india. He is definetly an amazing tabla player in the making.Balbir S · 08 Mar 2006
Check out there site: www.virtuosoprodn.com I saw video google tabla movie.......Rohan is an amazing tabla player.......crazy man thanks for showing me.... [%sig%]tableji · 09 Mar 2006
please check darbar.org.uk u will see which tabla players came to the festival...3 of the best in the world..somehow i dont see pinky there and yet ive had personal lessons from all of these great players...they are miles better than pinky. chakardar has been in tabla for almost 15 years and Taal before that for 20 or so years...we've had concerts by the best in the world...u dont think that a tabla ustad such as Harkirat Singh would not know who is of what calibre I think people need to seriously rethink and reassess what they assume tabla to be. If you cannot even understand the bols or the exact sounds or phrases that each tabla player produces in the composition how are u to know who is better. Also the maths element, how many out there can actually count to the beat or have heard of the jatti system? tisr, khanda, mishra?? or various laays ard, byard, quard? Look in the real world, and u will see why Zakir Hussain has year long tours around the world and is able to produce students such as Rohal Singh... and compare to Pinky...do a search in google even. tell me if there is even one student of Pinky's that can come even close to Rohan Singh? I mean no disrespect when i say the majority of sikhs are completely blind to the indian classical world, but it is the truth, and it will remain the truth until we decide that raag and these saaj which are mentioned in gurbani are given proper status. Fateh jitableji · 10 Mar 2006
oh also if u didnt know already pinky is a mona...Table Singh · 10 Mar 2006
Another great is Preetam Singh, disciple of the great Ustaad Ajit Singh Matlashi Ji.........tableji · 10 Mar 2006
Preetam Singh is good, but cannot count either... when he shows the jatti systems in his cd, he gradually makes it fit, the beats are not equal at all... the only jatti he gets properly is tisr, he messes the others up...mo · 10 Mar 2006
pinky is the best...rhapsodic rythms is an ace cd and i used to learn from him once myself. Its true he is a mona..but i guess there is no harm in taking the gunn and leaving the avgunn.Jas · 27 Jun 2006
Obviously u children who talk ill of Shiri Suhkwinder Singh ji are not old enough to take the facts. The world over Shiri Pinky ji is the only tabla playa on this earth to play 2 intruments and be master of both. Shiri Pinky ji and maybe Bhai baldeep singh ji are the only two people who are able to carry on Guru Arjan dev ji's oldest tradition of Jori pakawaj. As for pinky ji being a mona. Were not sata and balwand ji muslims who cut there hair and shaved? Yet they were the hazori rababis in the time of Guru Arjan dev ji. Gurbani says Hum nehi changay bura nahai koway. If u children are goin to judge well judge ur selves first! No 1 is perfect and evry1 is different. The problem sikhs face in todays age is they neva stick together an theyd rather pull ne1 progressin down! If sikhs stuck together, together they would have the expertises to conqure the world. As Pinky ji says 'alone we are nothin but together we are strong and nothin can effect us' And as for Tableji and compare to Pinky...do a search in google even. tell me if there is even one student of Pinky's that can come even close to Rohan Singh? How old are u singh? U most be 15 at the most! Ur argument is very biased u havnt a clue who pinky jis students are. Shiri Navinder Singh Ji. In his early twenties, Navinder Singh, is one of the most aspiring young tabla players based in England. Navinder has been brought up in a musical environment, as his father Gurdev Singh is a well-known Sarod, dilraba and tarsharnai player. Navinder is a student of the dynamic Tabla player Sukhvider Singh Namdhari, disciple of maestro Pt. Kishan Maharaj of Banaras Gharana (style). Navinder's Tabla style reflects the dynamism of his teacher and strength in rhythmic play. Navinder has given solo performances and accompanied vocal, instrumental, dance and fusion. He has featured regularly with