Forum
Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 27 Mar 2006
Dear visitor to this website :
Please make clear to the definition/details in the present era of Sehajdhari Sikhs, Clean-shaven Sikhs, Sardar, Sikh, Singh and Khalsa.
Please be confined to the subject only; and no deviation to Jathebadis or organizations, without any biased attitude and angerness. Let us disucss with love and affection, for the sake of Sikhi and Sikhism.
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh
[address removed]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
MEHAK · 27 Mar 2006
Professor Singh,
This is a good subject and needs to be discussed by all of us.
Sikhi needs it. We need it in USA and Canada. I would love to read replies from JS Arshi/Kulbir Veer ji/LK/Sidhu ji and others.
MEHAK
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Dil Hindustani · 27 Mar 2006
A Punjabi article on 'Sahajdharis':
http://www.amritworld.com/rahatnama_bhai_chaupasingh_ik_adhiyain/sahajdhari.pdf
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jiti Singh · 27 Mar 2006
Am I alone in being bemused by the email address "[address removed]" of the Prof.?
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
sk (Satnam kaur) · 27 Mar 2006
Piyari sadh sangat ji,
We talk very long on many topic. This topic is our fundamental. Now, nobody is coming up. It looks we have no much knowledge. We ladies are married to all the above categories men. All should come out and write for knowledge, please.
SATNAM KAUR
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Lakhvir Singh · 28 Mar 2006
WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.
KhalsaJi,
In my humble opinion, to make matters easier for me to comprehend and follow, I would only like to say that all those terms are mere contradictions of the one term that matters over all - Sikh.
Gurbani makes mention of just Sikh and GurSikh. I understand the usage of those two terms as almost one and the same, though in depth, they mean quite different things. We can deduce the different meanings through our own level of understanding. Accodring to Gurbani, a Sikh is one who is attuned to the teachings of Guru, while GurSikh is one who practice the Guru's instructions.
How do we define Sikh, let alone sehajdhari, sardar, singh, khalsa or clean-shaven? The word 'Sikh' is attached to all other terms. So it is imperative to first define who a Sikh really is. Gurbani defines that clearly, no argument about that (Gur Satgur Ka Jo Sikh Akhaaye . . .) and any other definition we add to that would amount to manmat.
In essence, a Sikh is only he/she that is defined by the Guru's word, not by our own thinking. So when we talk about a sehajdhari, sardar, singh, khalsa or clean-shaven, we are refering to one who is on the Sikh path but does not become one unless he/she follows the instruction of the Guru. According to Gurbani, Sikh and GurSikh score the highest marks on the relationship between the Guru and His disciple.
We would be lying to ourselves by branding ourselves anything outside the definition of a Sikh by terming ourselves as amritdharis, sehajdharis, singhs, kaurs, sardars etc. A Sikh is a Sikh, and is defined only by the Guru in Gurbani which is the ultimate say of the Guru. When we follow what the Guru instructs, then we become Sikh. Until that happens, we can call ourselves anything, really, but in truth, we are far from being a Sikh.
WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
sk (Satnam kaur) · 28 Mar 2006
Lakhvir Singh ji,
Very good. I like your expression.
Where are Veer JS Arshi and Kulbir singh/LK/Sidhu/Kaur/Confused.
Where are our ladies, who show their utmost sewa in all Gurudwaras.
SATNAM KAUR
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jiti Singh · 28 Mar 2006
Sikh Rehat Maryada:
Chapter I
The Definition of Sikh
Ariticle 1
Any human being who faithfully believes in
(i) One Immortal Being,
(ii) Ten Gurus, from Guru Nanak Dev to Guru Gobind Singh,
(iii) The Guru Granth Sahib,
(iv) The utterances and teachings of the ten Gurus and
(v) the baptism bequeathed by the tenth Guru, and who does not owe allegiance to any other religion, is a Sikh.
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
P.S.Sandhu · 28 Mar 2006
Respeted MPSingh Ji,
Thou may not be absolutely right..let me try to put few words as answer to explain your words of question :
Who is a Sikh, Sehjdhari Sikh, khalsa, Sardar, Singh :
A person who believes in Gurmat, takes amrit , wears five K's uniform and follow the reht becomes a Sikh (I am writing Sikh, S capital). Otherwise a believer in Gurmat is a Sehjdhari, a "sikh" (sikh, s, small), i.e a person on his way to taking Amrit, becoming a Sikh and thus being a full and visible member ( we can say he/she is Khalsa, means pure) of the Sikh Panth.
Sehjdhari Sikhs is a contradiction in terms. Having become a Sikh, one is no more a Sehjdhari. In the other case, "Sehjdhari sikh the word sikh is redundant because Sehjdhari means a sikh moving on the path to be a Sikh(Singh).
Sehjdharis are wellwishers, supporters and helpers of the Panth, and they have to be respected as such. It is no favor to them, they deserve it and it is an obligation for the Sikhs to treat them that way.
Sehjdharis have an analogus status in the Panth. Even though they are not visible (keshadhari) members of the panth, they play a very important and vital role in the Panthic affairs. They have their beliefs in Gurmat, their close relationship with the Sikhs and their moral , social and financial support to the panth. In short they are the wellwishers of the Panth.
There is a common example to explain the status of the Sehjdharis in the Panth. Many persons from all over the world have moved to USA and have become residents- aliens. They are considered Americans for all purposes but they can not vote, because of not having become citizens by taking the oath of loyality to the nation. As a resident-alien needs to take an oath to claim membership of the country, a Sehjdhari (a resident of the Sikh community) needs to take Amrit(oath) to be a member (citizen) of the Panth before he can participate in the decision making (voting and becoming a member of the Sikh institutions/Gurdwaras) of the panth.
It is to be mentioned that keeping long hair and tying turban alone does not make one a member of the Panth. It is both the faith and practices of the reht which make one a Sikh. Those who do not believe in Guru Gobind Singh and Amrit ceremony founded by him ( who gave Sikhs suffixes Singh and Kaur) are not Sikh. Sikhs are thus Sikh and Singh both. more appropriately Sikh is who follows teahing of Gurus , Gurmat principles and learner of faith as much as possible and Singh is one who along with Sikh also blesses and worships arms/shastras as per advised by our Tenth master and after undertaking Amrit becomes Khalsa : The Tenth master said rightly :
Aas kirpaan khando kharag tupak tabar aur teer,
saaif sirohi saithi yahi hamaare peer !!
Thus it is the origin of the concept Saint Soldier ( Sikh + Soldier)
radha Swami, false Nirankaris, communists and many others who do not believe in Amrit, even though they keep hair and tie turbans, are not Sikhs. They are not even Sehjdharis because they do not believe in Gurmat preached by Guru Nanak Dev. They believe in another faith and they practice what was rejected by the Gurus. One can not be a member of two faiths at the same time, for example, a Hindu and a Muslim, a Sikh and a Hindu or a Sikh and a Radha Swami.
Sardar is a title name which Sikhs use as prefix towards their names. Sardar means who is leader or head of some group or congregation. Sikhs use Sardar word coz they are leaders of torch bearers of the Panth and on them lies the responsibilities of putting the Sikhism in forefront.
and lastly.. what does a clean-shaven Sikh means ?
I am still searching the answer. infact more in the sense how this term originated ? I am seeking answer from learned fellows of the forum.
waheguru ji ka khalsa.
waheguru ji ki fateh !!
Parminder Singh.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
sk (Satnam kaur) · 28 Mar 2006
P.S.Sandhu, Bha ji,
beautiful, I like your answer. Guru Kirpa Kare. if possible, write on the left over portion also, please.
Thx.........
SATNAM KAUR
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
P.S.Sandhu · 28 Mar 2006
A simple question, lets say if some westerner asks me ...do Sikhs cut hair ?. My immediate answer will be ..No !, hair is the identity of a Sikh. But if the same question will be asked by south asian, asian-western, I will also give same answer. just ponder on the issue.....the first person wil ask, are Sikhs liberals ?.....but just think why the same question is not coming from the mouth of south-asian ....here the same question again haunts our mind, Why Sikhs keep long hair and why girls set priority over clean shavens, so called Sikhs ?.
So by defintion clean shaven Sikhs : they belive in Sikh faith, they call them liberal, far far away from rehats and Gurmat.
The most prompt answer ofcourse will come from the followes of clean shaven sikh faith or so called liberal sikh faith :" Anyway what has long hair to do with the faith of a person ?. One can be honest, truthful, and religious without keeping long hair".... anyway most suitable answer holds in that deciding not to join the khalsa ( a Sikh who faith in 5 k's and follow rehit), did n't mean the Sikhs , the disciples were no longer good persons, an impression which some sikhs mistakenly express about them ... such sikhs we can call slow adopters...slow follwers of Panth...or can say shejdharis too... being follwers of Guru they are wellwishers and supporters of Sikh Panth. they always sided with the Panth and suffered with them...
but the question will remain unanswered... till sikhs ( "s" small ) stay away from Gurmat, rehat put forward by Gurus and Sikh History. the enlightenment of these precious jewels automatically takes us in the fold of Khalsa..the race of pure's...as further when Sikhs hear in the daily prayers :
jinnah singhaan singhniaan ne dharam hit sees ditte , band band katwaaaeee...... dahram nahi haarya , sikhi keshaan swaashaan naal nibhaai !!
" Those who sacrificed their heads, got themselves cut joint by joint ....but lived their faith along WITH THEIR UNCUT HAIR."
waheguru ji ka khalsa.
waheguru ji ki fateh !!
