cat/dog food
G · 10 Dec 2003
Im just woundering what you think about having Cat/Dog Food in your house... do you think its wrong because its made outa of meat? and also I have ggs in my house so do you think its wrong?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
G · 10 Dec 2003
Im just woundering what you think about having Cat/Dog Food in your house... do you think its wrong because its made outa of meat? and also I have ggs in my house so do you think its wrong?Vegetarian for Life! · 10 Dec 2003
You do know that you can buy vegetarian cat/dog food at your local safeway or superstore? C'mon what century do you live in buddy? Veggiechow is a widely available soybased vegetarian alternative to meat based cat and dog food and can be purchased at safeway or superstore in the pet food aisle. It's a bit more expensiver than the meat based cat and dog food though . . . [%sig%]new · 10 Dec 2003
Personally, i would find it gross. Do you eat meat? And what do you think of it? why are u feeding it to animals..... sure it helps.... but animals can also be given vegetarian dietskookar ram ko · 10 Dec 2003
First of all, why even keep a dog, especially if you have SGGS at your home? Just like humans have freedom, animals have the same rights. But if you want to know what I think well here goes: I personnally think that if you gave meat to somebody so they can eat it, I think that that is a big sin. So why would you feed meat to any animal?Vegetarian for Life! · 10 Dec 2003
Please see this site. Problem solved G! You can have the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee at your house and have your cat or dog too. www.veggiepets.comGABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 10 Dec 2003
to kookar ram ko, dogs and cats are demostic animals they can't live without humans, they need human love and kindess (they give plenty of their own 2 us). depending on climate a dog can be a vegi, look at dogs in punjab they only eat roti and dood, but here wher ei live its freezing she requires her meats, so we provide it no choice, otherwise she'll die... · 11 Dec 2003
ouch some people talk a little harsh on this site... we should accuse people of being wrong if theyre just asking a question :s.. they didnt ask us to judge themIGNORANCE · 11 Dec 2003
I really cant believe im hearing this......are u guys soooooo blind. Dogs are canines......canines are animals that primarily eat meat. Their bodies are made in such a way to eat meat. We are human....omnivors......we can live fine eating veggie(or better). DOGS ARE MEANT TO EAT MEAT honestly.....you guys dont understand the point of eating or not eating meat in Sikhi........ we are humans.......free will......free mind..... animals do not have this.....they live by instinct....there is no such things as an evil animal.......just acts in nature...if they eat meat its because their supposed to what are u going to do........feed grass to a lion I am a veggie......i have a dog.......and i feed him meat all the time...he needs it.....im not going to give him some soy protien stuff......his body was evolved for meat.... you guys act and talk like hindus......go understand the faith...go read the SGGS..... man.....such pointless foolishness....... · 11 Dec 2003
If you look at the natural order of things (i.e. the way Waheguru intended things!!!) you will see that dogs and cats that are in the wild (i.e. wolves, jackals, lions, tigers) all eat meat. As such, my dog is only fed meat (the dry kind). Thats the way god intended it, and thats the way I will continue to feed my dog. As far as having a SGGS, once I get the knowledge of how to take care of SGGS, I will keep it in my house. We recently had akhand paath at our house, and our dog which was used to going into every room would not come into the room that we used for divaan. Dogs know what is right and wrong. To be honest, the joy that my dog gives our family, I would give it nothing less than the best food possible. WJKK WJKFmy thoughts... · 11 Dec 2003
Obviously, it is a personal decision on whether one should feed meat to their dogs or not, or to even keep a pet at all. The way I look at it is that we shouldn't make another person(I use the term loosely..refering to both humans and animals) do anything that we wouldn't do ourselves. Because if we do then we contradict our beliefs. How can you justify that it is okay to feed the dog meat, however, it is wrong for yourself? A life is still being taken to feed the dog. And the reason that meat is a primary food for dogs doesn't really cut it, there are always other options. I think that dogs have been living with humans for long enough that they can adjust, unless you got your dog from the wild, which I doubt:). There is no way a Gursikh can say that it is wrong for me to eat meat but it is okay for me to condone it by feeding meat to my pets. It doesn't make sense! It might be best not to keep pets at all!singh · 11 Dec 2003
