Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Panthic · 28 Mar 2006

Extract From "SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA" By Bhai Randhir Singh Ji [i]Translated by: Jaspinder Singh sqn.ldr (Retd) I.A.F[/i] Among Sikh young men religious faith has suffered on account of the missing beard and among Sikh ladies such down fall is the non-belief in ‘Keski’ as part of Sikhi Rehat, the Code of ‘Five Kakkars’. The two evils have ushered in the epidemic of apostasy. Here is question-answer dialogue between an abiding Sikh girl with Keski and another fashionable ‘modern’ Sikh girl:- Chatter Kaur: O sister Suchet Kaur Ji! Since when did the usage of turban tying start among Sikh females? Suchet Kaur: Turban tying among Sikh ladies has been in usage ever since Sri Dasmesh Ji created Khalsa-Panth. Now you tell me since when has the lowly practice of tying hair in pleats, parting hair in the middle and hanging braids at the back started among you? C.K.: This has ever been in vogue with the females. The men are distinguished by their turban that the ladies do not wear. S.K.: Is this distinction right from birth? C.K.: No, it is not from birth. S.K.: When is a female distinguished? C.K.: Right from birth S.K.: What is mark of distinction then? At the time of birth, a baby girl has no pleats nor parting of hair. C.K.: (Interrupting S.K.) The new born have no hair, fit for pleating. S.K.: You only stated that pleats and parting of hairs starts from the very birth of females. C.K.: What I mean is that whether it is a boy or a girl is known from the very birth. Is it not a distinction? S.K.: But this distinction is of the sex-organs and not the hair. All other body parts are just the same. C.K.: This is right. S.K.: Now you agree that hair is not a distinguishing feature. In both cases ears and nose are not pierced. The natural gift of hair is cared for in the natural way only by Gursikhs. The nursery of Gursikhi, young boy and girls are taught to care for their hair in accordance with Gurmat-Code of living from the very beginning. All those of other faith are not particular concerned for maintaining natural hair as these grow. C.K.: In the case of children the hair are taken care of by pleating by braiding from the earliest custom. S.K.: The Sikh families, defying Gurmat and following-mind-wardness, copy the custom of braiding hair otherwise the abiding Sikhs comb the hair of their children with wooden comb and the grown hair are combed twice and tied in a knot over the head, irrespective of the child’s sex. C.K.: The usage of pleating is also followed. S.K.: Mere copying another’s custom does not make it the ordained Gurmat Code of living. C.K.: However a good custom does not call for negation. S.K.: What is good about tying up the hair in pleats and braids? C.K.: The hair is nicely kept and grows faster. S.K.: What is the urgency for fast growth of hair? Gurmat sanctions normal natural growth. The artificial growing or shortening is self-orientation instead of ordained Gurmat. There cannot be a better care for hair than combing, tying their knot at the top of head and covering the head with a turban. The mind-oriented ladies part the shortened hair of their children or make long braids at the back. This is ill-advised copying of others, non-sikhs. The lazy mothers are thus negligent of their duty to comply with Gurmat Rehat (code of living) and get the heads of their children infested with lice. The caring mothers comply with Gurmat practice of combing, making a knot at the top of head and tying a turban. Not only the hair is cared for and kept clean there is no scope for infestation with lice. The Gurmat ordained discipline ‘Combing twice and tying the turban layer by layer’ is maintained. C.K.: Of course the change is mere copying others. S.K.: The Gurmat Code is not following any custom, but a well thought of principle. C.K.: However it is difficult to comply with. S.K.: What is difficult about it? On the other hand making pleats and then picking up lice is cumbersome. The Gurmat style is unique and different from other customs. The difficulty is in parting from the old wrong practices. Tell me, is it better to part with wrong practices or sticking to them in fool hardiness? C.K.: No doubt Gurmat way is good and easy, yet the common people are prone to regard this as inferior and difficult. S.K: Leave aside what common people believe, let us talk about the discipline of Guru’s House. The abiding Sikhs are forbidden to follow fashion of parting hair and having long braids at the back. Non-compliance of Gurmat is rebellion against Guru. C.K: Some cunning preachers state that Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji never administered Amrit of The Double-edged Sword to ladies. They could only be initiated with Amrit of Kirpan, ordinary sword. S.K.: This is an utterly foolish statement. There is only one kind of initiation with Amrit. All get initiated with Amrit of The Double-edged sword irrespective of sex, according to Gurmat. "O, Nanak! There is only One Amrit and none other." This quote in Gurbani confirms Gurmat belief. Dasmesh Guru administered Double-edged-sword-Amrit Himself and then through the Five Beloved Ones to one and all, without discrimination of male of female or caste at Sri Kesgarh, Anandpur Sahib. To be continued...