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
sanjo · 28 Mar 2006
i dont think there is such a thing as a clean shaven sikh. if u aint amritdhari with rehit then u aint a sikh. sehajdharis myt be well wishers as bhai sahib put it but they aint sikhs. sikh means student to my knowledge and a student follows the teachings of his teacher or guru, so if u cant follow the teachings of keeping hair or taking amrit then u aint a true student therefore not a sikh.
for me a sikh and a khalsa is one and the same. as to be a sikh in my opinion u msut take amrit and therefore become a khalsa.
thats my opinion but i dont see the confusion over definitions it seems simple to me but then again i myt be wrong and may not have grasped the idea behind this post.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jiti Singh · 29 Mar 2006
sanjo, you are talking about Khalsa, not Sikh.
Sikh Rehat Maryada definition of a Sikh, which I have quoted above, tells us what a Sikh is. If your kesh are cut you can still be a Sikh.
This is universally agreed Sikh Rehat Maryada as published by SGPC.
If you don't like it, or you don't agree with it, that's your own problem. The definition is there in black and white.
Jiti Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jeewan Singh · 29 Mar 2006
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
If you believe in something, you don't go against it. A person who cuts their hair and calls themselves a Sikh is a Sikh by no means, not even by the Sikh Rehat Maryada as some claim. Believing doen't mean just acknowledging something, it means that you accept it as being true. If you cannot accept the rules of the Guru as being true, you can never believe in teachings of the Guru.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
MEHAK · 29 Mar 2006
Dear Jugroop singh/Kulbir Singh/JS Arshi - Singho
You also please come out with your knowledge and do not hide. Good people have written with wisdom, on this basic and very important topic.
MEHAK
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jiti Singh · 30 Mar 2006
Jeewan Singh, this is what is called a "holier than thou" attitude. There are millions of Sikhs who do not keep their kesh, or who trim their beards, or other variations. Yet they do Jap Ji Sahib every morning, they go to Gurdwara regularly and do sewa, they are good human beings with pleasant personalities, always willing to help. They love Sikhi, they read Gurbani and perform rauL duties during akhand paatths.
These people do not owe allegiance to any other faith. They were born in Sikh families, have been brought up as Sikh, think of themselves as Sikh, and they are Sikh. But they are not Khalsa.
So what do you propose to call these people?
Jiti Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
PTE SINGH · 30 Mar 2006
To be part of any thing requires firstly an outward proclamation and then a diciplined dedication to that cause. By becoming a Sardar you are taking that initial step.
A sardar makes that proclamation of being a Sikh, he requires faith, dedication and dicipline in every day life, he is representative of his faith and judged by it. His life is diciplined to take care of his kesh and distar at all times. A Sardar is a 24 hour Sikh.
A Baptised Sikh or SINGH is then taking his dicipline and dedication to its highest and complete level.
A person who does not keep his hair or distar makes no such outward proclamation, and has taken no initial step into Sikhi. They offer no dedication and no real faith.
I have known many Hindu Punjabi's both in the UK and in India and every single one acknowledges the divinity of the 10 Gurus and their houses adorn pictures of them. They wear Kara, they go to Gurudwaras and partake in all the Sikh holy festivals.
How are they different to all the millions of monna lads who put on a khanda t shirts and think they are Sikhs. For those t shirts come off when they put on a football shirt or a shirt and tie for the office or if walking through Bradford on their own. A sardar is a sardar in the office on the terraces of Highbury or standing in the middle muslim ralley at Trafalgar Square.
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jiti Singh · 30 Mar 2006
Jeewan Singh, this is what is called a "holier than thou" attitude. There are millions of Sikhs who do not keep their kesh, or who trim their beards, or other variations. Yet they do Jap Ji Sahib every morning, they go to Gurdwara regularly and do sewa, they are good human beings with pleasant personalities, always willing to help. They love Sikhi, they read Gurbani and perform rauL duties during akhand paatths.
These people do not owe allegiance to any other faith. They were born in Sikh families, have been brought up as Sikh, think of themselves as Sikh, and they are Sikh. But they are not Khalsa.
So what do you propose to call these people?
Jiti Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Isher Singh · 30 Mar 2006
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh,
According to Jiti Singh a person who cuts his hair is a sikh and that too according to Sikh Rehat Maryada.
Jiti Singh can you answer one simple question , we Sikhs all over the world do Ardas to waheguru and ask waherguru
Hey Akal purakh waheguru, Sikhan nu Sikhi daan, Kesh Daan, Rehat Daan,Bisah Daan,Bhrosa Daan te Daana sir Daan NAAM Daan,...
we ask waheguru for Kesh, and what do you think those fellows who cut their hair even after asking for them are Sikh, do they follow the teachings of Our Guru Sahiban, decide yourself choice is yours.
One thing here these fellow who cut their hair and still call themselves Sikh should not ask Waheguru for the same or they should not do Ardas at all.
According to me there is no such things like clean shaven Sikhs.
The road to Sikhi is full of hardships and always ask for sacrifice , it is like walking on the edge of Kirpan, did they forgot the teaching of Guru Nanak Dev ji who said
Jeo Teo Prem Khelan kaa Chaoo,
Sir thar tali gali merey aao,
Ethoo Marg Pair Dhreejay,
Sir deejay par Kaan na Keejay.
You decide yourself (all the so called liberal sikhs/clean shaven sikhs) are you worthy of calling yourself Sikh. Please do'nt fool yourself and others.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
singh · 30 Mar 2006
Reading the book "amrit ki hai" by bhai sahib randhir singh ji,I came to know that he prepared himself for amrit for a period of 2 years,i think from 23 to 25.He used to long meditaitons in these 2 years.So wouldnt he be called a sikh during these 2 years.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
... · 30 Mar 2006
There are "cultural Sikhs" and people that have the "Sikh label". This is almost a cultural title.
If someone wants to be a spiritual Sikh, then that in my opinion only starts fully after initiation of Amrit.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jeewan Singh · 30 Mar 2006
Jiti Singh, one cannot pick and choose what to believe. Thats like saying one had filled out 8/10th of a test, and still expect to get a full 100% on it because the 8th they filled out is "perfect." That doesn't make sense. If one cuts their hair, they have given up so much that the Guru has given them.
bhaeddaa vaagee sir khohaaein bhareean hathh suaahee ||
Their hands are smeared with ashes, and the hair on their heads is plucked out-they are like sheep!
It doesn't seem like Guru Ji approves of removing hair.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
P.S.Sandhu · 30 Mar 2006
There are two things:
One, those who called themselves Sikhs.. born in sikh families and get the certificate of Sikhs. this category can include all what ever we can think ...clean shavens , liberals, sehjdharis, sardars.
Second, who are true Sikhs, follow strict code of conduct prescribed by Gurus and they also want the other to follow the same coz they see the formers are going away from what Guru had advised. and as per my understanding goes, very limited souls comes in this category on whom waheguru bless His blessings. One can include Brahamgyanis, who have given major directions to Khalsa Panth in this category.. Baba Deep Singh ji, Bhai Manni Singh, Bhai Taru Singh to name a few.
The second category in the eyes of people are orthodox or hard core followers. so one can ask ourself why are only orthodox/hard core followers are incharge of Guru's spiritual centres.. Gurdwaras., leading Panth in difficult times.... why they are only who do daily ceremonies...bless millions amirit..and many others Sikh ceremonies..... some of my friends here also said here that people of other faiths also adorn Sikhism in India and abroad .. I fully agree with that ..but one thing I wana ask my respected brother with request ...I am not sure about outside India , but in India... countless atrocities have been commited on Sikhs...to supress their genuine causes .. and only Sikhs comes out to ask for their identity and their share... so my question to my respected fellow is " where goes then these silent followers of sikh faith?". they never ever voice their opinions..they never made any peace rally of protest on the Sikhs ..here the suspicions arises What they are then following ?
there are many non-sikh followers in many metero cities India...u go to Gurdwaras ..you can get the answer...but where these followers goes when after two and half decade the major political party of country says ...we are sorry for Sikh pogram.. and when poor souls protest ..they throw water cannon on them and batton beating to disperse.
they did n't protest for those with whom they pray ?
they did n't demand or share their anger ?
Is n't this blind faith for Sikhs to trust these things ? or its a just to assure that we are very amicable towards Sikhism and we really admire ( I am using word admire, thou it is too small) Sikhs, for the contribution of their Gurus and many great Sikhs of the past. In my terminology this is a hyprocracy not following the faith.
malice towrds none ....
waheguru ji ka khalsa.
waheguru ji ki fateh!!
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jiti Singh · 30 Mar 2006
All I ask is: what do you want to call those who do Jap Ji Sahib, Rehras, Kirtan Sohila, sewa etc., are born in Sikh families, owe allegiance to no other faith? Vast majority of Sikhs in the world understand that these are Sikhs, but that it is better to be Khalsa.
I think simply to say they are not Sikh is very narrow minded and shows that you are not living in the real world, but rather in a fantasy "pure" world.
We must be careful not to start thinking that we are better than others. This is Brahman-type thinking: only the very holy can be Sikh, or only those who have taken Amrit can be Sikh, or only those who cook and eat from iron vessels are really and truly Sikh. When it came to the crunch, the Nirmalas (initially appointed by Guru Gobind Singh) were found to be too puritanical and obsessively Hindu-ised, thus leading the Khalsa to keep them at arms length. When push came to shove, the Tat Khalsa rejected the anti-Beef and overtly Hinduistic practices of the Bandai Khalsa.