Bhavani Shanker in his various tours. In England he has accompanied his father, Dharambir Singh (sitar), KiranPal Singh (Santoor) and Priya Pawar (dance). Navinder has played in various music conferences in India including Gunidas and accompanied internationally renowned Sarod player Ustad Amjad Ali Khan, Shahid Parvez, Shavamini and Hariprasad ji. Shiri Surdrashan singh Chana Surdarshan ji is one of Uks leadind tabla players. From the age of 9 he was already accompanying drupad singers, playin Saath (pakawaj). From then on the list goes on. Surdarshan ji has given solo performances in countries such as India, Pakistan, Israle, Rome, Germany, Denmark, France and the list is never endin. He has also accompanied vocal, instrumental, dance and fusion. In recent years he has played amongst major artists such as Kala Ramnath, Pandit Mani prasad of the kirana garana, Pandit laxman singh, Bhai Balbir singh, Shiri gurdev singh ji and the list is progressin. Shiri Dalbir Singh Rattan who has toured all over the world to countrys such as Japan, Italy and Pakistan. An currently is Tourin With Aziz Ibraham, one the best guiteristin the world. Other students include Shiri Gurdit Singh, Shiri Gurdev singh Sagoo (Who just played with Kamal Sabri and Shiyad pravez Last month) Shiri Balbir singh Ji, Shiri Probjot Singh and Shiri Sukhminder Matharu. Please also visit www. taalvadyavidiya.com [%sig%]Ram · 28 Jun 2006
thank you jas singh ji for your inspiring write up on maharajs bani and thank you for educating theese people who do not know of Shri Pinky Ji. Oh and just for the record, even if it issn't a competition, theres a story where Pinky Ji was performing a solo, infront of all of the major ustads including, Pt Kishan Maharaj, Allah Rakha, Zakir Hussain, Swapan Chaudri, Kumar Bose, Anindo Chatterji, Bikram Gosh and many other world reknowned artists. Half way through the solo Pt Kishan Maharaj got up and took hold of the microphone and asked the audience "is there anybody here today that can sit infront of my Pinky and play the way he is playing?" nobody answered....nobody stirred, from the audience you could hear the voice of Allah Rakha ji saying "kiaa baath hai". Pt Kishan Maharaj ji asked again, "is there nobody here who will dare to sit infront of the worlds greatest tabla player?" only after Pinky ji Pari Hath'd (touched the feet of) his Ustad ji did Pt Kishan Maharaj sit down and all of the audience there broke into applause, acknwledging the power and greatness that Pinky Ji held in his hands. oh and tableji i guess your one of harkirats students, well then you should know all about Shri Sudarshan ji, and how you all know that none of you can touch him. please next time think before you speak because your causing a lot of unnecesary heartache, mind you for yourself, not others. check out the site www.taalvadyavidiya.com, there you can here some demo's of Shri Pinky Ji's tabla and pakhawaj, then come back and let us know what you think. bhulla chucka ki mauf, WJKK WJKFR Singh · 28 Jun 2006
i think anuradha pal, she is the best tabla player in the world www.anuradhapal.com also a student of ustad alla rakha, check video and audio clips on her sitereality · 29 Jun 2006
this thread is funny, doesn't say anything in relation to gurmat whatsoever, total ego boost trip going on, the reality is tabla is an instrument, every instrument has master of it, heres an analogy the whole word knows of mozart other than the tabla community who's heard of pinky, basically tabla isn't on par with piano etc, though its good to excel at whatever you do for Gursikhs the tabla is an accompaionment to the baja which is tool to do the keerat of hari jas, koee gaavai raagee naadhee baedhee bahu bhaath kar nehee har har bheejai raam raajae || Some sing of the Lord, through musical Ragas and the sound current of the Naad, through the Vedas, and in so many ways. But the Lord, Har, Har, is not pleased by these, O Lord King.Observer · 30 Jun 2006
I just wanted toknow ho can this pinky guy be a singhif he is a naamdhari? Also y is Shri put infront of he's name?Redeyes · 30 Jun 2006
Chill out its just tabla. Its not even an intrument used by the Gurus. So lets all calm down..