Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Chittsinghpora killings of Sikhs coverup

Chittsinghpora killings of Sikhs coverup

KS · 30 Apr 2006

An enquiry needs to be opened into the massacre of 35 Sikhs when Bill Clinton visited India. It is now proved that the people that India blamed for the killings did not do it PATHRIBAL ENCOUNTER Those killed were blamed for Chittinghpora killings CBI to book 5 Army officers for killing 5 Kashmiris in cold blood RUTU SARIN NEW DELHi ,APRIL27 THE Central Bureau of InveStigation (CBI) is set to charge sheet five Army officers, including a Brigadier, for the alleged abduction and murder of five unarmed, innocent Kashmiris in the infamous Pathribal "encounter" in Anantnag in March 2000. The agency's indictment is sweeping: from Army officers faking witness statements and "fabricating evidence" to passing off the premeditated killings as a "stage managed encounter' from the hasty burial of the bodies to 'evidence that the weapons the 'Army said it used were not used 'at all. The charge sheet to be filed in the next few days in a Jammu ,and Kashmir court, names Brigadier Ajay Saxena, Lt. Col Brijendra Pratap Sinh, Maj. Sourabh Sharma, Major Amit Saxena and Subedar I Khan. The case hit international headlines, coming as it did four days after the Chittisinghpora massacre in which 35 Sikh villagers were lined up and killed, allegedly by militants. The fact that US President Bill Clinton was in India at that time ampIified the 'significance of the event The five persons ki1led in Pathribal on March 24, 2000, were made out to be foreign militants behind the Chittisinghpora massacre. When local residents took out a protest march complaining these were men gone missing from nearby vill.ages, and killed in cold blood, they were fired upon near Brakpora. Ten more persons were killed. Confirming the CBI's decision, Director Vijay Shankar told The Indian Express: "The Army has performed an exceptional role in Jammu and Kashmir. However, there are one or I two encounters where their role has been severely criticized. The Anantnag encounter is one such case which can be called an aberration and it was necessary for the CBI to clear the good name of the Army and expose persons responsible for the fake encounter." The decision to charge sheet the Army officers (who were then attached to the Rashtriya Rif1es) was delayed because former, Director U S Mishra could not take a final decision given the division in the agency: while investigators were all for prosecution, some on its legal panel were not. Shankar is said to have finally ruled that there was no requirement for the Agency to seek sanction in the, case and that direct charge sheet was in order.