Please, let's live in 21st century global reality, not our views of 16th century India projected into the present day. Sikhism is a global, universal, welcoming religion of the One Creator, not a closed-minded philosophy that excludes legitimate followers.
Jiti Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
... · 30 Mar 2006
Jiti,
So a smoker and drinker who has a hair cut is a Sikh if he does Sukhmani Sahib and nitnem?
What rights does this "Sikh" have in Panthic decisions? Should he have a say in Gurdwara management? How about in formulating rehits?
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jiti Singh · 30 Mar 2006
What about the Keshadhari who drinks and takes drugs?
The Nihang that consumes bhang?
The Giani who molests a girl?
The SGPC head that has her daughter killed?
The khulee-daRee wala who forces his wife/daughter-in-law into aborting her female foetus?
I'm no judge. Are you?
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
... · 30 Mar 2006
Yeah, I'm pretty sure I can judge those: not Sikh.
These aren't the people who are going to be able or allowed to make Panthic decisions.
The fact that they are is our own weakness, but that does't mean the principle is wrong or we lower the principle/standard.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jiti Singh · 30 Mar 2006
Well, "..." (is that your name?), this must mean nobody is a Sikh.
Because, according to you only the perfect "Sikh" can be called "Sikh".
And since nobody is perfect, let alone a perfect Sikh, nobody is a Sikh.
Well done. Very realistic.
Jiti Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
... · 30 Mar 2006
How hard is it that someone is a Sikh if they aren't violating the 4 kurehits (at a very minimum).
I'm not asking for perfection, just not someone clearly in violation of basic Sikh principles.
In your idea, we'd have a Malechh Panth run by adulterers, smokers, drinkers and the morally corrupt.
Very well done to you as well. Shabash.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jiti Singh · 30 Mar 2006
Let us see your name, brother/sister. Don't be scared. Be brave.
If you think that every Sikh that cuts his/her kesh is an adulterer, smoker, drinker and morally corrupt, then I've got news for you: they are not. Furthermore, I know plenty of holders of the 5 K's that are more morally bankrupt than many a sehajdhari.
The Khalsa identity is supremely important in the Sikh Panth. No arguments there. But there is a distinction between a Sikh and a Khalsa. The 4 kurehits (cutting kesh; sex with someone other than your spouse; tobacco; halal meat) refer to the Khalsa.
Let us not divert from the main topic here. What do you propose to call Sikhs without kesh, or indeed Sikhs with kesh that, say, eat halal meat?
Jiti Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
sk (Satnam kaur) · 30 Mar 2006
Dear Jiti Singh,
Please, Gussa nahi khana. There is no punishment to anyone to say anything, but for the sake of Sikhi and Sikhism. This indicates above by the author, Professor Mohinder Pal Singh.
P.S.Sandhu has very nicely presented his views, without any biased attitude, veer ji, aap likho, lekin pyar naal. We should spread the msg to all, other than the Sikhs, must be reading.
Je Sikh, Sikh nu Na Mare, Ta Kom Kadi Na Hare (but from others).
So, please,my request.
Bhul chuk maaf karna.
SATNAM KAUR
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
amarjeet singh · 30 Mar 2006
how can u have a clean shaven sikh????? thats like having a white ball which is the solour black.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jiti Singh · 30 Mar 2006
Satnam Kaur Jee,
Thank you for putting me right.
SaaDee galtee je kisse noon naraaz keeta.
Jiti Singh
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Balpreet Singh aka. "..." · 30 Mar 2006
Jiti,
If you're so bent upon having my name, there it is for you.
I don't claim that all people who cut their hair are morally corrupt.
I don't claim that all those who keep Sikh outter appearance aren't morraly corrupt.
I'm saying that to make decisions for the Panth and to be included as functioning members of the Panth, a person has to be at the very least, avoiding the 4 kurehits.
If someone claims to be avoiding but is actually doing them, there is no real remedy for that, however, if someone is clearly violating and it's apparent, then they should certainly not be accepted.
So Jiti, while my standard excludes all the undesirable people whom your earlier list mentioned your approach seems to include them because by your own admission you can't "judge". I think any reasonable person could, however and would chalk that up to your own weakness.
Balpreet Singh
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jiti Singh · 30 Mar 2006
Balpreet Singh,
Again, it's the Khalsa that take those Panthic decisions, not ordinary Sikhs. Although, ironically enough, it is those very kurehit-valay "Khalsas" who are running the show today. Badal, who de-facto appoints the Akal Takht Jathedar and SGPC head, is no teetotalling vegetarian and, along with Surjit Singh Barnala, was photographed with a matka tied around his turban while performing havan ceremony around a fire with Vajpayee and Advani.
So your side point about Panthic decisions has been addressed: Khalsas only, not Sikhs.
Nice of you to call me weak, brother. That must be the "mittha bol" of the Khalsa in you.
Now, are you going to enlighten me with the word you would like to use for the millions of people in the world that call themselves Sikh but do not keep kesh?
Jiti Singh
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Balpreet Singh · 30 Mar 2006
If the system is corrupt now and we only allow "Khalsa Sikhs" , then are you suggesting it would improve if we included monas?
I think the solution is to kick these people out who are corrupt, not to widen the system more. So the system I propose isn't in effect.
You seem upset that I called it a "weakness" that you aren't able to decide that a "giani who molests" and someone who kills their daughter are Sikhs. I would be hard pressed to call it a strength...at any rate, the answer is pretty clear that such people aren't Sikhs and can't be included in the Panth. I didn't call you weak, I called it a weakness that you can't make such a determination.
As for your final question about what to call these millions of people in the world who call themselves Sikhs: it depends on what they want to call themselves. I recognise that there are many monas out there who have piaar for Sikhi and do lots of paath. But until they become Sikhs of the Guru, by following his basic hukams and receiving amrit, they aren't more than Sharda-vale (those who have faith reverence in the Guru but not Sikhs).
Legally and culturally they will probably still be called Sikhs, but religiously, they are not.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
we need to use our brain · 30 Mar 2006
i know some monai who keep all rehit except for kes. One i know personally does panj bania, sukhmani sahib, asa di var every morning 2 years non stop every morning 2am. i do not believe its useless as these people must get something out of it which is far better than wasting time drinking and clubbing. Surely that would lead to a better future like a better life next time round than being totally stray.
yet there are people in sikhi roop who do wrong things, even when they have taken amrit, so same argument can cancel out to whats the point keeping kes if they do wrong? To make that statement would be wrong because end of day the idea should be to keep as much rehit as one can keep.
end of day if the man loves god thats all dat counts and if he chooses to come under the same canopy as you why get your knickers in a twist?. thats snobbery, God loves everyone, define what a sikh is and ask a kamai wala person how many true sikhs exist out of our own amritdhari panth? half of em believe in caste and stop the ball rolling right there, all of a sudden sikhs are not equal from the start anyway while our mone veers have proggressed further than us. lol.
I do not think of someone with kes as anything special, most changey singhs i know were once mone even bhai rama singh and others. But obviously kes wis requirement but theres no point talking negative on that level the theme should be encouragement and love . The world is a crap place why make it worse, bring in more people and make em proud of what they have. Sikhi aint yours its for everyone, i just love it when mone jump on the microphone and kick the kirtan on stage leaving the sangat stunned. ekta ekta and more ekta, keep the division out.
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jiti Singh · 30 Mar 2006
"we need to use our brain" has the right spirit according to me.
Balpreet Singh: I respectfully disagree with you, brother. The "system you propose" is very lovely and nice, but the reality is different. The mona Sikh considers himself a Sikh. If you ask him "tera dharam kee hai?", he will say "Sikh". If at that point you tell him that he is a Shardha-Vala, I'm sure he will be spurred on even more to embrace the faith of Guru Nanak.
On the molesting giani and the Bibi Jagir Kaur who has her daughter killed, please don't make the mistake that I cannot determine this is wrong. These are heinous, criminal acts that should be punished under law (even though the Bibi has not been). But you have made a unilateral decision that they are not Sikh. I have not heard anyone else declare this. What are they now, Hindu?
The Nihangs take bhang. So they are also not Sikh now, according to your logic. Are they Muslim?
"Na koi Hindu, na koi Musulman" is what Guru Nanak first preached, i.e. religious labels are meaningless. It is your deeds that count. So what exactly is achieved by renaming most Sikhs to Shardha-vale? Which is why the Sikh Rehat Maryada definition most wisely defines it: the human that believes in One God, the ten Gurus, the Guru Granth Sahib, the baptism of the tenth Guru, and does not owe allegiance to any other religion IS A SIKH.
End of.