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Panthic · 28 Mar 2006

Continued... C.K.: It is said that there was no female among the Five Beloved Ones, so females are not eligible for Amrit. S.K: This is a foolish argument. Guru Sahib laid down a principle that whosoever, whether male or female, is readily willing to offer in Sacrifice his/her all, mind, body and family is eligible for being initiated into Panth. It so happened that in the call of first selection, Bhai Daya Singh Ji, Bhai Dharam Singh Ji, Bhai Himat Singh Ji, Bhai Mohkam Singh Ji and Bhai Sahib Singh Ji offered themselves for the sacrifice. Had a female made such an offering, she too would have been included in the Five Beloved Ones. The Guru just established the example, that any sacrificing individual is eligible for being initiated with Gurmat Amrit. Some ignorant people are so lowly in thought that they consider eligible only those who belong to the castes same as the castes of The Five Beloved Ones. However, The Guru, having established the ideal of sacrificing Beloved Ones got countless men and women baptized in his own presence. This Amrit was same, of the Double-edged sword that was first administered to the The Beloved Ones. Thus many women became Singhanian and countless men of different castes became singhs and renounced casteism. There was no more discrimination after getting baptized. "One Sikh, two from Sadh Sangat and WAHEGURU is personified in the gathering of five" and the "exalted ones are recognized and they are acknowledged leaders," Gurbani quotes formed the basis by Guru Sahib for selecting only Five, after testing their mettle. He dropped the scene at that or else many Gursikhs were ready for the demanded sacrifice. Subsequently, many deserving persons got initiated with Amrit. Those, who were destined and ready, availed the opportunity and this process shall go on eternally. The discrimination on the basis of sex or caste is unthinkable nor is there any waiting for a propitious time for this. C.K.: It is established that the Amrit of the double-edged sword is common for all, men and women alike, from the time of Sri Guru Dasmesh Ji. However, it is still felt that living code for men and women should be distinct. S.K.: Why so? Amrit is the commonality between everyone, Amrit-Naam Gurmantar is the same and all are ordained to abide by the same Naam-devotion and the four strictly forbidden practices are the same for men and women. The Baptised Singh is committed to forsake sexual relations with other than his wife and the Baptised lady is equally strongly committed to forsaking sexual relations with the exception of her husband. Any violation of this discipline makes a man/woman apostate. C.K.: Yes, but there should be some difference in the code of the five Kakkars. S.K.: On what basis? C.K.: Women shy away from tying a turban. S.K.: Ladies of other faiths may be shy of tying a turban. However, how can Singhnian, baptized ladies feel ashamed in abiding by the ordained conduct. Prior to 1900, there were many Sikh wives, who felt shy of wearing a "kachhera." This was a parallel case of resistance to the tying of the turban at the present time. Even the half-baked Singhs felt odd about their wives wearing a "kachhera". Thus such women remained uninitiated and without Amrit. Only when the Guru Panth decided against sexual relationships with unbaptised wives was this resistance broken. It was thus made compulsory for a Sikh wife to be baptized and wear a "kachhera". In both cases, the resistance is created by fool-hardy self-oriented minds and a rebellion against Guru’s command of Gurmat. C.K.: Yes, the question of resistance to the "kachhera", one of the "kakkars", was unreasonable and was justifiably settled, but how is "dastar" a "kakkar"? It is a "D" in this case and not a "K", like "kachh", "kara", "kirpan", and "kangha". How can you replace "kes" as a "kakkar" with "dastaar"? S.K.: This is where the major mistake lies. The fifth kakkar is "keski" and not "kes". "Kachh, kara, kirpan, kangha, keski, abiding by this discipline of "Five Kakkar" alone is a Sikh." In the "Rehatnamas" of Guru Gobind Singh Ji’s ordained "Rehat", "Keski is clearly stated as a "Kakkar". It is by omission that "Keski" was reduced into "Kes" and over a period all "Rehatnamas" aligned with the omission. It is debatable whether the omission was an innocent one or purposely made by dishonest persons. However, there is no ambiguity in the fact that "kes" cannot be a "kakkar". The confusion created by the omission came handy to all those opposing the turban. C.K.: How can keeping "kes", unshorn hair, be called manmat or self-indulgence? S.K.: It is punishable to say a word against keeping unshorn hair. Sikhi is about maintaining one’s "kes" to the last breath. To do away with hair is not mere self-indulgence, rather it is an apostate deed. However, it is manmat to think of "kes" as a "kakkar". If a baptised person is without a "kakkar" that person is not considered apostate, rather the person is given a minor punishment and says a prayer for pardon. Removing any hair, on the other hand, calls for re-baptism. Calling "kes" a "kakkar" is to reducing the importance of "kes" and the worst manmat. It is prohibited to keep "kes" uncovered. Thus, it is mandatory to keep "kes" covered with a "keski" and to keep a "kangha" in the "kes". Any voluntary violation calls for punishment. Involuntarily misplacing a "kakkar" is a minor offence that does not amount to a major offence and does not necessitate re-baptism. However, a person short of any "kakkar" cannot be called an abiding Sikh. Without a "keski", a baptised lady falls short of two "kakkars". C.K.: How come? S.K.: Without a "keski", a baptised lady is not tying a knot of hair at the top of her head and is likely to have parted hair and braids or have pleated hair in order to conform with fashion. In either case, she cannot keep a "kangha" in her "kes". To be continued...

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjuk-ute · 28 Mar 2006

it has never been part of akj for singhnees to be in panj i know many singhs singhnees from bhai sahibs time, and not one of them had singhnees in panj one person i know had babu mal singh chosen to to seva in panj, but as soon as babu ji stepped into that room he represented one of the original panj (and ceased to be babu mal singh) look at all amrit sanchars done by akj akjuk akj india singhnia are not put in panj becuase no singhnia were present in the original panj 5 pyare - bhai daya singh, bhai mokham singh, bhai sahib singh,bhai tharam singh, bhai himmat singh when 5 singhs come together each singh represents each of the original paanj since original panj were all singhs, 5 singhs make up panj. ie when you go to take amrit you see 5 SINGHS - bhai daya SINGH, bhai mokham SINGH, bhai sahib SINGH,bhai tharam SINGH, bhai himmat SINGH singhs and singhnees are equal, but this doesnt mean they must be able to each others roles. a singhnee cannot represent a singh, they have different physical forms. this is why singhs in panj must not be deformed, they must have same BASIC PHYSICAL FORM. dont play this equality thing, akj is totally for equality, modern sikhs/jathe cannot take cerain aspects of sikhi like 5 singhs in panj, or that all gurus were in male form, people end up bending rules.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

TarrandeepKaur · 29 Mar 2006

akjuk-ute is 10000%%% CORRECT!!! vahigurrrrrrrrrrroooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

AKJ UK singh · 29 Mar 2006

what are you on about ? Singhnia have done seva in the panj in India. Even in Uk, the panjdo not only do amritsanchaars, but the AKJ UK is run by 5 Gursikhs. It always has been. The Jathedar and General Secretary are only two people, but they always have 3 other singhs with them to help run AKJ UK. In the past Bibi Manmohan kaur has done seva in this Panj that run AKJ Uk. In AKJ UK, the 5 with the highest avastha are choosen, if in the future a bibi is there, then she will be choosen.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

quackquack · 29 Mar 2006

ive never seen bibia in panj akj uk singh, bibia were not present in panj pyare of 1699, therefore they are not included in panj now. not complicated.i hav been told baba ram singhs (ex akj jathadar) wife said this.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjuk-ute · 29 Mar 2006

FROM AMRIT KI HAI - The Gurmat Method of Giving Amrit Bhai Sahib- It is a matter of great regret and surpise that you have personally partook of Amrit and have witnessed ceremonies for giving Amrit many times, you you have not understood the secrets of the Gurmat method of giving Amrit. In order to give Gurmat Amrit, the following equipment and methods are used: 1. In the presence of Guru Granth Sahib, at least six Gurmukh SINGHS are required, for whom it is necessary to be practitioners of Nam, gourmets of the Nam, lovers of Gurbani, Nitnemi, and firmness in Gurmat lifestyle. There should not be even one transgressor (kurehitia) among them. There should not even be an ang-heen (without ang) among them. (Note: the word used in the original Punjabi is "Singh") Bhai Randhir Singh ji, "What is Amrit" in "Gurmat Vichar", pp. 34

