Saddam still defiant
Kulbir Singh · 15 Dec 2003
NADAR UPATHEE JE KARAI, SULTAANA GHAAH KARAAINDA ||
This news has been met with disbelief and utter surprise by everyone. No one expected him to be caught alive and then get humiliated by the Americans. I guess Vaheguru gave him what he deserved.
Most in Punjab sympathized with him but Punjabis living in Western worlds mostly opposed him.
It would be interesting to hear other gursikhs views on his capture.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
WASHINGTON: A defiant and belligerent Saddam Hussein has been lashing his interrogators and interlocutors with a stream of invectives while professing pain for his people "bonded" by American occupation.
According to various accounts of his questioning following his sensational capture on Saturday, Saddam has refused to apologise for his brutal three-decade reign of oppression and instead justified his methods of torture and summary execution.
"He has not been cooperative in terms of talking or anything like that," Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld told CBS' 60 Minutes programme.
"He clearly was compliant or resigned... as he was being examined and as he was being transferred from the hole to the transport that took him away. It's a bit early to try to characterise his demeanor," he said.
But other later reports of his interrogation suggest that Saddam, contrary to the submissive image that was initially broadcast, raged against his captors and Iraqi interlocutors whom he saw as traitors to the nation he presided over.
He spat fire and abused them for betraying the Iraqis and collaborating with the Americans.
He reserved much of his abuse for his former foreign minister Adnan Pachachi, who was one of the four Iraqi governing council leaders who were allowed to question him.
"You were the foreign minister of Iraq. What are you doing with these people?" he asked him, according to one account.
The former Iraqi dictator also rejected the American charge of amassing weapons of mass destruction, saying "the US dreamed them up itself to have a reason to go to war with us."
"If you had no weapons of mass destruction then why not let the UN inspectors into your facilities," he was asked. "We didn't want them to go into the presidential areas and intrude on our privacy," he responded.
"He was quite lucid. He had command of his faculties. He would not apologise to the Iraqi people. He did not deny any of the crimes he was confronted with having done. He tried to justify them," Ahmed Chalabi, the Iraqi leader promoted by the Americans told the US media.
The captured dictator had earlier been described as disoriented and incoherent. Following his capture, he was transported from Tikrit to the Baghdad international airport, where much of the deposed Iraqi leadership is held. He appears to have regained his composure there.
Another governing council member Mowaffak al-Rubaie said when he asked why Hussain had killed two leading Shiite clerics, Ayatollah Muhammad Bakr al-Sadr in 1980 and Ayatollah Muhammad Sadiq al-Sadr in 1999, the dictator replied "Al Sidr or Rijl?" In Arabic "sidr" means chest and "rijl" is foot.
Asked about the mass graves of tens of thousands of Iraqis uncovered since he was toppled from power, al-Rubaie said that Saddam replied: "Ask their relatives. They were thieves and they ran away from the battlefields with Iran and Kuwait."
But US officials described Saddam as the coward. "Here was a man who was photographed hundreds of times shooting off rifles, showing off how tough he was. In fact, he wasn't very tough, he was cowering in a hole in the ground and had a pistol and didn't use it and certainly did not put up any fight at all," Rumsfeld sneered.
Re: Saddam still defiant
my thoughts... · 15 Dec 2003
It is amazing how Guru Sahib works everything. One day he was the 'King' of a country, living in massive palaces, and over night he is living/hiding in a hole just large enough to cover him.
Re: Saddam still defiant
Gur ka Sikh · 15 Dec 2003
Here is what a Toronto Star journalist had to say about him:
The Ace of Spades proved to be a Joker.
Even his teenage grandson, a mere boy, slain with Saddam's two repugnant sons during a military raid months ago, showed more courage in his final moments, never crying out for mercy, never surrendering. Saddam has not an ounce of that child's nerve.
He is a coward and a fraud, a bully emboldened only within the protective web of his security forces. Now he stands fully exposed — the meek and compliant felon being checked for lice, with a tongue depressor stuck in his mouth, obediently turning his shaggy head this way and that, as if anxious to be good, be submissive.
This will be his legacy. Not the powerful Saddam, in that weird trilby hat, one-handedly wielding a shotgun from the terrace of his palace, a dutifully worshipping crowd at his feet.
Re: Saddam still defiant
warrior*princess · 15 Dec 2003
vaheguru jee kaa khalsa vaheguru jee kee fateh
I wouldnt be suprised if they try to torture Saddam unnecessarily. I do understand the injustice saddam may have inflicted on others such as the Kurds, which is not okay, BUT i do NOT agree with what Bush man and what others are doing to him.
No one has the right to start attack on another country for holding weapons of mass destruction..every country has a right to defend themselves with backup if such need occurs..even the attack that bush began on saddam was not actually within the legal rights, bush had not broken any rules for that to happen.