Jiti Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
kds · 30 Mar 2006
when it come to politics we count each and every person who call himself.sikh.but on the other hand we does not recognise him as sikh
does any sikh organisation has courage to say to the GOI that clean shaven are not sikhs and do not recognise them sikhs in the survey.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
P.S.Sandhu · 31 Mar 2006
By reading the above passages put forward by dear colleagues ...lets move jointly step by step.....I ask my dear friends to come amicably with all these debatable points ... According to my observation :
Who is better Sikh and who is not !! ..as put forward by dear colleagues.... this analogy can be easily understood if we relate it to "one is a Sikh by appearance but not by actions, while the other is a Sikh by actions but not by appearance" .. But the first fundamental principle of Sikhism is... to be accepted and honoured as member of the Khalsa Panth, one has to do good deeds , wear the five symbols and obey/observe the Khalsa reht.
but one general question haunts my mind which I have observed is that ...Why Sikh by appearance, whts the problem with Sikhism by heart ?This is not a question but lets say a common observation to me when I see around with wider prospective.. people may agree with it or not. the general image among the Sikhs today is that during the 18th century Sikhs had very high character. they offered their heads for their religious freedom and human rights.. they would die but not lie.. The Sikh youth, after learning the Sikh way of life, wish and decide to sincerely follow that path..however today they do not see many Sikhs living up to those standards.. rather they see them fighting for taking control of Gurdwaras instead of serving the Sikhs and living the life of a Sikh.
if we see with a wider prespective we find many Sikhs who are making the highest sacrifices and suffering tortures even today to protect their religious freedom and human rights... thousands have already become martyrs in the last decade.. the history of the 18 th century and early 20th century is being repeated today.. there are people who have even sold their houses to help the Sikhs struggling against the mighty Indian government. many are silently leading a good Sikh life and helping needy people..IT IS IRONIC THAT FEW HUNDRED SIKHS FIGHTING FOR THE POSITIONS IN THE GURDWARAS management become more prominent than hundreds of thousands of Sikhs who go there for religious singing and learning the principles of Sikh life.
waheguru ji ka khalsa.
waheguru ji ki fateh!!
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
sanjo · 31 Mar 2006
if the moneh/umalee etc wona call themselves sikh let them, i do agree we cant push em away from sikhi, cos asoon as we start saying oh your a abit of a clown and ur not a sikh then why would they want to learn about sikhi if they think oh these singhs n that all they ever do is cuss us. we should do parchar with pyaar, but thats not to say that inside we dont know the true deifinition of a sikh. surely every person in this forum agrees it is necessary to take amrit. so we should encourage these people. but then i see people blatently doing kurehit and acting like real idiots n going round with khanda tops etc, its hard to ignore i hve to admit.
i agree with both jiti and balpreet singh, but i think we stil need to keep at least some strong conduct on who we betray as sikhs in the media. would anyone on this forum be happy if a documentary was done on sikhi by a tv channel and all they showed were moneh/umalees acting like prats purving on girls? then all of a sudden people would be saying hold on that aint sikhi thats out of the order. but then agn there are keshdharis out there who hve taken amrit n they do such things, but then in my view they aint amritdhari anymore, they havent respected amrit, they havent respected guru ji, so they have no guru just like how the challi mukteh signed the paper saying guru gobind singh wasnt their guru, everytime we do something majorly manmat on purpose knowingly and continue without pesh we are effectively signing that paper.
"rehit bina sikh na kahaveh rehit bina darchotta kaveh"
then agn how many of us can say we follow strong rehit so like stated above maybe none of us are sikh? but then again we embrace guru roop with pyaar and alot of people are scared of this n dont want to give up shaving, so obviously people with kesh are a step further than the moneh etc,
"pritham rehit khandeh ki pahul shakae"
so taking amrit is the 1st commandment for a sikh, says it all really, we should all strive to do so, but many people say they dont have to and that they are sikh at "heart". look how much pyaar the shaheeds had for guru ji n sikhi, they gave their lives, like bhai taru singh ji, never gave up his kesh but rather gave his life. now thats what u call a sikh at heart. being sikh is something physical and spiritual, u need both.
"menu rehit pyari sikh nehi"
we should try and follow what our guru ji wants. he has blatently said so right here that he dont want these sikhs by name, he wants rehit, which keeping kesh, doing paaht, taking amrit, naam abhiyaas. thats all rehit,
so i think we all know what a true sikh should be, and to me a sikh is a khalsa. but really i keep my views to myself, i find no need to go up to moneh n say oh ur not a sikh etc etc. concentrate on ur own jeevan n ur own sikhi, try n do parchar with pyaar n influence others. we all knw what a true sikh is and we should strive to achieve that, though we may not think others r true sikhs, who cares, thoguh i still find it very difficult to stand by while clowns like some do blatent disrespect and give out the wrong message about sikhi. its a hard one but nothing we should get in to a fight about,
n regarding the sgpc rehit maryada, ino alot of people who do nitnem and read other gurbani but do not believe its necessary to take amrit, so therefore are they not sikh? though they myt do alot of paaht according to maryada they aint sikh ryt. and i believe if someone ahd faiht in guru jis amrit then they would have taken it already or atleast be preparing for it like bhai sahib randhir singh was for two years. how do we know who has or hasnt got faith in amrit? so if we r going to stick to sgpc maryada then we have to dig deep in to the minds of every single monah n see if he has faith in khandeh ki pahul, then we cna happily call him a sikh, its a abit hard to do that tho.
other than that i think we all knw what guru sahib wants from us as sikhs, and we should try n give something back to guru ji in return for soo many sacrifices guru ji has made for us, n we should teach people about the greatness of amrit n encourage them to become amritdhari,
bhull chukk maaf
waheguru
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
unity · 31 Mar 2006
i agree with sandhu sahib.
in one place alone out of 4000 accountable profiles held at holy bones gurdwara leiscter on display on khalsa human rights day 500 slain martyrs shaheeds for khalistan were mone who fought bravely and sacrificed their lives, freedoms, homes, families, futures, for the upkeep of sikhi, in the spirit of their sikh forefathers fighting for the panth, its community cause against oppressive brahminical reflexes.
When one sees such pictures then you will begin to interpret transmit reality different from a secluded life where one is this or across the line he has to be that to an appreciative reality where demarcated lines are replaced with love with whatever love stood ground. I am no place to ask myself why someone does not have the ability to grow their kes all i can do is look after my own, and pray for my brothers and sisters.
My best friend another sandhu but mona goes to every khalistan march reads bani, has a decent spirit, does not bull around, made reems of money and caved around me to give me a financial lift when i needed it although i refused. Now singhs around me would not do anything, and others put you down even more.
Another mona veer offered to send me double figure sums to help me set up bussiness while singhs around me asked me well what do you do for a living and then look down on you? yet another mona veer offered me a managerial job at his mamas chain of franchises when i grew my kes . In my life my mona veers have a long history standing shoulders together from cradle, to school, yet i can only but feel the same level does not exist between singhs i know while with some it does. Now in terms of sikh spirit where do you start? if you havent even got the slightest bit of prem for your own bhais then how much of a sikh are you?
The world you live in is not as easily divided into kesdari and some mone it never was. In my own family some of our chachey had kes others did not.
Time and time again struggle after struggle i have seen goodness on all sides. I have more respect to my mona grandfather who came to this country in 1963 slept rough on floorboards, no heating, just a sack, worked 16 hours a day, shared room with 5 others, worked saved money sent small portion back to punjab, then their first cause was to establish gurdwara by giving 500 quid each in 1967 which is a lot of money in todays terms as ones weekly earnings would have been 10 quid a week. and then they would save again and then bring their family over from punjab liveon rent two years work their nuts off again for 10 20 years and then buy their own homes. Even after they did that the fauji generation sent money back to help others they knew. If i compare my grandad to some random guy with kes yes i respect the kes but if someone was to say whats the point of my grandad being like that ? who am i to judge? god made him, it is my job as a sikh to pray for him without judging whether he is a good or bad sikh. I grew in the cradle where mone sacrificed i appreciate that ten times over some singh trying to demercate lines between mone and singhs.
Then the bnp used to plague the streets with racist attacks in those days national front. It was mone who were always the front men with singhs who went forward, like all these people dissing mone no offence but where were you? popcorn chocolate watching cartoons. its easy behind a pc but like come out when its show time. when you see tunghi (difficult times) you will begin to understand reality.
its a combined effort, theres a lot of good blood out there you just aint tapped into it. Theres nothing to gain through negativity and stereotyping.
there are punjabi shers who gave a name to the sikhs over here. Two i can count are marcus singh bassi, who alone took out 22 kaley in 1990 brixton prison one after the next , heavyweight boxers sukha and kam bassi fought street battles alone with 60 skinheads, kashmira from gravesend with 2 others took out 70 musalmans,
sidhu, deepak and hayar took down by knocking out clean 24 fanatic muslims in city just 2 years ago, and not to forget our old boy johal who went up and down the country combatting racists in 1980, putting the mark of sikhs onto the freestyle kickboxing platform bringing back world trophies. Thats when skins kaley got hot not to mess with sikhs.
Then you get all these anti mone people trying to drive away our footsoldiers from gurdwaras in the 1990s hence a lot of our bloodbrothers are bec oming radaswamis as they are not even given a place in a gurdwara to sit without being stared at or being scolded for not keeping kes.
these are all mone and loads more, who were once on the streets kicking butt at a time when your mum and dad could not walk out on the streets were victimised because of their pagha and tharia. others fought for their rights you should be grateful others put themselves on the front for you to have a better life so today you could walk with turban and beard freely. End of day whos a better sikh?
you or the clean shaven one who fought and sacrificed their life? or had the prem to put the name of sikhs on top? the answer is your good so are they learn to have a bit of respect and aceptance! it does not hurt. In bani many times Guru ji bows down in humility and caling themselves lowly so whats wrong with you to think your lower?
When our brothers are ready it is upto them to grow kes, you do your job love them like you would your own, and give them good sangat, as that sangat rubs off onto bhais then you give them gutka, and let the bani do the talking provided one does not do meat or drink. Then let god talk to the bros.
Invite mone to resnbhais, let them feel the simran, bani being sung passionatly by rehetvan singhs so it may enter their souls. Trying to make lines will either push our footsoldiers to radaswamis as our mone veers left morally bankrupt religious instituitions to communism in the old days, or it will only worsen your own state of mind in a gurdwara when you see a mona and theres nothing you can do about it when the monas twice your size. How would you like to be stereotyped as a singh? now try to comprehend not all mone want to be stereotypoed by their appearance too.