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjuk-ute · 29 Mar 2006

The Olden Maryada of the Akhand Kirtani Jatha "As a result of the company of Mahapurkhs, this humble servant has certain memory that in this Jatha, the Prasad-distributing Singh used to be completely ready (tiar-bar-tiar), and they only used to take water and clean the hands of those completely ready Singhs whose Singhnis were adopters of the keski rehit, then used to have the prasad of the Panj Piyare only to them and those Singhs whose Singhnis were keski-less did not get the the portion for the Panj Piyare. Neither did such Singhs ever take the prasad of the Panj Piyare." page 175, Son chiri chari gain, Bhai Jodh Singh (Note: the word used in the original Punjabi is "Singh")

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Sengh · 29 Mar 2006

i think they are talking about the panj that does amrit sanchars and within the panj that does amrit sanchars there are no singhnis in akj uk or akj india i dont think.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjuk-ute · 29 Mar 2006

mmmmmm akj uk singh if your right something is wrong bhai sahib clearly states 6 singhs, not 6 gursikhs. this point should be highligted at the next akj commitee meeting, to ensure amrit sanchars conducted by akj are as per khalsa code which bhai sahib reminded us of.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Balpreet Singh · 29 Mar 2006

I didn't want to comment but this is going way-overboard. First, there is no basis to say Bibian can't distribute degh, or make degh or receive degh of Punj Pyaare. When refering to a seva, I and most others usually just say "Singhs". It doesn't mean that only Singhs can do that seva though. Giani Harbhajan Singh, one of Bhai Sahib's companions and who still keeps very strict rehit including Sarbloh Bibek has said that in one instance he knows of, a bibi did seva in the Punj Pyaare. He would have no reason to lie about this. He has no vested interest in it. I don't want this to turn into a bibi in Punj Pyare disucssion because we've done that more than once on this Forum so just look back. But when we're going so far as to limit Bibian and their role in Degh Seva, it's going to unacceptable extremes.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjuk-ute · 29 Mar 2006

balpreet singh how can you reject what bhai sahib has WRITTEN you WANT to believe a STORY over a WRITTEN STATEMENT ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1. In the presence of Guru Granth Sahib, at least six Gurmukh SINGHS are required, for whom it is necessary to be practitioners of Nam, gourmets of the Nam, lovers of Gurbani, Nitnemi, and firmness in Gurmat lifestyle. There should not be even one transgressor (kurehitia) among them. There should not even be an ang-heen (without ang) among them. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- it specifically says 6 SINGHS, it could have said 6 GURSIKHS this would allow bibia in panj BUT it says SINGHS not GURSIKHS

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Balpreet Singh · 29 Mar 2006

As I said earlier, the term "Singh" is used in a lot of other places as well for sevas and duties but that doesn't mean that these things are restricted just to Singhs. At any rate, what I'm taking issue with is your going overboard and restricting degh seva to Singhs only as well.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjuk-ute · 29 Mar 2006

im not saying singhnia cant do seva, just using that other quote from jodh singh to illustrate the fact that degh is given to panj singhs before given to rest of sanghat. ie panj pyare

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akj uk singh · 30 Mar 2006

akjuk-ute - I am not sure who you are, but what you are saying is incorrect. When Bhai sahib writes Singhs it means Gursikhs including bibian. In the tract "Singhan da Panth Narala", he was speaking to both singh and singhnia. The term singhs in prataan times represented both Singhs and singhnia, because singhnias in them days had the same Roop as Singhs. So please stop confusing yourself and others.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

... · 30 Mar 2006

"Singhaan da panth nirala" hawwwwwww! Bhai Sahib is saying the Panth is only for Singhs. See? Bhai Sahib has used "Singhaan" so clearly it's only Singhs' Panth. See the flawed logic ?

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjuk-ute · 30 Mar 2006

akj uk singh-"When Bhai sahib writes Singhs it means Gursikhs including bibian" ????????????????????????? bhai sahib only used to speak absolute truth, he meant what he said and said what he meant. singhs means singhs. its like me trying to argue black is white. "Singhaan da panth nirala" - the panth is run by singhs, this is why bhai sahib says singha da panth nirala this doesnt mean panth doesnt include singhnees why do you complicate things???????????? there is no flawed logic. for example lets take akjuk, who are the main figures? we have bhai jarnail singh, bhai raghbir singh, bhai sohan singh, bhai onkar singh, bhai tarsem singh dont play the sexist argument with me becuase im totally for equality, but singhs and singhnees have different roles. it surprises me what lengths people go to in an attempt to support their own mat. stop trying to interpret and twist bhai sahibs words. ------------------------------------------------------------------- 1. In the presence of Guru Granth Sahib, at least six Gurmukh SINGHS are required, for whom it is necessary to be practitioners of Nam, gourmets of the Nam, lovers of Gurbani, Nitnemi, and firmness in Gurmat lifestyle. There should not be even one transgressor (kurehitia) among them. There should not even be an ang-heen (without ang) among them. -------------------------------------------------------------------- why did bhai sahib need to include the word SINGH, it could have been left at 6 GURMUKHS. fullstop, it SPECIFICALLY says SINGHS WHATS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE THE TRUTH IS HERE IN FRONT OF YOUR EYES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

... · 30 Mar 2006

Can someone say "mysogyny" ? If it's "here in front of your eyes" the title of the tract says "Singhan Da Panth Nirala" so only the Singhs' are nirala. What about the Singhnis? Are they part of this Panth? Because it's "Singhaan da Panth". Wait, if it's Singhan da Panth and we are supposed to read it literally, then it's not Guru Sahib's Panth? What does this mean? It means to use your common sense.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjuk-ute · 30 Mar 2006

... sed "Singhan Da Panth Nirala" so only the Singhs' are nirala. What about the Singhnis? Are they part of this Panth? Because it's "Singhaan da Panth"." the panth is basically run by singhs, hence singhan da panth ... sed "Wait, if it's Singhan da Panth and we are supposed to read it literally, then it's not Guru Sahib's Panth? What does this mean?" singhan and guru sahib = same, no difference, didnt you know that?