Re: Chittsinghpora killings of Sikhs coverup

KS · 01 May 2006

IHRO accused Indian Intelligence Agencies and Renegade (Non-Conformist) Militants For the Sikh Massacre in Chithi Singhpora village in Kashmir LUDHIANA, March 29, 2000- The International Human Rights Organisation (IHRO), after a spot investigation, indicted the renegade-militants for Chithi Singhpora (Anantnag) massacre of 35 Sikhs on March 20 last. They, it said, aimed at breaking the Sikh-Muslim worldwide nexus to rundown the Kashmir movement for self-determination. Sensing the gravity of the situation, IHRO dispatched a high level investigation team, comprising its Chairman D S Gill, General Secretary M S Grewal and Randhir Singh, to the tormented Sikh village in South Kashmir, erstwhile a hot belt of militants in the Valley, to make spot inquiries to clear the mist that is even today prevailing regarding 'who are the guilty?' "Today, this area is dominated by renegades (non-conformist militants) who are often covered by military" said Mr Gill, in a Press conference here today, quoting Chief Justice Mufti Bahuddin Farooqi (Retd) of the J & K High Court as saying: "No one is safe from these renegades and they have hit-list of their own, besides Kashmiri activists." The IHRO team met about 200 people, including the aggrieved family members and eye witnesses, besides members of the Sri Nagar High Court Bar Association and the All Party Hurriyat Conference (APHC). Justice Farooqi and Mirwaiz Umar Farooq were unanimous in opining that the Sikh carnage was directed to rupture the secular fabric of Kashmir and to defame the Kashmir movement for freedom. "The heinous act was so designed to scuttle US President Bill Clinton's intermediary role in resolving the conflict to restore peace in South Asia." This machinated gruesome massacre impressed the mind of President Clinton who hurriedly endorsed the preconditions imposed by India for starting peace dialogue with Pakistan. And, this will definitely dampen the peace initiative in the region, asserted the IHRO. Sri Nagar High Court Bar Association members told the IHRO team: "Area around the ill-fated Singhpora village is largely controlled by armed militant groups that had abandoned freedom movement and are recruited by the army as an auxiliary counter-insurgency force. They are provided with settlements almost adjoining to the army camps." Even as the authorities alleged that the two militant organisations are involved in the killings, Hizbul Mujahideen leader Sayed Salahuddin has to say: "The killing is aimed at creating a wedge between the Sikhs and the Muslims in Kashmir," adding that Mujahideen and the people of Kashmir strongly condemn the killing of innocent Sikhs and share the grief with the victims' families. We promise that Mujahideen will avenge the killing of innocent Sikhs, according to North America chapter of the IHRO. Lashkar-e-Toiba's spokesman Yahya Mujahed has also said: "We have never attacked any civilians. It is our record that we only target the Indian military." Pakistan condemned the Sikh carnage as well and demanded an inquiry, voicing fears that India might exploit the incident for propaganda. "Isolate the Muslims in Kashmir," said a midlevel officer from the BSF, "then we will be free to deal with them," according to The New York Times, March 22, 2000. Then, how come National Security advisor Brajesh Mishra named at New Delhi the two militant groups early on March 21 while the DIG, Anantnag, Raja Ajaz Ali the same evening said that killers could not be identified as they were in army fatigues, surprisingly asked the IHRO. Almost all the militant groups of Kashmir, including their political front APHC, and Sikh organisations world-wide have accused the Indian intelligence agencies and counter-insurgency force for the killings of innocent Sikhs, said the IHRO, adding that it is not without strings that the J & K state is headed by two intelligence men as Governor (former RAW chief) and DGP. Definitely, the accusing finger is towards the intelligence network and counter-insurgency force (renegades). "We are, therefore, left with no option but to demand a judicial inquiry by two sitting judges of the Supreme Court into this horrible massacre of innocent Sikhs in the area of South Kashmir, now mostly commanded by renegade militants, so as to sift out the truth," said the team. "We would also demand an inquiry into the alleged