my thoughts do you understand animal anatonomy...have you ever taken a course on biology. do you understand the conept of herbivore and carnivore. DOGS ARE CARNIVORES.........they eat meat a primary source of food..... that is how their bodies are made and evolved. are u telling me that in natural any animal that eats meat is bad? what are u saying......it makes perfect sense to feed an animal what it is natural for it to eat. you said yourself <<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>> its is not wrong for me to eat meat.......it is simply benificail to my spirituality and personally i think, to the world......humans evolved in a way so this was possible......dogs on the other hand cannot....... in nature wolves and lion always kill other animals for food.....is this wrong....are u so ignorantJagroop Singh · 11 Dec 2003
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! I think 'my thoughts' is right - why keep pets at all... We try not to be attached to family, friends etc...why would we then also keep animals? Animals such as horses, falcons which Guru Sahib and other Gursikhs used were being trained/implemented for a Higher Purpose and so do not count as pets. Anyhow, how would a Gurmukh 'handle' maas...full stop. This point circumvents the whole debate about what is the animal's natural diet etc. The point is: Lets leave 'pets' where they belong - in the wild. The only reasons dogs/cats are so used to humans is because we domesticated them over hundreds of years and are still 'redesigning' them to suit our needs. Thats why dogs such as alsations have dodgy hips and bull-dogs have breathing problems etc. because humankind tries to play Vahiguru and messes up. Bhul chuk maaf karna. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!Gaiani · 11 Dec 2003
I think the key word here is "NATURE", used in the context as in "NATURE". I may be wrong, but I don't think your house, or anyones hoouse for that matter, is "NATURE". I think the jungle is nature, the forest is nature, not your house.GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 11 Dec 2003
100% agree with singh ... and ignorance very good points to who say dogs should be vegis, try feeding ur dog a vegitable, theres noway in helllll ...... plus guru ji kept a baaj who ate meat all da time.....even tho guru ji did'nt...sooo.....g · 12 Dec 2003
well ill let you guys know what I do personally... I have around 20 cats at my home... they dont stay inside they live outside most of them are wild they go off and do there own thing I have about 5 that are tame and I let in the house sometimes and Im planing on getting a dog, I feed them dry cat food and I have never seen Veggie cat food I live in Califonia that sounds like something hippies would create veggie cat food.. but anyways we do keep ggs in our house and I see nuting wrong with feeding cats or dog meat... its the natural order of things... you said a life is still being taken to feed the dog... well thats how it was meant to be and maybe its helping that soul move on to the next life so he can become human eventually, the reason I brought it up because I once had someone get mad at me for havin cat food in my house... and I thought it was soo silly cats and dogs eat meat thats how it is... and you ask why keep pets at all? well pets are loyal alot more loyal than many "Gursikhs" I have known. and about cats and dogs being wild... cats are independant my cats run off whereever they like they roam wild they go to the neighbors.. I live out in the country side... and for dogs... all the dogs I have ever had ran free too they allways did what they liked... but Guru ji made dogs how they are... we did not make them that way what makes you think we can take credit for anything... dogs are domestic thats just how it is... so its not wrong I dont care how you look at it. but your all intitled to your own opinions I just find it silly the stuff that has been said on here... bottom line Dogs and cats eat meat even if you fed them a vegitarian diet they still hunt... my cats hunt birds and goffers ... mice all kinds of stuff like that so doesnt matter if you fed them vegitarian chances are they are going to find some meat and eat it unless you kept them chaged and tied up all the time... but then again wouldnt that be wrong? haha anyways thats just my take on the situationGABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 12 Dec 2003