They showed the iraqees that are cheering but what about those that do not agree with what is happening to saddam,...those who cheer; i think they need to realise how they are going to be ruled by cold hearted manmat gaurai americans sooner than they know it.
Bush and the US lot talk in ego...they label saddam with such harsh words, but what about the innocent that bush has killed and his past track record...he is not exactly a saint either!
Bush probably swims in the oil...as for the weapons of mass destruction, i think someone should show the bush how they work and what effects they have!
Besides what saddam may have done i feel sorry for him and they should have left him alone in the 1st place.
I think bush had hidden agendas and personal greed of power and other gain for pursueing attack in the first place. They are showing the world that they are these heroes saving us from terrorists, I DONT BELIEVE IT! Who will they attack on next? What makes us think that he would back us up if we ever needed it, sadh sangat jeeo dont be so sympathetic to bushs actions....what may appear as okay on the outside, does not mean it is inwardly okay too...
2ndly, this saddam could be a fake to get peoples side by america and to please blair and so that he gets good media and people will then support him more! But maybe this one is out of the question.
theres a 3rdly too, but i dont want to mention that one as its a possible that would help saddam.
I think that Saddam should have put up a fight or at least killed him self, but then again Sikhi says committing suicide is a sin. But it sure is not nice to see him humiliated...Bush has done his crimes too but has made them appear as heroic acts.
Why arent the media interviewing those iraqees that do not agree with saddams capture...they are all in this together.
Bush is so keen to focus on injust acts in that country ONLY, WHY!...i think if he saw the injustice that indian gvrnment are doing and have done to sikhs, then his dentures will fall out of his mouth. I dont believe that bush is all that heroic innocent person who helps the needy, yeah right! and pigs can fly.
At the end of the day, no man has the right to inflict pain or murder on to another being....everything does happen under Vaheguru jee's will...we have to pay for our mistakes if required via Dharam Raj's order.
ps. notice how Saddam looked better and like a good person with the beard :D
...some of my thoughts.
Re: Saddam still defiant
warrior*princess · 15 Dec 2003
i think the journalist wants to be shakespear, lol
Re: Saddam still defiant
warrior*princess · 15 Dec 2003
i meant saddam had not broken any rules
Re: Saddam still defiant
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 15 Dec 2003
omg can't blieve what i read
ppl think saddam should'nt be arrested
the kurds need their way with him
i dont' care if he wuz a "sikh" or ne thing
he wuz indra 2 the kurds
Re: Saddam still defiant
Gurjit Singh · 16 Dec 2003
Mkhalsa,
I've personally seen protesters protest at protests throughout the United States. (i.e. anti war protests)
And they all yelled anti Bush slogans, they called Bush a terrorist, they called Bush evil, etc. etc.
They weren't arrested.
America usually has freedom of speech.
America is the second or third freest country in the world.
So don't hate it - Look at it comparitively.
Canada is probably more free, Britain might be more free as well.
But outside those 2 nations?
Most of mainland Europe is incredibly racist.
If you go to France or Germany, you'll be persecuted 10 times worse than if you were in America.
So America might have its weak points,
But don't be so negative!
Lighten up.
Look at it comparitively,
Its not so bad.
Re: Saddam still defiant
domalla premee · 16 Dec 2003
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki fateh
What is the point of this thread and what does it have to do with Gurmat or Gursikhi. I am sure there are plenty of other forums to discuss and opiniate on world events. Please admins this is taking us off track.
dass
Re: Saddam still defiant
warrior*princess · 16 Dec 2003
I dont support saddams past actions against the Kurds - that was injust and absolutely wrong. I was just trying to point out that there are two sides to everything. I hate politics and all this government stuff and do not think that Sikhs should become involved in such stuff.
Yes other governments are just as cold hearted. I cant find one that i would like to support.
Domalla premee stated that what does it have to do with Sikhi...i understand, but the way that bush behaves about other countries etc, we don't know what his intensions are or future plans. We only see and know what we are told by media, but there is always much more brutality that goes on behind the scenes, just as we know it does in places like India.
Gabroo Khalistan da jee, i totally understand and of course they deserve justice...also, then who is going to get justice of those innocent lives that bush killed?????? Why is that bush can rule whatever he wants but also gets away with his wrong actions. I think he is the one who acts more like a king.
veer or bhainjee, you said :
>>>Warrior Princess think about this - Especially as a woman - If you had been living under the rule of Saddam you would likely not be free to express any of your opinions (unless of course they were in favor of his regieme) under the penalty of death - But under the rule of "cold hearted manmat gauri americans" anyone may express their own view whether of not it matches up to that of US gov't, president or whatever- irregardess of how it may differ.<<<
Yes thats true...im sorry im just not convinced about being able to express my own view...even if i was able to express it - would be heard and be acted upon???