encounter in which militants, said to be involved in the Singhpora killings, have been killed." The Sikhs in the valley are least bothered about who did the act or who had directed to do the trick but they seem determined to migrate to safer place in order to live a peaceful life with a guarantee of their life and property. The cat is out of the bag The Times of India reported on March 31 that "militants" killed were civilians. "The killing by the army of five "militants" at Pataribal, nine km from Chithi Singhpora, on March 25 has kicked up a row with local villagers claiming that they were civilians." The civil administration, however, has decided to order a magisterial inquiry and if necessary, exhume the bodies as the villagers have alleged that the persons were killed in a fake encounter. The army had claimed that the "militants" killed were involved in the massacre of 35 Sikhs on March 20. Divisional Commissioner of Kashmir, Khurshid Ahmad Gani, told The Times of India News Service that truth would prevail. Meanwhile, the Anantnag Bar Association exhibited some traces of killed persons, which indicated that those killed were civilians who went missing on March 24. The district bar association demanded an independent inquiry into the Chithi Singhpora massacre and the killings in a faked encounter, according to The Tribune, March 31. "Dr Farooq Abdullah said he had directed DGP Gurbachan Jagat and ADGP-CID R K Tikku to inquire into the incident of encounter." There was a tension in Anantnag town following an agitation launched by the local people who observed complete strike for the second day on March 30. They also took to streets and demonstrated before the Deputy Commissioner's office disputing the army's claim that it had killed foreign militants involved in the Sikh massacre. The army had blown up a house, said to be the hideout of the militants, and recovered five bodies, which were charred beyond recognition. The army later buried them. The villagers alleged that they had found the turban of Jumma Khan and the sweater of Zahoor Dadal from the site of the fake encounter. They were among the five persons missing since March 24, a day before the encounter. The villagers claimed that Jumma Khan (55), Kumma Khan (50), Zahool Dadal (25), Muhammad Yousuf Malik (45) and Bashir Ahmad Bhat (18) were missing from Braringam, Momonabad and Hallan. Their relatives had filed FIRs about the missing persons with the local police station. But the police said those killed were not the missing persons, added the TOI report. Yet another encounter A Defence Ministry representative said that the troops, on a tip-off that a group of militants had entered Brang valley from Kuthar valley in district Anantnag, launched a massive search operation around six 'O clock morning. "The troops were conducting house to house searches at Halan village when they were fired upon by militants with automatic weapons from different directions. The troops retaliated and killed six militants, allegedly part of the militant group who had killed 35 Sikhs at Chithi Singhpora on March 20 night," he said (Indian Express, March 30). He said with the killing of the six militants, 11 ultras responsible for the March 20 carnage had been eliminated within four days. This too seems a fake encounter and needs to be investigated. Why does the army do so? Because, they have something to hide from the public. That why the IHRO has demanded a credible judicial inquiry into the Sikh carnage and the encounter killings of those allegedly involved in the Sikh massacre. Future of Kashmiri Sikhs in the Valley? They are not bothered who did it. They are worried about their future. Six persons of the ill-fated village were on the hit list of the renegade militants. Three (Fauzi Charan Singh, Prabhu Singh and Nasib Singh) of them have been short dead and the fourth one (Nanak Singh) was injured seriously and now is in the army hospital. (Binder Kaur is also in hospital due to heart attack caused as a result of her son Ravinder Singh's death in the carnage). The top on the list was the ex-serviceman Charan Singh who along with the others was vocal enough to oppose the iniquitous deeds of the renegades in the village who frequently visited them. A young boy and relative of Mohammad Yaqoob @ Chhatta, who was arrested next morning from the village, told the IHRO team: "Who knows in a village who is who? Renegades are