Creating barriers is a lost cause! you all know that. so love accept others and you will reciprocate back. Life is too short, go forward with something. Gods gonna ask you what you do for my faith? what you gonna say to that well i just want my own place in sach khand? nah nah it aint that easy, you gotto give and sacrifice a part of yourself along the way, its not just sitting at home reading a bit of paat and keeping yourself away from anyone with a chopped kes face. Build relationships without intentions, the sikh way love spirit do things, if you cant even be jacked to support love your own people how the heck you gonna even love your own family or wife?
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
... · 31 Mar 2006
No one is saying Monay can't be good people.
No one is saying Monay can't have pyaar for Sikhi.
All this is being said is that to be considered a Sikh of Guru Gobind Singh (in the true sense of that word) you have to become amritdhari and keep Guru Sahib's rehit. There is no other option.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
P.S.Sandhu · 31 Mar 2006
Dear brother Unity,
You are absolutely right..i agree with you in your view points.....no one is saying monas are bad ..no one is saying nice by heart and good in deeds is against the nomenclature of truthful life in this world, which a true human being should suppose to live...but keeping the present topic in scrutiny with wider perspective, we can categorise the discussion in two: (a) Sikh and (b) Sikhism. and what you said my dear is in full acceptable with as, Sikh.
I agree, holding a Bible in hand does not make one a priest or a holy person and neither does if a person holding alcohol bottle would make him alcoholic. The statement is used as a phrase meaning hypocracy is bad and it is worse if practised by people claiming religious. However this can not be or should not be used to justify drinking by those who claim to be nice and sincere by heart, ofcourse everyone knows its not okay for nice people to love bottles. But unfortunately more often wrong conclusion are drawn from the statement : that cutting hair is not a bad thing provided one is sincere on the inside. Many people who believe this actually cheat themselves.
Now coming to second part , Sikhism. Inspired by a divine mission to right the wrongs of the world, the Guru exhorted his followers to come upto the ideal deal of tandem of two terms, sikh + Singh = saint soldier. Surcharged with such inspiration, a Sikh was urged to combine in him the virtues of a sant and the strength and sternness of a soldier. The Guru aimed at creating a nation that would be pure and strong enough to free itself from oppression of the rulers and priests. Among his supporters was also Muslims, Pir Buddhu Shah , who admired the spiritual status of the Guru because of ideological affinities. two of his sons died fighting on the side of Guru. And it was same doctrine of Sikhism which assisted a Mahara saint, Ram Das, to meet Sixth master, Guru Hargobind. His meting with Guru left such a profound impression on sant Ram Dass mind that he undertook to train the Maratha leader, Shivaji on the same lines. No matter who is mona sikh, who is muslim, who is hindu, Guru's blessings fill all the voids and cavities of illusion.
We agree or we agree not :
1. To be a Sikh is more paying than to call one a Sikh.
2. Follwing Sikhism as per advised by The Guru than demaded by world, is still tougher.
3. Once who is in fold of Sikhism, in Rehat, queries concerning, me did it , he did it, for did it, got from other which was not with in Sikhism, will automatically get answered.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa.
Waheguru ji ki fateh !!
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
singh · 31 Mar 2006
SEHAJDHARI -SIKH
The definition of the term Sehajdhari - Sikh is a very strange one. The term tends to be applied to those non - members in the Sikh community. Those that have been born in Sikh families, who keep the roop of patits while calling themselves Sikhs or those that keep the Sabat Soorat Roop and do not wish to get initiated in to Sikh faith by taking Amrit from the Panj Pyaare.
The confusing thing is that there is no such thing as a Sehajdhari Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Jew so where did this term (Sehajdhari) sprout from in the Sikh community?
The understanding that Guru Ji has given to the sevadaars of this web sight makes us believe that by taking Amrit an individual obtains admission into the Sikh faith. Once an individual has been initiated into the Sikh faith it is their responsibility of the individual to achieve the goal of this life, which is to achieve the Brahm Gian state.
This in turn leads us to believe that an individual cannot become a Sikh without first being initiated into the Sikh faith by part taking in the Amrit ceremony. In other words there is no such individual as a Sehajdhari - Sikh. An individual can be a Sikh on not a Sikh, there is no in between.
The very definition of the term Sehajdhari - Sikh is discriminative in nature. The logic that applies to it is that an individual born into a Sikh family is automatically a Sehajdhari - Sikh (a member of the Sikh community). However an individual born into a non-Sikh family would have to part take in the Amrit ceremony in order to become a member of the Sikh community. Why the difference?
Some facts to be considered in this regard are given below.
a quotation from the book "who are the Sikhs?" written by Dr. Harjinder Singh Dilgeer.
"... In fact, this term had been coined in the early twentieth Century by the Hindus in order to get benefits and favours available to the Sikhs by the then British regime. According to the Sikh ideology there can not be any so-called Sehijdhari; there are either Sikhs or non - Sikhs........."
Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Ji's Hukams:
"Ture kes pahal bhin phake murakh Sikh mera darshan nahee tis pappee
tiage pikh"
Translation: an individual that keeps the image of a Sikh and does
not take Amrit, i do not want to do his Darshan
"Sabat Soorat rub ke bhanay baeeman"
Translation: the person who destroys the God given image is a
Baeeman person.
Quotation
Rehat Maryada
"The Defanition of A Sikh
Article 1
Any human being who faithfully believes in
1. One immortal Being,
2. Ten Gurus, from Guru Nanak Dev to Guru Gobind Singh,
3. Guru Granth Sahib
4. The utterances and teachings of the ten Gurus and
5. The baptism bequeathed by the tenth Guru, and who does not owe allegiance to any other religion, is a Sikh"
The question may be asked as to how an individual was initiated into the Sikh faith before Sahib Siri Guru Gobind Singh Ji brought about the Amrit ceremony? The answer to this is quite simple. The customary ceremony of the time, Charan Amrit was used.
This ceremony involved Guru Sahib dipping his toe in a bowl of water, anybody who drank that water would be initiated into the Sikh faith.
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
sk (Satnam kaur) · 01 Apr 2006
Piyari Sadh sasngat jeo,
Do you think, those who killed our young boys with one excuse or other He/they are Sikhs. They are old and hold high ranks. Though, they tie turbans and beard also. and another fellow talks too much on TV with one example or the other. And players with Patkas. and Punjabi pop singers and singing Shabad for the sake of money, without turbans and clean shaven ?
Bhul chuk maaf karna.
SATNAM KAUR
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Jaspal Kaur · 01 Apr 2006
penji satnam kaur ji
People who may keep their kes but then do all the anti gurmat actions as some, which you have questioned. Yet this does still not count them as sikhs. What did guru nanak dev ji creat sikhi for, thats the first question we need to ask ourselves.
One needs daya and dharam to follow the code of conduct. For someone who is a killer yet keeps kes, someone who singhs shabad and yet is a punjabi pop singer and is clean shaven non of those brings true justice to either of them.
Again to actually under stand why guru ji called a person who lives a truthfull living, does paath, simran and stands out proudly with its guru's given saroop ie dastar,kesh. a sikh, is something we need to take into accout.
It is a different matter that monas lovingly do alot of paath seva, which is absoloutely brilliant compaired to alot of the loafers we see here and there,(calling someone a loafer doesn't initially mean i hate them or are not worthy of being spoken to). However to simply know 'ke guru da sikh ki hai' (who is truly or a complete gurka sikh) is the person who comes into rehit and that is not just physical appearance, but when one does paath simran with sharda as well as understanding and proudly wearing guru ji's bana and being truthful in all means.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
P.S.Sandhu · 01 Apr 2006
Satnam ji.
As stated , Sikh in physical form and Sikh "in realization" are two different things. what you are talking is "Sikh In Dress" and nothing more than physical form. they proclaim themselves Sikhs though they reap their fruit by cutting roots of Sikhs and sacrificing Sikh interests. Thou long list is there in Sikh History, few recent ones :
1. Giani Jail Singh, the sucker Sikh President of India. After the blood bath of Darbar Sahib, he says in his speech "he was kept in illusion for this action !!" and on his visit to Darbar Sahib immediate after army attack, dressed in a spotless white Achikin and only "blot" on his snow white shining dress is a red rose hung on the left side. And he was roaming in Sikh sacred complex clasping "red rose" as though he had gone to attend a marriage party.
2. Kushwant Singh, to sikhs say eminent sikh writer...who has written bunch of joke books on Sikhs and had remarks like... he is a sikh by apearance and what he is to Sikhism is that he is born in Sikh family and its a emotional attachment.
3. Fellows like KPS Gill , Beant Singh, Darbara Singh, to name a few, whose deeds are no longer hidden from anyone. proclaim there is nothing thing like Sikh in today's world..it existed in Past, when it was oscillated by time.
4. K.S.Brar, a clean shaven sikh, incharge of military operation on Darbar Sahib. Arun Singh, another sikh, a scion of the ex-royal family of Kapurthala, R.S.Dayal, a staunch follower of Nirankaris ,to name a few, all were megalomaniac follwers of megalomaniac world's biggest democracy, who ruthlessly conducted and monitored the brutal military operation against the people whom they claim to be an integral part of their hindu society.