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjuk-ute · 30 Mar 2006

basically you people think bhai sahib called singhnees singhs why would he do such a thing? do you think bhai sahib thought singhs are more important, therefore called everyone singhs including singhnees? if i was a singhnee i would be offended if someone reffered to me as singh, or referred to singhnees as singhs just as i wouldnt be to happy if someone called me a singhnee, or called singhs singhanees singhs and singhanees are equal but different.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

... · 30 Mar 2006

If male Sikhs run the Panth, then why did Guru Amar Das appoint so many female Manjis? Women like Mata Bhag Kaur were leaders. So they weren't capable of leading the Panth? Mata Sahib Kaur and Mata Sundari issued numerous hukumnamas to the Khalsa Panth after Guru Gobind Singh, weren't they leading the Panth? It is unacceptable sexism to say the Panth is only for Singhs or run only by Singhs. This is not acceptable and has never been the stand in the Akhand Kirtani Jatha. Don't give us a bad name with your views.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjuk-ute · 30 Mar 2006

haha new it, you had to turn this into a sex thing, its people like you who say sikhi isnt fair because all 10 gurus were in male form you have been unable to respond to any of my other comments, so you have had to turn it into an attack on me calling me sexist. i have already given you the akjuk example , im not gonna write an essay.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjuk-ute · 30 Mar 2006

i dont know much history i did a random search on sikhs of the panth and picked the first webpage and the following list came up 20th Century Shaheeds of the Panth Bhai Anokh Singh Ji Babbar Jathedar Avtar Singh Ji Brahmaa, KLF Shaheed Beant Singh Ji and Shaheed Satwant Singh Ji Bhai Dilaavar Singh Ji Babbar Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji Manochahal, BTF Jathedar Gurjant Singh Ji BudhSinghWala, KLF Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa, Bhindranwale Shaheed Bhai Jasbir Singh Ji Babbar , BKI General Labh Singh Ji , KCF Shaheed Sukhdev Singh "Sukha" and Shaheed Harjinder Singh "Jinda" Jathedar Sukhdev Singh Ji, BKI Jathedar Talvinder Singh Ji, BK Canada Puratan Singhs and Shaheeds of the Panth Bhai Dayal Ji Baba Deep Singh Ji, Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh Ji Bhai Mati Daas Ji Singhneea from Meer Manu's Prison Gurmukhs of the Panth Bhai Nand Singh Ji (Bhai Nand Lal Ji) Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji Bhai Hira Singh Ji - Ragi Bhai Sahib Bhai Veer Singh Ji Prof. Sahib Singh Ji Prof. Gurmukh Singh Ji then you have the 1978 shaheeds, and other gurmukhs like baba budda, there are many bibia also but majority are singhs. this is a fact, cant call me sexist. these singhs wouldnt have existed if it werent for bibia, singhs and singhnees are equally important in the panth, but have different roles.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

... · 30 Mar 2006

The number of Bibian who have taken leadership roles or major sevas is huge. Just because they don't appear on Fort Panth Khalsa's website doesn't make their role any lesser. Off the top of my head I can think of Bibi Nanaki as the first Sikh, Bibi Bhani jee, Mata Khivi, Bibi Harsharan Kaur (Chamkaur Saka), Mata Bhag Kaur, Bibi Balbir Kaur, Bibi Sharan Kaur, and in modern times Bibi Satnam Kaur, Bibi Vahiguru Kaur, Bibi Ravinder Kaur and countless others. What role do you have in mind for Singhnees? You said they have different roles. What role is that? Care to elaborate? Where is this role elaborated? I have seen Guru Gobind Singh's description of a Khalsa and they seem to apply to both Singhs and Singhnees. Have you seen otherwise? So I'm interested. What role do you think Singhnees have in the Panth.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjuk-ute · 30 Mar 2006

lol, theres no point you will just call me sexist bhai randhir singh was a singh so are/were nearly all prominent figures of other jathebhande lets look at akjuk again bhai jarnail singh bhai sohan singh bhai raghbir singh bhai bhopinder singh bhai tarsem singh etc india, baba ram singh was jathadhar now pooranji, bhai jeevan singh, bhai rama singh uk, list is endless. if you cant see singhs have a far more prominent role in running the panth there is no point discussing with you, especally seen that most of my points have gone unanswered.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Panthic · 30 Mar 2006