jagroop singh try returning the thousands millions billlions of dogs and cats and other domestic animals to the wilderness :) its called mass murder and what about the cow we get our milk from, thats wrong 2 then... · 12 Dec 2003
Gabroo, As far as milk...drinking milk is naturally wrong. If you look at other species, the human species is the only one that drinks milk. All species are supposed to drink milk for the first years (from their own species, not another species). Milk is a maternal lactating secretion, a short term nutrient for new-borns. Nothing more, nothing less.The enzyme Lactase in humans breaks down milk, and humans only have a limited supply of lactase (enough for the first few years). After this, our lactase supply breaks down, and this is when you get lactose intolerance (i.e. the body cant break down milk in the digestive system). Milk is not just milk. The milk of every species of mammal is unique and specifically tailored to the requirements of that animal. For example, cows' milk is very much richer in protein than human milk. Three to four times as much. It has five to seven times the mineral content. However, it is markedly deficient in essential fatty acids when compared to human mothers' milk. Mothers' milk has six to ten times as much of the essential fatty acids, especially linoleic acid. (Incidentally, skimmed cow's milk has no linoleic acid). It simply is not designed for humans. Fifty years ago an average cow produced 2,000 pounds of milk per year. Today the top producers give 50,000 pounds! How was this accomplished? Drugs, antibiotics, hormones, forced feeding plans and specialized breeding; that's how. So why is milk pushed as healthy?? 2 words - the Milk Councils. These groups are very powerful lobby groups. In fact, go to www.notmilk.com to see why milk is really bad for us.Jagroop Singh · 13 Dec 2003
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, I believe Guru Sahib has ultimate respect for animals, trees etc. and loves them all as He loves us. GurSikhs see Vahiguru in everything therefore they can't help but love all Creation for what it is...now why would they want to domesticate Creation for the sake of having a pet? Gabroo Khalistan Dah, my point exactly...us humans are jokers sometimes! Look at how many animals we have INTENTIONALLY made dependent upon ourselves...the situation is so bad that your point about trying to release billions of animals is absolutely correct. However we can make a change; stop keeping pets...encourage others to do so - appreciate Vahiguru's Nature for what it is...WHERE IT IS. Even better, let's try and do something for animal rights...a GurSikh friend of mine is heavily involved with the animal rights scene in the UK and just having Guru Sahib's Roop amongst other protestors at rallies and demonstrations is excellent...he always gets asked questions about why he is there etc. and in this way does Guru Sahib's Seva by spreading the message of Guru Sahib...love towards all sentient and non-sentient beings. Bhul chuk maaf karna. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!G · 13 Dec 2003
how can you say we made animals dependent on us... we didnt do that Guru ji did it... its how he made them how can we take credit for that... everything is the way it is because it was Guru ji's hukamGABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 13 Dec 2003
yo man dogs n' cats are chilin 2 have, ur not depriving them of ne thing i don't under stand how that is "wrong"?G · 13 Dec 2003
its not wrong... you could use the same argue ment with humans if you want... we where born wild why do we have all these restrictions laws.. way we have to live why would be even have religion then... how far do you want to take it... back in the begining their wasnt any religion there wasnt cars there wasnt anything... so if your going to use that arguement for animals why dont you go live in the woods with no clothes no food no nuting.. because thats how we started.... · 13 Dec 2003
HAHAHAHAHA this is the funniest post i've read in along LONG time!!!! first saying we shud make our pets vegetarian, and then on top of that saying we shud realize them back into nature as they shud be!!!!! Pets aren't the only things that are domesticated.... ppl are too... maybe all humans shud go back to living in caves and the jungle, cuz thats how it should be!!!! and as someone previously said, no animal is being deprived.... the only way we are depriving them, is by trying to make them vegitarian when their bodies are made to eat meat!!!! Mass isn't against sikhi, EATING MEAT for a SIKH is wrong.... an animal eating it isn't, do u think if guru jee came up against a dead animal and found another animal eating