Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Baba Mann Singh

Baba Mann Singh

m.a.l. 84 · 20 Dec 2003

what is tapoban's, akj's view on baba mann singh ji and his style of kirtan? i know other jatha's are against it, but i cant help notice that its pretty much the same as dhadi, the only thing is that he is sitting down and they are standing up, and he uses different instruments. if he singing about the guru, whats wrong? dhadi do the exact same thing. he gets people pumped up, and dhadi pump people up too. if there is nothing wrong with dhadi, what is wrong with baba mann singh ji? i only ask this becuase i hear so much against him, but have absolutley no reason as to why they do. he has brought so many people into sikhi, including myself. he is very inspirational to many and i really think its wrong.

Re: Baba Mann Singh

kookar ram ko · 20 Dec 2003

sri guru Gobind Singh ji Maharaaj made dhadis so that they can give josh to the singhs/singhniaN. But what he's doing is just Kachi Banee. There is no point in that. Satguru bina, hoor Kachi hai Banee Banee ta kachi, satgur bajhu, hoor kachi banee

Re: Baba Mann Singh

Factual Singh · 20 Dec 2003

I cant speak for the jatha but Baba Mann Singh creates his own kachi bani and tries to pass it off as bani of guru sahib. That is wrong. On top of that hes a GOI agent and has punjab police and indian intelligence agents as bodyguards (source: burningpunjab, gursikhs) in fact burning punjab had pictures of him pointing out indian agents with him. He is also afraid of gursikhs and has no problem talking about Singhs behind their backs, but if Singhs are in sangat he turns on the fake pyaar. Thats the facts y'all.

Re: Baba Mann Singh

akka · 21 Dec 2003

Baba Mann Singh is a great blessed soul. I think people only do nindhia out of jealousy. Baba Jee's speaches make your hair stand up on their ends, especially when they talk about Guru Gobind Singh Jee.

Re: Baba Mann Singh

Harbhajan Singh · 21 Dec 2003

Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh, Dear Sangat Jee, If think you are talking about Sant Maan Singh who does great vichaar to the sangat in plain language. I have to say the some of his speeches are inspiring if you are just getting into sikhi. He uses the same techniques as the Christian Evangelists (Fire and brimestone speeches) which are very effective and always hits a nerve with someone in the sangat/audience. Anyone who brings the astray back into the fold does a great seva for the panth. Now I havent talked him up so that im going to put him down. But there has been times when he has basically taken the mick out of certain Jathabandis especially AKJ on the stage about some of it asools. Majority is in a derogratory manner in plain punjabi bolee, I think people will know what i mean. Its probably makes it worse because its in the presence of Guru Jee. But I don't think anyone is 'Jealous' of what he is doing but hoping he dosent say anything wrong. I have nothing against his keeratn as long as he's sings Gurbani, if he uses Kuchee bani which some sants do, then it might be wrong. But if his message gets across and sikhs come back to the fold then hopefully the sikhs will connect more with Gurbani and not with any Kuchee bani, because the gems are in gurbani. Hope I haven't offended any one who respects Sant Maan Singh as if he has brought you into sikhi that is great, but just wanted to point out why some gursikhs might feel a little aggreived about what he says. Harbhajan Singh Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh [%sig%]

Re: Baba Mann Singh

brup brup · 21 Dec 2003

hes good because he does parchaar, and brings people into sikhi

Re: Baba Mann Singh

Jinder · 21 Dec 2003

How can you call him an agent of GOI???????????????????????? I am so fed up, of how people can say stuff about saints. Have'nt you heard of 'santa ka mat nindo'... Man, the real saints help us like baba mann singh ji, the fakes one you can see before your eyes, harnek, ashotsh, and virsa singh of delhi.. I am not sure where your getting your information from him, and I am not his chela. I have lots of love for this baba ji, but you guys are pushing jhoot and that's what ticks me off.