Continued... C.K.: Why not? "Kangha" can be carried in a pocket. S.K.: "Kangha" is not meant to be carried in a pocket, but in the hair. Somebody may come up with the suggestion of carrying the "kachhera" in a pocket. We know better than that. Just as "kachhera" is to cover our bare body, the hair needs the "keski" in order to be covered and the top knot of hair is a must for keeping the "kangha". The right place for the "kangha" is in the hair on the head and not in a pocket. C.K.: It is not essential to tie a knot of hair at the top. It may also be tied at the back at the "kangha" can also be kept there. S.K.: O yes sister! There are ladies, who are semi-fashionable, keeping knotted hair at the back and claiming to be abiding Sikhs and yet unable to resist fashion. It is not just the knotted hair at the back but so also is their sense that lies buried there. Firstly, these ladies are unlikely to keep a "kangha". Most would keep clips in their knotted hair. Where is the place for the "kangha"? Kangha cannot be supported below the knot and when placed above it, it interferes with fashion. Have you ever seen them with a "kangha"? The "kangha" aside, even their fashionable head cloth keeps slipping from their head. C.K.: This is true. The level head, having knotted hair at the back, cannot support the slipping head cloth. That is why the fashionable girls have done away with the head cloth. S.K.: It is not even done away with completely. Rather, they put it around the neck abiding with the latest fashion. Head-cloth around the neck and bare is the scalp and head. Is this dress befitting for Sikh ladies? C.K: Of course it is not befitting. You are right there. This is unworthy copying of others’ fashion in blind following. S.K: This is an evil custom that does not befit us. It is highly degrading the "kes" that are regarded holy in Gurmat, blessed with holy Amrit at "Dasam Duar", top of the head and thus the "Kes" becoming highly venerable. Exposing the "Kes" all the time, even while roaming around the streets and market places, is disgraceful. The dust covers the exposed hair, and this is condemned in Gurbani in Asa-Dee-Vaar: [i]"Flying dust keeps falling in the hair and the watching public ridicules this."[/i] An uncovered head invites all this shame. It is strange that our modern, fashionable ladies are immune to this self-inflicted shame of two braids hanging at the back of their uncovered heads. However, for them the shame lies in tying a turban. For winning admiration of the evil rogues, it is essential to comply with the latest current fashion. Their husbands are equally shameless who allow their wives to stray around inviting lustful glances of the wicked who are [i]"seeking other women forsaking their wedded wives."[/i] Is this noble behaviour? All this delving in fashion amounts to attracting the attention of other men’s lustfulness. Even the parents of Sikh school and college girls, parading in groups with bare heads, are accepting the sway of evil fashion without a whimper. On the other hand, they take pride in their darlings as models of fashion. To fall in line, such parents also submit to fashion in preference to Guru-ordained discipline. The current fashion, characterless exhibitionism is regarded as the most admirable turnout. Cursed be such evil-thinking parents, the so-called Sikhs, who gladly permit their daughters and daughters-in-law to indulge in evil ways and evil company. They should all shun the evil instead of shunning Gurmat discipline. What is there to fear from general non-acceptance? "[i]The one living in sin should be afraid, while a righteous being is always in high spirits."[/i] The righteous beings should abide by ordained Gurmat discipline and keep flourishing in high spirits, without a care to run for general acceptance and compliance with current styles. C.K: Whatever you have said is a hundred percent correct. The school and college girls are generally spoiled. Parents should not send them for studying. What is there to lose in forgoing such studies? S.K: Just a blind following. Many Sikh families are stuck in this cursed practice. Are the girls going to join some sort of service after studying? It is merely to attract educated boys for marrying their daughters. The seeking for educated boys is high. According to Gurbani quote, [i]"Such an educated person is an idiot, who is ridden with greed, avarice and ego",[/i] education, without mind enlightenment, makes a person idiotic. It is asking for affliction of suffering by going into a relationship with greedy and egotistical boys. How can there be peace in such a case? The worldly greedy parents, thinking an educated boy to be well earning, give their daughters in marriage to such boys who think highly of themselves. This is a foolish self-entrapment. C.K: Why do parents not send their daughters to religious institutions? Are there no such schools for Sikh girls? S.K: Plenty! However, these are no different. They are named as religious institutes without imparting religious education. There are no teachers of religious outlook nor are any organized courses for building religious background among students. Even the classes for the "Giani" course are prescribed with ill-advised romantic novels that pollute the minds, much opposed to Gurmat of Divine fear and love. In reality, not only girls but even boys go to such institutions. Sikh institutions are the bases of embroilment in evil. In these dens of sin, life is rotten. Students do not get enlightened. Without character building, studying is useless. These institutions are contradictory to Gurmat-discipline. The products of non-religious Sikh colleges are generally non-religious, atheists and keep bad company. C.K.: It is now clear that without the "keski" the baptised man/woman is not an abiding Gursikh. It is also established that the baptised ladies having braids are without a "kangha". How come such violations of Gurmat discipline are taken so lightly? S.K.: This is their misfortune and misdeeds of polluted thinking. Says Guru Gobind Singh Ji, "I love righteous Gurmat living of a Sikh and not mere Sikh in name." Further he says "Only the abiding Sikh, observing Gurmat discipline is my Sikh." If an abiding happens to remain without a ‘Kakkar’ involuntarily, by mistake even, he forgoes food and drink till he seeks pardon through a prayer. The Sikh ladies, who knowingly ignore ‘Keski’, are confirmed guilty and punishable. Their husbands, who eat with them and have relationship, are also guilty. C.K: It is improper to show any respect to husbands, who fail to ensure their wives observing Sikhi discipline. S.K: The slaves to way-ward, undisciplined wives are certainly not shown the respect due to an abiding Sikh in House of the Guru. C.K: This fact of withholding deference must be apparent and noticeable by the erring Sikh husbands. S.K.: What can be more apparent than non-acceptance of these husbands for selection to ‘Five Beloved’ in Amrit-initiation ceremony. They are considered equally guilty as their erring wives, without ‘Keski’ C.K: What is the punishment for committing strictly prohibited violations against Sikh discipline of Gurmat? S.K: The defaulters are pronounced apostates. Those having relationship with apostate wives are also considered apostate. They have to get rebaptised and whatever punishment is prescribed during re-initiation with Amrit, they have to undergo. C.K: Obviously initiation of only one of the couple is not acceptable. It appears mandatory for both husband and wife to be baptized. S.K: Wife is considered ‘better half’ for the husband and both join to make a married couple. Any one of the couple is denied baptism singly. It may only be made an exception, if the person seeking baptism undertakes in presence of Sri Guru Granth Sahib and The Five Beloved Ones to abstain marital relationship with the unbaptised partner till such time that he/she gets baptized. C.K: At few places, specially at Akal Takhat, singles are freely baptized, without any condition. Thus baptism is left to free will. S.K: This is a grave omission. The practice of old priests still persists. Modern Akalis are queer persons. Following Gandhism, they are even willing to lose their separate identity from Hindus and Muslims. However Guru Sahib has clearly prohibited relationship with Smokers, Killers of baby-females and persons from Sikh families, who shave off hair, by abstaining eating with them or inter-marrying. Yet, these half-baked Akalis of Gandhism, are least bothered about Guru-ordained discipline. They have no fearful respect of abiding Sikhi. They freely eat with smokers. If such Godless people are in authority for Amrit-administering, they could not be bothered to check elegibility or otherwise conforming to Gurmat standards. It is this devil-way-care attitude that has destroyed pride in Sikhi of outstanding merit, distinctiveness, glory and firmness of character. They have nothing in common with righteousness of Khalsa Akali Singhs nor do they reflect the high character of the Brave singhs of yesteryears, nor their activity or polity reflects Gurmukh humility. Sikh-discipline of Gurmat is totally missing in them. Losing their distinct identity, they have become immune to Gurmat teachings and discipline. They have no love for Gurbani or Naam nor faith. They are enamoured by worthless power-politics and avarice for worldliness and in pursuit of this, they have acquired slaving mentality for selfish ends. The high ideal of spirituality is nowhere in their reckoning. Some of them, who show concern for Panth, have heavy leanings towards others of different faith. Their intermingling with Hindu masters leaves no scope for essence of Khalsa personality. Lost to touch of spirituality, they are just dancing to the tune of others. They are happy to transform their wives in the customs and outlook of Hindu wives, conforming to their masters. They are happily adorning them with skirts and saris, but making no allowance for pride in Gurmat way of dressing. The outer wear has lot of influence on the inner mind and thinking. The Gurmukh-way of dressing of Guru-oriented Singhs reflects every bit of their Gurmukh personality and abiding faith, when we behold Gurmukh - like beard, double turban of a ‘Brave Khalsa’. A tied-up beard and western dress of coat and pants, topped with fashionable multi-coloured turban never can give an impression of the person as a Gurmukh Gursikh. Further, their doll-like fashionable wives in Saris, wearing gilted bangles instead of a ‘Kara’, accompany them shoulder-to-shoulder. What to talk of their hair fashion of bare-heards, ladies with red-painted lips walking by the side arm-in-arm, can such fashion model person be Akali-Khalsa? In self-justification, they make their empty utterances to the effect, "The essence is purity of mind. What use is the outer display of Kakkars?" How would they reply to the questions, "If the mind is pure, how come the face is smeared? Why the lips are painted?" The fashionable exterior is indeed a reflection of a lowly mind, that would never be ever be clean. Instead of righteous thinking, their polluted minds yearn for sinful deeds. The ill-advised, shameful dress is only the initial step! To be continued...