5. Sikh preachers, saints argue with the contents of Gurbani , rather than searching what is inside the Gurbani. Minds argue this Rehras (evening prayer) is big and that is small, do this much of mool mantar (and it is up to this), but no one is concerned what is inside these immortal things and beauty of their expression.
6. Players, sports persons can project the image of their faith in right direction..... projecting cap is against the tenets of Sikhism, so not to bear it means not to have it at all. Guru has blessed us best Savroop in world. sadly there are always trend setters in modern world.. Bishan Bedi is credited with cap-tradition to brought in lime light....and Mr. Harbhajan Singh, spinner in Cricket is too in line... also he is addding how a Sikh with pony tail can walk on the ramp staying as a cricketer (sikh) as well...if not wrong we have not seen him projecting nice turban at any social event or congregation...he is always clad with his small patka..It proves for the comming generation of sikhs that "first comes the pony tail and then if possible comes the turn of Turban !".
7. Punjabi singers with hype of coyly and scantly clad babes, too some times project the image of Sikhs differntly to new learner of faith and more over eloquently projecting khanda with that, proves things without any doubt that Sikhism is more about ostentation in today's world than simplicity what Gurus had taught and injected in Sikhs !!
waheguru ji ka khalsa.
waheguru ji ki fateh!!
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
JSGyani "Arshi" · 02 Apr 2006
this is a fine line..SIKHI is as thin and sharp as a RAZOR SHARP BLADE !!
I see that the Sikh world is up in arms about the KESH of a "SIKH CRIMINAL"..languishing in a USA Prison. Now IF that person is genuinely concerned about his KESH...he wouldnt have done this ACT..which landed him in Prison in the first place...a "CRIMINAL PRISON is NOT the place for a AMRITDHAREE SIKH" ( unless he is political prisoner/asylum seeker etc in which case this doesnt apply as he is not a Criminal)..but a Court convicted criminal ?? An Amrtidharee Sikh would have followed His Gurus SIKH REHAT MARYADA..and not committed any such act that can prove him a criminal..
???? why di he..and what makes him an "amritdharee" now after the fact that he has murdered soemone/killed soemone..are "we trying to tell the world that it is ok for an "Amrtidharee" to so such acts and we will fight for them...??? The World today is very intelligent..every action has a reaction..People through out the world are questioning why we "support" normal criminals ?? What do we say "if" we force the authorities ( agisnt their regulations) to give him a six foot dastaar/kachhera /kirpan etc and he then goes ahead and uses these towards further "criminal" acts in the Prson itself ?? ( because he has NOT shown any remorse in his previous criminal act//what makes us so surte he is a REFORMED and wont commit any more crimes maybe using the very things an amritdharee shoudl keep as rehit ??
just a few thoughts... feedback i received from some other races
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
PTE SINGH · 03 Apr 2006
I think by putting in the 'what ifs' a debate is some what ruined. When talking about being kesadari or not we are assuming that all things are equal, not if a kesadari murderer is better than a mona person who prays.
Because by the arguments of most of the mona a good muslim or hindu or christian is better than a murdering kesadari sikh, so should we all become good muslims?
We are not talking about good or bad people we are talking about the fundaments of Sikhi.
The only distinguising constant that exists in Sikhi from it conception is 'NAAM' and 'KESH'. All 10 Gurus preached the importance of Naam and the importance of kesh. The Guru Granth sahib reitarates again and again the importance of NAAM and KESH as the most primary tools for a Sikh. That is where we started.
By no means am i taking away from the rahet set by Guru Gobing Singh and only by taking amrit can we be complete Sikhs. However Naam and Kesh is where we began and that is where any one who claims to be Sikh must begin.
I am not challanging that mona can't be godly people, clearly they are, however are they Sikh? When as a people we are asked ( by various governments) this question, we have always said that it is essential, not preferable, that Sikhs have long hair and the men wear turbans to cover their kesh. Then why the debate.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
SK (Satnam kaur) · 03 Apr 2006
P.S.Sandhu veer ji
Giani Jail Singh was an opportunist, like all politicians. KPS Gill buthcered the young boys, just on mis-information. He shall have no place in Hell, what to talk of Heaven. Brar/Dayal etc. etc. has no place in Guru Ghar. Simply, they are in illusion, they did well. Simply, such people got benefits of being Sikh, but contributed nothing.Yes, their contribution was to killings.
Regarding preachers - Rotian Karan Poore Taal. But their greed has jumped to Mercedes Benz, 5-star Hotel-like Dere., any hidden ........
Guru Mehar kare. Punjabi pop singers shud come on the path of sikhism.
Bhul chuk maaf karna.
SATNAM KAUR
[%sig%]
Re:
call4moreunity · 03 Apr 2006
its obvious kes alone does not fit the definition of a sikh as pointed above.
now forgive me for not using the sources or exact words but i am sure they have been raised here many times for anyone to research i do not have time in a net cafe.
If we go by definitions then there are more aspects to consider to start with
1) gurbani which states the instruc tion of a sikh to wake amritvela and contemplate gods name. Does this mean amritdharis who wake after 6 for simran are not sikh? does this mean those who do not have the joogti technique do not have naam and therefore are not sikh?
2) gyani thakur singh of damdami taksal is said to stated if a sikh is not khalistani he is not a sikh. So that many amritdharis not khalistani are no longer sikh?
3) dasam granth sahib states in one place that he who beieves in caste never was my sikh and never will be. i have scanned across another verse time back where the instruction goes further and one who believes in caste will go to hell. so any amritdhari believe in caste through whatever excuse are not sikh. whether that be for matrimonial/cultural differences/whatever you can think of are not sikh, this includes some local sevedars i know, even one panj, whatever paat bani they do at 2am however much they believe and do rolla of guru granth sahib ji they arenot sikh? so let us stick with definitions.
so now how many sikhs are left?
on a technical logical scholarly level you can go on filtering till there will be very few left. And sure there should be a boundary but as to how far do we draw the line? obviously one who wonders into sect dhere in manmut are not sikh, those who do anti sikh activities are not sikh.
We do have rogue elements, drunks, meat eaters, adulterers, but if that implies most cut haired people born from sikh families then how would it feel to be known as these things even if uncut haired people did this? Meaning you may not know of many decent dharmic people with cut hair but others do.
There are many youth who feel they are sikh, born and raised having participated with sikh spirit in sikh causes so today you are able to freely walk out of your door without getting jumped, gurdwaras bought out nice cosy and warm for you to sit down when you feel like. whether i you disagree with them the fact is they believe in that.
The one side argument is you are not a sikh until you follow which does hold a reasonable point on one side. However the groundbreaking reality in life is if you was to tell a person they are not sikh, they would either walk away from the path more, depleting the panth in which case:
you should never complain when these mone look the other way when they see you or complain about dehras growing when they inevitably will go where they feel welcome with their cut kes.
if there are soldierlike qualities out there one man can take on 10 15 other men without having read gurbani or taken amrit, do you not wonder how amazing the kirpa of amrit could have upon our brothers from the same flesh and soil we are made from?
Then what would be the most realistic step to keep our brothers grounded in sikhi? by telling they are not sikh?
There comes a time when humans have a spiritual malady a soul search. The pressures of life one is taught to live, gain, educate, survive under conditions, work like slaves in exchange for money and see less of family. the world is far from that good place where truth and justice was taught in childhood. Therefore when that time comes for our soul searching brothers and sisters would it not be right to at least have the correct approach to at leas keep them finely tuned towards the reality of sikhism or lose them further?
i do agree with some of what has been said but look at the state of the panth. Depleting your panth indirectly by telling people they are not sikh with cut hair will clearly leave people very peed off and either make their point stronger or leave. so what will you gain? nothing!
the correct way is a positive attitude, potential, keeping our brothers and sisters grounded even if they have cut hair thats a lot better to know what they are, have the catalyst knowledge and know where they belong to work towards a goal. Maybe you want them to walk to the goal but that will never happen by messing around with their honour heritage.
Its just to find the right way to make a person tick into sikhism. This is where i have agreed with bhai ajit singh swindon sangat while i disagree with other points in the sangat. The nurturing of brotherhood, between mone and encouraging mone to read bani has seen an incxrease in interest and there were a few mone who began the spiritual path and have made progress and its this progress that will encourage them to go further and grow their kes. This prooves a lot better than pushing our brothers away.
So anywhere brotherhood is nurtured that place will keep on growing whether that be radaswamis, dhere of sants, muslims, rss they will keep gaining our brothers this is the bitter reality. In which do not complain we are the ones sending our brothers away. If we want them we have to nurture brotherhood love and make sikhism grow.
And finally gurbani states that we should look inside and read our minds horoscope meaning look only at ourselves where we head not at others. so what is a sikh who is a sikh?
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
... · 03 Apr 2006
It's not complicated.
Someone who violates any of the 4 Kurehits (as a minimum standard) cannot be called a Sikh in the spiritual sense of that term. Maybe as a social/cultural/ethnic label it is fine.
This doesn't preclude giving love to monas or encouraging them to read bani. If you tell a mona he is a full blown Sikh doesn't that condone his cutting of hair? Isn't it better to tell him that we can't be true Sikhs until we follow the hukam of keeping kes? That seems like the honest and more productive approach.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
????? · 03 Apr 2006
Sikh = Amritdhari?
If so, then a lot of people like Maharaja Ranjit Singh, Shaheed Bhai Harjinder Singh Parha & Shaheed Udam Singh weren't Sikhs at all. If you guys agree with my last sentence, then why do you Sikhs take pride of these men's accomplishments?