more dangerous. They more often indulge in immoral activities, including drinking, sexual abuse, loot and innocent killings. Both Sikhs and Muslims alike are targets of these elements." Sikhs reported two cases of abduction of Sikh girls at gunpoint in area around by these itinerants. On the night of March 23 when the IHRO team was staying in the village, an army colonel offered arms and Rs 5000/- monthly to each of about 200 village Sikh youth for purging militants. They flatly refused to become cat-like. They along with other Kashmiri Sikhs decided to migrate from Kashmir and finally put this decision before the Sikh national leadership on March 31. The Sikh world extended all support and sympathy to the victim families of Chithi Singhpora village and assured all help in future while postponing the idea of mass migration for the time being. Almost all-militant groups and their political outfits have with one voice condemned the ghastly massacre and decided to instil the confidence among the local Sikhs at mass level. And the Government should shoulder the responsibility to let the people know: who are the guilty (?) by ordering judicial inquiry into the Sikh carnage. Meanwhile, the IHRO has, on April 2, 2000, petitioned to the National Human Rights Commission Chairman Mr Justice J S Verma to get investigated the massacre and subsequent killings of the "militants" in encounters with the army troops so that the truth may come out and the guilty may be brought to book. "Seeing the gravity of the matter, we therefore, urge this honourable commission to immediately take up this matter along with the petition preferred by Sardar Manjit Singh Butalia advocate for compensation to the aggrieved family of Singhpora village massacre." J & K High Court Bar Association Members' Views A K Malik: The act is very condemnable. It seems an act of counter-insurgency forces. There should be a thorough inquiry to identify the real culprits. Government must shoulder its responsibility for this. Abdul Majeed Daar: This genocide of Sikhs is to malign the majority community of Kashmir. In the last 12 years, the Sikhs were never harmed. There is a deep-rooted conspiracy to do that. One can understand who really is the gainer of this most deplorable massacre of innocent Sikhs, especially at a time when President Clinton was scheduled to start a dialogue with the PM in New Delhi. H D Ahmed: There is always a reason for an action. At a time when Pundits migrated from Kashmir Sikhs opted to stay back home because of fellowship with Muslims had become strong after 1984. Actually, Sikhs and Muslims are now coming closer not only in Kashmir but also worldwide. This ghastly act is aimed at dampening this process. I am afraid a few renegade boys in the form of Mujahideen might have used in this machination. A M Khan: One who was not ashamed of killing thousands of Sikhs in Amritsar and then Delhi and other parts of India will not feel ashamed of killing 35 Sikhs in Kashmir to defame Kashmir freedom movement and to blame Pakistan for all this. Unless checked by the majority here these like incidents may repeat in future elsewhere in the valley. Justice Farooqi: The motive behind the mass killing of Sikhs at a certain point of time and the circumstantial evidence available with us goes to show that the real culprits may not be the freedom fighters, but the renegades and their masters who cover them and condone their private loot and nefarious activities. Onkar Singh: Kashmiri Muslims owe a reply to the Sikhs why they have been so killed and what is the future security. List of Sikhs killed in the Chithi Singhpora Massacre Outside the Village Gurdwara 1. Charan Singh 2. Jagir Singh 3. Nasib Singh Nambardar 4. Didar Singh 5. Sartaj Singh 6. Ujjal Singh 7. Darbara Singh 8. Rajdeep Singh 9. Kingpal Singh 10. Sukha Singh 11. Sarwan Singh 12. Jagdish Singh 13. Gurmit Singh 14. Kulbir Singh 15. Raghunath Singh 16. Ravinder Singh 17. Faqir Singh In Shokhipora Mohalla 18. Niranjan Singh (60) 19. Ranjit Singh (40) 20. Rattan Singh (35) 21. Karnail Singh (30) 22. Gurbax Singh (35) 23. Uttam Singh (30) 24. Gurdip Singh (22) 25. Ajit Singh (17) 26. Devinder Singh (17) 27. Surjit Singh (17) 28. Ravinder Singh (25) 29. Mangal Singh (30) 30. Joginder Singh (30) 31. Sukhpal Singh (40) 32. Rachpal Singh (29) 33. Ranbir Singh (27) 34. Gurmukh Singh (35) 35. Jang Bahadur Singh (30) One Injured: Nanak Singh