Re: Baba Mann Singh

Factual Singh 2 · 21 Dec 2003

First off, I've seen him with his body guards, so Factual Singh is right on the money. What kind of "sant" needs bodyguards? what would a "sant" have to be scared of? Also, one time I was with a chardeekalaa singh who came here after being tortured in India. One day, Mann Singh comes with his bodyguards. The Singh pointed one of them out and said thats the guy that arrested, tortured and beat me. Some sant. Also, I know for a fact, Notice FACT (NOT NINDA), that he used to send "amrit" in bottles to people saying just drink this and you will be amritdhari. Total Manmat and a disgrace. I have nothing against him but he is a harm to the panth, the sad thing is that so many people think hes panthic and that hes a sant. Again, what kind of sant makes fake amrit, administers it himself (by mail) and needs GOI bodyguards? the facts speak for themselves. I would give you a link to the burningpunjab website with PICTURES and PROOF pointing out the bodyguards but unfortunately the Singh Jee died of a mysterious heart attack in his early 30s a few years back.

Re: Baba Mann Singh

BKI · 21 Dec 2003

What kind of panthic "Gursikh" or "Sant" is scared of just the words "Babbar Khalsa"? I was wearing a vest, and he just turned away, his chelas surrounded him and they hightailed it out.

Re: Baba Mann Singh

akka · 21 Dec 2003

Anyone that says singing translations of gurbani in simple language is kacha is a kacha sikh.

Re: Baba Mann Singh

Guru ka · 21 Dec 2003

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh I have seen his picture on www.gursikhijeevan.com, he has so many body gaurds around him with guns.Whom he is afraid of? from GOI? so many SSPs and DSPs and highly ranked PP officers his Chele. I don't think he is Jarnail singh Bhindranwala type sant.He neves said to his cheles and to his gun men to do the SODHAA of Ashutosh or harnek or another fake sants becouse he is fake too. He has his gun men to give the fear to those gursikhs who say something against him or he can order to his DSP chela to arrest to torture anyone who says anything against him. That is why not many singhs say any thing against him.When Singhs asked him to give the clarification why he sent the Amrit from his Amrit sanchar to his money -rich chela in some container in UAE, he gave no clarification.He said on his stage that the people who do ninda of him be careful and read the thirteenth ashatpadi of Sukhmani Sahib , which explains what will happen to those who do the ninda of a sant. So he considers him self the same sant the gurbani tells about!!!!!!!! He is member of sant samaj.He allows the cassette companies to write is name as Shromani Sant. I have read that Bhagat Kabeer was considered to be sharomani sant,but now sant baba maan singh ji replaced him.He will rush to anywhere to please the hindus like to orrisa or to Gujrat to help them. But he didn't helped widows of 84 and children of shaheeds of panth . He did nothing to help the singhs or thier faimlies who are in the jail from so many years for the crime of asking about Khalistan. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh. [%sig%]

Re: Baba Mann Singh

Trying to be Gursikh · 22 Dec 2003

Baba Mann Singh does kirtan in RaraSahib style. You will find that GurSikhs from RaraSahib jatha do kirtan in this way. I am not sure if Baba Mann Singh took Amrit via Sant Isher Singh Rarewale's jatha, but he's definetly inspired by his style of kirtan.

Re: Baba Mann Singh

.. · 22 Dec 2003

I have listened to Sant Mann Singh, and by listening to he's kirtan I understand so much, its far better then the AKJ. I think most of you are 100% AKJ and don't belive RaagMala is Bani, where Sant Mann Singh belive RaagMala is Bani. Main reason why you dislike people. Also what do you guys understand when AKJ do Kirtan, all you lot do is WaheGuroo, where Kirtan should, be done the way Sant Maan Singh does it. BY the way I am not part of any group

