Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Marriage decided upon person or the family?

Marriage decided upon person or the family?

anon · 15 Apr 2006

Got bit of a scenario at the moment; my side have rejected the proposal in marrying a gursikh bibi who I believe to be perfect for a person like me. Very inspirational - talks about the need to keep amritvela all the time and does not come across as one of those people in the clouds (those that like acting very spiritual). My side arent keen on her family as they dont have 'jatha' qualities. But should that matter if she has these 'jatha' qualities - rehitvaan and wears a dastaar – took amrit from ‘akj’? Don’t get me wrong I hate being labelled 'akj' as with a few other Singhs I know. Her side don’t have any problems whatsoever; they want the best for her daughter. I also know for a fact that she doesn’t want to marry me because of what I do as a living- she is more qualified than I am. Ive only started working so I got time to decide on my future. My parents say that they have always taken decision for the best and yeah I will agree but can we not have the final say on our own future?

Re: Marriage decided upon person or the family?

... · 15 Apr 2006

I was with you up to the point where you said she doesn't want to marry you. If you KNOW she doesn't want to marry you, then why would you want to marry her? Just leave it and find someone else. She doesn't want this marriage, your parents don't want this marriage. That leaves just you. Now if she DID want to marry you, it would be a different story I think, but here it's clearly not a good idea.

Re: Marriage decided upon person or the family?

a singh · 15 Apr 2006

maybe she is abit "IN THE CLOUDS" as she isnt look at ur jeevan..but ur wallet?

Re: Marriage decided upon person or the family?

* · 15 Apr 2006

I think he's saying he knows for a fact that she doesn't want to marry him BASED on what he does for a living, ie. she isn't superficial and isn't basing her decision on his earnings/career.

Re: Marriage decided upon person or the family?

... · 15 Apr 2006

THAT makes much more sense. In that case then, there should be no objections.

Re: Marriage decided upon person or the family?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Apr 2006

this is shaky ground..lol...the writing is on the wall....your parents rejected her family..she rejected you... what are you reading ??get back on the ground and go look elsewhere.. such shaky marriages soon fail....she may not like what you do for a living..ever....so are you going to keep changing jobs ??..to satisfy your wife ?? its not easy.. already she is more qualified than you..get real man...

Re: Marriage decided upon person or the family?

SKaur1980 · 01 May 2006

My sister is in a similar-ish situation. She has met a singh she wants to marry and he wants to marry her and they seem very compatible in both thier sikhi and thier personalities. The only thing is, we've heard negative things about his family and he seems to be the only truely religious person in his family. Me and some of my family therefore aren't sure its a good idea purely because of his family but then his sikhi seems strong and genuine. Any opinions ?

Re: Marriage decided upon person or the family?

Gurpreet Singh · 01 May 2006

Um he's saying (from what i get that).. he doesn't think she would marry him for what he does for a living because she's much more qualified than him...please get your infos correct before declaring this bibi superficial :)

Re: Marriage decided upon person or the family?

moorakh · 01 May 2006

hehehe --- please be more careful with your use of the English language when you make a post on the forum. To clarify for people who post from now on --- *We think* He was saying - she is not superficial and is not judging his job as the reason to marry him. She is more qualified, so from her side she is only wanting to marry him for who HE is, not what is job is. And so his situation is that He wants to marry her, she doesn't mind, but HIS family says "no" because she's not "AKJ" enough for them.

Re: Marriage decided upon person or the family?

Skaur1980 · 03 May 2006

Any input please?

Re: Marriage decided upon person or the family?

Biodata :-) · 29 Jul 2006

I think first of all people should learn how to read better, please don't take offense, but we tend to jump at 'headline' posts and jump yet again to answer them in haste. Let's actually read.. Second, how many of you who have answered the question are actually married? Third, I don't have a third, my opinion as a married person is that you should find someone that is compatible in personality as well, just because a person keeps up with their nitnem etc they might be completely different to you, of course these things aren't seen until after the marriage is well into its blooming stages. It may sound cliche to say 'you're marrying him/her, not the family' but it is true, just because other family members are not as religious (or more religious) shouldn't change anything, it doesn't make them better or worst people--the important thing is that the family consists of warm, open and loving people. I think it's high time people look at the fine print...

Re: Marriage decided upon person or the family?

... · 29 Jul 2006

I heard mahapursh say that in marriage they should see how the 'children' get along; thats all that matters in that regard.