And this also means that a lot of people who died in process of freeing India from the British weren’t Sikhs after all.
So why are these Jatts/Punjabis part of Sikh history then?
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Balbir Singh · 03 Apr 2006
Satsriakal to all!
Quote "Someone who violates any of the 4 Kurehits (as a minimum standard) cannot be called a Sikh in the spiritual sense of that term."
One of your Gurus might have made this rule.
My Gurus never talked about these definitions and Kurehits.
Balbir Singh
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
anon · 03 Apr 2006
I am an ignorant young fool, but heres my two paise worth of mindless ramblings...
Yet again we are finding more divisions within this great faith of ours!!!
Forget all of this definition of other people - the only time we need to judge people is to see whether they have pooran jeevan, and so can be one of the Punj Piaarae. Which is very few!!!
Otherwise, if someone wants to call themselves a sikh, let them be a sikh!!! There is no need for sehajdhari definitions.
A non-kes-keeping person has every right to call themselves a sikh. If they have pyaar for Dhan Dhan Guru Granth Sahib Ji then Waheguru has already done massive kirpa.
Imagine what a great world this would be if we didn't keep judging and defining OTHER people!
I mean, if being a Lover of Waheguru isn't enough then what about all the people the Gurusahibs blessed with their darshan who didn't keep their hair, but did plenty more sewa than me for the Gurusahibs in their human form? They weren't sikhs?
I'm sure this has been said, i am forever barking mad. Please forgive me if i have wasted your time with my post or re-iterated someones view, OR made a mistake - i'm only trying to tread a good path.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Balbir Singh · 03 Apr 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear Anon Ji!
You may be a little loud but your voice is truthful. I can hear you clearly.
Some people are more worried and engaged with the theme 'cutting hair' than the Sehajdharis.
Sehajdharis may be doing Naam Simran in a saloon. But a kattar Sikh may be busy cursing the hair cutter during Simran also.
I don't think Sikhs need to impose more rules in life.
I feel Sikhs should remain on earth accepting all Jeeves as they are.
And let them become freely A Sikh when God inspires them by meeting a true Gursikh.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
sk(satnam kaur) · 03 Apr 2006
Please - Veer Kulbir Singh/Arshi JS Gyani/ Vijaydeep singh/Kulbir/Jugroop Singh/Kaur/Singh/khalsa/LK (Lion King) - where are you all.
You talk very big on other topics. Where is your knowledge on this
fundamentals. With my respects to all.
Bhul Chuk Maaf karna.
SATNAM KAUR
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
PTE SINGH · 04 Apr 2006
Maharaja Ranjit Singh did have kesh. I am unaware of Shaheed Bhai Harjinder Singh Parha. Udam Singh was nothing of note if you are talking of 'Sikh History' and was kesadari for much of his life.
However 'Sikh history' as you put it would in no way shape or form be diminished if all the Mona were taken away from it, Infact i would be interested to learn the impact of the 'Mona Sikh' on over 300 hundred years of 'Sikh' History.
Where were the mona boys during, the hundreds of years of Sikh history? The wars with the Mughals and Afgans, the holacausts during those times? I have never read there being a price on the head of a mona? Any mona mentioned in the Ardass?
Where were the mona when the Khalsa army was taking kabul and Little Tibet or was fighting the British, or when the SIKH regiments were fighting the Jerry or Japs??
Up untill the 1930's there was no such thing as a mona Sikh, you were called Hindu's and your entire contribution to SIKH History would not be enough to fill the pockets of Jassa Singh Aluwalia or Hari Singh Nalwa.
[%sig%]
Re:
unity · 04 Apr 2006
i am happy to most members contributing here showing maturity in this discussion.
I understand what ...... and pte singh are saying but the time is here and now and in the present. I have no answers about mone in history all i can say is the world of sikhism i live in mone and sikhs live side by side in the same houses,please check khalsa human rigthts holy bones leiscter to check the martydoms of mone in the khalistan movement, as for b4 that i have no knowledge of the matter.
Perhaps to some here the very idea of mona may cause an itch, whatever we wish to think of them then let us see how they see it ( the good rooted element) . They are from sikh forefathers, therefore believe in their unique history, and part of the sikh faith. Let us exclude the dodgy elements and look at the good.
From my experiences even in youth, mone had respect for singhs, if singhs were jumped they would come in numbers, when a singh was seen he was greeted sometimes with greater admiration as some mone felt here are brothers who are doing what we should have been and give back double respect.
A singh automatically knows his kes commands that respect in his own community, and a mona would definatly have to give. But if you were to tell our bhai them they are not sikh, they would probably knock you two feet off the ground first, when that respect is turned into beizziti. This is the cutting edge, to you its logical a sikh is practicing to be a sikh, to them if you say that, you would raise strong emotions and get your own beizziti done.
. I have seen directly how some mone guys i know have done things for sikhi, for sikhs, and then some skinny 5 foot singh comes along and tries to talk about their kes, and heres huge 6 and half foot blokes who can mould men into putty. Like theres a line its just a matter of time before someone would end up on a hospital bed. You cannot diss someones honour and that is how they percieve being told they are not sikh. In fact that would cause greater divisions and marginalisations of sects.
and perhaps these mone were not the defined sikh, but they have taken their encouragement from sikh history, their spirit came from sikhism, they may not have been fortunate to have been blessed with amritdhari homes and families therefore less association with sikhism than yourself. Therefore how can you best bring someone onto the same platform as yourself? through knowledge or experience?
knowledge is one thing, experience to feel the power of a rensbhai, to recite bani would induce certain qualities into a mona, before long a mona would feel the value of kes and understand the keemat and rise to a level where kes does not feel like growing but an automatic part of nature and feel its strengh and beauty and harnessing to greater heights with more rehit. However everything stops as soon as you say your not a sikh. By sayting that to our bhais with warriorlike qualities they would not take kindly to having their honour being thrown in dirt.
I can say this as i have been a mona before and can speak from experience of two sides of the world, i know how i would have felt and how i feel now. if you have seen mone growing kes after being told they are not sikh fine carry on.
But i have seen warrior spirit in our bhais and that spirit has lkater come to a stage of dissappointment when they came to gurdwara no rtesource, giani dirty looks, a sant man singh comes knocking mone, if these sants sadhs were to know what kurbania people put down before they open their mouthes they would think twice. Such warriors who dedicated their early lives to the panthic well being, leave. the kind who if they had taken amrit they would be an asset that could be multiple t what we have.
when we speak of quality over quantity what qualities do we have over someone else? and who are we to judge?
the qualities of our bhais an be centralised into the panth or you can make lines and definitions and keep them far away.
Once a gori bibi was on stage commanding the sangats attension and telling an entire sangat of women they were not sikh because they did not adorn dastar. Now what did bibi get out of that? how many bibis began wearing dastar after? the world is a crappppppp place as it is right, pressures and trensuions increase further, God has not given us the riught to push people away.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
????? · 04 Apr 2006
“Maharaja Ranjit Singh did have kesh.”
So what? If someone kept his/her kesh, does that mean he/she is automatically a Sikh? Maharaja Ranjit Singh behavior was anti-Sikh. In fact, did you know that he eat halal meat, celebrated Hindu holidays and even worshipped Hindu idols? Did you know that his wife was a Muslim? But yet his is a Sikh because he kept his hair? LOL
“I am unaware of Shaheed Bhai Harjinder Singh Parha.”
He is a fight fighter who died during 80’s/early 90’s. I believe that you can find a picture of him in the langar hall at Dixie Gurdwara. I think his picture is beside Baba Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale picture. Besides, he is from Canada (I think he is from Toronto to be exact).
“Udam Singh was nothing of note if you are talking of 'Sikh History' and was kesadari for much of his life.”
Are you saying Sikhs who contribute the Indian independence movement are not good enough to be mention in Sikh history? Every time Sikhs (especially the Khalistani supporters) talk about Khalistan or India, they always mention about how Sikhs have contribute of freeing India from the British. If you take these “mona” outs, then how many Sikh did contribute to the Indian independence movement then? Besides, Shaheed Udham Singh Kamboj was a mona when he murdered Michael O'Dwyer and committed other acts.
“Where were the mona boys during, the hundreds of years of Sikh history? The wars with the Mughals and Afgans, the holacausts during those times? I have never read there being a price on the head of a mona? Any mona mentioned in the Ardass?”
There was no such thing as Mona because they were just label as Sikhs (or Sahajdhari Sikh). Just you know, not every Sikh took amrit back in the dayz.
“Where were the mona when the Khalsa army was taking kabul and Little Tibet or was fighting the British, or when the SIKH regiments were fighting the Jerry or Japs??”
What are you talking about? Even Hindus and Muslims help out the Sikhs to fight against the British and help the Sikhs to take over Kabul. Besides, I wouldn’t be surprised if most of the soldiers in the Sikh regiments today are “mona”.
“Up untill the 1930's there was no such thing as a mona Sikh, you were called Hindu's and your entire contribution to SIKH History would not be enough to fill the pockets of Jassa Singh Aluwalia or Hari Singh Nalwa.”
Nice logic there buddy! Mona Sikh = Hindu? Why not Muslim or Jain? Like I said before, If you take these “mona” outs, then how many Sikhs did contribute to the Indian independence movement? If you answer is none (or small amount Sikhs), then why should the Indian government give land to Sikhs to start their own nation when they did nothing to free India from the British in the first place? Now I will stick with taking pride and biggin' up non-Khalsa/Amritdhari people like Shaheed Udham Singh and Maharaja Ranjit Singh
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
PTE SINGH · 05 Apr 2006
Just to clarify that the comments on Mona in Sikh history was not meant to offend. As ???? bought up the discussion my response was only to indicate that the mona phenomenon and contribution is relatively new and small in the context of 'SIKH HISTORY'.