Re: Baba Mann Singh

Kulbir Singh · 22 Dec 2003

Anyone who does sewa of Panth is worthy of respect. We have no opposition with Sants Mahapurakhs who do sewa of Panth. But there are some sants like Maan Singh who openly on stages condemn Akhand Kirtani Jatha and declare manmukh Fatwas like "Anyone who does not read Ragmala is not a Sikhi" thus opposing the decision of Siri Akaal Takhat Sahib. I have personally witnessed this in one of his diwan. Then he goes and targets Singhs who consider Keski as kakaar. He goes on and on as to why sangat should not tolerate people who believe in Keski Kakaar. While Maan Singh openly speaks against Rehit of Khalsa - Keski and calls AKJ Singhs "non Sikhs", we are not going to sit with our hands on our laps, smiling. This person in definitely of a dubious character. Great Mahapurakhs like Sant Kartar Singh Bhindranwaale and Sant Gurbachan Singh jee had close relations with AKJ Singhs. Great Sants like Baba Attar Singh jee Mastuanaewaale were intimate friends of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh. Who is Maan Singh to slander one of the most Panthik organization of Panth - Akhand Kirtani Jatha? So while this fellow Maan Singh openly slanders Jatha, don't expect jatha to fall at his feet like some misled Sikhs. Jatha Singhs are not cows that he can herd them anywhere he wants. Singhs are lions and jackals like Maan Singh cannot decimate Khalsa. ---------- I have listened to Sant Mann Singh, and by listening to he's kirtan I understand so much, its far better then the AKJ. ---------- AKJ Sings Gurbani. Maan Singh sings kachee baani. So his kirtan cannot be better than Hari-Kirtan that Jatha sings. --------- I think most of you are 100% AKJ and don't belive RaagMala is Bani, where Sant Mann Singh belive RaagMala is Bani. Main reason why you dislike people. -------- We respect most singhs who consider Raagmala as baani because we know that their intention behind reading raagmala is good. But they too need to understand that the singhs who don't read raagmala, do so with good intentions. These Singhs have in the past sacrificed their lives for baani. So don't mistrust their intentions on Gurbani. AKJ Singhs like many other organizations and scholars, don't consider Ragmala as baani. As for AKJ's opposition of Maan Singh, the reason is not his pro-Raagmala stance but his slander of gursikhs. We wonder why he is trying to stir the Raagmala issue and the keski issue when we have so many other things to deal with. Even if he has to raise this issue, he should not stoop to calling names to the ones who don't read Raagmala. ------- Also what do you guys understand when AKJ do Kirtan, all you lot do is WaheGuroo, where Kirtan should, be done the way Sant Maan Singh does it. -------- Sorry sir, we cannot do kirtan as Maan Singh. Doing Vaheguru Vaheguru is milliion times better than singing kachee baani that Maan Singh sings. ----------- BY the way I am not part of any group -------- This does not seem to be true. It is obvious that you support Maan Singh and belong to his group. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Baba Mann Singh

Trying to be Gursikh · 22 Dec 2003

This is turning into something nasty. We should have respect for all GurSikhs regardless. Sometimes we apply too much ego into our discussions. Waheguruji Ka Khalsa, Waheguruji ki Fateh!!!!!

Re: Baba Mann Singh

singheee laad · 22 Dec 2003

Waheguru ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh, Sangat jio, In the UK sangat has had great exposure to Baba Mann singh, some of good, some of it bad. A number of years ago when baba mann singh first came here on his parchar tour, he did a lot of parchar against the jatha from the stage using derogatory and inflammatory language. A number of elder jatha singhs went to southall to discuss this with him and he refused to talk to them and was driven away. About 2 years later we received an audio tape of a baba mann singh programe in ludhiana. The baba was singing the shabad "khhaalasaa maero roop hai khhaas " Half way through the shabad he started the dhuni of "Dhan hey Dhan hey panth Khalsa Dhan hey" He would then go back to the shabad, he then started another dhuni "Dhan hey Dhan Hey Santh khalsa Dhan hey" At this point you can here a bibi shouting to him "eh kachee baneee band kardey" at which point she slaps him and picks up the waja. We are told by a singh that this bibi was from the jatha and she then walked straight out of the durbar without anyone challenging her. The point with this incident was that they way the baba was mixing his kachee banee with guru shabad in such a way that it is confusing for some sangat to tell the difference. There are many points about this baba which maybe hearsay or gossip, but the above points are what daaas has experienced On a seperate note, and this is my personal opnion, at the moment the flower of sikh is dying in the punjab...we desperatley need parchar in punjab. but these parcharaks seem to be intent on coming to the west to do parchar. why? the answer is simple next time you are in punjab pay a visit to baba mann singhs koti, (if they let you anywhere near it). These luxirious mansions cost money western money simple as that. Siri Guru Arjan Dev Jee describes a sant thus: gourree mehalaa 5 guaaraeree || rain dhinas rehai eik ra(n)gaa || prabh ko jaanai sadh hee sa(n)gaa || t(h)aakur naam keeou oun varathan || thripath aghaavan har kai dharasan ||1|| har sa(n)g raathae man than harae || gur poorae kee saranee parae ||1|| rehaao || charan kamal aatham aadhhaar || eaek nihaarehi aagiaakaar || eaeko banaj eaeko biouhaaree || avar n jaanehi bin nira(n)kaaree ||2|| harakh sog dhuhehoo(n) thae mukathae || sadhaa alipath jog ar jugathae || dheesehi sabh mehi sabh thae rehathae || paarabreham kaa oue dhhiaan dhharathae ||3|| sa(n)than kee mehimaa kavan vakhaano || agaadhh bodhh kishh mith nehee jaano || paarabreham mohi kirapaa keejai || dhhoor sa(n)than kee naanak dheejai ||4||17||86|| does this baba with his mansion, servants body guards and Cars even begin to come close? Many people will agree that baba mann singh has put thousands on the path of the guru, but how many are still on that path? This marag that we are trying to walk on is not about quantity but quality, to begin on this path we need strong foundations based on gurmat and a thirst for amrit. I do not believe this baba provides any of this. Gur Fateh.