it, it would stop that animal???? isnt THAT against DIVINE WILL!! As humans we shud have compassion for animals, and not eat their flesh for spiritual reasons...... animals dont have this level of thinking... maybe its their punishment to be in the body of a dog and have to eat meat, who knows..... why mess it!!! And wats wrong wid pets, their great companions, and loyal.... if i had a cat or something, i'd let it wander whereva it wanted, even into the baba jee's room..... WHY???? i say why not....... cats are cleanier than humans, and as long as it doesn't go sit on guru jeee..... its all good, maybe it just wants darshan, or wants to sit there while doing kirtan... who knows...... But please stop being so DAYMED RETARDED PPL!!!!!Jagroop Singh · 14 Dec 2003
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, 'G', Ofcourse, all is in Vahiguru's Hukam...please forgive me for misscommunicating my point. 'Gabroo Khalistan Dah', further to valid issues about deprivation, mistreatment etc. It comes down to a simple fact: Vahiguru has placed specific animals in specific environments. There is a reason for this, because Vahiguru is The Perfect Creator. Let's look at it another way; how would you like it if a 'superior' more highly evolved alien species turned up on our planet and decided to make us pets and then took us out of our 'natural environment' for their own gratification? In terms of Sikhi, as already stated earlier, Guru Sahib and Gursikhs kept animals for specific higher purposes - imagine how blessed those animals were...being able to serve Guru Sahib and the Gursikhs e.g. falcons, horses etc. Guru Sahib (Guru Har Rai Sahib) also kept animals (as well as plants) in what i think may have been a 'reservation type' intitiative in order to protect certain species and to promote the use of natural ayurvedic medicines...Guru Sahib was a conservationist and it is said his love for animals was awesome (as was Bhagat Puran Singh's love...it is said that whenever he would find a dead animal, however small or large, he would always carry out funeral rites on that Creation of Vahiguru). A person who loves animals and still eats meat, in my mind, doesn't quite love them. A person who keeps animals, primarily for their own pleasure also doesn't quite love them in the purest sense of the word... ...not too mention the fact that they would have to feed them meat which would undoubtedly affect their own Gursikhi Jeevan. If you want to protect your house, buy a burglar alarm... I won't post any more on this topic because it would be futile...this murakh has made his limited point and to carry on doing so would only make him more egotistical than he already is. I respect all the Gursikhs who gave their opinion in this thread and helped my limited understanding. Bhul chuk maaf karna. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahigure ji ki fateh!G · 14 Dec 2003
I had a cat that loved going in babjis room he would go sit under ggs all the time... he never went ontop and he never got babjis room dirtykakaree · 16 Dec 2003
There are good points made for and against this question. Animals have a short digestive sysem made for meat, they require certain nutrients that are not in a 100% veg diet. For dogs this can be supplimented with eggs tofu and brewers yeast and brown rice. Cats are more complicated, they will die on a veg diet. However most cats and dogs that can, will hunt. People on the other hand have a very long GI tract. It is harmful for them to eat meat, because it takes up to a week for it to get through their system. Plenty of them do anyway and have all kinds of disease like heart disease colon cancer from doing so. People smoke too and ruin their lungs. Our gurus gave us practical guidelines to live by, but people like to turn these into fanatic rituals. There are so many sikhs who eat meat. They will argue until they die of it that it is ok to do. People keep animals for a variety of reasons. And as previously mentioned so did our gurus. Instead of being so preaching and imposing our personal views on each other about whether its right or wrong, it would be nice to see solution oriented posting. If we don't like cat/dog food in the house lets figure out a better place for it. One problem is that cat and dog food smell bad. It makes the kitchen and house have unpleasant odors. Seems like it would be better if it could be kept out of the house in a shed or someplace else. Also it seems like a good idea that what ever dishes are used the household are not shared with animals. The animals are not amritdhari and it does mention in SRM that amritdhari should not share a bowl with those who are not. Seems like this would include