I noticed how the media stated that the people against saddams arrest are a 'minority', so what about if we were a minority asking for our justice with indian gvrnment, would our voices be heard? I think that what goes in with indian gvrnment is most brutal, yet people like bush wouldnt even dare to investigate into it.
See, what about what happened in 1984, everyone, i.e. all the media were ready to claim that the Sikhs in the Harmandir sahib are terrorists...not even one journalist cared to find out the truth and reflect those Sikhs in the correct light. I remember watching the news. So have we forgotten what its like to be on that side? We shouldnt just look and accept what media says, but we should know and understand the truth behind it and then make a final judgement.
Bhul Chuk Maarf Karnaa since everyone seems to be targetting me :D Im sorry if i hurt anyone, i dont have anything against GurSikh sangat :)))) please remember that.
At the end of the day Saddam is caught, thats what Vaheguru jee wanted and no one can stop that. But i will never agree that Bush actually caught him for the safety of the Iraqee people etc, just not convinced! I think Blair doesnt think straight anymore, and now i think that no one deserves a vote from the choices left in uk.
Re: Saddam still defiant
my thoughts... · 16 Dec 2003
I don't think there is anything wrong with this thread. Gursikhs are suppose to judge and base their opinions on Gurmat. Veer Kulbir Singh asked :
'...It would be interesting to hear other gursikhs views on his capture..'
I think there is much to learn from this story.
And, veer 'G,' when one starts to follow the path of Sikhi, then one should think about everything based on Gurmat, live in the hukam of Guru Sahib. Nothing occurs/happens outside the hukam of Guru Sahib. So, following Gurmat does does not mean that one is cut off from rest of the world.
Re: Saddam still defiant
Gurjit Singh · 16 Dec 2003
"...",
I'm not from America. I'm from Canada as well.
I'm just against irrational, negative, cynical America hating. Its against Gurmat to be so irrational without looking at things comparitively.
Why do you have to look at America so cynically? It has its weak points. But you have to look at America as a whole.
I've never been persecuted in my many visits to America. I actually believe I've been treated quite nicely. I'm sure other people have been subject to unnecesary hate and ignorance but this doesn't reflect on the ENTIRE nation.
There's so many Americans who are quite progressive. Even Bush isn't purposely evil. Its easy to say he is. But if you actually look at the guy. He might be misguided and stuff, but you can't just level accusations that he's evil. Does he run torture chambers?
Now you didn't answer my question - Which nation outside Canada or *maybe* Britain/Australia is more progressive on race relations and human rights as America? No nation. Not one. Mainland Europe is incredibly racist in general - Every major country in Europe has a legitimate mainstream white supremacist political group. And every other nation in the world hasn't properly experienced ethnic diversity. So please. Look at America comparitively. Don't just hate it because it has power.
Re: Saddam still defiant
Gurjit Singh · 16 Dec 2003
So you're saying America brought the death of 1 million Iraqis?
What baloney!
If Saddam didn't abuse the food for oil program,
If he didn't build lavish palaces,
If he didn't waste money on developing weapons programs,
NOT ONE PERSON WOULD HAVE DIED DUE TO HUNGER.
America has its faults, but don't indirectly try to blame them for deaths they had nothing to do with.
And Please!
Stop understating the carnage, destruction and fear Saddam brought upon Iraq.
I know having extreme left of centre views is "hip" and "with it" these days,
But its not rational, and its not realistic either.
Re: Saddam still defiant
simran_sewa_sacrifice · 16 Dec 2003
WAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA WAHEGUROO JI KI FATEH!!
i personally dont see bush as some soorma or bahadur, who has ridden the world of another evil..it is no secret that he has interest in the oil there. apparently saddam is not someone with a flawless reputation either. its funny how all these countries will only participate in things where there is some self gain...id rather look to history of Gursikh who even battled and freed some 2000+ women when there was no person gain (there are thousands of selfless examples).
for americas sake i hope that they can get saddam to talk and reveal the location of the "dangerous weapons" or else america will be seen as opressors of muslims (even more than they already are) and as greedy for oil.
-my thoughts
WAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA WAHEGUROO JI KI FATEH!!
[%sig%]
Re: Saddam still defiant
domalla premee · 17 Dec 2003
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh
Peeareo G
It is obvious Gurujee works through everything. It is His creation right? But how do YOU want to spend your energy? Opining and discussing who is right, wrong, to blame or not or chanelling it towards simran, Sikhi and spiritual growth and service of others?? The world will run itself and events will unfold without our opinions. It is just vain arguement that gets nowhere. If there is something you can do something directly about that which will help others then by all means do it. This is all I have to say about this thread.
dass