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

... · 30 Mar 2006

Don't back down now! Tell us what you think the role of the Singhnis is in the Panth. I've already shown you with examples that Bibian have lead the Panth at times (example of Mata Sahib Kaur and Mata Sundari jee issuing hukumnamas to the entire Panth) As for "nearly all prominent figures of other jathebandis" and AKJ as well being men; it may apply to other Jathas, but not Akhand Kirtani Jatha. Akhand Kirtani Jatha is much different that your regular Jatha or as it may be, Saadh Tola. Who was it that gave blessings to Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh to go forth and do akhand paaths and enjoy akhand kirtan? It was MATA Gulab Kaur. In Rangle Sajjan, Bhai Sahib features Mata Prem Kaur, Bibi Harbans Kaur, Bibi Joginder Kaur along with many others he names in the text. Don't negate the role of bibian in either the Panth or the Jatha.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Panthic · 30 Mar 2006

Continued... [Final Part] C.K: Yes! This is absolutely right. The evil minds have plenty of excuses to justify their wrongdoing. The non-abiding Sikh ladies are often heard to say "How does a turban increase faith in Sikhi? True faith is in Naam and Bani." S.K: How much could they be devoting to Naam, Purifier of mind? Their embroilment in fashion, as fashion-models is a clear indication of the polluted minds. They cannot be regular in Nit-Nem, daily prayers. How can they spare time for Naam Baani? Their life is too full with rate-race of worldliness. The modern fashionable girls may perform Gurbani Kirtan just for show, lacking in depth of inner feeling of the enshrined Gurbani. They do try to impress with artistry in music, only if they really lose themselves in love for Gurbani Kirtan, they would derive personal benefit of inner spiritual enhancement and the audience will also feel enchanted. The real devotional attitude leaves no scope for interest in artificial make-up for self-conscious show of appearance. It only promotes abiding faith and discipline, eagerness to comply with Gurmat. Indeed submitting dutifully to all the Commands of Guru is True Rehat, Code of living. The topmost priority is to devote to Naam Contemplation. However all the other discipline is essential to prepare the foundation for spiritual edifice. If one fails to carry out the preliminary instructions, how can one be expected to comply with stricter and more demanding discipline? If somebody claims to be a Naam-devotee in self-effacement, what is there to hold back from adopting Guru-ordained distinct identity? Such a false claim is merely in frivolous argumentation. In fact a fashionable girl and Gurbani Kirtan are just not compatible, with opposite nature of orientation. Pothohar, especially Rawalpindi (now in Pakistan) was centre of acclaimed Kirtan. Sadly the love for ‘Mod’ fashion also originated from there, seeking to wear a look for public admiration. However this proved to be undoing of the Sikh Nation. Rare is the person who becomes of high spiritual stature, but the numbers of lowly fallen abound. Performing Kirtan, lacking in depth, the ‘Mod’ Kirtania girls were swayed away by fashion without a respite or recovery. They were distanced from Gursikhi and Gurmat discipline. The erstwhile followers with Keski were swept away by the desire to go about bareheaded shamelessly. It is not intended to encourage mere showmanship of outer Sikh religion and Khalsa wear. The inspired love for Sikhi discipline from within is really proper and commendable. Who says that abiding Sikh ladies with Keski do not contemplate Naam and say their daily prayers, Nit-Nem and Bani. For abiding Sikhs, it is improper to boast of their Sikhi discipline, unlike the pretending ‘Mod’ ones. The abiding Sikh ladies not only reflect the glory of their Sikhi Regalia but also the spiritual splendour on their forces. C.K: Truly the youthful glory of the newly baptized faces is unbearable. It is also undeniable that Kirtan by the abiding Sikh girls is beyond comparison, spiritually touching and their faces reflect their innermost high spirituality. In my own experience, I remained in high Sikhi spirits as an abiding Sikh girl and I had great dedication to Naam and Baani. Performing Kirtan, I would lose myself totally in Kirtan and the listeners were enchanted too. Sadly this did not last long. I was given away in marriage to a tardy Sikh youth, who did not believe in ‘Kakkars’. His unspirited Sikhi had direct effect on me. This Sikhi only in name degraded my original love to lowly depths. The glory of these days is like a dream now. After baptism, I was given the name ‘Sugarh Kaur’, but my in-laws did not approve of this. My old dead name was revived and I remained ‘Chattar Kaur’ only. In the view of ‘Evil mind thinking up countless excuses’, my mind started thinking justification against ‘Keski’ that was dearer to me than life. In reality the unworthy husbands of young abiding sikh girls are responsible for their down fall from the upkeep of ‘Keski’ Kakkar. This is also true that an abiding Sikh match of young elegible men is a rarity these days. S.K: It is not a rarity, but the will to find is not there. The match-seekers often look for a well to do family, prosperous in worldly wealth and comfort. Sikhi and Sikh values are no-where in the reckoning. It is not only the parents to blame. If Sikhi and Gurmat is dear to the eligible girls they can hold on to their values determinedly and no power on earth can change them. C.K: You are very right, but personal values do get affected by peer-pressure and company that one keeps, specially in the case of immature girls, like me. Rare are the abiding ones who dare to stick to their Faith in Gurmat ordained ideals through thick and thin. Very rare indeed are exemplary beings like Bibi Daler Kaur, not every one can willingly make the required sacrifice. S.K.: Bad example is readily followed, just as you gave up ‘Keski’ to conform to the general appearance of Hindu women. You ought to have displayed some determination in Sikhi-Faith and resistance to undermine Gurmat values. Even now, it is not too late. Satguru will surely provide help for you to awaken spiritually and re-establish your original values. C.K: I agree, dear sister! Pray for me. What shall follow will be according to Guru’s dispensation. Let me make one more admission of guilt. After falling from the ordained Sikh discipline, I was instrumental in weaning away other abiding Gursikh ladies from their Faith. I did this through argumentation of negativism. I seek pardon for this sin, also, I am now so determined that even if my husband is unwilling to accept me as abiding Gursikh, I shall still not abandon Sikhi. My marital relationship with him will depend upon his accepting Sikh Faith in totality. I now request for my rehabitation as abiding Gursikh. S.K: Well done! Sister you are indeed ‘Sugarh Kaur’. You must readopt this name only. The other name is dead for you. It is no good to carry the carcass of old name that must be discarded. On the next seventh of ‘Poh’ month Samagam Gurpurab, you will be presented before The Five Beloved Ones, at the place of initiation Ceremony, Amrit-Sanchar. There you will receive the Commands for restoration of your faith and ever thereafter you will be blissful both here in this world as well as in the hereafter. ---------------------- Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