I am not saying that the Shaheeds that ???? mentioned do not deserve acknowledgement , however HISTORY stands the test of time and geography. Now as it happens I’m from the UK and a picture of the person ???? mentioned does not adorn Gravesend Gurdwara. I cant pick up a readily available book on Sikh history that will mention him. In the same way that numerous people that fought the good fight here in the UK find no mention in North America or the rest of Europe.
The thousands of stories and the books we read today will mention many numerous Sikhs all of whom will be Sardars. From Bhai Mani Singh to Baba Bhanda Singh to the Punj Pyare, the 40 Mukta, Ranjit Singh, Hari Singh Nalwa, Jassa Singh Alluwalia, the defenders of Saragarhi and Satwant Singh, Beant Singh, Jarnail Singh Bindrawala, The Gadari Baba, who instigated the struggle for Indian independence. That is our HISTORY and any way in which you paint it is 99% Sardars.
This discussion at the moment is about Sikhs and Kesh vs. clean-shaven and should be limited to that. Why is ???? bringing in Muslims who fought and Halal meat, drink and the taking of Amrit to justify the not keeping of Kesh? That’s a whole new discussion and one we can get into latter. If I said that idol worshippers and those who worshipped other gods as well as ‘believed’ in Sikhi were still Sikh, would you all agree?
I don’t have a problem with Mona; many in my extended family are Mona, however the wider world society as in France at the moment asks for clarification. What are we to say?
As a nation we always say that Sikh men have beards and wear Turbans, we don’t say that SOME do or that it’s PREFERABLE that they do. British as well as Canadian Laws allow all SIKHS, not some Sikhs, but all SIKHS to wear turbans and beards where others are not allowed, i.e. in the army on building sites etc… ‘mona Sikhs’ are not allowed? Does British and Canadian law not recognise that group as Sikh enough…
Re:
unity · 05 Apr 2006
there was a subjective era in which we lived where we lived as we were taught, that time became blended from subjective to objective in between that phase mone may have been scolded for not keeping kes, this was also a time when singhs had a name, high moral character, and robh, when what a singh said or did carried weight. Now you do not find the qualities of old existing much in singhs themselves.
Also now a time where people are now educated, think of their own accord
that time is gone where mone would be sharminda about kes, and they can very easily take it as treading on their ground.
a good chunk never had kes in this modern time, and therefore would have no guilt about it the feeling that singhs try to induce will never surface hence a pointless waste of time.
let us for the sake of the debate exclude mone out of sikhi on the basis they do not keep kes. by the same argument let us also examine the shabad that defines a sikh to rise at amritvela and
exclude all amritdharis out of 3 4 million whatever in the panth who rise after as they do not fit the definition. But whats wrong now in applieing this definition?
now let us go by dasam granths definition of a sikh believe in caste for marriage considerations, seperation whatever and also exclude them, now would that be a lot of amritdharis or maybe just 10 out of 3 4 million? why cant we apply this definition?
and finally exclude all amritdharis who do not believe in khalistan from sikhism as defined by gyani thakur singhs statement in the khalistan chapter. now let us apply this. why not?
let us also look at why are amridaris forgiven for adultry and its ok just retake amrit and get pesh, while a bani reading mona rising amritvela whos never dated would not even be looked at on par? what kind of fake judging is that?
how many sikhs are left now? theres a difference bwteeen an ideal world and reality.
let us be realistic in terms of the sangat. there are some of you who are born in amritdhari families, there are others from mona families who have issues with your mone rishtedar but there are other amritdharis who are linked with mone in families living under the same house from day 1.
I can only see the gulf widening amongst amritdharis when we can be talking of REAL areas in which we can progress.
what is the point in saying you are not a sikh?
the point surely should be how do we make these guys sikhs to the level we wish them to aspire to?
it would be a great idea to bring more acceptance, the benefits could be mone doing seva and attending protests against hotel weddings, this would also capitate the mainstream perception of the two sided argument when they see mone with singhs.
it is mone brothers who are the progeny, of those great sikh singh shaheed forefathers who laid their lives down for the panth in those 300 500 years they are the children of singhs who fought and died and achieved victory. You have to learn to live with mone thats life! tough luck we did not ask for it but then theres a lot of things we find not palatable and have to learn to accept.
In the last 20 30 years it is these very people who laid down their resources with sacrifices for panthic causes along with singhs. It makes more sense to help brothers wherever we can, division is destructive by nature, sectarianism according to gurbani is what mankukhs do.
[%sig%]
Sikh Kache/Ghar Pucce - Solid home/Slippery Sikhs
Professor Mohinder Pal Singh · 05 Apr 2006
Dear visitors to this website :
There is a big contrast between the appearance of the two - Home and Body. Fundamentally, both are the forms of homes, one is for living of the body and the other, the home of the soul in the body.
In the olden days, we were more close to our Guru/Gurbani and Guru Granth Sahib. Now, we are becoming more close to Money/Bank balances/hypocricy. We are running away from our love for Sikhi and Sikhism. Reasons are best known to each and everybody. We simply blame to Fortune/Society/Poverty and to Girl friend or Boy-friend. And in our homes in USA/Canada and Europe, we have solid homes and we are slipping away from our Guru sahib, which adds to our mental agonies.
There is a big need to discuss and understand this topic, to be happy and contended.
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
. · 06 Apr 2006
kaljog has heightened , people suffer from mental and physiccal illnes, deppression, coping in a foreign country, pressures , hostility, the list goes on forever.
Some of us are lucky to have nam, amrit, sangat,kirpa of sikhi, which helps us through life others are not so lucky. Try to feel how life would be with the most important part missing.
Its not a duty to inform someone they are not sikh, to be told that is the most heartbreaking thing.
History writers can be biased pte singh .
Such as certain writers pointing in the negative on jassa singh ramgharia, banda singh bahadur causing more confusion instead of praising singhs lives. like the hs dulleh version.
singh sabha era is championed as a revolutiuon on one side while the mammoth gathering planned at darbar sahib for dalits to embrace sikhism has no mention in any sgpc book, no khalistan litereature, no space in singh sabha history.
the shaheeds who were mone fighting in the khalistan movement and attained martydom hardly have any mention on sikh websites exept for maybe 1 picture of shaheed harjinder singh parha on one website . Therefore those in charge always keep the upper hand in what they want you to know. Before we know it the reality on hardback paper is different to reality arund us. If tapoban sevedar knew such archives existed at the leicter gurdwara i am sure they would have approached, but even this is probably news because the mainstream sikh media just does not cover it.
we can go on and make more divisions but it will not benefit sikhism nor will it bring khalsa rule closer.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Prabhjoyt singh · 16 May 2006
where did monaism come from? when did someone just say "i am aSikh and i agree with the Teachings of the Sikhs Gurus but i cant grow my hair" when did someone say that and who was he?
this aint an argument pos but a question which i have had in my mind for a long time so if anyone knows answr it plz
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
J.A.T.T · 25 May 2006
Monaism? I think correct term is "Sehajdhari"
More information about Sehajdhari:
http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php?title=Sehajdhari
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Prabhjoyt Singh · 26 May 2006
that link says Bhai Khaniya Singh Ji was sehajdhari that is false Bhai Khaniya Singh was Amrtidhari for defo! It aslo says Bhai Nand Lal Singh jee were sehajdhari this again is false, do you realy think Guru Sahib would have a non-Amritdhari write Rehitnamay for the Khalsa?
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
J.A.T.T · 26 May 2006
When did Bhai Khaniya Ji & Bhai Nand Lal Goya Ji take amrit???????
Bhai Nand Lal Goya Ji might have become an Amritdhari, but he was sehajdhari first.
Anyway, they were both sehajdhari at least during some period of time in their lives before taking amrit (if they really did take amrit of course)
Besides, if they were amritdhari, then why didn't they add "Singh" to their last name? Also no one refer these two guys as "Singh".
[%sig%]
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
... · 27 May 2006
Bhai Sahib Khaniya Singh Ji and Bhai Sahib Nand Lal Singh Jee were two great Gurmukhs.
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Prabhjoyt Singh · 27 May 2006
we have recorded many names of Historic figures inncorectly
Bhai Gurdass jee-- Bhai Gurdass Singh Jee
Mata Gujjari--- Mata Gujjar Kaur Jee
Mai Bhago --- Mata Bhag Kaur Jee
Mata Sahib Devan --- Mata Sahib Kaur Jee
Bhai jeta jee ---- Bhai Jevvan Singh Rengreta Jee
Kavi Sainapat--- Bhai sain Singh Ji
are u calling Guru Ji a hypocryte by having a non-amrithdhari write rehitnamay for the Khalsa?
The reason Guru ji called him "lal" was out of affection
Lal=Piyara=beloved
Re: Sehajdhari/Clean shaven & Sikhism
Baljit Singh · 26 Jul 2006
After 240 years passing from Guru Nanak Dev Ji to Pitha Guru Gobind Singh Ji the 10 Guru's 1 joth-Light created the perfect human being.......'The Khalsa', Khalsa meaning 'Pure'. After the day of 1699 Vaisakhi there should be only 1 type of Sikh and that is a Amritdhari Sikh. Otherwise we are picking and choosing what we want out of Sikhi to create our own way of life.