Re: Chittsinghpora killings of Sikhs coverup

LS · 27 May 2006

On March 20, 2000, innocent Sikhs numbering 35 were killed in Anantnag Distt. of Kashmir. People including human right groups had strong suspicions that it was the kartoot of Indian agencies. It was done in view of US president Bill Clington's visit to Indian Sub-continent. The Sikhs were used as dummy because the politicians knew that there is hardly any statesman who can raise the cry here and internationally. Because the Akali leaders like Parkash Singh Badal were manageable. More over they knew Badal was their ally of the ruling alliance Delhi and his son was a minister. They knew the Congress's Sikh leaders have no guts because their own party had massacred about 3000 Sikhs in 1984. Obviously no one bothered to enquire into the massacre. But God has his own ways to reveal the truth. The killers of Chittisingpora subsequently killed 5 innocent Kashmiri Muslims and claimed that they have liquidated the foreign militants responsible for Chittisinghpora massacre. What the army branded as mercenaries were innocent Kashmiris of the nearby villages. There was a mass protest and the graves had to exhumed and it was finally determined that the people were local innocents. Under tremendous pressure the Govt had to order CBI enquiry which has now booked 5 army officers including a Brigadier. But in the present story Brigadier claims that army alone is not responsible for the misdeed. ++++++++++++++++++++++ Blame J-K cops, not just us for Pathribal: Brigadier to DGMO RITU SARIN Posted online: Monday, May 15, 2006 at 0000 hrs http://indianexpress.com/story/4462.html# Fake encounter: Joint Op was on Anantnag SSP’s information: Brig Saxena; Army plans to appeal against trial, suggest court martial Digging up the Pathribal truth Related Stories Records show J-K police had big role in 2000 fake encounter For own survival, J-K govt hushed up sex scandal two years agoBar Association plea gets PIL treatment Prostitution legal in J&K, govt plans to scrap old law J-K sex racket: BSF begins internal probe NEW DELHI, MAY 14: With the CBI filing chargesheets against five Army officers in the fake Pathribal encounter and the case listed for hearing on May 24 in a Srinagar court, Army Headquarters plans to ask the court to let them hold a court martial instead of subjecting the officers to a trial after a CBI probe. The Indian Express has learnt that Brigadier Ajay Saxena, the seniormost officer named as an accused by the CBI, has written a letter to Lt General Madan Gopal, Director General of Military Operations (DGMO), pointing out how five Army personnel (four officers and a JCO) have been singled out for “harassment, ignominy, humiliation, agony and financial strain” over an operation conducted jointly by the Army and J&K Police. Brig Saxena has said that the operation was ordered by a senior Army officer (Sector Commander) of the Rashtriya Rifles on the basis of information provided by the SSP of Anantnag. Brig Saxena’s wife, Sushma Saxena, has also written to the Army chief’s wife Anupama Singh who’s the president of the Army Wives Welfare Association (AWWA). Saying she was expressing the views of wives of all five officers who have been indicted by the CBI, Sushma Saxena wrote: “If our husbands are prosecuted in this case, then every husband who is fighting in the Valley in the future is also liable to face such action... all our husbands have done is obey orders and carry out operations based on information provided by a Senior Commander and the police.” The circumstances of the Pathribal encounter have now been outlined by the indicted officers for the Army top brass. The DGMO is understood to have been told that: • The Pathribal encounter took place in an area notified as a Disturbed Area under the Armed Forces Special Powers Act, 1990 and that protection should be provided to the five officers named as “accused” by the CBI. • That two of the five persons killed in the operation were on the list of active overground workers maintained by the Rashtriya Rifles and that the CBI probe revealed that a third among the dead also had terrorist links. • That during the relevant period (command of Brig Saxena), the 7 RR unit received over 50 awards, including a dozen Sena medals. In two years, the unit eliminated 78 militants. • That the CBI chargesheet had serious operational ramifications for future Kashmir operations since it would create distrust in the rank and file about verbal orders and posed a threat to the lone Kashmiri accused whose intelligence inputs had led to the elimination of 40 terrorists. Though the CBI’s legal panel rules that the agency does not require sanction for prosecuting Army officers because killing of innocent persons in a fake encounter cannot be taken as discharge of “official duty”, the Army is gearing to challenge that view in the Srinagar court. The Army’s counter is that the Pathribal encounter was a joint Police-Army operation, carried out on intelligence provided by the J&K police and that trial would jeopardise further joint counter-insurgency operations. [address removed] --------------------- Records show J-K police had big role in 2000 fake encounter Express News Service Posted online: Monday, May 15, 2006 at 0000 hrs http://indianexpress.com/story/4463.html NEW DELHI, MAY 14: While the CBI has chargesheeted five Army officers, including a Brigadier, for the killing of five civilians in a fake encounter in Pathribal six years ago, the fact remains that the J-K police too played a major role in the encounter. This is what The Indian Express found out: Advertisment Related Stories Blame J-K cops, not just us for Pathribal: Brigadier to DGMO For own survival, J-K govt hushed up sex scandal two years agoBar Association plea gets PIL treatment Prostitution legal in J&K, govt plans to scrap old law J-K sex racket: BSF begins internal probe • The FIR filed by the 7 Rashtriya Rifles described the fake encounter as a “joint operation” with J-K Police • Daily diary reports of Sherbagh police post clearly indicates that on the orders of the then Anantnag SSP, Farooq Khan, a SoG (Special Operations Group) party was sent for a “secret operation”. In fact, ASI Bashir Ahmad wrote about the “secret mission” in his departure report • Tajinder Singh, then DySP (SOG) Anantnag, and Col Ajay Saxena explained the “joint RR-police operation” with the help of an extensive site map to then Union Home Minister L K Advani, giving graphic details about the killing of five Pak-based Lashkar terrorists who were behind the massacre of Sikhs in Chittisinghpora • Advani congratulated the police and Army for the operation and even had a group picture taken with the police and Army officers. Cash awards were also announced for the officers • Kashmi Zonal Police headquarters issued a press statement, claiming that five Lashkar terrorists responsible for the Chittisinghpora massacre had been eliminated in a joint RR-Police operation. The then Union Home Secretary Kamal Pandey gave a similar statement at a press conference in New Delhi • Mohammad Yaqoob Wagay alias Chatti Guru, a local milkman, was picked up a few days after the March 20, 2000 Chittisinghpora massacre by the police for allegedly “guiding” the killers to the village. Union Home Secretary Kamal Pandey announced his arrest in New Delhi and the police and RR claimed that based on Wagay’s “leads”, they had killed five Lashkar terrorists • Nine months later, Anantnag Police admitted that the police had no corroborative evidence to chargesheet Wagay and that they have reduced the charge from multiple murder to “trying to breach peace (CrPC 107/151)” • Once the CBI established that the five killed in the joint police-RR operation were actually civilians, the question is: who picked up the civilians? The J&K Police itself established that a Maruti van was used to ferry one of the victims, Zahoor Ahmad Dal, from Anantnag. This van was a seized vehicle, in the custody of the police. Anantnag SSP during encounter gets clean chit, new posting NEW DELHI: After remaining under suspension for three years in connection with the Pathribal killings, Farooq Khan was posted last week to Rajouri as SSP. An IPS officer of the 1994 batch, Khan received a clean chit from CBI last year but the Mufti Sayeed government refused to to reinstate him. —PTI