DasnDas* · 30 Mar 2006

vjkk ,vjkf the last picture looks amazing. :) vjkk, vjkf

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

... · 31 Mar 2006

akjute, I was reading Gurmat Bibek and it says "[gurbani]pUrn DrmI gurmiq-DwrI AwigAwkwrI isMG sujwn hovy so kry gurU ky lMgr dI syvw[/gurbani]" It mentions "Singhs" again in the same section but NO mention of Singhnis or Bibis. Uh-Oh! According to your interpretation, it's time to kick all the bibis out of the langar and for the Singhs to do it. Each Singh's home is also a langar, and so Sikh men should only do the seva there. You and I both know Bibian can do langar seva, then why did Bhai Sahib use "SINGH" for this seva? Reason: just a generic term. Just like he used it in the quote you provided.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjsevadar · 01 Apr 2006

I have read these posts with great interest. It seems as if the discussion is missing some critical points : Some point for akjute : You cannot simply say wherever we use the word Singhan we mean Singh and Singhnian. If this was the case then clearly there is no need for the word Singhnian !! Also why do we never refer to Singhnian di panth nirala . You must look at context. Gurmat Bibek is all about rahit for all sikhs. So throughout Gurmat Bibek Singhan generally refers to Singh and Singhnian. You cannot then say wherever in any book anybody refers to Singhan it means Singhs and Singhnian. So what happens when we refer to Singhan di bhaone(showers) - does that mean Singhs and Singhnian !! NO Also I have been amritdhari for 25 years and met Babu Mal Singh, Bhai Hajoora Singh and many others. My uncle knew Bhai Sahib for 20 years. Whenever I am with these Singhs we talk about Sikihi, rahit and the old days when Bhai Sahib was here. None of these have ever mentioned to me Singhnian in the Panj Piare. My wife took amrit when Babu Mal Singh was in the Panj - no Singhnian then even though there were very many Gurmukh Singhnian around at the time Of course in our Panth there is equality. What does equality mean ??? Whatever a man can do a woman can do ? Ok then a woman can marry a woman ?? NO. Can a man get pregnant NO. You misunderstand the meaning of equality. Equality means everybody is treated with equal respect and has the same access to become mukat. Neither singh nor singhnian are superior. We are judged by deeds. This does NOT mean men and women can do the same things. Men cannot breast feed, is this inequality ?? No, Singh and Singhnian have roles to play - as defined in Gurbani. Singhnian play the mother role (poota mata ki asees), Singhs play the Father role (too gur pita hai...). Each role is different but EQUALLY as important So the tradition from Guru's time is the Panj are Five Singhs - full stop. This does not mean singhnian are not equal. It simply is another ROLE. Please do not confuse Western manmat and inequality with pure sikh principles. Sikhs believe in equality and different roles for different people. These are two different concepts NOT one. Please do not mix western manmat with gurmat.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Daas Soora · 01 Apr 2006

VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeekeeFateh The future will hold thousands of Tyar bar tyar Singhnia which will be taking part in the seva of the panj with singhs. Don't distingush males with females, they're both the same thing. Any of you could have been a female in your past life and now a male, you never know. So, when you call singhnia less religious than singhs your basically talking about yourself, singhs. Its not the case that a singh or singhni can part in the panj its the fact that only a Gurmukh is allowed to take part in the Panj. Each individual in the panj has to be tyaar bar tyaar to represent Guru Gobind SIngh Jee once they are as a Panj. A Khalsa is above this inequality, a Khalsa is not a male nor a female but just a light. Sat Sri Akaal VaheguruJeeKaaKhalsa VaheguruJeekeeFateh

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjsevadar · 01 Apr 2006

Daas Soora, your comments are, I am afraid, your own thoughts (ie 'daas soora mat') and not gurmat. You have not read my mail properly or understood what I am saying. We are not talking about inequality. I have already said we believe in equality. Playing different roles does not make us unequal. Can father play a mothers role ? Can a mother play a fathers role. Why did Waheguru make mothers, fathers males and female!! It is all a part of a wonderous play. A mothers role is no less than a fathers role and vice versa. A man cannot breast feed. Shall I complain to Waheguru that he is discriminating against men ??!! Why did waheguru make men not able to breast feed or give birth ? Is this inequality from Waheguru ?? No of course not men play certain roles and women play certain roles. So please stop thinking with the limited Western concept of equality that you read in women's magazine's. Khalsa is above all that. Panj Piare must be of a certain form. So if you are ang heen (missing a limb for example) then you are not allowed in the Panj, this we all know about (read Bhai Sahib's Amrit Ki Hai book). So is this inequality for the handicapped !!!! What about if you are not chardi kala jeevan, or you are kurahiti - again you cannot go in the Panj - so is this inequaility against 'kurahits' or against 'non chardi kala' sikhs!!!!!! I am sorry but Gurmat says the Panj have to be panj SINGHS, chardi kala, non kurahiti, and not ang heen. When you do more kamaai you will see the truth of why this is [%sig%]

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

The Sarbloh Singh · 01 Apr 2006

akjsevadar is correct. Panj must be Singhs, with chardi kala jeevan. Non kurahiti, non ang heen, just like the original Panj were Singh's. All ten human Guru's were male. Why did Waheguru not send a female Guru ? Are you saying Waheguru is practising inequality ?????!!!!!!!! NO this is His Hukam