Re: Baba Mann Singh

ashamed · 22 Dec 2003

i think this topic shud come to a close because there are a hell of a lot of people in the panth who believe in baba maan singh, and equally a lot of youth in akj. this cud leave to stupidity. rather than highlight diffs, why not share things with each in common? i mean read sggs, see god inside each man, according to bhai gurdaas ji vara even krishna fed clothed and housed his enemies. So however or whoeevr is ur enemy show more pyar see God through em in all directions listen to the Guru talk to you inside.

Re: Baba Mann Singh

huh · 22 Dec 2003

easi isnt it? get brave with each other! comfort zone. try comin out and face those who burn nishan sahibs, forcibly hack off sikh schoolkids uncut kes, attack our elders and mug them, and distribute racist inflamatory literature that targets sikhi. u dont wanan challange summit dat happens directly on the streets but come home behind a pc a jatha v jatha maya yudh what a joke! besti see were only brave in our own comfort zones, wheres the quest for truth and standing up for it when we r directly oppressed here? then nobody wants to know. what do we do? take the easy road out! blame each other, familiar with the other person their capabilities, strengths weaknesses. What happens when your faced with something that is a bit out of your reach? we chicken it, why? cos u dont know what ur dealing with. what kind of singhs are we? are we paper tigers? showpiece warriors?

Re: Baba Mann Singh

m.a.l. 84 · 22 Dec 2003

***what is tapoban's, akj's view on baba mann singh ji and his style of kirtan?**** that was the original question. i have heard those other rumours, and they are not true. just like the rumours i have heard about akj are not true. but back to the question, isnt his kirtan similiar to dhadi? what the difference between the actualy words being SUNG??? i dont care to know about if hes a good or bad guy because i have basically learned that EVERYONE has bad qualities, noone is truly who they seem to be becuase in a sense, EVERYONE is a pakhand in one way or another. so if someone can answer the original question, it would be appreciated.

Re: Baba Mann Singh

Southall Incident · 22 Dec 2003

It wasn't just elders. It was gursikhs that came in bana to listen to his katha themselves as they did not want to beleive just hearsay that he was spreading lies about jatha. Upon seeing them, he began katha about love, pyaar and unity. After the divaan the gursikhs aproached him to ask about his open hatred of gursikhs, just to ask him personally if they were true or not. His chelas immediately surrounded him, a car drove up, he got in and they raced away. Soon after punjabi papers had this headline "Babbar Khalsa Extremists Attack Baba Mann Singh Jee" BTW, nothing posted here about him is a lie and can be easily proven, if one actually cares to look.

Re: Baba Mann Singh

Admin · 22 Dec 2003

This thread is now closed. Nothing new is coming this way. At requests by our panthik readers, we have decided to close this thread. No more posts under this thread will be approved. Admin.