animals, especially wild ones that may not be treated for worms and other disease that can be caught by humans. It's a lot of responsibility to keep a domestic animal, similar in some ways to having a young child, especially when it comes to baba jis room. There has to be controlled supervision to prevent mistakes and unintentional disrespect. I can kind of guess that those opposed to keeping animals would also be opposed to nuetering them. This is another area of responsibility, if they are not to be allowed to breed uncontrollably. With humans we impose social (religious) restrictions, and hope for the best. This is simply not going to work with animals. They must be confined. Some people including gursikhs like to manipulate the breeding of animals for specific outcomes. I am reminded him of The story of Bhai Randhir Singh when he was imprisoned and force fed by a one legged jailer. He previously had a dream of a past life and actions that were coming to fruit in his present life. It's good to be aware there is a bigger picture. There may be a reason an animal and human share this life. What ever circumstances we find ourself in let us remember to keep focused on simran and gurbani. Then maybe we have the chance to break out of the ongoing endless cycle by Gurprasaad. [%sig%]Singh 0 · 17 Dec 2003
Interesting I would like to see anyone make a cat vegetarian. Although you will be able to feed it bread and carrots at home outside it will catch animals and eat meat as that’s what nature, which Waheguru Ji made intended. To even suggest such a thing is so funny and unscientific and unsikhi in my eyes. Why can’t people understand the basic laws of nature which God made ie animals feed off each other. Even early man used to hunt years before even considering becoming a Veggie. It’s the natural way as without predators (cats, Lions or what ever) the World simply couldn’t function and would be over full with vermin. Any one who disagrees with the way Waheguru Ji has made the World should think who know best at the end of the daySingh 0 · 19 Dec 2003
Any opinions from my post from Vegiterian For Life, I await a responce.ridiculous · 19 Dec 2003
I can't believe I am reading this in here... this is absolutely unbelieveable... guru pyareee sadh sangat jee... so many mahapurkhs, shaheed singhs and singhneeaa of the past had gaatraas, shaster cases, shaster handles, tablas, and much more made from chamra (leather). A lot of clothing is made by insects. Butter and milk have the fat of the cow in them. These are all maas. All meat. If you can have these in the presence of Guru Granth Sahib, what is it about dog food ? We are not supposed to EAT meat - it brings our avasthaa down. It is bad for our health. It is not part of our nature. However that is because we have MAANAS DEHI... human body... which can acheive union with Waheguroo... it is a fragile clay pot... a very gentle and delicate tool our SOUL must use to get to God... therefore we don't jeopardize our avasthaa by eating meat but for ANIMALS - it's their DHARAM KHAND .. it's their REALM OF DUTY AND RELIGION to eat meat and to be wild in instinctSingh 0 · 22 Dec 2003
ridiculous I agree with you that maas isn’t an issue. But must point that that you are wrong that’s its not our nature to eat meat, infact we are not 100% herbivores early made used to eat meat and being an vegetarian is a very new phenomena in accordance with the history of man. As for your theory about leather and not eating meat it simply doesn’t make hence and hence cannot be Gurmat. You are arguing that its fine to kill innocent animals to wear their skins, as puratan Singhs did so. But on the other hand you argue its wrong to eat meat as it brings our avashta down. Excuse me but how can you justify this ridicules contradiction, you are saying its fine to kill but just don’t eat them.Mkhalsa · 22 Dec 2003
I beleive Kulbir Singh Jee explained this in a post a long time ago. You are what you eat and the pain and suffering of that animal will effect you for a long time.Singh 0 · 23 Dec 2003
Mkhalsa Yes indeed you are what you eat, which is why some Sikhs think its wrong to eat meat. However as you point out the pain and suffering you cause to animals will affect you but pain, death and suffering are created when we kill for leather, the only difference is that we don’t eat the dead corpse. Hence should we not kill for leather etc but this contradicts Sikh facts which show Puratan Singhs used to have leather saddles and buffalo shields on their backs etc.AKALI · 23 Dec 2003
Mr. Singh O, Tabla skins etc are made from skins of animals that die naturally. Singhs have too much daya (mercy/compassion) to kill an innocent creature.