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

' · 01 Apr 2006

IK SIKH DOAY SAADH SANG PANJEE PARMESHAR (Bhaaee Sahib Gurdaas Jee) PANCH PARVAAN PANCH PARDHAAN (SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE - JAPJEE SAHIB) "One Sikh, two form Sadh Sangat and WAHEGURU is personified in the gathering of five" and the "exalted ones are recognized and they are acknowledged leaders," Gurbani quotes formed the basis by Guru Sahib for selecting only Five, after testing their mettle.(Bhaaee Sahib Randheer Singh Jee-(translation)) DHAN DHAN SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE ੴ ਸਤਿ ਗੁਰਪ੍ਰਸਾਦਿ ॥ ik-oNkaar sat gurparsaad. There is but One God. By the True Guru's grace He is obtained ਗਉੜੀ ਸੁਖਮਨੀ ਮਃ ੫ ॥ ga-orhee sukhmanee mehlaa 5. In Gauri Pearl of peace 5th Guru . . . ਕਈ ਕੋਟਿ ਪਾਰਬ੍ਰਹਮ ਕੇ ਦਾਸ ॥ ka-ee kot paarbarahm kay daas. Many millions are the servants of the Supreme Lord God. ਤਿਨ ਹੋਵਤ ਆਤਮ ਪਰਗਾਸ ॥ tin hovat aatam pargaas. Their souls are enlightened. ਕਈ ਕੋਟਿ ਤਤ ਕੇ ਬੇਤੇ ॥ ka-ee kot tat kay baytay. Many millions know the essence of reality. ਸਦਾ ਨਿਹਾਰਹਿ ਏਕੋ ਨੇਤ੍ਰੇ ॥ sadaa nihaarahi ayko naytaray. Their eyes gaze forever on the One alone. ਕਈ ਕੋਟਿ ਨਾਮ ਰਸੁ ਪੀਵਹਿ ॥ ka-ee kot naam ras peeveh. Many millions drink in the essence of the Naam. ਅਮਰ ਭਏ ਸਦ ਸਦ ਹੀ ਜੀਵਹਿ ॥ amar bha-ay sad sad hee jeeveh. They become immortal; they live forever and ever. ਕਈ ਕੋਟਿ ਨਾਮ ਗੁਨ ਗਾਵਹਿ ॥ ka-ee kot naam gun gaavahi. Many millions sing the Glorious Praises of the Naam. ਆਤਮ ਰਸਿ ਸੁਖਿ ਸਹਜਿ ਸਮਾਵਹਿ ॥ aatam ras sukh sahj samaaveh. They are absorbed in intuitive peace and pleasure. ਅਪੁਨੇ ਜਨ ਕਉ ਸਾਸਿ ਸਾਸਿ ਸਮਾਰੇ ॥ apunay jan ka-o saas saas samaaray. He remembers His servants with each and every breath. ਨਾਨਕ ਓਇ ਪਰਮੇਸੁਰ ਕੇ ਪਿਆਰੇ ॥੮॥੧੦॥ naanak o-ay parmaysur kay pi-aaray. ||8||10|| O Nanak, they are the beloveds of the Transcendent Lord God. ||8||10|| www.srigranth.org

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

' · 02 Apr 2006

DHAN DHAN SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE ੴ ਸਤਿ ਗੁਰਪ੍ਰਸਾਦਿ ॥ ik-oNkaar sat gurparsaad ਧਨਾਸਰੀ ਮਹਲਾ ੧ ਘਰੁ ੨ ਅਸਟਪਦੀਆ Dhanaasree mehlaa 1 ghar 2 asatpadee-aa . . . ਸੁੰਨ ਮੰਡਲ ਇਕੁ ਜੋਗੀ ਬੈਸੇ ॥ sunn mandal ik jogee baisay. Only The Special Joagees(The Gurmukhs) have their minds sitting in The Place of Absolute State of Meditation. ਨਾਰਿ ਨ ਪੁਰਖੁ ਕਹਹੁ ਕੋਊ ਕੈਸੇ ॥ naar na purakh kahhu ko-oo kaisay. Neither do They look or are like the worldly women and men, Somebody Say - How are They Like? ਤ੍ਰਿਭਵਣ ਜੋਤਿ ਰਹੇ ਲਿਵ ਲਾਈ ॥ taribhavan jot rahay liv laa-ee. They stay connected to the Light of The Three Worlds ਸੁਰਿ ਨਰ ਨਾਥ ਸਚੇ ਸਰਣਾਈ ॥੪॥ sur nar naath sachay sarnaa-ee. ||4|| The Divine People(The Gurmukhs) and the Yogic Masters(The Gurmukhs) are in the Sanctuary of The True One. . . . DHAN DHAN SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

another akj singh · 03 Apr 2006

I am disappointed that there are singhs in the jatha with such views. I am a jatha singh and believe bibian can do seva in the panj. One of the reasons that I was attracted to the AKJ is because it does not have the same bipparvaad views of taksal and sant samaj. I am very disappointed in the akj ute and his mate. Why cannot a mother have a fathers role. Where the father is shaheed there are biabin who are looking after their kids in the role of a parent, both mother and father. These are sad arguments. I would request admin to put the Singh da Panth narala tract up again, without akjute nonsense views because I want to forward it to my friends. Akjute has just ruined the thread with his sant samajist views.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Hardeep Singh · 03 Apr 2006

Of course Bibian can do seva in the punj. If you ask any of the elder akj singh's: Bhai Jarnail Singh, Bhai Raghbir Singh and Bhai Sohan singh. They all agree to this!

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

akjsevadar · 03 Apr 2006

Sorry Hardeep Singh/another akj Singh but these are a your OWN views and not gurmat. On what do you base your conclusions? I have just this weekend spent hours talking to Singhs/Singhnian who spent MANY YEARS with Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh. The SINGHNIAN I have spoken to have both said exactly the same thing, Singhnian do not do seva in the Panj - FULL STOP. I have spoken to a Singhni who has spoken to Babu Mal Singh himself on this subject. Both these SINGHNIAN agree that no time during Bhai Sahib's time did they ever see Singhnian in the Panj EVEN THOUGH there were Singhnian who had reached the HIGHEST SPIRITUAL STATE. Singhian who I am not even equal to the dust of their feet. So please, please stop giving your PERSONAL views and give us GURMAT. Give me evidence. I have given my evidence above now show me yours. Remember the views from above are from very chardi kala SINGHNIAN who spent many years with Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

... · 03 Apr 2006

G. Harbhajan Singh, a companion of Bhai Sahib has said he knows of one occassion when a bibi did do seva. It wasn't common but it happened.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Admin · 03 Apr 2006

Thread is closed.

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

AnmritKaur · 18 Feb 2007

i think it is paramount to remember that there is no male or female...we are the roop of the Khalsa. we are all equal in all that we do, be is seva or keeping rehit. [%sig%]

Re: SINGHAN DA PANTH NIRALA - by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh

Prabhjoyt Singh · 19 Feb 2007

what did the panth decide on this issue? i dont see any problem with bibia doin Panj piare di seva, but if people have a problem they dont have to make their blood pressure go up by like a 100 points (the way dhumma and sant samaj did when it was said bibia will be allowed to do keertan seva at harmandir sahib) [%sig%]