Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Langar - How important

Langar - How important

VikariSingh · 25 Apr 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Sadh sangat jio I have few questions about Guru ka Langar. Please share your thoughts and experiences. 1. Is Langar a mandatory part of sikh culture? 2. Is Langar mandatory after Bhog(Akhand Paath or other)? 3. What do we conclude from the sakhi of Akbar, mughul empror, who was asked to take Langar before getting darshan of Guru Amardas Jee?. 4. Was it just to tell Akbar that everyone is equal in Guru's darbar?. 5. Or does it mean that Guru Ka Langar must be taken before Guru's darshan?. 6. Or does that mean Guru Ka Hukam may diffrent for a sikh than Akbar?. I have more questions that I will ask after Guru Piari Sadh sangat shed light on the above. VikariSingh

Re: Langar - How important

Kulbir Singh · 28 Apr 2003

> Sadh sangat jio I have few questions about Guru ka Langar. > Please share your thoughts and experiences. > > 1. Is Langar a mandatory part of sikh culture? I think it is important part of our congregation. > 2. Is Langar mandatory after Bhog(Akhand Paath or other)? It may not be mandatory but it is very much desired. Who would not want sarblohi daala and parshaade after Siri Akhand Paath Sahib? > 3. What do we conclude from the sakhi of Akbar, mughul > empror, who was asked to take Langar before getting darshan of > Guru Amardas Jee?. At that time it was important to force everyone to have langar as Guru Sahib wanted to eliminate the disease of caste system. That tradition was only for that time. Today there is no maryada to eat langar before attending a samagam. It is upto sangat now. > 4. Was it just to tell Akbar that everyone is equal in Guru's > darbar?. Yes and to eliminate caste system from the Sikhs. > 5. Or does it mean that Guru Ka Langar must be taken before > Guru's darshan?. At that time Yes. Today - No. This maryada was not kept by other Gurus as they did not feel the need for this anymore. What they wanted to accomplish had been accomplished. > 6. Or does that mean Guru Ka Hukam may diffrent for a sikh > than Akbar?. > No the hukams are same for all. > I have more questions that I will ask after Guru Piari Sadh > sangat shed light on the above. > Please go ahead when you are ready. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Langar - How important

VikariSingh · 29 Apr 2003

>>At that time it was important to force everyone to have langar as Guru Sahib wanted to eliminate the disease of caste system. That tradition was only for that time. Today there is no maryada to eat langar before attending a samagam. It is upto sangat now.<< I think it was not just the caste system, there were other diseases like hatred between rich and poor, Anhkaari people, etc. Don't you think those diseases still exist? Who and when was that maryada was chaged? Is there any reference that the following Guru sahiban changed that maryada? >>At that time Yes. Today - No. This maryada was not kept by other Gurus as they did not feel the need for this anymore. What they wanted to accomplish had been accomplished. << Again is there any reference that this maryada was not kept or was intentionally ended by Guru sahib? What are you reffering when saying "had been accomplished"? If it is the caste system you reffering to, are you sure it is not there anymore in sikhs(I think Langar maryada was not just for sikhs, otherwise Guru sahib may not have asked Akbar to take Langar because he was not a sikh) Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji what I understand (I might be wrong) from your views is that the Langar maryada is kind of outdated or obsolete now and we may not need it any more. I have seen or heard people not taking Langar for the following reasons: 1. Langar is not prepared according to the maryada(No question about it). 2. Some may not take Langar because they don't find what they want to eat in the Langar (I have heard some people actually call to check what is there(Daal, Sabji, Pkorhe, Rasgulle) in the Langar today). 3. Ahankaar, Haume, ego which may be in different forms like Maya, Caste, Japping Naam too much, doing lot of paath etc. 4. There could be some other specific reasons to specific people. My personal oppinion is that Langar is a must for us and it is as must as Parchhad(deg) after Bhog. I have heard people saying that we must take Langar even a little one as required. Bhul chuk maaf karnaa jee. 'Mun vakareen varhia bhee -------' VikariSingh

Re: Langar - How important

Kulbir Singh · 29 Apr 2003

>>>>>>>>>>> Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji what I understand (I might be wrong) from your views is that the Langar maryada is kind of outdated or obsolete now and we may not need it any more. <<<<<<<<<<<< Veer Vikari Singh jeeo, I do not consider langar to be obsolete or outdated. I fully support that langar should be there in every gurdwara sahib. What I referred to was the practice of partaking langar before going to the diwan. None of the Gurdwaras follow this maryada anymore. All I was saying is that I don't think that it is mandatory to eat langar before going to the darbaar of Guru Sahib. I could be wrong. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Langar - How important

VikariSingh · 30 Apr 2003

Even I am not saying it is mandatory to take Langar just before going to dewan, but I think it is mandatory to take Langar, may be before or after dewan. Langar is an intergral part of sikh culture. I too could be wrong. VikariSingh